Tony Burke
Blinky Bill, Caramello and Sam the Thirsty Koala would be well satisfied this week.

Thanks largely to The Greens, koalas will be better protected in three states. Their status is now officially “threatened”, which is one rung below endangered on the uh-oh ladder, but several rungs above “fend for yourself, buddy”.
The Greens don’t get an enormous amount of love on this website. That’s mostly because the writers and commenters who set the tone of our dialogue largely believe that The Greens should stick to saving bits of the environment we can actually see and touch and interact with.
Continue reading "Greens stand up for the stoned and indolent" »
There was movement at the station for the word had got around that the Feds might have finally gotten something right for a change.

Late yesterday, news filtered through that Tony Burke, Minister for Sustainability, Environment and a bunch of other stuff, had put the kybosh on Victorian premier Ted Baillieu’s absurd, cynical and dangerous plan to reintroduce grazing to the High Country. Good.
Minister Burke rejected a proposal by the Victorian government to allow cattle into the Alpine National Park for five months a year, arguing it was in breach of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act. He’s right, too. Parks Victoria is just one reputable body which has produced scientific evidence showing that grazing is detrimental to the High Country.
Latest 2 of 75 comments
View all comments-
sam says:
spot on, those same whingers are the ones calling any other group un-Australian for trying to change laws Read more »
-
Mattb says:
That’s it Charles, don’t bring your own scientific evidence in to refute the scientific evidence that has been presented, just attack the credibility of the scientists that provided it by saying “as persons that should be held up as paragons of wisdom, they ain’t. Well done. All of us should… Read more »
There’s a rather odd immigration debate taking place in this election, characterised appropriately enough, by today’s immigration debate between Tony Burke and Scott Morrison.

Minister for (*sustainable) Population Tony Burke began his address talking about all those things that Labor have been stressing in the population debate: sustainability on region by region, arguing that the Coalition are all over the place with their policy and refusing to be pushed into naming a goal population figure: “A sustainable Australia involves a level of detail that will not be solved by finding a glib magic number,” Mr Bourke told the National Press Club today.
Then Opposition immigration spokesman Scott Morrison got up and made his pitch on immigration: it involved talking about boat people almost the entire time. At one point exciting a group of student don John Howard masks and start screaming at Morrison.
Latest 2 of 38 comments
View all comments-
Greg says:
Maybe nobody mentioned it because it wasn’t worth mentioning? There was no Australian nation before European settlement. There was only a wilderness inhabited by a disparate bunch of stone-age tribes, who had not even invented the wheel or metal tools yet, let alone formed a civilised nation. This is the… Read more »
-
Greg says:
OK, if it makes you feel better, we can call illegal immigrants illegal aliens instead. Happy now? Read more »
Over Easter, the then Prime Minister quietly upgraded one of his Mandarins. It was the second time in as many weeks that a Mandarin has been invited into the bunker to receive new instructions.

This time it was the NSW Right Faction which scored a prize. The part-time Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry, Tony Burke, has been asked to come up with a cunning plan to have a cunning plan, and was even given a new moniker to go with the job. Mr Burke, who has always aspired to have his Who’s Who subscription waivered because of Who he was, is now to be know as: The Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries, and Forestry, Minister ‘Sustainable’ for Population.
Three days into the job, the Prime Minister’s first actual policy announcement was to add the word ‘Sustainable’ to the Population Minister’s title. It really does sum up the way Labor is driven by spin.
Continue reading "The only population Labor cares about is its own" »
Latest 2 of 37 comments
View all comments-
Alex says:
MIichael - Totally agree with you. Julia Gillard could have given instant credibility to Labor’s ‘sustainable’ population strategy had she appointed Kelvin Thomson this position. Mr Thomson has shown leadership on ths issue well before other Federal politicians got interested, has come up with an excellent 14 point plan whicch… Read more »
-
Joseph says:
It doesn’t matter whether the right or left are in power. Both must bend to the will of big business and accept neverending population growth. John Howard, for all his smoke and mirrors tough talk on refugees, increased immigration over 200% of what Keating was running it. Immigration will never… Read more »
It is easy to dismiss the growing backlash to population growth as a case of national NIMBYism, but the story could have more to do with the capacity of our major capital cities to deal with any extra people.

While there was lively debate over the idea of a new city in yesterday’s Punch the latest Essential Report shows the real issue is whether the government should tell new arrivals to go bush.
In what could be a real clue to the Federal Government in how to handle this difficult issue, most Australians actually support an increase in the population of major regional centres and smaller regional towns.
Continue reading "The key to coping with more people is to send them bush" »
Latest 2 of 32 comments
View all comments-
Front Man says:
Spot on, Robert. Politicians from all sides will try to pander to the seats where the population is already settled into marginal, urban and suburban seats. Anything they will or can do has to be sold into the marginals, and in SA’s case that means stripping out any stable Government… Read more »
-
acotrel says:
We need a rethink about the education system in rural areas. Project Management is a basic business skill needed for development of infrastructure. In Goulburn Ovens TAFE, it is taught as one subject in an information technology course. So tradesmen don’t get exposure to it, nor do engineers and scientists!… Read more »
Welcome to sunny Big Australia, the land of opportunity, where you’re welcome to be one of 36 million of us by the year 2050 - as long as you’re prepared to live, oh, about 4,000 kms from the Opera House.

The Punch set out last week to find out just how tolerant Australians are of the idea of the kind of population growth being considered by the Federal Government, and more to the point, how it should be managed.
What we found on the streets of Sydney, the country’s most under pressure city, is a political nightmare for both sides of politics. While Sydneysiders are quite open minded about welcoming more Australians, 70 per cent said we’d need a whole new city to house them, and that city should be far, far away.
Latest 2 of 204 comments
View all comments-
dmmaseoseoseo says:
Is not marriage an open question, when it is alleged, from the beginning of the world, that such who are in the institution wish to get out and such as are out wish to get in. Read more »
-
acotrel says:
You could easily fit Australia’s current population between Goulburn and Albury. The phobia about ‘big Australia’ is townie bullshit! Read more »
Today there will be thousands of Australians losing an hour of time with their kids for the privilege of sitting in traffic gridlock in our major cities. Somewhere else there will be an employer looking at a business, which could generate much more money if only a worker could be found.

The concept of Australia running at two speeds couldn’t be starker than it is with population. One group of Australians are flying at high speed to work at a mine while others may as well put the handbrake on.
Developing a sustainable population strategy means finding a way forward for both groups. So far a lot of the debate has dealt with national population figures and presumed all we need to do is arrive at a total number.
Continue reading "We can’t keep the country running at two speeds" »
Latest 2 of 55 comments
View all comments-
Lin says:
Tony (or one of the ‘advisers’): You say: “The critical difference is all deaths are subtracted from the birth rate – as though people who come from interstate or overseas don’t die. That’s why the quarterly report quoted has figures which seem to inflate the impact of immigration and reduce… Read more »
-
Dave says:
You better be careful Andrew, not everyone likes it when you tell it like it is. Read more »
There are plenty of vast, empty spaces on this continent and many Australians The Punch spoke to last week would like to see them filled.

In a survey The Punch ran testing Australians’ thoughts on population growth, the majority of respondents were open to the idea of building a new major city somewhere on the continent to relieve population pressure on other cities.
They were resolute about its ideal location: anywhere but near Sydney and Melbourne. John, 20, from Cronulla agreed with many survey respondents that Australia’s next Canberra, if built, should go somewhere on the country’s Western coast: “It should be somewhere between Perth and Broome.”
Continue reading "We’ve land to spare, but it’s got to be out there" »
Latest 2 of 34 comments
View all comments-
wendy says:
Plenty of population growth would accur when we create many channels allowing the deep blue sea to find its own level inland and then build many new ports and towns on the new inland sea areas all around the vast desert coastal regions not in use as yet and build… Read more »
-
sam says:
“Bad things happen when cities are built in deserts. In science fiction movies they’re usually taken over by robots.” I like the sound of Camilla, 20, from Rockdale. She sounds like my sort of girl. Read more »
Proponents of chaos theory would have enjoyed being in Sydney this week where an unremarkable collision between two trucks generated a spirited public discussion about population policy.

The accident itself and its comical aftermath was merely the latest demonstration by the NSW Government that it would be flat out organising a chook raffle, with the hated Roads and Traffic Authority playing the starring role.
Late Tuesday morning and well out of peak hour, two trucks collided on the F3, the busy northern freeway which connects Sydney to the Central Coast. No-one died, but one of the truck drivers had to be taken to hospital by helicopter, and there were concerns for public safety as one of the trucks was carrying fuel. It took the RTA almost five hours to decide that the fuel needed to be siphoned from the truck.
Continue reading "The tiny road bingle behind a huge national debate" »
Latest 2 of 64 comments
View all comments-
bufqeyjulup says:
xTA53Y nbqhledmdlty, fptmifytxfqr, [link=http://mvsuzkyiuzqz.com/]mvsuzkyiuzqz[/link], http://bkqouycrgmnr.com/ Read more »
-
d.jay.stevo says:
What gets me, is the RTA and police used this fiasco to revenue raise, fining truckies who had been stuck in the mess with not taking a proper rest break away from the truck! That is disgusting, penalising workers for getting stuck in a mess they created. Read more »
Facebook Recommendations
Read all about it
Punch live
Up to the minute Twitter chatter
Marc Glasby says he's the 'meat in the sandwich' - he loves two women. And they're identical twins... http://t.co/kL2jL1RK via @sharethis
RT @ThePunchHQ: COMING SOON to a suburb near you: A controversial #NT intervention policy. @drpiotrowski explains http://t.co/MYjvaAy6#auspol
Recent posts
The latest and greatest
On a hiding to tweet nothing over mining jobs
You know you’re in strife as a political leader when you must rely on the almost uniformly vacuous…
An NT intervention policy coming to a suburb near you
A controversial policy from the Northern Territory intervention has managed to get through the atrocious…
An insight into a particularly tricky relationship
Marc Glasby has been married to his wife Belle for over thirty years. Three years ago, Belle was reunited…
Nosebleed Section
choice ringside rantings
From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments
Michael S says:
"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone
Change Up! says:
I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]Gentle jabs to the ribs
They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments
A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more
Latest 2 of 135 comments
View all commentsAdd your comment