Stern Hu

The Prime Minister has his mojo back on the domestic front thanks to some Kevin07-style plain-speaking and a victorious health debate. Now it is time for him to strut his stuff on the world stage and become an “arse-kicking Prime Minister”, starting with China.

A lot has been written about acting and politics in the last few weeks since Opposition Leader Tony Abbott turned down acting lessons. In my favourite movie Love Actually there is a famous scene involving the heartthrob British Prime Minister played by Hugh Grant. Annoyed by a misogynist American President he stands up to him for taking advantage of their bilateral friendship.

“I love that word relationship,” the Prime Minister begins, with his beautiful admirer of a secretary Natalie walking in on the press conference.

Latest 2 of 35 comments

View all comments
 
  • stephen says:

    08:22pm | 11/04/10

    Yeah, yer right about God’s Own Country there, but the appeasement is wrong because the problem is ‘wrong’. China’s no threat, though she has the completely wrong view to Capitalism. This will need fixing ; perhaps our Prime Minister can help ? Read more »

  • Robert Smissen of God's Own Country, Rural SA says:

    01:27am | 11/04/10

    Offering appeasement to China a proven winner, just look what happened in the 1930s when the then British PM Neville Chamberlain tried to appease Hitler it worked then didn’t it? ? ? NOT! ! Read more »

 

The decision by a Shanghai court to sentence Stern Hu to ten years should teach us a lesson about the future of our relationship with China: Australia cannot expect to continue to reap the benefits of Chinese cash without periodically accepting some of its pernicious qualities.

Stern Hu, sentenced to 10 years in prison last night

Following the Hu sentence there will no doubt be a temptation to invoke what could be called the “Corby Protocol”, which assumes that whenever an Australian is arrested in a non-Western country they are ipso facto innocent and victims of a corrupt and dictatorial regime.

But in this case it would probably be in our interest to understand that while Hu has become a victim of the workings of the Chinese state and business, he was also very much a product of it. This was a position that up until this point had made him, and by extension Australia, very wealthy.

Latest 2 of 117 comments

View all comments
 
  • James says:

    02:36pm | 31/03/10

    I’m sure we are unlikely to ever know the truth and that is the problem, people will speculate, and given the history of the Chinese legal system I’m sure most people will assume that Hu is innocent and his confession was forced, even if this isn’t true. By hiding the… Read more »

  • Scot says:

    02:23pm | 31/03/10

    Randal, If you are a China Expert of many years then you should be able to answer your own questions? Or maybe next time you go, ask you business associates-partners what goes on and what happens to those people not matter what level of government the penalties they are handed… Read more »

 

The world is entering a new dynamic which is merely a repetition of the recasting of the political, social and economic order that has happened for as long as man can write about it.

How much are we prepared to overlook to protect our economic interests?

History is punctuated with the ebbs and flows of kingdoms, empires and political movements and the conflicts that are always apparent at the peripheries of influence that abuts competing interests. In the past, the cycle of influence was over, sometimes thousands and generally hundreds of years.

From the initial cultivation of land between the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers and the Sumerian civilisation, to the Greeks, to the Romans, to the Qin Dynasty, the first imperial dynasty of the Chinese, to the British Empire, we notice that the rise and fall of empires accelerates as technology, personified by communications, military hardware, economic processes and other associated influences advances.

Latest 2 of 18 comments

View all comments
 
  • Davido says:

    06:11pm | 27/01/10

    I would suggest that Stern Hu is a warning that may not have been heeded. Read more »

  • Derek says:

    07:10pm | 12/08/09

    There is clearly a big incentive for our governments not rock sour the relationship with China. Its all about money and power. But there comes a point when to remain silent and not condemn a countries immoral actions is wrong. Whether that point has been reached remains to be seen… Read more »

 

If you ever find yourself in a foreign prison awaiting representation from Australia on your behalf just pray that West Australian Premier Colin Barnett does not come through the door.

WA Premier Colin Barnett was happy to talk to journalists aftter spending several hours walking on his knees to the forbidden city

Not only is he unlikely to put up any kind of a fight for you, after a big Yum Cha lunch he may well agree to pull the hanging lever should your executioner be off sick.

Like the prince of a Chinese tributary kingdom of the middle-ages Colin Barnett travelled to Shanghai to assure his leaders that he wasn’t angry at them over the arrest of Stern Hu – actually it was our fault as Australians for over-reacting.

Latest 2 of 18 comments

View all comments
 
  • johnv_au says:

    12:22pm | 06/08/09

    Colins gone at the next election he wants chinese only run mine sites and australian run mine sites to get over the language barrier (bollocks Barnett ) Read more »

  • M says:

    09:01pm | 23/07/09

    I’m not lying. Read more »

 

While the Australian media is working itself into a frenzy over the jailing of Rio Tinto executive Stern Hu, the public seems to be forming a more pragmatic view of our relationship with China.

The Herald-Sun's Mark Knight on Mr Hu's imprisonment

The Federal Opposition’s attempts to whip up a new round of dog whistling over the arrest have fallen on deaf ears as the public accepts there are things that are outside the power of even a Mandarin-speaking Prime Minister.

But the failure of the Hu jailing to bite with the public may speak to a broader maturing in out attitude towards the emerging superpower to which our fortunes are so closely tied.

Latest 2 of 11 comments

View all comments
 
  • NellMendez19 says:

    04:38pm | 10/10/10

    A lot of specialists tell that credit loans help a lot of people to live the way they want, just because they can feel free to buy needed goods. Furthermore, banks offer commercial loan for all people. Read more »

  • Albert Fish says:

    12:51pm | 19/08/09

    Stern Hu is not an Australian citizen. Some time ago the Chinese government downloaded the entire website: http://www.basicfraud.com and then got some advice upon the issues raised from a number of internationally recognised universities. The Law School at Cambridge has always been most helpful in that regard. Read more »

 

I keep waiting for the traditional church to launch its campaign against the government’s treatment of boat people.

Perhaps Stern Hu needs a rocket launcher to get the churches' attention

After all, boats carrying asylum seekers keep entering Australian waters in greater numbers, there are allegations that boats are left to drift and, worst of all, some have perished along the way.

I glance skyward in Melbourne, looking for the immense banner hanging from the spire St Paul’s Cathedral, like there was a few years ago. Instead of “Justice for David Hicks”, it will read “Justice for SIEV 624”.

Latest 2 of 22 comments

View all comments
 
  • Christian Eden Monaro Voter says:

    08:04pm | 18/05/10

    Thank you so much for this post. I am a voter in the Eden Monaro electorate. Just this morning, I was wondering who on earth I would vote for at the next election. Traditionally, I have voted Labor. But lately, like many other people it seems, I have turned against… Read more »

  • Simon H says:

    02:16am | 23/07/09

    “And then, of course, the traditional church can’t even agree on its social agenda.” Gee, the church (really dozens of churches) being politically split and all over the place: that’s a massive change of pace from what’s been happening for most of the last 2000 years. And your point is?… Read more »

 

One of the more bracing moments of my adolescence involved going to the movies with a female friend, also in her late teens, to see the French film Betty Blue which opens with an explosive 10-minute sex scene which is arousing enough to fire up an entire retirement village, let alone an 18-year-old lad who is already as toey as a roman sandal.

When Beatrice Dalle finally got around to having her orgasm and the actual dialogue began - aside from the “oui! oui! oui! oui! oui!” spectacle we’d just witnessed - my friend, a hysterical young Francophile who’d just spent an off-year living in Paris, whispered to me: “This just isn’t going to survive the translation.”

Her pretence was eclipsed only by mine as, in the same way that she had a terminal dose of the French, I’d just come back from an off-year living in Mexico, and was so badly afflicted by a showy determination to steer any conversation in the direction of Latin America that it’s remarkable the two of us ever managed to have an intelligible conversation at all…

Latest 2 of 19 comments

View all comments
 
  • Pricey says:

    12:53pm | 20/07/09

    Isn’t it amazing that the first time KRudd can use his Super Mandarin Power, he’s having informal time off. Remind me to put that in my next work contract. “sorry boss but that task you have given is gunna have to wait. I’m having informal time off”. And i’m sure… Read more »

  • joe2 says:

    10:32am | 20/07/09

    This is a very ordinary line of criticism you are running here, Penbo. Would you have an individual hide their skills and talents because they might later raise expectations? We are not going to blame you, for instance,  for the Mexican swine flu epidemic because, as one of the few… Read more »

 

He may be known as the Ruddbot, but when it comes to his much vaunted specialist skills on China, it would seem that batteries were not included.

Hicks galvanised Labor in opposition, but Hu has confused Labor in power.

As the Prime Minister plays catch up on being caught flat footed on the Stern Hu case, he needs to demonstrate that his special China skills are not just a party trick, but can genuinely be used in Australia’s interests.

When in Opposition, Kevin Rudd was quick to criticise John Howard, claiming he was “dragging his feet on providing Mr Hicks with a fair trial”. These were his exact words in a door stop he gave almost four years ago on August 2.

Latest 2 of 27 comments

View all comments
 
  • johnv_au says:

    12:27pm | 12/08/09

    Hicks was cought with the smoking gun I say he got of lucky Hu has be detained without charge so charge him or let him return to his adopted land Geoff, Who cares if he is a lib he has a right to free speech and get Rudd To act… Read more »

  • Geoff says:

    11:39am | 19/07/09

    Scott Scott Scott…......Why don’t you put somewhere that you are a Liberal MP. ( another unknown one ) The only way people can find out is by clicking on your picture. Are you ashamed of which side you are on? Read more »

 

Nothing that follows is personally approved by David Penberthy or Rupert Murdoch, let alone Kevin Rudd. That’s the beauty of writing for a free media in a democracy.

Nicholson's take on the Hu case in The Australian.

However, it’s equally ludicrous to suggest that every word that appears in China’s state-owned media every day represents the personal views of Chinese president Hu Jintao.

I don’t know Hu - who really does? - but I’m not sure he would have chosen the noun “perfidy” to describe Rio Tinto’s betrayal of Chinalco a couple of months back. Yet that phrase was quickly interpreted as the semi-official, if colourful, position of China Inc to the collapse of the deal - purely because it ran on the “state-owned” Xinhua news agency.

Latest 2 of 10 comments

View all comments
 
  • miantiao says:

    05:07am | 21/07/09

    Socialism with special Chinese Darwinist-capitalist characteristics! Socialism in China is very different to the idea of Western socialism where we regard it as welfare, policies that put in place mechanisms that provide citizens with help and assistance when life takes a turn for the worse. The social welfare systems of… Read more »

  • Madison says:

    10:55pm | 16/07/09

    There are countless third world countries, with many of them run by democratic governments who have tried and continuously failed to lift themselves out of poverty. China may have done it under a communist regime but at least they are making serious progress. Regardless of political regime, as long as… Read more »

 

餵。我的名字是凱文,我有一個非常大的問題 (Translation: Hello, my name is Kevin and I have a very big problem).

Oh how Kevin Rudd must be wishing right now for a dirty stoush with, oh, let’s say Malaysia, or Indonesia, or even better, one of the African nations.

How terribly unlucky for the Prime Minister that his first bona fide diplomatic crisis involves China. Our man in Beijing is facing calls to personally intervene in the case of Australian Rio Tinto executive Stern Hu, who’s being held without charge by Chinese authorities on suspicion of commercial espionage.

Latest 2 of 36 comments

View all comments
 
  • Miantiao says:

    11:34am | 21/07/09

    Australians are breaking laws all over the world in the service of Australia’s national interest. Such people are called ‘assets’ and form a vital part in.Australia’s efforts to get the best possible trade outcomes. Every nation does this, its no secret. Hu is not one of them, but he may… Read more »

  • Tory Maguire

    Tory Maguire says:

    06:42pm | 15/07/09

    Wow Paul - you’re the first person who’s ever made that joke about my name, or at least the first person in the past 10 minutes. Genius. Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

@farrm51 I gave you a ridiculously Dr Seussy headline, Mal. Hope it kinda almost sorta represents the actual story http://t.co/uLOCrOtG

Paul Colgan

@GrogsGamut for the record I thought it was a shocker and the Irish follow up feeble.

Paul Colgan

@Jess_Hunichen I think Sharon Corr is touring with Ronan Keating? Think I'll pass on that one.

Paul Colgan

You know, The Corrs are pretty good.

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

New speaker’s slack clobber, old speaker clobbers slackers

New speaker’s slack clobber, old speaker clobbers slackers

Peter Slipper, draped in black in a manner most young voters will not see outside Hogwarts, has dramatically…

Snappy 60th birthday to our most fun newspaper

Snappy 60th birthday to our most fun newspaper

Life is far from dull in the Northern Territory. Or if it is, we’ll never know. And that’s…

There’s no evidence sex-for-cab-fares is a trend

There’s no evidence sex-for-cab-fares is a trend

Fifteen years ago when one of your girlfriends had a few too many Illusion shots standard practice was…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: City vs country: What would you change your life for?

Dieter Moeckel says:

We made the tree change from Darwin to Wonbah more than 15 years ago. After fencing, a road, and couple of dams our money was gone. Super is enough to live comfortably. We have geese growing old and stringy the only one that made it to the pot committed Kamakazi by flying into a tree; the chooks are… [read more]

From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics

Erick says:

Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

151 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter