School
A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not providing her with the necessary tuition and support to get into a law course at an elite university, and so they should.

The girl in question, a pouting, willowy petal by the name of Rose Ashton-Weir, boarded at Geelong Grammar in 2008 and 2009 and was clearly neglected to the point of indifference. The school is Prince Charles’s alma mater, and is Victoria’s most expensive secondary institution with annual fees topping $30k, yet evidence was tabled in court yesterday that Ms Ashton-Weir was never once given a silver spoon with which to imbibe her daily Bircher muesli.
Further, the school patently failed the young lady by refusing to provide an immaculate gravel pathway lined with lovingly-tended hedges stretching all the way from the doors of its Geelong campus to the nearest sandstone university law school. Quite rightly, the family is outraged.
Continue reading "They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments" »
A few weeks back we got the note home from school that every parent fears: “Please come in for a chat about your child’s behaviour in class.” Jack is a gorgeous eight-year-old: kind, funny, affectionate and busy.

He asks great questions like “Do ladies wake up pregnant, or do they get pregnant in the morning?” (Our answer for that one was “Both”.)
Problem is, he’s not really a natural scholar (takes after his Dad). And instead of doing his work this year, he’s been busily making a name for himself as the class clown. It was one of those all-too-frequent moments when you realise parenting should also be known as “muddling-through-with-absolutely-no-idea-what-you’re-doing”.
Continue reading "So, this parenting thing. Anyone mastered it yet?" »
Latest 2 of 34 comments
View all comments-
Testfest says:
Acotrel, We’re all very familiar now with your tale of woe about your ex-wife and her allegedly abusive father. Please stop ending every one of your posts with a reference to it. Read more »
-
marley says:
@acotrel - you can control and still be democratic? Umm, no, you can’t. Read more »
Do Australian schools reinforce disadvantage and fail to promote equity in education? Cultural-left critics, like the Australian Education Union, teacher academics like Melbourne University’s Jack Keating and, most recently, the Gonski Report on school funding all argue “yes”.

The belief is that instead of providing a ladder of opportunity and overcoming disadvantage, Australia’s schools, especially non-government schools and selective high schools, reinforce inequity and injustice by favouring already privileged and affluent students at the expense of those less fortunate.
According to critics, only the wealthy can afford a good education while poorer students forced to attend government schools are destined to failure. As a result, critics argue, governments must stop funding Catholic and independent schools, selective high schools (where entry is based on merit and ability) must be closed and all students must be forced to attend the same state-managed and controlled government schools.
Continue reading "Dogmatic private school haters will never, ever learn" »
Latest 2 of 140 comments
View all comments-
Viagra Deutschland says:
comment2, Comprar Viagra, Comprar Viagra, http://viagraces.com/ Comprar Viagra, %D, Viagra, Viagra, http://viagrakde.com/ Viagra, uoly, Read more »
-
Reade says:
Now come on Jade (the other one), pull the other one! Less than 12 students elected to do Maths B? I’m sorry but I just do not believe you. Maths C yes, but Maths B is a standard subject. I went to a large public school in a large regional… Read more »
I recently visited the Primary School I attended in rural Victoria. The old school, first built in 1870, has been replaced by a new structure on the outskirts of the town. The modern buildings, with their light, open work spaces and landscaped surrounds, offer an attractive learning environment. The old brick school that I attended now serves as a community centre.

There was one surprise at the new facility: a large covered area to house the many bicycles that the students ride to school. In my time, most pupils either walked or rode to school. Only the kids from the surrounding farms were driven, and even some of them rode their bikes into town.
These days, very few children ride to school, with over 60 per cent being driven, and another 20 per cent using public transport. Many schools don’t have a bike shed. According to a survey released by the Health Foundation and the Cycling Promotion Fund this week, 46 per cent of children travel less than ten minutes to get to school.
Continue reading "It’s time we spoke up about kids riding to school" »
Latest 2 of 75 comments
View all comments-
VickiPS says:
The federal government does, in fact, provide funding to local authorities to construct cycle paths, although I can’t recall details of the funding program. The nutty result is that in some places (such as the suburb I live in) bicycle paths will be constructed even while there are no paved… Read more »
-
Robert Smissen of country SA says:
When I was a kid in Katanning WA my siblings & i road 3.2km across the paddocks to catch the school bus from the side of the road. HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM, I guess times have change a bit Read more »
In most social circles being into poetry has about the same social cache as having an STD.
Small children are introduced to poetry early in the guise of nursery rhymes and they can’t get enough of it. The lilt and the quirk of the language in these rhymes pleases them automatically and profoundly.
But then something happens, and by the time a kid is a teenager they may as well stick a “kick me” sign on their own back if they want to carry around a book of poetry. And adults that are interested in poetry will find that even “top notch” bookstores usually have more titles on cake decoration than of verse. Where and why does poetry lose its fan base?
Continue reading "Poetry is NOT dorky, high school just ruins it" »
Latest 2 of 78 comments
View all comments-
Cris says:
Kenneth Slessor’s Sleep: Do you give yourself to me utterly, Body and no-body, flesh and no-flesh Not as a fugitive, blindly or bitterly, But as a child might, with no other wish? Yes, utterly. Then I shall bear you down my estuary, Carry you and ferry you to burial mysteriously,… Read more »
-
stephen says:
Oh, big ‘W’. Read more »
The last few weeks have seen the annual surge of stories talking about the dangers facing young adults celebrating the end of their compulsory schooling.

Most of the headlines have been taken up with reports on the tragic fatal electrocution of a young man in Bali. However, coming close behind have been a glut of current affairs pieces, garnished with a menacing techno soundtrack, detailing the many and varied ways Australia’s sons and daughters can either have their lives ruined or cut short during Schoolies.
Predictably, parents across the nation have made public their fear and reluctance to allow their offspring to go let off a little steam, far away from the stress that has been their constant companion for the last couple of years.
Continue reading "A teacher speaks: chalk schoolies up to experience" »
Latest 2 of 30 comments
View all comments-
St. Michael says:
Hey jade, I hate the Punch blog software too, but y’need to stop clicking “Submit” three times. Read more »
-
marley says:
Umm, maybe their parents? Read more »
On very rare occasions, having an incompetent rabble on the Treasury benches can be a blessing in disguise.

Those of you with long memories will recall that in the early days of the Rudd Government, the then Education Minister Julia Gillard promised that by 2011, Australia would have a national curriculum for Maths, Science, English and History.
Shortly thereafter it became obvious they weren’t going to make it and so the deadline was pushed back to 2012, then to 2013 and now it seems we’ll be lucky to see it before 2014.
Latest 2 of 143 comments
View all comments-
HeatherG says:
I lived in Moscow for 6 months in the 1970s. I visited the USA in 2008. You, sir, are an idiot. Read more »
-
HeatherG says:
Yes. I have always found it quite ironic that many people who call themselves atheists will use the Moses story to claim slavery in Egypt. While many parts of the Judaeo-Christian Scriptures can be used as a primary source historically, they can only do so because they have substantiation from… Read more »
Picture a psychologist’s office. Inside, there’s a 16-year-old girl. She’s sobbing. No, her parents haven’t divorced and her BF hasn’t unfriended her. She’s crying about the dress she wants to wear to her school formal. Her parents won’t buy it. Why? Because it costs $3000.

True story. It was relayed to me by one of Australia’s finest psychologists and, no, he didn’t counsel with, “Come on, Princess. Get a grip,” which would have been my response.
Sure, it’s more than 20 years since I went to my school formal in an approximation of Cyndi Lauper’s finest get-up (I may or may not have worn rags in my hair). And, yes, I appreciate that events have become a little more sophisticated than my big night, the highlight of which was sneaking out to drink wine pinched from the kitchen by a roadie from the band – ironically called The Snatch.
Latest 2 of 78 comments
View all comments-
Pauline says:
I really liked the idea of the donating to charity thing… that was excellent. More of these “formal” events could do that, and look how everyone would benefit. All those red carpet things where the lady is interviewed about her dress… ask her about the funds she’s raised and her… Read more »
-
B says:
Yawn!!! The old ‘Women is a victim’ line. So old Read more »
It was all over in 30 minutes. Bowls were washed, toasters put away and the lids of the honey jars screwed back on. But the feeling was hard to beat.

Just like every other weekday morning between 8-8:30am, at least 25 kids from the Alexandria Park School in Sydney’s Inner West eat breakfast around a communal table and head off to class with full bellies; a peaceful and warm start to the day.
Lucky kids would do all of this in the comfort of their own homes. But for an increasing number of others, mum and dad are just not earning enough to feed them the most important meal of the day.
Continue reading "In this breakfast club, Weet-Bix saves the day" »
Latest 2 of 65 comments
View all comments-
HeatherG says:
Ronnie, interesting. You may like to re-read what I actually said. Yes, I’ve chosen to get further education, because without it I am, apparently, unemployable in this city as it stands at this moment in time. I chose full time this year—to speed up the process—because I lost my job… Read more »
-
sick of selfishness says:
Jade have you considered that rents have more than doubled in the last 5 years? Many are have to pay 60-80% of their income on rent, all while utilities and food costs have increased rapidly too. Telling people to move is so simple but doesn’t take into account that it… Read more »
One of the major criticisms of Catholic and independent schools advanced by those arguing that government funding should be cut is that choice and diversity in education lead to inequality.

Critics like the Australian Education Union (AEU) and the Canberra-based Save Our Schools pressure group argue that non-government schools should not be funded as, supposedly, they are elitist and privileged and because they promote an education system where state school students from low socioeconomic communities are further disadvantaged.
As argued by the AEU President, Angelo Gavriolatos, “At the heart of the equity problem is the increasing concentration of students from wealthy families in private schools and those from low SES (socioeconomic status) families in public schools – a segregation that is the direct result of the market reforms of successive governments”.
Continue reading "The more school options, the better it is for all of us" »
Latest 2 of 63 comments
View all comments-
Sue58 says:
sorry - but the author was misquoted - she would NEVER have put an apostrophe there. And she was educated at a country high school. She also did not say that a LARGE number of low socioeconomic background students achieved high scores, but that SOME achieved high scores just as… Read more »
-
acotrel says:
@Bomber ‘The coal face of Catholicism is very different to the public facade that is the Vatican. ‘ I’m married to a catholic. I’ve only ever had one issue with the catholic church. It has to do with ‘the authority of christ’. The catholic church might be better if it… Read more »
Barely a week goes by without yet another controversy about the funding of schools, most recently over high-fee school profits and school assets.

High-fee schools in particular aren’t excited by the prospect of increased scrutiny of either on the My School website.
But such scrutiny might be delayed for some time and this might ease their discomfort: In the time it takes to get the information correct they’ll be able to flex their considerable lobbying muscles to make sure it doesn’t happen.
Continue reading "School funding review faces an uphill battle" »
Latest 2 of 41 comments
View all comments-
kate says:
Any private organization that accepts the taxpayer dollar should also obey the law and pay taxes. Unlikely religions which are exempt from land tax, have charitable tax status, and are free to sack or expel gay & lesbian students and teachers. Read more »
-
shep says:
Every single child in Australia should have exactly the same amount of money allocated to their education. What parents choose to contribute over and above this amount is nobodies business but theirs. Its about a culture of sacrificing so that your children have better than you. Its not rocket science… Read more »
Last week’s decision by the Independent Education Union of Australia to split from the Australian Council of Trade Unions because the ACTU supports the Green’s stance against non-government schools is the correct one.

On reading the Greens’ education policy document, there is no doubt that Catholic and independent schools are in the firing line. While the Liberal-National Coalition is committed to properly funding such schools and respects their right to manage themselves, the Greens are dedicated to cutting funding and destroying the autonomy such schools currently enjoy.
Given that the Gillard-led government is beholden to the Greens for its continued survival, and the equivocal nature of its commitment to properly funding non-government schools, then there is every chance that those opposed to Catholic and independent schools will get their way.
Continue reading "Green with class envy and bent on change" »
Latest 2 of 231 comments
View all comments-
Anne Stocks says:
No James, a yellow star was to many a symbol of hatred, as Christians we are told to Love GLBTIs as God does even if their actions make them His and our enemy. It’s not God’s will they will suffer eternally, yes He hates the evil that they do because… Read more »
-
James says:
What should we do to GLBTIs, make them wear a yellow star? Read more »
When my daughter told me she felt stressed one Saturday morning, I did a double take. She’s 10. She sleeps with a stuffed bear and has drumsticks and dirty socks strewn across her bedroom floor.

In my eyes, she’s still a child. Yet here she was, “stressed”. I asked her what it felt like (“Like I can’t really enjoy myself”) and why (“Because I have to write a speech and then do all this maths homework”).
I wrapped my arms around her and declared it a homework-free day. Instead, we went to the park. Later, we baked her favourite cake and read The Encyclopaedia of Immaturity together, in which we learnt how to make vegie-proof tongue covers and take photos that look as if your head’s fallen off.
Continue reading "Childhood isn’t preparation for life, it is life" »
Latest 2 of 52 comments
View all comments-
BlancheMoses says:
According to my own analysis, millions of people on our planet get the loans at good banks. Thence, there’s good chances to get a car loan in every country. Read more »
-
whatahooha says:
@Mark, perhaps you would have ended up in a different place altogether if your parents or school had taken you to RftD to help out when you were a young impressionable and sweet kid, with your fringe hanging over your face and freckles on your nose. Read more »
It would be funny if it wasn’t so predictable. The original opponents of My School - the Greens, State teachers unions, public education spruikers and the like - who at first campaigned against publishing schools performance data claiming it would lead to the stigmatisation of selected schools, have now done a complete reversal.

Now, their line is that My School confirms what they have said all along - that private schools are overfunded, and that federal funding of independent schools is grossly unfair. From being condemned at first, My School has morphed into a Trojan Horse for tired old positions on independent school privilege and State school disadvantage.
Typically though, what the State education spruikers conveniently ignore is that My School offers as many insights about the fairness of public funding of State owned schools as it does about the traditional public versus private debate.
Continue reading "My School lifts the lid on state school funding mess" »
Latest 2 of 30 comments
View all comments-
kil says:
Public education in NSW is too focused on the selective system, really? I did not notice .... Also, all the of the selective schools in Sydney are in the better parts of the city so for any working class student, theres a long commute to be had. I went to… Read more »
-
Lachlan says:
The teachers unions were never outright opposed to the idea of a schools website, only the first version of it that was flawed. The AEU’s submission to the federal government actually recommended all the changes that the government is now doing. You could have found this out within 5 minutes… Read more »
On a recent trip the US I read journalist Dave Cullen’s book about the Columbine massacre. With a spate of highly-publicised suicides there apparently linked to bullying, and a subsequent rash of legislation in various states designed to “combat” the phenomenon, Columbine is a timely publication with much relevance to our own national debate on the subject.

In his book, Cullen demolishes one of the central and most persistent myths of the Columbine massacre: that a pair of misfits with artistic and intellectual tendencies were hounded by meathead jocks until they finally snapped. Instead he paints a chilling portrait of a malignant relationship between a psychopathic narcissist and his angry and malleable best friend.
Yes, the Columbine kids were picked on, argues Cullen, but not as badly as many others and they certainly displayed no ideological biases when it came to blowing away their classmates.
Continue reading "Bullying myths: Who are the real victims?" »
Latest 2 of 169 comments
View all comments-
Alex_Qld says:
I was bullied from the start of primary school to almost the end of highschool. Not just emotional bullying, that was bad enough, but physical assaults on an almost daily basis. The one time I truly fought back in the 9th grade, the head thug convinced the big dumb one… Read more »
-
AngryAsp says:
You are sadly misinformed about this subject by a slick, aggressive but ultimately vacuous media campaign promoting this book and its author. Dave Cullen is nothing but a lying,opportunistic famewhore. His book is riddled with odious lies. Its disgusting how quick you all are to swallow whatever the liar says… Read more »
Last week’s news of the death of anti-anorexia billboard model, Isabelle Caro, came one day after I gobbled Portia de Rossi’s graphic memoir about her battle with anorexia in almost one sitting.

An Unbearable Lightness intrigued and terrified me. De Rossi’s obsessive calorie counting, exhaustive exercise and waifish results seemed strangely juxtaposed with the delicious gluttony I’d experienced over Christmas - nine weeks after the birth of my third child – weighing my heaviest.
Female body image is a complex beast. It wrestles at some point with most of us - regardless of the skin we’re in.
Continue reading "Not so much a killer body as a body that kills" »
Latest 2 of 110 comments
View all comments-
fit-mama says:
@frankie - i had the same problem while completing my masters, working full time and had just had a baby. just keep your weight steady during semester and go hardcore during the breaks, you’ll be fine. Although I will warn you that employers are much more narcissistic when picking from… Read more »
-
Lauren says:
Why do you need to be a size 10? Are you actually overweight, or would you just prefer it because it is the ‘ideal’? Everyone comes in different shapes and so long as you fall within a healthy weight range, that’s all that matters. Don’t live your life stressed out… Read more »
In the battle between the nerds and the bullies, a seven-year-old girl is striking back.

Katie wears glasses and likes Star Wars.
At the start of the school term, she was excited about bringing her new Star Wars backpack and matching drink bottle to show her friends.
Continue reading "Schoolyard Star Wars: nerds versus bullies" »
Latest 2 of 50 comments
View all comments-
Mum says:
I have an interesting dilemma and wouldn’t mind some advice. Is a Year 7 High School child ‘obligated’ to have a year peer as a close friend. What right does a child have to say no to another kid who wants to be part of a group and who regularly… Read more »
-
acotrel says:
The trouble is that employers often promote sociopaths, whom they believe will exercise control. The bullies find their place in middle management! - A good kick in the nuts works wonders! Read more »
Jung Chang’s Wild Swans and James Joyce’s Dubliners don’t make my list of “books that changed my life” but as required reading for my grade twelve English class and therefore the sole focus of my attention for an entire year, let’s just say they’ve stuck in my mind.

If I ever want to remember what it felt like to devote an entire year to reading a couple of books, I only have to grab them down from the bookshelf and flick through the curled up pages and read the number of Post-it-notes still stuck to the spine or the lead pencil scrawled in the margins; a testimony to the days, weeks and months spent poring over the content, the characters, the plot line, the history and in the case of Wild Swans, the extensive family tree printed on the inside cover.
Yes, both books eventually did my head in. Yes, I often questioned their impact on my future life, the one that was sooo hard to see from my bedroom desk. But I’m glad I read them.
Continue reading "Don’t ditch literature in your final year" »
Latest 2 of 27 comments
View all comments-
Kitty says:
As a post-graduate student currently writing a PhD thesis in political science, I thank my lucky stars that I was immersed in literature for an entire year at high school. Although I did not go on to do an ‘arts’ degree (which some of you have implied is the only… Read more »
-
Marnie says:
I resented having to learn maths up to year 10 but I’m not whinging. It works the other way too you know. Read more »
Are there four syllables in the English language to strike fear into the hearts of men and women across Australia than – high school reunion. Hell, that’s five syllables. There you go – I was no good at either English or maths. And I just know everyone I went to school with knows it.
Panic grips you in the days before the reunion. Just what the hell have I been doing with my life? How can I spin it so I appear successful/rich/happy? I call this the Romy and Michele Method (after the movie Romy and Michele’s High School Reunion starring Mira Sorvino and Lisa Kudrow who decide to make up a life for themselves at their reunion as the inventors of Post-it Notes.
Or maybe the high school reunion is a perfect chance for a cheap group therapy session and calls for four hours of brutal honesty. Why pay a shrink several thousand dollars when for fifty bucks you can, over ten beers and some bad finger food, cut to the chase, strip back your life to its foundations and expose just what you have become and who you really are. And all this with the people who deep down know you the best – your old school friends (and enemies).
Continue reading "Romy and Michele and Duncan’s School Reunion" »
Latest 2 of 13 comments
View all comments-
stephen says:
My dear, forget the apostrophe on ‘boys’. Read more »
-
Lisa says:
My dear relative was a senior member of Sydney Boys’ Grammar teaching staff. His general level of intellect (Professor of two subjects) and his level of expectations for his students put my own country government school education not in the shade, but in complete and utter darkness. Read more »
You aren’t allowed to smack your partner, so why should you be allowed to smack your child?
It also makes no sense to me to declare war on thugs in the street and yet still allow parents to hit their kids.
This is particularly the case when it’s done with a blunt wooden object rather than just a hand.
Continue reading "Wooden spooning is assault, no back chat" »
Latest 2 of 73 comments
View all comments-
Louise says:
There are so many other reasons as to why ‘youth today are so bad compared to the good old days’. however, some would say that it is better (some studies have shown this) though of course some would say it was worse. Rose-tinted glasses may look good to wear when… Read more »
-
Louise says:
just because someone hasn’t had kids doesn’t make their opinion invalid?!! I do not know what Susie’s comment is, but I know that she has been a child and a human, so she also knows some of these issues. Fair enough, she may not have seen what it is like… Read more »
Recently, a private boys’ school in Queensland took the progressive step of incorporating emotional intelligence into its syllabus. Bravo.

In Western society, we have for too long adopted a blinkered approach towards education, focusing heavily on the development of cognitive skills, such as writing, reading and counting, and not those associated with a child’s emotional development.
Research and early childhood literature has shown that children who possess well-developed emotional and mental skills, have a greater likelihood of being successful later on in life.
Continue reading "Putting self-esteem on the school syllabus" »
Latest 2 of 5 comments
View all comments-
flower child says:
Maybe I’m missing something, but why is the school responsible for a child’s emotional development? Surely that’s entirely the role of the parents. I’m all in favour of kids participating in a range of activities, but I don’t see that playing a sport or joining the camera club necessarily contributes… Read more »
-
stephen says:
I once met some of these boys from Kings, and I can honestly tell you they don’t need leadership studies, because they already think they’re top sh.t. (And to sound completely cynical, you cannot learn emotional intelligence from direct instruction ; the only way is by trial and error from… Read more »
Facebook Recommendations
Read all about it
Punch live
Up to the minute Twitter chatter
Recent posts
The latest and greatest
Is there a nicotine patch strong enough for this?
Ok. I am not a leading expert in world’s best practice on prisoner rehabilitation — my experience…
A great win by Webber, but it sure as hell wasn’t sport
This morning I joined millions of other Australians in accelerating, braking, swearing and spilling coffee…
Fighting Assad one strongly worded statement at a time
This weekend’s massacre in Houla, Syria, is one of those stories that invites but doesn’t…
Nosebleed Section
choice ringside rantings
From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments
Michael S says:
"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone
Change Up! says:
I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]Gentle jabs to the ribs
They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments
A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more
Latest 2 of 243 comments
View all commentsAdd your comment