Refugees

With detention facilities on Christmas Island getting closer and closer to capacity, and a Federal election looming, the issue of desperate people seeking asylum on Australian shores remains a hotbed of cheap political point-scoring at the expense of some of the world’s neediest people.

Asylum seekers board a boat to Christmas Island. Picture: Colin Murty.

Disappointingly, the term “queue jumper” is now so deeply entrenched in our nation’s vernacular that some Australian politicians use it interchangeably with the term “asylum seeker”.

Let me be clear and point out that two are not synonymous. In fact, the queue is a myth. 

Latest 2 of 131 comments

View all comments
 
  • Your name:Noemie says:

    02:50pm | 03/03/10

    I can’t understand while in having been in contact with these individuals and families you can be so influenced by rumors. You talk about the “benefit of the doubt” rule for all asylum seekers coming. i do not think any body who has nothing to fear for his safety in… Read more »

  • John says:

    10:35am | 26/02/10

    Robert King@ Mate, I’m not sure if you could have seen me, wearing those thick rose coloured glasses. But I think I would have noticed you in your Pollyanna outfit. Read more »

 

Who knew the lower north shore of Sydney was a hunting ground for anti-immigrationists. This flyer popped up in mail boxes last weekend in more than one apartment block, in more than one suburb. Unauthorised of course, and probably the work of a nutter.

A pamphlet distributed in Sydney

But it’s an election year, and these things don’t tend to happen in a vacuum. During the next six months there’ll be a lot more of this rubbish peddled by those outside the political mainstream.

Scott Morrison has requested we be able to debate immigration without labeling people racist. That’s more than fair. But keeping the debate clean is a two way street.

Latest 2 of 224 comments

View all comments
 
  • J Citizen says:

    06:59pm | 24/02/10

    “Lose the racism”? The leaflet never had any, and you still call it racist anyway. You call it “rubbish/garbage” from a “nutter”. But let’s not have any name-calling, eh? Read more »

  • Craig Hendry says:

    07:38am | 18/02/10

    It is always a concern when people (population) is viewed as a problem rather than a solution, and “policy” is formed from that type of perspective. Read more »

 

Last week I returned from a visit to Christmas Island to Parliament where the Labor Member MP, John Sullivan, from Longman in Brisbane, interjected during a speech and called me a racist.

Asylm-seekers arriving at Christmas Island late last year. Photo: Alison Millcock

At the time, I was speaking to an Appropriations Bill that was seeking additional funds to make up for shortfalls in this year’s budget. Included in these shortfalls was $132 million for off shore processing of asylum seekers.  We were supporting the Bill.

I noted that the 100 per cent plus blow out in costs demonstrated the Government had failed to appreciate the impact of their policy changes on the detention population on Christmas Island, that is now at unsustainable levels.

Latest 2 of 231 comments

View all comments
 
  • Seano says:

    09:05am | 17/02/10

    “Anyone with a pair of eyes in their head can see many of our ’ new Australians’ have no intention of ever integrating &  want to bring their tribal mentality here” Of course same thing was said about the Greeks and Italians when they came and that turned out to… Read more »

  • Mick says:

    04:34am | 17/02/10

    A charity case I meant sarcastically, in the sense that those who do not want such high levels of immigration are often called racist, and therefore it comes off like bringing in these relatively high numbers of people is some sort of undebatable cause we need to get behind or… Read more »

 

This is an emotional week. It started with the National Prayer Breakfast in the Great Hall of Parliament House where the keynote address was from Gemma Sisia, the founder and continuing driver of the school of St Jude in Arusha in Tanzania.

Despite the debate over the treatment of the asylum seekers on the Oceanic Viking Australia does a lot of good for refugees. Who else needs our compassion?

It was inspirational. A rigorous selection process of children who are 5, 6 or 7 (not 4 ½ or 8) as Mrs Sisia emphasised, are selected on the basis of intellectual ability, work ethic and poverty. If they get in they get 14 years of free education. The aim is to produce a professional class of doctors, engineers, and architects etc, who will lead the Tanzaman nation. That is they will stay in Tanzania and help their own people.

Mrs Sisia, an Australian, who now obviously lives and works in Tanzania seeks financial support from all over the world with her last big donor being American.

Latest 2 of 26 comments

View all comments
 
  • Vanessa Browne says:

    04:07pm | 20/11/09

    The reason why most of the politicians in charge of funding don’t care about the fate of Kingsdene is that they are completely ignorant about the degree of disability affecting our students. How long would your local state school cope 17 year old 6 foot tall hyperactive boy who does… Read more »

  • Use ya brain! says:

    09:28pm | 19/11/09

    What I find interesting about these comment blogs is that once people who REALLY know what they are talking about add their comments, the twits and the knockers lose interest. Read more »

 

We have had the ‘Pacific Solution’, the Christmas Island solution, and now the Indonesian solution - it’s time for an Australian solution to the problem of asylum seekers making the desperate and dangerous voyage to seek the protection of our country.

Voyage of the damned: Warren Brown in The Daily Telegraph this week.

Reasonable people would agree that - those who cynically exploit desperate asylum seekers for profits should be stopped; it is appalling to see women and children making dangerous voyages and putting their lives at risk; people fleeing persecution will give everything they have to get their families to safety; there should be an orderly and fair refugee assessment system and Australia must honour its international obligations.

The core problem is that those who embark on boats are desperate. Between 85 per cent and 98 per cent of people arriving by boat are ultimately accepted by Immigration to have legitimate refugee claims. That is, they have fled from serious harm in their home countries for reasons covered by the Refugee Convention.

Latest 2 of 39 comments

View all comments
 
  • Voxpop says:

    04:38pm | 13/11/09

    Julie Coker-Godson - go back to the MSM pages where your hateful diatribe fits in best (the Top Gun comment gives you away ).  Or better yet grow a brain - it’s incredible how truly ignorant people can be.  I’d be embarassed to write comments that are factually wrong and… Read more »

  • Julie Coker-Godson says:

    05:56pm | 12/11/09

    The refugees do not own the Oceanic Viking, the Australian Taxpayers do:  the refugees are writing cheques their bodies cannot cash! (with credits/apologies to Top Gun producers).  Get these people off our vessel!! To our cringeworthy government I would say, stop weasling and just get on with it! Read more »

 

I missed the last week of Parliament during the ongoing debate concerning boat people.

The tiny residents of the Watoto Babies home in Uganda. Picture: Stuart Robert.

I was in Uganda at a board meeting of my favorite charity Watoto, a charity that rescues abandoned children and babies and gives them hope and a future.

I’ve been going to Africa every year for many years working with some of the poorest people on earth.

Latest 2 of 41 comments

View all comments
 
  • KW says:

    03:12pm | 29/10/09

    Thanks DG, Appreciate that you took the time to read & respond. Even if we don’t quite see eye to eye! Read more »

  • paul says:

    07:28am | 29/10/09

    @marley no mate, you are simplistic and naive. Do you know where the massive amounts of money came from to support an extended Tamil campaign came from?  Australia is on the list -google it. Just as Aussies and Americans funded the IRA back in the day -google it too.  And… Read more »

 

Of the 9.1 million people who the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) describes as refugees, there are 827, 323 with outstanding applications for asylum around the world. This compares to 9.6 million refugees five years ago and 912,291 people still seeking asylum. Five years prior to that, there were 11.5 million refugees worldwide and 1.3 million seeking asylum.

Kevin Rudd has some thinking to do

Looking at even more recent data, between January and August 2009, there were 226,069 asylum applications worldwide. During the same period in 2008 there were 226,857 applications.

So much for the Rudd Government’s claim that international push forces are the cause of 41 boat arrivals since last August with almost 2,000 people on board, putting their lives at risk.

Latest 2 of 65 comments

View all comments
 
  • anna says:

    03:07pm | 01/11/09

    lighten up Wayne H and maybe you won’t be a racist anymore Read more »

  • Wayne H says:

    04:53pm | 16/10/09

    Lighten up a bit….. A beautiful fairy appeared one day to a destitute refugee claimant outside the Parramatta Immigration Offices in Macquarie Street. ‘My good man,’ the fairy said, ‘I’ve been told to grant you three wishes, since you’ve just arrived in Sydney, Australia with your wife and seven children.’… Read more »

 

Amnesty International flatly rejects the assertion that recent changes to Government policy have led to an increase in the number of asylum seekers arriving in Australia by boat.

Children on the HMAS Adelaide after the 'children overboard' incident. Boat arrivals have a high profile but the majority of asylum seekers arrive by plane.

Despite much sensationalist reporting on the issue of boat arrivals, the fact remains that only a tiny percentage of the millions of people seeking asylum choose to seek that protection on Australia’s shores.

Statistics published in June by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), the international body responsible for addressing refugee issues worldwide, show that at the end of 2008 there were 827,323 pending asylum seeker cases worldwide. Australia was handling 2159 of these – which is substantially less than one per cent.

Latest 2 of 64 comments

View all comments
 
  • Colin says:

    01:56pm | 23/10/09

    Can’t believe the comments on here!  I feel like in a time warp back in the days of Good Ol’ White Australia. Please read the article you are commenting on at least.This is embarassing. Read more »

  • Paul says:

    10:51pm | 15/10/09

    Enough of left wing policies, and there loonacy ,the fact they need to get to Australia these illegal immigrants so badly after they are all in a safe Muslim country like Indonesia ,is proof enough that Australia is there desired destination because they get a free ride and a how… Read more »

 

The Pacific Solution has been replaced by the Indian Ocean non-solution.

One of the boats intercepted off Ashmore Reef in September

In the ABC documentary The Howard Years those responsible for the Pacific Solution said that the mandatory detention camps they inherited from Labor were almost bursting, due to the influx of boats.

We face the same situation with the Christmas Island Detention Centre rapidly filling up as the boats keep coming.

Latest 2 of 71 comments

View all comments
 
  • Jason says:

    04:31pm | 13/11/09

    Amazing - nobody is saying we shouldn’t take genuine refugees.  Just don’t accept queue jumpers.  If Australia collapsed into a civil war (or say, the greens got into power), it’s the “fat cats” who would be the boat people choosing their destination and leaving the poor “working class” back in… Read more »

  • Kelley says:

    01:18pm | 13/11/09

    It was interesting to see Evans last night on tele squirming and dithering, and then Lateline with Tanner and Pyne. Pyne made mince meat of Tanner. Well done Pyne about time. About time this Government had scrutiny. Read more »

 

No matter if you’re sitting in a boozed state in the back of a cab at 2am,  if you’re being taken on a half-hour “shortcut” or have to revert to sign language to say ``take the next left’’, always take time to share a nice word with your cabbie.

Wonder what sort of night this cabbie's going to have. Picture: Gordon McComiskie

Those on the road we never feel guilty to rage at, honk or flick the bird, cabbies are fast becoming public enemy No.1 - And there’s no mystery as to why.

In hometown Brisbane it’s hard to get a driver who speaks English and doesn’t stare at you blankly when you ask them to drive you into town.  Their 12 hours shifts means they get bored with indicating, speed limits, right of way and other minor road rules and a simple ``to the airport please’’ usually provokes a frantic tom-tom tap-fest.

Latest 2 of 14 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sam says:

    04:59pm | 30/09/09

    Great experience, being a cabbie. I did it for a few months, night shift, day shift… I often felt that my life was in the hands of the passengers. It really is an art trying to stay on the good side of an aggresive rude illeterate uncultured uncivilised moron at… Read more »

  • regina says:

    04:10pm | 28/09/09

    i like cabbies but when i was growing up i dreaded having to hail one late at night when i was a little worse for wear. that’s because inevitably the cabbie would be a relative of mine sometimes several times removed but family nonetheless and i’d spend the whole trip… Read more »

 

It’s not a new adage that it takes a community to raise a child, but sometimes the simple assumptions we take for granted need to be brought back into the spotlight to reinforce their relevance.

Asylum seekers taken off board the HMAS Tobruk earlier this year. Picture: Colin Murty

If we’re to expect to be able to raise well-adjusted children who each have a sense of security and belonging, we need to be progressive in our definition of community – including in our consideration of where our individual responsibility to community starts and ends.

While Australia provides a safe-haven for many thousands of refugees seeking asylum every year, their relief can be short-lived if they fail to adjust to a life so completely different to any they have ever known.

Latest 2 of 4 comments

View all comments
 
  • stephen says:

    04:20pm | 14/08/09

    This is a big country, and let them come. And when they do, house them inland. (Our ancestors, stuck to the coast, wanted to re-create the coloures of the old country, e.g. blue and green.) But our future belongs inland ; we are a desert people, and maybe our new… Read more »

  • Mr Subramanian says:

    04:01pm | 14/08/09

    I listened with sadness when the Opposition blamed the increase in illegal immigration on the relaxation on laws under Kevin Rudd - because it is quite possibly true, and nonetheless something I welcomed, if that is one of the costs of becoming a more open and welcoming country to such… Read more »

 

Once again, Australia’s focus has been on the so-called threat of boat people heading our way. Do we defend our borders? Are we soft on people smugglers? Is our way of life under threat?

Hieu Van Le with sons Kim Anh Le and Don Anh Le and wife Lan T. P. Le.<br />
Photo: Ben Searle. Source: University of Adelaide

It is a debate that has raged on and off for more than 30 years, since the first boats appeared off Australia’s northern coastline in the wake of the Vietnam War. There were many Australians who did not want to welcome those for whom we had sacrificed so many young Australians.

Good enough to defend, but not good enough to welcome. It was a time when a young man named Hieu Van Le set out on a perilous journey in search of freedom and opportunity.

Latest 2 of 18 comments

View all comments
 
  • Mark says:

    10:20pm | 09/11/09

    Do you guys only post comments that are politically correct? I repeat;- The days of the open door policy is over. The boats must be turned back.My and every other tax payers money is being wasted .Howard’s Foreign policy techniques were correct and appropriate for 21st Australia.He is a true… Read more »

  • franklin says:

    01:17pm | 08/10/09

    The most desperate and vunerable of the worlds refugees are single women and children living in squalid refugee camps in Africa and Asia. They live in abject poverty and are forced to deal with hostile locals, an almost total lack of economic opportunities, frequent gender based violence, high rates of… Read more »

 

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Paul Colgan

@MClarke23 nip out of camp to help out Warney? Now that would cause some chaos

Lucy Kippist

@SimonThomsen LOL you can try!

Lucy Kippist

Don't bring your children and other "rules" of supermarket shopping. Got a gripe or two of your own? Add to my list: http://bit.ly/dBWydm

Lucy Kippist

What voters really think of Tony Abbott, great piece by Nic Christensen & Tina Tek: http://bit.ly/bvLWSz#thepunch

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Breaking news: Something is going on

Breaking news: Something is going on

Is this the greatest ever send-up of 24-hour news? Warning: contains strong language and hilarity. From… Read more

10 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter