Pope Benedict
It’s in the Catholic Rulebook, more commonly known as the Bible, that any Catholic can be Pope. The next one should totes be me.

To those who say, ‘Why you?’
I reply, ‘Why not?’
Just in case that flawless argument isn’t enough, let me expand.
It’s exciting when there’s big news at the Vatican. Everyone tunes in, Catholic or not. I get excited for a few reasons – I am Catholic, I follow the Pope and what he’s up to, and I just love reading the ignorant dribble that emerges from those who take the liberty to call themselves “Vaticanologists”.

Or in this case, a historian. Dr Geoff Nathan from UNSW wrote his thoughts on why the Pope had to go, as if it was a fait accompli that his days were numbered. While you expect the usual complaints from another “informed observer”, you certainly don’t expect a blatant disregard for facts, which should be bread and butter for a historian.
Mistaking John Paul II’s election year (it was 1978, not 1981) was a schoolboy error, and a taster for greater oversights.
Continue reading "Nobody could have predicted this early goodbye" »
Latest 2 of 122 comments
View all comments-
stephen says:
Quite a few famous Thinkers have gone to Catholicism toward the end of their lives when they see death knocking at their own door, and they see, too, the despair of so many around them, and there is no hope. I though, never want to be so miserable that the… Read more »
-
Shane From Melbourne says:
I blame Emperor Constantine for all this mess. If only Emperor Julian the Apostate had lived Read more »
“Declaro me ministerio Episcopi Romae, Successoris Sancti Petri…renuntiare”. Uttering these words in reedy, German-flavoured Latin, Benedict XVI became the first Pope in almost six hundred years to abdicate.

The last man to do so was Gregory XII in 1415, not entirely of his own choosing, when no fewer than three pontiffs all claimed to be the heir of St. Peter. Abdication - voluntary and otherwise - is nothing new for the papacy; we have examples going back almost 1700 years.
But Benedict’s decision is certainly novel in modern times. Predictably, the blogosphere and twittersphere have exploded in conspiracy theories (including the always present, but as of yet unrealised, end of the world), but their concerns and those of more staid commentators boil down to two questions: why did Benedict abdicate and what will happen now?
Continue reading "Three compelling reasons why the Pope had to go" »
Latest 2 of 89 comments
View all comments-
K-Oz says:
Appreciate your post, unlike the inane and childish “contributions” of most others. Read more »
-
LJ Dots says:
@Chillin, I’ll pay that. lol Read more »
It’s a familiar scenario and one which has played out ad nauseam for a long time. It polarises opinion like few other topics and there just isn’t any common ground. In fact, the gulf has widened to become a chasm.

That is pretty much the only conclusion to be drawn from Pope Benedict’s recent ramblings about all things gay marriage.
In his Christmas address to the Vatican bureaucracy on Saturday, Pope Benedict decided not to celebrate what the Festive Season should mean to Roman Catholics – peace, love, family, togetherness, oh, and the birth of the religion’s deity – but instead chose to rail, again, against gay marriage by saying it was destroying the very “essence of the human creature.”
Continue reading "An edict from Ben which stamps him as a dopey pope" »
Latest 2 of 97 comments
View all comments-
stephen says:
Over a year ago I visited the State Library to meet Sir Michael Kirby - the retired High Court Judge - and to buy his book titled ‘Michael Kirby - A Private Life’ - and possibly to get this volume signed, and to say hello. I did both, and in… Read more »
-
Roscoe says:
Man, you’ve got a lot of time on your hands Reg. What a waste of a Xmas eve putting together that diatribe! Read more »
In a major global exclusive, The Punch has received a sneak glimpse into the Twitter feed of Pope Benedict XVI.

Despite boasting hundreds of thousands of followers since joining Twitter with the handle @pontifex overnight, His Holiness is yet to tweet.
However, the Pontiff is said to have a dozen or so pithy 140 character pronouncements ready to roll, just as soon as he can find a biblical passage to prove that God, not science, is relaying his Tweets to the world.
Continue reading "Vatileaks: An exclusive look at the Pope’s Twitter feed" »
Latest 2 of 64 comments
View all comments-
pfffft says:
Thppptfft is the most intelligent thing that has ever come from anthony sharwood Read more »
-
TheRealDave says:
I thought it was pretty obvious Tubesteak Read more »
For one of the world’s most powerful men Pope Benedict has a big problem with clear communication.

Health experts around the world have rejoiced at a hint from the Pope that it kinda, sorta, maybe could be better for a male prostitute with AIDS to use a condom when having sex.
The Vatican has been quick to clear up that it’s not official teaching so headlines such as “Vatican makes first concession on condom use”, in one paper this morning seem a little hasty.
Continue reading "Thanks Benedict, that’s about as clear as mud" »
Latest 2 of 61 comments
View all comments-
Kika says:
Because all the scourges of the world are women’s responsibilty. Remember, they are the source of original sin? Man was once pure and innocent and were corrupted by a foul evil woman. When will the RCC ever care about women’s rights? hahaha. Never. Read more »
-
Robert S McCormick says:
Any method which even offers an 80% safety factor is better than none. Total Abstinence, though it will ensure non-transmission of any diseases or stop the risk of falling pregnant is for the most part a pipe-dream. Have a look around at all those 10s or 1000s of Priests, Monks… Read more »
I can see why the new atheist commentators Christopher Hitchens and Richard Dawkins want to take on the Pope. Here is someone who fears what Gareth Evans called “relevance deprivation”. He fears it for himself as Pope, he fears it for the Church. To bolster the declining authority of the Church, he has set up the straw man of “aggressive secularism” and sets his adherents against it.

Religion, the Pope told Britons in his trip this month, is being “marginalised”, relegated to the “purely private sphere”. Believers holding public roles are being asked to act against their conscience, he claims. Secularism, Britains were warned, no longer values or tolerates their traditional values such as honesty, respect and fair-mindedness.
Your Holiness, this is rubbish – ideologically motivated rubbish.
Latest 2 of 169 comments
View all comments-
Badger says:
Well, good on you if you “prefer education over restrictions”, Jade, but that is not the prerogative of the secularists. In other areas - for example, racial vilification - some religious and some secular people support legal bans, other religious and other secular people support education as the solution. In… Read more »
-
True Believer says:
I find it depressing that so many who know so little expound so much about what they do not know and think they are clever. For those who only rabbit on about the Roman Catholic Church, not all Christians are Catholics. Just as not all church-goers and those who lord… Read more »
At breakfast yesterday my two-year-old daughter wanted to “read” me the Easter card she got from a relative. “One day, they went in the forest, and then they were finished. The End,” she said, looking up from the card. “Now you read it to me.” So I did. The greeting was:
Easter time is here again
That lovely time of year
When we especially think of those
We hold especially dear
So naturally you’re thought about
And wished the nicest things –
All the special happiness
A joyful Easter brings!
I’m enthusiastic about explaining things to her so I was about to drop a few sentences somehow explaining Easter was really about God, but a thought crossed my mind and stopped me. I have no tolerance left for the Church’s protection of child abusers, its silencing of victims and failure to adequately apologise or explain why it failed to act against paedophiles. Why, I asked myself, should my daughter be exposed to these men in frocks and their beliefs?
For someone raised as a Catholic this is an arresting thought. Even though its dogma is world-renowned it may still be hard to grasp, for anyone not brought up with it, the all-or-nothing way Catholicism requires you to accept, without question, the authority of the Church. Put simply, if you don’t accept the Church you’re not Catholic.
Continue reading "How much abuse can you take from the Church?" »
Latest 2 of 453 comments
View all comments-
online loans says:
Also don’t need to need to wait around so very long to your request to get approved. You will need to apply on the web for choosing these financial situation. After you fill use and send it here the job permitted in a short time. Within 1 day your resources… Read more »
-
Rob Pollock says:
Sam Miller has his numbers wrong… Mr. Miller’s statement, “10% of the Protestant ministers have been found guilty of pedophilia” has no basis in fact! It was refuted by the named source in 2002 and remains refuted today. In his original 2003 speech Mr. Miller cites a July/August 2002 Sojourners… Read more »
Ever tried to apologise to someone and been rebufffed?

Pope Benedict experienced just that on the weekend when he made an apology to Irish people who were sexually abused by Catholic priests.
His apology came in the wake of last November’s government report, The Murphy Report, which found the Irish clergy “obsessively” concealed child abuse by priests in Dublin from 1975 - 2004 and operated under a policy of ” don’t ask, don’t tell.”
Continue reading "Pope’s apology won’t be enough for change" »
Latest 2 of 50 comments
View all comments-
www.thepunch.com.au says:
Pope apology wont be enough for change.. Very nice Read more »
-
hmmm says:
My good, someone on this blog has been studying critical thinking! Read more »
Facebook Recommendations
Read all about it
Punch live
Up to the minute Twitter chatter
RT @ToryShepherd: "We have children, and our children are loved and our children are cherished", @SenatorWong says http://t.co/CQhJFpdf2o v…
"We have children, and our children are loved and our children are cherished", @SenatorWong says http://t.co/CQhJFpdf2o via @newscomauHQ
Apple "quietly negotiated" a corporate tax rate of 2 per cent with the Irish government http://t.co/FFIHgqLFOA
Recent posts
The latest and greatest
The Punch is moving house
Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…
Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?
I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…
Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”
In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…
Nosebleed Section
choice ringside rantings
From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go
Tim says:
They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go
Kel says:
If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]Gentle jabs to the ribs
Superman needs saving
Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more
Latest 2 of 109 comments
View all commentsAdd your comment