Nauru
Winston Churchill once noted that democracy was the worst form of government, except for all the rest.

It may also be true of Chris Bowen’s Malaysian solution -assuming it can be revived somehow. It is the worst possible answer to the asylum seeker problem, except for any others anyone can think of.
I know. I know. Calling a people-swap arrangement “good’’ policy is a stretch. Very few voters would agree right now and for a government that goes backwards even when spruiking a tax cut, the task of selling something so inelegant and counter-intuitive is clearly a bridge too far.
A straightforward decision by the High Court: the government’s “Malaysian solution” was illegal. But that simple decision is surrounded by a kaleidoscope of complexities, conundrums and challenges. Julia Gillard has to find a way through the maze, and come out of it with a policy which will not cause key elements of her support base to rebel against her.

The maze is complex indeed. The Greens are demanding that all asylum seekers be vetted in Australia. This would be a massive “pull” factor, which goes against the oft-stated aim of the government to stop the boats.
But with the Greens holding a balance of power in the Senate, and one Green, Adam Bandt, holding the tenure of the government with his single vote in the House, there will have to be some real ducking and weaving.
Continue reading "Gillard is up the creek in dire need of a paddle" »
Latest 2 of 103 comments
View all comments-
Kaedon says:
Whoveer edits and publishes these articles really knows what they’re doing. Read more »
-
PC plod says:
The international law should state that refugees MUSt flee to the CLOSEST nation ratifying UN laws. They should not be able to bypass other countries and come to Australia if it’s not the closest country to their ‘oppression’. Fleeing to countries taht have welfare payment isn’t fleeing oppression it’s trying… Read more »
The Government’s choice now is to bring asylum seekers onto the mainland – maybe even into the suburbs – or find a fresh way to park them somewhere off-shore.

That choice is simple, but the politics and legalities are wretchedly complex as Julia Gillard and Tony Abbott deal with last week’s High Court ruling.
And it now seems increasingly likely that the ultimate decision, and in fact Government and Coalition policy, will have to be made by the High Court.
Continue reading "Both sides courting disaster over asylum seeker policy" »
Latest 2 of 178 comments
View all comments-
Marilyn Shepherd says:
Marely, I know the law inside out and upside down. Do try not to sledge me in such a pathetic manner. Why on earth anyone is anti trying to help those who have fled the taliban, al Qaida, the deranged mullahs and the genocide in Sri lanka though is beyond… Read more »
-
Marilyn Shepherd says:
The high court cannot and did not rewrite anything. We have laws and obligations that cannot and must not be waved away on the whim of one minister. That boys and girls is tyranny and Kelly is flat out wrong. Read more »
Tony Abbott is a beautiful boy. His straight hair, perfect eyes, ears and nose. No, I am not talking about the Opposition Leader but the 3.47kg baby boy in Nauru who now bears his name.

On the way into Nauru Hospital on Sunday June 12, Nauru Foreign Minister Dr Kieren Keke warned Mr Abbott that he should watch out if a child was born while he was in the maternity unit.
Nauru mothers often name their babies after the first person they see, he explained, and there are plenty of Nauruans named after celebrities. “You might have a few questions to answer,” Dr Keke said with a laugh.
Continue reading "Nauru, where Gillard may one day wed Tony Abbott" »
Latest 2 of 73 comments
View all comments-
PeterA says:
Dear oh dear TimB, given the reporter’s track record and the mere fact she was in tow with Mister Abbott should be a big enough hint, even for someone like you. Read more »
-
RyaN says:
@DY: what no reply, are you not outraged? Read more »
As a chartered aircraft carries Tony Abbott into Nauru this weekend he will have asylum seekers on his mind, but his first glimpse of the island should remind him of another type of refugee.

It could be that in 20 to 30 years the 10,000 folk of Nauru (maximum height above sea level: 65 m) will be climate change refugees looking for somewhere dry to live.
As the Opposition Leader lands seeking a pledge that under an Abbott government Nauru would again be available as a processing centre for boat people detained on the western flank of the Australian continent, the locals might be preparing a few demands of their own.
Continue reading "Pacific solution: Abbott may live to Nauru the day" »
Latest 2 of 198 comments
View all comments-
Simon says:
@ Ben Wimping out already ? My point was that you’re less concerned with refugees and people smuggling than with trying to make some cheap domestic political point, which you’ve now repeatedly confirmed, complete with some bonus playground name calling. Now, what contradiction ? Read more »
-
Ben81 says:
“Thanks for proving my point” You don’t have one Another weak copout like all your replies. I’m not wasting any more time your stupid little game, already wiped the floor with you enough times. Bye. Read more »
In so many ways it looks familiar. Players lining up for their turn to lead, mark the ball, and pass to their team mate leading in the opposite direction. It is the quintessential footy drill.

But with the familiarity comes two big differences. First, despite this being Australian Rules we were not in Australia. And second, every sprinting player left a cloud of dust rising in his wake.
Nauru is a footy mad nation and the Linkbelt Oval is its home of footy. It is the MCG. It may also be the most unique ground in the world of AFL. It is not a field of grass. Rather, footy is played on soft phosphate looking dirt which sits upon a base of coral rock.
Continue reading "The power of sport to cross cultural divides" »
Latest 2 of 14 comments
View all comments-
Shawn says:
Sports bring people of different culture together as it gives them a common interest and passion. Read more »
-
Michael C says:
almost a year on, and having seen the 4th installment of the AFL international cup, and attended the Gala dinner at the end of the tournament - I can vouch for the ‘bringing people together’ stuff. It may change way into the future if it all get’s hijacked by ‘professionalism’… Read more »
Nauru has been struggling to get a good run in the press of late. Tales of business largesse, overseas trips, and big deals make juicy copy, leaving scant oxygen for any other news about Nauru. Coupled with the reporting on the detention centre which characterised Nauru as a bleak island in the middle of the Pacific, the Australian public could be forgiven for having a dim view of the place.

And yet such a view would not appreciate the deep history and friendship which has existed between Nauru and Australia since Nauru’s independence and before.
Originally known as Pleasant Island for its natural environment and the friendliness of its people Nauru is one of two nations (the other being Papua New Guinea) which has a history of Australian administration pre-independence. This history alone means Australia has a particular role of friendship to play in modern Nauru.
Continue reading "Nauru: we should treat our neighbour with more respect" »
Latest 2 of 12 comments
View all comments-
MarK says:
Nauru does deserve more respect, you forgot to mention the shell banks registered in Nauru which were used to funnel somewhere between 50-300+Billion out of Russia in the early post-communist transition period. and you thought Australian Banks robbed you blind Read more »
-
acotrel says:
If imprisoning asylum seekers is all Nauru can do to ‘earn some badly needed income’, they should pull the plug out and sink the island! Read more »
Nauru has the greatest airline in the world. It’s called Our Airline. The leased-from-Taiwan 737-300 looks a little dated, not having those upturned wing tips which denote a modern plane, but the smiles of the Nauruan flight attendants are warm and welcoming.

There are plenty of spare seats (flying in and flying out) and they offer long-flight sedation in the form of brimming plastic cups of red wine. One of the flight attendants even has her own baby on board, a homey touch.
This airline used to be called Air Nauru. Then, in 2005, the last of its more contemporary 737-400 series jets was repossessed as the country fell into a heap. Clearly, the older plane’s navigational equipment is up to scratch. You’d need it to find this pin-drop island in the middle of the night.
Continue reading "Nauru, unemployment 90%, is ready for business" »
Latest 2 of 89 comments
View all comments-
jack says:
Heard they are going to put somalis up there. Read more »
-
Lin says:
Reading some of the cases and decisions made me think that it’s a script for a sitcom… it would be comical if it wasn’t real. Why are we giving tax money to some ‘tribunal’ to overturn decisions made by tax funded public servants?? And all they base it on is… Read more »
Facebook Recommendations
Read all about it
Punch live
Up to the minute Twitter chatter
Recent posts
The latest and greatest
On a hiding to tweet nothing over mining jobs
You know you’re in strife as a political leader when you must rely on the almost uniformly vacuous…
An NT intervention policy coming to a suburb near you
A controversial policy from the Northern Territory intervention has managed to get through the atrocious…
An insight into a particularly tricky relationship
Marc Glasby has been married to his wife Belle for over thirty years. Three years ago, Belle was reunited…
Nosebleed Section
choice ringside rantings
From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments
Michael S says:
"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone
Change Up! says:
I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]Gentle jabs to the ribs
They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments
A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more
Latest 2 of 71 comments
View all commentsAdd your comment