Nanny State
If the legislation for the Orwellian-sounding Australian National Preventive Health Agency passes, then expect an avalanche of make-work exercises by the Agency all for the cause of making us healthier.
Armed with a budget of $133 million of your money over four years, the agency would get to work advising commonwealth and state health ministers about health issues surrounding alcohol and tobacco consumption and obesity.
It will look to create new policies about interventions in settings such as schools, workplaces and communities.
This week parliament will debate a bill to establish a national Preventive Health Agency, reminding of that classic Mark Twain observation: nobody is safe while the legislature is in session.
On The Punch Federal health minister Nicola Roxon insisted that she was no nanny statist, and that the purpose of the Agency was about saving lives and reducing health costs.
Most modern governments understand the follies of outright bans, such as the failed US Prohibition movement from 1919 to 1933. However, the Agency plans what it sees as the next best thing.
Continue reading "Counterpunch: The nanny state will nag you to death" »
Latest 2 of 50 comments
View all comments-
SandDollar says:
Well the only fun things left, everything else if offensive apparently. Not sure this is the role of government. Business and government getting into areas of life and culture too much and too often. Read more »
-
Julie Coker-Godson says:
I found this article on the BBC about discrimination against the overweight. http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/em/fr/-/2/hi/health/8314125.stm > It makes for interesting reading. Personally I’m fed up with all the judgemental statements being made about this issue and would be interested to see if it ever constituted a “hate crime” as discussed here. Read more »
Next week Parliament is set to consider legislation that is another first from the Rudd Government – Australia’s first agency dedicated to Preventative Health.
Currently the media abounds with stories about our obesity epidemic, rising rates of chronic disease and problems with alcohol and tobacco. This Agency will help us do something about those problems.
As much as some media outlets find the labels irresistible, this isn’t about creating a nanny state, or nagging people into being ‘good’. This Agency will be staffed with experts who will work hard to find the best possible ways to help us be healthier – and reduce our health bill as a result.
Continue reading "I’m no nanny, it’s about saving lives and the system" »
Latest 2 of 72 comments
View all comments-
KaXien VaLa says:
Basically the essence of this idea comes down to the process used to treat health issues and the pathway through treatments. The key elements to consider when proscribing a treatment is the risk to effectiveness relationship. Typically the more severe the issue the more potent the treatment…this means that for… Read more »
-
gusgrogan@gmail.com says:
Thanks but no thanks Nicola Read more »
YOU know what I love about the Grand Canyon, other than that it is one awesome kick-arse hole in the ground?
It’s got no fences. You are free to fall into it if you feel so inclined. Sure, there’s the odd sign telling you that straying too close to the edge could bring a premature and permanent end to your holiday, but that’s the extent of the bureaucratic concern.
If the Grand Canyon was in Australia, it would have a fence around it.
Too dangerous, the nannas who govern us would cry, to let people just explore it in a manner of their choosing.
Continue reading "Wowser watch: the plastic beer glass is pure evil" »
Latest 2 of 10 comments
View all comments-
Your name: says:
for a start there are harsher sentences for glassers. prevention is better than cure. If you go somewhere with a prevailence of glassing, you will appreciate plastic Read more »
-
sarah (glassed) says:
when you’ve been glassed, you can comment. Read more »
Recent posts
The latest and greatest
Former army chief says ‘make love, not war’
Throughout history millions have urged us to ‘make love, not war’ and an important voice… Read more
Most commented
The talk of the town
- Food allergy fascists make peanuts of us all 287
- For God's sake, can our MPs just stick to their day jobs 266
- Abbott: Why I journeyed into the dead heart 213
- What is the best age for women to have babies? 211
- Why there is no International Man’s Day 172
- Abbott's first mistake 134
- An unfinished guide to etiquette for beggars 120
- Art is the not the enemy in the fight against child porn 118
- Even for angels a warm inner glow ain't hard cash 109
- Uncovered meat, Facebook and a simmering melting pot 96
Punch live
Up to the minute Twitter chatter
Gentle jabs to the ribs
Breaking news: Something is going on
Is this the greatest ever send-up of 24-hour news? Warning: contains strong language and hilarity. From… Read more
Latest 2 of 19 comments
View all commentsAdd your comment