Murray Darling

This might come as a shock, but last week 11 bills were passed by the House of Representatives and Parliament that dealt with some of the most significant issues of the century so far. And lots of cross party agreement was needed to get this work done.

Substantial events of the week included agreement on a management plan for the Murray-Darling Basin, a quest which is almost as old as Parliament, and steps to create a National Disability Insurance Scheme, a plan once considered unachievable.

In any week, and not just the last, these would have been important signposts of progress benefitting the Australian people.

Latest 2 of 61 comments

View all comments
  • maria says:

    06:58pm | 03/12/12

    You to stop more “shit happens” than direct democracy a la Switzerland is the only answer. A democracy is a society in which the citizens are sovereign and control the government as it is under the swiss democracy. By calling a federal referendum a group of citizens may challenge a… Read more »

  • Mouse says:

    06:44pm | 03/12/12

    ChrisL,  are you all green?  :o|  **that’s my “straight” face** Only joking buddy!!  hehehehe I do reckon you forgot the luvleeeee bit before it though!  lol ;o) Read more »


History is littered with good intentions gone bad and concerns are growing the Government’s recently released draft Murray Darling Basin Plan is a prime example.

Too much of a good thing.

Frontline environmentalists, who live and work with the vagaries of the rivers, are warning that the Government is heading down the wrong track and could be responsible for allowing wetlands, which not even the worst drought in living memory could kill, to be severely damaged as a result of over-watering.

If we have above average rainfall over the next 12 months the world’s largest river red gum forest is facing the very real prospect of being degraded within three years of it being declared a national park, and two years before the Federal Government has signed off on an environmental watering plan.

Latest 2 of 19 comments

View all comments
  • Ian Robinson says:

    03:10pm | 16/12/11

    Hi Tom - Good to talk with you in Deniliquin today.  There is a lot of local involvement in environmental water management at present as we have a network of partners including local environmental water advisory committees and catchment management authorities (CMAs). For example the Deniliquin based Murray CMA is… Read more »

  • Eastern State Mentality Person says:

    07:54pm | 15/12/11

    South who? Oh you guys down there at the bottom end of the system…oh yeah..forgot about youse. We’ll send you a few megalitres if we have any left…ok? Fair enough? Read more »


The Murray-Darling Basin Authority Draft Plan, released yesterday, includes a reduction in water use of 2,750 gigalitres per year, compared to 2009 baseline diversions. So there will now be extra 2,750 GL/y in environmental flows. Does this give the right balance?

This Murray Cod is clearly unimpressed with the draft plan

The candidates for the biggest loser are (1) the irrigators, (2) the Basin communities and (3) the environment.

The extra environmental flow is estimated to lead to a reduction in irrigated agricultural production of about 11%. But the irrigators won’t be the big losers because they will be compensated by the water buyback scheme.

Latest 2 of 31 comments

View all comments
  • Rick with a silent P says:

    02:22pm | 29/11/11

    Yeh that’s the best place for Vic’s….....underwater! Read more »

  • palone says:

    02:12pm | 29/11/11

    Peter, I think that you cut the above diatribe from a report on John Howard’s Government and put it away for when Labor came to office, and now you send it in whatever the topic. Didn’t you make that very same comment when Australia got kicked out of the World… Read more »


Labor hard man Graham Richardson noted yesterday that courage was a defining quality in a leader. He was speaking about Peter Costello’s unwillingness to do the hard graft of gathering the numbers for a challenge which of course, never came. That tawdry clash of egos which bedevilled the last Coalition governemnt will re-surface this week when John Howard’s memoirs, ``Lasarus Rising’’ hits the bookshelves.

Cartoon by The Australian's Jon Kudelka

Courage remains important in the contemporary political context too because it is not just seizing power that takes guts, exercising it fully also requires steely determination in the face of resistance.

Even Julia Gillard’s political enemies concede she has passed the first of these tests. Blasting Kevin Rudd from the leadership took a lot of sand.

Latest 2 of 13 comments

View all comments
  • Gregg says:

    04:22pm | 25/10/10

    If the truth be known Ted, there ain’t been a hell of a lot done by any parties for about fifty years since the Snowy scheme and water storages were constructed, the Mitta Mitta being a bit later but it is as much north of the Murray if not more… Read more »

  • Ted N says:

    10:51am | 25/10/10

    Thanks Alcotrel. As the father of a farmer, I put much of the blame at John Howards feet. If the same effort and money and media discussion had gone into our major food bowl crisis, as Howard put into the War/s, swanning around Washington, spending billions on refugees, and general… Read more »


I just returned from almost three weeks in Hong Kong. It is a city that I fell in love with some five years ago when I worked there with Oxfam Hong Kong.

A ram's skull at Trilby, on the intersection of the Murray and Darling rivers. Pic: AAP / File

There is a great deal that Australia’s major cities could learn from Hong Kong: it is a city that promotes and rewards efficiency, cleanliness and creativity – aspects that we often neglect.

This is clearly evident in the integrated design of the public transport system that is regular, clean, safe and on time. (Please note NSW State Rail Authority: the definition of ‘on time’ does not change at regular intervals but is kind of set). For example, last Saturday I missed a bus – my irritation was subdued when I informed the next one was ‘four minutes’ away. We can compare this to the two-hour gap between busses on the 370 route between Leichhardt and Coogee which I was faced with only a week later: and this is in the eastern suburbs if Sydney – the best served public transport corridor.

Latest 2 of 44 comments

View all comments
  • Bep says:

    03:29pm | 29/05/11

    Brad got owned. Read more »

  • Jordan Rastrick says:

    11:59am | 19/10/10

    @sheps: You’ve accused past governments of mismanagement through overallocation. Now government is flagging that it may propose to buy the excessive allocations back from anyone prepared to voluntarily sell them - so wouldn’t you support this newfound responsibility on the government’s part? Anyway, I’m just a city slicker with, I’ll… Read more »


Independent MP Tony Windsor yesterday continued what is becoming a pattern of rather cryptic and fencing sitting statements. 

When you're everyone's friend you're no-one's friend. Tony Windsor in Parliament House. Picture: Kym Smith

He told The Australian that he wasn’t sure he supported the Murray Darling Basin plan to buy back 3000-4000 gigalitres of water from irrigators, and that perhaps the Government should look at other methods to return water to the system like diverting water from other areas.

This is a perfectly legitimate stance, although it was his other comment about the likelihood of any legislation on the plan succeeding in Parliament that is confusing. Windsor told The Australian and later the ABC that he didn’t think any legislation would see “the light of day” in this Parliament:

Latest 2 of 87 comments

View all comments
  • Holly says:

    10:00pm | 17/10/10

    Gosh this article and some of the comments seem particularly cretinous.  Lets look at this.  The coalition after years of total inaction, sets up an Authority to look at the problems of Murray Darling Basin - this is one of the biggest and most complex ever to face the future… Read more »

  • Kamal says:

    10:45am | 17/10/10

    “Why are people so unkind?” Read more »


As far as political slogans go, “No Dams” had an absolute simplicity about it which resonated with the vast majority of Australians.

The receding shore of Lake Alexandrina. Photo: Adelaide Now

Despite the localised concerns of Tasmanians, some sympathy from blue-collar mainland communities reliant on industries such as logging, and the arcane constitutional quibbles of a few States’ rights enthusiasts, most Australians happily bought the clear message conveyed by the bright yellow triangular bumper sticker.

The Franklin River was saved. The year was 1983. Twenty-seven years on and it’s obvious that while “No Dams” might have worked as an effective call to arms, “Save the Murray” is struggling to get beyond being an empty slogan as the nation remains paralysed as to how we should save it.

Latest 2 of 58 comments

View all comments
  • Peter Oataway, Hay, NSW says:

    11:18am | 27/10/10

    @Alice C ..when you try supporting water to a city of over 1 million people located in a spot with less than 450mm annual rainfall (Adelaide) you deserve to pay a levy.. Read more »

  • AliceC says:

    08:42am | 19/10/10

    @Peter, Yes, just about eveyone pays a water bill, but only people in SA pay a levy on top of their normal water bill. The levy is over and above the normal access charge and usage price. Read more »


It is an absolute tribute to the men and women who built the Snowy Mountains Scheme that their engineering marvels continue to supply drinking, irrigation and environmental water to two million people who call the Murray Darling Basin (MDB) home.

A once-flowing tributary of the Murray in SA. Photo: AAP

Because if it wasn’t for the man-made miracle that is the Snowy Mountain Scheme, the only thing coming out of many taps in the MDB would have been dust.

Permanent plantings of citrus, stone fruits, grapes and the myriad of fresh food that lands on our table would have been wiped out. Whole communities would have had to pack up and leave and the environment would have worn the full fury of Mother Nature with death a daily reminder of the power of the weather gods.

Latest 2 of 100 comments

View all comments
  • Incicyplany says:

    06:33pm | 11/05/12

    clomid online - <a >clomid 50 mg</a> , clomid 25 mg Read more »

  • Nick says:

    01:29pm | 06/05/12

    Hello. And Bye. Read more »


The recent significant rain event in the northern stretch of the Murray Darling Basin has not only given hope to suffering farmers and rural communities, it has also placed a spotlight firmly on the fraud being perpetrated by the Prime Minister and the cabal of Labor Premiers when it comes to water policy for the Murray Darling Basin. 

Rudd's stimulus could have paid better dividends here. Picture: Amos Aikman.

Only 18 months ago this group of ‘leaders’ stood together and waved around a ‘historic’ agreement in Chamberlin like fashion claiming that it delivered a national system of water management. 

Not only has this been shown to be a complete joke by the torrent of water now flowing down the Darling, it has also shown the Rudd Government’s failure to invest in the necessary infrastructure to deliver real water savings before the rain came.

Latest 2 of 26 comments

View all comments
  • David Boyd says:

    05:28pm | 22/01/10

    Jamie, The South Australian’s claim that the dreadful condition of the Lower Lakes is due to extractions and lack of fresh water from upstream. No mention of the fact that under natural conditions the Lower Lakes were sometimes salty and sometimes fresh depending on fresh water flows, or lack of… Read more »

  • John A Neve says:

    09:01am | 22/01/10

    Persephone 20527hrs, yesterday. If those “silly people who think their lives are OK’  why do they whinge on these blogs? If people like you feel all is well with the world, what is there to debate? Unlike you, who defends a dying system, I believe change can take place, but… Read more »


In a move reminiscent of John Howard’s “headland” speeches ahead of his successful 1996 campaign, Opposition Leader Tony Abbott last night delivered the first of his direction statements ahead of this year’s poll. And he adopted a decidedly green hue, saying it was time to scotch the misnomer that conservatives could not be good environmentalists.

Abbott says environment a vote-changing issue in this year's election.

The speech contained two policies - the national takeover of the Murray-Darling river system and the creation of a so-called 15,000-strong “Green Army”  - and a promise of more to follow, with Abbott conceding he did not yet have a finalised position on carbon emissions but would do so within the fortnight.

The first policy should have Kevin Rudd worried as if he had been acting as a decisive national leader he would already have stepped in to wrest control of our biggest river system off the squabbling states. The second policy seems more a bit of gimmickry - and expensive gimmickry at that, with a potential bill of up to $750 million to send 15,000 environmental fix-up folks into the bush at $50,000 a pop.

Latest 2 of 131 comments

View all comments
  • Evan Findlay says:

    10:44pm | 22/01/10

    Radical chick, do your research. The green army was an idea brought out in the nineties by Abbott when he was a secretary for Amanda Vanstone. Hardly fresh! Read more »

  • Timmo says:

    04:33am | 19/01/10

    I suggested in a previous blog which was not included here that instead of interfering more in what little bit of nature we have left, that we might embark on a rather grand plan of greening the centre of Australia by building a canal large enough to bring ships from… Read more »


Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more



Read all about it

Sign up to the free newsletter