Matthew Johns

The response to The Age’s decision to sack Catherine Deveny says a lot about the Australian media and Australian media audiences. In particular, it shows how selective both can be depending on whether they like or dislike the person — and whether it’s a man or woman at the centre of a scandal.

The Deveny double-standard…enough to make your hair stand on end.

Soon after Deveny’s sacking was announced, some of her supporters in the Twittersphere claimed that she had been a victim of censorship.

It makes Deveny seem heroic, but it’s hard to see this as censorship.In the first place, Deveny wasn’t prevented by The Age from expressing herself. On this occasion at least, they didn’t spike her writings.

Latest 2 of 51 comments

View all comments
 
  • Peter Ketsup says:

    01:11am | 16/05/10

    Sandilands may have a rating show but when did ratings suddenly have a say in seriously borderline criminality not being punished. 2Day FM should be boycotted for their spineless stance against this bully. Read more »

  • Ben says:

    05:17pm | 08/05/10

    Alright Brooke, find this nasty press coverage. You will find a few articles that relate her exploits with a matter-of-fact tone and alot more that have “lets hope that she gets the help that she needs” type comments. You will find nothing nearly as vicious as the nastiness directed at… Read more »

 

At the Walkley Awards last Thursday night one of the biggest cheers of the evening was reserved for Tracy Grimshaw, who won the gong for broadcast interviewing.

As the A Current Affair host made her way to the stage, the big screen behind the presenters played an excerpt from one of the interviews Grimshaw was being honoured for - her excruciating chat with former NRL star Matthew Johns.

There 10 times larger than life was a visibly distraught Johns, flanked by his wife Trish, responding to explosive claims about group sex in the NRL contained in a 4 Corners report - another Walkley winner. Half the media executives in the country were in the room watching Grimshaw accept the well-deserved award.

About the same time, according to yesterday’s Sunday Telegraph, Seven and Ten were engaged in a bidding war to see who can sign Johns to spearhead their NRL coverage. These network bosses sure do have short memories.

Latest 2 of 52 comments

View all comments
 
  • Helen says:

    07:43am | 09/12/09

    DG thinks it might be perfectly normal for a footy team to trap a woman in a room and all have sex with her and I’m the one who’s deluded. Right. *Backing away slowly* It appears that in Australia if any woman is alone with any man in a room,… Read more »

  • Rybags says:

    01:08am | 09/12/09

    Easy solution. {CLICK} Change the channel. In fact, turn the TV off, go outside and play with your kids or take your wife for a walk instead. Read more »

 

AIN’T rape a hoot?

It seems like the good old boys at Carlton Football Club just can’t stop laughing about former president John Elliott’s claim that at least four women were paid not to pursue rape allegations against players in the 80s and 90s.

Pig's arse: Elliott bemoans troublesome sheilas

``We just sort of said, `Righto, here’s five grand, off you go’ and they’d leave,’’ Elliott told a charity event in Hobart last week. ``There’s some very ordinary people out there.’‘

Onya, Johnno.

Latest 2 of 20 comments

View all comments
 
  • FJ says:

    02:46pm | 27/06/09

    Excellent article although from the scant media coverage you’d never know that AFL players get in strife. The Sydney media never report any of these things yet TV channels like Ten always mention AFL in their sport. I’d love to know if there are still deals in place with the… Read more »

  • jg_rat says:

    04:23pm | 26/06/09

    Surprised at the air of surprise that Elliott would say such a thing. Gosh. Read more »

 

There’s an extraordinary piece of journalism in today’s Daily Telegraph by “Coogee Cougar” Charmyne Palavi where she takes more positions than the Kama Sutra on the questions of sex and consent.

Occasional op-ed writer Charmyne Palavi in research mode

Palavi, who among other things has blown the whistle on the sub-culture of predatory women bedding sports stars as “scalps”, shot to prominence last week with her morally ambivalent star turn in the Four Corners report on the Matthew Johns sex scandal.

In today’s Tele Palavi speaks of her disappointment that many of her apparently positive experiences have been sullied by the white-hot debate over the Johns affair. She introduces a handy new term to the sexual lexicon - the concept of “mostly consensual” sex.

Latest 1 of 1 comment

View all comments
 
 

UPDATE 7.20pm: Willie Mason has been fined $2000 and ordered to do extra work on his club’s programs that help the homeless.

It’s just a pity it was Willie Mason. Unbelievably, this picture was taken just over 24 hours ago, with Mason deciding the best way to conclude the worst week in NRL history was to piss all over the footpath on a public street outside a Sydney nightclub.

Contempt for the code: it's time to put Willie away

The morning newspapers were squeamish with their use of the photo so we thought we’d run it in full here. It wasn’t a sidestreet or an alleyway either - it was bang in front of dozens of youngsters at the Golden Sheaf Hotel, one of Sydney’s busiest pubs. It wasn’t like Mason deserved a drink anyway - his team the Roosters had just been flogged 38-6 by the unfancied Newcastle.

If only because he brings nothing other than headlines such as these, Mason should be punted from the game. How many lives has this boofhead had? How much contempt has he shown for the code that pays his salary? Follow the furore throughout the day here.

Latest 1 of 1 comment

View all comments
 
  • Stan Wills says:

    12:53pm | 01/06/09

    Willie , always the gentleman has turned his back Read more »

 

In a week when the nation was confronted with a $58 billion budget deficit, when more than a million Australians were stripped of their private health rebate, when plans were unveiled to push the pension age to 67, there was obviously one story in town - Matthew Johns.

Within 24 hours the Johns scandal pushed the budget off the front page

Knocking the federal budget off the front page of a major newspaper in budget week is no mean feat. The last people to do it were called Todd and Brant. They hijacked the coverage of Peter Costello’s 2006 Budget by spending the previous 14 days buried alive in a tiny air-pocket in the collapsed Beaconsfield mine.

While Costello was frustrated by his own burial on the inside pages, Wayne Swan might have been faintly relieved that, just two days after sheepishly unveiling our biggest-ever deficit, replete with some fingers-crossed growth forecasts which may have us not on the path to surplus but bankruptcy, Sydney’s Daily Telegraph devoted its first three pages to Matthew Johns affair.

Latest 2 of 2 comments

View all comments
 
  • Greg Smith says:

    02:42pm | 02/06/09

    Media silence, you mean. The media must shoulder much of the blame for not reporting these incidents. Sports journalists don’t want to risk their ‘matey’ contacts by reporting on these things. Remember, it was Liam Bartlett who revealed the first of the Ben ‘whathisname’ scandals. Read more »

  • Catharine Lumby says:

    09:35pm | 31/05/09

    Agree with much of what you say.  The real issue is getting everyone to understand that men treating women in this way is not isolated to a particular sporting code or a particular post code. The blaming and shaming of women who find themselves quite literally ambushed by men who… Read more »

 

JUST because she bragged about having sex with a lot of rugby players doesn’t mean, under it all, she wasn’t traumatised.

Accuser: Nine tracked down a workmate of the woman at the centre of Johns sex scandal who said she had boasted about having group sex with league players.

Sure, it kicks on the story a bit by playing to a view which doubtless many believe - that the woman enjoyed the whole sordid incident.

Nine tracked down someone in New Zealand to have a go at the woman who told her heart-wrenching story to Four Corners. It ran on the 6pm news last night and this morning was the lead story on Australia’s biggest news website, ninemsn.

Latest 1 of 1 comment

View all comments
 
  • Pete says:

    12:17pm | 02/06/09

    What a bizarre and elitist post. Since when was it the job of ‘the media’ to send messages? I thought it was about reporting events, even when the reported reality may make some uncomfortable. Are you seriously suggesting, Paul, that Channel Nine or any other media outlet should decide on… Read more »

 

UPDATE 1PM: Matthew Johns has been stood down by the Nine Network.

This time last week we were saddling up for NRL sex scandal #847. Commentators were jogging to their designated positions on the pitch, limbering up to churn out the usual for/against Rugby League diatribes, this time about League favourite Matthew Johns, who was about to be outed as a fan of group sex by the ABC.

Johns walks into a growing storm at Sydney airport last night. Photo: Adam Ward

Then Sarah Ferguson’s incredible report went to air on Four Corners on Monday night and for 36 hours most people were speechless. It was so much worse than anyone could have imagined after Johns’ inadequate explanation on last Thursday’s Footy Show.

I don’t know if it was the vivid way the two young women featured articulated the damage done, the glib comments to Four Corners from the players involved, or the sickening sight of Fatty Vautin slapping Johns on the shoulder after his preemptive strike, but the usual barrage of analysis paused.

Last night Tracy Grimshaw broke the awkward silence.

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

RT @leysie: Kate Legge on the last days of Hazel Hawke and Bob's farewell serenade. Warning: it will make you cry. http://t.co/iBDFBw74DJ

ToryShepherd

@TomRichardson @891adelaide That one is definitely a keeper #misheardlyrics

ToryShepherd

@TammyMLC @891adelaide @matt_gilbertson Oh I much prefer a gherkin to a virgin #misheardlyrics#springgully

ToryShepherd

“@JessAdamson7: @jhwakelin I like Grace's version. I learned the hard way Alex the Seal was actually Our Lips Are Sealed”#misheardlyrics

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter