Literature
Welcome to this week’s I Call Bullshit. Get ready to get steamy. The hot topic du jour is romance novels and the apparent threat they cause to women’s sexual health.

A UK medical journal has published a piece from ‘agony aunt’ Susan Quilliam arguing that bodice-ripper romantic fiction is discouraging condom use and giving women crazy ideas about orgasms.
Before we go any further, let’s have some gratuitous ‘literary’ sex scenes, just to give you the flavour.
Continue reading "ICB: Steamy romance novels are bad for your health" »
I have a passion which many others might quietly share: I am in love with the Mitford girls.

Such is my passion I have developed a parlour game which some players initially sneer at but soon become obsessed by.
What sisters they were: Dowdy and heroic Jessica, ultra sophisticated Nancy, gloriously beautiful Diana, Unity the tragic Valkyrie, and Pamela who, in Decca’s (Jessica’s) phrase, emerged as ``a you-know-what-bian’’ living with an Italian woman.
Latest 2 of 22 comments
View all comments-
johanna says:
Well, Mal, I always thought you were too bright to care about nothing but Parliamentary ping-pong. Since we are playing fantasy things, how about: Meryl Streep - for any role. Geoffrey Palmer - Dad. Then - Bette Davis, Barbara Stanwyck, Patty Duke, Elizabeth Taylor, ..oh what an anodyne and boring… Read more »
-
stephen says:
Jackie, these Mitford ‘lassies’ were (and i mean this so succinctly), the ‘tail-end’ of Britain’s Victorian era. Corsets, lisps, and the sweep away of the hair at the merest mention of the lair. Huh ! They pretend vague and disinterested (this word is the guise of the Romantic Poets, far… Read more »
One recent evening, my husband posed the question: If you only had three months left to live, what would you choose to read?
The discussion was travelling along perfectly well until he raised a name guaranteed to set me on a rant: Harold Bloom.
Bloom is a professor at Yale University and the author of many books including How to Read and Why. That title alone makes me want to employ the great Dorothy Parker quote: “This is not a book to be tossed aside lightly. It should be thrown with great force.”
Continue reading "Well read-head: Throwing the book at literary snobs" »
Latest 2 of 60 comments
View all comments-
hjxvrrvlte says:
e1Du5y owoahzkvojpj, hjjbhcvglrlr, [link=http://uoxaiiuygbqr.com/]uoxaiiuygbqr[/link], http://oekikdnsolyu.com/ Read more »
-
Claire says:
Sorry, but anyone that knows who Harold Bloom is and what he is about, and quotes Dorothy Parker is a literary snob (even if they do not accept this). Read more »
They come from far, they come from wide. They come with a fire in their bellies and a penchant for the written word that not even a million monkeys on a million typewriters could even dream of topping no matter how many sonnets they secured or peanuts they procured with their feverish and dexterous opposable thumbs. They are, of course, and without a shadow of a flickering doubt - bad writers.

The bad writer is a mystery for the ages. A mystery, wrapped in a riddle, snug as a bug in a tightly woven and off-white or eggshell coloured woollen rug.
The fact remains that since man has walked the earth since time immemorial, our command of language above all is what has set man apart from beast; what has separated the men from the boys (by men I of course mean men, and by boys I mean animals).
Continue reading "I hate bad writers with a fiery passion in my heart" »
Latest 2 of 123 comments
View all comments-
Duncan Horscroft says:
you might want to check the spelling of WILDEBEEST Read more »
-
q says:
this is my favourite comment by far. Read more »
I probably know as much as anyone reading these words about the life of William Shakespeare.
That’s not the boast it sounds like – it’s a statement about how little there is to know about the biographical details of the greatest writer in the language.
He died nearly four hundred years ago, and he’s been celebrated for at least three hundred, but the documentary discoveries about Shakespeare have been few and far between.
Continue reading "Disproving the porky that Shakespeare was Bacon" »
Latest 2 of 13 comments
View all comments-
James102 says:
I saw this entertaining piece about the authorship question recently: http://www.itsasickness.com/lounge/joe-plummer-obsessed-shakespeare-controversy. For me it’s an intriguing line of debate because there are a number of holes in Shakespeare’s history as detailed by John that make it hard to believe he wrote the plays. But until some new piece of evidence… Read more »
-
Ken says:
Jarred asks the question “Why is it that people accept conspiracy theory’s so readily…” but I would ask “why is it that people accept history as fact, when all probability suggests they should not.” ? Read more »
I can’t remember how I stumbled across it, but it has really threatened my Christian faith. It’s a book unlike any other, challenging my worldview and giving me nights of tossing and turning in a cold sweat.

The book is The Christian Mother Goose Book by Marjorie Ainsborough Decker, and it’s enough to make anyone an unbeliever. No doubt in good faith, Mrs Decker has ‘improved’ the nursery rhymes you and I know from childhood into ones she feels better communicate the Christian message. So, ‘Lavender’s Blue, Dilly Dilly’ begins:
Lavender’s blue, dilly dilly
Lavender’s green
Teach me to say, dilly, dilly
John 3:16.
Continue reading "Morris Gleitzman and Christian Mother Goose" »
Latest 2 of 98 comments
View all comments-
Jiana says:
i don’t know about this The only thing l know is the God in heaven is the Only God we can all worship on Earth Read more »
-
Steve says:
@Steely Dan says “If Genesis 1 and 2 are allegorical, what does it teach us?” The prevailing pagan ideas were that the world was created out of the body of a defeated god after a war between gods, and that humanity was created afterward to serve the gods through sacrifice.… Read more »
The latest in the endless string of novels about Jesus has just been published in the UK (due out here in May). It comes from the pen of Philip Pullman, the author of the fantasy series His Dark Materials (a film was made of the first novel in the series, The Golden Compass, starring Nicole Kidman alongside a polar bear).

Pullman has already stated that it’s a novel, and needs to be kept in the category of imaginative retelling. But I recall that Dan Brown said the same thing about The Da Vinci Code, and it didn’t stop millions of people revising their view of Christian history as a result of its wildly entertaining (and historically ridiculous) reconstructions of the life of Jesus.
I feel it is fair to speculate that Pullman likely hopes people will revise their view of Jesus as a result of reading his novel.
Continue reading "Pulling the other one on the life of Jesus" »
Latest 2 of 21 comments
View all comments-
Harquebus says:
Zombie worshipers are f’d in the head. Read more »
-
Jason says:
Pullman is an atheist, does Greg know this? This article seems to suggest (to me, anyway) that he believes that the author is trying to retell the story of Jesus to somehow bolster it - I don’t think this is his intention. Interesting to note that the title of the… Read more »
‘Do not start me on The Da Vinci Code. A novel so bad that it gives bad novels a bad name’. That’s how Salman Rushdie described Dan Brown’s 2003 blockbuster in an interview with the Lawrence Journal-World in 2005.

Rushdie isn’t alone in his unflattering assessment of Dan Brown’s writing. More recently, professor of linguistics at the University of Edinburgh, Geoffrey Pullum told the Daily Telegraph that ‘Brown’s writing is not just bad; it is staggeringly, clumsily, thoughtlessly, almost ingeniously bad’.
And Pullum isn’t just being a high-minded literary snob, either; the professor has a point. To illustrate his case, Pullum cites a passage from Angels and Demons in which the lead female character hears about the death of her scientist father. ‘Genius, she thought. My father . . . Dad. Dead’ writes Brown.
Latest 2 of 15 comments
View all comments-
Wayne Robinson says:
You would have to be an idiot to read any of Dan Brown’s books (I have read them all). Amazon.com has a great review of “the Lost Symbol” (look for the one star reviews and the one by Valennin (or something similar). It is hilarious; having read the book makes… Read more »
-
Alison says:
@ Ben. Quite. My kids started reading (shudder) with Garfield, but I figured that was what they enjoyed, and that hasn’t stopped them enjoying Dostoevsky or Berger or Barthes now they’re older. (And, now you mention it, I read dozens of Enid Blytons between seven and ten, when I discovered… Read more »
When I was a hare-brained 25-year-old travelling around the world, I decided to climb Alaska’s most northerly mountain range, alone, with winter approaching and with almost no comparable experience.

I got into trouble thumpingly quickly. Two hours out from an Inuit village the polar wind came thundering up the valley like a great icy bowling ball, the wind-chill factor dropped to about minus 20 and my fingers burned just short of frostbite as I struggled to peg my whip-cracking tent into the snow.
By morning I wanted to abort, but I went on up into that white morass of mountains. It was painful, it was terrifying and it was unwise, but the experience was a perfect instance of the paradoxical payoffs of exposure.
Latest 2 of 19 comments
View all comments-
SeanT says:
michael ‘people with these disorders can barely get a break from centrelink’ is the kind of stigma i guess an article like this is asking us to reconsider. i have two friends with anxiety disorder and neither of them have anything to do with centrelink. they might not go mountain… Read more »
-
Robusto says:
Risk taking without preparation and calculation (which may need to be lightening fast) I believe is still stupid and just has the effect of reminding yourself and others what a noong you are! As any rock climber knows the last person you would want to climb with is someone who… Read more »
It has become somewhat fashionable of late to out oneself as a bit of a reader. A self-confessed bookworm. A well-read head, as it were.

The trend, of course, was started by this site’s resident well red-head, complete with that strangely-situated hyphen of hers, and it is indeed her shining example that has compelled me to write this piece. In her first column for this website, and in more or less each of her columns since, Ms Sales has – I’m sure you will have noticed – been detailing her personal history as a reader: her obsessive love of word puzzles; her discovery of camaraderie and community at a writer’s festival; and the origin of her love reading, Enid Blyton’s The Enchanted Wood, as well as the many tributaries that have fed into that love ever since.
For my money, though, her best piece remains the one she wrote, somewhat earlier on, about being interrupted when very obviously engaged with a book. “The final step,” she wrote in that piece, “is to explode.”
Continue reading "Shed kilos and get bitchin’ abs with existential prose" »
Latest 2 of 6 comments
View all comments-
sophiej says:
Ah don’t listen to the nay-sayers. Walking and reading are made for each other - what else is there to do when you’re wandering down the same street you wander down every day. I’ve been an avid walking reader since my high school days and I haven’t once wanted for… Read more »
-
sarahj says:
omg i used to do that at the gym! and walk around school footpaths reading novels that weren’t for class… Read more »
Are people who read better people than those who don’t?

That’s the view of a well known Italian writer who was recently in Australia for the Melbourne Writers’ Festival. You know Vicenzo Cerami’s writing if you’ve seen the film Life is Beautiful. He wrote the screenplay.
‘Those who read are better people,’ he told The Australian newspaper. ‘They are able to travel with their imagination, so they can look at things from different perspectives and don’t take things at face value. They are more mature and tolerant and therefore more realistic about the complexity of life.’
Continue reading "Well read-head: Does reading make you a better person?" »
Latest 2 of 19 comments
View all comments-
Pete says:
Ahh yes the Bible, the Good Book . Accessible to anyone purely as literature, is then that person a better person? Perhaps so perhaps not. The text itself cannot make you a better (stronger moraled) person as the Bible is not stand alone. It is a tool that enriches ones… Read more »
-
Dan says:
There’s nothing that the deplorable Bolt could teach anyone about anything. Read more »
Tim Winton is the master of fiction. But his latest tirades prove he doesn’t understand when reality kicks in.
Last week Winton won a fourth Miles Franklin Award for his book, Breath. And to celebrate he used his moment in the spotlight to attack the Productivity Commission’s review to scrap protection for Australia’s book industry.
Parallel import restrictions require books sold in Australia to be produced in Australia. It’s an idea so bad the New South Wales government could have thought of it.
Continue reading "Australian authors on Clown Street over book prices" »
Latest 2 of 13 comments
View all comments-
Bumka says:
What do you mean she was very “un auartslian”? what is it with people and that expression? What is it with Australians and that expression? It all comes back to all that “Australian Identity” (meaning WHITE identity) twaddle from upper class north shore conservatives. (i know this comment is slightly… Read more »
-
LORE says:
“Cultural Cringe”, I like that word. I am an Asian iimgmrant living in so-called posh Sydney North Shore suburbs for only 20 years and I was already infected with that disease.(I rather read Gosh or Roy or Rushdie than Winton or Grenville.)Though, I think that could be the pleasant side… Read more »
Facebook Recommendations
Read all about it
Punch live
Up to the minute Twitter chatter
"We are the only animal that actively seeks out a zoo" Good line to start the day from @jasonthetin on reality TV http://t.co/gEZ4XOiB
@farrm51 I gave you a ridiculously Dr Seussy headline, Mal. Hope it kinda almost sorta represents the actual story http://t.co/uLOCrOtG
Recent posts
The latest and greatest
The humourless hysteria of the holier-than-thou
In I Spit On Your Grave, a young woman is gang raped in a remote woodland. She is beaten and tortured…
Cash mobs aren’t so flash
For a moment in the mid-naughties, they were the coolest of all cool social media-fuelled meme-thingos.…
If we wanted reality, we’d turn off the television
“Some day, far into the future, this here machine will become a powerful medium with the potential…
Nosebleed Section
choice ringside rantings
From: City vs country: What would you change your life for?
Dieter Moeckel says:
We made the tree change from Darwin to Wonbah more than 15 years ago. After fencing, a road, and couple of dams our money was gone. Super is enough to live comfortably. We have geese growing old and stringy the only one that made it to the pot committed Kamakazi by flying into a tree; the chooks are… [read more]From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics
Erick says:
Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]Gentle jabs to the ribs
No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops
Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more
Latest 2 of 88 comments
View all commentsAdd your comment