Indigenous Affairs

Nobody likes to look incompetent or inept. So it’s no wonder the Federal Government fought to keep secret a report that revealed the $3.5 billion it spends each year on indigenous programs has generated “dismally poor returns”. 

Money for indigenous programs needs to be used better. Pic: The Australian

Close to two years after a 470-page Finance Department report slammed the Government’s management of indigenous programs and expenditure there’s been no radical movement, no overhaul of the Departments responsible, and none of the 115 recommendations adopted.

The report may never have even been made public save for a long-running freedom of information case brought by Channel 7.

Latest 2 of 63 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sam p says:

    11:36am | 16/11/11

    The money went into the pockets of non Aboriginal people, they dont consult, then employ non.Aboriginals for a paid holiday. Its as well planned as the alpine grazing trial, if your going to control humans like a dictatorship then take responsabillity for the repeat failures, the Aboriginal population is growing… Read more »

  • xar says:

    09:29pm | 25/10/11

    I don’t have the answers, I wish I did. People seem to propose stuff that either involves cultural whitewashing or things which have already been implemented with a massive failure rate. Read more »

 

A couple of months ago I was gallivanting around the UK on a holiday. One night I popped up to the apartment I was crashing at to grab my jacket when I heard a voice through the window from the road below.

The beautiful Kimberley landscape in WA. A region haunted by suicide. Pic: Supplied

“Come on darlin’, you don’t have to do this.” Across the road a woman had climbed up onto the third story of some scaffolding. She wasn’t particularly sober, she’d tied a noose around her neck and she was about to jump.

If today is a typical day, by the time you’ve hit the hay tonight nearly 178 Aussies will have attempted to end their lives. Seven would have gone through with it. It’s a national tragedy. And in some remote parts of Australia it’s just tragedy after tragedy after tragedy after tragedy.

Latest 2 of 107 comments

View all comments
 
  • rizal says:

    01:23pm | 08/02/12

    @ Libéral : gbeoalemlnt OK sur votre premier point, et je serais même plus sévère encore. Les chiffres sur les suicides enregistrés à France Telecom – dont je ne minimise rien du drame, qu’on se le dise et la question n’est pas là pour l’instant – ne sont pas des… Read more »

  • NESLIHAN KUROSAWA says:

    12:32am | 17/09/11

    Hi Daniel, Could it be that the indigenous community are living in very remote areas of Australia?? Then again, they have been living in those areas for centuries, right?  Is it more about the fact that if it is our sights, it is out of our minds also!!  Living on… Read more »

 

I don’t think anyone is that shocked to discover former Carlton president John Elliott is a bigot and no doubt Can of Worms let his comment air because of the publicity, but sadly it seems the sentiment behind his recent racial slur is echoed by a cross-section of Australians.

Some comments on the story included:

“Aussie is OK as an abbreviation, but Abo isn’t? I never knew that Abo was offensive?”, and “Why can’t we use the word ‘abo’ it is just an abbreviation.”

Latest 2 of 483 comments

View all comments
 
  • Maryanne says:

    12:22am | 28/09/11

    Wayne, I completely agree. I have just watched a re-run of the episode currently being discussed and could not believe the double standards of Fiona O’Loughlin. Suggesting it is OK to “make fun of rangas” (a term I actually despise) but in her next sombre breath stating her very non… Read more »

  • Annabel says:

    08:23pm | 16/08/11

    Okay, so according to your logic, because some aboriginal people have used hateful language directed at white people, it is appropriate/acceptful to use the “a-word”. The reason so-called “white-rascism” is not an issue, is because white people are not a marginalised group. Its like complaining that as an able-bodied person,… Read more »

 

The health and welfare of our young people has been at the centre of many policy announcements made so far this election.

Tradtional indigenous society built values and respect in the children. Pic: File

Childcare centres and chubby babies provide popular photo opportunities for campaigning politicians, and both parties are arguing over who’s paid parental leave scheme is best.

Focusing on our young people is important: they are the future of our nation, the next pillars of our community; but is it the role of government to tell us how to raise our children?

Latest 2 of 40 comments

View all comments
 
  • Kate says:

    04:35pm | 24/03/11

    John A Neve, that quote of Melanie’s came word for word from the above article that some of us just read. I’ll say ‘some’ as since you didn’t recognise it, I’ll guess you didn’t. Though I should point out that that is conjecture. Read more »

  • John A Neve says:

    12:56pm | 05/08/10

    Christain, I’d hate to think I had a “narrow mind” or “tunnel vision” and no, I don’t think all people are good or bad whatever their race. But the numbers Christain speak for themselves, added to which 100 years of whinging does no one any good. Read more »

 

Good Government is about empowering people, creating a sense of community, facilitating change and giving people real choices.

Government policies are encouraging a handout mentality. Photo: Getty Images

Fifty years ago the people managed our communities, looked after employment, hospitals, policing and schools. Problems that occurred in the community were sorted out by the community.

However successive policies by both parties have moved Australia away from a community empowerment model towards a centralized control system with bureaucrats managing down on communities. The people with the power to help sort out problems with hospitals, policing and towns have been progressively removed from our communities, taking their power with them.

Latest 2 of 16 comments

View all comments
 
  • BTS says:

    06:15am | 28/05/10

    The choice of Local Police Commanders and Hospital staff in Queensland has not had ‘local community input’ for more than twenty years. It’s observable, historic fact, that if an Aboriginal Community is made up of more than one tribe, the elected tribe, holding power, distributes wealth disproportionately in favour of… Read more »

  • Gary Cox says:

    10:28pm | 27/05/10

    But Dick if you take power away from bureaucrats and hand it to local councils or communities too many bureaucrats would lose their jobs and have to get a real job. Hits on facebook would halve instantly. Read more »

 

While some argue Tony Abbott has “opened up the culture wars” by declaring the practice of respecting traditional Aboriginal land owners at official gatherings as “out of place tokenism”, you can’t deny that though controversial, the Ab-Blaster has a point. These repeatedly enforced preambles for the Whatever Tribe Of Wherever grow ever more meaningless each ensuing shindig, and are at best, descending into farce.

What is the point of repeating this ritual over and over every year?

It isn’t culture, it’s clutter. PCYC CEO Chris Gardiner has also picked up the dustpan and brush, declaring kicking off parliament with the Lord’s Prayer is not only intolerable, but “anachronistic at best… superstitious at worst”. The message is clear – it’s time for a clean out Australia!

This is a big, brown and far too dusty land, and there’s plenty more mouldy, moth-eared, curry-stained tokenistic traditions still loitering about the flat, in desperate need of either chucking in the wash, or just a good old chucking out.

Anzac Day marches:
This bizarre annual tradition of old blokes marching up and down city streets, blocking shopping access to discount fashion outlets and electrical goods warehouses, has surely done its dash.

Latest 2 of 64 comments

View all comments
 
  • Leah says:

    07:54pm | 18/05/10

    Live for the moment indeed! Read more »

  • SecondChild says:

    03:46pm | 30/03/10

    I think we should add marriage to that massive list of stupid things marriage is stupid and pointless because i believe if you love a person and they love you - thats wonderful. WHY DO YOU HAVE TO PROVE IT WITH A PIECE OF PAPER!? what is THAt going to… Read more »

 

There is nothing more certain to generate cynicism than having to suffer political correctness in full force. When the experience is compounded by the paternalistic condescension of those who don’t really believe what is being said or done but in their generosity are reaching down to those they really see as simpler than them, it’s intolerable.

And then there's this. Pic: Kym Smith / File

The idea that you must open your gathering and deliberations by paying lip-service through a ceremony or incantation demanded by vocal spokespersons for what amounts to sectional interests, should offend most citizens.

For many, when the ceremony invokes a cosmology or belief system that they consider anachronistic at best, or superstitious at worst, it is particularly galling.

Latest 2 of 88 comments

View all comments
 
  • James1 says:

    02:44pm | 18/03/10

    All that does is show you have no understanding of Mr Darwin’s theory. Read more »

  • Fred says:

    12:09pm | 18/03/10

    Eric you really are a serial pest.  I’m not saying you’re wrong about the changing environment and mammals going extinct, but I’m not saying Kit is wrong either.  The fact is you’re both right.  Yes, the environment did change.  And yes, most tribes did follow rules that meant no hunting… Read more »

 

Back in October last year, I promised a group of Aboriginal stockmen that I would soon return to observe progress in the re-establishment of an Aboriginal cattle industry in the Northern Territory.

Tony Abbott talks with men from the Ukaka Community at Middle Dam, Urrimbyni, 250km south of Alice Springs. Photo: Ray Strange

It was not a promise that I considered I could break just because I now had a different job. The problems of indigenous Australia need to be taken seriously by Australia’s leaders and not just by the ministers and shadow ministers with special responsibility for them.

That’s how I came to be on a quad bike, low on fuel, following tyre tracks in the gathering dark earlier this week. That’s how I sampled a witchety grub and honey ants dug up by the women of an outstation called Ukaka.

Latest 2 of 215 comments

View all comments
 
  • masealake says:

    02:12pm | 06/09/10

    Who parties danger Australia’s social fabric? Australia citizens now enter a very challenging political era for 70 years in the 2010 federal election, many reforms are demanding by voters are looking for a change with anger to share fairer resources supplied lives from the first term of government? Australia social… Read more »

  • masealake says:

    02:03pm | 06/09/10

    Who parties danger Australia’s social fabric? Australia citizens now enter a very challenging political era for 70 years in the 2010 federal election, many reforms are demanding by voters are looking for a change with anger to share fairer resources supplied lives from the first term of government? Australia social… Read more »

 

Anthropologist Peter Sutton has a long association with indigenous people.

A sign on the way into an indigenous community in the Northern Territory

In his new book The Politics of Suffering, he makes an observation that deserves quoting at length:

The first consideration must be to focus on those conditions that are conducive to the emotional and physical wellbeing of the unborn, infants, children, adolescents, the elderly, and adult women and men. It is remarkable how many people living in the comfort, affluence and healthy surroundings of Australia’s suburbia have, in the debates over indigenous policy and especially the Intervention, covertly promoted the view that respect of cultural differences and racially defined political autonomy takes precedence over a child’s basic human right to have love, wellbeing and safety. It is as if political feelings and political values are more important than one’s emotional feelings and moral values as fellows of those other human beings in the ghettos.

Latest 2 of 31 comments

View all comments
 
  • Robert Smissen says:

    11:41pm | 01/03/10

    Evie it would be a piece of cake! ! ! My wife & I are both on pensions not to mention that I have full time of my disabled son. We eat well(salmon at least once a week)both of us drive late model cars & I bank $150 every month.… Read more »

  • Toady says:

    10:08pm | 01/03/10

    It’s not the type of house, and it’s not a desire to live on the land without a roof over their heads.  Don’t fantasise about the mystical image of Kooris drawn to a nomadic life, yearning to spend their days living off the land.  The issue is the provision of… Read more »

 

When the Indigenous All Stars run on to Skilled Park tomorrow night it won’t be just another game of football.

Champion team: the NRL Indigenous All Stars.

The game has been sold out for months and has been a dream of Indigenous league players and Indigenous people for decades.

For the indigenous players it’s about more than just rugby league – it’s a chance to represent and pay tribute to their communities and people. The game is a celebration of indigenous culture and has great symbolism, but equally important will be the profound effect it has on Indigenous youth.

Latest 2 of 30 comments

View all comments
 
  • Rai says:

    06:32am | 23/12/10

    Are we all the same or not? If the liberal left thinks Aboriginals are inferior to such an extent they need to be provided everything because they couldn’t possibly achieve it on their own, perhaps they should be leveling the finger and shrieking ‘racist’ at each other. Its a despicable… Read more »

  • Tony G says:

    08:42am | 15/02/10

    If your going to hold an Indigenous match (which in this country means Aboriginal or TSI ONLY) then the players should ALL BE JUST THAT, which clearly they are NOT. Pacific islanders are NOT Indigenous and neither are red haired or Chinese named persons. The idea was a great thing… Read more »

 

When Kevin Rudd delivered an apology to the indigenous people in 2008, he committed himself and his government to a series of practical measures, designed to lift many aborigines from appalling conditions of poverty and abuse.

A lot of symbolism, but no action.

He promised a new bipartisan approach under the leadership of himself and the Leader of the Opposition. Subsequently, he promised the report on this great moral challenge on the first sitting day of each Parliamentary year.

Today these solemn promises can be seen for what they were: hyperbole from a Prime Minister who regularly makes grand statements but fails to follow-up on many of them.

Latest 2 of 50 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sam says:

    01:37pm | 09/12/11

    @ Scot If your saying depriving Aboriginals of humans rights and running in communitys with the army, without consultation like a dictator doing something for Aboriginals you should hang your head in shame, you a disgrace to this.70,000 year old black peoples nation Read more »

  • Sam says:

    01:27pm | 09/12/11

    The problem is whites riding the aboriginal disadvantage gravy train, aboriginals are not controling these programs, maybe anglo aussies are failures, billions of dollars are spent and cant change any stats, now thats a bludger. You fools blame the government for all failings then claim its our responsability to fix… Read more »

 

Around this time of year, Aborigines are conducting ceremonial business in central Australia, including circumcision initiation rites.

News Ltd reported on Monday that three teenagers had turned up at the Tennant Creek hospital, 500km north of Alice Springs, bleeding badly from circumcision procedures that had gone wrong.

They had been circumcised in a makeshift bush camp just out of town. The boys spent three nights in hospital. It can be revealed here that a fourth teenager presented at Tennant Creek hospital on Sunday night, also with lacerations.

Latest 2 of 46 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sam says:

    03:44pm | 16/11/11

    The story’s from news ltd, with there history I dout anything in this story is true, getting facts from them is like asking the church about evolution, I expect more than recycled dribble from gossip papers Read more »

  • LC says:

    06:11pm | 05/01/11

    @ Lisa again: “Many eminently qualified Australian medicos are campaigning to have circumcision brought back into fashion within Australia.” Really? http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2007/12/09/2113665.htm Really? Read more »

 

The reputation of Western Australia as a frontier state received another unwelcome boost today with revelations that an Aboriginal man was set on fire after being shot with a taser gun while sniffing petrol.

Tasers: the new frontline in WA Police race relations

At issue is whether the taser gun started the fire, or whether the man, who was violent and threatening to set himself and the police alight, started it inadvertently with his cigarette lighter.

But even before the case is investigated, it’s been declared case closed by the state’s top cop.

Latest 2 of 76 comments

View all comments
 
  • Bob says:

    09:10am | 26/08/09

    To DP, thank you for your comments about life as a cop in these areas. This is a poorly researched article, strong on hyperbole and designed to create outrage rather than address the issues. The only thing I can see in this to complain about is the apparent lack of… Read more »

  • Mick Gold Coast QLD says:

    12:41am | 26/08/09

    Who wrote this rubbish? Have you all gone mad over in WA? You don’t deserve a police force - put the petrol sniffers in charge of law and order and self immolate with them, swiftly. What a bunch of self righteous, hand wringing, grief stricken lunatics! Read more »

 

THE best thing about the mooted ban on climbing Uluru is that it gives slightly overweight, middle-aged white people who enjoy the occasional cigarette the perfect vehicle to forgo taxing exercise on the pretence of respect for indigenous heritage.

The worst thing about it is that it seems to be a bit of pre-ordained, politically correct posturing that will add to the nation’s ever-expanding collection of hollow symbolic gestures that do nothing to increase white Australia’s respect for, or understanding of, our Aboriginal history, and may actually work against it.

I have never climbed the rock and probably wouldn’t _ not just because I’m kind of lazy and would rather do the bus tour, sit down in front of the rock for a while, and get back for beers at sunset at the Yulara resort _ but also because it clearly distresses some Aboriginal people. It just seems kind of rude.

Latest 2 of 15 comments

View all comments
 
  • Phil says:

    10:21am | 14/07/09

    Just returned from Uluru. Its a moot point to have this argument in this day and age because the climb is never open!!! The bigger issue is Australia has become a “nanny state” driven by our legal system. We were told by one of the local tour guides that the… Read more »

  • Rossini says:

    07:51pm | 13/07/09

    If you “close” the rock why not close Sydney Harbour? People piss it as well! So what’s the difference? Read more »

 

Here’s my guilty admission. I sat through Samson and Delilah and I wanted it to end.

The violence, the petrol-sniffing, the exploitation – white and black, and the indifference were all confronting.

But it wasn’t my squeamishness that had me longing for the closing credits. What did me in and left me feeling completely bombed was that for much of the movie you are placed in the shoes of Aboriginal young people who have seemingly little to live for.

Latest 2 of 10 comments

View all comments
 
  • shannyn says:

    12:09am | 06/06/09

    So has the movie highlighted the need for better policy for indigenous people Maxine, colonialisation hasnt worked for them and neither will the intervention, these people need to be part of their recovery, they need to be able to assert their will and to direct us as to what they… Read more »

  • Geoff says:

    07:57pm | 05/06/09

    As superb and uncomfortable as this movie is 2 quibbles about your comments Maxine. 1. star crossed lovers? Hardly. and 2. while the end does show the strength of spirit of aboriginal women the ending could not/would not happen. What was this girl doing seemingly devoting herself to this by… Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

tory_maguire

@jessmcguire I can't decide if that's the best thing ever or really troubling!

tory_maguire

Best news pic of the day - the rescue of Busta the goat in Londonderry, Sydney, last night http://t.co/miMqk1fX

Anthony Sharwood

Is the dole generous enough? Commenters saying "more than". Oh, and see if u can spot the double pun in this headline http://t.co/6pHfW9eB.

ToryShepherd

RT @KVMcLeod: RT @dailytelegraph Australian Vaccination Network fights closure | http://t.co/cNqojN3khttp://t.co/o3XqgnfL

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

La dole cheque vita is not so sweet on $16 a day

La dole cheque vita is not so sweet on $16 a day

Your task is simple. Here is $115.50. It must last one week. You have no savings, no assets, but thankfully…

Those greedy ATMs gobble up more than your card

Those greedy ATMs gobble up more than your card

We’ve been talking a lot about interest rates this week. And the 30 per cent of us who have mortgages…

Wrap of the week: It’s the economy, stupid

Wrap of the week: It’s the economy, stupid

There is a touch of Lleyton Hewitt about Julia Gillard. It is not merely that both are redheads or that…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Punch on: Open thread 09/02/2012

marley says:

I'm one of the older ones, so I've certainly seen a few changes in my time. When I started school I learned to write with a nib pen, dipped in an inkwell (no, I'm not kidding). My mother became a dab hand at getting inkstains out of my clothes. Flicking ink at one another in the classroom was an essential… [read more]

From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics

Erick says:

Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

151 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter