Human Rights

At a recent protest outside the electoral office of Immigration Minister Chris Bowen, Greens Senator Lee Rhiannon said Australia was mishandling the refugee issue, and it was the “lack of a humanitarian approach and failure to abide by international obligations” that was causing problems.

You don't have to be Australian to have human rights.Photo: Peter Martell

Another refugee advocate at the protest said, “You don’t have to be an Australian to have human rights.”

Human rights should be the lens through which we consider the economic, cultural and geographic implications of increasing our intake of refugees and asylum seekers. It is about enacting people’s basic rights to freedom, choice and safety.

Latest 2 of 163 comments

View all comments
 
  • Al2 says:

    02:55pm | 21/01/12

    And as for the well off that arrive by boat ready to buy their lifelong refugee subsidy lotto tickets, send them back home. How many people on this forum have $10 000 /head per family member saved up to travel anywhere? Like I said, got to the refugee camps and… Read more »

  • Al2 says:

    01:13pm | 20/01/12

    @GMB, right on. The fact remains, these cashed up fellows that have 10’s of thousands of dollars to pay for all the channels to get in to Australia, hardly have the right to come in as refugees because they can afford to come in legally. What they are in reality… Read more »

 

The Queensland Government absolutely abhors any attack on a person based on their sexual preference and, to be absolutely clear, does not believe that anyone should be able to plead a non-violent homosexual advance as a partial defence for murder.

Don't mess with her!

On this, we agree with Father Paul Kelly, who wrote the piece on The Punch on Wednesday, “An archaic defence that belongs in the dark ages”. However, it is important that we take expert advice. The legal reality is that the Criminal Code has to be drafted carefully.

It must be drafted on what will work to the letter of the law or else other people will seek to exploit it in unforseen circumstances where society would not support it.

Latest 2 of 101 comments

View all comments
 
  • Greg says:

    05:55pm | 16/01/12

    Didn’t Lady Justice used to wear a blindfold? I suppose that affirmative action preferences can’t be applied to the politically preferred minority groups if she can’t identify them. Read more »

  • paul says:

    08:56am | 14/01/12

    B, the gay panic provision is a reality in the law of QUeensland.  It is not a fiction. it is not helpful to just say ‘its not a legislative reality’ because that is ignoring that the law is legislation+common law and in the combination there is the problem. if this… Read more »

 

Welcome to this week’s I Call Bullshit, a column that looks at all kinds of myths and mistruths, at falsehoods, fiction and fabrications. This week we look at whether gamers are breaching international conventions when they loot, pillage, or kill.

Virtual animal rights abuse. Pic: Supplied

I’m no war criminal. Not even a virtual one. That’s because I’ve never played a violent video game – or indeed any video game since Donkey Kong. The original version.

But if the Red Cross has their way, it raises the question of whether I could be up on some kind of charge for (ahem) enjoying The Human Centipede.

Latest 2 of 143 comments

View all comments
 
  • Kheiron says:

    05:50pm | 23/12/11

    I always released my prisoners. I figured it was more demoralizing to the enemy to have their soldiers sent home with a spanking instead of ‘dying for the cause’. With the way I fought the battle, though, there weren’t a hell of a lot of survivors… As for the FPS… Read more »

  • LC says:

    07:55pm | 09/12/11

    A study started in the late 70’s and continuing to this day have been showing a steady downward trend in all violent crime across the first world. Of course, newspapers are continuing to report these crimes, and are reporting more trivial events then they used to, for example, a minor… Read more »

 

On the northern tip of Queensland, a young woman from the Philippines worked up to 18 hours a day for a married couple. She looked after their three small children, cleaned their house at night, and worked in their store in the day.

Human beings should not be treated as other people's baggage. Photo: News.com.au

The woman, known in court as Ms G, was repeatedly raped by the husband, threatened, abused and exploited. After numerous appeals, in February 2010 the husband was jailed for slavery offences. The wife was also convicted, although she has since lodged another appeal.

These workers are Jills of all trades: cooking, cleaning, caring for kids, the elderly and the sick. Domestic workers – nannies, maids, au pairs, “the help” - make the lives of Australian families easier. But sometimes the lives of these workers are unbearably hard.

Latest 2 of 57 comments

View all comments
 
  • Eddy says:

    07:33pm | 04/11/11

    The constant contradiction I find on comment boards like this in Australia is incredible. On the one hand, it appears there is a belief in Australia, if you don’t like the way things are here, bugger off, go somewhere more to your liking. Then on the other hand, we have… Read more »

  • Fiona says:

    09:12pm | 03/11/11

    Nathan, my hubbie found out that one of his colleagues travelled to Thailand a bit. While over there last time, he “made a deal” with a local family, whereby he bought one of their daughters. She lives with him and his 12 year old daughter. Her duties consist of housework,… Read more »

 

It’s hard to pick the most disturbing moment. Is it when the van hits two-year-old Yueyue, pauses, then drives off? Is it the mother and small child who detour around her prone body? Or is it the sheer number of people who clearly see her and do nothing?

Warning: Disturbing footage

The video of the Chinese toddler, who wandered away from her mother and into trouble, makes you heartsick. It makes you question humanity. It makes you want to shake those people - shake them until their teeth rattle.

And of course, even as Yueyue lies in hospital with critical head injuries, it makes you wonder whether a similar evil negligence could happen here, or whether life is cheaper in places where it’s so much more abundant.

Latest 2 of 202 comments

View all comments
 
  • ATP says:

    08:42pm | 25/10/11

    I am currently in China and saw a particular article on the incident. What was shocking was the story was about how majority of people had claimed that the person who eventually stopped to help the 2 year-old had only done so to gain attention, and she only helped for… Read more »

  • DriveByHeckler says:

    06:22pm | 25/10/11

    Blessings Yue Yue, I hope there are nice people wherever you are now, there certainly aren’t many here. Read more »

 

This week’s Q and A program featured Rosalie Kunoth-Monks, who has been an instrumental figure in drawing attention to the federal and Northern Territory Governments policies which are effectively stripping traditional Indigenous communities - ‘homelands’ - of funds.

No, it's fine now. We totes said soz. Pic: Supplied

Aboriginal peoples’ rights to traditional lands, culture, informed consent and adequate housing are being undermined.

Last week, Salil Shetty, the Secretary General of Amnesty International and I had the honour and privilege of spending time with Rosalie and the people of the Utopia Homelands on a fact finding mission. This was the first time I had travelled to Utopia in two years. I was struck by the fact that very little had changed.

Latest 2 of 73 comments

View all comments
 
  • Rhys says:

    06:54pm | 21/10/11

    a lot of the people in Utopia don’t drive Toyotas. They drive 2wd fords and holdens that are within 10 years of age. Some drive landcruisers, most dont. Some listen to country and western, follow Southern AFL teams and have two radio stations. The people go hunting, paint, play football,run… Read more »

  • Christian Real says:

    09:09am | 20/10/11

    Anna “Aboriginal people who are without jobs and living on the dole’ What a narrow minded,tunnel view that you have to see only our Aboriginal people doing this. I am sure that you will find that our Aboriginal people are out numbered in the unemployment office by you white fellas… Read more »

 

Sentenced to 90 lashes and a year in prison.

That’s was the verdict Marzieh Vafamehr received. Her crime? Acting in a film about an actress whose work is banned by Iranian authorities. No prizes for spotting the irony there.

Public whippings should outrage and anger us. Yet compared to a year in jail, these 90 lashings will most likely be the humane aspect of the sentence.

Latest 2 of 67 comments

View all comments
 
  • subotic says:

    10:21am | 17/10/11

    Australia has some pretty deplorable laws, but you don’t see the Iranian’s kicking up a stink about our crappy laws. Why, because it’s not their place to do so! I don’t agree with how Iran, let alone a whole heap of countries out there, treats their women. But Australian’s have… Read more »

  • Donyell says:

    10:17am | 17/10/11

    Extremely hpleufl article, please write more. Read more »

 

Remove romantic love from the concept of marriage and what are you left with? A partnership, long-term companionship, shared living and financial arrangements, the promise of a family - or a domestic horror story? 

I do (if mum and dad agree) Photo: Indianblogspot.com

For the 16-year-old Lebanese Australian girl who successfully took her parents to court last month to protect herself from a forced marriage, it’s definitely the latter. The Sydney judge presiding over her case agreed, and praised her bravery in defying her parents’ decision.

Unfortunately this story is not uncommon. Forced or servile marriage arrangements have reared their ugly heads in many Australian communities of late. Take the last year. A 14 year old Melbourne girl and a 17 year old Sydney girl. Both contacted the AFP in desperation, fearing their family’s plans to force then into marriage overseas.

Latest 2 of 124 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sam says:

    07:26am | 16/10/11

    “relationship”? doesn’t sound like it. Go play in the sandbox with the other children. Read more »

  • Bruno says:

    01:08pm | 14/10/11

    richard, be honest, you wish your parents could find you a nice girl? you dont honestly expect everyone to believe that you’re really happy trawling the west for boilers do you? You ought to move out to Fairfield, single mothers everywhere, you would love it Read more »

 

Should we ban the live export of asylum seekers?

Not everyone on this boat has the same rights. Photo: Stephen Cooper.

In a compelling majority, the High Court seemed to think so, issuing a permanent injunction against the Commonwealth Government, barring them from pursuing the current proposal to trade asylum seekers with Malaysia.

Despite numerous changes to the Migration Act over the decade to expand administrative power, the Act could not be used to justify the transaction of asylum seekers as if they were export goods.

Latest 2 of 116 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sarah says:

    03:37pm | 06/09/11

    @Govt@FauCitizen - your father sounds like a good hard working Aussie - my hat goes off to him. Ignore the vitriole from Ms Shepherd. Your second half of your comment about the stark difference that you see - I could not agree with you more. We have demanding, violent, tantrum… Read more »

  • Brian says:

    05:37pm | 05/09/11

    Actually, we’re constitutionally required to be a secular country… And there’s plenty of leeway in the Bible to do practically anything you want if you go and find an appropriate passage (particularly in the Old Testament, which is still canon). Point 2 is fair enough. Read more »

 

More than 20,000 people pledged to join a Ban the Burqa protest yesterday by donning balaclavas and trenchcoats to show that… people shouldn’t wear balaclavas and trenchcoats. Or something like that. 

Protest organiser Kye Keating with Eleanor (no last name given). Photo: Jon Hargest

Those who want the burqa banned are facing some pretty big hurdles. Sure, there’s all the civil liberties guff, but they also have a big public relations problem because their side of the debate seems to get regularly hijacked by illiterate, hate-filled, intolerant, violence-prone, ignorant bigots.

So here’s some advice to the burqa banners as to how to keep ‘on message’:

Latest 2 of 649 comments

View all comments
 
  • Thommo the Enlightened says:

    03:26pm | 25/07/11

    Obviously there is one simple solution - wear what you want but if you enter a building or any public place you must have your full face exposed. Motorcyclists have to live this way - they can’t just jump off teh bike and enter a bank can they? It shoulldn’t… Read more »

  • Nicole says:

    02:20pm | 24/07/11

    Unfortunately, I think the only people who would “like”/recommend this blog post are those who are already literate, rational, and don’t condemn hate. Read more »

 

The government’s failure to “stop the boats” is an albatross around its neck and the issue is driving the political agenda. Their asylum seeker problem is two-fold. Scores are dying trying to reach Australia by boat and the government is losing support by its failure to stop those who don’t. However, the solution to both problems is simple - a blanket ban on accepting boat people as refugees.

Say no to the boats. Photo: News.com.au

Australia and Malaysia have tentatively agreed to exchange 800 boat people for 4000 confirmed refugees. The underlying assumption is that asylum seekers will be deterred from making to voyage to Australia by the prospect of ending up in Malaysia. Although the Greens have spit the dummy over Malaysia’s human rights record, the inhospitality of partner countries is the very reason these agreements may deter some boat people from coming.

Yet the Malaysian agreement doesn’t go far enough to fully deter asylum seekers and entering Australia will be a lottery with enticing odds. You don’t need to have an abacus to calculate that if arrival trends continue - 6535 people having arrived in Australia by boat last year - the vast majority will have an opportunity to stay in Australia. 

Latest 2 of 101 comments

View all comments
 
  • Matt says:

    10:02pm | 28/06/11

    Oh, ok Janey, so if they can’t claim Centrelink or draw attention to themselves, then gee….. What are they gonna do?  I guess they have to find jobs - isn’t that the problem with ‘real Aussies’ and refugees? They’re stealing all our jobs? Taking all our money?  I was merely… Read more »

  • mike j says:

    06:32pm | 28/06/11

    Hi Gregg. On cursory inspection, I don’t understand a lot of what you’ve said, but I’m not sure you understand what I’ve said, either. My proposal is to centralise refugee placements with the UN. Under this proposal, people smuggling of those claiming asylum would cease to exist, as refugee status… Read more »

 

I’ve always half-liked the Labor Government’s Malaysian solution on asylum seekers. I like the half that involves bringing an additional 4000 refugees from Malaysia to Australia. It’s a small additional burden that our rich little country is very capable of bearing.

Go Back to Where You Came From was compulsory viewing, but did little to change many people's views. Photo: SBS.

It’s quite a clever strategy, too, in light of new research showing humanitarian arrivals are generally younger and more likely to live in regional areas, thereby helping to counter our rapidly ageing, urbanised population.

But I abhor the other half of the equation – the part that involves sending 800 asylum seekers to Kuala Lumpur, where 90,000 mostly Burmese are already rotting in a refugee quagmire in the hope of a better life they’ll never get.

Latest 2 of 76 comments

View all comments
 
  • Gav says:

    05:34pm | 27/06/11

    @Marilyn - There is that old saying about an ounce of prevention being better than a pound of cure, since you seem to know everything, how about you travel to the countries that these “refugees” come from, fix the problems there and then they won’t have to leave.  Problem solved. Read more »

  • hot tub political machine says:

    03:39pm | 27/06/11

    probably - in any case, it wouldn’t have improved things Read more »

 

When it’s this cold many of us think of escaping to a warm island paradise, but when it comes to Fiji the postcard images of warm water lapping pristine beaches mask an uglier picture.

Storm clouds looming? Photo: Supplied

Many travellers have been able to ignore the fact that Fiji is under a military dictatorship, but when the government is using their absolute power to stifle free speech and attack the rights of the workers who are serving you, it’s time to ask some serious questions.

The problem is what do we do?  Making calls on how we treat developing nations, especially our neighbours, is always tough. Tourism keeps the Fiji economy afloat and is vital to the living standards of all its people. Fiji is far from being North Korea with palm trees – there is still some civil society and freedom left.

Latest 2 of 48 comments

View all comments
 
  • Leisha says:

    09:48am | 09/08/11

    Since you Erik are more interested to see the so called ethinic and cultural purpose of this issue I have an article written by a Fiji Born Australian name Graham Davis that explains the real motif behind this 2006 so called coup as opposed to Ged article that merely critiques… Read more »

  • Leisha says:

    10:32pm | 07/08/11

    Continue-I feel Frank Bainimarama is the only genuine PM and individual who for an indigenous guy who genuinely cares for people as a whole compared to corrupted leaders of the past who were doing things to self satisfy themselves and always used the divide and conquer rule or the race… Read more »

 

Look, I didn’t want to interfere but it seems the Government just can’t do it without me, so here it is. Please pass on to your local spin doctor.

Ruddock mastered the trick of boring the pants off people - including his colleagues. Photo: Michael Jones

1. Stick to your guns

Honestly kids, I just can’t say this enough: People would much prefer an honest person saying something they disagree with than a liar telling them what they want to hear. The ALP’s policy is for a more humane approach to asylum seekers and abiding by our international obligations under the UN charter.

Latest 2 of 221 comments

View all comments
 
  • DP says:

    04:23pm | 25/06/11

    @ joe hockey - stop masquerading as a person named’ nil by mouth’ and posting comment ( and tweets) and carry around cardboard cut outs of someone you envy ! shouldnt you actually be doing something useful when paid a good wage . Read more »

  • Brad says:

    03:47am | 11/06/11

    Don’t forget maximum family assitance $430 fortnight for 2 kids it starts to add up Read more »

 

Talkback radio, that eternally squawking companion, last week carried the more disturbing sound of a grown man weeping.

Bill Leak genius

As the gruff voice melted into tears, I imagined he must be talking about the poor cows we’d seen on Four Corners, half beheaded and in infinite pain. Or the uncertain fate of the asylum seeker children.

Nup. He was upset about Port Adelaide. SA’s poor, crippled football team. It seems we all only have a finite amount of caring in us; we have to limit how much we care and what for, or we would fall apart. Some of us pour all our caring into sport, or plants, or train timetables, and have nothing left afterwards.

Latest 2 of 177 comments

View all comments
 
  • RB says:

    06:44pm | 08/06/11

    fml, your mistaken if you think i feel ‘guilt’ over asylum seekers.I dont feel anything for them.Like much of Australia i consider them ungrateful & uninvited parasites who are eating up taxes that would otherwise be spent on Australians in need.Blaming the worlds ills on ‘the west’ is living in… Read more »

  • Govt@FauxCitizen says:

    02:29am | 08/06/11

    @Duff @St Michael,,, I’ll type slower for you’s next time,,,OK! Read more »

 

Human rights abuses happen everywhere, including Australia. Amnesty International has today released a report on human rights, which is critical of Australia’s treatment of asylum seekers and Aboriginal people. Claire Mallinson discusses the report’s findings and takes a look at the effect of digital media on the fight for human rights.

When Burma’s pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi was released after 15 years under house arrest late last year, one of the first things she commented on was how she had missed the digital revolution.

That may be so, but the digital revolution did not miss her. When she stepped out on to the balcony of her home she was greeted by a sea of supporters, mobiles phones held aloft and eager thumbs pressing buttons. Within seconds her picture could be seen on web sites, the internet and 24-hour news channels around the world.

Latest 2 of 58 comments

View all comments
 
  • fairsfair says:

    06:11pm | 14/05/11

    Yes Acotrel, because “King of Knives” is also responsible for every stabbing to have ever happened…. I agree, access is part of the issue - but as that article implies, one must want to create change within ones own life for it to happen. Read more »

  • acotrel says:

    12:28pm | 14/05/11

    Who sells alcohol to the aborigines.  Surely they must take some responsibility for their ‘crimes’? Read more »

 

When announcing Osama bin Laden’s death, US President Barack Obama declared it was about “liberty and justice for all”.  The Punch asked RMIT’s Adjunct Professor Peter Norden, a law, crime and justice expert, what that means.

A memorial stone to the victims of 9/11 at the Pentagon. Pic: AFP

What was your immediate response to the announcement of bin Laden’s death?
Certainly a sense of surprise that it happened without warning.  But then I reacted to the words used by the US President and Australian Prime Minister that “justice had been done”. My understanding of justice being done is when an accused person is taken into custody, tried and receives the verdict of the court. 

Latest 2 of 69 comments

View all comments
 
  • Adam says:

    04:35pm | 07/05/11

    It would appear Mr Norden has retreated to the ivory tower of isolation to embrace groupthink with his progressive acadmic mates, rather than sticking around to debate his ideas in the real world. Read more »

  • the whisperer says:

    12:34pm | 07/05/11

    SeanR.. Sorry, I forgot. When you are ranting and raving over this and that, (usually with someone else’s right to an opinion), you must try to stop using the juvenile, silly phrases. Say what you like but do try to make some sense. Perhaps you might get Dad to read… Read more »

 

“Homosexual tendencies (are) one of many conditions that beset fallen humanity.”

According to Exodus International’s policy statements, those who embrace “homosexual behaviours” have lives that are “sinful” and “destructive”.

Rather than simply condemn non-heterosexual desire, Exodus International (A Christian organisation that condemns homosexuality) adopts what they refer to as a ‘redemptive’ approach – seeking to ‘reorient’ the ‘fallen’.

Latest 2 of 221 comments

View all comments
 
  • Anne Stocks says:

    08:58am | 17/08/11

    Senthorun Raj says…  it is hardly a surprise that suicidal ideation and suicide is an endemic problem amongst same-sex attracted and gender diverse people….why do you think they suicide Senthorun because they feel happy and content or perhaps as you assume they agree with what others are saying about them… Read more »

  • David says:

    03:07pm | 15/08/11

    @Adam C I object to your assertion that Ex Gay therapy is no different from Tarot Card Reading or Aromatherapy. The first two harmless curiosities, but Ex Gay therapy is psychological abuse that fucks up peoples’ lives. Read more »

 

I appreciate the high standard of human rights we enjoy in Australia just as much as the next person. But when it comes to the possession of illegal substances, I think it’s better to be presumed guilty rather than innocent, even if it intrudes on our basic right to a fair trial.

The law can protect you when pre-historic curry and cheap vodka isn't the only thing you find in the communal fridge.

In 2008, solicitor Vera Momcilovic was convicted of trafficking ice found in her apartment, despite her claims that the drugs were her boyfriend’s and she knew nothing about it.

Now she’s challenging the legitimacy of the state’s drug laws in the High Court, claiming the Victorian Charter of Human Rights effectively invalidates them because they remove the presumption of innocence.

Latest 2 of 131 comments

View all comments
 
  • Roselyn says:

    09:40pm | 07/02/12

    I find it aazming that you will go to all that trouble to put your­self in a mind altering state.  First you might have a “panic attack”, severe head­ache, nervous, shacky, anxious for 20 minutes of being really stoned.  Yeah, sounds like a really great time.  Why don’t you just figure out what… Read more »

  • dmmaseoseoseo says:

    11:52am | 13/12/11

    Awesome share! Thank you very much Read more »

 

Australians are bombarded with advertising and initiatives from governments educating the public about health risks. Smoking kills. Occupational health and safety regulations are law.  “Is gambling a problem for you?”

Photo: AFP.

It makes sense, educating the public on health issues saves money in the long run, is preventative and reduces risks.  And yet one of the most pervasive, damaging and normalised threats to public health remains taboo and largely unaddressed.

Violence against women is a critical human rights and public health issue. One in three women will experience violence in her lifetime. It is normalised, domesticated and prevalent.

Latest 2 of 157 comments

View all comments
 
  • Squeeze the Middle says:

    06:34pm | 15/12/10

    AliceC. Eric was agreeing with you that mothers are not inherently evil. Eric’s point is that even if men are 5 times more likely than women to hit children (I’m not saying they are), the fact that women spend 20 times (a guess to illustrate the point) more time with… Read more »

  • AliceC says:

    09:35am | 15/12/10

    @Eric “Robert, the statistics show that mothers are more likely to abuse children than fathers. This is probably not because mothers are inherently evil, rather they simply spend more time with children.” Mothers are more inherintly evil? Based on what? Now who’s pushing a gender agenda? Read more »

 

“We want what they’ve got” is not a valid argument for gay marriage.

Illustration: Eric Lobbecke.

I have to agree with Professor Kerryn Phelps that the quality of debate over same-sex marriage is depressingly tepid.

But to be fair, it’s not just the defenders of traditional marriage who exhibit a lack of intellectual rigour in mounting their case.

Latest 2 of 169 comments

View all comments
 
  • Guilo says:

    02:28pm | 15/11/11

    The best post so far is the coca cola and water comparison.  What the homosexual community wants is ACCEPTANCE by society for the chosen lifestyle which is repucnant to the rest.  Hence “Gay” is more acceptable than ‘Homosexual”.  The word marriage has a clear definition.  The word “gay” used to… Read more »

  • DOT says:

    06:52pm | 30/09/11

    Perfectly put, and @Paul Horn, ...marriage is under our current definition meant to be between two people. the problem is discrimination due to gender furthering the terrible discrimination globally of gender roles and abusive sexism. Maybe someday, we will be debating to legalise polygamyist marriage, but ti seems a bit… Read more »

 

Watching the debate over the merits of gay marriage, I feel like I am watching a scene from the movie “The Castle” where the totally underprepared solicitor for the plaintiff gives as his sole argument: “It’s the vibe”. 

This is not the place for Darryl Kerrigan or Dennis Denuto.

That pretty much sums up the quality of the arguments being put forward by those opposing marriage equality. While supporters of gay marriage have abundant and cogent arguments about why it is right and fair, its opponents have nothing more to offer than “I don’t like it” or “that’s what the Marriage Act says”. They put forward no justification because there is no justification.

The Marriage Act says that marriage is between a man and a woman because John Howard changed the wording as recently as 2004.

Latest 2 of 485 comments

View all comments
 
  • Mary says:

    11:52pm | 14/03/11

    Rubbish, I nothing against two people loving each other but two men having gay sex is just wrong. Therefore its wrong to marry cuz you gonna have sex arent you? You have more risk of disease, health problems etc. More risk of bowel cancer, prostrate cancer, HIV and related diseases.… Read more »

  • the apologist says:

    06:08pm | 15/12/10

    Steely, just to let you know, i’m out and about in coming weeks. I’ll try to reply promptly, but if responses are slow you’ll know why. Thanks for the conversation, I appreciate it - not sure how long it’ll kick on for (it seems to have been going for some… Read more »

 

NSW is on the brink of introducing ethics teaching into classrooms across the country, but no-one, not even the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority, has any notion as to what we will be teaching our children.

No one is born understanding respect and common values. Photo: Brad Newman.

The problem with modern day ethics is the lack of unified standards for deciding what is right or wrong.

Worse than this, many educators seek to frame the debate in terms of relativism, which provides the perfect platform for communities and countries to sacrifice basic human rights in the name of concepts such as religion, culture and philosophy.

Latest 2 of 94 comments

View all comments
 
  • Exercise Balls says:

    09:08am | 11/11/10

    If you are open to having a guest blog poster please reply and let me know. I will provide you with unique content for your blog, thanks. Read more »

  • Steely Dan says:

    10:00am | 09/11/10

    @ Ryan “the Rhodesians were apparently “conspiracy theorists” too according to the Australian government at the time and just look what it got them” So let’s assume that every leader in the world is out to execute us.  Watch out, I saw footage of Julia Gillard with a pen this… Read more »

 

On Wednesday Bob Brown said two odd things that either proved he is some kind of political genius, or was the kind of rhetoric that sets the Greens up for a big fall in the future. My guess is it’s the former now but will be the latter later.

Just your run-of-the-mill political party.

The first was his apparent objection to the proposed merger of the Australian Stock Exchange with the Singaporean Exchange.

The crux of his opposition was that Singapore had executed the young Australian Van Nguyen for drug trafficking in 2005, and this was a militaristic non-democratic state that we should be careful about handing over our stock exchange to.

Latest 2 of 151 comments

View all comments
 
  • Helen says:

    11:25am | 01/11/10

    Jim - sounds like you’re talking about the good old days before neoliberalism, “downsizing”, outsourcing and endless “productivity gains” (i.e. longer hours), right? Read more »

  • Andrew says:

    09:15am | 30/10/10

    PC is killing free speech? Really? You’re sure it’s not just other people using their freedom of speech to tell other people they might be unintentionally causing offence rather than some great catastrope a la Mao’s Cultural Revolution where anyone who uses an ethnonym with fewer than 17 syllables gets… Read more »

 

While you’re watching the Commonwealth Games closing ceremony tonight, take a moment to look at the VIP box.

Amnesty Who? Sorry, you're breaking up…President Rajapaksa on the blower. Photo: Getty Images

The first guest of honour in New Delhi is Britain’s Prince Edward, there representing his mother, the Queen, in her capacity of Head of the Commonwealth. Nothing unusual about that. But alongside him in the guest of honour spot will be Mahinda Rajapaksa, the President of Sri Lanka.

The Games are these days the most visible expression of the Commonwealth itself – an organisation which aims to promote democracy, human rights, good governance, the rule of law, individual liberty, egalitarianism, free trade, multilateralism and world peace.

Latest 2 of 29 comments

View all comments
 
  • marley says:

    12:47pm | 15/10/10

    So what you’re saying, Marilyn, is that Australia, which detains Tamil asylum seekers temporarily while it processes their claim for refugee status, is a worse human rights offender than Sri Lanka, which commits the persecution from which they are claiming refuge.  The logic of your position escapes me. Read more »

  • acotrel says:

    02:16am | 15/10/10

    ’ Robert Menzies went so far as to call Hitler a good fellow. ‘ Well Hitler’s ideology wasn’t so much different from Menzies’s - both rabid right wingers? Hitler knew how to deal with communists. Read more »

 

I’m relatively proud of what I’ve achieved professionally and personally. I wrote a letter of complaint that got me a new washing machine and a new career; I got the word ‘existential’ on the letters pages of The Daily Telegraph, got to ride in the Queensland and Federal Governments jets and I saved the government $10million in one afternoon.

I contributed to this being impossible in Australia

This was all before I discovered nominative determinism. Today’s name is Gai Lemon, a woman featured in an article in the Q Weekend in The Courier Mail about 20 years of Gay Rights in Queensland.

Which brings me to my point. There is one thing I’m not so proud of and that is my part in the amendments to the Marriage Act.

Latest 2 of 135 comments

View all comments
 
  • Ethanael says:

    10:14am | 21/11/11

    Son of a gun, this is so hlpfeul! Read more »

  • Skipper says:

    11:44pm | 21/07/10

    Amending the Marriage Act is fine by me. Even better, amend the Telecommunications Act to exclude such soap box rubbish as this article…..dear oh dear, we are casting far and wide for someone to say something, aren’t we? Read more »

 

I know many of you would assume after my glowing endorsement of Ms Gillard and the opportunity she represents to shape a more inclusive socio-political culture that I’d be the first to denounce her opposition to gay marriage. Well, you’d be wrong.

In fact, I don’t consider the ‘right’ to marry part of any socially progressive agenda and so I say Julia is correct on this issue, but for the wrong reasons.

I guess I’ve always had a romantic, almost Wildean view of homosexuals as somehow more evolved than the rest of us. We all know deep down that stereotypes are true. So you know I’m right when I say that most gays are inherently more civilized and cultured, and are generally superior citizens than the rest of us.

Latest 2 of 55 comments

View all comments
 
  • AnnieMelendez says:

    02:57pm | 10/01/11

    Some time ago, I needed to buy a building for my firm but I didn’t have enough cash and couldn’t buy anything. Thank heaven my brother adviced to take the business loans from creditors. Therefore, I acted so and was satisfied with my short term loan. Read more »

  • Greek Snake says:

    06:02pm | 06/07/10

    It isn’t misogyny at all. This implies hate for women. While I agree with the institution of marriage in it’s current form, I disagree that it is a trap for women. If anything, the rights of a woman in today’s western society is perhaps at it’s greatest in the family… Read more »

 

Last week I gave birth to my second child – another beautiful daughter.  Like most new mothers, in between the very physical challenge of adjusting back to sleepless nights and the many other wonderful changes wreaked upon the body, I was during a quiet moment filled with a sense of great hope and optimism for her future.

Masai and Kipsigis school girls wait to join an Anti-Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) run in Kenya. Pic: AP (File)

I am thrilled that the opportunities that lie available to my daughters (and I am also blessed to have 2 step-daughters) are vastly more varied than the choices their grandmothers had.  The world has evolved so much, in terms of what women can achieve – even just in the past 40 years.

Yet for all the advancement of women in our nation, the same week that I gave birth, there were calls to allow Australian doctors to perform a form of female genital mutilation (FGM), citing “cultural reasons” as a mantra for tolerating this barbaric practice.

Latest 2 of 83 comments

View all comments
 
  • LC says:

    10:04pm | 07/01/11

    The mutilation of genitals of females or males is unacceptable in a so-called “enlightened” western society. If they choose to immigrate to our country they must live by our laws; we are expected to in their countries. Those doing the mutilating, as well as parents who send their children to… Read more »

  • Anna says:

    06:57pm | 27/06/10

    Brian, you obviously have NFU about what Female Genital MUTILATION actually involves - a more appropriate comparison would be male castration. Read more »

 

Each year Amnesty International releases an assessment of the human rights realities in the majority of countries around the world, and each year it is a sobering reminder of how governments are failing to deliver on their human rights promises.

Life on a boat carrying Tamil asylum seekers to Australia. Pic: AAP / CNN

Our 2010 report shows that torture or other ill-treatment were practised last year in at least 111 countries, there were unfair trials in at least 55 countries, restrictions on free speech in at least 96 countries and prisoners of conscience imprisoned in at least 48 countries. 18 countries executed their own citizens. And the list goes on.

The achievement of universal human rights relies on the world’s governments being held accountable for their actions. It relies on the international community enforcing international law and seeking justice for the victims of human rights violations.  All too often, however, powerful governments stand above the law on human rights and act only when it is politically expedient. 

Latest 2 of 72 comments

View all comments
 
  • George says:

    10:42am | 22/06/10

    With a history such as Australia’s in the slave (black birding) trade and the virtual extermination of Tasmania’s aboriginals, who are Australians to preach amnesty or racism? A few pathetic apologies, an annual “sorry day” and kissing the ass of a black American President just for his color does not… Read more »

  • Loz says:

    04:50pm | 21/06/10

    Unfortunately, yes you do. You pay taxes, that contribute towards the wellbeing of our population. That is your responsibility. You don’t have a choice. You can’t opt-out. If you get sick, you will go to hospital - which is funded by the tax-payer. So other people are looking after you.… Read more »

 

The decision by a Shanghai court to sentence Stern Hu to ten years should teach us a lesson about the future of our relationship with China: Australia cannot expect to continue to reap the benefits of Chinese cash without periodically accepting some of its pernicious qualities.

Stern Hu, sentenced to 10 years in prison last night

Following the Hu sentence there will no doubt be a temptation to invoke what could be called the “Corby Protocol”, which assumes that whenever an Australian is arrested in a non-Western country they are ipso facto innocent and victims of a corrupt and dictatorial regime.

But in this case it would probably be in our interest to understand that while Hu has become a victim of the workings of the Chinese state and business, he was also very much a product of it. This was a position that up until this point had made him, and by extension Australia, very wealthy.

Latest 2 of 117 comments

View all comments
 
  • James says:

    02:36pm | 31/03/10

    I’m sure we are unlikely to ever know the truth and that is the problem, people will speculate, and given the history of the Chinese legal system I’m sure most people will assume that Hu is innocent and his confession was forced, even if this isn’t true. By hiding the… Read more »

  • Scot says:

    02:23pm | 31/03/10

    Randal, If you are a China Expert of many years then you should be able to answer your own questions? Or maybe next time you go, ask you business associates-partners what goes on and what happens to those people not matter what level of government the penalties they are handed… Read more »

 

The American architect, Philip Johnson, once said “all great architecture is the design of space that contains, cuddles, exalts, or stimulates the persons in that space.”

The reading room in the Victorian State Library. Picture: Peter Ward

A trip to the State Library in Melbourne bears testament to that. The glorious reading room, which at the time of its construction boasted one of the largest domes in Christendom, manages to exalt the entranced tourist while cuddle the engrossed researcher all at once.

Yet it is hard to feel cuddled by a building if you cannot get into it. And for millions of Australians with a disability the state of our public built environment prevents them entering or using the bathroom let alone feel stimulated or exalted by the wonder of the architecture.

Latest 2 of 5 comments

View all comments
 
  • Kitty says:

    10:53pm | 20/03/10

    Sam, don’t be stupid, we all know Daleks can levitate up stairs now. Read more »

  • Eno says:

    08:52pm | 19/03/10

    I’m sorry but putting ramps into all buildings is unacceptable - or do you secretly want to help the Daleks to take over the world?? Sorry - somewhat tongue in cheek. My only concern is that there are many older / historic buildings with corridors that were not designed wide… Read more »

 

Last week saw an unusual event in Australian politics: backbench members of Parliament from both sides took a foreign affairs initiative, independent of their party leaderships. Sixty Members and Senators – Labor, Liberal, Green and independent – signed a letter which was presented to the Malaysian High Commissioner protesting against the current trial of Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim on charges of “sodomy.”

The author presenting the petition to Malaysian High Commissoner Salman Bin L Ahmad last Thursday.

The letter was signed by, among others, Laurie Ferguson, Malcolm Turnbull, Greg Hunt, Bob Brown, Nick Xenophon, Duncan Kerr, Deputy Speaker Anna Burke, Jennie George, Gary Gray and Mark Dreyfus QC.

It followed a speech which I gave in the House of Representatives on 3 February, in which I drew the House’s attention to the 2nd Sodomy trial in Kuala Lumpur of Anwar Ibrahim.

Latest 2 of 12 comments

View all comments
 
  • laincoubert says:

    12:01pm | 25/02/10

    In my lifetime can these back benchers speak up for the Palestinians Anwar is a politician.Are we suppose to feel for him.Really.I know Anwar is innocent, just look at his size,how can a man that size rape a much larger man?My argument is the causes our politicians take up.Defending another… Read more »

  • M.K.Shah says:

    01:03am | 23/02/10

    First of all please do not in terfear with another countries affairs.Human right\s are there and in defvending human rights, other vpeople’s rights’ should not be overrule. Annuar is Human and emotions are emotions. Let the court rule. TRUTH WILL PREVAIL.. He is paid by by his own coins.He was… Read more »

 

Are there any men out there who feel genuinely aggrieved at the idea that a travel company might offer packages specifically for women?

Men - this is a breach of your human rights

And no, I’m not talking about those of you who wish you could significantly increase your strike rate by being the only bloke on the Contiki bus. I mean men who really feel your human rights are violated by a group of women planning a chicks-only trip.

In general most people are in favour of legal protection against discrimination - if it’s the kind of discrimination that prevents someone having the same opportunities as everyone else because of some arbitrary barrier such as sex, race, or a disability. But sometimes the application of that principle is more arbitrary than the discrimination it’s trying to address.

Latest 2 of 83 comments

View all comments
 
  • cats says:

    05:27pm | 26/11/09

    Men - you do not treat us like equals. Stop saying that you do. I agree with what Helen has said. Women still need to overcome the constant sexual harrassment that we get from men. You don’t do that to other men, do you? Read more »

  • Helen says:

    03:15pm | 26/11/09

    *ticks off another square in Eric Bingo card* Did any of you who are yelling, “Youse feminists have gotten equality and look where it’s got you, huh, HUH?!” have a look at the women-on-boards thread? We haven’t exactly penetrated into the bastions of male prifvilege, have we? Moreover, where’s the… Read more »

 

We forget to consult history at our peril. 

Blind justice: The push to enshrine human rights could actually deny them.

It is very relevant to the Rudd Government’s latest assault on the sovereignty of the people – that is the proposal of its hand picked committee, headed by Father Frank Brennan, to impose upon them a charter of rights masquerading under the title of a Human Rights Act.

The last time Labor tried for a bill of rights it was by way of a Constitutional amendment to insert a mini bill of rights with the aim of continual enlargement.

Latest 2 of 31 comments

View all comments
 
  • B Pearson says:

    12:09pm | 05/09/10

    I came across this website while doing some research for a Constitutional Law subject.  I don’t think I have ever seen any comment so blatantly biased as the turgid rubbish shown here, particularly this piece by Bishop. Read more »

  • What says:

    11:50pm | 20/10/09

    Here’s Brownyn talking about Labor pushing through legislation with their ‘numbers’, when her government took advantage of a Senate and House majority to impose WorkChoices! Give it up Bronwyn, you’re out of touch and out of time. Read more »

 

Amnesty International flatly rejects the assertion that recent changes to Government policy have led to an increase in the number of asylum seekers arriving in Australia by boat.

Children on the HMAS Adelaide after the 'children overboard' incident. Boat arrivals have a high profile but the majority of asylum seekers arrive by plane.

Despite much sensationalist reporting on the issue of boat arrivals, the fact remains that only a tiny percentage of the millions of people seeking asylum choose to seek that protection on Australia’s shores.

Statistics published in June by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), the international body responsible for addressing refugee issues worldwide, show that at the end of 2008 there were 827,323 pending asylum seeker cases worldwide. Australia was handling 2159 of these – which is substantially less than one per cent.

Latest 2 of 64 comments

View all comments
 
  • Colin says:

    01:56pm | 23/10/09

    Can’t believe the comments on here!  I feel like in a time warp back in the days of Good Ol’ White Australia. Please read the article you are commenting on at least.This is embarassing. Read more »

  • Paul says:

    10:51pm | 15/10/09

    Enough of left wing policies, and there loonacy ,the fact they need to get to Australia these illegal immigrants so badly after they are all in a safe Muslim country like Indonesia ,is proof enough that Australia is there desired destination because they get a free ride and a how… Read more »

 

The Pacific Solution has been replaced by the Indian Ocean non-solution.

One of the boats intercepted off Ashmore Reef in September

In the ABC documentary The Howard Years those responsible for the Pacific Solution said that the mandatory detention camps they inherited from Labor were almost bursting, due to the influx of boats.

We face the same situation with the Christmas Island Detention Centre rapidly filling up as the boats keep coming.

Latest 2 of 72 comments

View all comments
 
  • rooney says:

    11:13pm | 24/05/11

    im from the future! we still have the ame problem Read more »

  • Jason says:

    04:31pm | 13/11/09

    Amazing - nobody is saying we shouldn’t take genuine refugees.  Just don’t accept queue jumpers.  If Australia collapsed into a civil war (or say, the greens got into power), it’s the “fat cats” who would be the boat people choosing their destination and leaving the poor “working class” back in… Read more »

 

Tehran - an inferno waiting for a match

People are dying on the streets of Iran, which isn’t surprising. Iran seems to have ended up as both a theocracy and a military dictatorship, and neither forms of government are known for their permissiveness to public disorder.
So why are rioters still bothering? Even if you dislodge the latter, you won’t get rid of the former.  And lets keep in mind that Mir-Hossein Mousavi’s reformist colleague and friend Mohammad Khatami had two terms as president and the mullahs- the real power in Iran- let him reform but very and little.

Khatami even found that while he held the highest elected office in the land, governmental agents were still murdering other reformists. And even after he found out about it, he couldn’t stop it. So I ask again, why bother? And why now? I think the answer is maturation and technology, but also pride.

Latest 1 of 1 comment

View all comments
 
  • yas says:

    10:50am | 09/02/10

    hello Ben, thanks for an astonishingly insightful article. in 2007 i traveled to Iran to teach English and spend a year reconnecting with my roots. for many years i was so frustrated by the ignorance of the western mind set, wondering how on earth a heritage of such nobility and… Read more »

 

Iranian poster art of the harrowing moment of a young protester's death

UPDATE June 25: The Twitter user quoted at length in this column reappeared after three days of silence, saying he was stiff, sore and bruised, and now outside Tehran, but still alive.

It seems to me that many people are still trying to find out as much as they can about the situation in the Islamic Republic, even though a week-and-a-half has gone by since the election.

Journalists tend to treat stories like, literally, ‘nine-day wonders’, because few, anywhere, about anything, stay on the front page for much longer.

Yet at least on Twitter, as I write, among the top ten trending topics are ‘Iran elections’, ‘Iran’, ‘Tehran’, ‘Mousavi’, and ‘Neda’. Neda, by the way, was the name of the young woman shot dead by paramilitary forces at the weekend.

If you haven’t seen the footage or the still picture of her lifeless, bleeding face already, it’s probably because you can’t face it. I sympathise; yet Neda’s may yet become the face of events as they unfold in Iran. Whether it’s a revolution or a counter-revolution, and whether or not it succeeds, it will make martyrs, and martyrs are central to Iranian culture.

Latest 2 of 6 comments

View all comments
 
  • jarod simpson says:

    02:33pm | 15/12/11

    the united states of america should just take over iran and let its people vote in a election that isnt fixed. and barrack obama should do something about neda dying for freedom.she deserves more .do something .stand up for neda .the angle of iran Read more »

  • Rod says:

    03:48pm | 24/06/09

    Let us all focus this sympathetic energy with worldwide action . There is a ACTU protest at Canberra’s Iranian Embassy at noon Friday 26/06/09 Read more »

 

The images we’ve been seeing of rioting and bloodshed in Tehran take me back almost three decades, to the northern spring of 1980, and the weeks of living dangerously in what was then still a revolutionary situation in Iran.

Clandestine photograph of current violence in Iran published at www.tehranlive.org

It was May the first of 1980 when I learned that my translator had been murdered. His name was Bahram Dehqani-Tafti. He was a poet in his mid twenties, a graduate in Politics, Philosophy and Economics from Oxford, bilingual from birth because his mother was English and his father was the Anglican bishop of Esfahan.

Bahram himself showed no signs of following in his father’s footsteps; he was a secular, literary, somewhat westernised character, and I am often reminded of him by the cosmopolitan, western-oriented youth who blog in such numbers from Iran today.

Latest 2 of 2 comments

View all comments
 
  • shannyn says:

    12:03am | 15/06/09

    I feel sick, powerless and grateful for my own life all at once.  Thankyou Read more »

  • Donna McLachlan says:

    10:19pm | 14/06/09

    Thankyou for these evocative heart-felt words in memory of a good person Mark. Read more »

 

Follow this person on twitter right now: http://twitter.com/Change_for_Iran

He or she is an unknown Iranian student who is giving a live first-hand account via twitter of the repression that is unfolding at the University of Tehran. Despite the attempts by the Iranian regime to disable facebook and twitter this student has sent 34 tweets so far in the past five hours.

“I’m dizzy but ok. some people are getting shelter in the nearby unfinished bank building. police arresting a middle aged man.” - two hours ago.

“my eyes are burning hard to keep them open #iranelection” - two hours ago

Latest 2 of 49 comments

View all comments
 
  • Erhard says:

    11:52am | 05/01/12

    Make hay while the sun shines. http://i2h.de/fI625 Read more »

  • Aron says:

    11:34am | 07/12/11

    <a >snow white christmas coloring sheets</a>  <a >red monster energy logo</a>  <a >day of the dead skull tattoo</a>  <a >writing paper and templates primary grades</a>  <a >gerald levert funeral</a>  <a >nikki catsouras graphic pictures</a>  <a >karrine steffans photos</a>  <a >applications for kmart</a>  <a >lds primary christmas sharing time</a>  <a >jcp… Read more »

 

It is 20 years to the day that the student protests in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square were put down with brutal force by the Chinese Government.

This calculated act of state-sponsored violence was the most audacious expression of the Chinese dictatorship’s disregard for human rights. In full view of the world, with the above video still standing as a defining moment in history, China cemented its standing as a rogue state.

The face of modern Australia was also changed by Tiananmen. Our then prime minister Bob Hawke famously broke down on television, announcing that all 20,000 Chinese students then resident in our country could stay permanently. Today, Bob Hawke is a lobbyist with an office in Shanghai, and has spent much of the past week ducking requests for interviews.

Latest 2 of 6 comments

View all comments
 
  • Viney says:

    12:22pm | 14/06/11

    Now we know who the sesnbile one is here. Great post! Read more »

  • Lived There For Years says:

    12:08am | 05/06/09

    That Chinese people have more freedom is arguable given that the Party has deliberately blocked information on the massacre for two decades, dissidents are reportedly removed against their will, widespread blocking of internet information occurs and the subject, when it is raised by the Chinese in China, is done so… Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

tory_maguire

What sort of people are watching your show @PMOnAir dying laughing at the ads for fungal toe nail treatment! #pmlive

Daniel Piotrowski

@NehaMadhok services eg gym, excellent kebab store?

Malcolm Farr

More gay marriage legislation than you can point a straight stick at. http://t.co/k2SC4xNp

Paul Colgan

@c41 yes it is.

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

ICB:  If I could offer you only one tip for the future…

ICB:  If I could offer you only one tip for the future…

Welcome to this week’s I Call Bullshit, an irregular regular column on calumny and codswallop.…

Six prominent Aussies with a case of the dreaded “yips”

Six prominent Aussies with a case of the dreaded “yips”

The yips. It’s an old golf term which refers to golfers who lose the ability to putt. They stand…

The humourless hysteria of the holier-than-thou

The humourless hysteria of the holier-than-thou

In I Spit On Your Grave, a young woman is gang raped in a remote woodland. She is beaten and tortured…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Punch on: Open thread 09/02/2012

marley says:

I'm one of the older ones, so I've certainly seen a few changes in my time. When I started school I learned to write with a nib pen, dipped in an inkwell (no, I'm not kidding). My mother became a dab hand at getting inkstains out of my clothes. Flicking ink at one another in the classroom was an essential… [read more]

From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics

Erick says:

Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

151 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter