Discrimination

Anthropologist Peter Sutton has a long association with indigenous people.

A sign on the way into an indigenous community in the Northern Territory

In his new book The Politics of Suffering, he makes an observation that deserves quoting at length:

The first consideration must be to focus on those conditions that are conducive to the emotional and physical wellbeing of the unborn, infants, children, adolescents, the elderly, and adult women and men. It is remarkable how many people living in the comfort, affluence and healthy surroundings of Australia’s suburbia have, in the debates over indigenous policy and especially the Intervention, covertly promoted the view that respect of cultural differences and racially defined political autonomy takes precedence over a child’s basic human right to have love, wellbeing and safety. It is as if political feelings and political values are more important than one’s emotional feelings and moral values as fellows of those other human beings in the ghettos.

Latest 2 of 31 comments

View all comments
 
  • Robert Smissen says:

    11:41pm | 01/03/10

    Evie it would be a piece of cake! ! ! My wife & I are both on pensions not to mention that I have full time of my disabled son. We eat well(salmon at least once a week)both of us drive late model cars & I bank $150 every month.… Read more »

  • Toady says:

    10:08pm | 01/03/10

    It’s not the type of house, and it’s not a desire to live on the land without a roof over their heads.  Don’t fantasise about the mystical image of Kooris drawn to a nomadic life, yearning to spend their days living off the land.  The issue is the provision of… Read more »

 

I’m going to confess straight up to having little to zero interest in the underwear choices of Venus Williams.

Depressing: I know she played well, but what was she wearing? Photo: AFP

Yet in recent days her flesh coloured shorts have become a story in sport in themselves and sent twitter abuzz with is she or isn’t she wearing underpants debates.

Perhaps this isn’t so shocking, Maria Sharapova’s green “frocklet” (I kid you not- apparently there is indeed such a thing), got its own press conference launch and then we saw precious column space designated to the diamond earring and necklace choices of Serena Williams, (which she liked “because it had lots of S’s in the design”, and we can all respect that).

Latest 2 of 115 comments

View all comments
 
  • cats says:

    05:52pm | 29/01/10

    Look i honestly don’t care about women’s sport, i just think that your statement was really stupid. Read more »

  • cats says:

    05:50pm | 29/01/10

    Tim, please explain how women are supposed to transform their bodies to match a man’s strength to be able to serve that fast, or have the same stamina as men? There is a reason women and men don’t compete against each other in sports. To do this would put women… Read more »

 

Would Australia’s sporting mainstream benefit from the introduction of a Rooney Rule?

Former Indianapolis Colts coach Tony Dungy getting dunked. He was the first African-American coach to win a Superbowl. Pic: AP / File

In 2003, America’s NFL introduced the Rooney Rule to provide legitimate opportunities for minority candidates. The rule, named after Dan Rooney, owner of the Pittsburgh Steelers franchise and a strong advocate for the rule’s introduction, requires all NFL teams to interview at least one minority candidate for any vacant head coaching or front office position.

Concurrently the Fritz Pollard Alliance was established to identify candidates, submit names for vacancies and to prepare prospective applicants for the interview process.

Latest 2 of 29 comments

View all comments
 
  • Phi says:

    10:42am | 21/01/10

    When I first started reading the article I wondered how many people in wheel chairs could want such jobs. I must admit I was a bit surprised when I realised that they considered African Americans as a minority. Read more »

  • Rev says:

    10:43pm | 20/01/10

    Rob, you’re technically right, but still wrong.  Cricket is dominated by ‘whites’ but Anglo Saxons?  Many of them aren’t.  Katich, Krejza, Hauritz, Kasprowicz, are all clearly not ‘Anglo’ names.  Gillespie was part Aboriginal, Dav Whatmore part Sri Lankan, and a rising star for NSW is Pakistani-born Usman Khawaja. I grew… Read more »

 

Unless you were lucky enough to be of nightclubbing age in the 1970s it has never been cool to wear white leather shoes. Despite being akin to wearing a large sign that says “I’m a tool”, this hideous footwear has had something of a resurgence in trendy nightclubs thanks to metrosexuality.

Not cool

But after a decade at the cutting edge of cool, metrosexuals have been given one clear signal they may have to go back to being ordinary blokes. Nightclub promoter Scott Mellor has chalked a line in the pavement outside a new club event in Melbourne that debuts on Friday. Beyond it, metrosexuals shall not pass.

Anthropologists might be tempted to attribute this to a socio-collectivist and culturo-genetic realisation that men are not capable of understanding manicures and shopping to the extent required to live a truly metrosexual life. But most would say metrosexuality was like platform shoes for blokes – a stupid idea in the first place – and besides, since David Beckham first dyed his tips blonde women have been clamouring that they prefer real men.

Latest 2 of 42 comments

View all comments
 
  • Alex says:

    03:47pm | 11/12/09

    There is nothing wrong with a guy looking after himself. On that note some guys do go too far, if you don’t have at least a few rough edges that define you as a man you may as well wear a dress. Read more »

  • Drew (Darlinghurst) says:

    08:23pm | 27/11/09

    Meterosexuals….meh Thank God Im Homosexual. I find most Heterosexual men….... LAME. Now piss off back to Suburbia Meeeeow. Read more »

 

In his deservingly scornful review of the book Iron John, Robert Bly’s absurd bible of the men’s movement in the United States, British author Martin Amis describes the comical pilgrimage made by maladjusted men into the American woods to sniff each other’s armpits, channel negative energy into circles of hate and howl at the moon at the fact that mum had them circumcised.

Come with me Brian…those girls were plain nasty anyway

Happily, this quest to unleash what Amis ridicules as “the hairy satyr within” does not appear to have any formal and organised equivalent in Australia.

This is probably because most Australian men have nothing of any real magnitude to get off their chest, or simply find that the odd night at the pub or the occasional fishing weekend provides ample therapy for any lingering sense of gender injustice. That, and the fact that we’ve got too wry a sense of humour and too much self-awareness to engage in anything that silly.

Latest 2 of 77 comments

View all comments
 
  • Lisa says:

    04:15pm | 06/11/09

    As I said earlier, my feelings are that overall, we are a herd animal, and those individuals that step outside gender roles may be spectacularly punished in the sexual / relationship arena. Perhaps that is why all your unemployed chaps can’t find ‘sugar mommies’, Paul and DG. And perhaps that… Read more »

  • DG says:

    01:08pm | 06/11/09

    Paul Horn (11:19am | 06/11/09) My point was that if a person chooses to support their partner (i.e live off the financial benefits of their partner, rather than derive their own income) they can hardly be surprised that their partner is better off (financially) if things change. I deliberately used… Read more »

 

Fifty-eight years ago, as a conscript in the Australian Navy, I was on parade with ship’s company on the wharf at Williamstown, I believe it was.

Since this 1978 rally, which was a pre-curser to the Mardi Gras, we have come a long way

A police identity check was taking place. Two rather hefty men, wearing dark fedoras, so favoured by celebrated criminals and successful detectives of the day, and bearing police standard issue suspicious scowls, moved between our ranks.

A third, slighter and very nervous, man was in tow. The offence being investigated was the bashing and robbery by sailors of a homosexual man in a park, the third person with the two detectives.

Latest 2 of 65 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sabina Nowak says:

    08:04pm | 07/10/09

    Thanks Bill for saying what needs to be said and The Punch for publishing it.  It is about time more public figures debunk the myths about the ‘homosexual menace’.  There is absolutely no rational need for the double standard. Read more »

  • Michele says:

    06:49pm | 07/10/09

    Margaret Gray maybe you should make friends with some gay/lesbian people and then you might be a nicer person. You might then see them as real human beings with thoughts & feelings, hopes & dreams that are shared by many of us. Just because they have a preference for same… Read more »

 

So long, farewell, and thanks for all the flab.

Goodbye “Dance Your Ass Off”. Goodbye to the lurid outfits and the ridiculous hats that Australian audiences for but one brief week got to sample. Goodbye to the prospect of a weekly side-serving of self-abasing, mortifying attempts at burlesque routines and swing-dancing in the name of farewelling the extra kilos.

Channel Nine in its estimable wisdom and impeccable taste broadcast the first episode of this part dance competition, part ritualistic humiliation of overweight wannabes for Australian audience’s viewing pleasure a couple of weeks ago.

Latest 2 of 7 comments

View all comments
 
  • Faye says:

    10:29pm | 15/08/09

    I am relieved that the remaining 20207310 Australians have something better to do on a Tuesday night than support such a program. The world would be a better place if instead of looking at, we looked after those who needed help. Read more »

  • davido says:

    01:43pm | 15/08/09

    Finally? Happens on a regular basis rom what I can see. Read more »

 

Is it playing up to stereotypes to put Bruno’s failure at the Australian box office down to the same more-than-lingering homophobia that doomed it in the US?

The numbers would suggest so, with ticket sales in both countries following the depressing downward curve set aside for movies that cop a flat ‘don’t see it’ around the watercooler.

The mockumentary opened here July 9 and is largely concerned with putting its title character, a flamboyantly gay Austrian TV presenter, in play opposite unsuspecting rednecks in order to get audiences laughing and/or squirming at flamboyantly gay behaviour.

Latest 2 of 36 comments

View all comments
 
  • SimonP says:

    06:46pm | 07/08/09

    I’m a GenX gay man. I saw Bruno only because it was at a fundraiser screening - I would not have gone otherwise. I had low expectations, but the movie was WORSE than I expected!  It was silly, shallow, tasteless, crass, but worst of all… simply not funny.  It is… Read more »

  • Janelle Batt says:

    07:50pm | 06/08/09

    This movie treats gay men very unfairly - Bruno’s character is too defined and reliants upon his sexuality. Cohen has been forced into pushing even more barriers of decency and socially-accepted behaviour - to achieve the same shock value as Borat - but he’s pushed it too far. His character… Read more »

 

When the delegates at the ALP National Conference sat down on Saturday to discuss the issue of same-sex marriage, there’s one question that should have loomed large in their minds: “Which side of history do you want to be on?”

Gay marriage: more and more countries are saying I do.

Despite the result, same sex marriage is inevitable in Australia - and a quick analysis of two factors makes this blindingly obvious. The first is the international situation.  Seven countries have now introduced same-sex marriage, along will six states of the USA.  Just like so many other waves of social reform before it (giving women the vote, decriminalizing homosexuality, etc.) same-sex marriage will spread throughout the western, liberal democracies eventually reaching Australia.
 
The second factor that makes same-sex marriage inevitable is the demographics. 

Latest 2 of 26 comments

View all comments
 
  • Hopium says:

    04:11pm | 11/08/09

    Ben - my marriage wasn’t religious. At all. I had it in a park. So does that mean, by your definition, that I am not married? It had no mention of “god”, but threw in some British comedy. Why can’t homosexuals have that? Read more »

  • Chief says:

    01:59pm | 06/08/09

    “All the people who say ‘marriage’ is not a religious instituion are simply wrong. If you want to get married in a church as thousands do or by a Minister of religion then its simply nuts to claim that marriage is not religious.” Marriage was first and foremost a secular,… Read more »

 

Raised on a diet of Disney movies, contemporary society has become so besotted with the idea of heterosexual romance, marriage and weddings, we fail to see the people for the confetti and happily-ever-afters.

Caught up in a Hollywood version of what constitutes a legitimate union, we’re becoming exclusive, political and discriminatory and overlooking what should be a very basic human right: the right of the individual to form a loving, public and legal commitment to another person and have it civilly sanctioned regardless of sexuality.

I find it fascinating and more than a little bit perplexing, that when it comes to discussions of same-sex unions, those best positioned to provide compassion and understanding resort to straw polls, prejudicial language and silencing tactics to proclaim, yet again, the almighty significance of heterosexual unions. 

Latest 2 of 35 comments

View all comments
 
  • Andy says:

    09:18pm | 03/08/09

    No chase it ISNT, face that reality chump. Read more »

  • Chase Stevens says:

    04:02pm | 01/08/09

    @Krammer there’s no such thing as ‘reverse discrimination’. Saying ‘reverse discrimination’ means that whoever is comminting ‘reverse discrimination’ is doing the complete opposite of what discrimination is. While gay marriage may not become a reality in the near future, I’m happy to think that there are a lot of people… Read more »

 

David Penberthy and others on The Punch have written about the issue of gay marriage recently. His argument was, essentially, that there are lots of bad traditional marriages and there would be some good gay marriages therefore we shouldn’t be worried about gay marriage.

Why not share the misery, asks Bill Leak in The Australian

While a lot of people may agree and leaving aside the fact that there would also be a lot of bad gay marriages, it’s not particularly good logic. It fails to discuss the nature of marriage and its purpose.

Is marriage perfect? Of course not. But mere imperfection of itself is not an argument for its removal or significant change.

Latest 2 of 105 comments

View all comments
 
  • Summer Glau says:

    04:58am | 14/12/09

    Dear Radical, I found your argument interesting and hence I wish to make a response directly particularly at it.  Firstly, “I think that the qualifier “gay” marriage is already something that makes it something other than marriage as we currently understand it”. You seem to not understand the point of… Read more »

  • Radical says:

    05:50pm | 10/12/09

    I think that the qualifier “gay” marriage is already something that makes it something other than marriage as we currently understand it. I am against gay marriage. And that is because after thinking about this debate I conclude that marriage if open to gays will need to be open to… Read more »

 

Why is anyone surprised by this? There’s plenty of people who go on Dancing with the Stars who can’t dance. Gerrard Gosens is a very inspiring man. He’s run marathons, flies an ultralight and plans to climb Mount Everest, all things most of us have no hope of achieving.

Dancing with the barbs - Gerrard Gosens on Sunday night

This is a man who in spite of his visual impairment, is used to being good at things, and is obviously extraordinarily competitive and is accustomed to positive feedback and public adulation.

But he can’t dance to save himself. I saw him on Sunday night on Dancing with the Stars, and as McKenney pointed out, Gosens has no rhythm, hunches his shoulders, and doesn’t exactly look like he’s cutting up the dance floor.

Latest 2 of 46 comments

View all comments
 
  • Marisa says:

    04:53pm | 12/11/09

    it is very ignorant to think that blindness is the worse disability per the comment above. AT least I think so. There are people who couldn’t look after themselves and personally care for themselves. The point here is he gave it a go and the public voted not because they… Read more »

  • Tony says:

    01:55am | 18/08/09

    We all applaud Gerrard for having a go, but the voting system - half judges and half viewers - can destroy a dancer regardless of having a disability. In this case, clearly the sympathy factor kicks in and provides compensation for the decreased dancing ability (due to the disability) in… Read more »

 

On Friday, 5th of June this year, my partner Beck and I were married in Vancouver, Canada. However, since arriving home in Australia, our marriage is no longer recognised, and this has brought significant sadness to our lives, and also to our families who were unable to travel to Vancouver to be with us on our special day. 

Davina and Beck on their wedding day. Picture: Davina Storer (not to be reproduced without permission)

Beck and I are now in the bizarre predicament, that we are married in a growing number of countries in the world, but not married here in our own country.

Some people find this funny, saying we have the ‘best of both worlds’ we can get on a plane and be married one day, and get off a plane and be free of the ‘ball and chain’ the next. But this situation is far from funny to us. It is heartbreaking because we want to be married all the time, not just in certain parts of the world.

Latest 2 of 68 comments

View all comments
 
  • Hopium says:

    12:46pm | 07/08/09

    I just got married. I’m not gay so mine is legally recognised. It was a secular celebration in a park. No church or religion involved. Once upon a time, you could not get married this way. I shed tears during the ceremony. Not for my beloved (we show love by… Read more »

  • Bugalug says:

    07:08pm | 31/07/09

    Bunny and Sal, I think the point is that saying “my friends say it’s OK/not OK” is not statistically valid, as groups of friends tend to self select people of similar views.  Pointless statement both ways, and all my friends agree with that assessment. Read more »

 

Can you believe that in 2009 we don’t allow same-sex couples to get married? It happens in countries all around the world. Not just where’d you expect like Holland and Sweden. But places like Spain and South Africa. It makes Australia look a little behind.

Everyone deserves their own Hallmark moment

We all have gay mates or rellies who pay their taxes and live by the law.

But when it comes to one of the most important moments of your life - your wedding day - the law says gays are suddenly so different they’re not allowed to have one.

Latest 2 of 175 comments

View all comments
 
  • Tom says:

    06:55pm | 10/03/10

    If marriage is all about reproduction, how come heterosexual old and sterile people can get married? Read more »

  • chris says:

    12:11am | 10/03/10

    “Can you believe that in 2009 we don’t allow same-sex couples to get married?” Well strangely enough Rob, I can, because in all of human history to this moment we haven’t allowed it. “The law says gays are suddenly so different they’re not allowed to have one” Well, if you… Read more »

 

Apart from the kerfuffle it caused in Brisbane last week, the nation may have missed a rugby league scandal that makes Cronulla’s woes look as shocking as a Phil Spector wig.

In fact it was less a rugby league scandal and more the culmination of years of a war on the interaction of the sexes in the workplace.

Joel Clinton: Fined 50 grand for hanging out with a chick

Poor Joel Clinton, the Broncos frontrower, was fined $50,000 for inviting a friend to his room the night before the match against the Tigers recently. That friend happened to be a woman.

And? And nothing That’s it, that’s all he did.

Latest 2 of 5 comments

View all comments
 
  • Steve says:

    05:14am | 17/06/09

    Well of course he deserved a fine.  A woman goes with you to your motel room and you do nothing other than talk ? An outrage. This behaviour has to be stopped . Everybody knows motels are for nooky and transgressors deserve sanctions of some kind…a fine being one possibility… Read more »

  • Bill Jones says:

    03:44am | 17/06/09

    I guess it pays to be gay in the NRL. Read more »

 

My name is Tracey and I am not a lesbian. Well, except for 15 minutes in 1987. At university. Does that count? 

Everyone is at risk of being ‘outed’ these days, as tabloid media organizations eat their own to get the next exclusive story.

Last week, journalists were salivating at the mouth at the prospect of using the name ‘Tracy Grimshaw’ and ‘lesbian’ in the same sentence, following Gordon Ramsay’s outburst.

Tracy has publicly denied the allegation, but she will be forever haunted by a claim that, until now, was only whispered by carpet-strollers in TV corridors.

Latest 2 of 51 comments

View all comments
 
  • Jack Thomas says:

    11:18pm | 19/06/09

    Build a bridge Nancy and friends. Why does Alan Jones work so hard stifling the book Jonestown and mention of his arrest in London for leed behaviour in a public toilet, when at the same time he can rip into anyone else on radio? Why was Gordon Ramsay’s arrest for… Read more »

  • Caitlin says:

    06:17pm | 19/06/09

    I am not worried if someone is same sex or not. All that matters is people live a happy life and enjoy it. Of course Australia has issues with same sex people the majority of people in the world do not just here. Just because a country allows you to… Read more »

 

Shh, don't tell anyone I'd rather be at home

It has been reported in recent times that the proportion of women on corporate boards and in the top management of Australia’s leading companies is actually shrinking has come as a shock to many.

Australia was once ranked second only to America in the number of top companies with a woman senior executive, and we now fall last on a list of comparable nations including New Zealand, Britain, South Africa and Canada.

In Australian about 55% of the top 2000 companies have at least one woman in an executive management position – compared to 85% in the US.

Latest 2 of 13 comments

View all comments
 
  • eve says:

    06:45pm | 15/06/09

    I work in the media and of all the companies I have worked for (mostly small, with less than 100 employees) none has supported flexible work practices. Not surprisingly most women that had babies didn’t come back. The dads that left at 5pm were looked down upon. At a time… Read more »

  • Ben says:

    03:46pm | 12/06/09

    ‘We even “gifted” the world with one of the most outspoken feminists ever in Germaine Greer.’ ... and we’re still very, very sorry World. Please forgive us. I think it is simply the fact the current generation of women in childbearing age range want to do the ‘mum’ thing right.… Read more »

 

C'mon Lleyton: its time for political correctness

Take note Lleyton Hewitt - the phrase “spac attack” is now on the banned list. And while he’s normally the kind of bloke who would rail against political correctness, it’s National Party Senator Barnaby Joyce who agreed to put it there.

Joyce will tonight apologise on television for saying Kevin Rudd had thrown a “spac attack,” after the Spastic Centre called on our political leaders to stop using the word “spastic” as a term of abuse.

“I would like to blame ‘Kylie Mole’ from the 1980’s Comedy Company but I should have understood the derivation of this word,” he told The Punch yesterday afternoon. “I generally can not stand political correctness but this definitely deserves an exception.”

Latest 2 of 11 comments

View all comments
 
  • steve says:

    08:28pm | 03/06/09

    No this isn’t a uniquely Australian saying - it is used in all English speaking countries. It is highly immature and childish and just as bad as racism. Oh we have a Senator that uses Kylie Mole as his role model. He goes, he goes, he goes, he goes….. I… Read more »

  • Jo says:

    10:41pm | 02/06/09

    When we discard our uniquely Australian sayings, then we discard our identity. Why do we keep purifying and refining everything we say? What ever happened to strine? It was colourful, eloquent and uniquely Australian. ‘Spac attack’ is a term that has been used to describe a fit of rage, a… Read more »

 

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

tory_maguire

Martin Ferguson coming up on #lateline. Time for bed.

tory_maguire

Tanner just called Abbott a "fiscal arsonist who's pretending to be the fire brigade". Quite original. #7.30report

David Penberthy

Brilliant Lara Bingle piece by Tors smashing cricket's "what happens on tour" hypocrisy and sanctimony of Roebuck et al http://bit.ly/d6DeO2

Paul Colgan

RT @_Tors: Can't believe Roebuck et at are so threatened by a 22-year-old model... just posted this http://bit.ly/d7rpjO on #thepunch

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Breaking news: Something is going on

Breaking news: Something is going on

Is this the greatest ever send-up of 24-hour news? Warning: contains strong language and hilarity. From… Read more

5 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter