Death

How would you feel if you found out that your mere existence is such a burden on your parents they want $10 million compensation?

In 2002 Keeden Waller, through his parents Deborah and Lawrence (pictured), sued for compensation for wrongful life, but the courts dismissed his claims. Pic: Stephen Cooper

It’s not clear whether 11-year-old Keeden, who has severe brain damage after a rare genetic condition caused a massive stroke, will ever understand what his parents are doing.

Debbie and Lawrence Waller are suing their IVF specialist for “wrongful birth”, claiming he breached his duty of care by failing to take proper care that Lawrence’s genetic blood clotting condition would not be passed on. They say they love Keeden, but wouldn’t have gone ahead with the birth if they’d known because of his suffering.

Latest 2 of 148 comments

View all comments
 
  • TracyS says:

    11:06pm | 07/02/12

    I don’t agree with wrongful birth suits on principle as I believe that it devalues the life of the person whose birth is being claimed as “wrong”. That being said, I have some sympathy for these parents as they are dealing with a child with significant disabilities, and they would… Read more »

  • the parents says:

    11:50am | 04/02/12

    You actually don’t have all the facts Bec.  You only have what’s in the media.  I invite you to come and breathe some oxygen in the court room so you can not be so judgemental and you can be fully informed before you write such comments.  My son gets an… Read more »

 

Facebook is replete with all things grim and morbid. Attention-seeking status updates, almost as much woe-is-me as look-at-me. Now the social media site is hosting an app that will let you send a message after you die.


‘If I Die” lets you appoint trustees to release your final message in the unfortunate event of your demise.

Would you use it? What would you say? Share your thoughts and anything else on your mind below.

Latest 2 of 120 comments

View all comments
 
  • thatmosis says:

    08:38pm | 17/01/12

    I always ask the name of the person I am speaking to and ask them to spell it. When they ask why I tell them that I wouldnt want to get their name wrong when I complain that whatever I am calling about doesnt happen. Its amazing how quickly you… Read more »

  • thatmosis says:

    08:15pm | 17/01/12

    I think you should add conscription for everybody at the age of 18, male, female or whatever. Those that are conscentious objectors should have their benefits taken away and used as target practice. Read more »

 

As we approach the Centenary of World War I, we start to think about the tremendous sacrifice so many of our diggers made. It is unimaginable to think that over 60,000 young men died in Gallipoli and the Western Front.

If we're going to do this, we might as well do it right

When you visit the battlefields of France and Belgium and the cemeteries and memorials you see countless numbers of white crosses honoring the fallen. Many of those crosses are for soldiers who are “Known Only to God”.

At the various memorials such as VC Corner and Menin Gate the names of those who were missing in action are engraved in stone. The Australian Government’s official estimation is there are approximately 18,000 Diggers lying under the fields of France and Belgium.

Latest 2 of 70 comments

View all comments
 
  • ajrichar says:

    08:35am | 10/12/11

    The author’s name is Roland Perry, not Fry.  And Monash did not win the war.  He was a good commander, but so were others like Canada’s Currie.  Australians have a view of their role in the Great War that needs some perspective amongst the sheer number of Divisions in the… Read more »

  • Colin Stewart says:

    03:10am | 10/12/11

    Real Dave @11.49 on 8/12 seemst imply that one day we simply decided to invade little old innocent Turkey who was minding its own business and killed 80000 of their troops. The fact is, the Ottoman Empire (the Turks) were a legitimate target once they joined the Triple Alliance, our… Read more »

 

Inspired by that 80-year-old Californian guy who recently completed 80 skydives in less than seven hours, I’ve spent the past couple of weeks thinking about creating a bucket list.

A tin bucket. Check the author's name if the significance of this escapes you.

These days, people do not accidentally live awesome lives. They work for it. Fiery impulsiveness and terrifying recklessness must be meticulously planned. A bucket list is a scientifically-proven and Morgan Freeman-endorsed way to achieve said awesomeness.

Without an action-filled plan of action, a person risks losing focus and aimlessly drifting to the point where they find themselves in a tacky, neon-lit club making out with a 53-year-old Kardashian sister while her publicist gently weeps beside a broken tray of tequila shots.

Latest 2 of 33 comments

View all comments
 
  • Pat McCormack says:

    07:45pm | 04/12/11

    This 80 year old person is absolutely amazing, unless of course the story has got the facts wrong.  80 sky dives in 7 hours is 1 jump EVERY 31.5 seconds.  Did He/She use Superman as the aircraft or was it EIGHT jumps in 7 hours which would be a more… Read more »

  • Gidgee says:

    06:05pm | 02/12/11

    The sage says that if one has to ask oneself “what’s it all about - why am I here?” one is seriously ill; sick. Life is a mystery which has to be lived, it is not a mystery which has to be solved or explained - accordingly and just a… Read more »

 

If people didn’t donate their tissue and organs to others, the following people wouldn’t have contributed nearly as much to the Australia we know: Kevin Rudd, Derryn Hinch, Kerry Packer, Jimmy Little, Fiona Coote…

Now with new logo-y goodness

We’d be a lot poorer for it. But Australia is already a poorer country than it could be. There are plenty of sick people who need organ transplants but can’t get them. Australia has one of the lowest rates of organ donation in the developed world. There are some 1,566 Australians on the waiting list for a transplant right now and every week an Aussie dies waiting for a kidney transplant.

The way to ease this crippling shortage is breathtakingly obvious. When you die, your organs should automatically go to someone who needs them. End of story.

Latest 2 of 195 comments

View all comments
 
  • Jess says:

    01:52pm | 12/11/11

    @Max Power. I think you have forgotten that whether or not someone’s organs are donated to a person in need, they are still dead. People die, thousands die every single day and every single one of those people has the opportunity to prevent more death. Donating organs doesn’t mean more… Read more »

  • Josh Simmons says:

    02:44pm | 25/10/11

    @Richard Well that’s between you and your sky fairy, feel free to opt out. But don’t use your theories to constrict the choice of others. Read more »

 

Some people effectively work as plants; double agents within a lobby group, party or organisation who undermine the very thing they purport to be working for. It’s anti-astroturfing. Chameleon white-anting.

The only way is out. Pic: Greg Higgs

Dr Philip Nitzsche is, I suspect, one of these.

The ghoulish right-to-die campaigner has won Therapeutic Goods Administration approval to import Nembutal, a drug used for voluntary euthanasia, for suicide, and for executions – including in the recent case of Troy Davis.

Latest 2 of 121 comments

View all comments
 
  • Neil Cadman says:

    02:33pm | 13/12/11

    Kaye says:12:40pm | 26/09/11 The Atheist Kaye says “there is no moral code apart from what God has given man”. is rubbish.  I don’t run around murdering, stealing, or abusing other people because it is against my moral beliefs to do such things,”  But why does she have those beliefs?… Read more »

  • Anne Stocks says:

    11:08pm | 03/10/11

    Jay says…If this is how euthanasia is to be implemented then I am against it…It sounds cruel but when you see it first hand you will change your mind. Dear Jay, I’m so sorry to hear about your father in law how hurtful for you, I was told they gave… Read more »

 

The power of the Roman Empire can be traced back to one key factor: The Romans did not fear death. This was not so much a state of mind or philosophical outlook on life. It was, simply, the law.

Maybe Labor can just leave all the crap behind… Photo: AP

This was a society in which making a good speech in the Senate, winning a major victory on the battlefield or even just being Emperor, were all grounds for a swift and unexpected execution.

If the leading men of Rome had permitted themselves to have even the slightest fear of dying no one would have gotten anything done, since the consequence of doing pretty much anything was to be stabbed in the neck by an old friend.

Latest 2 of 247 comments

View all comments
 
  • oldtimer says:

    10:30pm | 14/09/11

    Abbott accountable for what ? he’s NOT the PM…he can say and do whatever in Opposition. it’s the PM and her Party that need to be accountable….they are the ones in power arent they ??? or is it the Greens? (sarcasm) i dont know, im confused as to who or… Read more »

  • Gubbaboy says:

    09:07am | 10/09/11

    I usually like your stuff Joe. But this is a bit wet and non sensical. You forget we have certain limitations in processing the queue jumpers. Gay marriage? Why not polygamy then? Why not incest? After all we are in the age of trashing traditions that have served us well.… Read more »

 

By now, Robert Ettinger should be well and truly frozen.

Enter the human iceblock capsule

At 92, the man widely credited as the founder of the cryogenics movement had already seen the some of the best and worse of the past century.

He died on Saturday and reportedly became the 106th patient at his Michigan-based Cryonics Institute, where he joins his mother and first two wives. I genuinely hope it all works out for him and that he lives long and prospers… again.

Latest 2 of 29 comments

View all comments
 
  • Marta Sandberg says:

    04:10pm | 01/08/11

    Mark G says: 08:23am | 29/07/11 Marta, I would like to point out that rejuvenating live cells is completely different to rejuvenating dead or destroyed cell tissue. With things like stem cells we are not that far of being able to rejuvenate living cells now. Dead cell matter that has… Read more »

  • Marta Sandberg says:

    04:01pm | 01/08/11

    It is easy to dismiss something if you haven’t taken the time to research it and, unfortunately, your comments show that you do not understand the basic of cryonics.  Before I signed up for cryonics I spent three years trying to debunk it.  In the end I had to reluctantly… Read more »

 

Since the dawn of life, there has been death. And since the dawn of death, there have been endless vain attempts, some gallant and some desperate, some real and some imagined, some tragic and some inspiring, to grasp the key that unlocks immortality.

The brilliantly understated grave of boxing champ Sonny Liston reads simply: A MAN. Online memorials are getting a bit more elaborate nowadays.

One of the earliest literary works, the Epic of Gilgamesh, is preserved on twelve clay tablets recovered from the Assyrian King Ashurbanipal’s ancient library collection and depicts a hero’s search for the secret to everlasting life. Jumping forward almost two thousand years, Oscar Wilde’s fictional character Dorian Gray was consumed by his desire for eternal youth.

The human preoccupation with preventing death is as alive today as it was in the times of Ashurbanipal and Wilde.

Latest 2 of 41 comments

View all comments
 
  • TracyH says:

    03:15pm | 07/06/11

    A funny one I read the other day…a waiter’s headstone “God finally caught his eye” Read more »

  • andre says:

    09:56am | 07/06/11

    @John Unfortunately John , evolutionism is a religion regardless of how much you dislike the fact. Darwinists teach about evolution of stars, evolution of chemicals, evolution of life, macroevolution and microevolution. Out of above five kind of evolution only microevolution is a scientific fact. Other four are just religious concepts.… Read more »

 

There’s nothing like a good euthanasia debate to make you wary of doctors.

Lobbying could get pretty hectic before the vote.

Sure, they come across all innocent with their gentle bedside manners, illegible handwriting and attempts to cure what ails us. If euthanasia opponents are to be believed, though, they’re actually dastardly devils with a desire for death.

Give ’em an inch when it comes to helping us die and they’ll take a mile – not to mention solicitations from family members who want to knock us off and take our riches, too.

Latest 2 of 73 comments

View all comments
 
  • Titia says:

    03:22pm | 15/10/11

    I hate my life but at least this makes it berabale. Read more »

  • Troy says:

    03:28pm | 21/05/11

    Jade, you ask “where do we draw the line”? and you ask in a highly emotive way. Every system the law makers has pro’s and con’s, good and bad. To argue about small children choosing to die with dignity is a non-question, what if they do? Just because they are… Read more »

 

What do you do with your life when what is left can be counted in years, rather than decades?

Table tennis champ Dorothy De Low. 100, still going strong. Pic: Phil Hillyard

When the realisation hits that you are sliding into oblivion?

This new fear is aided and abetted by the overwhelming attitude of the community towards the elderly.

Latest 2 of 34 comments

View all comments
 
  • Damocles says:

    06:58pm | 21/03/11

    Yeah, well picked “rickety” Reg (blah..blah…blah), but I think you’ll find that “their or they’re” is a GRAMMATICAL error, not a SPELLING error, so go and bark up another tree! My “breathtaking, assumptive, god damn statement” is true and correct and one you didn’t respond to, but feel free to… Read more »

  • sherry says:

    01:44am | 20/03/11

    At the age of 45 I was bemoaning my state of ‘already too oldism’ to an 85 year old friend who had immigrated from England at the age of 75 to be near a particular spiritual community. She looked penetratingly at me and smiled indulgently; ‘My dear, 45 is a… Read more »

 

George Bernard Shaw once observed that the statistics about death are very impressive - one out of one people dies. So why don’t we give more thought to what happens after we die? A 10-minute cab ride on Christmas Eve reminded me of a question we all need to ask, but rarely do.

If this guy can get in the rest of us must have a fighting chance. Cartoon: Warren Brown

I jumped in the cab at Chatswood with a spring in my step - I’d successfully completed my Christmas shopping - shopping I’d foolishly left until the last minute. When I asked the driver where he was up to with his present-buying, he explained that as a Muslim, he and his family wouldn’t be celebrating Christmas.

Instead, they would be holding their own celebration a couple of months later in a traditional Persian celebration that would appear, on the outside at least, much the same as a traditional Australian Christmas, minus of course, any references to God himself dwelling among us as he is born as a baby.

Latest 2 of 598 comments

View all comments
 
  • Stephen Hatzman says:

    09:28am | 28/06/11

    I thought you were going to give an elaborate explanation and that was it?  The bible?  Give me a break.  How can so many people base their faith on a guide written by man?  It was not written by god, if so where is he now?  Why are there no… Read more »

  • Steely Dan says:

    02:14pm | 28/01/11

    @ Jason Todd Don’t forget that many creationists have another category of evolution they like to talk about - superevolution!  Superevolution (yet another term actual scientists don’t use) was thought up by young-earthers to explain the immense diversity of life given that two of each animal simply couldn’t have fit… Read more »

 

Dear Mum,

This illness has gone on long enough. I can’t bear to see you suffer any more. I know you are going to say in your usual way, ‘don’t worry about me, I’ll be ok’, but it is becoming hard to see what the point of it all is anymore.

The Grandfather clock would look great in the den!

I am worried about you, really worried. You shouldn’t have to live through this. This cancer isn’t who you really are.

I really don’t think I can bring the kids again. The thought of them seeing you like this – with no hair, helpless to look after yourself, those blotches on your skin, your face screwed up in pain – is killing me.

Latest 2 of 147 comments

View all comments
 
  • LC says:

    09:02pm | 07/04/11

    “PS a disclaimer that the author is heavily influenced by religious bias would be good on an article like this.” Funny that you mention this. A man who was rendered a quadriplegic after a climbing accident was allowed to refuse to be fed and end his life on his terms.… Read more »

  • LC says:

    08:38pm | 07/04/11

    Firstly, don’t pretend palliative care is a treatment. It’s nothing more than a place where people are left to die. The purpose of the panel (which would consist of 2 doctors and a psychiatrist) is: - To make sure that the patient is well aware of his condition - To… Read more »

 

We all have to pay tax. And then we have to die.

Animated debate…the Greens are in step with the public on euthanasia.

These two fundamentals are well understood by most Australians - that’s what I surmise from our latest Auspoll. Somewhat astonishingly, to me anyway, a massive 76 per cent of Australians we asked this week said people with terminal illnesses should be allowed to choose euthanasia without breaking the law.

76 per cent is an extraordinary figure. It’s hard to get that for a tax cut. We thought we would find a modest majority on this question, but backing from four out of five Australians for the right to choose the timing and manner of our inevitable exit is very emphatic.

Latest 2 of 55 comments

View all comments
 
  • LC says:

    12:47pm | 07/04/11

    The slippery slope is still a logical fallacy, Robert. There are only two gaurantees in life, and one of them is death. If we find a cure for stage 4 cancer, for inoperable brain tumors etc that’s great. But that won’t stop people from dying. And in the interm, if… Read more »

  • Robert says:

    01:24pm | 29/09/10

    But who pulls the plug, effects the injection, strangles the patient or poisons one who may or may not be dying. Is this the legacy of today, for the generations of tomorrow. Will then it be compulsory, for anyone, who has retired and is considered a drain on the public… Read more »

 

I’ve upset a lot of people over the years. At first I thought this was due to my unwavering history of frank and fearless journalism but it turns out people just find me rather annoying.

Whistler's Mother, a haunting image of an annoying old woman.

It is for this reason that I find the euthanasia debate a little bit worrying. I’ve seen the way my mother looks at me sometimes.

There are also fiscal considerations. I am already in my mid-thirties and drink and smoke far too much. If I were bumped off now it would likely save the hospital system a great deal of money and - from what my bosses tell me - have no discernible impact on national productivity.

This is not just a fear for myself of course but a fear for all of us who are vulnerable at times.

Latest 2 of 189 comments

View all comments
 
  • scotty says:

    12:00am | 27/09/10

    Venise “there is none so blind as he who will not see” Read more »

  • austin 3:16 says:

    01:47pm | 25/09/10

    Hey Cate, how does an unreglated “informal” system, such as currently operates provide more protection than a legally regulated one ? Read more »

 

It’s one of pop culture’s great clichés that some actors and some films are best known for their great dying scenes.

When my mother was a child, her father must have held this hand in his just as I’m doing now.

I’m watching another dying scene right now, but this is real life and to the people involved, as the weeks have gone by, it seems all the drama has been bleached out of it. The dull flat winter days are turning to vibrant spring. My family is watching my mother slowly dying.

I hold her hand. The cancer inside her is fighting hard. She is resilient and quietly tough and fighting too. But by this stage, we all know what the final result will be. It’s a matter of time, a matter of days. The nurses and the palliative care team, magnificent, tireless, dedicated, work to make her comfortable.

Latest 2 of 8 comments

View all comments
 
  • Brendan says:

    03:39am | 03/06/11

    My mother is fading. It is a surreal experience that doesnt seem fair. The pain i sense on her face before the morphine takes it away is something i cannot begin to describe. The realisation and the feeling of hopelessness gets pushed away when you realise it isnt about me… Read more »

  • Steve says:

    05:18pm | 24/09/09

    Thank you Duncan for sharing that very personal moment We lost my mum and dad late last year within months of each other, they had been together, Darby and Joan for 59 years. a testiment to the capacity of a couples love. makes you hug your kids all that much… Read more »

 

The Rudd Government’s latest health blueprint is a well-intentioned but ultimately futile attempt to manage a system that has become the unwitting tool of our quest for immortality.

No matter how well the system is managed, it will remain unsustainable so long as we expect it to keep us alive way after we have passed our personal use-by date.

As we await the barrage of Baby Boomers to enter old age and demand access to the life-sustaining machines that go ‘beep’, we should draw inspiration from the 1970s classic Logan’s Run and accept death is part of the deal.

Latest 2 of 11 comments

View all comments
 
  • Jason M says:

    08:50pm | 04/08/09

    Brave article Peter!!  It would be interesting to have some numbers on the average age of people reading the Punch. Maybe you could publish the article in a couple of our classic magazines, sorry i mean papers the Daily tel and the Herald sun.  I think you may cause the… Read more »

  • John with cufflinks says:

    06:18pm | 04/08/09

    Peter has a good point here.  What do we do when the total amount that we produce in our entire lives is exceeded by the cost of our health care between our 80th and 110th year? At that point we have to decide that we can’t affod to keep everyone… Read more »

 

Rumour has it that if Katherine Jackson is granted permanent custody of Michael Jackson’s children, the brood could be raised by her eldest—and private—daughter Rebbie.

What a relief, when one considers the frightening prospect of Joseph Jackson playing a more permanent role in their upbringing.

Here is a man who has long been accused of ruling the famous clan with an iron fist and who, according to Michael, sat in a chair with a belt in his hand as the Jackson Five rehearsed.

Latest 1 of 1 comment

View all comments
 
  • Brent Blackburn says:

    05:38pm | 26/07/09

    Nice jab Dylan Read more »

 

NO Billie Jean. No Beat It. No-one was starting something, not even a moonwalk. Of all the unlikely things, it was often quiet.

Whatever your life had been, you’d probably want it mourned this way: solemn, plenty sad, and plenty of slow songs. But this was Michael Jackson, and no one expected it be as normal as that. So it was time to put aside your thoughts about the life being recognised and be surprised.
And perhaps nothing could have surprised a viewer more than a farewell that flipped the coin from crazy heads to solemn tales - the telling of gentle and kind stories that somehow did not leave you feeling conned, despite all we think we know about the man.

Latest 2 of 8 comments

View all comments
 
  • Dave says:

    11:26am | 10/07/09

    Has it been 3 days yet? Isn’t he suppose to ‘rise’ now? Read more »

  • Tye says:

    04:20pm | 09/07/09

    Thank heaven’s it did’nt happen next wednesday or you could bet your bottem dollar the net work’s would have S.O.O no 3 delayed till midnight or next day replay Read more »

 

While we officially record our sorrow at the passing of Michael Jackson and Farrah Fawcett - and anyone else who’s carked it in the past 20 minutes or so - it’s worth noting the terminal case of death-mania which has struck the media today.

Leading the charge was Richard Wilkins on Channel Nine who aired the hoax story that Jeff Goldblum had died, apparently from a fall. Nine boldly declared Goldblum to be deader than disco and ran with the story for a full ten minutes before airing new details which had come to hand, namely that the star of The Fly and Jurassic Park was considerably less dead than originally feared.

The official, pissed-off word came on Twitter from Kevin Spacey.

Latest 2 of 17 comments

View all comments
 
  • S says:

    09:42am | 01/07/09

    Billy Mays had also died on June 28.Dang,every one is dying.Oh,well it is just the End Times. Read more »

  • Moose says:

    05:15pm | 30/06/09

    6390 people die every hour. Being crass about 1 dead plasticised “star” helps us cope with the shame of not caring for the other 6299. Now what are we going to about MJ? rinse and recycle or landfill? Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Daniel Piotrowski

@NehaMadhok services eg gym, excellent kebab store?

Malcolm Farr

More gay marriage legislation than you can point a straight stick at. http://t.co/k2SC4xNp

Paul Colgan

@c41 yes it is.

Daniel Piotrowski

Tomorrow on The Punch: why we're being shafted at the ATM.

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

ICB:  If I could offer you only one tip for the future…

ICB:  If I could offer you only one tip for the future…

Welcome to this week’s I Call Bullshit, an irregular regular column on calumny and codswallop.…

Six prominent Aussies with a case of the dreaded “yips”

Six prominent Aussies with a case of the dreaded “yips”

The yips. It’s an old golf term which refers to golfers who lose the ability to putt. They stand…

The humourless hysteria of the holier-than-thou

The humourless hysteria of the holier-than-thou

In I Spit On Your Grave, a young woman is gang raped in a remote woodland. She is beaten and tortured…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Punch on: Open thread 09/02/2012

marley says:

I'm one of the older ones, so I've certainly seen a few changes in my time. When I started school I learned to write with a nib pen, dipped in an inkwell (no, I'm not kidding). My mother became a dab hand at getting inkstains out of my clothes. Flicking ink at one another in the classroom was an essential… [read more]

From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics

Erick says:

Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

151 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter