Constitutional Monarchy

On Tuesday 19th of January, Prince William – the 2nd in line to various thrones – will visit Australia for just the second time. It has been reported that he is doing this to “get to know Australia”.

English Rugby fan Prince William tosses it around with some Kiwi kiddies

Since this tour was announced in December, as Media Director for the Australian Republican Movement (ARM), I have been busy with requests from English broadcasters and newspapers.

The interest should have been surprising, since William is only stopping in on Australia for three days for a “semi-official” tour on his way to New Zealand. Moreover, he is visiting only two cities: Sydney and Melbourne. However, given that there has been a massive PR campaign by the Palace to present William as the youthful – cuter – face of the monarchy, it was inevitable that the English press would be awash with expectation about whether Australia would warm to the Prince like good little subjects.

Latest 2 of 56 comments

View all comments
 
  • davrosz says:

    08:10am | 30/01/10

    dead right, this debate has absolutely nothing to do with you. Read more »

  • William Mohan says:

    09:09am | 29/01/10

    For people who say the don’t care about the monarchy, you sure are getting in a bit of a tiz over this visit.  Here in the UK we respect and are quite happy to have a constitutional monarch.  We are not forcing you Aussies to have it.  You can vote… Read more »

 

The Australian monarchists are divided – David Flint and his tightly controlled Australians for a Constitutional Monarchy (ACM) claim the Governor General is the Australian head of state while Philip Benwell and his Australian Monarch League (AML) are with the Republicans – it’s the foreign non resident unelected British Queen who holds this nation’s top job.

Republican ridicule from The Australian's Bill Leak.

Ten years up the track, the debate is simmering away under the surface and right now Flint is holding the trump cards – he is said to pull in half a million dollars a year towards his cause which is remarkable considering ACM has only two members – Flint and his sidekick former Roman Catholic seminarian Thomas Flynn. The movement’s constitution is clever; its run by the pair with the help of would be members, who are non voting “supporters”

Professor Flint’s latest take on the vexed subject of a republic revolves around the quaint notion that if we change the constitution we’ll have a “politician’s republic”. He fails to mention we are now laboring under a “politician’s monarchy” – a point Tony Blair underscored when he pulled the Queen into line over her unbelievable indifference to the death of Princess Diana in 1997.

Latest 2 of 21 comments

View all comments
 
  • Mark says:

    07:14pm | 29/10/09

    Can anyone argue that our current system hasnt worked? Furthermor I can not see how in a republic a President could repesent the entire community the way a monarch does. Firstly if the parliment elects the President then the President only represents the parliment and isnt constitutional either. The second… Read more »

  • Ron says:

    02:11am | 11/10/09

    It’s interesting that many of the obviously historically inept and deficiently researched comments by most people on this blog including the original ‘braniac’ who composed the opening article filled with inaccuracies, decry the German origins of the monarch as if she was a foreigner in her own land. These same… Read more »

 

Most commented

The talk of the town

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Paul Colgan

Clarke and Bingle are off, Sky News reports

Paul Colgan

@ngeoghegan bankers too?

Paul Colgan

Lolz at the rugby. Waratahs 73-12 Lions. Great entertainment, tahs merciless. Robbie Deans here too and he enjoyed I think #rugby#super14

Paul Colgan

Go Tahs. Great to see some confident rugby #rugby#super14

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Breaking news: Something is going on

Breaking news: Something is going on

Is this the greatest ever send-up of 24-hour news? Warning: contains strong language and hilarity. From… Read more

6 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter