Bob Carr

It was organised as a celebration of Australian car makers but the 250 people in the Great Hall of Parliament House found themselves witnessing a reunion of Veterans of Labor Leadership Wars.

Making himself at home

A big chunk of the event became what one attendee called “a festival of Kevin”. Kevin Rudd that is, of course.

What was designed as a rousing salute to the automotive industry had to share the focus with anti-Gillard comrades-in-arms uniting on a stage, and in videos.

Latest 2 of 110 comments

View all comments
 
  • Brad says:

    09:47am | 15/05/12

    If it comes down to Kevin v Tony. I’m nervous. Now, Julia v Tony…I haven’t a care in the world. Read more »

  • Garry says:

    09:02am | 15/05/12

    LucyG…. Gillard will go down in history as the worst PM Australia has ever seen, she will be credited with destroying our economy and building massive debt, but above all the other failures, she will be the one Labor PM that through her obsessive socialist ideologies could be the end… Read more »

 

The Australian aid sector’s fury at the aid budget cuts announced on Tuesday has been focused on the dollar figure that the Government has (or rather, hasn’t) allocated to foreign aid.

Funding international banks won't help this situation. Or any like it.

But there’s another reason to be angry.

Alongside its much-smaller-that-promised aid budget, the Gillard government delivered another announcement. “Australia is deepening its engagement with effective multilateral organisations including the Development Banks,” Foreign Minister Carr blogged proudly on Wednesday.

Latest 2 of 62 comments

View all comments
 
  • Dave Charlesworth says:

    01:23pm | 11/05/12

    The grammar Nazi’s are out today! I take it you didn’t agree with the comment SDA? Read more »

  • Scotchfinger says:

    11:55am | 11/05/12

    Yes we should impose trade sanctions for the ol’ Rusty… Read more »

 

People looking for reasons for the ongoing implosion of the federal government are, it is fair to say, spoiled for choice. There is a phalanx of reasons lined up ready to drag Labor into electoral and political oblivion.

Going downnnnnnnnn. Illustration: Warren Brown

These include the assassination of Kevin Rudd, the carbon tax, the mining tax, the pokies cap, the second Rudd showdown and subsequent recruitment of Bob Carr and the Craig Thomson and Peter Slipper scandals.

However at the core of them all is one common element. One fundamental characteristic of the current Labor leadership which will prevent it ever again winning government in this country until it is expunged.

Latest 2 of 407 comments

View all comments
 
  • Karin says:

    03:24pm | 06/05/12

    “Anyone that still supports Labor should be commited.” Says the poster with that weird and juvenile handle??? Read more »

  • Bob says:

    09:35pm | 05/05/12

    I’m an Atheist Liberal voter. >>But Atheism and democracy is never compatible<< Why not? Before you reference the Soviet Union and communist dictatorships, the problem there was that religions competed with communism. It was about divided loyalty. How communism was treated was very similar to a religion in those cases… Read more »

 

As the Arab Spring continues its momentum throughout the Middle East engulfing Syria, and with it the hope of greater democracy, it’s also worth reflecting on the consequences such as the ancient Christian communities which are becoming a disappearing minority.

A mosque and a church sit next to each other in Damascus. Picture: Steve Butler

Syria’s Christians, represent no more than ten per cent of the country’s 22 million people, tracing their origins two millennia to the beginnings of the faith. Apostle Paul is said to have converted to Christianity on the road to Damascus, from which he went on to spread the religion across the Roman Empire.

Christianity has its origin in the Middle East from the fourth century. Covering communities speaking Greek, Syriac, Armenian, Coptic, Georgian, and Arabic.

Latest 2 of 107 comments

View all comments
 
  • pj says:

    10:05am | 02/04/12

    median. Ditto!! Read more »

  • stephen says:

    12:30am | 01/04/12

    I think the women are allowed to drive now ... well ? I’m being cynical, really, but the Arab League is guilty of setting up bogus resistance groups in Iran, (remember, about 12 months ago a local uprising in Tehran which the West had hopes for ... bogus) and also… Read more »

 

Australians do not need to be told that today is World Water Day to remember that water is both a giver and taker of life. This is the driest populated continent and we know well the impact of both floods and droughts.

We can't rely on Kevin Costner to solve the world's water issues…

But how many people are aware that billions of people across the world still lack access to a hygienic toilet, a tap and soap? Or that the failure to provide sanitation and safe drinking water causes about 4000 children to die every day?

The preventable diseases caused by poor sanitation cause more child deaths than malaria, measles and HIV/AIDS combined. Almost one in three people live in unsanitary conditions.

Latest 2 of 21 comments

View all comments
 
  • marley says:

    01:18pm | 23/03/12

    @Little Joe - well, at least a few of us care. I’ve spent a bit of time in Africa and the sub Continent, and seen some of conditions there.  We don’t know how lucky we are in places like Australia, not even to have to think about things like clean… Read more »

  • Little Joe says:

    06:34am | 23/03/12

    @ Marley The Punch has pushed this to No.12 on yesterday’s stories, the story has only 19 comments and about half of them are ours .....it appears that people do not care. Read more »

 

When Bob Carr prepared for a recent television appearance he stood in the middle of a room and loudly declaimed slabs of Shakespeare. Other guests for that evening’s edition of the ABC’s Q&A quietly continued munching their Turkish wraps and sipped drinks as the rich Carr baritone set sail on a chunk of Hamlet.

Bob Carr arrives at the stage door, I mean, Senate door this morning… Picture: Ray Strange

He was warming up that voice, long so distinctive in Australian politics. Bob Carr knows that drab politics, like drab TV, don’t get god ratings. He believes in theatre to sell a message and the Senate today will benefit from that.

Young Robbie, as Paul Keating used to call the man who now is an elder Labor statesman, this morning was preparing to be sworn in as a senator, and as Minister for Foreign Affairs.

Latest 2 of 120 comments

View all comments
 
  • Bob Young says:

    08:13am | 23/03/12

    Bob Carr has one great asset.. Timing… He certainly knew when to leave NSW>  His timing was perfect.  Apart from that I can think of nothing to commend him.  Good at Latin verbs perhaps, could help Julia with her vowels otherwise I can think of nothing.  His own little circus… Read more »

  • Tom says:

    06:17pm | 15/03/12

    Rose, “The man is a raving lunatic, an economic illiterate [pretty good work for a Rhodes scholar in economics] and quite frankly ...” HE IS GOING TO EAT OUR BABIES TOO? Read more »

 

It might be one of those urban myths which take hold in politics and follow their subjects to the grave. Legend has it that, during the Sydney Olympics, Bob Carr was caught reading Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment at the beach volleyball finals. Or it might have been Tolstoy at an NRL match.

Bob Carr, senator in waiting, anointed Foreign Minister and sports nut. Photo: Kim Smith

He certainly did predict, during a motivational pep-talk to the NSW Blues at Origin Camp where he quoted from Marcus Aurelius, that they would triumph over Victoria in their Origin clash. Carr was also busted teaching himself German during Question Time, mouthing verbs to himself from a textbook called Die Stufen as an indignant Opposition demanded answers about the neglect of Sydney’s trains.

That episode was held up as an example of Carr’s disengagement in the job of premier and his indifference to the parlous state of Sydney’s infrastructure. Conversely, it was hailed as an indictment of the hapless NSW Liberals that the Premier was under such little pressure that he could use the peak forum for executive accountability as a chance for quiet self-improvement.

Latest 2 of 99 comments

View all comments
 
  • Glenn says:

    05:02pm | 28/04/12

    I am sad in a way that I have already expressed the virtues of bob car in my earlier post. 5.24pm. However after reading the long winded @patricia’s post I felt compelled to write again. The only other time that I have heard such wisdom expressed from the far left… Read more »

  • Glenn says:

    04:24pm | 28/04/12

    Bob is one of those cars that Gillard wanted off the road in the cash for clunkers fiasco. I’m astounded how he’s found his way back to the future. Should have stayed in the junk yard where these types of cars belong. Read more »

 

There has been much fun for many going through Bob Carr’s writings to embarrass the incoming Foreign Minister by highlighting his private citizen notions about Barack Obama, the Dalai Lama and others.

Maybe there wouldn't be so much congestion if a certain NSW Premier had built more infrastructure… Picture: John Grainger

But so far no one has pointed to the passionate campaign which gave Mr Carr when NSW Premier the nickname of The Malthus of Macquarie Street.

Bob Carr is against a big Australia. He wants a national population smaller - much smaller - than some projections indicate it will be by 2050.

Latest 2 of 134 comments

View all comments
 
  • Gregary Boyles says:

    11:58am | 24/03/12

    Can I point out the bleedingly obvious to you booster! If you increase Australia’s population so that everyone is fighting over dwindling water supplies during times of drought, then the major national security threat will come from within rather than from China or Indonesia! Over population relative to limited resources… Read more »

  • Mark/Fox says:

    07:09pm | 08/03/12

    You do not need to be a scientist to realise we are oerpopulated. You only need to be a politician to think we are not. Good on Bob for realising we are. Read more »

 

At 12.10pm last Friday Julia Gillard strode into the Blue Room in Parliament House with Bob Carr in tow and knocked everyone’s socks off. In the hubbub one of the journos even called Carr “Senator-elect Carr”.

It may surprise you to learn this photograph has been digitally altered…

Then at 2pm on the same day NSW Labor emailed its members saying this:

Due to the resignation of Senator Mark Arbib, a vacancy has arisen in the Australian Senate. Under Rule N.4, the NSW Labor Party Officers have called for nominations for this position to be determined by a ballot of the NSW ALP Administrative Committee, according to the following timetable:

Nominations open:      1pm, Friday 2 March 2012
Nominations close:      5pm, Monday 5 March 2012
Nomination fee:        $750

The rest of Gillard’s Cabinet movers were sworn in this morning without Carr, who is waiting for this ALP process to pan out and then a joint sitting of the NSW Parliament before being sworn in as both a Senator and the Foreign Minister. It’s all a bit weird.

Bob Carr, along with Steve Bracks and John Faulkner, authored an extensive review into the Labor Party last year, which had many, many recommendations including: “Community engagement with primaries, introducing primaries for preselections in nonheld and open seats so that Labor’s supporters have a say in their local representatives.”

Latest 2 of 69 comments

View all comments
 
  • Matt C says:

    02:14pm | 08/03/12

    Heres some fun facts for you GB!!!! Paul Keating was a economic genius. You give him crap about 18% interest rates but you forget that under John Howard as treasurer before Hawke/Keatings term that interest rates were capped at 14%. If they weren’t, they were predicted to be up and… Read more »

  • Just Sayin' says:

    01:00pm | 07/03/12

    We all got a say, and we collectively decided. I know, you know it, everyone else knows it. Read more »

 

It’s not often in Australian politics when a Prime Minister can go beyond Parliament, and select the best possible candidate in Australia for a Ministerial position.

Hmmm. I believe these bricks were crafted sometime between the Tang and Shang Dynasties. Pic: Sam Mooy.

Not so in the United States, where the President selects his Cabinet Secretaries not on the premise whether they are in Congress or Senate, but whether they are the best possible candidate for high office.

Prime Minister Gillard selected one of Australia’s best candidates to the Ministry, not the best candidate in Parliament (at the time of the appointment). Let me clear, Australia is the beneficiary by having Bob Carr installed as Minister for Foreign Affairs.

Latest 2 of 146 comments

View all comments
 
  • Yasemin says:

    10:07am | 18/03/12

    Qing & Ming is less than %0.001 of world politics & international affairs. His wife is Asian & it should be no surprise he knows Qing & Ming. If Sassoon thinks knowing this difference will earn Carr respect from the Chinese, either he doesn’t know the Chinese or he doesn’t… Read more »

  • Mark says:

    09:56am | 06/03/12

    Oops. Wrong reply button. That was in reply to Joan’s statement below that “the unelected should not get top jobs.” Read more »

 

That’s one for the books. Julia Gillard unbotches something. Turns failure into success instead of the other way around.

He goes from zero to foreign minister in three seconds

Bob Carr’s appearance at her side as the new Foreign Minister yesterday - after the apparent collapse of the deal earlier in the week - was a breathtaking political development.

For days the prime minister had been lambasted in parliament and in the media for weakness because she had allegedly allowed a few senior ministers - particularly Defence Minister Stephen Smith - to veto the recruitment of Carr to the post.

Latest 2 of 271 comments

View all comments
 
  • Dragon Slayer says:

    05:36pm | 05/03/12

    I think what the reference to the GST was that Howard said never ever, took it to an election, didn’t get the mandate and numbers to implement it and sweet talked the Democrats (who went to the election against it) out of existence to give him the numbers. Hardly a… Read more »

  • Ron Vincent says:

    04:19pm | 05/03/12

    Laurie, aren’t you and your ilk a great excuse for the Labor Party. The Liberal Party did not object to the appointment of Bob Carr, although I suspect Labor will not be happy if he performs as badly as he did as Premier of NSW and get out before Australians… Read more »

 

Julia Gillard says her Government colleagues will be delighted to learn Bob Carr is Foreign Minister, presumably after they get up from the floor.

A slightly used Carr. Picture: Kym Smith

It was a surprise, so stunning that it would have amounted to a shock for many players and observers.

The Prime Minister today sent a “don’t mess with me” message to critics within and outside the ALP by parading her star recruit.

Latest 2 of 313 comments

View all comments
 
  • Gaz says:

    03:11pm | 05/03/12

    What a joke.  Jobs for the boys. And this boy is the one who led NSW on it’s progression to the basket case it became by around 2009. I suppose at least we should praise him for having political allegience over making money.  No doubt he was making a good… Read more »

  • AnthonyG says:

    04:09pm | 04/03/12

    Being a swinging voter and having voted both labor and Liberal in the past I can’t believe how anyone can say the labor Gov are doing a good job. Not only are they trying to put one over everyone with a carbon tax but their still is the same morons… Read more »

 

The Gillard prime ministership is like a badly scalded arm. The mildest touch can cause pain way out of proportion to the force behind the blow. Even when she does nothing unusual, remarkable or even particularly clumsy, the Government ends up screaming in agony.

We typed Bob Carr into our picture system and this was the first photo that came up. True story. Picture: Getty

So when Julia Gillard followed standard procedure by canvassing possible candidates for a Senate vacancy and for the post of Foreign Minister, there was an outcry over what was actually a light brush.

In broad terms, the suggestion is that Julia Gillard had decided former NSW Premier Bob Carr would fill the Senate slot and become Foreign Minister replacing Kevin Rudd, but was rolled by furious ministers led by Defence Minister Stephen Smith who wanted the job for himself.

Latest 2 of 159 comments

View all comments
 
  • Jolly says:

    03:57pm | 04/03/12

    It’s such fun watching these folks in their desperation. It’s good reminder to us all that we don’t always have to pay to see a good comedy. Ooops, suddenly I realise that we do pay the actors. Ah hell, never mind the cost ... let’s watch and have a goooooood… Read more »

  • PMSL says:

    01:03pm | 04/03/12

    If the Punch gives award for comment of the year, I nominate the above! Read more »

 

Our society puts great stock in the merits of hard work.  You know how it goes.  If you work hard enough, you can achieve anything. 

No one ever accused Rudd of being a slacker. Picture: Kym Smith

Fail to achieve a goal?  If only you’d worked harder.  For an upcoming Lateline interview, I’ve read a book called Bounce by Mathew Syed. 

His theory is that God-given talent is a myth and that the key to achieving greatness lies in how hard you’re prepared to work. I’m not sure I buy all of that.

Latest 2 of 25 comments

View all comments
 
  • Ture Sjolander says:

    03:11pm | 09/07/10

    I’m not writer, but I’m a bloody good reader. So this is my point of view: http://www.unitednation.homestead.com/unitednations.html If you can’t handle this Internet language, well than try this: http://www.newstime2010.net/ You are just one click from a new brave world! Ciao Read more »

  • Ture Sjolander says:

    11:41am | 06/07/10

    Can you imagine the whole Australian population of 22 million citizens being dogs and you have to pick a PM among them? I would pick a Golden Retriever. It struck me after seeing the interview with Alexander Downer on TV. There is less politicians talking during parliamentary debates than during… Read more »

 

Our supposedly classless society is showing signs of being divided into two camps where people’s private choices as individuals and their behaviour as families are regulated on the basis of their affluence.

Apparently one of these people needs government intervention

And it’s in the area of nutrition, preventative health and exercise where the working class, for want of a better term, is increasingly being treated like a bunch of babies, while the more affluent members of society continue to live as they please.

It’s only a small thing but it’s a signifier for the times, a demonstration of a mindset which holds that working class people are unable to modify their behaviour, while the gentry can be trusted to keep its conduct in check. But get along to the SCG, that great people’s arena, where our knockabout, egalitarian society lets the members drink as much full-strength beer as they want and limits the great unwashed to light beer.

Latest 2 of 37 comments

View all comments
 
  • Sir Lolsworthy says:

    11:50am | 30/10/09

    Yes, E, that’s exactly what I said. Thank god someone was able to work it out. In case you can’t tell, I’m being sarcastic. Get your hands on copies of ‘Fast Food Nation’ and ‘Don’t Eat This Book’ if you want to learn about the realities of the situation Read more »

  • Sophie says:

    09:28pm | 29/10/09

    I blame the baby boomers. Aspirational… apathetic and about to become a massive burden on the healthcare system. Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Paul Colgan

It's a Sydney thing, but 95.3FM... Why? It used to be all Bohemian Rhapsody and Walk this Way; now it's Father to Son and Country Road. Wah.

tory_maguire

@pryorlisa There's a column in this... turning into something you thought you'd never be... I crossed the threshold with a soccer mum car!

Paul Colgan

@davesag it's @qantasairways

Daniel Piotrowski

@Colgo i'm upset I missed that headline. Ba bow.

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter