Black Saturday

In Grantham and beyond, they searched for bodies in battered houses and hot, swampy fields. Clearing debris from footpaths, roads and yards. Eighteen months before, they’d fought the inferno in southern and central Victoria, fighting fires, saving lives, and making endless cups of tea.

A more meaningful thank you…

They’re Australian volunteers - thousands of them - who left jobs and families to lend a hand to the natural disaster recovery efforts that swept across our eastern states in the past three years.

Their work saved lives and homes. Comforted hearts, and made towns livable again. Actions fit for a reward of huge proportions. But here’s what they got instead. A muddled up medal with serious eligibility issues and a confusing criteria that ignored the efforts of thousands of others. And a bungled up awards ceremony. Seem unfair to you? Well, here’s how it happened.

Latest 2 of 44 comments

View all comments
 
  • mick says:

    09:44pm | 12/05/12

    At the very most. I thought 7 days volunteering straight would be enough. It was 7 days for the Vic fires but is 14 days unpaid for floods/cyclone. I am too confused. And I also agree that , I never joined for the medals but the recognition is good, even… Read more »

  • mick says:

    09:35pm | 12/05/12

    I tend to agree here. I drove to chinchilla, to help people I know in the flood effort. Because I have very little evidence, it doesn’t apply. I then drove back home to Mackay. We then braced for Cyclone Toni and waited. We were then briefed by EMQ Mackay to… Read more »

 

Sometimes it takes a disaster to shake the complacency out of us. To rethink the attitude of ‘she’ll be right’ when clearly things are not right.

Yep, we're definitely going to need a plan. Photo: Sam Mooy

So isn’t it time to develop a national masterplan to help guide future planning and development in this country to try and stop the increasing loss of life and damage that the natural forces around Australia unleash?

If you look at the past decade there have many natural disasters, both fire and flood, which have destroyed so many homes. We have seen the fires in Victoria which swept through the hill communities of Flowerdale, Kinglake and Marysville in 2009 destroying over 2,000 homes and taking 173 lives. Back in 1983 Ash Wednesday fires in South Australia destroyed 2,400 homes.

Latest 2 of 31 comments

View all comments
 
  • Ray says:

    02:49pm | 25/01/11

    It is ironic that the Wivenhoe Dam that was built to lessen the risk of flood damage to Brisbane, has in fact contributed largely to the 2011 Brisbane Flood, thanks to the ineptitude of the dam operator, which is a Qld Govt instrumentality. As a taxpayer, I find it appalling… Read more »

  • Population Pooper says:

    07:37am | 25/01/11

    Having toomany kids is a disaster! Read more »

 

Christine Nixon’s testimony in front of the bushfire Royal Commission today could well spell the end of her role chair of the Victorian Bushfire Reconstruction taskforce, and stain a successful career in the police force.

Nixon on her way to the Commission today

Nixon’s testimony today has drawn a thundering afternoon editorial from Melbourne’s Herald Sun demanding that Ms Nixon be sacked.

The paper pointed out that Nixon has admitted (amongst other things) today that she did not use her phone at all between 6pm and 9pm that evening, did not speak to Assistant Commissioner Kieran Walshe once despite previously saying she had and had not told anyone she had gone to dinner.

Latest 2 of 43 comments

View all comments
 
  • alex says:

    12:49pm | 17/04/10

    No doubt the firies felt like eating too, after a day at the front, even if only for a toasted sandwich, but NO they stayed on the job fighting the fires ...so did their boss charge her pub dinner to the taxpayer or VicPol as well? Read more »

  • BTS says:

    05:46pm | 15/04/10

    In my State in an Emergenc,y ultimate authority remains with the Police.  Fire authorities advise, but if push came to shove, they don’t have ultimate authority.  Police enact the Emergency situation under legislation and remain at all times in control. Read more »

 

Whatever you make of the revelations that have emerged of Christine Nixon’s actions during the Black Saturday bushfires, she deserves respect for the apology made this morning in Victoria’s Herald Sun newspaper.

Has a tough job. Picture: Richard Cisar-Wright.

Admitting that you are wrong is difficult for people of any profession and given the tumultuous scale of grief and loss of the Black Saturday disaster, her position and decision to make admissions and forthcoming apology is an unenviable one.

As she wrote herself, no-one could have known or prepared for the disasters that ensued on that horrible Saturday a year ago, but her willingness to “report” back on her own actions in such a difficult situation shows not only a deep respect for the Victorian people but a willingness to support them and push through into the future by their side.

Latest 2 of 145 comments

View all comments
 
  • Ann says:

    10:38am | 17/04/10

    I am honoured to have heard, met and been in Victoria on Black Saturday.  The effort Christine put in was over time and continues to be enormous. She trusted her staff to keep her informed and she had no reason to be unsure.  Corrupt police who surfaced in Victoria are… Read more »

  • Bushfire Victim says:

    02:25am | 17/04/10

    For those praising her efforts on the bushfire reconstruction, remember that her “empathy” comes with a nice big juicy pay packet funded by the public. Money that she is no longer deserve to receive given the revelation of her gross lack of leadership in time of great need. If she… Read more »

 

As we observe the first anniversary if the horrific firestorms that ravaged whole communities on Black Saturday, a typically scorching summer has again gripped much of Australia, providing a stark reminder that such dangers are a constant threat for those living in a sunburnt country.

Tragedies such as Black Saturday have been made possible by poor forest management. Picture: AFP

Yet despite an ongoing Royal Commission, a flurry of catastrophic warnings and a flood of big-ticket resources which go right up to a water-bombing jumbo jet, little attention has thus far been given to the vital role that sustainable forestry traditionally played in essential aspects of fire management.

In recent decades, as politicians clamoured to placate the noisy environmental movement, they blissfully ignored the long-standing efforts of a sustainable forestry industry in managing forests, reducing fuel loads, building and maintaining access routes and fighting fires.

Latest 2 of 29 comments

View all comments
 
  • blossom fungus says:

    08:29pm | 27/08/10

    The bush is crying out to us .... ie the planet . I have worked for ten years as a horticulturalist. I earn 25 thousand dollars a year and support a family - I cope because I know real food and I know your law ie common I am not… Read more »

  • persephone says:

    07:23am | 11/02/10

    formersnag There’s a fair few Eastern greys banging around, too - saw some in the grounds of my local hospital yesterday! I take your point on rock wallabies (not big forest grazers) and the like, but would point out that in the areas where they might have had some impact… Read more »

 

Our flag flutters from letterboxes, fenceposts and trees along our roads – an enduring and binding tribute to the resilience of our communities in the 12 months since that fateful February day we now call Black Saturday.

Jill Sanguinetti at her property near Marysville. Photo: Stuart McEvoy

Their resilience was tested like never before on February 7, 2009. And it has been severely challenged many times since as they struggle to slowly rebuild lives, homes and entire towns.

The progress has been slow, painfully so, for many communities. A year on Kinglake is still without a petrol station, Marysville still waits for a school and new shops. And people in each community have had to battle ever increasing bureaucracy and building permits based on new building standards that still can’t deliver the required roofing and window materials.

Latest 2 of 39 comments

View all comments
 
  • persephone says:

    08:44am | 08/02/10

    Ah - interesting admission there, Jane. So you do know that free firewood collection is still allowed from roadsides! And, as I said, even twenty years ago you needed a permit. The reason I cut down trees was that the DSE directed us to do so rather than collect from… Read more »

  • Captain Koala says:

    08:47am | 07/02/10

    Well put Mrs Bailey - your sentiments same as I have heard from friends in fire towns -. They reckon, and after track record with Victorian Police force, cant blame them that Christine Nixon is all about mug in paper.  Let the locals do the job Read more »

 

While I’m not a huge fan of public grieving there are some events that demand a collective emotional response, and it can be very healing.

An image of hope amid the ashes. Sam the koala with fire fighter David Tree. Picture: Reuters.

Public memorial services after the Bali bombings were amazing for their outpouring of emotion while also remaining very dignified and respectful.

The 173 people killed in the Black Saturday bushfires are still being grieved by the whole nation. That’s why I’m uncomfortable the death from Chlamydia of Sam the Koala is being tagged a national tragedy.

Latest 2 of 19 comments

View all comments
 
  • Payton L. Inkletter says:

    08:14am | 09/08/09

    As a bull koala bear myself (it’s a long story), it might surprise some that I agree with Ms Maguire about Sam the koala’s death. Had Prime Minister Rudd, at the Pacific Islands Forum press conference, said “It’s sad that Sam the koala is no longer with us…” he’d have… Read more »

  • Leo says:

    11:33pm | 08/08/09

    I’m confused by this entire facade.. a koala dies because we can’t stand to watch it suffer from chlamydia, the same koala that was previously injured by backburning operations managed by the very firefighters capturing the circus act for their kids on a mobile phone… and we somehow transmutate this… Read more »

 

The Red Cross does some of the most important work people can dedicate their lives to.

After the Black Saturday bushfires its role in collecting and distributing millions of dollars in aid was extraordinary so they’re a group more than entitled to voice an opinion about its cause.

In a statement this week the organization linked the Black Saturday fires to the now popular notion that it was all the fault of climate change.

The eerie image of the bushfire ravaged town of Marysville under snow

The media release promoting the report was headlined: “Be Prepared says Red Cross as climate change boosts world disaster toll” and included the Victorian fires as part of its evidence for this.

This was accompanied the publication of the World Disasters Report and found that in 2008 and astonishing 225,842 people died in natural disasters. Cyclone Nargis in Burma and the Sichuan earthquake in China accounted for 93% of deaths worldwide killing 138,000 and 87,000 people respectively.

But by putting climate change front and centre of the Black Saturday fires Michael Raper, Red Cross director of services and international operations, runs the risk of being intellectually dishonest about the multiple causes of the fires.

Latest 2 of 4 comments

View all comments
 
  • Ben Payne says:

    10:21pm | 18/06/09

    No, no, no, you’ve got it all wrong.  The Black Saturday bushfire was god’s way of punishing us for our abortion laws - didn’t you hear? http://catchthefire.com.au/blog/2009/02/10/media-release-abortion-laws-to-blame-for-bush-fires/ And you just watch out, those darn pornographers in Melbourne are gonna get us all fried when god melts the ozone layer on… Read more »

  • Josh says:

    08:15pm | 18/06/09

    It was also no great help for the likes of Andrew Bolt and Miranda Devine to say that Greenies had blood on their hands over this. Casting ignorant blame without, as you say, an understanding of the complexity of the issues is dangerous. Read more »

 

I like Cate’s economic thinking here:

She ... mentioned the loss of agricultural and tourism industry jobs, adding: “We have the ability to kick start the low carbon economies of the future right when we need to, and that’s now.”

On fire: Cate Blanchett in Copenhagen. Pic: AFP

Changing the traditional drivers of economic production is something that I reckon will be fundamental to bringing about serious reductions in carbon emissions across the economy. Agriculture and heavy industry cannot continue in their current form, but making anything happen is going to take enormous will from politicians and consumers, open-mindedness from workers on new opportunities from innovation, and also support from government for workers making a transition between jobs.

On the other hand, I can’t say I agree with Cate on this:

Latest 2 of 4 comments

View all comments
 
  • dennis k says:

    11:11pm | 02/10/11

    I don’t think she’s a good person to talk about climate change. She’s not an expert phone number lookup Read more »

  • Dallas says:

    03:18pm | 01/06/09

    More Spin, acting, staging, weaving dreams, selling snake oil, credibility lies in modern comics. Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Daniel Piotrowski

@Colgo i'm upset I missed that headline. Ba bow.

Paul Colgan

Square kilometer array? Exactly http://t.co/GOte9QFy

tory_maguire

@pryorlisa I had exactly the same feeling when I bought the Women's Weekly the other day. I think it's demographic creep!

Paul Colgan

@ClaireRConnelly hops into CSIRO and the government for the total non-campaign for the square kilometer array http://t.co/GOte9QFy

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter