Army

It’s a pretty special set of circumstances when a tax-payer-funded body releases a series of reviews exposing decades of cultural problems, including 775 allegations of sexual assault, and the Minister is the one facing questions over why he won’t apologise for standing down one of the people in charge.

Stephen Smith yesterday with David Hurley and Duncan Lewis

Last night on the ABC’s 7.30 Defence Minister Stephen Smith was asked in numerous ways why he wouldn’t apologise to Australian Defence Academy Commandant Bruce Kafer, who has been reinstated this week, 11 months after being stood down over the so called “Skype” scandal.

When the scandal broke, involving an 18-year-old woman cadet being filmed without her consent having sex, and the vision broadcast via the internet to some of her classmates, Smith went in pretty hard and fast.

Latest 2 of 220 comments

View all comments
 
  • RonaldR says:

    07:04pm | 14/03/12

    All Australian populations should get up and apologies to the Australian people for putting their party’s before the good of Australia especially the great pretender Abbott. Read more »

  • Mel says:

    02:21pm | 11/03/12

    Matt, I applaud your bravery for ” outing” the elephant in the room. You are correct, each consenting party breached the rules of the DFDA,  by engaging in the sex in the first place. Defence has those rules in place to maintain order and for the protection of these kids… Read more »

 

When Rod Stewart rocked Adelaide last month, he dedicated Rhythm of My Heart to the servicemen and women of Australia and Britain. I remember it distinctly for two reasons: 1) in Australia, we might ‘well up’ once a year as veterans march on ANZAC Day, but we most definitely don’t fawn over serving troops; and 2) someone shouted “THANKYOU” in a way that implied “FINALLY, some bloody recognition”.

Lest we bloody forget. Pic: Darren Fletch

I’ve been musing on the incident this week in the wake of those inane comments uttered on Channel Ten’s morning chat show The Circle.

In the unlikely event you missed the subsequent outpouring of wrath, hosts Yumi Stynes and George Negus ‘joked’ about the intelligence and sexual prowess of Australia’s newest Victoria Cross recipient, Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith. Tacky at best, disgusting at worst, and the social networks went into meltdown.

Latest 2 of 125 comments

View all comments
 
  • Steieve says:

    03:20pm | 20/03/12

    Not often does a journo put together an article in defence of OUR Service Members & when one does it shines. So to all you pinkies out there wanting to slag & slang the Services, remember their parents, children & wives do appreciate who & what they are & what… Read more »

  • BT says:

    10:14am | 20/03/12

    @BJ did you even read that document? “2007-08 there were 150 notified work-related fatalities” The 7000 figure is an ESTIMATE as to the fatalitis from work related illness I.e Cancer etc from exposure through their job. If your job involves you painting the inside of a aircraft with lead based… Read more »

 

It has been almost 600 days since 28-year-old Lance Corporal Jared MacKinney from Brisbane was killed in action in Afghanistan.

The new dad was shot in the upper body by a single enemy round during the Battle of Derapet in the Tangi Valley on August 24, 2010.

Following the battle one of his close mates in the Mentoring Task Force wrote a detailed email in which he claimed that with better fire support from mortars, artillery and light armoured vehicles, Lance Corporal MacKinney might not have been killed.

Latest 2 of 59 comments

View all comments
 
  • Roger says:

    03:56pm | 05/03/12

    “You should also note that when a helicopter is in the vicinity all offensive support must be stopped. You can’t have both at the same time because one tends to hit the other” “You should also note that when a helicopter is in the vicinity all offensive support must be… Read more »

  • Geoff says:

    09:27pm | 03/02/12

    If the Americans had assisted Afghanistan after the withdrawal of the Russians then me might not be in this mess - ie see the end of the movie Charlie Wilson’s War Read more »

 

There has been plenty of diplomatic semantics around the American presence in Darwin but many including the Chinese are still not satisfied. The United States has long wanted a permanent military base in northern Australia.

Just smile and say 'rotational presence' three times. Pic: Brad Fleet

But they are not stupid. 

So when Australian officials conveyed that a fixed establishment would not be politically palatable here they saved us the embarrassment of having to say no in a high-level bilateral meeting if the request was made.

Latest 2 of 39 comments

View all comments
 
  • OchreBunyip says:

    08:15am | 30/12/11

    Unfortunately the US government only has a hammer in its toolbox and every problem looks like a nail. If they learned some diplomacy, or practiced what they cunningly conceal they know, then maybe their increased presence on Australian bases would be a good idea. At the moment they are as… Read more »

  • stephen says:

    08:33pm | 29/12/11

    Indonesia’s defense exercizes with Beijing would be effective if they were not done on one of their - the latter’s - trains. Otherwise, it should be done, from the Indonesian side,  on old wooden boats, the captain should be local - approved, of course - the Chinese subs should be… Read more »

 

Defence Minister Stephen Smith may see the first female body come back from the frontlines in Afghanistan and rue the day he peeled back the discriminatory laws that stopped women from taking up the most dangerous roles.

Women are not always weaker than men. Pics: AFP and AP

But he probably won’t. He probably won’t be Defence Minister and he probably won’t have implemented the changes before Australia withdraws from Afghanistan.

And, because he’s a fairly intelligent sort of bloke, he’ll probably have thought through the squeamishness of letting women do dangerous jobs and realised that’s what you do in a liberal, non-discriminatory society, even if it means poor press if things go to shit.

Latest 2 of 349 comments

View all comments
 
  • GB says:

    01:24pm | 06/10/11

    Women don’t belong where the bad guys can get them! The bad guys do terrible things to their own women/boys/goats, so why would a woman want to potenially allow herself to be exploited as a PW and suffer at the hands of people who see them (women) as nothing?? Some… Read more »

  • Sick of the BS says:

    03:55am | 01/10/11

    Hit the nail on the head brother! Read more »

 

As another Australian family endures the soul-destroying grief of the loss of a young son in Afghanistan - the fourth in a week -  the debate about the nation’s role in the campaign has shifted into fraught territory.

The coffins of Lance Corporal Andrew Jones and Australian Army Pilot Marcus Case

Some surveys show that the majority of Australians want the troops to be brought home immediately. Our political leaders say we must hold our nerve and harden our resolve for more losses in the weeks ahead.

Given that only two of the four latest casualties, Sgt Brett Wood and special-forces combat engineer Rowan Jaie Robinson, were killed in action fighting the Taliban the bipartisan position is the right one for a host of reasons. 

Latest 2 of 189 comments

View all comments
 
  • Zabrina says:

    07:15am | 15/06/11

    And I thought I was the sensible one. Thanks for settnig me straight. Read more »

  • Dan says:

    12:59pm | 11/06/11

    Well said,. Read more »

 

In 2006 I spent a couple of days at the Australian Defence Force Academy.

Looks innocent now, but after the lights go out…

I inspected its organised dormitories (where male and female cadets shared the same buildings - but separate rooms). It’s like an upmarket youth hostel with communal kitchen and bathrooms at the end of each hallway. While there, I fired weapons, ate in the mess and spoke to staff including officers, professors and historians.  It’s an impressive place. 

ADFA at first glance looks like a tidy university, but walk into the bookshop and titles like Knife Fighting Techniques by inmates at Folsom Prison remind you this is a different world. This is a frat house with guns.

Latest 2 of 172 comments

View all comments
 
  • Tory Shepherd

    Tory Shepherd says:

    11:24pm | 14/04/11

    Hi again - I’m hereby closing off comments. It’s just getting nastier and not at all constructive. Sorry! Until next time… Read more »

  • P. White says:

    10:38pm | 14/04/11

    Wow…...Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong….the SASR, are an entity in themselves…. You have no idea my friend. The Australian platoon commanders are doing a bloody great job overseas….this highlights their training and professionalism….civilians pull your heads in. This is simply disgracful. Read more »

 

The reputation of the defence force has once again been tarnished by its personnel behaving badly. A defence force cadet has allegedly filmed himself having sex with another cadet and broadcasting it to his peers in an adjacent room.

The 18-year-old female RAAF cadet spoke of her sense of betrayal and abuse on Tuesday as the federal police and Defence investigators launched an investigation. She alleges she had consensual sex with the fellow cadet who was broadcasting their moment of intimacy by webcam to his mates in a separate room.

UPDATE: Defence Minister Stephen Smith said this afternoon that the ADF will not tolerate conduct that was sexist, vilified women or was indecent or uncivilised. He also said it was possible the female cadet could face disciplinary action.

Latest 2 of 398 comments

View all comments
 
  • GoldCoaster says:

    01:36pm | 20/07/11

    Sorry to bring you the truth Bbender - no one in 1983 was discharged - they were all reinstated and the COMDT directed by the Minister to impose a lesser sentance - 21 63 as I recall.  Yes I was there too. Read more »

  • lee says:

    02:22pm | 13/04/11

    Yet you don’t know what AIRN means? Interesting. Are you one of those guys that dresses up in someone elses medals on ANZAC day and tells stories about “the war?” Read more »

 

“We sleep soundly in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm.”

“Ragheads’‘, “dune coons’‘, “sand niggaz’’ and “smelly locals’‘. Last night we were exposed to ADF soldiers with experience in Afghanistan acting in prejudicial, discriminatory, racist ways. That is what we call it in the civilian world.

A group of soldiers, some who have served overseas in contemporary conflicts, and apparently some who are serving, have allegedly posted their discontent on the social networking site Facebook. They have expressed their disdain, their hatred of the Afghanis, their racist and pejorative perspective of those they are charged to ‘liberate’ and their insubordination to their boss, Lieutenant General Gillespie.

Latest 2 of 242 comments

View all comments
 
  • Bill says:

    12:02pm | 02/03/12

    I agree. Go “over there” do your job which by the way for an Infantryman is to seek out and close with the enemy,to KILL or capture him to seize and to hold ground by day or night regardless of season weather or terrain….You Mr Wadham are an ex Infantryman… Read more »

  • deedeewhy says:

    08:54am | 31/03/11

    Yes, the Japanese did all that but they certainly paid for it by being bombed the shit out of by the americans during wii, literally killing thousands of women, old men and children, so they have paid their dues tenfold, haven’t they been punished enough without you lot slagging off… Read more »

 

The stomach clenches with a cold nausea. The lip curls in disgust. It’s the same visceral reaction I had to pictures like the one below that emerged from Abu Ghraib; the images that made the idea of winning hearts and minds in Iraq a cruel joke.

Private Lynndie England holding a leash attached to a detainee at the Abu Ghraib prison in Baghdad, Iraq, 2003. Pic: AP

Now, Der Spiegel has published three pictures of US soldiers, posing with the bodies of civilians they allegedly killed.  One grins. The German news magazine says it has thousands more ‘trophy shots’.

The soldiers are described as ‘rogue’ – as opposed to ‘sanctioned’. But of course this is just another one-off atrocity. Isn’t it? Just Americans, right?

Not right. Not one off.

Latest 2 of 156 comments

View all comments
 
  • brendan says:

    12:02am | 29/03/11

    tory, while i have no issues with anyone expressing their point of view as you have made with this article, and many others have made in comments ive just noticed reading through that their are alot off disillusions about the army, i am thinking that mayby for your next piece… Read more »

  • Averill says:

    01:10pm | 25/03/11

    What on earth do we expect of out soldiers? We send them out to bomb and kill ‘the enemy’ and expect them to say nice things about them? Grow up you lot. If you don’t like it YOU go out there and see how you fare. I am damn sure… Read more »

 

I read with glee this week the news that the Rudd government is reviewing the role of women in the Defence Force.

Shouldn't you be baking me a pie?

For some reason this always gets me riled.

Call me a bra-burning feminist with hairy under-arms and a Subaru if you like, but it appears to me that men don’t want women in the military because they are scared of themselves.

Latest 2 of 100 comments

View all comments
 
  • Craig says:

    12:11pm | 12/04/11

    I know some female medics who skipped the sugar pill, and only take the hormone pill to stop their periods.  These ladies also had to sign away their lives for deployment, years latter they were both medically discharged for various reasons. Medics are still poges dear, you never served have… Read more »

  • Kyle says:

    12:55pm | 29/10/09

    @ suze,  quite a few comments up you posted this “Consider childbirth or even Rape, women are very resilient and can be put through overwhelming trauma and survive through it.  Suicide rate is higher among males which says something about the psychological strength of women.” Just the slightest bit of… Read more »

 

It is safe to assume that Australia has the only high court in the world to have an important case of constitutional and military law decided over an incident of “teabagging.”

Teabags in a more appropriate context

Following the High Court’s decision in Lane v Morrison on the illegitimacy of the Australian Military Court, the practice of “teabagging” will be forever etched in the legal lexicon of this country.

While Big Brother’s turkeyslapping incident introduced us to genital based attempts at humour taking hold of the national agenda, turkeyslapping was only brought up in Parliament while teabagging made it all the way to the High Court - and won.

Latest 2 of 10 comments

View all comments
 
  • Peter from Sydney says:

    08:41am | 30/08/09

    The thing was a close call. French CJ almost did not give it a run. Now they have to wake up to the hangover they have created for themselves, and move ever so slightly, to the position that any Court constituted by one Officer, appointed no matter how by a… Read more »

  • Jack Tar says:

    10:05am | 28/08/09

    I’ve been on the wrong end of the old Kangaroo Court a few times myself and know firsthand that a lot of what goes on is hardly justice in any sense of the word. 4 seperate charges where all evidence showed innocent. And yet still charged at the end of… Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Paul Colgan

Greece makes the final and Ireland gets in on a golden ticket. How awkward and embarrassing. Love it. #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Every single #eurovision band is roxette #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

The weird thing about #eurovision is you've got this massive collection of dorks in a room and no one is wearing Spock ears #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Europe has the large hadron collider which is light years ahead of its time and #eurovision, where the eighties never die

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

This concern for Thomson won’t change the script

This concern for Thomson won’t change the script

Under pressure himself over his crusade against Craig Thomson, Tony Abbott has moved to present a softer…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter