Today Kevin Rudd will hold his first Community Cabinet of this election year, bringing his road show to Adelaide, no doubt with much fanfare and pageantry. According to recent news reports it also comes at not insignificant cost with taxi and hire cars fares alone clocking in at $10,000 plus for the Labor promoting talkfests.

Is Kev up the creek without a paddle: Peter Macmullin in The Advertiser

If Kevin Rudd is serious about responding to community concerns there are a number of key issues he simply cannot ignore or baffle his way out of with his usual unintelligible answers.  He must tackle these issues head on if these visits are to be of any benefit.

First and foremost for South Australians and anyone who cares about the health of our rivers and river communities is our ongoing water crisis. It is clear that Kevin Rudd has not managed to ‘end the blame game’ on water as he promised. His so-called historic agreement reached in 2008 is riddled with so many loopholes and concessions to the States that he clearly should go back to the drawing board if he is serious about attaining real national management of the Murray Darling.

It is a travesty that many vital water-saving infrastructure projects Kevin Rudd described as urgent in 2007 haven’t been started, let alone completed. I would have thought urgent priority projects would be, well, urgent and a priority – not left waiting for years on end while our water crisis only gets worse.

I often wonder how Kevin Rudd expects to get 180 countries to agree to an international agreement to solve climate change when he can’t even get four state governments, run by his Labor mates, to agree to a workable solution to the problems in the Murray Darling Basin?

While Kevin Rudd has endlessly focused on an Emissions Trading Scheme that will send jobs overseas and do little to actually reduce global carbon emissions, he has abandoned real action on climate change by slashing solar rebates.

Worst of all he is actively blocking developing countries from taking direct action to cut their carbon emissions – why ban India from buying our uranium so they can develop clean energy sources and end their reliance on coal?

The boost to uranium mining would not only boost jobs and exports but would also deliver a tax windfall that could be used to start paying back the enormous debt burden Kevin Rudd has already racked up.

When Labor came to office they had billions in the bank and a budget position that was the envy of governments around the world. Kevin Rudd is now on course to rack up an even bigger debt on the nation’s credit card – and it’s the future of the next generation that he has put down as collateral.

Kevin Rudd has embarked on billions of new spending with waste and mismanagement par for the course. $200 million wasted on rorts and overcharging in the bungled pink batts program, millions wasted on the now abandoned grocery watch and fuel watch, not to mention billions wasted in blowouts, mismanagement and overcharging in the schools stimulus debacle!

All of that is money we will all be paying off with higher taxes, higher interest rates and less money for services in the future for years to come.

Health may be one of the areas where Labor’s debt cripples its ability to follow through on its election promises. In 2007 the state of our hospitals was so bad that Kevin Rudd promised to seize control of them by the middle of 2009 if they hadn’t improved, saying “Its time for someone to put up their hand and take responsibility. I am prepared to do it.”

Its 2010 now and our hospitals are more stressed than ever. Strangely, Mr Rudd’s hands seem to be firmly in his pocket – and his wallet is missing in action.

The much heralded education revolution has not reduced class sizes, improved teaching standards or fundamentally altered the way subjects are taught.

Instead we get the computers in school program that was meant to provide every secondary student with a laptop, but even with a budget blowout of $800 million we are nowhere near the promised result.

Then there’s the Building the Education Revolution debacle. Who ever would have thought a revolution would come in the form of standardised kit buildings offered on a take it or leave it basis? Knock down a gym to build barely bigger gym. Knock down 4 classrooms to build 4 classrooms. Contract expensive operators to build these projects when locals have quoted to do it for a fraction of the price? Funny kind of ‘revolution’…

Of course Mr Rudd has revolutionised border protection policies. He’s been so successful that he’s attracted nearly 80 illegal boat arrivals with 3000 plus people on board. He’s even done special deals with some of those intercepted to help attract more arrivals in future. Perhaps he could explain how he expects his open-door approach will maintain public support for a healthy immigration program?

Mr Rudd, when you address your hand picked audience at your taxpayer funded Community Cabinet tonight I hope that you will give some straight answers to these key issues. After two years of spin, mismanagement and delay its time for action. As you might once have said yourself, the buck stops with you.

73 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Margaret Gray says:

      05:05am | 20/01/10

      Has anyone measured the carbon footprint of these obscene palavers?

      Or the quantum of hot air generated?

      Will Kevin be reading passages from his latest ‘book’ to the raptured cognoscenti?

      Will somebody be counting the number of times Kevin says “I…”?

      So many questions.

    • persephone says:

      06:30am | 20/01/10

      Simon

      1. Kevin Rudd never promised to ‘end the blame game’ in relation to the MD Basin, so it would be nice if you stopped making things up.

      2. It is a travesty the Liberals - who were in power for most of the present drought - didn’t do any infrastructure works on the MDB at all.

      3. The problem is apparently so urgent for your party that it’s prepared to wait until 2013 to do anything about it.

      4. No he didn’t slash solar rebates, the program ran out of money because it was so popular. I think it exceeded its targets, as promised in the 2007 election, something like 10 times.

      Oh, and btw, if you want a rebate on solar hot water, it’s still available.

      5. When Labor came into power, there wasn’t a GFC. The debt you keep banging on about saved thousands of jobs and put us in the strong position, relative to the rest of the world, that we are now.

      Much easier to pay off debt when you still have people working who can pay taxes, rather than sitting in dole queues costing the other taxpayers money.

      6. BILLIONS wasted? Stop telling porkies. And list the projects that you don’t think deserve funding, and thus will slash if you get into government.

      If you think the money’s really been wasted, that should be easy.

      7. And your alternatives are——?? When you’re in government, you will——-?

    • Macca says:

      09:00am | 20/01/10

      Persephone

      The article was about following up on promises, i.e. the role of a government. The role of the opposition is to hold Governments accountable, exactly what Simon is attempting to acheive here.

      If you’re happy with the current MD situation, fine, but I’m guessing from the above rant you’re not, and all that does is demonstrate your highly blinkered acceptance of Rudd’s spin.

      Re: no.5, thats rubbish, the only reason we escaped a recession is because China kept buying stuff we dig out of the ground for large sums of money, mostly due to their stimulus packages. You want to pat somone on the back for keeping BlueCollar Australia in jobs, thank them.

      Re: 7, http://www.theaustralian.com.au/politics/full-text-of-tony-abbotts-address-to-the-sydney-institute/story-e6frgczf-1225819327681

    • Wayne Hutchins says:

      09:57am | 20/01/10

      persephone, your blind faith in your leader is making me gag again. Just admit he has not done what he committed to in the run up to the last election. Blind Freddy can see it so waffling crap like you do just makes things worse. I voted for the clown last time but he has let me down. Only a fool, stooge or someone on the payroll could think any different.

    • Trent says:

      11:08am | 20/01/10

      I’m glad there are atleast a few sensible people left to put ‘kruddwashed’ persephone back in his place!

    • Fog Badger says:

      11:11am | 20/01/10

      I hear KRudd is blaming Howard for the need to be unpopular in this year’s budget.

      What a dick.

    • Rob says:

      12:11pm | 20/01/10

      JHo tried persephone, remeber all those State Premiers getting all antsy about it?

      Remind me, which party were they from?

    • Adam says:

      03:22pm | 20/01/10

      I assume Simon is from the liberal party which should be prominently displayed in the article above. But why the allegiance to a political party? IMO I only ever choose between the lesser of 2 evils and by the public constantly choosing between the two partys we reach a sort of equilibrium where neither party can do too much harm to the country (or any good).

      The worse thing Rudd did was spend the rediculous amount on combating the GFC but somehow did not manage to fund many important infrastructure jobs already planned and ready to go.

    • Paul H says:

      10:28pm | 20/01/10

      Simon, are you for real or are you on a media spin payroll of the loony left? If you think that the insulation rorts are a good thing or the schools building projects are worth the money that I am paying for, then you obviously live in la la land. Regardless of who did or did mot do previously, the matters covered are in the present and Kevin 707 has done squat to address the issues. No amount of blame shifting or finger pointing will alter the fact that he is all talk and no action.

    • steve says:

      06:40am | 20/01/10

      The electorate gave Gough Whitlam a kick in the pants many years ago. It resoundingly voted them down after a bit over 3 years after they voting them into power with much fan fare and adoration. There is a possibility that the electorate will do it again to Kirrabilly Kev for all the same reasons.
      Waste and mismanagement, Huge debt.
      All talk and no action.
      The reality not living up to the rhetoric.
      The education revolution gave out a truck load of computers to high schools students but the schools has to pay for the power connections, band width and software licences from their scant excess cash. Hence some of the revolutionary computers are still in their boxes gathering dust under lock and key.
      The best we get from the Rudd Govt is announcements and spin, symbolism and rhetoric, they throw money around like a drunken sailor on shore leave but the reality will hit a few swinging voters when the bankcard has to be paid back
      Remember folks Paul Keating was elected into power by less than 1500 votes in a handful of swinging seats.

    • acker says:

      07:08am | 20/01/10

      I hope neither political party’s cabinet or shadow party blinks and offers support to the barbaric teaching union, which is attempting to stop Australian parents measuring benchmarked performances of their kids and their schools.
      For cripes sake enough is enough as this shameful ANU study shows

      http://econrsss.anu.edu.au/~aleigh/pdf/SchoolProductivity_media.pdf

      I hope both party’s stop the teachers union from hijacking what should be the basic right of every parent, to benchmark their childs and childs school performance.

    • T.Chong says:

      07:10am | 20/01/10

      Come on Right Punchers, wheres Simons cheer squad?
      Last time Liberal Senator Birmingham wrote a piece, so many here were exalting its even handiness, common sense, and lack of bias.
      Funny stuff.

    • Gloria says:

      07:11am | 20/01/10

      I’ll never understand how Kevin Rudd gets away with all his stand up prepared speaches, and doesn’t have to answer the questions Australians are interested in. Remember how annoyed he looked at a news conference during the Oceanic Viking saga when an off the cuff question was fired at him by one brave journo, the anger that came over his face was unmistakeable, it also happened while he was launching his kiddies book last week when another brave journo did it to him, his eyes and face went steely and his co writter jumped in and laughed the question off for him. Tony Abbot can take the off the cuff hard questions and personal digs regarding him and his credibility but Rudd and journos seem to think he is above that. All his announcements are about the future in 2020 or 2050 when he will not be around to be judged on them, not about what he is going to achieve now, and they are usually futile announcements stating the obvious whith out telling us how he plans to achieve them.

    • Andrew G says:

      07:16am | 20/01/10

      Simon stop trying so hard to be another Christopher Pyne with uninspired and uninsightful writings. Rather than catalogue others research you should come up with something original and of substance Simon.

    • T.Chong says:

      11:14am | 20/01/10

      Keep up the good work old son. Must head out for our communes meat free , union sourced, commie red tofu burgers.
      Having a laugh ,lot more preferrable to the usual name calling and hate some seen to indulge in too easily.

    • Muzz says:

      07:25am | 20/01/10

      Rudd is the best actor since Bette Davis.

    • Old Clive says:

      07:32am | 20/01/10

      Intereresting article, you don’t sound like a Rudd supporter or a labor voter, but apart from that, do you have a solution to the problem,. I doubt that anyone taking water from any river would like to see anyone else suffer. They all think that it is their right to take from what is flowing past their property. Water is the most important part of all our lives, we can’t live without it. Politics is a dirty game, critisizing your opponet when you don’t have the answer to the problem seems to win votes from the people who can’t think things through, but that is also a fact that some of us intellectuals have to live with.

    • welcome to 1984 says:

      08:35am | 20/01/10

      “Hand picked” audience at a “community cabinet”?
      What’s the point of more BS?

      This is as bad as the NObama teleprompted speeches to adoring *fainting*  “hand picked” audiences. Why do 99.9% of all journalists seem to be in a coma with these two? Why are the media giants backing these socialist puppets?

      I’d like to see politicians be required to hold regular community forums or “town hall type” meetings. Where they are held to account, face to face by the general public. I think this is the least they should be expected to do in this age of media spin and manipulation.

      I’ve had enough of Rudd and the Greens, I have NO idea how he continues to poll well. I guess the sheeple are also in a coma. Wish everyone would wake up.

    • JT says:

      08:35am | 20/01/10

      Will Rudd duck questions at Community Cabinet today?

      Is the pope Catholic?

    • paulh says:

      08:53am | 20/01/10

      You could put Mr Rudd in a room full of mirrors and he would still talk himself stupid.These community cabinets are a costly publicity stunt and attempt by Rudd to convince the public he is actually doing something, copied off Mr Beattie and look where he ended up.

    • mountcross says:

      08:58am | 20/01/10

      I believe that Australia has never been in better hands politically what with the excellent government of Kevin Rudd guiding us deftly through the gfc. I live in Brisbane where Kevin comes from and here in qld we have another excellent alp goverment with Anna Bligh in charge. The LNP have tried hard to oust her but 3 times lawrence Sprinborg has been rejected by us qld voters. Now federally we have leader number 3 is it, lost count, from the Liberals having a go at our hero Kevin and not making much of a dent. The pensioners of australia are very grateful for the help kevin has given them and will pay him back at the polls by voting for him whereas Abbott spoke against the rises in the pension that not being a wise move was it. No we are lucky to have the alp firmly in charge in australia.

    • Bruce says:

      09:24am | 20/01/10

      I beg to differ. Financially we are worse off than we were 2 years ago. Dont believe me, check out the value of your superannuation from where it was 2 years ago. As for the queensland government, it runs a close second to the NSW labor government as being the most incompetent in Australia in living memory. In regards to pensioners, any increases have already been stripped with increase costs in electricity (21%) increase in NSW), grocery and petrol costs etc etc. No doubt kevin rudd will be elected next time, we now like our politicians who are soft and smiley and promise things 10 and 15 years into the future.

    • persephone says:

      11:31am | 20/01/10

      What part of ‘Global Financial Crisis’ don’t you understand, Bob?

      Your super would have been even worse if it hadn’t been for the government’s quick actions.

      Oh, and pensioners get extra money specifically to help with utility costs.

    • AJ says:

      09:00am | 20/01/10

      Evidently Simon believes that countries that don’t sign the Non-Proliferation Treaty should have free access to uranium.

      Great idea, Simon, no, really.

    • Macca says:

      09:10am | 20/01/10

      @AJ, Fair argument, but you can’t have your cake and eat it too. Reducing global carbon emissions will require a collective effort and forever selling Coal to India and China is unlikely to elicit excellent reductions

    • Phil says:

      12:43pm | 20/01/10

      AJ

      Good ALP work book tactics son. Whatever It Takes. SPIN SPIN SPIN

      Maybe not give them unlimited access, but as has been mentioned in these pages previously, it would not be hard to monitor Uranium Sales, create a great big economy of selling it ready for Power Use and only supplying more when independantly audited usage of the fuel for power generation was provided, or take the spent rods back and dispose of them correctly.

      To tell us on one hand that the planet is in peril and about to end, then supply brown coal to India is obsurd and pure hypocracy.

    • wolf says:

      09:16am | 20/01/10

      An interesting article Simon, unfortunately so many people seem to be turned off from what you have written because of the damage the Howard government did to the liberal brand.
      Taking some of the themes you have outlined above such as the need to restore the murray darling river system, the need to move from coal based power to something else and the need to rejuvinate our health system perhaps you could campaign under the banner of ‘regeneration’ rather than as liberals.
      You may need to do something about the colour too.  Orange would be more eyecatching than the traditional liberal blue, and would also help to further disassociate you from the Liberal brand sullied by Howard.
      Of course, this strategy would present the risk that someone could move into the gap by calling themselves a ‘liberal’ (in the small ‘l’ sense) but I’m sure a couple of well placed phone calls could smooth that over.
      What do you think, is it worth a try?

    • D'oh says:

      09:23am | 20/01/10

      @ Persephone:

      1. He did promise to end the blame game between states & fed.  MDB are state issues.  As such, MDB falls under that blame game

      2. It is a travesty that the Labor State goverments - who were in power for most of the present drought - didn’t do any infrastructure works on the MDB at all.

      3. State elections are coming up.  If Liberals are voted in they will take the initiative.

      4. Solar rebates were poorly planned and thus ran out of money.  Solar hot water rebates are a good idea and it is good that they are still around.

      5. Australia survived the GFC because it had reserves so meticulously established by Howard & Costello.  This government managed to decimate that and put us in the red in less than a year.  And don’t bang on about the mining boom, the states rode through that boom too and lok where they are…..

      6. Oh dear, where do I start?  $900 cash handout, school halls blown budget, aforementioned rebates, xxxxx-watch (take your pick), consultative fees budget blown etc etc

      @T.Chong: “Come on Right Punchers, wheres Simons cheer squad?”

      Busy working, but I just had to bite wink.  It is like a drug really.

      Rudd has a lot of questions to dodge, list shall be forthcoming.

    • persephone says:

      11:47am | 20/01/10

      1. In relation to Health, specifically. Not the MDB. Doesn’t mean he shouldn’t act on this, and he is, but the blame for inaction should be shared around (in this case).

      2. The Victorian government has been very active in this area, but yes, NSW, QLD & SA haven’t.

      So it was disappointing that Howard agreed to give those guys far more money than he was prepared to give to Victoria. Another case where doing nothing means that you benefit in the long run!

      3. Yeah. They’ve really got some great policy solutions out there. Ballieu will build a dam - oh, no he wont’; he won’t use the water from the NS pipeline - oh, hang on, yes, he will…

      And the other Lib leaders are just as decisive and policy driven.

      4. No, they were incredibly popular, far more so than anyone expected. Sensible budgetting (needed, apparently, to pay back our debt) was thus necessary.

      5. Reserves of $20 billion, not even a drop in the ocean when it comes to what was needed. Now, if Howard and Costello had structured the tax regime properly, we would have been even better off.

      I’ve been banging on about the mining boom? Haven’t noticed.

      Virtually every economist in the world is hailing Australia as a miracle economically and giving the credit to the stimulus spending. Of course, d’oh, you know better.

      6. So you, like Simon, think this was all wasted (despite saying the solar hot water rebate was a good thing).

      For a start, if there has been any wastage, it’s not in the billions, as Simon claimed, which is a ridiculous assertion. And there’s very little evidence there’s been much wastage at all, with the government auditting cost over runs.

      Simon, as a politician seeking election to government, has the responsibility to explain which waste he would cut. He should be prepared to nominate the school halls his government wouldn’t go ahead with, for example.

      And, again, most economists disagree with you that this was money wasted, as would anyone who kept their job when they expected to lose it. The best way for an economy to get out of trouble is for people to keep their jobs, as this means the government can collect tax from them and doesn’t have to pay out to support them.

      Again, if Simon thinks unemployment is better than debt, that’s fine, but he should have the courage to quantify that.

    • Grumbles says:

      12:32pm | 20/01/10

      Mainly in reply to persephone,  there are two things you fail to realize, 1. Currently the libs are in oppositition, it is there job to hold the Government accountable for its promises and prevent the passing of legislation that will negatively affect our way of life, on all accounts since TA took over they have been doing a great job. 2. Labor are in government, it is their job to make things better and meet their election promises. Since Rudd said sorry they have failed on every account. Sure the GFC happened, do you throw out your promise to be economically conservitive, to maintain the surplus? These were never promised by the Liberals, only by Rudd.

      Of course stimulus spending was needed, but we spent too much, way too much, and on the wrong areas, handing out billions of dollars to people and telling them to spend spend spend is rediculous. Do you think the education revolution has been a success? Thats another Rudd promise, again, never promised by the Liberals.

      Stimulus money is STILL being spent, even tho unemployment is dropping and interest rates are rising. Sure we can highlight the shortcomings of every previous government that has been in office, but really only one matters and thats the one thats in power right now.

      Do you think they should be held accountable?

    • Timfromthetopend says:

      09:26am | 20/01/10

      Will Rudd duck questions at the community cabinet meeting today?

      Quack Quack, are the Kennedy’s gun shy?

    • Timfromthetopend says:

      09:28am | 20/01/10

      Will Rudd duck questions at the community cabinet meeting?

      Does it take a tall dog to make love to giraffe?

    • Anjuli says:

      09:48am | 20/01/10

      What did Rudd give the pensioners ? He gave single pensioners $30 each pay rise but he gave couples $10 BETWEEN them they say a couple can live a cheaply as one well we might be in the same room at some time but we have double the washing and every thing and the $5.80 Pharmaceutical allowance is between us not each like singles ,beside don’t we all have reduced lighting costs due to the low energy globes(tongue in cheek). How about when a single pensioner lives with daughter who earns big bucks does that not count when a single is claiming the pension I think not.

    • iansand says:

      09:48am | 20/01/10

      I think we can market a variation of Buzz Word Bingo.  Party Hack Bingo.  Mr Birmingham and Ms Bishop are the front runners.

      Do you people really think that regurgitating the same standard, negative phrases over and over and over would convince a lobotomised axolotl that you actually have an idea?

    • John says:

      03:34pm | 20/01/10

      its been working for 100 years why change now?

    • Timfromthetopend says:

      09:48am | 20/01/10

      Bruce, you have forgotten the hapless NT Labor government, seven reshuffles in 14 months, clinging to power thanks to an independent. One should not dive headfirst into the state/territory labor talent pool.

    • D'oh says:

      09:51am | 20/01/10

      List of Rudd FAILS! Part 1

      Make questions out of these as you like:

      1.  2020 - 1,000 B&B; minds, $2+m = 9 useable ideas.
      2.  Save the whales – FAIL
      3.  Fight Inflation Genie – Oops GFC
      4.  Taxes up (Gas, Diesel, Transport, Alco pops) – inflationary
      5.  Fuelwatch - cost $21 million – FAIL
      6.  Grocery Watch/Choice – June, 2009 abandoned $13 million election promise – FAIL
      7.  Arresting Iranian leaders – Stunt
      8.  Bank Guarantee - still over 200,000 bank accounts frozen from September 2008 - $25B of savings locked up for possibly 4 years.
      9.  Laptops
      10.  National Broadband Network (from $4b, to $7b to $43 billion) – Experts are now saying it will cost in the region of $20,000 PER CONNECTION
      11.  Cash Splash 1 – borrowed
      12.  Cash Splash 2 – also borrowed = $42 billion
      13.  Work Choices /Fair work – Will cost jobs Awards Back flips – special dispensation for Tourism/Food industry. Horticultural Industry warning new awards will put farmers out of business, eg, casual pickers weekend rates.  - No response from Gillard yet.
      14.  Immigration/Refugees/Asylum Seekers how many boats so far? Need I even mention the Oceanic Viking?
      15.  Defence - cut expenditure & increase weaponry?
      16.  Homeland Security Department – “a non-core promise” broken Nov 28, 2007
      17.  The buck stops with me – so where are you?
      18.  Securing water on the Murray/Darling
      19.  IVF Program – cuts - the caring ALP.
      20.  Medicare/Private Health – rebate not to be touched - key election promise - outright lie
      21.  Dental Scheme – gone – the caring ALP
      22.  Cataract Surgery – costs doubled – the caring ALP
      23.  Superannuation – the government needs it more than you.
      24.  Home Savers Grant - a fizzer, not enough people saving
      25.  First home Owners grant – increased, not aimed to generate building, inflating house prices
      26.  One Stop Super Childcare Centres
      27.  GP Super Clinics - $275 million borrowed – 1 open Palmerston NT, ALP stronghold – FAIL, 3 approved SA – Noarlunga, Playford North, Modbury , all ALP safe seats
      28.  No compulsory University Union Fees – an outright lie voted down
      29.  Worker Share Options, June 2009 – on, off, on, off, on like a light switch – blunder
      30.  Carbon emissions reduction - LPG conversion subsidies being phased out l – June 2009
      31.  Carbon Emissions reduction Part 2 - Household Solar Rebate axed 9/6

    • Bruce says:

      10:18am | 20/01/10

      Wow !! I wonder where the sense of “OUTRAGE” is from the media. Deafening with the sounds of silence !!  I wonder why this is the case?

    • Phil says:

      12:52pm | 20/01/10

      Bruce

      The media is left wing, that or they have done a deal with the devil himself.

      It is a great shame that many in the media choose to just have a go at one side and not report in a balanced way about Rudd and his policy failures.

      For Persophone to simply say Rudd is doing the job is insufficient and as I have always said. He can dupe many of the dumb Australian public who voted for his lies and deception but deep down he knows he is out of his depth. He can lie to us but cant lie to himself about his failures.

      If governments were held accountable in the same way directors are held accountable with similar penalties for misleading and deceptive conduct, labor would be abolished immediately and many of them in Jail. Some of the libs would be with them as well.

      Labor are the best polititions money can buy.

    • D'oh says:

      09:53am | 20/01/10

      Rudd RAILS part 2:

      More questions (and a hell of a lot of dodging):

      32.  Schools Stimulus/? Infrastructure Program – Subject to AG inquiry.
      33.  Ruddbank
      34.  Federal takeover of hospitals by mid 2009 if no improvement. – EPIC FAIL
      35.  Reduce consultancies by $112 million = increase to $800 million (6354 consultancies)
      36.  Govt will pay small business invoices on time = takes a lot longer
      37.  No nuclear Waste Dump NT – election promise – broken June 2008
      38.  $15 million to rural research & development corporations – election promise – broken May 2008.
      39.  A - E reporting on childcare standards & universal pre-school for 4 year olds – election promise – broken June 2009
      40.  ALP Uranium Policy/stance – in tatters.  Garrett approves uranium mine.
      41.  Diplomacy – Japan – biggest customer – FAIL.  India – Uranium contract – FAIL .  USA – conversations (real/imaginary) released to media. China, May 2009 – “difficult to deal with” Australia led Asia Pacific Body – thud.
      42.  Boost funding for aboriginal Legal Aid – lie – actuality = cuts to funding in first budget.
      43.  Scale back Intervention – ignored review recommendations.
      44.  Homes /renovations for indigenous – not one shovel lifted to date
      45.  Digital TV –Conroy, 2008, slash $22m from costs of changeover, figures make no sense – original estimate $16m now to cost $66m
      46.  Cheaper Better Childcare – Govt regulations will see Childcare costs going up by about $1500pa on July 1, 2010
      47.  SORRY! Feb 8, 08. K Rudd
      “We apologise especially for the removal of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children from their families, their communities and their country.”
      Aug 22, 09 The Australian
      “WELFARE workers have swooped on the opal mining town of Lightning Ridge in northwest NSW, removing more than 40 Aboriginal children from decrepit homes in shanty towns….....
      Aboriginal women, stunned by the removals, say it amounts to a “modern-day Stolen Generation”, but the most recent statistics on child removals show Aboriginal children are being taken from their parents in numbers much greater than the Stolen Generations.”
      48.  Skills Program, Sept 2009, The Australian – “Kevin Rudd’s $2bn skills plan in disarray”
      49.  More affordable Housing – October 2009 – prices forecast to go up 20%
      50.  Cheaper Books for Australians – back flip to protectionist policies
      51.  ETS, Versions 1&2;–FAIL senate.
      52.  2007 Rudd promises a new era in cooperation between Federal Government & States. 2009 Rudd loses patience with NSW ALP, Qld Traveston dam.
      53.  Copenhagen conference - EPIC FAIL – CLASSIC COMEDY
      54.  “Ian McPhedran July 26, 2009 11:00pm
      WHEN it comes to chalking up VIP jet bills, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Governor-General Quentin Bryce leave their predecessors in a $5.8 million wake.
      During the six months from June to December last year, the PM Kevin Rudd and Governor-General Quentin Bryce team hit a record of $17.2 million in taxpayer-funded VIP flights – which equals $716,000-a-week.” – Kevin Rudd – Our “Stay at home prime minister”
      55.  Relaxed restrictions on foreign ownership elevate house prices.
      56.  FOI review/results. – Open and transparent government promised 2007 by 2009 promise = increased FOI requests and increased rejections of same = markedly increased secretive Government.
      57.  Blunder – superannuation cuts for ADF personnel.  Combet claims difficulty in straitened times = tough luck.
      58.  “Obscene” homelessness numbers = War on Homelessness = increased Homeless numbers for 2010.

    • Randal says:

      09:59am | 20/01/10

      1. Rudd promised action on the MD Basin prior to the election and when he came into office, we have seen none, just rhetoric. It is time he honored his pledge of “the buck stops here” and steps in to remove the State bias from the issue.

      2. John Howard put together a 10B action plan on the MD Basin as a policy (completely supported but not enacted by then opposition leader Rudd) in the lead up to the 2007 election, the government investigated whether they could seize control from the States under the constitution and had they won the election would have pushed for action, a takeover or if necessary a referendum. The lack of action of the MD Basin lies squarely in the hands of the ALP State governments and now Rudd.

      3. I think point 2 addresses this quite adequately.

      4. Yes they did slash solar rebates as they failed to adequately budget for the take up rate, a common occurrence with this government… just look at the mess with batts roll out.

      5. When Labor came into power they where gifted the most stable and prosperous economy in the world, it was the strength of the economy they inherited, plus China continued thirst for our minerals and energy supplies, that spared us the full pain of the GFC. Due to the reckless spending of the Rudd government we will now be in a position for decades where should a global hiccup occur we will feel the full force and we can thank Rudd and Swan for this gift.

      6. Let me see, the cash handout to all Australian’s, building pointless halls at schools as a shrine to Gillard, propping up of the luxury car sector auto sector, over the odds first home buyers grants… need I go on!

      7. We are in opposition and will provide our policies as your illustrious leader would say “In due season”. it is the responsibility of opposition to keep the government accountable, and that we have done in regards to the “Big Fat Tax” and that we will continue to do.

      Of course all policies will be launched prior and during an election campaign, and as you are so interested in what we will be doing, please log onto the below website to keep yourself fully informed:

      http://www.liberal.org.au/

      Hope this helps in dealing with your queries!

    • persephone says:

      12:00pm | 20/01/10

      Covered a lot ot this in my reply to d’oh before, but what the hey…

      1. Establishment of the MDB Authority, massive buy backs of water (over $1 billion worth purchased so far), investment in infrastructure, extra water freed up for lower lakes…etc.

      2. Er, no. Howard knew what the position was - he couldn’t take over water without a referendum. He never proposed one. Instead, he tried to bribe the states to hand over their rights to water. Unfortunately, he offered Victoria less than the infrastructure was worth, let alone the value of the water in the system.

      3. No, it doesn’t. If the problem is urgent, then you need to act in 2010, not 2013.

      4. See answer to d’oh.

      5. Not according to most economists internationally, who subscribe Australia’s position to the effects of the stimulus. Not saying that having a good basic economy, as set up by Keating, didn’t help. At least Howard had the sense not to muck it around too much, though he could have left us with a more resilient tax regime.

      6. Doesn’t prove ‘billions’ of waste, which is Simon’s contention. Again, see my answer to d’oh.

      7. ROFL. Keeping governments accountable does not mean blindly opposing everything they do, but pointing out flaws and suggesting alternative courses of action.

      But at least you admit to being a hack. Simon too busy to answer us mere mortals himself?

    • Randal says:

      01:14pm | 20/01/10

      You are getting desperate are you not persephone.

      1.  The current policy in relation to MDB is a complete disaster and failure by Rudd to ‘end the blame game between the States’ a verse he trumpeted when the current failed policy on the MDB was announced, so you probably need to do a little research there my friend, and I think the term ‘hack’ would best suit your rants.

      2. The Howard government sought legal advice on whether they could take control without a referendum, more than likely as stick to get the States in line, unfortunately the do nothing Rudd government took control and despite announcing a policy to tackle the problem in 2008 we are still nowhere… just another empty promise.

      3. As for timing, it is very hard to tackle a problem from the Opposition benches and by announcing such a strong stance, the Opposition is doing all it can to drive the government to act. I am not sure what more you expect them to do and perhaps you should tackle your mate Rudd on this issue, as the ball is firmly in his court.

      4. Perhaps with a few less Julia Gillard Memorial Halls, they would have found the money to fully fund the Solar Rebate program. Then again what else can you expect from a government that acts before it thinks.

      5. You must read very different financial magazines to me, the focus on “most economists” has been on the stability of our economy and in particular the finance industry, meaning the shortfall in cash lending to business did not affect Australia, as it did globally with international underfunded lenders causing a credit crunch.

      6. As for the billions, well hundreds of billions let’s be honest, that is a debt our children and more than likely their children will wear and has set us down the road of the US economy and that is not a place we wish to be. Unfortunately in politics there seems to be one common denominator there ALP=DEBT.

      7. As you would well know the opposition passes the vast majority of government legislation without debate, it is only the contentious issues that require further scrutiny, amendments, and in extreme cases an attempt to block the passage in the Parliament forcing these issues to be determined at an election. This ensures there is complete transparency and wide ranging community debate and is the role of every opposition.

      As for Simon Birmingham, I am certain that he is busy holding the government to account on its many failures and working with his colleagues to put together a strong policy platform for this nation, a platform that will ensure that this failed Rudd government is thrown into the one term wilderness with the likes of other failed PM’s Keating and Whitlam.

    • Rob says:

      01:59pm | 20/01/10

      and the batts keep rolling out.

    • Brad Coward says:

      05:08pm | 20/01/10

      @persophone….stop it !  Stop it now !  You’ll go blind, I tell you !  You might blindly believe all of the crap that you go on with, but unfortunately, the sleeping giant that is the Australian electorate is starting to wake up…even without fair and unbiased reporting by the lefty media.

    • Anjuli says:

      09:59am | 20/01/10

      I wonder if the community knows what is going on with the new nurses that are coming out of the universities ,they are being shafted by the economic crisis that’s what here in Perth the richest state the hospitals are canceling the Post Grad intake which leaves all of them unable to get jobs and that is only February"s graduates there will another 2 lots finishing by December of this year the hospitals will not employ them without this experience so where does that leave them after 4 years how must they feel ,like my daughter who feels gutted after taking 6 years to get there due to having a planned pregnancy .I am surprised by the lack of Journalistic interest about their plight.we here when the teacher have a complaint loud and clear but the nurses not a dickie bird.

    • put nurses back in nursing homes says:

      04:08pm | 20/01/10

      NO - the community does not know the nurses are being shafted - but eventually they will. Having just had my parent enter a nursing home - I was alarmed that there are almost NO nurses on staff in a “nursing home” these days. New migrants with poor English fresh from completing short carer courses at TAFE, make up the bulk of the staffing. One or two qualified nurses sit in the office doing all the paperwork.

      When you realise how short sighted the nurse training initiatives are - it is REALLY scary. No one gives a crap until it affects them directly of course - but Australian nursing homes are one place you DO NOT want to find yourself in. With an aging population I assume KRudd is planning lots of jobs for these millions of new migrants instead of training Australian nurses. Disgraceful.

    • Karen says:

      10:00am | 20/01/10

      Rudd always talks about his vision for the future. Hardly profound stuff, I can even manage to do that. I’m more interested in what he’s going to do while he is in Government.. Talking about visions so far off into the future obviously gets him off the hook for accepting responsibility for anything now.

    • Deliah says:

      10:12am | 20/01/10

      D’on re: no 56. You are spot on with your comments on FOI. Unfortunately the Rudd government does not see to understand the term accountability. Also, no 2. I hope someone at the community cabinet asks about the whaling issue which remains a hot topic of public interest.

    • Wayne Hutchins says:

      10:14am | 20/01/10

      Come on D’oh, surely you can get it up to 100. We should then send it off to the prime Ministers office and see if he can explain any of it. It does really highlight just how bad this government is but just how well they control the media. You can see it, I can see it but for some reason the media can’t or don’t want to.

    • Deliah says:

      10:32am | 20/01/10

      Wayne, D’oh will be lucky to get an acknowledgement of his correspondence, let alone honest answers. Again, it is that accountability thing. I am still waiting for a reply to written questions eight months later.

    • D'oh says:

      10:43am | 20/01/10

      LOL I am sure I can, I actually had to trim it back to fit in the 5000 character limit.

      As it was I had to split it into two posts.

      If I yhave missed any FAILS, please feel free to add to them.

    • NP says:

      02:26pm | 20/01/10

      D’Oh, another failure by Rudd is consideration of microeconomics with two clear examples:

      1) The alcopops tax, which was mitigated by the substitution effect. Alcohol is an inelastic good, so trying to distinguish and tax specific types of alcohol is just lunacy, consumers switched to straight spirits.

      2) The ETS: Fails to consider that power is a highly inelastic good; a large price change will yield only a small (if at all) change in consumer behaviour.

      People are best motivated by incentives, not taxes. But Rudd would know this, if he had any inkling of microeconomics. He doesn’t.

      The best PMs are the ones who consider microeconomics, such as Hawke, Keating & Howard. Rudd is very much Whitlam II in my opinion.

    • Julie Kippin says:

      10:27am | 20/01/10

      The reason Kevin Rudd is now talking up his visions for the future is when he put deadlines on anything while he is in office he has failed. Hospital take over june 2009, indigenious housing etc. His media advisers have obviously told him to change tact.

    • Diamantina Dick says:

      11:07am | 20/01/10

      The evidence is in, the question is whether the Australian electorate is a whole are as fickle and easily distracted as the NSW one where the ALP tactics have worked a treat for 15 years. NSW deserves everything it is currently getting, perhaps more.

      NSW have just been presented with the equivilent of a cute fur seal which they will be asked to club (or not) next year, wonder what they will do?

      So long as the electorate is prepared to be placated by spin and distraction, the ALP will survive, it is their stock in trade.  Pathetic appologists such as those who frequent on this blog aid and abet. Don’t rock the boat, we like the way it is sinking now.

    • Trent says:

      11:12am | 20/01/10

      Maybe Rudd should do something of substance instead of hollow words, and then Simon wouldn’t have to spend his time writing at length about the many lies & unfulfilled promises of the Rudd government…

    • persephone says:

      12:04pm | 20/01/10

      Well, if I was a staffer, I’d have been aware of that press release, wouldn’t I?

      And he says ‘end the blame game between the states’ not ‘between the States and the Commonwealth’, which is what the original MDB comment was about.

    • Martin G says:

      12:34pm | 20/01/10

      Read it again, mate.

      “This is central to our commitment to end the blame game between CANBERRA and the states”.

    • Martin G says:

      11:15am | 20/01/10

      Andrew G, this is as opposed to the spin-addicted, substance-lacking KRUDD with his uninspired and uninsightful leadership, with all the broken promises as listed in Mr Birmingham’s article.

    • Moreton says:

      11:18am | 20/01/10

      Just saw Ruddy on the ABC news “by 2050 blah blah blah”, he is looking sillyer by the day.

    • Lucia says:

      11:25am | 20/01/10

      Rudds latest spin line after being continually attacked about his concern for his popularity is “some of my decisions may not be popular, but they are decisions that need to be made” oh please Kev, nice try but it doesn’t wash. You’ll need to do better than that.

    • persephone says:

      11:33am | 20/01/10

      I meant Bruce, of course!!

    • Damo Nails says:

      12:16pm | 20/01/10

      I am actually enjoying watching Saint Kevin fail miserably in every respect of his 2007 election platform. Funny as that may be, its nowhere near as hilarious as the distinctly innaccurate arguments of those left brave enough to defend him. Whilst it was always going to happen this way, finally (after 2 years of complete inaction and failure) the Media are asking hard questions. It really must hurt the Labor faithful that Howard was so much better and decisive.

    • Harquebus says:

      12:21pm | 20/01/10

      “Australia will not become China’s quarry.” China spent $9billion buying up our quarries last financial year.

    • D'oh says:

      12:32pm | 20/01/10

      @ Persephone:

      1. And what a bang up job they have done on that front hey?
      2. true and acknowledged
      3. As opposed to what has been happening under Labor governments??
      4. Being more popular than expected is poor planning.  To their credit, they turned the tap off in acknowledgement of their error.
      5. So now it is their fault for not saving enough!  Coming off the back of Keatings ridiculous deficits!!  Funny, Rudd is trying to push this spin as well today.  The mining boom comment was not directed at you specifically (it is a popular though flawed argument), I shall express myself clearer next time.
      6. Re the rebate, I was trying to give credit where I feel credit is due.  AS for the rest when you add them all up (even just the school halls blow out and the cash splash alone) it does in fact add up to billions.

      Now, have a go answering the other lists.

    • persephone says:

      03:29pm | 20/01/10

      1. Well, the reality with the MDB is that the problems will only be solved by rain, and lots and lots of it.
      However, by buying up water and investing in infrastructure, the government is putting in the necessary preparation for improving in the system in the long term.

      3. The states are now working together on this, resulting in today’s announcement, for example, of more water being sent down to SA. And see 1.

      4. No it isn’t. Being more popular than expected is being more popular than expected. To their credit, they extended the program considerably once it became evident how popular it was.

      5. No, it’s nobody’s fault the GFC came along. Howard wouldn’t have been prepared for it either. He may not have been so keen to spend to save jobs, however.

      6. Birmingham talked about billions in WASTE not in spending. There was not billions WASTED.

      Don’t have time for your lists, sorry, have to take children to cricket training. Maybe another day….

      If I was paid to do this, however….

    • Jason Jenkins says:

      09:15pm | 20/01/10

      Can’t you guys give each other telephone numbers and argue over the phone instead of invading this space with all your dribble. I’m sure no one apart fron you guys read anything you have to say. You need to get a job instead of spending all day on here taking up space and wasting your time. The Punch was a good place to read other peoples views on topics.

    • Darryl Price says:

      10:05pm | 20/01/10

      In a sad irony, I find K Rudd to be best described as “a drink of water”.

    • Pete says:

      09:23am | 21/01/10

      When will Margaret Gray (1st comment) and other Labor supporters realise that Australia never had a financial crisis. Mr Rudd hid behind this as a way of masking his mismanagement and in doing so gave big companies a free ride at reducing staff levels to shore up their profits. Just blame it on the GFC.
      The PM is considered a joke in international circles. This is best represented by his “sitting” with Prince Willliam. The British news reported him as a staunch republican but one that would never miss a photo opportunity of any kind.

    • Pete says:

      10:05am | 21/01/10

      Sorry Margaret I meant comment no.2…..... my sincere apologies

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

#markwebber just wasted petrol faster than everyone else in monaco #f1

Anthony Sharwood

In my sports column on The Punch tomorrow: why Eurovision was easily the best game on the weekend. Mummy bloggers, you'll like this one!

Daniel Piotrowski

The Logies could learn a lot from Eurovision #lamethings#sbseurovision

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @ellehardytweets: Already despondent about the next fifty one weeks. #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter