The flooding in Pakistan was an unavoidable natural disaster. The measures we take now will decide if we can avoid an ongoing humanitarian disaster.

Picture: Corporal Chris Moore.

Last Thursday I visited Pakistan to inspect the flood damage and the Australian response in Kot Addu, near Multan in the Southern Punjab.

The UN High-Level Meeting on Pakistan today met to discuss the adequacy, or inadequacy, of the international response. This meeting has one challenge – to prevent a natural disaster becoming a humanitarian calamity that could have been avoided.

Even if you are well aware of the facts in Pakistan, the figures are still confronting:

  • 21 million people affected (more than all those affected by the 2004 Boxing Day tsunami, the Pakistan earthquake of 2005 and the Haiti earthquake combined)
  • 10 million people without shelter, and
  • 6 million people dependent on emergency food supplies.

One month after these floods, the damage to crops, homes, roads and the natural environment takes your breath away.

The potential for large scale loss of human life, if water-borne diseases now take off, is frightening.

One field that is high and dry is the soccer field in Kot Addu ‘Camp Cockatoo’; The Australian Medical Task Force facility. Green tents in every direction are filled with military, medical and AusAid staff busy delivering emergency medical aid to thousands of locals.

I went there with Peter Baxter, the Director General of AusAid, to thank nearly 200 Aussies in the business of saving lives each and every day.

I was handed a prescription pack by one of the medical staff. It was empty. They have run out of a new malaria drug Artemisinin that has helped treat many patients with cerebral malaria which is potentially lethal for adults and particularly dangerous for kids. More supplies of this vital drug are on the way to Camp Cockatoo.

Along with the new supplies of Artemisinin, $40 million in additional funds will also provide both immediate relief and support, and longer term help with reconstruction in the Pubjab and other affected areas.

Australia’s efforts are not about being near the top of some league table of do-gooders. We do, however, want to provide leadership for other countries to follow. The rest of the world has to chip in.

Australia’s non-government organisations, like so many humanitarian disasters in the past, have been at the forefront of the response in Pakistan; organisations like World Vision, Care Australia, Caritas and Save the Children.

But the task is still enormous.

Of the new $40 million of Australian Government funding, $9 million will go directly to non-government agencies in the field. They are often the best, with their extended international networks, at getting the aid out and making a difference with speed. And this money starts flowing now.

Apart from basic humanitarian need, and doing the right thing by other members of the human family who have been hit by a disaster, we also have big interests at stake in Pakistan.

Australia needs a stable Pakistan; Pakistan is key to our anti-terrorism efforts in Afghanistan.

What we achieve as governments, as Australians, as compassionate people, in providing an appropriate response will be judged by history.

What is not in question is what has already been achieved by the efforts of our Australian NGOs, volunteers, medical staff and armed forces. All these good people in the field are doing us proud. They are the best ambassadors for Australia.

49 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Eric says:

      03:32pm | 20/09/10

      I’m not a big fan of Pakistan, as my previous comments may have indicated.

      But I’m happy for some small portion of my tax dollars to go to help those people.

      It would be nice if the chattering classes stopped categorising Aussies as bigots, racists and xenophobes. If that was true, we wouldn’t ever help anyone else.

    • Nicole says:

      04:35pm | 20/09/10

      Agreed Eric. Watching these people suffer like this is gut wrenching. It’s unimaginable what they are feeling.

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      09:03pm | 20/09/10

      I wouldn’t help Pakistan if I could avoid it, but since the Govt sees fit to give away our tax dollars to every foreigner who sticks their hand out, we have no choice.

      And, in any case, if Gillard doesn’t do something fairly soon about border protection, the Pakistanis and Afghans will be running *this* country and we won’t have any say at all about where our foreign aid money goes. Or anything else.

    • Phil says:

      09:30am | 21/09/10

      Eric. I wonder how much Kevin and Therese donated.

      As many yesterday said, if Pakistan decided to reduce their army, nuclear weapons program and place their citizens in safer areas, a disaster like this would be minimised next time. It would be like us setting up all communities in bushland and expecting that bushfires will not cause havoc.

      Pakistan is one of the most corrupt countries in the world. Should this stop, we would be happier to have more of our tax dollars help the nation and its people.

    • Denny Crane says:

      03:36pm | 20/09/10

      Kevin,

      You want us to lead the way, and you are saying not a scoring record of who pays, well my friend maybe we could send more cash, but this country has a crippling debt like never before, and who caused it, you and your party.

      We cannot lead the way, in donations, we are 20 million, how about the rich middle eastern countries like Saudi Arabia, Bahrain lead the way for a change, apparently Pakistan knocked back aid from India, so what we should be in turn leading the way i think not.

      Then to try and link the disaster to having a stable Pakistan re the terrorists, so what are you trying to say, if we give aid, terrorists wont attack us, if we dont they would, that is very strange comment, as the Government runs the country, so if we dont give the aid the Government will pass this information onto the terrorists, whom the Pakistan Government are apparently trying to remove.

      We are not responsible for fixing every disaster around the world, yes we help, but shouldnt the help be first and formost to those in Australia, who need help each and every day

    • The Badger says:

      03:59pm | 20/09/10

      Bad form Denny

      This isn’t about national politics, this is about suffering, starvation and disease.

      hope you feel better taking a cheap shot.

    • Steve Putnam says:

      04:17pm | 20/09/10

      We have a smaller debt than any other country at 6% of GDP. You really should consult the Australian Bureau of Statistics before you make these statements of such breath-taking stupidity.
      No, there is no guarantee the terrorists wont attack us, but clearly Rudd is correct in saying it is greatly in Australia’s interest to not allowing Pakistan to descend into chaos.
      I agree with you that the wealthy gulf states should do a whole lot more to ameliorate the sufferings of their co-religionists. Last time I looked it was the ‘infidel’ states: the US, the UK and Australia who had contributed most to the disaster relief.

    • Chris L says:

      06:07pm | 20/09/10

      Denny we all know your dislike for Rudd and Labor, but this was not a political piece and should not be seen as an opportunity to repeat party slogans from either side.

      You do raise a good pont that other richer countries should get involved, but that doesn’t mean we should sit back and wait for them.

    • sachs says:

      09:03pm | 20/09/10

      Agree with you Denny Crane. Govt will make big contributions when most of people will suffer once the rates go up.
      Lived in similar country, whatever help is given.. Not even 2% is going to reach the ones who really need it.
      Besides where are the biggest supporters and saviors of islam gone….must b planning a terrorist attack..

    • RB says:

      09:17pm | 20/09/10

      Now’s the time for compassion Denny, not politics.

    • Azamat says:

      10:17pm | 20/09/10

      the debt is 6% of real GDP, barely crippling like never before. Get your facts right

    • Joan says:

      03:55pm | 20/09/10

      Guess what? You still look and sound like the PM and Gillard looks and sounds like the deputy.  While Gillard and her henchman scrap election promises and haggle with Bob and Oakeshott -you look the statesman every night on TV.-

    • Ghandi says:

      10:00pm | 20/09/10

      ahahaha - a statesman - bwahahaha

    • Zeta says:

      04:05pm | 20/09/10

      It kind of was avoidable. As I understand it, and admittedly my knowledge of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa monsoonal rain patterns is sketchy, but I would have thought in a monsoonal climate in a mountainous region criss crossed with river beds someone, at some time would have thought to build a levee. Or two. Or maybe a dike. Just saying.

      As for Pakistan being some lynch pin in our defence of the region… Pakistan’s ‘efforts’ at fighting the Taliban have been lacklustre at best. The flooded region’s Afghanistan border might as well not exist for all the good the Pakistani military is doing. You got the FATA, the tribal areas running through the Khyber and they’re Taliban strongholds! You got reports of US Special Forces conducting raids on Pakistani territory as though it might as well be in Afghanistan.

      What will end up happening, is what happened in Palestine, Lebanon and Somalia. The supposed ‘evil terrorists’ will turn out to be the only ones able to deploy effective aid relief where it’s needed, while the Government sucks away the cash into buying more moustache oil for their elegantly coifed soliders who seem to spend more time training with their new US bought toys than I don’t know, actually fighting the insurgency on their very door step.

      And if you’re some poor mug whose house just got washed away because your Government has all the infrastructure investment credentials of NSW State Labor - who you gonna vote for next time there’s an election of some description? The corrupt Pakistani military leaders with their ridiculous facial hair and complete failure to save you and your family from water bourne illness? Your local warlord chieftain with his inability to build you anything resembling a new house, but an uncanny knack for funneling UN funds into his own personal fleet of Mercedes? Or your friendly neighbourhood insurgent, who actually delivered you food, who protected your patch of sodden earth from looting, but who just so happens to believe in the righteous fury of his Jihad.

      This is the opportunity Al-Qaeda have been waiting for. To legitimise themselves the same way HAMAS legitimised themselves in Palestine. And all the fresh faced young Australian doctors in the world aren’t going to stop that.

    • Just Sayin' says:

      07:36pm | 20/09/10

      Sadly, you’ve nailed it.

    • Alicia says:

      08:08pm | 20/09/10

      Wow, I actually found someone else in the world who seems to get it! That is exactly how people are recruited into the Taliban. People feel grateful when the Taliban uses their Opium money to bring the “down trodden” on side by giving food, medical care etc. Outside of the cities the Taliban IS all the social security that people have. If I was a regular non-city-dwelling resident of Afghanistan or Pakistan I reckon I’d be with the Taliban. Religious zealots they may be, but also a better bet for the poor man.

    • David says:

      12:29am | 21/09/10

      brilliantly written and so very true!

    • Gregg says:

      04:09pm | 20/09/10

      Have you looked at what the total population of Pakistan is Kevin and do you not think their own government should be doing much more with a total of about 170M, even something like making it mandatory that host families away from the flooded regions take in women with babes and young children.
      Older Juveniles and adults could be organised as recovery workforces and then there would be less delivery of emergency aid that sees cartons of energy biscuits thrown from helicopters flying fast and at height so as they explode on impact.
      Why not get into some talks with the Pakistanis in Pakistan and you could have contributed the cost of bignoting yourself in Washington and New York.
      That $40M btw is Australian taxpayers money given by the government and not government money, perhaps an attitude you need to adopt a bit more.

    • jeffb says:

      04:57pm | 20/09/10

      Rudd is doing what foreign ministers have always done, is it his fault that its suddenly front page news? The fact that Rudd is more newsworthy than previous foreign ministers does not mean he is doing anything significantly different.

      Seriously, tell me how Rudd’s trip to America was “bignoting himself”.

      While your at it try explaining how taxes aren’t “government money”.

    • Eric says:

      06:28pm | 20/09/10

      Jeffb, that would be because taxpayers’ money is created by the taxpayers, not the government - and therefore it is rightfully taxpayers’ money, not “government money”.

    • Gregg says:

      08:41pm | 20/09/10

      Compare Rudd one week into the job Jeff with both Stephen Smith and Downer if you like and neither of those two were out there on the world stage and there were worse disasters than the Pakistan floods while those two were doing the same role.
      And then take another look at hpw Rudd was a would be world stager as a PM from Bali to Hopenhagen and any chance he had in between.
      And to boot he’s a slime ball trying to play up to the media any chance he can get and hasn’t left that behind it would seem his words with Hilary Clinton on a good time being very calculated with the attempt at cocking an eyebrow.
      I’d rather an open Rat F##ker representing Australia.

    • Matt says:

      04:16pm | 20/09/10

      Denny Crane,

      First of all the country is not in crippling debt like never before. We’re known globally for the strength of our economy. For the first time I can remember Australia has one of the most traded currencies in the world.

      You need to hold a certain worldview to say we’re crippled - because it’s just not backed up by international evidence.

      You’ve done a bit of verballing of Mr Rudd saying that if we give aid terrorists won’t attack us. But it is true that Pakistan remains key to anti-terrorism efforts, under successive labor/liberal in Aus and democrat/republican Governments in US.

      Time and time again throughout history we see that instability breeds extremism. To ignore this would be a great folly.

      Mr Rudd is not putting forward a partisan position, rather an evidence based position rooted in history and commonsense.

    • Denny Crane says:

      09:23pm | 20/09/10

      Matt,

      The country does have crippling debt we borrow money each day from China.

      If Pakistan needs support so quickly why did they refuse India’s help straight off, you accept help where you can, that would tell me Pakistan is too petty to accept help from a regional neighbour.

      Pakistan is already unstable they cant man there borders already, and now what will they want us to do that as well.

      Pakistan have more money then we think, all they need to do, instead of investing heavily into nuclear power for weapons, but to invest this money into its people and infrastructure, instead what we fix this up, and what do Pakistan do next time nothing, becasue again it will be again weapons first

    • Austin 3:16 says:

      05:33pm | 21/09/10

      Hey Denny, yeah Australia’s debt is about 6% of our income.

      Unlike Tony Abbott who’s personal debt is several times his income. Maybe we should also start a fund to help him out, what do you reckon?

    • iansand says:

      04:43pm | 20/09/10

      We should help, but we should make sure that the Pakistanis know that the help comes from the West and that going down paths of extremism is not the way to ensure future help.

    • Scarneck says:

      04:50pm | 20/09/10

      “Australia needs a stable Pakistan; Pakistan is key to our anti-terrorism efforts in Afghanistan”...what an under statement, not just Australia, the World needs a stable Pakistan, I just hope the USA realise this. If the Taliban topple the Pakistan Government (not through lack of trying) then 9/11 will become an everyday occurrence!

    • Steve Smith says:

      10:56pm | 20/09/10

      “I’m afraid it could be 9/11 times a thousand”

      - “You mean…”

      “Yes, Nine hundred and eleven thousand.”

    • N. Bene says:

      04:51pm | 20/09/10

      As a victim of the black saturday fire cyclone I was heartened by the reaction of one Kevin Rudd,compassionate and inspiring, I,m convinced he is a man of high principle and a genuine humanitarian,so to turn the plight of the Pakistan flood victims into some kind of political football is absolutely the most vile form of human behaviour you would ever want to witness.

    • Sam says:

      05:26pm | 20/09/10

      I never fell for the kevin07 nonsense, and thought his leadership was a waste of time - but well done to Kevin Rudd for highlighting this tragedy. 

      If he can prompt Australia and the west to confront this tragedy then that’s a great achievement and all of us, no what our own partisan backgrounds, will stand and applaud (and kick in a few quid as well).

    • steve parker says:

      06:44pm | 20/09/10

      You know Kevin, I have never actually liked you much, and even rejoiced in the fact that the Labor Party was ripping itself in shreds with your demise - BUT…..all power to you my friend with this. Now for the Millenium Goals and I am sure expecting a bigger overall contribution from Australia. If you can do that - increase GNP to AusAid, then I for one will be swung around your way. When I read some of the bigoted statements on here, forget the NBN, how poor we think we really are and all the other minor issues - this is the one that counts, this is what you can write your record on. We are all part of a global community and will be now, forever.
      Apollo Moon Landing - Archibald McLeish
      To see the earth as it truly is, small and blue and beautiful in that eternal silence where it floats, is to see ourselves as riders on the earth together, brothers on that bright loveliness in the eternal cold—brothers who know now they are truly brothers.

    • Ricardo says:

      07:10pm | 20/09/10

      steve parker says: increase GNP to AusAid. No way, no how. AusAid was set up to help poor countries in times such as these, but has spent millions of dollars on promoting AFL. That’s right millions of Australian taxpayer dollars that should be used to help the poor have gone to AFL promotion in foreign countries.  AusAid will waste this money and should be held accountable for every sent it has wasted on this ludicrous idea that AFL saves lives. Help the Pakistan people absolutely, but do it by providing health care and infrastructure, AusAid can’t be trusted to do either of this.

    • steve parker says:

      09:58pm | 20/09/10

      Ricardo I agree - the AFL stunt in Africa was stupid and I wrote to McMullen saying that at the time - but let’s not forget the poor in Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and the greatb programs there.

    • Bravozulu says:

      07:07pm | 20/09/10

      Pakistan Govt needs to do more, stop ISI training insurgents and stop insurgency, and maybe things can be different !!

    • Roger says:

      07:16pm | 20/09/10

      The challenge with Pakistan is that you can never ever be surre that the donations and contributions end up supporting those in dire need. All too often the funds are diverted to some other project that the gov deems a priority, and that usually has nothing to do with the original intent of the donations.
      Sadly, it is often to projects needing cash due to the military spending sucking it all up. They are apparently a poor nation but have a military spending level that is astronomical.
      Pakistan is rife with corruption at all levels of govt and militarty.
      So in the end, many donations are financing guns and rockets for the biggest single commercial operation and land owner in Pakistan: The military…

    • K King says:

      10:25pm | 20/09/10

      Too right Roger. Unfortunately the money ends up in the Swiss accounts of the corrupt Pakistani Govt ministers and officials.

      There are some good charities you could donate too if you look around hard enough. Not sure by these people seem to be on the ground helping people in need - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdul_Sattar_Edhi

      “he received 1986 Ramon Magsaysay Award for Public Service. He is also the recipient of the Lenin Peace Prize and the Balzan Prize”

    • Robbo says:

      07:33pm | 20/09/10

      Well Kevin, you could stop off in Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Syria and a few other Middle East countries and convince their leaders to donate a few billion for aid in their fellow Muslim countries.  Surely the brotherhood of Muslim solidarity feels for their brothers and sisters in dire times?
      Or is it only the stupid Western infidels who give in times like this?

    • K King says:

      10:18pm | 20/09/10

      As principled men and women of this great nation of ours, let’s not get the ill-actions/ non-action of others influence our good ones my friend. What would then be the difference between “them” and us? Last time I checked we were all humans.

      We always take the high moral ground on almost everything but then follow it with such hypocrisy. How about we start this change by extending our goodwill and just, maybe just, we may bring about a change in “these people’s” attitudes. Let us share our good fortune with others who are not so fortunate, and history will look upon us kindly and our future generations will stand to benefit.

    • Dan says:

      01:54am | 21/09/10

      I feel much the same way as you Robbo. Time for the rich muslim states to step up and help out their “mates”.

      Unfourtunatly they seem to be as apathetic about the floods as they do about terrorism.

      Oddly enough it’s the “west” that created the demand for oil, that gives the few “funtioning” muslim nations the opportunity to help.

    • bobw says:

      02:21am | 21/09/10

      Sorry to disrupt your slanted rhetoric, but if you had actually done some research before mouthing off, you would know that Saudi Arabia has made an enormous contribution to the relief effort.  See http://bit.ly/by6Si6

    • Louisa says:

      08:12pm | 20/09/10

      Many people just don’t want to Rudd - get it?

      We have overdonated for too many years and I for one am not prepared to continue

    • K King says:

      10:11pm | 20/09/10

      I just hope and pray to God that you and me never have to see the day when the roles are reversed. There can be no limit to giving and goodwill, and so long as we have more than food to eat and a roof to live under, we will be more fortunate that others who don’t. Compassion sister, compassion, and God will love you for it!

    • fran says:

      09:01pm | 20/09/10

      give us a break. Australian’s are paying out enough to Pakistani taxi drivers here. why don’t the Pakistanis themselves do something for their own people.

    • K King says:

      06:50pm | 21/09/10

      Fran Fran Fran, Pakistani cabbies aren’t as wealthy and fortunate as some of us snobs. They, like any other cabbies from other ethnicities are deservedly earning their hard earned dollar, exposing themselves to dangers and working the odd hours while you and me sleep in our warm and cozy beds. I don’t know many Pakistanis but the ones I do know or have had contact with are deeply touched by disaster and in some instances, their families and close relatives have lost everything. And yes, they have opened their wallets and done what decent folk do.  Where has the compassion gone?????

    • Ashlee says:

      10:08pm | 20/09/10

      I can’t believe people can be as cruel as some of the commenters have been when faced with such tragedy and suffering.

      These are emergency humanitarian measures to stop people dying en masse and to try and alleviate their pain.

      Any long term foreign aid program into Pakistan would obviously have to be examined more closely and perhaps the Australian government would have to ask certain things of the Pakistani government to ensure aid funds were used properly instead of funneled off by corruption etc.

      But in this situation, its about getting in there and trying to save lives as soon as possible.  The aid money will be largely used by international non-profits and Australian government agencies to deliver immediate assistance.

      I think it is pretty sad that Mr Rudd feels the need to mention Pakistan’s role in fighting the Taliban, but I understand why he has to in this situation, because unfortunately Pakistan is not a popular cause.  Do we only have ‘strategic compassion’ left?  It seems that way by reading some of the comments, and that’s pretty sad.

    • ZSRenn says:

      12:20am | 21/09/10

      Yes sadly Kevin

      Pakistan had to down grade its growth from around 5% GDP to around 4.1% after the flood,

      Yes let the world dig them out heaven forbid they would have to reduce their GDP to somewhere near that of Greece to help their own people.

      This would reduce their military and allow room for Taliban expansion.

      Oh sorry not helping at all seems to allowing for Taliban expansion,

      I’m confused!

    • Rashed says:

      02:42am | 21/09/10

      very nice…I am deeply touched by the action Mr. Rudd has taken.
      But what important is that this is natural disaster..we can’t help to fix every thing.
      I believe that this natural disaster is yet another sign from GOD and our forgetting of last day of resurrection.As ALLAH says in Quran that we send calamities and natural disaster in this world so that the people may repent and if not then there is a big punishment waiting for them on the day of judgment.
      Although Muslims, but Pakistan is a leading country for corruption, human abuse, unlawful killings and injustice. I am happy that Australians are more Muslims than Pakistanis.

    • Jim says:

      07:48am | 21/09/10

      I remember the first 6 months or so of KRudd’s term; he took every single opportunity there was to get his face on camera. Suddenly the Swine Flu ‘epidemic’ hit…who was fronting the media scrum every morning - Nicola Roxon. Where was her illustrious leader? Nowhere to be seen. It was a ‘bad news’ story and he didn’t want to be seen to be associated with bad news.
      Fast forward 3 years, disaster in Pakistan - KRudd gunning for a UN job…perfect opportunity to look the saviour on the cameras.
      I said it yesterday in response to Tim Costello’s piece - politicians or religious leaders pointing the finger of guilt at people and demanding they do something just doesn’t work anymore - we have our own problems. “Donation burnout” was mentioned yesterday - it’s true….phone calls almost every night, people with their little tables set up outside supermarkets - everyone wants you to donate these days. Over it!

    • Jon says:

      11:56am | 21/09/10

      Kev, how is this money going to be spent? From my reading of some of the commentary regarding the cause this disaster, was a failure of a levy bank system mainly in the poor areas. So my guess is that if the money if not gobbled up in corruption, it will go to the rich areas to make sure that their levy banks are even stronger for the next flood.

      There is no doubt that we will have many more of these kinds of natural disaster due to climate change from over population. But the UN seems to be unable or unwilling to put preventative polices into action or even to get the population problem on the agenda. The religious and politicians in third world countries fight tool and nail to stop any form of birth control and the implementation of universal human rights for woman. Population growth, which is used cynically to obtain political and financial advantage.  The UN does health very well, but this become problematic as this increases the world population. Education is good, but what but do you teach? Funding of religious schools in third world countries will just perpetuate the lack of useful knowledge and population increases.

      Politicians in general, like Ban Ki-Moon make grandiose statement about world poverty, but the logistics of food supply, and infrastructure cost don’t add up. The paradox is that some of the UN policies could actually make these problems worse.  We need to invent a new world body, one based on rational problem solving and universal human rights, not one that seems to be a social club or an overpaid employment agency.

    • Catching up says:

      04:29pm | 21/09/10

      A little help at this time could prevent much more being spent on our troops being involved in the area in the future.  We now have troops in the country next door.  These people deserve our help.  We can afford it.  We cannot afford to do nothing.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter