What is wrong with Adelaide? We call ourselves the ‘Festival State’, but far from being overrun by action we appear to be operating as a surrogate nursery for the rest of the country’s sporting events; they are born here, we suckle them, and then they unceremoniously move elsewhere. And they never call!

Screw this, let's go to Sydney! Pic: Calum Robertson

We lost another of our great sporting events last week, The Rugby Sevens carnival. I was lucky enough to attend two weeks ago for the carnival’s last Adelaide showcase with my son, but had I realised it was a rugby funeral I would have worn black. 

The Deputy Treasurer and Minister for Tourism John Rau was unconcerned, however, by the loss of yet another great sporting event. He shrugged his shoulders and said ‘the fact is we can’t win everything’. Well, yes Minister, but why are we losing so many?

There is much to be proud of in South Australia, and the Minister was right to list great events including the Fringe Festival and Womad, but how have we manage to consistently lose so many others?

The Grand Prix raced off in 1993, The Jacob’s Creek Golf Open teed off in 2006, the Australian Hard Court Championships went out of bounds in 2007, the Tasting Australia Festival has recently had its budget starved, and now the Rugby Sevens event has been booted out of the park (please forgive my puns, but anger has this effect on me).

Let me be clear, this is not the fault of the people of Adelaide, who support and attend these events in their droves. But things like these need funding, they need support, and most importantly that need a government which is willing to defend them from interstate rivals with loose cheque books.

In lieu of that happening, I think proud crow-eaters should support the creation of an event so quintessentially South Australian that it can’t be stolen. Why don’t we replace the Rugby Sevens carnival with a lightening carnival made up of all the South Australian National Football League teams?

We have a rich history of supporting our SANFL teams, so why couldn’t we have a Rugby Sevens style lightning carnival using our local Aussie Rules talent? A modified format, round-robin series with finals and would be hugely entertaining, and would no doubt draw a great crowd. This is an event which could be held in the lead-up to the start of the SANFL season each year. It would provide kids and families a great way to get up ‘close and personal’ with their local teams – something which really differentiates the SANFL from its more remote cousin the AFL.

I remember playing in lightning carnivals as a child. They were always the highlight of the season. With obesity levels on the rise in our young people and the Government fighting a losing battle in encouraging children to put down their iPhones and exercise, why don’t we look at new ways of engaging children with competitive sport? These fast and exhilarating carnivals are the perfect foil to the low attention spans of younger children, and are easily replicated on the playground.

South Australians are great supporters of sport, and are endlessly frustrated by the march interstate of our popular festivals and carnivals. However, instead of lying down and letting the scrum run over us, let’s create something for our state and our children. We have all the talent we need right here, and I know that there are many families who would love the opportunity to cheers their teams on together.

If that fails, we could always start up a Farmer’s Union Iced Coffee guzzling carnival. Heaps good.

61 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • TChong says:

      08:01am | 21/04/11

      Nothing too wrong with Adelaide, or SA, very pretty etc
      Very good roads , lead back east.

    • C1 says:

      09:17am | 21/04/11

      Great Chongy,

      First cab off the rank and you add absolutely nothing.

      As for the directional quality - SA also has very good railways as well. You really notice it when you hit the border from the East when your teeth stop rattling!

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      09:55am | 21/04/11

      C1

      You must be kidding. The metropolitan train system here is the worst in the country. The trains themselves are decades old and as far as TransAdelaide is concerned, the ‘peak hour’ finishes at 6 sharp. 
      The ALP has closed most of the country lines in deals with their transport mogul mates. You used to be able to get to the Riverland, the Barossa, Mt Gambier etc by train. And the Overland used to run at a useful time ie overnight so you could get a good night’s sleep, grab a shower and get dressed and be in Spencer St by 8:30 am, which beat getting up at 4:00am to catch a plane. 
       
      Rann’s idea of public transport is to jam more diesel belching buses onto the already overcrowded roads. 
       
      I lived 40Km from Collins St when I worked in Melbourne (out near Sunbury) and I used to get there in half the time it currently takes me to get 15kms into the Adelaide CBD. Ditto to the Brisbane CBD when I commuted from out near Petrie.

    • TChong says:

      01:21pm | 21/04/11

      Jeez C1, yur teeth stop rattling, because yur in sand , and everythings so much slower.
      But will say, having been to adelaide , kangaroo Is - very nice.

    • WRong says:

      01:44pm | 21/04/11

      Does this bloke TChong get some thrill for being the first to comment even though he really has nothing to say?

    • Reggie says:

      08:23pm | 22/04/11

      Whats-is-name…“TChong get some thrill for being the first to comment’

      I thought it was funny but maybe I’m less serious than some. “The roads that lead East” Not at all Chongie, they lead to the good reds and let’s not be taken in by the labels on the wine in the US that pretend that Victorian wines are part of the SA heritage. South-Eastern Australia indeed.

    • Scott says:

      08:09am | 21/04/11

      The Adelaide 500 is a huge event and you’ve just been awarded a Socceroos game against the Kiwis so it’s not all bad..

    • Huey says:

      08:17am | 21/04/11

      But it would have to be in Adelaide.

    • MPFive says:

      08:28am | 21/04/11

      I would hazard a guess, and say its the same reason why video games were born on PC and then moved on to consoles for the rest of their lives.

      Money.

      Granted PC still gets these games, but we usually get the worst version. So its probably better off that they stay away from PCs.

      But yea, Money.

    • BL says:

      08:29am | 21/04/11

      There is one thing wrong with Adelaide:

      The Rann Government.

    • Melbourne says:

      08:31am | 21/04/11

      Ok… just follow me for a moment here… the master of the universe and bringing of light and truth, and ultimate owner of the company that produces this website, started his empire in Adelaide.
      He then promptly f*cked off to Perth and from there to Sydney and back to his native Melbourne (and then to the USA) - but he STARTED in Adelaide.
      News Ltd is currently in a takeover bid for Bernie Ecclestone’s F1 company.
      Are we drawing the dots yet?
      Lord Rupert of Adelaide will OWN formula 1 soon!
      If that isn’t time for the denizens of Adelaidia to start calling in some favours (hey rupe - My Dad bought every copy of The Adelaide from 1956-1989 when he died from newspaper ink poisoning.. while doing the crossword.. and filling in his liberal party how to vote card..) then I dont know what is.

      Now to another question - WHO THE FRAG IS POLITES AND WHY DO THEY OWN ADELAIDE??????
      Adelaide - A Division of the Polites Group. Proudly brought to you by Polites.

      Oh and the time difference… its April 2011 here in Australia…

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      09:01am | 21/04/11

      Murdoch left Adelaide and became a US citizen. News Ltd used to hold their AGM here, then opted for a Queensland island and now presumably hold it in the States. 
       
      Adelaide is a backwater. The only company of any note that is still headquartered here is Santos, and as soon as they suck Moomba dry, they will move as well. 
       
      There is no bank here anymore (BankSA exists only as a Westpac brand for the next few years and Adelaide Bank was delisted when Bendigo Bank took them over), no manufacturing sector (Mitsubishi, Email etc etc have gone) and no technology sector of any note (since large companies like SGIC, Kaiser Stuhl, Elders, Mutual Community, Davids have all been taken over and moved their IT operations to the eastern states). 
       
      Rann bleats on and on about the Submarine and Air Warfare Destroyer contracts but none of the smart stuff is being done here and they were organised by Downer and Hill, anyway. 
       
      We have an ALP State Government who are only interested in over-riding local council development decisions so they can do deals with their developer buddies (unless they can stack the council. One of them has ALP MP’s staffers on it).
       
      I’m marking time until I can get back to Queensland or Victoria myself and it cannot come too soon. Sporting events are no reason to stick around, particularly since the average citizen gets nothing. I pay taxes here but I’ve never been invited into the Govt’s hospitality tent.

    • Tony Bee says:

      12:53pm | 21/04/11

      Geez, Tony, you really like crapping in your own nest! If you hate it so much, why don’t you move? There’s a lot more going for Adelaide than mentioned here, such as the Tour Down Under and GMH in Elizabeth is powering ahead.

      The state needs another Don Dunstan ... and for those elitist, First Family wankers to die.

    • Nigel Badger says:

      03:34pm | 21/04/11

      Your father bought"The Adelaide ‘‘for many years? Rubbish it was “The Advertiser"fool.Tighten up a bit and research your subject . Don’t be lazy.

    • Markus says:

      09:03am | 21/04/11

      It is a shame really. My friends and I road tripped from Canberra to Adelaide for the Sevens (via Melbourne and Great Ocean rd).
      I really liked Adelaide. It was like a smaller Melbourne, with less shitty weather.
      The event itself was good fun, and while the crowds at the Sevens provided a great atmosphere, the numbers were poor. And it became apparent that the vast majority of spectators were from interstate or overseas.

      The problem? I don’t think anyone in Adelaide actually knew about it.
      There was little (if any) advertising of the event in the CBD, and it would definitely explain the confused ‘where are all these people going?’ looks from many locals.

      Hopefully the Gold Coast can sell it a bit better. Although they currently have the GC Sevens scheduled for the end of November, which is right in the middle of schoolies week if I remember correctly?
      Nothing says festival like a bunch of drunken teens molesting each other and sleeping in their own vomit…

    • Seanr says:

      10:20am | 21/04/11

      Agreed Markus, ARU has made a business decision in my view, get more rugby in one of the ‘heartlands’ especially if league and AFL are expanding in that area. Adelaide is nice but if the locals aren’t going, it can’t expect to keep the event.

      aaah Schoolies, so many blurry memories

    • Markus says:

      11:13am | 21/04/11

      I’ve heard that Adelaide have bought the rights to one of the Wallabies Tri-Nations fixtures, the one that was regularly held in Perth at Subiaco each year.
      Perhaps they see this as the easier way to spread the game in the state. Although given that a ticket to 2 days of Sevens cost less than a single Wallabies Test match, I know which I’d prefer.

    • Terry Duffy says:

      09:04am | 21/04/11

      The problem is obvious.  It’s not festivals per say. It’s SPORTING festivals and their very expensive. Try music festivals instead. At least they generally break even and people love to volunteer for them and they bring lots of cash into the local economy.

    • Eye Roller says:

      10:44am | 21/04/11

      What you mean like Womad, The Big Day Out, The Futire Music Festival and Soundwave music festivals?

    • Terry Duffy says:

      01:30pm | 21/04/11

      You can never have too many music festivals.

    • richo says:

      09:18am | 21/04/11

      The problem with Adelaide is the only thing its got is Aussie Rules. The last Crows vs Port game had a terrible attendance, maybe basing an entire event around Aussie Rules isn’t such a good idea. Adelaide would get more socceroos and Wallabies games if it had a decent rectangular stadium.

      Adelaide United put on a good show, I don’t know why they weren’t mentioned as a good thing to go and watch.

    • Markus says:

      11:16am | 21/04/11

      Because it’s the A-League.
      You can talk it up all you like, but it’s still a 3rd rate competition.

    • richo says:

      03:50pm | 21/04/11

      And you can talk up the AFL all you want it’s still a sport the rest of the world has either never heard of, or just plain laughed at.

      Oh, but I forgot being the best at something no one else does still means were the best right.

      Playing AFL is like a karaoke championship, even if you sing the best in the competition, no ones heard of you.

      3rd rate football, beats 1st rate nothingness to most of the world. At least United are a sporting team from Adelaide capable of winning something, unlike the AFL teams.

    • Thommo says:

      11:05am | 22/04/11

      How poor must your self-esteem be if you need the approval of other countries before playing a sport….sad, very sad…

    • Thommo says:

      09:32am | 21/04/11

      The Jacobs Creek Golf was cancelled - it didn’t move anywhere. So Fail #1.
      As was the Adelaide Hard Courts…. Fail #2
      THe Rugby Sevens had atrocious attendance - so fail #3
      So basically the only thing we’ve lost is the Grand Prix….we’ve got the Clipsla which is better so big deal….your entire piece is an EPIC FAIL.

    • Shifter says:

      11:17am | 21/04/11

      The supertaxis event is better than F1? This is what’s wrong with Adelaide right there.

    • K says:

      11:22am | 21/04/11

      FAILING to proof-read response before hitting enter = EPIC FAIL

    • Skitt says:

      12:28pm | 21/04/11

      Failing to realise that the Adelaide Hard Courts was moved to QLD… FAIL

    • Thommo says:

      11:04am | 22/04/11

      The Adelaide hard Courts were not moved. The Gold Coast WTA event was moved to brisbane and co-sanctioned with the ATP. The Adelaide Hard Courts were not ATP sanctioned tour events which is why they had past players and novelty formats - is taht what’s occuring at the Brisbane INternational? No. So Uberfail…

    • SACA says:

      09:41am | 21/04/11

      Maybe the SA government could build a decent sized rectangular stadium (like the Gold Coast, Melbourne and soon Perth) so they can bid for some different sporting events.

    • Rural South Australian says:

      10:59am | 21/04/11

      Maybe they can fund it vian user pays. Whys houdl I pay tax for a white elephant i’m never gonna use?

    • David LD says:

      09:48am | 21/04/11

      Adelaide is beautiful, but there is a significant rut of social conservatism on both sides of the aisle that repeatedly hold it back.
      Of course, having just about everything in the CBD close at or just after 5pm doesn’t help either.

      Beuatiful city though.

      (And all of that dismisses the right-wing ALP MP that just got done for child exploitation offences.)

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      11:36am | 21/04/11

      Not to mention the portfolio he was acting in ....

    • Steve says:

      10:16am | 21/04/11

      What’s wrong with Adelaide ?

      The people there.  A big country town desperately pretending to be a city.

    • Nigel Badger says:

      03:46pm | 21/04/11

      Oh tosh.Doubt if you have ever been here.I dare say you live in some inner city rat hole where you are unable to swing a dead cat. No doubt in Sydney or Melbourne.A battery hen existence.What a dogs life you must lead.

    • Ruggy says:

      10:20am | 21/04/11

      Nearly no-one in Adelaide follows rugby. Having a rugby event there doesn’t make sense.

    • Shane From Melbourne says:

      10:50am | 21/04/11

      I’d tell you but I haven’t got an hour to type it up…......

    • Ross says:

      10:58am | 21/04/11

      It wouldn;t matter what you wanted to do in Adelaide anything at all ,there will always be two people who will opose it . Decisions are not their strong suit . They even elected do nothing Rann to guide them.

    • nossy says:

      12:04pm | 21/04/11

      The best view of Adelaide is looking back through the rear window of a car speeding north !  hahahahahahaaha I am a QLDer so I am biased.

    • hot tub political machine says:

      12:42pm | 21/04/11

      As right of wind up reply nossy, i have a mate from Emerald who tells me he only realised he couldn’t speak when he moved to Adelaide. He is forever grateful to have moved from a place where four X is considered a beer to one where Coopers is the standard.

    • nossy says:

      05:10pm | 21/04/11

      @hot tub political machine - hey fella are you saying we QLDers are crude rude and vulgar ? You might be right !  hahahah Have a great Easter !

    • Reggie says:

      08:40am | 23/04/11

      Hey nossy, aren’t you the Winton Kid, or am I thinking of someone else? If you are, never turn your back on the bright lights of Adelaide by comparison.

      Some of the nicest smartest people I’ve ever met come from Adelaide and although I’ve only been there once, I back their judgment of Adelaide as a place that has a place with high values.

    • bikinis on top says:

      12:18pm | 21/04/11

      Well Stone the crows ! is Adelaide is a suburb of Melbourne?.
      Adelaide is the city of Churches and Adelaide has a Labor State Government.
      Adelaide is ahead of Sydney and Melbourne and Perth

    • ABC says:

      12:26pm | 21/04/11

      Quite frankly, (and I am from Adelaide), Adelaide is too locked into the view that is is somehow a cultural epicentre - the Festival State and all that rubbish.  It ‘aint.  There is the deep seated ideological position amongst the politicians - that in order to get over what it to a great extent an inferiority complex (I don’t know why this is - Adelaide and SA is an absolutely great place to live) that it needs to be badged more culturally than socially.  Hence, Womad etc.  While Tasting Australia is an absolute rip snorting success, ignoring sport on the basis that it is the purview of a bunch of bogans (with the exception of the Tour Down Under which is viewed as suitably posh!!) will increasingly be to South Australia’s detriment.  We are so reactionarily snobbish in our wish to be seen as something other than what we are.  The failure to embrace SA as the perfect venue for globally popular (non-posh) sports and the promote the place as such will continue to result in SA being seen as a bit of a backwater.

    • Rossco says:

      12:34pm | 21/04/11

      What’s wrong with Adelaide?

      3 things.

      1. The Advertiser
      2. Conservatives
      3. The Labor Party

      That is all.

    • HappyCynic says:

      02:34pm | 21/04/11

      4 things.

      4. Too many serial killers smile

      Oh and Adelaide is proof Tasmanians are able to swim.

    • hot tub political machine says:

      12:39pm | 21/04/11

      Ah, we still punch above our weight though, for a small state we get to have some bloody good events.

    • Fred says:

      12:57pm | 21/04/11

      Ummmmmmmm, duh, I think it is called LABOR!!!!

    • michael j says:

      01:21pm | 21/04/11

      TOO many bloody bikie’s,,you must be doing something wrong or the High Court would rule in the Governments side,,,,,

    • Frank says:

      01:54pm | 21/04/11

      Events come & go; such is life. I like the idea of a footy lightning carnival, but why not do it against the best of other states (except AFL teams) or D1 Amateurs vs SANFL.

      Also have to say that driving back from Melbourne on a recent Monday evening it struck me just how bad we can be and maybe why the Dukes Hwy has so many bad accidents. Hit the border at about 6pm and unless you wanted to share a run down service station with a heap of truckies, there was nothing open. Went into Keith looking for a coffee at 6.30pm - nothing. Nothing at Tintinara & Coonalpyn. At Tailem Bend even the Subway was shutting around 8pm. Then of course there’s absolutely nothing on the road until the Portrush corner. What the hell is that all about?

      We need to get real about a whole range of things and get into the 21st century before it ends. We think some of our events are great, but until you go to a great event somewhere else you don’t realise how meaningless most of our events really are.

    • BBB says:

      02:09pm | 21/04/11

      What is wrong with Adelaide?  You mean aside from the spate of weird murders, a (former) kiddie fiddling Magistrate, a (former) Treasurer getting involved in late night punch ons and now a Labor pollie found (allegedly) with child porn…

    • stephen parker says:

      02:39pm | 21/04/11

      Stuff you all - we still make the best shiraz in Australia at Kay Brothers winery down at McLaren Vale. Nothing else matters!

    • Rev says:

      03:54pm | 21/04/11

      Thank god we don’t have to pick it up in person.

    • Kika says:

      04:51pm | 21/04/11

      It’s Adelaide.. that’s why. People will go out of their way to go to an event in Sydney or Melbourne… but Adelaide?

    • Robert S McCormick says:

      08:11pm | 21/04/11

      Other than McLaren Vale, the Barossa & Adeliade Hills wineries like “Bird in Hand"there is absolutely nothing to do in what passes for the City of Adelaide. There are but three shopping areas: 1) The Central Market, which the Adelaide City Council is doing it’s best to destroy but which currently is still full of character & characters. 2) Rundle Street but it’s only fun at night. 3) the airless, dusty,dirty, boring Rundle Mall where the shop assistants are rude. That’s it folks!
      The current State government,the premier & all his ministers are detested & distrusted. How can you trust any man or woman MP when one of them wants to introduce laws which will deny anyone the government-of-the-day dislikes: 1) The right to a fair & open trial. 2) Deny them the age-old “Presumption of Innocence” 3) The holding of people for trial & denying them & their legal teams the right to know what they are being charged with until they appear on court. 4) The prohibition of making any public statements about the case.
      Straight out of 1930s Germany.
      Yes, folks, do come to SA but stay away from Adelaide there is nothing there for you. Spend your money on good wines & food for, just like the rest of Australia, those are just about the only things left which are actually grown, picked,processed & cooked here. Adelaide’s shops & shopping centres are full of exactly the same shops you will find anywhere in the world. Event the stores have the same names,same imported rubbish from sweat-shops & prisons in exactly that same undemocratic countries with their single-party, despotic dictatorships which you can just as easily by at home!

    • Malleeringneck says:

      09:30pm | 21/04/11

      With all the comments about losing events from SA no one has mentioned that The World Muzzleloading Championships were hosted twice in SA at Monarto.
      First time in 2000 and the second time in 2008.
      The Monarto complex is still the only one capable of holding the event in Australia, where around 300 international shooters compete.
      The next time Australasia is due to hold the event it will most probably be in SA at Monarto.
      This event is extremely well run by the committee of the Sporting Shooters Association in South Australia.

    • Harquebus says:

      09:56am | 22/04/11

      Mike Rann.

    • Greg says:

      11:09am | 22/04/11

      Adelaide doesn’t care about anything sport wise unless it’s AFL. When the local TV stations here bump the Bledisloe Cup matches for fricking Adam Sandler movie, what else can you expect?

    • Sickemrex says:

      03:05pm | 22/04/11

      Damn I thought I was going to read an article about serial killers and paedophiles.

    • Ian says:

      04:36pm | 22/04/11

      Steven - You’re kidding.  The general populace stopped caring about the SANFL in 1991.  Lightning Carnival indeed.  We are not a ‘rugby’ State, and for the most part, no one went, and no one cares about the 7s.

      What is wrong with Adelaide?

      Why is the Gold Coast hosting the Commonwealth Games, and we can’t afford a bid?  Why do we still *not* have an annual Arts and Film Festival whilst every other city does?  Why is there a vacant block of land where there used to be a furniture store?  Why do people have to shop in Melbourne because the range of goods in Adelaide is so poor?  Why does the Southern Expressway finish 13 kilometres short of the City?

      The facts are we have the oldest, and poorest, and least-employed, and least-educated population of the mainland capitals.  Everything else stems from that.  The only life in the City after 6.00pm comes from the international students.

    • CaptainReality says:

      04:34pm | 07/07/11

      No jobs.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter