What really defines these three aspects of our society: Its race or colour? Peace or violence? Street crime or racial crime?

Nitin Garg's mourning family in India

You might have thought that race, peace and street crime are more commonly seen in our society. People generally do. But take a second to think about your answers. 

To my mind, every person who lives in Australia should be given a ‘fair go’, an ideal that many Australians aim to hold. Australia was built by immigrants, and the influence of immigrants stretches broadly throughout society.

It has been a steep learning curve for both the Indian and the Australian communities, so why is it people cannot see that the social, sporting and economic interaction that occurs between India and Australia is beneficial to both sides.

The murder of Mr. Nitin Garg was a horrible heinous crime, which has opened the flood gates to many debates and has questioned our own humanity to answer questions on crime based on race, color and ethnicity.

Any person walking the streets (or indeed streets of any country) can be attacked, and any such attack is a terrible thing, but racism of any form is particularly abhorrent.

What triggers the incident? Usually, some of the attacks do carry a racial element and they come from younger and generally disadvantaged people of the society – usually people who are poorer/less educated.

They often blame foreigners for their situation in life, rather than doing something like getting skills or more education.

There were 1447 acts of violence against the Indians recorded in the State of Victoria as per Victoria Police, however way too many innocents have being injured and these are not even reported due to the fear of retribution.

Fear and prejudice are crucial mixes that lead to mistrust and social conflicts. The denial and the failure to address this can erupt into racial hatred, which in turn have led to further cycle of violence in the past.

The racism engendered in the attacks is not only a symptom of a lack of law enforcement by the courts and a lack of police personnel but it is also an act of cowards, idiots and thugs who prey on individuals from specific community and or background.

No one deserves to die or get assaulted so how do we explain these acts? For a country like Australia and a state like Victoria which is ranked the most livable place, it’s a disgrace that racial discrimination has become so institutionalized, that the system finds it easier to criticize the victims than to heal the wounds of these victims.

Lack of infrastructure with little or no guidance has left these students in a situation of paralysis. The solution to the problem is to have stringent law in place against such perpetrators and strict policies should be enforced.

It hurts to see that many fellow Indian students were hospitalized, some were in coma, some were unable to recognize their friends and family, some so stressed that they were afraid to walk on the streets, and in certain cases they lost their right to live. Yet, the criminals are on loose feet, walking on the streets, finding their next predators.

The system is not perfect and it seems that law itself cannot protect these students and when they defend themselves from the offender - that’s incitement, and they are blamed for it.

Old lived institutions have disappeared but the attitude still remains.

Is racism the biggest enemy of Australia? The answer to this lies within the individuals. What we really need to do is lead our lives by example.

By clearing the violence on the streets and by eliminating the racial element from the society we can become more multicultural and peaceful country.

The motto of, “Zero Tolerance and Total Accountability with Compliance” should be adopted to eliminate racial violence from the streets of country like Australia.

Most commented

42 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Eric says:

      05:01am | 07/01/10

      All violent crime is wrong. However, there’s no evidence that these attacks are caused by racism, rather than simple criminal thuggishness. It’s unfair to tar all Australians with the ‘racist’ brush when the real culprits would attack anyone if they could.

    • ian forest says:

      05:36am | 07/01/10

      Amit you want a perfect World free of violence i’m sure you’ll find it back in India or pakistan STOP knocking OZ imperfect it may be but it’s the best and safest country that i know.

    • Wayne Hutchins says:

      06:10am | 07/01/10

      It must be the cold miserable weather in Vic that makes people do strange things. Your figures indicate nearly 4 attacks a day against Indian students. Vic police website claims there to be 43971 offenses of this type in 08/09 or around 120 per day. Your percentage seems rather high so one must ask what do Victorians have against Indians? Lets look at India just a little bit but! On average there are 53 rapes a day in India and recently released government statistics suggest that it is the fastest growing crime in the country. I couldn’t get the number of assaults as the Indian site is down in some type of terrorist attack I think but I would imagine it makes us look like bloody angels in comparison. I think there is a little bit of racist in all of us! Yes even you Amit. It’s not the pot calling the kettle black is it? Don’t tell me you don’t stand up and beat your chest and wail “I’m Indian” with some level of pride? Seen you at the cricket. We like to belong to tribes. It’s just human nature. And sorry, but my tribe is better than yours.

    • Margaret Gray says:

      07:01am | 07/01/10

      Amit,

      You claim there were “1447 acts of violence against the Indians recorded in the State of Victoria”.

      Over what time period were these statistics gathered?

      How many of these were acts were ‘racially motivated’?

      Insitutionalised racism along class lines in India is endemic…why are you selectively ignoring this unacceptable situation in your birth country?

    • persephone says:

      07:03am | 07/01/10

      There is absolutely no evidence to support the idea that the attacks on Indian students are racist in nature, despite several studies by the police and academics.

      Some may be, some may be accompanied by racist abuse (just as a random attack on any other person would be accompanied by abuse), and some are occupational hazards, with convenience stores and taxis (now both disproportionately employing Indians) having always been the targets for late night robberies.

      Victoria has the lowest personal crime rate in Australia, with assaults falling due to targetted action by police of identified hotspots.

      It’s just as racist to imply that Australians are deliberately attacking Indians when there is no evidence that this is so.

    • Isabel says:

      07:15am | 07/01/10

      In my book, racism is like farting. It comes naturally to categorise people as ‘them’ and ‘us’. Likewise, some people find farting in public acceptable behaviour and others would be punished for farting indoors. It is not, I believe, good manners to fart without apology to others (unless asleep when there is no control) and similarly, it is not good manners to categorise people on the basis of their race. Stereotypes are evidence of sloppy thinking. Wayne, have you extended your analysis of the number of rapes in India to the number per capita of the total population?

    • Buzz says:

      07:44am | 07/01/10

      Amit, Why are you so determined to insist that the attack was racially motivated when there is no evidence (at this stage) to support this?
      India is known as one of the worst countries in the world for entrenched racism, as well as sexism and discrimination based on religious beliefs.
      No one in Australia wants international visitors or lcoals to be hurt or killed in our country, but it’s an uinfortraunate fact of life that this happens in EVERY country.
      And one final thing Amit ... approximately 35% of all statistics are made up smile

    • Toddzilla says:

      07:51am | 07/01/10

      Yes, there is a racial element to these attacks. However, it is not the race of the victims that is at issue, but the race of the perpetrators (which will never get reported in the papers for fear of appearing racist - ironic, huh).

    • Ly says:

      09:00am | 07/01/10

      Great work Amit.

      Violent attacks need to stop. Racially motivated attacks need to stop. End of story.

      Even if there is no evidence the most recent attack was racially motivated, this attack has definitely further fuelled the debate about racism in Australia.
      There is a distinct difference between pride in your country, and blatant out right racism. As a country, we need to learn the difference. The country is so large and has a kaleiedoscope of colours and cultures, it’s just not going to work if we don’t find the middle ground.

    • Kym Durance says:

      09:22am | 07/01/10

      Good heavens there are a lot of overly sensitive anonneemice ( blogers lacking the stones to use real names ) here; there is too much violence and some of it is racially motivated - I dont understand how come so many people seem to shy away from the fact - It doesnt devalue Australia in any way -

    • Eric says:

      09:59am | 07/01/10

      First of all, Kym, it isn’t a ‘fact’ - it’s an assumption.

      Secondly, the racism bogey has been used to bash Australians for decades now. We’re sick of this nonsense.

      This isn’t a race problem, it’s a crime problem and a media problem.

    • Bill says:

      10:13am | 07/01/10

      How many crimes are committed against white people in this country?
      How many crimes are committed by other ethnicities against white people?
      Why isn’t there the same media frenzy over race hate crimes against white people?

    • Phil says:

      10:19am | 07/01/10

      Maybe he was murdered because he was there, not because of where he was born.

    • Carl Palmer says:

      10:52am | 07/01/10

      Amit,

      Encarta definition of Racism “the belief that people of different races have different qualities and abilities, and that some races are inherently superior or inferior”.

      I’ve never met or heard anyone that fall into this group and I take offence at the suggestion that Australians are racist.

      My wife is Italian and she was called all sorts of names by kids when she was at school. Australian kids white and black were also called all sorts of names. My wife correctly deduced that it had nothing to do with race. 

      Lighten up buddy, it has nothing to do with race, you like me have to deal with rat bags that roam our street. These rat bags will dislike you or me because of the way we walk, talk, look, smell, scratch our nose or bum or the way we look at them. Sorry, but you have the same problem as me and I’m not Indian.

      No brainer as far as the stamping out of violence rant is concerned.

    • Ben J says:

      11:18am | 07/01/10

      The expression of Racism (verbal or physically) is not exclusive to any one particular country. Intolerance of others due to ethnic background, religious beliefs, tribal background, caste systems, colur of skin, place in the social order, occurs in every single country every minute of each day.

    • Western Melbournian says:

      11:46am | 07/01/10

      My family and I have personal experience of the complexity of this issue. We live in a block of new units in Melbourne’s west. Most in the block are owner occupiers like ourselves but one unit is occupied by Indian students - universally young men. They frequently drink to excess.
      Just before Christmas we heard a disturbance outside and found one of the students bloodied and shock from a bashing by his housemates. The cause was difficult to ascertain although he mentioned that they were from a different state in India whose residents practiced a different religion.
      We patched him up and called the Police who were unable to do very much.

      A second incident highlighted how I suspect many of us may feel about this issue. Just after Christmas the students were once again drinking heavily and making a lot of noise in the common area at the front of the units. We and other residents have young children who were frightened by the noise.
      When we asked the guys to tone it down they responded that it was because they were Indians that we were making fuss. This causes me great discomfort because I am not at all racist, I am horrified by the death and assaults on Indian students and I sympathise with them. Ironically, however the other residents in our block are of asian and greek origin and have no reason to be racist. This is far from a simple issue for those of us living in communities that have recieved a large number of Indian residents.

    • Stevo says:

      12:11pm | 07/01/10

      Amit,. I can’t speak for the motives, however clearly deranged they were for whatever “reason” they had in any and all of these rotten incidents. No dislike of any percieved difference or possesion is worth a persons life to any rational human being. These crimes,  They act as a cancer in indian-australian relations. However,  The media beat up and hyperbole in the indian press by commentators and politicians does what is a domestically based problem.

      I live in Hong Kong, where I, along side my multinational bretheren from more places on earth than i knew existed before i moved here, deal with the very real spectre of institutionalised racism day in day out, from the smallest of things to the very upfront and personal way locals will be rude and racist to your face.
      Because I am not chinese,  Aussies are in the same boat as Indians, Nepalis, Sri Lankans and so on here. Our attitude of survival is much like what my mother an italian migrant to sydney had to adopt. If you pay attention to them, they win and give them fuel to add to the fire. Making you a weak link and a source of sport. Ignore them and humiliate them where needed, it works. You are gradually accepted.
      At the end of the day the cultural shift adjustment may be very difficult for students of any region coming to Australia.
      Intergration is Key Amit, we becoming part of you,.. you becoming part of us.
      These sorts of positive change never happen quickly as people do not learn cultural norms as quickly as straight up book knowldege is.
      Im really hoping that this awful situation is resolved quickly

    • SLF says:

      12:37pm | 07/01/10

      Why can’t we all just admit that deep down everyone is racist to a certain degree or another? It is natural to be afraid of people and cultures you do not know or understand. Whatever you do or say racism and discrimination will always exists because guess what folks, people are different and some of those differences are strange, some are funny and some are scary and some of them people just do not like.

      People are also small minded, selfish and looking for someone else to blame. Again facts of life, the extent of which these emotions run through you is the difference.

      It is also OK to dislike things for completely irrational reasons, we all do it everyday.

      We can embark on study programs, cross community outreaching, understanding, etc etc, but ultimately unless there is a way to make everyone exactly the same (US culture is trying) there will be racism. 

      We need to protect the vulnerable from extreme prejudice, but at the same time we need to actually look at whther we want a vanilla identikit society or one with rich, diverse cultures which sometime butt heads against each other and sometimes dont understand each other.

      I am not saying racism and pejudice is right, I am simply saying it is a fact of life and in extreme cases a very sad one. BTW I am an immigrant and dont find Australia or Australians to be frothing card carrying Klan members, far from it, the model of multicultural sociaty here should be applauded especially given the differences and diversity of the culture.

    • cats says:

      01:49pm | 07/01/10

      Amit, these people attack everyone no matter how they look. They beat men and they rape women. Yes, these people are probably also racists, but i doubt thats the reason why they attack.

      @Carl Palmer says:11:52am | 07/01/10
      Encarta definition of Racism “the belief that people of different races have different qualities and abilities, and that some races are inherently superior or inferior”.

      I don’t believe any race is superior/inferior to any other, but i do believe they each have different qualities and abilities. I think Encarta needs to define racism a little better.. it just doesn’t make enough sense to me.

      @Bill
      I agree. There are many incidences of other races. But no one seems to call that racist. Oh i forgot, only caucasians can be racist *rolls eyes*

    • Nathman says:

      02:17pm | 07/01/10

      Has anyone stopped to consider that the attacker in this latest case could have been also been Indian? Or perhaps African/French/Croatian/Samoan or any of the other cultures we have living here in Australia?

    • Cuppa says:

      02:59pm | 07/01/10

      Amit, i find it hypocritical & insulting that India & indians are refering to my great nation as rascist.India is one of the most race orientated nations on earth that exists on a class system that seems to stem from the middle ages.The lower classes are treated like vermin.From my experience, Australians have had to tip toe around minorities in this country(often to the detriment of our culture) for fear of being branded rascist for imagined slights.I am sorry an innocent young man lost his life, but to say Australia has a race issue has no basis in fact & is insulting to many Australians that had to watch our culture change so we can be more ‘multicultural’.

    • Henry Ackroyd says:

      03:00pm | 07/01/10

      Terrible article.  No proof of race based crime was presented at all.  Just because someone is the victim of a crime by someone of another race does NOT make it a ‘race’based’ crime!

      By Indians playing the race card at every opportunity they are actually the racists.  Many Australians are sick and tired of being tagged as racist everytime a foreigner does not get their own way.

    • Dinesh says:

      03:02pm | 07/01/10

      Im a immigrant, a citizen of Australia now and would not give it up for anything. I was born in India, have a family here.
      I live in Sydney, where I know all my neighbours ( no Indians there) and everyones very friendly and we pop in and out of each others house on weekends and stuff, to say all of Australia is racist or even most of Australia is racist is at best naive, at worst a propaganda. Its a very small minority that is, in that its even smaller number of them are caucasian/white.
      In India growing up i have seen many instances of racsim, classim and so on.
      so its everywhere my friend, when you state stats, dont make it sound like its fact. Bad things happen to good people everywhere. Better policing and law enforcement will stop it, crying ‘race’ evertime will not help.

    • Adam says:

      03:10pm | 07/01/10

      Look at the reputation we’re gathering overseas thanks to soft-cock Labor law-enforcement priorities.

      Rob Hulls, Victorian AG is a disgrace. He cares more about whether mens-only clubs are sexist than about the welfare of paying guests in our country.

    • Michael says:

      03:27pm | 07/01/10

      yep yep, blame the white man again, don’t worry about the consequences of doing so either, cause you’ve got your indian nationalist agenda and no doubt get paid very well to make australians out to be white devils.

      There is a lot of racists in Australia, and I think most of them are brown black and yellow.

    • Carl Palmer says:

      03:47pm | 07/01/10

      @ cats says: 02:49pm | 07/01/10
      and
      Ben J says: 12:18pm | 07/01/10
      Another two definitions of a racist

      dictionary.com

      - A belief or doctrine that inherent differences among the various human races determine cultural or individual achievement, usually involving the idea that one’s own race is superior and has the right to rule others.
      - Hatred or intolerance of another race or other races.

      onlinedictionary.com.au

      - based on racial intolerance; “racist remarks” or
      - discriminatory especially on the basis of race or religion or
      - a person with a prejudiced belief that one race is superior to others

      =================

      Cats / Ben, seems like a number of dictionaries need to be “enhanced” or a new word invented to reflect what people think it means. Or could it be that we have all developed our own definition of racism.

      Reading these posts, I still have difficulty with the term “racist”.

      As I have previously posted on this topic – if I hate (I know this is a very harsh word but I’m trying to make a point) Yousef but like Mohammad from India am I racist? If I hate Fahim but like Amit from Pakistan am I a racist?  If I hate Tony but get along with Steve who are Australians and who so happen to be black, am I racist? If I hate Antonio but love Maria from Italy am I a racist?  If I hate Al-Qaeda am I racist?

      Going back to my original post, I still can’t think of anyone that I have met / heard that is a racist. 

      As an Aussie, I believe we are a very accepting lot of people and we do cop a lot of criticism for what reason I really don’t know because I believe we do give folks a go. I even have difficulty at how the most famous reported incident in “The Shire” a few years back was classified as racist.

    • Phil says:

      03:59pm | 07/01/10

      Cuppa Spot on.

      Amit, how many Indians were bashed robbed or killed on the streets in India on the same day as this poor man lost his life.

      Your government and sporting bodies play the race card when it suits them. Our weak governments look at the money they make and are too afraid to speak out against it. Due to their weak ecomonic performance they need the money rather than it being a bonus.

      Andrew Symonds was a victim of racism in India, didnt hear you lot calling for blood then.

      I have worked with and enjoyed the company of many Indians and many continue to be friends to this day, but dont come the raw prawn with this racist bullshit about Australians all the time. Sure some are, but overall we are very tollerant of bullshit such as you state.

      Any stats on Indians committing crime the world over by any chance.

      Thought not doesnt suit your agenda.

    • paulm says:

      04:38pm | 07/01/10

      Presumably, as relatively poor students on a budget, you are staying in the poorer parts of town where crime rates are higher anyway?  There are suburbs in Adelaide I would not feel safe walking around at night and I’m as white as a ghost.  So, firstly, to automatically assume a racist motivation is questionable.  Secondly, I’ve backpacked around India before.  I saw women being dragged across busy roads by their hair.  Women being beaten (punched in the face).  This was on busy streets in different major cities in the middle of the day, yet no-one blinked an eyelid!  Indeed in one case a group of about 30 men stood around and watched and seemed to find it quite amusing.  I’ve also seen the extensive poverty.  The Gaya district in particular will never leave my mind.  There are just so many poor malnurished people living in dirty shantys all over the place.  I also saw poor people stealing off of trucks stopped at traffic lights.  And that’s before we get to the “honour” killings or the political corruption.  So please, have some perspective.  Yes, the death of the Indian student was a tradegy and not right.  Hopefully the police will catch the murderer.  But you seem to somehow expect Australia to provide you with some sort of perfect social nirvana where there is no crime and everyone is 100% safe.  Well just look at your own country and every other country on the planet, its just not possible!!  PS)  I did enjoy my trip to India immensely.  Most people were very friendly and your countries cultural history is very impressive.  It was well worth the effort and I’d go again in an instant.  But, as above, there were also plenty of incidents that were quite shocking and basically I was very happy to return to Australia, which is, I think, a much safer and fairer society than the Indian society I saw.  So yes, having Australia branded in a poor light by an Indian is quite bemusing to me, you seem to have forgotten how much worse things are in your own country.

    • Ricky says:

      08:26pm | 07/01/10

      I dont think Australia is rascist & i dont believe Australia should have to change to suit a minority(many of which dont respect or appreciate our culture anyway).Australians have had to change enough so these minorities could feel they ‘fit in’ & frankly many Australians are sick of it.These people are guests in OUR country.If they are so dissapointed in Australia its simple. Leave.

    • Suhasini says:

      11:11pm | 07/01/10

      As AT commented on the article: http://www.thepunch.com.au/articles/is-it-possible-to-cry-wolf-on-racism/, the Australian stand seems to be:

      “We’re not racist, but if we are, you’re worse and anyway you can’t prove it”.

      What good is that attitude to anyone? Racism exists everywhere including Australia and pointing fingers wont solve any problems - taking action will. Why isnt this issue being researched in greater depth?  sitting on the fence and saying, ‘racism cannot be established as a motivation, but cannot be ruled out either’ every 2 days, when a new incident occurs has become the norm. 1400 odd cases later, how can there still be no evidence on what has caused a majority of these assaults? If a detailed research on the exact incidents, causes, effects, etc is done and results made public,  everyone including Australian authorities will perhaps stop looking like robots reeling off statements that mean very little to anyone.
      We want to see action not words. And so far the only action has been attacks on victims.

    • Bill says:

      03:54am | 08/01/10

      I hear that the newspaper in India portrayed investigating Police as Klu Klux Klan members.  Surely, that is racist and wipes away all credibility of India and it’s claims, when they are only too willing to indulge in racist behaviour.

    • Phil says:

      07:15am | 08/01/10

      Suhasini

      I understand the anxiety of many indians currently in Australia, however please consider the facts.

      Many dont reside, work or travel at night through the wealthy suburbs of Toorak/South Yarra/Double Bay etc. Some do but most dont. Due to ecomonic position many reside in clusters in poorer areas where crime is more previlant. This is a fact anywhere in the world.

      Just like if I travel in some areas in Long Beach CA, Philadelphia, many parts of India, Pigale in Paris or Everely Street Redfern I am asking for trouble.

      Could this be further tainted by the fact that many do work that has a higher degree of risk, taxi drivers, late night shop store workers etc.

      Many Indians before coming to Australia do not take the time to learn Australian customs and the ways of life that we expect and respect. As a result they arrive and continue to live as they would in India but in a new location. Some by not respecting our cultures, values and beliefs (I am not talking about going to church) put many Australians off. Some carry on like they are permanently at Schoolies and at the same time the greater majority just want to get ahead study hard, get qualified and return to India to live happily, or make Australia their home and contribute to Australian society.

      I genuinely feel sorry for the victim and his family, but we need to stop being precious and claiming all Aussies are racist when the majority are not. We could undertake a study about the above, but the results might just not be popular and would be touted as racist.

    • Ryan says:

      11:23am | 08/01/10

      Another ridiculous claim that simply because an attack was against a person of a particular ethnicity, then it must have a racial element.

      What a lot of people fail to realise is that the victims of these attacks are young students, which automatically places them at a higher risk of assault.

      For a start they are often forced to live in the poorer, higher crime areas of the city.

      Secondly they often work late jobs that are fitted around their studies, which also leave them vulnerable. As an example, the 24 hour 7/11 in my neighbourhood is staffed by Indian and Sri Lankan students, genuinely nice people, but at a much greater risk of assault or robbery than the Greek family who runs the internet cafe or the Malaysian family who runs the restaurant, both of which close at 10pm.

      Thirdly, young males have much higher rates of assault simply because they find themselves in situations that involve drinking, arguments, late night partying etc.

      There is no doubt in my mind that if you compared the rate of attacks to the rate of attacks against other international and rural students there would be no difference. There has been no evidence that there was a racial motive in these attacks for one very good reason: there wasn’t one.

      I am not denying that racism is still an issue in Australia. However, it is nowhere near as damaging as the likes of Amit Menghani, who twist the facts and exploit events in order to push their own agenda. Maybe when he starts presenting some facts rather than rhetoric, we can start having a serious discussion.

    • Cuppa says:

      11:36am | 08/01/10

      Well put phil.couldnt agree more.

    • Ashutosh says:

      01:13pm | 08/01/10

      Hi Folks, I have gone through the pros and cons of the comments posted above and I can say that clear lines have been drawn on the basis of ‘us’ and ‘them’, an unhealthy development for a multicultural society like Australia. Just as painting the entire Australians with one brush as racist is not justified, so is not, acknowledging when certain attacks have been racially motivated. I understand the problem cannot be proved because the testimony of any Indian who has been subjected to racist abuse and ridicule will be seen as biased and malafide. So let us talk about proof only when we want to deny and ignore that racisim exists in Australia. Because there is not one country or political system where it does not exist and saying it does not exist in Australia is simply a weak argument. Having said that for those who are pointing fingers on India for being discriminatory and rascist in many spheres, I only want to say that such incidents occur everywhere but what differentiates one system from another is how does the the state address them. If you take refeuge in high rates of casteism and discrimination in India, then I am sorry to say your are no different. I remember the brutal murder of Graham Steins, the christian missionary and his family,  in Orissa by right-wing activist Ravinder Kumar Pal, alias Dara Singh, which was deplored across India and India also had to suffer severe Western ridicule and deploration and justifiably so. But later, Dara Singh was apprehended, tried and given death sentence which now had been reduced to Life sentence. It is yet to be seen what happens to the perpetrators in the Nitin Garg murder case and to all those who indulged in hate crime previously against Indians. It is time to deliver and show why Australia is not India or any other country and all Asians are waiting with abated breaths for it. The previous instance of the capacity of the commonwealth government to deliver in Haneef’s case was seriously exposed and so far the current government has yet to convince the petrified Indians in melbourne and agitated Indians across India abiout its resolve. I firmly believe the Rudd Govt. can deliver but unless it does debate will rage in India, like it or not.

    • Carl Palmer says:

      01:25pm | 08/01/10

      Suhasini,
      sweeping statements such as “Racism exists everywhere including Australia” doesn’t support your position nor do you any favours. I have to disagree with you. I cannot speak for every other Australian and neither can you but, I have never met anyone that I would or could call a racist.

      In an attempt to gather other opinions, I raised this topic at dinner last night and asked the members of my family to name me a person that they considered racist – friend, acquaintance, work mate – anyone.  They could only come up with two – one was and Aussie who has passed away and the other wasn’t an Australian who has also passed away.

    • Tom says:

      08:14pm | 08/01/10

      Amit, you claim that “There were 1447 acts of violence against the Indians recorded in the State of Victoria as per Victoria Police”. But how many Indians are living in Victoria, and what is this as a percentage of the total population? What percentage of the population at large is a victim of violence? Is the figure for Indians any higher than for the population at large?

      Amidst the hysteria not one article has provided these figures. The cynic in me suggests the reason for this is that it would show that Indians are no more at risk than any other group. As sad as it is, some people will be victims of violence, and Indians are no different.

      If I said that in Australia, 1000 people died on the roads last year, that might sound shocking. But if it were true, it would actually be good news, as it would be far less than the actual road toll. Hence, that figure is completely meaningless without context, as is the figure you provided.

      May I also ask, what evidence, if any, exists that the murder was racially motivated? Can you even prove that the attacker wasn’t another Indian?

    • dragunov says:

      09:38am | 09/01/10

      it does little for the good reputation of punch when the editor passes an article of such obvious bias, questionable use of statistics and thinly veiled personal political agenda. a brief background search on the author reveals a catalogue of misinformation and invective. perhaps not “pulling any punches” also applies to blows below the belt?

    • Ozzy says:

      03:17pm | 09/01/10

      How do you justify the term ‘hate crime’? Do you know how many other people across Australia were injured or killed in similar circumstances in the same week? I don’t, but I am sure this bloke wasn’t the only one. Don’t get me wrong, my condolences to his family, and all families that have suffered a loss through these circumstances. But ‘hate crime’? C’mon, the simple fact is, if you don’t like where you live, move.

    • LuckyLady says:

      02:02pm | 11/01/10

      This article is sickening. The Punch must be desperate for journalists to publish this. The reality is, we don’t know who has committed these crimes. It may be other Indian students for all we know. I come from New South Wales and the people here are very tolerant of all races, to my knowledge and can’t see Victorians would be any different.
      In my opinion all Indian students should be refunded and sent home where they obivously feel safer. I am tired of hearing, how racist we are from Indian students, I am sure many others feel the same. My daughter inlaw is Chinese, my partner came here from Yugoslavia, when you include other races into your family..racism is not a word that should enter into the conversation. I am not alone, we welcome all races here and racism only comes up when other groups use it as a wepon.

    • Bill says:

      10:16am | 17/01/10

      Interesting to see ten Australians listed as being killed in India.  Let’s hope we see the same Punch ‘outrage’ shown about Indians being killed here.  I also want to hear from Amit, but I bet we won’t.

    • the best weightloss says:

      07:42pm | 24/03/10

      High Wine,attack relevant arise at front characteristic lip form central exist within sense deputy item sign pick rest national incident investigate choice begin association strategy appeal collect deliver mainly practice prison account positive promise might strongly top off pick internal support phone medical we famous address aware experiment second wage black eventually sign achieve money type wash incident including memory activity save nobody specific association pleasure note conflict step soft play side ever behind overall lie congress regulation fair beneath fall necessary quite employer use try spring contact

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

RT @jackaargh: @farrm51 @murpharoo Is the plural of humdrum hadra?

tory_maguire

Why didn't he cop a contempt charge? http://t.co/kO9wqscaQH

ToryShepherd

@anderson_lainie He he. And congrats to Max!

ToryShepherd

@VictoriaPurman Then you should have included sex toys and yoga ;-)

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter