When Julia Gillard appeared on stage at the end of a punishing Saturday night to try to make sense of the deadlocked election result she opened with a quote from former President Bill Clinton after a previous US election: “The people have spoken, but it’s going to take a little while to determine exactly what they said.”

Hey Julia - maybe the answer is in one of these! Tim Mathieson the morning after the election. Picture: Mark Smith

Well, if she is still in doubt about the message the people of Australia sent through the ballot box, she might like to read what they have been saying in cyberspace.

Even before election night was over, voters started sending a flurry of comments to online news sites with explanations and their own analysis of why the nation was staring at a hung parliament.

While a swag of marginal seats in Queensland and NSW recorded a swing to the Coalition, this was not necessarily seen as an endorsement of them by commenters. The overall mood was mainly one of disappointment with both Labor and the Coalition and a feeling that neither side had convinced the electorate of their worthiness to rule.

As Dieter D pointed out on ABC Online: “Labor and Liberal spent the entire campaign trying to convince Australia the other party wasn’t fit to govern - and succeeded.”

Posting on Perth Now, Mark of Perth thought Labor had self-destructed but he did not find much inspiration in Tony Abbott as an alternative: “I’m pretty sure it had more to do with Labor’s political suicide rather than anything wondrous Abbott did. Both leaders were just as uninspiring as each other and this was reflected by an uninspiring election result.”

Comments revealed a mixed bag of issues that contributed to the ruptured Labor vote. 

Graham of Oz on News.com.au highlighted two that influenced him not to return a Gillard Government: “Labor lost my support due to the mining tax. However, they lost my respect when they dumped a democratically-elected leader. I could have been wrong, but I doubt whether the loss would have been greater with Kevin Rudd as leader … It will take me a long time to trust the Labor machine again.”

In a comment to ABC Online, Daniel F said Labor had lost touch with its traditional support base: “They didn’t have the courage to stand up on matters that their supporters care about - principally doing something meaningful about climate change and taking a compassionate approach to refugees. Too much ‘me-too’ made them look like a cynical and weak imitation of Tony Abbott.”

Labor suffered its biggest losses in Queensland and NSW. Courier-Mail reader Ian Coffey of Townsville cited the influence state politics had and called for the Queensland Premier to resign: “The fact of the matter is that the two states with the highest swings against Labor happen to be where the state Labor governments are most on the nose. Anna Bligh, do the decent thing and fall on your sword for all our sakes.”

Terry of NQ added: “Regardless of the final outcome, the message is loud and clear. Labor has to clean out the backroom boys and the toxic state leadership in Queensland and NSW and actually get back to looking after the working people of this country as they have failed to do in the last three years. Labor at a state and federal level has proved to be mushrooms, big heads and short stalks. How long before the Queensland election? I can’t wait.”

Daniel of Melbourne, in a comment to The Herald Sun, pointed to the large swag of voters who decided to swing to the Greens: “I can tell the major parties what happened. It wasn’t leaks, it wasn’t fiscal policy. It was a complete absence of any real difference in policy and maybe the absence of any real policy. At least the Greens still believe in something and work to achieve real objectives.”

The possibility of Labor obtaining the backing of three or four Independents to form government did not inspire much confidence for change in the eyes of News.com.au reader Ironic: “So it is now up to four independent men rather than six faceless union leaders. Does anyone feel like we have moved forward?”

Steve questioned the governing ability of a minority Labor government, writing on the Herald Sun site: “Labor weren’t stable with a majority government. How could they be stable with a minority one?”

Meanwhile, Eddie of Sydney, predicted the instability would lead to another election being called before too long: “Here we go. A hung parliament with independents running the country. It does not matter which side buys the prize it will not last and we will be voting again within 18 months.”

Some online readers thought the spectre of a hung parliament should prompt changes to the electoral system. An optimistic Lincoln Fung of Canberra, writing to The Australian, said: “The new uncertain political landscape may also present unprecedented opportunities to reform Australia’s election system, more independent and effective federal policy assessments and scrutinies. The hung parliament may be shorter in life, but it may start a new political chapter for the future earlier.”

So who really won Saturday’s election?

In the unending hangover from the election maelstrom, Herald Sun reader Tony of Melbourne declared democracy the victor: “The Australian voting public have come of age! As a nation we have seen through the lies, hypocrisy and political spin of both sides of political persuasion. We don’t want any of them to have a free rein over our lives because we do not trust them at the moment. We await a true leader. Congratulations to the Australian public!”

The people have spoken.

19 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • John A Neve says:

      07:52am | 24/08/10

      “The people have spoken, but what did they say?”
      I’d like to believe they have said we are sick of Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum.

      This result in my view is the best result if the parliament remains a hung one. It is, I hope the first crack in our dualopoly system. One can only hope the Greens and Independents make the most of this opportunity and give all Australians some hope for the future.

    • Joe Blow says:

      08:34am | 24/08/10

      I think way to much is being made about what the people said.  In essence, all that has happened is that in the absence of any realdifferentiation, or any visionary policies being put forward, the population just defaulted to the party that they historically voted for, or made a ‘home town’ decision in the case of SA and Vic. 

      It is ridiculous for the media to portray this as somehow the people cast their votes so as to ensure a hung parliament???

    • Rosie says:

      09:00am | 24/08/10

      So much has been said after the Election from Politicians, media and the public that I am beginning to feel a little apprehensive about which major party is better suited to form a minority Govt.

      My understanding is that the PM in this case Julia Gillard has the first say if she has the numbers and Tony Abbott only comes into play otherwise. The Opposition needs 73 seats before they can even think about forming a minority party. I think if the Opposition ends up with 73 seats Tony Abbott will be PM because he is more likely to have the 3 Independents on his side.

    • All says:

      10:58am | 24/08/10

      Not much chance of that. Only Katter will stand back, the other two will turn their backs on the 90%  in their electorates who voted against the ALP and cling to Gillard. If they had gone into the election as independent Labor they would not have been elected. Just like the 3 independent Liberals and the National party member who fell victim to the gifts of office by Mike Ranns Labor in SA in 2002 they will be forever tarred as political crossdressers with no morals. How anyone can turn their backs on their own constituency is beyond belief. To join Labor just because a green dominated senate will be less obstructionist also defies belief, after all, the complaints against the last Howard term was that it had no opposition in the senate. and as a result could pass legislation unhindered. Join Labor and the BER ripoffs, pink batt debacles will continue unabated and at greater frequency.

    • Rosie says:

      02:50pm | 24/08/10

      All says

      I am hoping the push from the bush will do the right thing for their constituties and stay away from the Gillard Govt. If it is correct that Labor has 72 seats, Julia Gillard is in the position to make a visit to the Governor General if she has already made a deal with the 3 Independents. Labor 72
      Greens 1 and Independents 3 which will give Labor 76 seats. Hey Presto! Done Deal we wait no longer, Julia Gillard is our PM.

      Isn’t it a sign that the 3 Independents are not interested in hooking up with the Julia Gillard Labor Govt???????????

      Another scenario would be if Tony Abbott doesn’t get his 73 seats and only ends up with 72 seats and Gillard has 74 seats + 1 Green = 75 seats, she will need an Independent to form a Minority Govt. This will mean that the 3 Independents will have to spilt as Gillard will only need one of them to get her 76 seats required to form a minority Govt. Will the Independents spilt?????? I don’t think so!

      I think the silly Greens guy should have kept his mouth shut and not say he was going to serve in the Gillard Govt because now Gillard is stuck with him.

      This has been a lesson to the people, the media and our politicians so whatever the outcome we would have learnt not to take elections for granted. The people should take more interest during an election and when casting their vote should bear in mind that they are voting for good governance. The media should refrain from confusing the public and politicians should be more honest with themselves. Last but not the least there should only be 2 Polls - 1st and last day of the Election Campaign.

      I have a feeling that if Tony Abbott doesn’t get his 73 seats and Gillard 75 seats we will be looking at another Election.

      What will be will be! I am not anxiously waiting anymore!

    • Old Clive says:

      09:20am | 24/08/10

      Computers and the press have disabled our minds, we have been dumbed down by the technology and the majority of voters don’t know how to think and disseminate information anymore, on that basis Labor will rule forevermore,even after that when they bankrupt us with their NBN, I hope the Gunyahs of the outback have electricity and landlines before long so that that project can be completed. Then social services can pay for the computers and the ISP.

    • Robert s McCormick says:

      11:35am | 24/08/10

      As envisaged by the writers of the Australian Constitution, from 1901 until about 1910-12 Australia had Parliamentary Democracy. Our elected representatives actually believed in working for the advancement of Australia & it’s People. The advent of Political Parties put an end to it.
      Rob Oakeshott & at least two of the other three Independents have suggested our MPs (House of Representatives & Senate), once elected, should remove the Red/Blue (&Green;?) demarcation lines which currently exist & all of them work together for the benefit of Australia & it’s People. This would result in the best brains being appointed Ministers. Peter Costello was widely regarded, even by his foes, as being a brilliant Federal Treasurer. After the 2007 election what happened? He got put out to pasture on the Opposition Benches! A totally wasted talent.
      This happens every time there is a change of government. It is a disgrace. This hung Parliament is the best thing that could possibly have happened to Australia. If certain people would put aside their overwhelming egos,their lust for power, their arrogance & misplaced belief in their own brilliance & acknowledged that there are others who are every bit as clever & intelligent as they are & started to use them we could have a decent outcome.
      All the self-styled expert Political Commentators are already accusing the likes of Rob Oakeshott of entertaining Utopian ideas of True Parliamentary Democracy. They are wrong. We did have it once, we could have it again!

    • Peter says:

      01:46pm | 24/08/10

      @ Robert, spot on mate. Having had a look at these 3 independants holding the balance of power, God sent these people to us to fix up things in Canberra. I am so happy about the result and feel so comfortable about who is holding the balance of power, it makes me feel proud about the election result..

      Things have to change, and whether you are red or blue, i think we can all agree on that… As an example, a government appointed speaker would tell parliament that a minister is trying to answer a question even if he were merely picking his nose to torment the opposition.. Honestly, how they have been getting away with that for so long just defies belief….

    • Joe Blow says:

      02:56pm | 24/08/10

      @Peter Well if they were sent by God they are hardly going to support an atheist.

    • Reg says:

      04:36pm | 24/08/10

      Now now Joe, you’re tempting the hand of God, telling us what he will and won’t do. God is a great Labor supporter, he told me.

    • Peter says:

      12:12pm | 24/08/10

      This is what the people said, it wasn’t about stopping the boats, it was about stopping the bullshit we’ve been getting from Canberra for the last few years.

      It has degenerated into a farce..

      We need parlimentary reform, election reform, political party donation reform, more transperacy, more open dialogue with the public.

      This little taste of town hall meetings/debate that we had should be the norm in election campaings and should be held every second day. It should also include the Greens who have a large enough support to justify being included (im not a fan of the Greens but im a fan of democracy).

      The people voted for change. They want the bullshit to end.. And that’s why we weren’t willing to give either of them a mandate…

    • TheRealDave says:

      02:19pm | 24/08/10

      yes, because a hung parliament what was everyone planned….

    • Peter says:

      02:54pm | 24/08/10

      @ The real Dave. If you were standing in the same queue that I was last Saturday, you would have been standing with a group of people who still didn’t know how they were voting..

      Even the people handing out the how to vote cards were talking about the disgrace this election was. I’ve never seen it before. At least we were all having a laugh..

      This hung parliament may not have happened by design, but it happened i think because it was meant to happen. The universe somehow worked it’s magic.

      There a no shortage of people i know who aren’t delighted by this result. It might get our representatives in Canberra working for the country instead of playing party political games… People are sick of it..

      Turnball and Rudd were prepared to be bigger than that, but they got dumped for their troubles… Sad loss for us I say…

    • Andrew says:

      02:17pm | 24/08/10

      As far as I was concerned the election was a no win senario. One of the big issues for me was Conroy and his filter. That one issue made me do something I never imagined myself doing, voting for someone other than Labor, and I know many other people for whom this one issue was enough for them to change their vote.

      The problem is the Libs are no better, so who do you vote for then? I think we don’t want Libs and ALP being carbon copies of each other, and that is exactly where they where heading, we want real alternatives.

    • mervyn ford says:

      03:34pm | 24/08/10

      We didn’t all get together before election day and decide to vote for a hund parliament!
      Ther was a 12% swing against the labor party.Included in that swing was labor voters whocould not bring them selves to vote liberal so they went further left to the greens.
      I believe that mainstream media has a lot to answer for.
      They either blindly report the day’s sound bite or inflict us with teir political bias, not once was there any in depth analysis, pollies pulled up for half truths or outright lies.
      I think we can improve govt by getting rid of the press gallery.

    • Jay says:

      04:39pm | 24/08/10

      Labor gave everyone the stimulus package, tax cuts,increased the pension by a wopping $32.00 per week,gave away free insulation, tried to get the carbon tax through but was blocked by the Greens…and they still got smashed at the polls. This will teach them one lesson. Never give away anything in your first year or your second year, because people never remember. If there is nothing to give away in the final year of your term your time is up.Howard always gave the goodies in the last year and that is what people remembered.People are stupid and the Labor Party momentarily forgot this and now they are paying the price.Here endeth the lesson.

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      08:29pm | 24/08/10

      Hard to believe Tim and Joolya are so old-fashioned as to actually require hardcopies of the news. Thought she was the harbinger of the digital revolution.

      Or something.

    • masealake says:

      01:28pm | 26/08/10

      Why a minority government good to Australia people?
      People will have better resources supported of lives
      A letter regarding “Shaping a Healthy and Wealthy Future for Australia “sent to The Prime Minister Kevin Rudd on 29 October 2009.
      My “Health Olympic Australia” project will not only assist the Australian Government to shape a better health system for Australians but will also improve the general health of Australians. This will put Australia in a strong position for long term wealth generation and prosperity.
      “The China Project” is referred “The China Study” outcome conducted jointly by Cornell University, Oxford University, and the Chinese Academy of Preventive Medicine over the course of twenty years.
      Prime Minister, the steps that will allow Australia to pioneer in achieves the worlds “Health Economy” is by Australia:
      • Inventing health improvement patterns;
      • Growing high antioxidant healthy grains and plants;
      • Manufacturing high antioxidant healthy grain powder products;
      • Exporting its health improvement knowledge and pattern; and
      • Exporting health improvement resources (including human resources).
      The highest regards
      Ma kee wai
      (Member of Inventor Association Queensland since 1993)

    • masealake says:

      05:58pm | 01/10/10

      What democratic societies should learn lessen from Australia election 2010:
      1.  What productive action has PM Julia Gillard in office 100 days?
      When inflation is a looming threat, with the nation’s CPI growing by 3.5 per cent year on year - a 22-month high - just last month.
      When ultimately slow down the country’s growth and subsequently hose down the demand for Australian commodities.
      The Australia historical hung parliament demonstrated the big gap of inequality society between the small educated elite groups who get highest pay by talk feast used mouth work controlling live essential resources of the country in every social platforms against the biggest less educated groups who get lowest pay by hands work squeezed by discriminative policies that sucking live blood from individual poor/less wealth off?
      Ma kee wai
      (Member of Inventor Association Queensland since 1993)

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

#markwebber just wasted petrol faster than everyone else in monaco #f1

Anthony Sharwood

In my sports column on The Punch tomorrow: why Eurovision was easily the best game on the weekend. Mummy bloggers, you'll like this one!

Daniel Piotrowski

The Logies could learn a lot from Eurovision #lamethings#sbseurovision

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @ellehardytweets: Already despondent about the next fifty one weeks. #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter