If you ever find yourself in a foreign prison awaiting representation from Australia on your behalf just pray that West Australian Premier Colin Barnett does not come through the door.

WA Premier Colin Barnett was happy to talk to journalists aftter spending several hours walking on his knees to the forbidden city

Not only is he unlikely to put up any kind of a fight for you, after a big Yum Cha lunch he may well agree to pull the hanging lever should your executioner be off sick.

Like the prince of a Chinese tributary kingdom of the middle-ages Colin Barnett travelled to Shanghai to assure his leaders that he wasn’t angry at them over the arrest of Stern Hu – actually it was our fault as Australians for over-reacting.

Comments last night from the Western Australian Premier Colin Barnett have gone relatively under the radar, but if you haven’t seen them they get full marks for gutlessness.

While trying to sell to some news outlets the line that he had given the mayor of Shanghai a stern talking to over imprisonment of Rio Tinto’s Stern Hu, one gets the feeling that Mayor Han Zheng would hardly have been rushing off to Beijing with the message. You can read more of his comments here.

“I told the mayor I see this as an individual case and it should be dealt with according to Chinese law and every Australian would respect that.

“I made the point that we respect the Chinese legal system and its sovereignty and the judicial process and I would make no comment on that.

“However, I did say I had a concern for Mr Hu and his family and also that we would hope that the case could proceed as quickly as possible. I asked for Australian consular staff to have greater access to Mr Hu.”

Wow - strong stuff.

No mention of “gee it would be nice if he could have a lawyer” or maybe “could we perhaps be told what it is this guy is supposed to have done before he rots for several years without trial”.

But the really entertaining stuff was yet to come.

Apparently it was Australia’s fault for stirring the pot over Hu.

According to Barnett, businesses - which are perhaps concerned that their employees might end up in jail in China now - and the pesky media could be putting the whole Australian-Chinese relationship at risk. Have a look at the Lateline transcript here.

“China is more important to Australia than Australia is to China. And as Australians and people working and representing Australian business, I just urge you to be very conscious of that.

“I do have a concern that the amount of attention that this issue is attracting could in some way damage the long-term relationship between Australia and China.

“We depend on the growth of China and China continuing to buy from Australia for our economic prosperity. So I think it’s a very clear message. And in fact the message was not so much directed at China, but directed at Australia and Australian business people: don’t underestimate, don’t complicate and don’t confuse the relationship with China.”

While Kevin Rudd and Stephen Smith have been criticised for not being tough enough with China over Hu’s detention, they look like some kind of Green Beret rescue squadron compared to the West Australian premier.

Even Trade Minister Simon Crean is demanding more answers from the Chinese in recent days, pointing out the bloke is yet to even be charged with anything:

“We don’t know what the charges are because the charges haven’t been laid,” Crean said.

“We’ve been asking the Chinese government and the authorities to give us more and better particulars and to do it expeditiously.”

If anyone is confused with the handling of Hu it appears it is Colin Barnett - confused as to when it is appropriate to stand-up for wacky ideas like the human rights of Australian citizens even if it could mean a few bumps along his precious silk road.

18 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Seymour Regarde says:

      06:33pm | 22/07/09

      Great piece. As a West Australian this wanker is an embarrassment to us all, but is a reminder of just how lax and faux tolerant these Liberal creeps have been in the past in WA, not much better than their carpet-bagging Labor mates, selling out the people and the land’s resources to often the lowest bidder.

    • David JC says:

      06:42pm | 22/07/09

      Since when has foreign policy and consular assistance been the responsibility of state premiers? At least Barnett is actually IN China making some sort of representations on Hu’s behalf. Where have our intrepid China experts Rudd and Smith disappeared to all of a sudden? Its not like Kevin to be shy of jumping on a plane and heading off into the sunset at the drop of a hat. Apparently Comrade Fitzgibbon has a bit of spare time on his hands lately, why don’t they send him over to kow tow and grovel to the Chicoms?

    • Jeff W says:

      10:47pm | 22/07/09

      What can we expect Colin Barnett to do or to say while Rudd, Turnbull and Bishop all have been muted these days? The ore continues to be shipped to China, the media has been cooling down, the RIo denied, Mr. Hu is still detained…
      What will be happened is likely that Australians will enjoy the benefits from the Chinese buying money, the government will be happy with Chinese early recovery that will create more jobs in this country, the RIO will continue to be profited from the Chinese contract and then Mr. Hu may pay the cost of all these in Chinese jail.
      Is it fair?
      Why RIO denied so earlier? What strategy does the RIO take?
      Why the Australian media fueled up the heat and left the consequences with Mr. Hu?
      Why the media has never questioned or pressured RIO over the issue rather than inaccurately reported the issue with speculations to mislead the public?

    • Bruce says:

      10:56pm | 22/07/09

      This article smacks of political opportunism at its best and possibly a lack of understanding how best to deal with the chinese. However, this article could be a “fishing exercise!!”. There is a good chance that most chinese officials would not know who Colin Barnett is, or would even care and certainly would not deal with a “lowly” state premier. They appear not to care or have any interest in Kevin Rudd. So does this article imply that all state premiers should start individually “Barking” at the Chinese? Considering the delicate nature of dealing with the chinese, such as “loosing face issues” etc, solving the problem at hand would be better handled by the diplomats and the best attempts of the federal government. Remember, Kevin speaks chinese, the chinese should get the message loud and clear.

    • Ryan says:

      05:07am | 23/07/09

      Its Colin’s job to look after the people of Western Australia.
      KRudd and the DFAT are the ones who should be looking after Rio Tinto’s spy.

    • M says:

      06:36am | 23/07/09

      Jeff W: Please attend some grammar classes before posting again. Your comments are difficult if not impossible to understand.

    • Madison says:

      06:44am | 23/07/09

      Remember Nguyen? The drug mule hanged in Singapore? If you commit the crime, you do the time. The Chinese authorities would not come down so hard on a foreign national if there was any doubt on his innocence. Hu has more than likely done something out of line. Yes, they have not laid charges yet but the delay is nothing out of the ordinary. Hu has not been treated any different to any Chinese national awaiting trial. Why the Australian public is in uproar is beyond me. Do the wrong thing in the wrong place and expect to face the consequences.

    • Joel B1 says:

      08:59am | 23/07/09

      Rudd’s happy enough to send a delegation on a trip to India to protect foreign students but can’t seem to manage a single phone call on behalf of an Australian citizen.

      Rudd’s a lousy PM.

    • Jeff W says:

      12:49pm | 23/07/09

      M: Your response was pretty much the Chinese style while you disliked my comments you picked up the grammar issue just as the Chinese did while they dislike the RIO behavior they picked up Stern Hu.
      Make a comment with the major issue if you can.

    • Kym says:

      02:03pm | 23/07/09

      Cant tell you how tired I am of the faux machismo surronding the plight of Mr Hu - their country their rules - no amount of yelling and tub thumping will change that - even if the charges are trumped up— and the assumption at this end of the world that they are just becuase it is china is typical white guy arrogance

    • CR says:

      02:23pm | 23/07/09

      I can only guess that Kevin 707 hasn’t given enough spare change to the boys that operate his 737, otherwise they’d already have been down to Dick Smith’s & loaded up the ‘China & environs’ DVD into the on-board GPS and the plane would have long ago made landing skid marks on the runway in Beijing.

    • M says:

      02:52pm | 23/07/09

      Jeff W: You are completely out of line. The fact is I agree with what I can make of your previous comment. My request for you to use proper grammar on this forum was my one and only genuine concern. Please do not assume my point of view especially when I haven’t presented one.

    • miantiao says:

      03:30pm | 23/07/09

      the argument ‘our country, our rules’  is often used by Authoritarian regimes to justify all manner of laws. Western post-strucuralist philosophy and subsequent notions of cultural-relativism are the tools with which such govts use as justification. Those of the ‘Their country, their rules’  pursuasion are no better than the thugs and bullies implementing such laws.

      By proxy they are supporting the repression and in-humane treatment of the citizens of authoritarian and dictatorial regimes around the world.
      Well done those punters, hope your gratified.

    • M says:

      03:36pm | 23/07/09

      @m
      give him a fair go mate!  How’s your mandarin?

    • M says:

      04:30pm | 23/07/09

      It’s actually pretty good. I’m chinese!

    • miantiao says:

      05:12pm | 23/07/09

      @M
      zhendema!! haoxiang ni jiu shi pian wo de!! yaoshi ni zhende shi zhongguoren de hua, qing ni lai fanyi zhe ju: kill the chicken to scare the monkey.

    • M says:

      08:01pm | 23/07/09

      I’m not lying.

    • johnv_au says:

      11:22am | 06/08/09

      Colins gone at the next election he wants chinese only run mine sites and australian run mine sites to get over the language barrier (bollocks Barnett )

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

RT @mumbletwits: +1 MT @meadea Adding voice to the boss RT @abcmarkscott: Hereby instruct @Colvinius to make a swift return to good health. (Take care Mark.)

Paul Colgan

Greece makes the final and Ireland gets in on a golden ticket. How awkward and embarrassing. Love it. #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Every single #eurovision band is roxette #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

The weird thing about #eurovision is you've got this massive collection of dorks in a room and no one is wearing Spock ears #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We didn’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We didn’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter