I wasn’t upset when Princess Diana died. I didn’t know her, never met her, thought she seemed like a bit of a dill.

Princess Diana is dead: and that's not funny either.

Sad for her family but that’s life isn’t it. One day it’s all going to end. Hopefully not naked in a cupboard in Bangkok like David Carradine but you just don’t know.

If I’d said this about Diana in 1997, I would’ve been screamed at. Because the world was united in grief. You’d hear people interviewed outside Buckingham Palace going, I never shed a tear when my own grandmother died but here I am crying like a baby. Because the world was united in grief. The IRA, Welsh coal miners, Camilla Parker Bowles, everyone. United in grief.

And now there’s universal condemnation of The Chaser. Universal condemnation from the church, politicians, all of us. It said so on A Current Affair last night.

Of course, Kevin Rudd didn’t actually see their Make a Realistic Wish Foundation skit but he did have it explained to him – using glove puppets, possibly – which led him to direct The Chaser to hang their head.

It wasn’t as far as Wendy went, a distraught mother who was interviewed by A Current Affair.

They should be hung, drawn and quartered, she said. In the town square.

Steve Price’s recommended treatment was for them to spend a day at a children’s cancer ward.

Every time I see pictures of a celebrity touring a children’s hospital ward I want to throw up.

Now that’s what I call child exploitation.

And how the hell does Steve Price know what The Chaser guys have been through in their personal life?

Just because they – unlike, say, Rove – haven’t been dissected by a women’s magazine doesn’t mean they haven’t been across any dry gullies.

I’m a little bit old-fashioned when it comes to comedy.

I’d prefer to make up my own mind about whether to laugh, instead of being given permission by the government, or the media, or by somebody’s mother.

I didn’t find The Castle funny, as it happens, or Kath and Kim, but I’d never say that out loud.

It’d be practically seditious. And the argument that The Chaser is a waste of taxpayers’ money doesn’t cut it either. So’s Spicks and Specks. And Peter Garrett.

There is only one question The Chaser have to ask themselves: is it funny. That’s where their responsibility begins and ends. They’re comedians.

And didn’t we think they were geniuses when they walked right through the airtight APEC security. God we laughed. Risky, sure, but that’s how it is with good comedy.

There have been jokes like this before. There’s one, it’s been around for a while, about the sick kid who’s sending a charity bankrupt with his over the top demands.

The Chaser did another gag on Wednesday night, it was about a fake film called Oscar Bait. “From the Academy Award seeking producer Harvey Weinstein.’’ Which is funny if you know Harvey Weinstein. Which I don’t. But he does come across as an overly aggressive Awards campaigner. So anyway, Andrew Hansen is pretending he’s got muscular dystrophy … “I may be a gay wheelchair-bound Jew – and simple …’’ he says during his pitch for Oscar greatness. Not that funny, Kate Winslet was better as a grasping Holocaust nun on Ricky Gervais’s Extras.

Just because a joke is in bad taste doesn’t make it not funny. It’s the opposite – bad taste is generally what makes it funny. A Muslim and a Jew walk into a bar … see?

You’re laughing already.

Most commented

27 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Chris says:

      12:31pm | 05/06/09

      Was it tasteless? - probably, but their job isn’t about practicing good taste.
      Was it funny? - i didn’t think so. it missed the mark somewhat.
      Ratings for next week will be the real judge.

    • Patrick says:

      12:42pm | 05/06/09

      Nailed it like a cross Di. Oh, sorry, is that awful to say?

    • warb says:

      12:45pm | 05/06/09

      Comedians do walk a fine line some time, and generally speaking they seem to always offend someone…  this time, it was quite a few people… When i heard about it, i had a chuckle, and then the talkback comments came in.. So after scouring the net i finally found somewhere to view it.. Was it funny, no, not really, i was expecting better.. Was it bad taste, who knows, lucky we have insightful programs such a ACA to tell us what to think..

      comedy = tragedy + time

      warb

    • Robert says:

      12:47pm | 05/06/09

      Thank you! At last a voice of reason in all this.
      I was beginning to think I was the only person who understood what parody meant…
      This was to me a take-off of an advertising concept - a hackneyed cliched style of advertising many find obnoxious!
      But then I found Borat funny because of it’s commentary on American culture and lifestyle…
      While I consider The Chaser was closer to the cutting edge last season, I’ll be tuning in again next week. Because no one else (maybe Akmal excepted) is quite as honest and confronting with their ability to parody almost anything in our way too PC society.

    • Richard says:

      01:05pm | 05/06/09

      So sketches about, say, the families who died in the Victorian bushfires, the funny aspects of the deaths in the Bali bombing, the hilarious concept of terrorists slowly beheading their captives etc etc would all be fine, as long as the snotty-nosed private schoolboys of the Chaser think it’s funny.  Considerations of other people’s feelings, empathy, ordinary human decency don’t come into it.  What a frighteningly amoral attitude.

    • Shannyn says:

      01:11pm | 05/06/09

      Nah not laughing at yours or their joke!

    • Lily says:

      01:35pm | 05/06/09

      Hear, hear. We should collectively take a big breath. And as for the PM taking the high ground, anyone who was so drunk they can’t remember getting kicked out of a New York strip joint should be very careful about building glass houses.

      Bottom line: if you don’t like the show, don’t watch it!

    • Brian says:

      01:36pm | 05/06/09

      Ah sad to see so many people miss the point.  I didn’t think it was funny so I didn’t laugh, that’s it, fullstop.  I certainly do not think that bushfire victims, the Bali bombings, beheading of captives are funny either, so you will not here me laugh.  However if someone wants to try a joke about one of these subjects, then that is what freedom of speech is all about.  Just don’t veer off into vilification, and I won’t waste my time or trouble getting all offended about it, I just won’t laugh.  And if enough people don’t laugh then the Chaser will slowly fade into obscurity as an un-funny show.  Quite simply so many people saw it because so many people watch Chaser to see them send up sacred cows, and on the balance of probability they are funny, although in this instance, in my case anyway, they were not.

    • Alex says:

      01:48pm | 05/06/09

      Sometimes, I think the media are just looking for a reason to bitch about The Chaser. But that would be akin to a conspiracy theory and we all know the media isn’t that shallow.

    • RobJ says:

      02:26pm | 05/06/09

      The whole issue has confused me and made me question myself, I laugh at some sick stuff, I thought the Fritzl skit was funny, I was shocked by the ‘make a realistic wish’ skit, I was thankful my wife didn’t see it.

      But you’re spot on I don’t need Rudd to tell me if something or another is bad, I’ll make up my own mind.

      At the end of the day the Chaser can push the boundaries as much as they like but it may backfire and they may end up with no audience as a result. I think they’re losing it or maybe my recollections of earlier skits are viewed through rose coloured lenses. If they’re out of ideas (which I suspect may be true) they can do a different show.

    • Ross says:

      02:40pm | 05/06/09

      We are living through an entertainment drought.
      Like climate change it is all cyclical, with all the sadness in the world we are running out of nice things to laugh at.  Polticians are the only source of humour these days and that is very sad indeed.

    • Richard says:

      02:48pm | 05/06/09

      No Brian, it is you who miss the point.  This is not an argument about freedom of speech.  I don’t think anyone has suggested that the Chaser should be banned by law.  What I was responding to was the argument in this article that the only responsibility of the arrogant Chaser chaps is to consider whether they think it’s funny.  This is simply an issue of the wisdom or otherwise of that argument and the general merits of the Chaser sketch, not whether it or they should be banned.  What I suggest is that anyone putting anything on for public consumption should bear in mind rather wider considerations than simply their own opinion of its humour or otherwise, and they include the feelings of others.

    • Leuis says:

      03:17pm | 05/06/09

      What else was Kev going to say when asked about it? He definitely has form as an over-moraliser. He was gasping with eager outrage over the Henson photos. And at that time he didn’t even have to counterbalance the negative impact of questions of impropriety in his government. I’m surprised he didn’t go even further. Remember wthen he smacked McLelland down for suggesting that the Bali bombers should perhaps not be shot?

      I personally think Rudd is irrelevant as a comedy critic. As far as Wendy is concerned, I only hope she works for the Chaser. The pettifoggery is much more amusing than the skit was, that’s for sure.

    • T.C. says:

      04:26pm | 05/06/09

      With all this self-righteous uproar and public backlash I’m surprised the Chaser Boys haven’t been already been whisked away by the Witless Protection Program.

    • Wade of Adelaide says:

      05:31pm | 05/06/09

      Di Butler is Australia’s best satirical writer.  Full stop.  More of her on The Punch please.

    • Leuis says:

      06:07pm | 05/06/09

      T.C., It was a close thing, but after a call on the red phone from Kev, Mark Scott has opted for the Witless Persecution Program instead. It was the thought of waterboarding Chas that tipped it - just too irresistible in the end. I understand they are in orange jumpsuits on a private jet headed for Egypt.

    • Richard says:

      06:18pm | 05/06/09

      Gosh, all the smart-arse self-styled, legend in their own lunch-time humorists have certainly come out of the woodwork, haven’t they.  I guess the arrogant under-graduates on the Chaser team have cloned themselves in their audience.

    • Heléna says:

      10:14pm | 05/06/09

      whisked they have been TC - for 2 weeks
      http://www.chaser.com.au

      it’s simple really Richard if you don’t like it - don’t watch it
      I’m sure part of their ratings success can be credited to wowsers who watch the show just so they can take righteous offense

    • Michael says:

      12:36am | 06/06/09

      This is a disgrace the PC Brigade who admit they hate the show and never watch it can go to youtube get all outraged then start writing letters and whining, so all the people who didn’t get outraged are denied one of their favourite shows as a result.
      Now you watch they have won this battle against ABC, now they will go for south park on the gov funded SBS, citing all the same reasons, south park is far more offensive to some ppl then the chasers could ever be, censorship via beat up public opinion what a joke we have become, i find religious shows on ABC offensive how about taking them off air?!

    • Melissa says:

      08:50am | 06/06/09

      Spot on. I think that Oscar bait was in far more dodgy taste. And as far our self-righteous PM….

    • T.C. says:

      10:06am | 06/06/09

      The fault lies with the Chaser Boys for not thinking it through.

      They could be living like Packers if they put some effort into figuring out how to monetize their infamy. If The Chaser were to start printing out “I’m Morally Outraged At The Chaser” I’m sure they could cash in on their huge anti-fan base.

      Like Heléna said, if the Dick don’t like it, the Dick shouldn’t watch it.

    • Michael says:

      11:26am | 06/06/09

      Isn’t one of our basic rights, freedom of speech?  This form of censorship reminds me of buying newspapers and magazines in Saudi Arabia where those bits that were offensive were blacked out with texta or simply ripped out.  Is that where we are heading…?

    • Greg says:

      03:33pm | 06/06/09

      I don’t watch ACA, yellow journalsim at its worst.  But I don’t like civil libertarians who spout “thin end of the wedge” arguments either.  Taking Chaser temporarily off the air because they crossed the line of what is acceptable humour does not mean we are about to introduce sharia law.  I’m all for freedom of speech - and I agree that there should be no such thing as a sacred cow.  However freedom of speech is not without limitations; you don’t lie, you don’t exploit and you don’t cause harm.  Satire can be offensive.  In fact if someone isn’t offended it’s probably not funny.  The issue is whether the Chasers’ skit crossed the line between offensive and harm.  I put myself in the position of a parent with a child dying of cancer and I think maybe it did.

    • Leuis says:

      10:53pm | 06/06/09

      The ‘thin end of the wedge’ argument can’t be dismissed so easily. I’m not saying that the robotic reprodicution of taglines is not tiresome, but in this case we need to ask ourselves what the value is of the public discussion that ensued from this broadcast.

      My personal opinion about the skit aside, I think there is real value in an event that gives rise to a public discourse that tests the PMs response (calculated?, based on Christian ideology? ...), belatedly unrobes the editorial sentiment of senior management at the public broadcaster (reactive?, political? ...), or simply forces us to consider the implications of censorship more broadly.

      I support the ‘thin end of the wedge’ argument with respect to free speech because debates like this help define the very boundaries that self-censorship operates within. Self-censorship is largely invisible, I think visibility of ideas is very important.

      How can we know what is harmful without getting hurt once in a while?

    • Dave from ChaserLoverdotcom! says:

      09:00am | 07/06/09

      Ahh I reckon the Chaser’s community service / redemption should be they have to bust into a Mike Rann Labor fatcat fundraiser in Biker gear. While being filmed. Priceless.

    • nick says:

      09:11am | 07/06/09

      THe Chaser definitely need to have a skit on this true life (unfortunately) episode. Hopefully they can skewer the fact that Uncle Kev is tuned into whatever ACA will or has said. Really no better than John Howard.
      I would really like to know from Greg exactly what harm this did to a child with cancer. If anybody who commented had watched it, they would be aware that this was not making fun of the kids. The more we expect people to have conniptions when they are not treated as sacred (or scared) cows the more it will become reality (particularly if Unkle Kev has anything to do with it).

    • Maria F NSW says:

      06:03pm | 08/06/09

      Point taken and noted.  Perhaps we don’t know what the chaser boys have been through in their illustrious lives.  Having said that, does anyone honestly believe that they would have gone through with this pathetic excuse for a joke if one of their kids was going through treatment for a life threatening illness?? No matter how you cut, slice and dice it there is nothing humorous about seeing child actors made up to look like cancer sufferers grasping on for dear life and asked to make a realistic wish before they die.  Comedians always say that there are no boundaries to humour, perhaps but they should remember a delightful thing called karma.  Now that would be funny, a show where karma catches up with comedians….

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Lucy Kippist

RT @HeatherSmithAU: Can living in another country change your life for the better? by @lucyjk on @newscomau f. moi http://t.co/E5Ma3kBut2

David Penberthy

@mooks83 sophisticated response. Think the kids parents saw it differently

David Penberthy

More class from 9's footy show, lampooning a baby that allegedly looks like Sterlo with a pic swiped from Facebook http://t.co/BGoYP6Pn68

Lucy Kippist

A story that's close to my heart - can living overseas change your life for the better? With thanks, @Alisa_reduxhttp://t.co/n6tksJstqs

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter