My name is Yvette and I am a Masterchef addict. Not since Charlene married Scott on Neighbours have I looked forward so eagerly to my nightly fix of commercial TV.

Masterchef has been a revelation. With gripping culinary challenges, genuine emotion and insightful tips on cooking techniques it has become must watch TV. The prospect of its conclusion on Sunday night fills me with despair.

The show has also changed my mind about the culinary industry which up ‘til now I believed was full of offensive, egotistical, sexist chefs who thought it was OK for women to cook as long as they weren’t paid for it.

Although trail-blazing female chefs have taken on the blokes of the culinary world for many years, the old adage remains: men are chefs, women are cooks. To quote serial sexist, Gordon Ramsay, “women are better off mixing a gin and tonic than meddling with modern cuisine.”

In fact, a rash of revolting celebrity chefs in recent years prompted their inclusion in the Annual ‘Ernie’ Awards for male chauvinist piggery. The ‘Fred’ (named after Rev Fred Nile) for Clerical nominees became the Clerical/Culinary award. Fortuitously, the ‘Fred’ trophy was a fish on a plinth which meant the unlikely categories married well.

So what have these misogynists of mastication been saying? The usual stupid sexist stuff that is all rigorously documented in The Ernies Book: A Thousand Terrible Things Australian Men Have Said About Women.
Their sexist stuff-ups include gems like Neil Perry’s comment about Nigella Lawson’s TV Show (referring to her breasts, of course): “Why doesn’t she just get ’em out; that’s what they’re watching for!”; or Luke Mangan about Princess Mary: “She’s got some natural class about her. She’s not one of those Aussie bimbos”; or wine marketing manager, Trevor Corker (yes!): “For women, wine is not an intellectual pursuit.”
And how could we forget Gordon Ramsay who said about his ex-girlfriend: “Going to bed with her was like having a rottweiler strapped to your chest” (which might appeal to some but I’m sure wasn’t meant as a compliment).

However Masterchef has gone some way to repairing the bad reputation of celebrity chefs. On Wednesday night, as the boof-heads of league battled it out in State of Origin, the three not-so-tough-guy Masterchef judges cried on TV as Justine, one of the stars of the competition crashed out over a chocolate mousse cake. They all rushed to offer her a job because of her superior culinary ability but celebrated Sydney chef, Matt Moran beat them, literally, to her front door.

Masterchef has taken everyone by surprise. It is far and away the most popular show on TV. Boys across Australia are now demanding to cook marinated squid and fresh walnut gnocchi proving you don’t have to be a foul-mouthed misogynist to have a hit reality TV cooking show.

So what is the secret of the Masterchef success?  Simple - it’s about real Aussies who love to cook - like Julie, a mother in her late thirties who loves cooking for her family (that’s me); Poh, a stylish artist from a Malaysian background; the gracious and mellifluent Torres Strait Islander, Tom; Sam, a twenty-four year old call centre manager who grinned his way through to the second last week; and tattooed Melbournite, Chris, who needs a hair cut and should get rid of the hat but I would absolutely queue up at his beer inspired eatery to feast on roasted pig’s head and beeramisu.

The show celebrates diversity. Each of the contestants has been encouraged by the judges to value their personal culinary experiences. No differentiation has been made on the basis of age, sex or cultural background. A whole episode was dedicated to Masterchef judge, George Calombaris’ mother’s moussaka – a first for prime-time TV. Chefs from all around the world have generously shared their passion for food. The trip to Hong Kong was a fabulous cultural adventure that should be a lesson to the ugly Aussie tourist.

And remarkably, in a very blokey industry, not one sexist comment on the show to date! Even Luke Mangan who appeared on the show this week behaved himself.

It’s pretty clear that the front runners for this year’s Gold ‘Ernie’ are Gordon Ramsay for implying that Tracy Grimshaw was an ugly six-nippled pig and former Cronulla Sharks CEO, Tony Zappia for asking the woman employee he accidentally punched in the eye if she would like to spank him.

But more importantly, who would I put money on to win this week’s final of Masterchef? It’s down to three: Poh, Julie and Chris and I’m putting my money on a woman being crowned the first Masterchef Australia.

As emergency rooms full of men and boys with cooking related injuries attest to, Masterchef has made cooking cool, and it has helped reversed that old fashioned view that women can’t make it as chefs.

Let’s just hope that after each family member has licked their plate clean of beetroot jus from their braised duck with baby vegetables that the fellas don’t forget about the washing-up.

Most commented

37 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Chris says:

      07:26am | 16/07/09

      Absolutley Agree - even my 2 year old runs in and wants to watch the “cooking show” - so delighted to see her interest in Dad and Mum making something so mundane as she drags a chair over to the bench to “watch Dad cook”.. I will be sad to see it finish.

    • Eric says:

      08:12am | 16/07/09

      Fine words from a promoter of the sexist “Ernies Awards”.

      What about all the sexist things Australian women have said about men? Just doesn’t cross your misandrist radar.

    • YT says:

      08:35am | 16/07/09

      Off you go, Eric, why don’t you start your own awards on the horrendous things women have said about men, then?  Ha ha, good luck with that.

      Or are you the Eric who posts sleezy things on Bossy’s forum, and so you’re feeling a bit guilty?  Saying sleezy things - whether it’s you or Tony Zappia - does not demonstrate any kind of like for a woman, and women don’t enjoy it.  All it shows is how insecure you the person saying the sleezy things is.

    • Eric says:

      08:54am | 16/07/09

      I don’t have a full-time taxpayer-funded staff to go through every media outlet in Australia, unlike the authors of “The Ernies”. Nor do I have a sycophantic media willing to publicise everything I say without question.

      The very fact that “The Ernies” exists is evidence of the bias against men in our society. Nobody would be paid dare to compile a similar dossier on sexist women, and if they did, it wouldn’t be publicised.

      What’s Bossy’s forum? Is it full of misandrists? Maybe I should go there and tell them a thing or two.

    • YT says:

      09:29am | 16/07/09

      Oh dear Eric.  That chip on your shoulder is more like a field of potatoes.

      Sounds like you’ve had a bad experience with a woman.  I’m sure you’ve got lots to say, but I’d suggest that rather than commenting on Bossy’s blog, you write to her for advice on how to deal with your “misandrist” conspiracy theory.  I’m pretty sure she’s a psychologist and I’m sure she could help you through it http://blogs.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/katedebrito/

    • Eric says:

      09:41am | 16/07/09

      No thanks, YT.

      I haven’t had “a bad experience with a woman”. Just a bad experience with a sexist society that discriminates against men.

      Obviously you have had a bad experience with a man, and that’s why you hate men. I suggest that you seek psychological help to get over it.

    • minni says:

      10:04am | 16/07/09

      What a strange article! Full of its own sexist generalisations about men, about chefs, about rugby league players and supporters. No real surprise when you read the authors bio. As for masterchef, for those of us who watch a variety of channels on TV (not just the commericials) good cooking shows are nothing new.

    • Peter says:

      10:14am | 16/07/09

      Great article.  In my house, I am the custodian of the kitchen whether I cook or not.  My wife is atrocious at keeping it clean when cooking.  She is lucky I actually enjoy cleaning the kitchen - not sure why - and its really the only room I really love cleaning but there you go.  Lucky her.

      Anyway.  Agree with all this.  Our whole family including our 5 and 7 year old wait out for Masterchef to come on and then the next day to a post mortem with my parents.  We are also addicted to it and it has given us new inspiration.  We are making some fantastic meals and the kids love helping as well.  We are also starting to fret what we are going to do once it is over.  Its such a relief to see a reality show that is really positive and ignores the ugly sides a bit rather than the other way around.

    • Damian says:

      10:37am | 16/07/09

      Go Chris, you are easily the best COOK left. You will win by a street. Without any extra help from the “judges” too.

    • Sam says:

      10:45am | 16/07/09

      The article’s author is pushing a personal agenda on this - - Marxist Feminist ideology is extremely thick and ordinary.  You could teach such bigotry to a six-year-old and they would come out with the same drivel.

    • Jonathan says:

      10:53am | 16/07/09

      Hi Yvette,
      You should’ve mentioned in the body of the article that you were involved in the writing of the Ernie’s book.  Plugging your own work is fine, just let me know up front without having to click through to your bio at the prompting of another commenter.
      I’ve enjoyed masterchef.  It’s been the only thing worth watching this year, and I will go back to a TV-free life once it’s over.
      As for sexism, the three judges are great, but the female host brings NOTHING to the table.  Why not get a female judge who knows a bit and would bring a bit of balance to the sausage fest?  The female host is almost entirely unnecessary and reeks of tokenism.

    • Tony says:

      10:58am | 16/07/09

      I saw it for the first time on Tuesday because I couldn’t find anything else, and I’m glad I missed the previous episodes. It’s a pity that entertainment has come to depend on crushing people’s self esteem in this humiliating way.
      Oz TV has surely fallen to the pits with this sort of mindless rubbish. Hope it finishes soon.

    • Jack says:

      11:13am | 16/07/09

      “that the fellas don’t forget about the washing-up.”

      Deride an industry for it’s sexism, applaud a show based on that industry that manages to avoid that sexism, and then end with a comment like that. *slowclap*

    • Peter says:

      11:59am | 16/07/09

      Man, some of these comments are harsh.  Talk about not having a sense of humour.  I connected with it and found it an amusing read.

    • Robbington says:

      12:12pm | 16/07/09

      Eric said: “The very fact that “The Ernies” exists is evidence of the bias against men in our society.”

      So you think that a book that quotes men saying sexist things about women is evidence that there’s an inherent bias against men in our society? Following that logic, if you were to publish an article talking about domestic violence or sexual assault that focussed on the suffering of women, you’d be unfairly discriminating against men.

    • Anna Winter says:

      12:19pm | 16/07/09

      I love that Poh’s been able to get away with filling the sort of mad genius role that we don’t normally see women in. She’s able to fail spectacularly in public without it being some kind of proof that women can’t be chefs.

      But maybe that’s just my Marxist Feminist ideology talking.

    • David says:

      01:14pm | 16/07/09

      Damian, you are so wrong. Chris has been given more help than any other contestant, here are two examples: Gary fixing the temp and turning on the oven fan or his pig’s head would not have been cooked; telling him to redo his pasrty base last night because it was too thick and hard and would have made a good cart wheel. If that’s not helping him what is? No one else has received that type of help. So no, not go Chris; unless you mean he should be gone.

    • Zoe says:

      01:57pm | 16/07/09

      Great article, Yvette, and a great comment from Anna.  And I think we all need to be getting about in these.

    • S says:

      02:03pm | 16/07/09

      Excuse my cynicism but what makes you think Justine was only approached because of her cooking prowess? There are likely alterior motives at work. All of the judges know that Justine will pull the crowds of fans who “reckon she’s hot” regardless of cooking skill. As for Chris, Julie, and Poh, all have skill. It’s a shame they’re all so protective of the passion they have for food. Where is the sharing and expansion of cooking philosophy? They want to safeguard their skills from each other so badly because of this competition that the love of the food has diminished no matter how much they try and deny it. They may as well be competing to make Happy Meals. I’m glad it’s encouraging people to cook but it’s disappointing that good cooks are paraded in this way.
      As for The Ernies Book, sorry but I wont waste my time on a book which enforces division between genders. Sexism has been ingrained into our psyches for millenia. With so much history, why add to it instead of learning from it?

    • Helen says:

      02:18pm | 16/07/09

      Ha, go Yvette! I knew when I read your piece there would be some whingers in the comments!

      Yes my twelve year old son is following me around the kitchen saying stuff like, “The onions have caramelised nicely, while the sausage has taken on a whole new dimension of flavour!” He asked to be walked through cooking fried rice the other night and the result kicked serious butt. You’ve got to love it - and the way the judges encourage rather than bully!

      The thing I’d like to know is if there is a script or some rigging going on. Many people have suggested that Chris was scripted to win from the very start. I guess we’ll find out soon.

    • Helen says:

      02:20pm | 16/07/09

      Comment from “S” above: Greatest unintentional irony of the week! wink

    • GB says:

      03:06pm | 16/07/09

      You’ve sensationalised your story just a little bit, Yvette.  I watched three not-so-tough-guy Masterchef judges cry on TV and the program run to its completion in time to watch all eighty minutes of State of Origin football.  A great night of suspense!

    • Richard says:

      04:14pm | 16/07/09

      So now we have to turn what was just an enjoyable TV show with some interesting characters and a great theme about food into yet another forum for the gender war.  Isn’t everyone getting just a little bit sick of people like Yvette who want to prolong the war between the sexes, which was won years ago and is all now more than just a little bit passe?  It might surprise Yvette to know that I, and I suggest the great majority of people, have watched the show, enjoyed it, supported their favorites and commiserated with those eliminated without for one second thinking of the gender politics she sees as being involved.  The war’s over, Yvette - can’t you make peace and get over it?
      And, Minni, you left out Aussie tourists.

    • Greg says:

      05:17pm | 16/07/09

      Note at the top of the page that this story is also filed under “sexism” and “womens issues”. Sorry Yvette, but stories like this doing nothing to advance the cause of women, but merely show you up to be petty minded individuals with a victim mentality, who are happy to use sexist remarks to try and justify their cause. But of course, it is not a sexist remark if it is uttered by a woman against a man, is it?

    • vicki pavlos says:

      11:30pm | 16/07/09

      I love MasterChef. I can’t watch it when I’m hungry! Dinner has to be eaten beforehand or laid out in front of the telly so we don’t miss anything. I’m thrilled the finalists are two women. Chris doesn’t need to win this competition. His beer bar and restaurant concept will happen anyway.

      If this show spurs a new interest in healthy home cooking then it is worth its weight in gold. I have long been a fierce opponent of unhealthy fast food. My interest in cooking was learned as a child and it’s remained with me. I would love to see children interested and inspired.

      It’s also good to see a reality show that isn’t cynical, game playing or negative and cruel. If lots of children are watching this as well, I’m heartened they’re watching something a lot more positive than the narcissistic and idiotic Big Brother etc.

    • pierre says:

      03:28am | 17/07/09

      I’m in the line for the beer bar and food at Chris’s anytime he’s open!

    • mikk says:

      04:07am | 17/07/09

      When you become a qualified chef with your own restaurant and reputation to protect you will understand why head chefs are so mean. If the apprentice stuffs up a meal or the waitress is too slow it is not them the customers think ill of it is the chef. They dont think “oh the apprentice must be responsible for this crap” they think “wow this chef is hopeless”.

      A good show and quite entertaining but i fear there are many inspired to become kitchen staff who will be in for a rude shock. The pressure on MC is nothing to that in a real commercial kitchen.

    • Mcancook says:

      08:34am | 17/07/09

      More than happy for more woman to be in the kitchen where they belong. Just make sure you have enough time to do my laundry.

    • AFR says:

      09:32am | 17/07/09

      I love the way that Ch10 have deliberately stretched this show out for as long as possible. It saves having to actually produce a TV with scripts, actors etc. That takes money and talent. Sadly, reality TV does now.

    • Adam says:

      12:22pm | 17/07/09

      I for one believe in women’s right etc etc. However, im going to agree with Eric. Society isn’t sexiest against women these days, its darn well sexest against men. For example, i jump on a bus and sit down. A woman gets on the bus and im all of a sudden expected to do the right thing and give her a seat! Women don’t need to do that for men yet they in this apparent world of equal rights expect it from men. Then there is divorce. If you have a case where the man has earnt everything a woman can take half of his assets (to be a fair a man may be able to do this to a woman but its rare). Moreover, society views women as the better parents and often award custody to them over the fathers.

      Plain and Simple, society has many shortcommings which affect both sexes and not just women. Lastly, try on the shoes of a male nurse or child care worker and see how the world treats you.

    • Chauvinist says:

      12:42pm | 17/07/09

      I haven’t watched one episode of the this show. From the previews it looks just about as exciting as watching paint dry. BoorrriiinnGGG!

      Anyway, cooking is a womans job.

    • Miss Smack says:

      01:06pm | 17/07/09

      I love the show too. Great piece of written work!

    • Lima Oscar says:

      05:09pm | 17/07/09

      Hmmm whilst Masterchef has enlightened many ignorant folks about the joys of cooking - it doesn’t show the reality of what it’s like in a REAL commercial kitchen. 80 - 90% of the people in MC wouldn’t cut it in this environment. Trust me I know - I worked with both George and Gary some years ago in an established Melbourne hotel and worked as a cook for 9 years. As the only female in my team I copped my fair share. For example - if I didn’t walk in and make my french chef a cup of coffee and wish him a good morning then my name was dirt and I was ignored for the entire day. 
      Whilst I’m not saying all places are like this - and I hope to god that many establishments have eradicated this egomanical and blatantly sexist behaviour ! - it does exist. Shows like MC tend to make people put on the rosy glasses and make the general public think it’s all wonderful. Let me tell you - out there in the real world - it ain’t like tv land…...it’s bloody hard graft!! If the competitors on the show think they have been given a real understanding of what it’s like day in day out then they may be up for a rude awakening! However in saying this good luck - Go Poh!

    • CLS says:

      10:09pm | 18/07/09

      Absolute load of rubbish this TV show. Reality TV is fantastic at dumbing people down even more…....watch 10 minutes of it and that was enough to convince me to never watch MasterChef again.

    • Damo says:

      11:06am | 20/07/09

      Im SO happy Masterchaef has ended!!

      PLEASE!! Not another season

    • Joshenu says:

      09:55pm | 15/08/09

      The show was great, but it absolutely fell apart in the final episodes.

      Julie puts up three unfinished, boring, run-of-the-mill motherly dishes, and still knocks out Chris? How many ******* times do we have to see some dull and homely variation of lamb & potato?

      Julie was clearly given a free pass all the way through the finals. Uncooked fish; a disastrous pie; three unfinished and rather plain dishes… Not to mention the judges basically held her hand and told her what to do throughout the entire final ******* challenge. The only thing she had going for her was her (cliched) tear-jerking “I love my family” cookbook bullshit. The producers evidently want a “Masterchef” that will sell books to all the sympathetic (read: idiotic) mothers of Australia.

      Whenever Julie fell to pieces and ****ed up her dishes (virtually every challenge) she would just turn on the waterworks and pull the whole “I’m a mother; I love my family; cooking is how I give love to the world; mewmewmewmew I’m a woman don’t be harsh on me” card. **** her.

      Chris and Justine were by far the best, with Poh coming in third. Julie was not even close to the top 5 cooks in the show.

      $50 says she’ll never even open a ******* restaurant. At most, she’ll start a cafe, which will fail within a year.

      Rigged show is rigged.

    • Tayten says:

      09:11am | 17/10/11

      It’s imperative that more peploe make this exact point.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter