Mel Gibson may have had a few bad times recently, but let’s not forget that he’s still Australian. Let’s set aside the claims that he is sexist, homophobic, anti-Semitic, and allegedly now a girlfriend-beater as well. He’s still the same lovable Mel Gibson who grew up in Sydney, who attended NIDA (National Institute of Dramatic Arts), and who gave us Mad Max.

Mel Gibson: no longer our problem.

Surely he’s still the prodigal son of our land, making the nation proud.

Or maybe, now that he’s dragging down the Australian name, it’s time to admit that he’s a New Yorker and we don’t really have a legitimate claim to him.

The rise and fall of Mel Gibson has drawn attention to a startling quality that we Australians possess – the ability to proudly accept a celebrity as our own when the going is good, but as soon as they fall out of line, they’re quickly denied.

It’s now gotten to the point where Mel Gibson’s nationality can be successfully charted using the Fame Claim Index (FCI), as shown.

This graph shows that the high points (Mad Max, Lethal Weapon and Braveheart) are times in Mel’s life and career when we’ve been proud to call him Australian. 2006 will be remembered as a dark period in his life where a DUI revealed several regrettable facets to his personality. His FCI value fell even further in the past month with allegations that he had taken to beating his girlfriend.

But Mel Gibson isn’t the first person that we’ve proudly claimed as Australian only to later change our mind after a fall from grace. Case in point, Russell Crowe, whose career can also plotted on the FCI.

Another NIDA graduate who we’ve proudly called Australian for many years, Russell has acted well in some decent movies, and he saved the South Sydney Rabbitohs from certain death. But there’s no denying that he’s had his ups and downs.

At his best NZ's Russell Crowe is a great Australian.

Russell Crowe is known for his quick temper (to the point where I write this while looking over my shoulder) and in 2005 had an altercation that resulted in him being arrested for throwing a phone at a concierge. At this point in his career, Australians were reminded of the fact that he was born in Christchurch, Wellington. In fact, we could go one step further and dredge up his musical career, where in 1982 under the stage name of Rus le Roq, the Kiwi youth released a misguided single called ‘I Just Wanna be Like Marlon Brando’. Are we surprised that he threw a phone? That sounds exactly like something that New Zealand’s Russell Crowe would do.

While it’s been touch and go in recent years, we’ve recently started to open our hearts and shores to Russell again. Let’s just say entry is conditional on good behaviour.

Mel Gibson might find things a little tougher for a while. While a glance at the FCI will see that Gibson is currently an American, there is an inverse effect evident in the United States, with news reports labelling him as Australian. When you’re at the point where neither country has positive interest as a result of your presence, you need to take a look at how you’re acting.

Of course, it would do well to note in the fine print that the Claim Fame Index is subject to the celebrity residing in a country for a certain amount of time. Has enough time passed for Australians to palm the Paul Hogan problem off to America yet?

- More from Matt at otherendofthespectrum.wordpress.com

Most commented

48 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Cecil says:

      11:18am | 21/07/10

      Thank Heavens!! let America keep him, his lack of morals and racist comments do not make him a very desirable Aussie. I think alot of Kiwis would be pretending they don’t know him either

    • Greek Snake says:

      02:27pm | 22/07/10

      I tip my hat to Mel Gibson for not letting Hollywood change him.

      That dirty gold digger set him up, she deserved what she got. Hopefully she doesn’t see a penny.

    • Hermano says:

      11:19am | 21/07/10

      Wait… what?

    • iansand says:

      11:23am | 21/07/10

      Send Mel to New Zealand.

      Next problem

    • Peter says:

      11:27am | 21/07/10

      Mel Gibson didn’t ‘give us Mad Max’, George Miller did. Gibson was quoted after the movie was released, that he didn’t understand what Mad Max was all about. So it isn’t surprising then the Cars in the movie turned in a better acting performance than Gibson.

    • Dan says:

      02:42am | 22/07/10

      George Miller was mostly responsible for Mad Max, yes, but Gibson was terrific. His perfomance was extremely underrated and he was completely convincing, although he later produced superior performances.

    • Tails says:

      11:29am | 21/07/10

      Can’t argue with science. Just as Tom Cruise.

    • Sheedy's Left Foot says:

      11:34am | 21/07/10

      A bigoted, drunk…isn’t he the epitomy of us? ;P

      Anyway it will all be forgiven if he does something good again and he will be lauded as ‘Our Mel’

    • T.Chong says:

      11:50am | 21/07/10

      A young Mel in” Year of Living Dangerously “,” Mad Max’s” , brillant in “Galipolli ” -  ( if he retired after that he would have still been a winner), a patchy ,but mostly competent ” Hamlet “, William ‘Rambo"Wallace- Hollywoods idea of English history, an inane Vietnam flick- channeling “The Duke ” then all those awful Lethal Weapon movies.
      Sad . His best recent performance has been on The Simpsons.

    • Tails says:

      12:00pm | 21/07/10

      I reckon we’d get on like a house on fire in real life. That is, until you opened your big yap about politics.

    • Seano says:

      12:16pm | 21/07/10

      “if he retired after that he would have still been a winner” -  and he’d still be Australian.

    • Dan says:

      03:56am | 22/07/10

      ‘all those awful Lethal Weapon movies’? The first two LW films remain among the greatest action thrillers of all time, while the other two were also okay (altjough far inferior to the first two.) As for Braveheart, yes, it wasn’t factually accurate, but it was still brilliantly shot and filmed, had wonderful battle scenes, a good quality screenplay, and was an extremely impressive period piece (even if it was fictionalised.)

    • Sam Chowder says:

      12:09pm | 21/07/10

      I would have thought he would have taken a history professorship in Scotland.

    • Seano says:

      12:15pm | 21/07/10

      I did notice we stopped claiming him a while back.

    • Treadlightly says:

      12:28pm | 21/07/10

      How gullible gullible gullible people are that they believe the vitriolic diatribe
      coming from the media and the so called comments - anti semitic, racist etc., that have been digitilly put together.  He has been targeted since His movie - the Passion of the Christ, which was controversial ..and in a drunken state he asked a policeman if he was….....?? That was the end of Mel Gibson.

    • Hochfelden says:

      12:28pm | 21/07/10

      A Drunk…?
      A Violent Bigot…?
      A Racialist.. ?
      A Domestic Violence perpetrator…?
      Of course he cannot possibly an Australian with that record.
      Could he???

    • Ray says:

      01:52pm | 21/07/10

      Racialist? Hmm.

      Just not fond of women. May be he’s onto something.

    • Melissa says:

      12:29pm | 21/07/10

      Doesn’t anyone find it strange his girlfriend happens to have recording equipment on her when things happen?  I’m sure she antagonizes him and drives him crazy, and when he finally tells her to shut up and has a go back - she records it and releases it to the media?

    • Sheedy's Left Foot says:

      01:15pm | 21/07/10

      Yes, Melissa I am sure like so many other women, she asked for it and deserved it.

      <Shakes head>

      No matter the provocation, there really is no excuse for dmoestic abuse or violence. It really is that simple.

    • Melissa says:

      01:32pm | 21/07/10

      There is certainly no excuse for any form of domestic violence - but there has been no proof of anything so far - just a whole lot of attention drummed up by Oksana from her ‘recordings’ that only show one side to a story - her side, which could be very misleading as towards exactly what is going on..  Oksana “He Mel I’m just going out in this skimpy little number to get some action and there’s nothing you can do about it, oh I’m also taking all your money and our child with me, you are never seeing your child again” (Oksana hits record button, records Mel’s angry response and releases it to the public)... 

      I think there is more to this than what has been released to a gullable public

    • Peasant #3167 says:

      01:39pm | 21/07/10

      It’s called entrapment. He may have a tendency to to yell and carry on, and she knew how to tip him over the edge. And she did it while recording it.
      The police do it too, they set people up with stings. Police women dressed provocatively enticing you to break the law. Selling drugs to catch you, tailgating to force you to speed. It’s all wrong.

    • Ella says:

      01:47pm | 21/07/10

      Melissa - nothing justifies talking to another human being like that. If someone is antagonising you that badly that you can’t control yourself as an adult you always have the option of walking away.

      As for the recording equipment, there are a number of reasons she might have had it there. People sometimes try and record/video drunks so they can play their behaviour back to them when they are sober so they can see how bad it is or by that stage she may already have realised the relationship was over, it wasn’t the first time he had acted like that and someone told her she needed evidence if she wanted to be able to prove it and keep her daughter safe.

    • DJ says:

      02:22pm | 21/07/10

      I am with Melissa, there is no evidence he hit her, and with Robin coming out and saying that he was never abusive in their long relationship it does seem that it’s all fabricated. Surely if he had these tendencies they would have come out while he was with Robin?

    • Tedd says:

      03:38pm | 21/07/10

      DJ, some people are quite different with one person compared to another; and, no doubt Robyn garnered some respect from Mel.  It seems Oksana didn’t, for whatever reason (and there may be many).

      I’m with Ella - he didn’t need to carry on like that, and with his various other histories, including another woman subsequent to Oksana saying he became abusive, it doesn’t look good for Mel.

    • Ellie says:

      04:30pm | 21/07/10

      I think 9 out of 10 people in this blog could look bad if someone recorded us at our worst. I certainly fall into one of the 9. Ok, so we might not go to the extent that Mel did but I think he is getting far too much scrutiny. No one tends to record the positive stuff. It’s like the news.

    • KH says:

      01:18pm | 21/07/10

      BWAHAHAHA ‘the paul hogan problem’.........thats hilarious.

    • Wrong End of the Stick says:

      01:40pm | 21/07/10

      I was surprised he is a man, our Mel looks all women sitting next to Koshie in the mornings

    • Man says:

      01:58pm | 21/07/10

      Never mind the ones we don’t want anymore. What about the ones the Americans are trying to take? Hugh! Look out!

    • neil says:

      03:28pm | 21/07/10

      The problem with your theory is that unlike Russell Crow, Gibson has never been an Australian citizen, he was born in the USA and has American citizenship. He has been away from Australia for twenty years so he wouldn’t even qualify for residency anymore as you must spend three years in five in Australia to keep it.

      He’s all theirs and always has been.

    • TheRealDave says:

      03:42pm | 21/07/10

      Mel was stitched up by this bit of commie trash to be sure.

      She signed a pre-nup given her NOTHING if they split up. So in the two years they were together she got herself knocked up and managed to make all these recordings (isn’t illegal to record conversations without consent??), and the funny thing is, listening to the tapes you can hear her goading him. So now she’s selling ‘her story’ and has now been caught out blackmailing him for millions not to release the tapes to the public. She’s dribbling them out one at a time to force Mel’s cheque writing hand.

      Nice way to get around a prenup isn’t it?

      Not excusing Mel for being the drunken racist douchebag he is but its plain to see she’s stitching him up.

    • VickiPS says:

      04:09pm | 21/07/10

      No doubt she is No Better Than She Ought To Have Been, but so what?  They deserve each other.  Mel isn’t the first vain old fool to convince himself that a young thing wants him for his good self alone. <SNORT!>

    • Dan says:

      02:46am | 22/07/10

      So because she sets him up (not that he didn’t deserve it), she’s a communist? You do realise that the cold war is over?

    • John A Neve says:

      03:57pm | 21/07/10

      Was he ever Australian?
      Even Paul Hogan left us until he ran out of money, but I see he comeing back!!

    • Fiat Lux says:

      07:12pm | 21/07/10

      Mel Gibson came to Australia when he was 12 . So how long did he have an Aussie accent for ? He lost his wife , his faith , his mind . He is an outcast , shunned by society , a stinker . Russell Crowe’s younger and better looking anyway .

    • Dan says:

      01:07am | 22/07/10

      Correct me if I’m wrong but I’m now 32 and aside from being aware that Mel spent his teens and perhaps early 20’s in Australia I’ve never heard him speak in an Aussie accent (except for a couple of movies) or claim to be Australian first and an American second.

      As for Crowe he sounds like and Australian, says he is Australian, we accepted him as an Australian so therefore he is an Australian. Anyone who tries to say he is not should hang their heads in shame, because people with your fickle sence of loyalty should be deported for being (and I hate this word) “unAustralian”.

    • Trav says:

      08:23am | 22/07/10

      Mel is a national treasure. The fact that he got angry because that hag wanted to extort money from him AND take away his child is not surprising. I would be pissed as well.
      I’m positive Mel will be vindicated and prooven to be the man I believe he is.

    • Paddy says:

      09:19am | 22/07/10

      I’ve heard this asked a lot: “why do you love the likes of Mel when times are good but disown them when the going gets a little bad”.

      Well firstly likes others have said he wasn’t born here. When we say we ‘own’ an actor from another nation, eg Crowe or Mel, or even the band Crowded House, we are saying we are welcoming them into the fold.

      We don’t actually disown them when poor media reports come out, what we are saying is that for those who love to use offensive generalisations about us ie ‘typical drunk, racist Australian’ - well that theory just doesn’t hold water when in fact the man wasn’t born here and therefore doesn’t fit that highly flawed generalising, simpleton’s theory.
      The only thing that appears to be common in recent years is that quite a few Americans, UKites and NZersss love to quickly generalise about Australians. One and I mean one appalling fracas on the beach in Cronulla (not multiple race riots like northern england) means we are all racists, Black faces skit on Hey Hey performed by people of varying ethnic backgrounds, means all Australians are racists apparently, Indians being attacked or murdered (by other Indians) means Australians are racists, Under arm bowl which occurred I think, over 30 years ago - means we are all cheats and so on and so on (imagine if a friend kept going on about an incident that happened 30 years ago? surely you would ask them to seek help to get over it?).

      Gawd I’ve forgotten my point now ... gosh it’s a nice day. I must be confused from all the late nights watching the Tour.

    • Gidgee says:

      09:45am | 22/07/10

      The Punch that won’t allow a fair-dinkum punch?
      I see my observation about Mr Gibson whom you artfully describe as an “anti-Semite” has been disallowed…..surely it’s time you people in the Murdoch press came to terms with the utter barbarous nature of Judaism - a barbarity which kicked off with the “creation” of the cannily named state of Israel in 1948 right smack in the midst of the Arab population of old Palestine?
      Judaism moved in and viciously treated/imprisoned/murdered the native population of that Middle Eastern arena and you haven’t the courage to allow the commentary of a person who’s appalled by that religious mob of fanatic’s conduct?
      Shame, shame, shame.

    • P. Darvio says:

      11:06am | 22/07/10

      Mr Gibson is a wonderful shinning light of Christianity, the Bible and GOD (Genocidal Offensive Dictator). He just needs to go see those Catholic Archbishops of California again and beg their forgiveness - I’m sure they will oblige.

    • Amber says:

      11:48am | 22/07/10

      He’s not the first man to fall into the clutches of a predatory, ambitious Russian woman - just the first famous Australian.    Australian? - news to most Americans.  I’d like to see the pieces of that tooth - or did she throw those away?  Before or after she took the photo. Leave him alone - he’s also not the first male to let his urges lead him astray.

    • Sean Williams says:

      03:14am | 23/07/10

      Hey Paddy this one’s for you. If ever you needed proof that Australia was a land of “British rednecks” (thank you Robin Williams, I forgave you your recent movie career for that gem) then you just need to look at these comments, where a clear majority are DEFENDING Mel Gibson. It truly beggars belief. You wouldn’t expect anything less of Miranda Devine sticking up for a rabid, racist, mysoginistic right wing Catholic nutjob, but surely the rest of you have more scruples. Have people listened to the actual tapes? When Aussies try to pretend that someone saying to a young woman “if you go out and get raped by a pack of n****** it’s your own fault” is just letting off a bit of steam then you really have a problem. You’re all so blind to your own backwardness it’s pathetic. Of course the UK has its race problems, with 60 million people living on an island not much bigger than Tasmania there is going to be some tensions (as well as a vibrant cultural buzz Oz can only dream of)  but the kind of casual racism and boofhead views commonplace in Australia and even deemed appropriate to be aired in the media are thankfully a thing of the past in Britain. Like with fashion, maybe in 20 years you’ll have caught up with us

    • Paddy says:

      08:39am | 23/07/10

      Gosh Sean Williams I hope ‘we’ never catch up to you lot. Really I do. England is all about keeping up appearances where in fact the ugly truth sits just below the surface. England is the only nation who thinks WW2 just finished yesterday so its ok to continue abusing Germans. With right wing racists parties still in existence in England where as here in Oz we even locked up that crazy red head and her politics are long dead. We have one race riot in a misguided retaliation to rapes and abuse over 10 years, and you lot have people killing Muslims and you say you are ahead of us? Disgusting.

      Yes we have our problems, like all nations do, but nothing like the media, backed by the jeering english would have you believe. I’ve never met a more abusive people as the english are. Bad sportsmanship, throwing bottles at our cricketers and the media keeps it all quiet. No wonder it was ‘anyone but england’ during the world cup from your nearest neighbours.
      You seem to be excusing england’s racism because of its numbers. Gosh if only Australian journalists were equally as obsessed as english journalists are with Australia - we would constantly be writing articles with headlines such as “Why are the english so fond of right wing fascists ideals”. “Why are all english racsists” etc etc. Australia has a camel cull and the english are calling for a boycott of Australia - BP - Boycott england? Of course not - the world is not that stupid.
      Please let us never ‘catch up” with you lot. That would be a race to the bottom. Perhaps the english instead of criticising others could ‘fix’ their own problems they created in northern Ireland first please. You could also remind us of your treatment of Australian Aborigines (whilst my ancestors where in chains for simply being Irish) when your government declared the place empty of people. Oh and pleassseee ask all your mates “Why oh why if you hate Australia so much do you continue to come here?” One in ten Brisbanites are now Poms - bloody hell - good bye republic. My view - let those poor bloody ‘boat people’ in - they would make great citizens in this free country,- and cut British, more specifically, english migrants to suit.

    • Paddy says:

      08:51am | 23/07/10

      Oh forgot to mention Sean Williams - So I get it - England is ok because its all an illusion of numbers but you kind of prove my point - comments here are somehow representative of all Australians hey? Enough for you to generalise about us all and say we need to catch up with your ‘great nation’ . Golly gosh silly me. ““You’re all so blind to your own backwardness” - thanks for that sweeping generalisation - from someone who comes from a nation who specialises in um sweeping generalisations. The English - they abuse you and will insist that you agree - if you don’t you are arrogant and backward.
      Back to school with you young Sean - you have much to learn. psssstt… the empire is dead. sssshhhh

    • Sean Williams says:

      11:16am | 23/07/10

      I just knew when I put the worm on this hook I could land a big one with you Paddy and boy did you deliver. Thank you, you made my day

      Just a few points

      1) Yes we do have the BNP, though they are an irrelevance. You got rid of One Nation only when the “Liberals” stole all their policies and attitudes and won elections as a result for the next decade as a result

      2) I’m not excusing any kind of racism, but numbers do matter. Despite having a black president, he US still has racial tensions, much more even than the UK, but the casual racism of the average Aussie would be just as inappropriate to the average American (Harry Connick jnr wouldn’t be the only person offended)

      3) We have people “killing muslims”. I’m sure I would have noticed this genocide taking place! Ludicrous lies.

      4) “Gosh if only Australian journalists were equally as obsessed as english journalists are with Australia” - This has to be your best. Have you ever looked at the UK media? Australia is never mentioned, never, except when there’s a shark attack. On the other hand, not a day goes by in the Australian media without your obsession with Britain laid bare.

      5) I thought we had done quite well in sorting out the problems in Northern Ireland - in fact as a nation I think we have been incredibly patient as your fellow crazy Paddies have killed each other and us for decades.

      6) Aborogines, really? You’re laying that one on our door too? I don’t doubt there was some unacceptable behaviour by the British at the time of colonisation, it was a different time and this happened unfortunately. But you guys have been running your own show for over 100 years now - and when it comes to Aborigines disgracefully so

      7) “Why oh why if you hate Australia so much do you continue to come here?”  This one rivals No 4) for pricelessness. Take it you’ve never been to London recently, the place is swarming with Aussies who do nothing but moan about Britain. Clearly bar work isn’t that rewarding for them!

      8) What, the Empire is over? You could have broken that to me more gently. Oh well, nothing lasts for ever. When Australia has built the greatest empire the world has ever seen and effectiveley created the modern world as we know it, get back to me and we’ll chat again.

      9) God bless you Paddy and God save YOUR Queen

    • Sean Williams says:

      11:27am | 23/07/10

      P.S on a more serious point. I don’t get where you’re coming from as far as far as the WWII obsession goes. Can Britons not be proud of that part of our history? Australians too are still very interested in the role they played in the wars, if not more so than Brits. Americans likewise. But wait I just remembered, you’re Irish. During WWII they were, at best, neutral, at worst, Nazi collaborators. No wonder it strikes a chord with you

    • Elise says:

      10:39pm | 02/08/10

      Wow the Uk v’s Australia thing was full on guy’s. Obviously the pom is a rascist against Australian’s… and abusive to it’s men and woman.
      Look I’ll put it this way, If anyone dosn’t like Australia please feel free TO LEAVE…go back to your own wounderful country, that is just so much better!
      Oh as for Mel… I hope he gets his head around all that has been happening , hollywood has trashed a lot of otherwise good talented people to death!
      Litraly… And no woman deserve to be abused but no man deserves to be taped then put out to the public ether.
      He’s still a aussie as far as I am concered.

    • KerryKiwi says:

      08:07pm | 07/09/10

      NZ wants our Rusty back.
      Let Rusty go.

    • www.thepunch.com.au says:

      10:59am | 28/03/11

      Scientific proof mel gibson is no longer australian.. I like it smile

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter