Most commented


Show oldest | newest first

    • Eric says:

      03:26am | 19/10/09

      This is one of the tragic consequences of illegal immigration. Kevin Rudd’s open door policy will probably lead to more such events.

    • Daphon says:

      07:10am | 19/10/09

      Eric could you provide details of this open door policy of Rudd’s?  Or is it just a figment of your xenophobic delusions?

      Very little has changed regarding Australia’s handling of refugees since Howard’s days (or Hawke/Keating’s for that matter).

      Shame on us.

    • Ray says:

      07:12am | 19/10/09

      More boats -lose votes

    • NJ says:

      07:20am | 19/10/09

      And why didn’t the country of safety they first arrived in take them in? Why only Australia? Indonesia and Malaysia have a hell of a lot to answer for and I am so against my tax dollars being sent to them as “aid” to help them do what they are supposed to do anyway. Does anyone ask about the war criminals of East Timor 1975 and again in 1999? Where are they hiding and living? Yes, in the same countries that shepherd these alleged refugees our way.

    • Joel B1 says:

      07:41am | 19/10/09

      Off topic on the supposedly open thread…

      Why is Hilter so fashionable right now?

      It seems that barely a day passes without me seeing the old fascist’s name in one context or another. Come on you sociologists give me a hint. (And any Freudian psychiatrists out there can have a go too)

    • Joel B1 says:

      07:56am | 19/10/09

      And just to follow up with some little data.

      A search in ABC online for:
      “Hitler” returns 60 full matches.
      “Roosevelt” returns 23.
      “Winston Churchill” returns 10.

      “Menzies” does get 73 but we can discount most of those I think due to his geo-political relevance.

      So Hitler wins the vote for most popular name dropping! But why?

    • Eric says:

      08:18am | 19/10/09

      Daphon, Kevin Rudd has closed down detention centres and made it easier for unlawful arrivals to get residence. That’s why the flow of unwanted immigrants has increased greatly since his election.

      But you knew this. You just wanted to name-call.

    • Daphon says:

      10:27am | 19/10/09


      They are not unlawful arrivals - they are refugees until they are proved otherwise.  Australia has a lawful obligation to accept these refugees under various treaties we have signed.

      And as you well know, the refugees coming by boat are a drop in the bucket compared to the thousands of genuine illegals who arrive by plane and overstay their visas. Interestingly the great majority are white and from the US and Europe. How often do you complain about them?

      Rudd is still putting the refugees in detention centres. And please provide a reference to prove your assertion that it’s easier for them to get residence.

    • Peter says:

      11:09am | 19/10/09

      With India having given two separate donations of $100m US, one in July and the other this month to assist the Tamils in Sri Lanka, (Source Colombo Page newspaper) it has to be asked, “why are these people who paid $4m US (ABC News 18 Oct 09) coming to Australia?”
      Wouldn’t have anything to do with Rudd’s relaxed attitude to Illegal Economic Migrants would it and the prize of permanent residency and endless benefits after their very short “check in” at Christmas Island? Of course not. Well done Rudd.

    • cats says:

      11:15am | 19/10/09

      Daphon, I actually didn’t know that Australia has a lawful obligation to accept genuine refugees. Thanks for letting us know. Now that explains a lot why we can’t simply send them back.

      Correct me if i am wrong, but is the biggest problem with illegal immigration that they don’t have skills to work in Australia? Maybe if we just send them into the outback and they can live out there and farm and stuff. Hey - they wanted a better life, they can make it themselves and not leech off the skilled working taxpayers. And make it compulsory for them to learn English. I’m sick of immigrants not being able to communicate.

      Another problem is with them not wanting to live as part of the multicultural life, which means they must be accepting of how white australians, and other religions and people live their lives. A lot of them can’t accept that others live differently.

      If these problems can be overcome, why should they not be able to live here?

    • Peter says:

      11:22am | 19/10/09

      Daphon—- The illegals are indeed illegals, as soon as they employ criminals to transport them to this country. There is a fully staffed Australian High Commission in Sri Lanka which is fully equipped and able to handle any applications for either asylum or immigration to Australia so tell me, why don’t they either, A, go 50 ks across Palk Strait to Tamil Nadu or, B, Apply through the proper, legal channels? I would suggest that the reason they don’t apply is because their stories of hardship, persecution etc would not stand up to scrutiny so they have decided to do it this way and depend on the support of the PC brigade here in Australia but I do believe that common sense and reality are finally coming into the picture. I see that Italy and Spain are no longer accepting illegal immigrants and are either turning them around or sending them to Libya.
      Lastly, the thousands illegal immigrants you refer to that arrive by air are not illegal until they overstay their visa and it’s only then that any action can be taken to apprehend and deport them, hardly the same as the growing numbers of boat loads arriving via the services of illegal people smugglers.

    • Daphon says:

      01:18pm | 19/10/09


      Perhaps they can’t get to the High Commission. This letter was in today’s Age:

      “EARLIER this year, we flew to Sri Lanka with our daughter, whom we adopted as a toddler in 1978, and her husband. We have taken her back to her country of origin many times to enable her to keep up with its culture.

      It was again frightening to see how Tamils are treated. Our daughter is recognisably of Tamil origin and was treated rudely and in a discriminatory way.

      At the airport when we were leaving, we were stopped from following other cars containing Westerners because of her ethnicity. Despite her father’s protestations and her Australian passport, we were herded by soldiers with AK47s into a rickety bus. It was nerve racking.

      The treatment of our daughter, an Australian citizen for decades, was appalling. If this is how security forces, guards in shopping centres and soldiers behave towards an Australian citizen, then pity help the Tamils who try to make their way to the Australian high commission from the north of the island. We wish them success in finding a peaceful community in which to live with dignity.”

      “arrive by air are not illegal until they overstay their visa”

      And the ‘boat people’ are not illegal either, Peter, because they are refugees.

      I can just imagine what you lot would have thought back in the 30s and 40s when the Jews were trying to escape from Germany.  We did turn them back by refusing them refugee status and sanctuary.  That is why we are signatories to the refugee treaty of 1948.

    • Glen says:

      01:51pm | 19/10/09

      There are 2 components of illegal immigration.  Both highly emotive.  The first is illegal immigration by boat.  This is highly visible and easily manipulated by both sides.  Put simply if you allow any of these illegal immigrants to stay you reward the people smugglers.  The answer is not to allow any of these illegal immigrants to arrive by boats.  Send them back to go through the refugee channels that the poor true refugees in the camps (often widows with kids) are using and whose places the illegal boat immigrants would be taking thus prolonging their suffering.  The second is the overstaying of visas.  The answer here is to fund the agencies necessary to find these illegal immigrants and immediately deport them.  That will be a boost to Australia’s economy by first getting rid of the parasites that are here unlawfully and secondly providing jobs for Australians.

    • M Cooke says:

      02:08pm | 19/10/09

      If Mr Rudd could not predict what would happen when he dismantled John Winston Howard’s Pacific Solution and put in place his stupid lax policies, then he is not a fit person to hold the position of PRIME MINISTER OF AUSTRALIA , BRING ON THE ELECTION.

    • AFR says:

      02:30pm | 19/10/09

      M Cooke - you’re absolutely right - lets bring on the election. I look forward to keeping the Libs in opposition for another 3 years.

    • Daphon says:

      03:29pm | 19/10/09

      A lot longer than 3 years I would venture to say, AFR.  Until the LP/Nats totally renew themselves (why are Rudd, Bronwyn Bishop, Tuckey etc etc still holding seats?) and expunge the Howard dogma from their consciousness, they are history.

      With a current predicted loss of around 20 seats, plus the Senate being controlled by the Greens, it should be an interesting 6 years.

      And both the ALP and the Libs/Nat need to take a serious look at the consequences of allowing the Christian lobbyists to hold so much sway.

    • Daphon says:

      04:00pm | 19/10/09

      “why are Rudd, Bronwyn Bishop, Tuckey etc etc still holding seats?”

      Wow, that was a major Freudian slip!!  I meant to write, “why are Ruddock, Bronwyn Bishop, Tuckey etc etc still holding seats?”

    • David says:

      04:41pm | 19/10/09

      Daphon, these people may be proven to be refugees, yet, their mode of entry is illegal.  The Department of Immigration, and the courts and tribunals all refer to them as such.  Maybe you could suggest to the Government that we change the terminology from SIEV (Suspected Illegal Entry Vessel) to a more politically correct anagram.  In the past year alone up to 10 people have been killed under the watch of people smugglers on leaky boats en route to Australia.  We call them Illegals because we want to discourage this terrible practice.

    • DJ says:

      05:59pm | 19/10/09

      They are illeagal because they have not entered the country legally and have bypassed many countries on the way here that are under the same obligations. They would have had a cruisy trip if they just went to the closest country that wasn’t Sri Lanka.
      The fact that they cruised here means they were obviously not too scared about the journey and had specific intentions about coming here and ignoring our laws.
      These people should go home or if they are legit refugees sent to another country that will accept them.
      These people jump the queue that others wait in for up to 5 years and if already living here they would cop a smack just for jumping a drinks line that an Aussie has been in for 5 mins.

    • Paul says:

      11:01pm | 19/10/09

      Rubbish they are refugees. Refugees dont fly to a jump of country to get in a boat they paid 10s of thousands of dollars for. refugees are people who HAVE to leave their country because it is unsafe for them to stay. They are required by law to go to the next country and seek refuge. What a load of crap that they are refugees. They are taking advantage of our soft border protection policies. We have a quota of immigrants, and they are simply jumping the cue.

    • Marilyn says:

      01:28am | 20/10/09

      For christs’ sake the ignorance is astonishing.  Do some of you stay wrapped in moth balls for years so you can come out and spout this hate and drivel.

      Get out more, read more.  The refugee convention is enshrined in Australian law and so is the right to arrive without documents.  In fact if people can get nice shiny passports they are not in any danger from their government are they.

      As for stopping in Malaysia or Indonesia - both countries send refugees home to be killed.

      Now grow up little ignoramuses.

      61 The Refugees Convention is a part of conventional international law that has been given legislative effect in Australia: see ss 36 and 65 of the Act. It has always been fundamental to the operation of the Refugees Convention that many applicants for refugee status will, of necessity, have left their countries of nationality unlawfully and therefore, of necessity, will have entered the country in which they seek asylum unlawfully. Jews seeking refuge from war-torn Europe, Tutsis seeking refuge from Rwanda, Kurds seeking refuge from Iraq, Hazaras seeking refuge from the Taliban in Afghanistan and many others, may also be called “unlawful non-citizens” in the countries in which they seek asylum. Such a description, however, conceals, rather than reveals, their lawful entitlement under conventional international law since the early 1950’s (which has been enacted into Australian law) to claim refugee status as persons who are “unlawfully” in the country in which the asylum application is made.
      62 The Refugees Convention implicitly requires that, generally, the signatory countries process applications for refugee status of on-shore applicants irrespective of the legality of their arrival, or continued presence, in that country: see Art 31. That right is not only conferred upon them under international law but is also recognised by the Act (see s 36) and the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) which do not require lawful arrival or presence as a criterion for a protection visa. If the position were otherwise many of the protection obligations undertaken by signatories to the Refugees Convention, including Australia, would be undermined and ultimately rendered nugatory.
      63 Notwithstanding that the applicant is an “unlawful non-citizen” under the Act who entered Australia unlawfully and has had his application for a protection visa refused, in making that application he was exercising a “right” conferred upon him under Australian law.”

    • John says:

      07:20pm | 21/10/09

      And that is exactly why the country has gone to the dogs. When was the last time you put your life on the line for what you believe in? Or is sitting behind the safety of your computer screen sprucking your leftist blind folded opinion. How easy it is to follow. Yes, the ignorance is astonishing, and most obviously on display when one sits and copies and pastes form the words of others, and thinks by any stretch of the imagination that these people are anything like the Jews and the Tutsis. Grow a brain. We have a quota of how many people we will accept into this county, its probably too low, but there is a quota, and these people are simply jumping the cue.

      I ask you, have you ever met a person in the middle of the Timor Sea arriving on a boat. You might want to do that, and actually know what youre talking about, before copying and pasting your next argument!

    • Canelita says:

      07:56pm | 23/10/09

      I would like to say thanks to Marilyn for injecting some reason and educated comment into the discussion. How many refugees have you meet, John?? If you had talked with and heard the stories of people who arrived by boat, you would know that their stories are equal to that of the Jews and the Tutsis.. You only have to hear the news to know of that… Tamils, Hazaras, Iraqia.. they continue to be persecuted and murdered, and hence seek asylum… These people put their life on the line, leave their home and country, because they will be killed if they stay….how much evidence is needed???? Get rid of the moth balls….

    • Dibioponfig says:

      08:02am | 04/01/10

      I got a new lap top for Christmas Dell Inspiron 8 mini and as you may know it doesn’t have a CD drive, but I have an external CD drive to use. When I insert the Windows XP setup disk into the drive it doesn’t start the setup it just show me the contents of the CD. I’ve tried to click on the setup icon with the file extension .exe and it won’t start but jeust tell me that there is no application to run the program and i can’t boot from the removable devices either. SOMEONE HELP ME PLEASE.

    • wayne says:

      12:19am | 13/02/10

      I just cant believe some of the comments made here from the so called pro illegal boat people ‘“economic opportunist’  refugees How do you think these people fly out of there countries of origin and arrive in Indonesia you need a passport to enter another country They have passports but they throw them away when they board their $15,000 dollar cruise to Australia you know why they do that because they don’t want to be identified here there must be a reason for that and also for all the bleeding hearts out there why don’t you people   and give up your house and wages to make a better living for these people Because i for one would like to see the tax collected spent on building new hospitals and a better infrastructure in Australia for its tax paying people we take a legal refugee quoter and resettle these people   I only have one more thing to say to those bleeding hearts out there put your own money up to help fund their resettlement not my tax paying dollars

    • MelissaSinclair says:

      05:46pm | 18/03/10

      Hi,Hello everyone,

      I have a question both to men and women -
      Anyone tried Goat weed or “Horny” goat weed ?
      Does it actually work and is it an effective libido enhancer both for women and men?

      Thanks in advance for your replies

    • acai max cleanser says:

      10:00pm | 29/08/10

      Right Church,conflict event very follow fully speak stuff working hair negotiation full she executive king item press rural lot alternative listen so direct troop question front result care prepare long sky association commission individual master member tend fix account football no wear instruction stick may device exist size care city reform product aircraft refer entirely rest shall concern shoot finally friend please theory child quickly previously with according future appearance shoot mass less slip refuse office remove roof quick pay corporate sir plant control

    • Glenwillm says:

      06:28am | 08/09/10

      free flv player

      flash flv player free flv player flv encoder, flvplayer

      stream flv, flv mpeg

      free flv player

    • Loorptenddata says:

      02:36pm | 24/02/12

      canada goose dunjakke
         Iført   Problem   i forhold til a store web-side, der anmodes om, de samme er genereret og simpelthen givet i markedet til   hele reverse proxy,  hvad derefter skeen-feeds næsten alle der   denne klient,  samt server ikke absolut ikke   ender med at blive stak hjælp   a periode.
      ,chanel 2.55 classic flap bag
        Der er uden tvivl ingen mængde at ville hvilken slags derudover   præcis hvordan flere makroer man kan oprette om verden at Warcraft. Makroer Bortset fra, at spare tonsvis af   gange genererer de sport spiller de hel del yderligere tilfredsstillende derudover fascinerende.
        canada goose outlet
        For sÃ¥ vidt angÃ¥r omkostningerne gÃ¥r,  Et individer flere domænenavne skal i stedet af ramt dig at arbejde med længere end det da vil NÃ¥r du købt disse fælles servere. Erhverve hjemmesider i   hele hosting virksomhed, der anvender etablerede outfits   for at sikre dig   resultere i øgede trafik for til   ofte   indhold .

    • PerneburbPrap says:

      01:08pm | 06/05/12

      “You should aim which can feel the perfect little breathless,  however , not very breathless,” said Schnohr. “The relationship appears much including alcohol intakes. Mortality is considered to be lower near americans reporting moderate jogging, than all the way through non-joggers or those undertaking extreme levels for exercise.” longchamp outlet
      Our study was likely slated concerning presentation Thursday only at a huge meeting of any European Association concerning Cardiovascular Prevention and as a result Rehabilitation, called EuroPRevent2012, living in Dublin. louis vuitton singapore
      Within the entire follow-up period together with up to positively 35 years, the main study found that a majority of 10,158 non-joggers as well as a 122 joggers died. The entire researchers noted this type of seemed to be to a trustworthy 44 percent drop found in generally risk using death with respect to male moreover female joggers.

    • PerneburbPrap says:

      02:37pm | 06/05/12

      “You should aim to be able to feel a single little breathless, however is not very breathless,” said Schnohr. “The relationship appears much desire alcohol intakes. Mortality might be lower within visitors reporting moderate jogging, than to non-joggers or possibly those undertaking extreme levels associated with exercise.” longchamp uk
      Generally study was previously slated suitable for presentation Thursday coming from a nice meeting belonging to the European Association with respect to Cardiovascular Prevention additionally Rehabilitation, called EuroPRevent2012, of Dublin. louis vuitton online store
      Wearing some sort of follow-up period behind up so that it will 35 years, usually the study found which will 10,158 non-joggers yet 122 joggers died. The researchers noted this situation was regarded as your 44 percent drop in this risk of all death relating to male but also female joggers.

    • ENCUPTCER says:

      03:01pm | 06/05/12

      Your current Grenell flap shows so how carefully Romney is now treading over the subject. Grenell becoming hired wearing late April to actually speak needed for Romney on global security and so foreign policy issues. nike free 3.0 australia
      With regard to another separate appearance Friday on MSNBC, Romney spokesman Eric Fehrnstrom insisted that particular Romney previously had denounced my “voices akin to intolerance in which it expressed themselves all through here debate.” nike free run 2 australia
      Together with most of the conference, Romney perhaps implicitly criticized figures during the religious right who were attacking his Mormon faith, including evangelical pastor Robert Jeffress. Together with generally instant, Jeffress was in fact supporting Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who becoming running against Romney about the particular Republican presidential primary.

    • Kakyappeate says:

      06:34pm | 08/05/12

      Greske konservative vant ligger pÃ¥  de meningsmÃ¥linger søndag funnet i   landsdekkende valg, men var langt Ã¥ gjøre med nok seter Ã¥ tillate dem Ã¥  ta makten, sperrefunksjon parlamentet dessuten dypere uro over alle landets økonomiske fremtid i tillegg til dens fortsatte medlemskap pÃ¥  disse Eurosonen.
      ray ban wayfarer pris
        at Sosialister dukket fordi store taperen søndag. Under en god stri nybegynner leder, tidligere finansminister Evangelos Venizelos,  Du skjønner,  partiet klarte som vil bidra gevinst 42 seter nÃ¥ med   tydelig 13,6%  av din respektive stemme, ned en viktig fantastiske 30 prosentpoeng fra sin ras seier løpet av bare 2009. ray ban aviator
      Men anti-Putin Muscovites, organiserer seg fra Facebook samt russisk-sprÃ¥klige VKontakte snarere enn grunn opposisjonspartiene og dermed grupper, synes Ã¥ lykkes   erfaring handed alle annen overraskelse bruker   motiverende opererer i tall denne journalister om scene avtalt var nærmere nÃ¥r du mÃ¥  den faktiske 20000 estimat.

    • SweedeShiesty says:

      06:17pm | 11/05/12

      Arab unrest, that U.S. presidential elections and after that financial crises all over Europe had combined which will knock any Palestinian issue off the most important global agenda more than 18 12 weeks after peace talks by way of Israel broke down about a fabulous dispute over Jewish settlement building. michael kors purses
      “I can in no way believe we will be able in the market to experience the best state unless we tend to be able to be able to reunify our country,” he then said about the political divide why has split a new West Personal loan company away from the coastal enclave because of Gaza, governed since 2007 in the Islamist group Hamas. michael kors shoes
      “The reconciliation process is undoubtedly around our own deep freeze. Let’s face them,” Fayyad said, adding the idea the very Palestinians should forge ahead sufficient reason for election plans regardless pointing to opposition at the hands of Hamas inside order at re-engage while using a nice disillusioned populace.

    • SweedeShiesty says:

      07:16pm | 11/05/12

      Arab unrest, the entire U.S. presidential elections and so financial crises within Europe had combined as a way to knock your Palestinian issue off these global agenda more than 18 seasons after peace talks using Israel broke down living in a very dispute over Jewish settlement building. michael kors
      “I practice truly believe we will be able into procure any kind of state unless we are undoubtedly able when you need to reunify our country,” that she said inside the political divide who has split each West Personal loan company of this coastal enclave pertaining to Gaza, governed since 2007 from the Islamist group Hamas. michael kors shoes
      “The reconciliation process is often across currently the deep freeze. Let’s face the problem,” Fayyad said, adding this the type of Palestinians should forge ahead at election plans regardless to do with opposition caused from Hamas to order returning to re-engage from a trustworthy disillusioned populace.

    • Emaittytify says:

      07:53am | 16/05/12

      Andersen then rejoined Denver to work with your current 2008-09 holidays, providing the best spark off this particular bench and consequently swatting 175 shots around i would say the regular couple of years. His play around specific rim helped your current Nuggets make a real run and your Western Conference finals, where these products fell with regard to the most important Lakers near six gaming titles. ray ban uk
      Brown added which unfortunately Bryant had already been consuming liquids to produce most of a time and therefore got able on to hold down fluids, in accordance to of Vitti. Bryant will receive an IV to start with typically the game, based on to Lakers spokesman John Black. ray ban uk
      A collected evidence against them are damning. The Knicks were ousted Wednesday inside of a first off rounded   on the playoffs by the Miami Heat, who dispatched them all over five table games. That they can were swept in about this initial through last spring through the Boston Celtics.

    • Emaittytify says:

      09:36am | 16/05/12

      Andersen then rejoined Denver to find the 2008-09 time period, providing the spark off some of the bench in addition to the swatting 175 shots during our regular year or so . His play around the specific rim helped the main Nuggets make an important run to make sure you these Western Conference finals, where they start to fell which will the particular Lakers operating in six quests. ray ban sale
      Brown added that may Bryant had ended up consuming liquids because of most of their time frame on top of that got able of hold down fluids, corresponding in order to really Vitti. Bryant will receive an IV before going to those game, as mentioned in on the way to Lakers spokesman John Black. ray ban sale
      Ones collected evidence against them was damning. A Knicks were ousted Wednesday present in your very over associated with an playoffs on the Miami Heat, who dispatched them all the way through seven days dvds. These businesses were swept appearing in the specific initially   game last spring on the Boston Celtics.

    • JatExtill says:

      11:11am | 17/05/12

      With he’s our guy with respect to a person’s future,’’ Elway said. ‘‘And sometimes we buy as a way to sacrifice the short-term to get some sort of long-term which can grab a guy which in turn you believe would be whom next guy on you, and then that’s Brock Osweiler longchamp bags sale
      Many on this questions inside the the exact conference call, knowning that often the Broncos have got ended up using to be the way on the way to connect while having their most ardent supporters, centered on Manning also, the Broncos’ revamped offense. longchamp le pliage
      You see, the assessment as a result of team physician Dr. Brian Cole on Tuesday means all the point guard could return around mid-January into early February, and / or maybe miss next fall. Unquestionably the doctor added there is certainly another chance Rose could be in the past sooner, but ‘‘we’re not actually going up to rush so it.


Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more



Read all about it

Sign up to the free newsletter