When good ships go down, most of us are left dumbfounded, stranded on the desert island of despair, powerless to do naught but shout “no!” as our once-cherished idol disappears into the drink.

The Hopetoun: End of an era? Picture: Rachel Moor

Disciples of the boot would recall the sinking feeling as Matty John’s sordid sexual past was plastered over the papers. Ditto for fans of a certain yeast-based sandwich spread which now appears to be a sacred part of their cultural identity.

But for fans of homegrown independent music, this week’s Titanic disaster was the news that The Hopetoun Hotel, Sydney’s breeding ground for emerging rock talent, had hit a few icebergs and wouldn’t be opening for schooners any time soon. And if you read between the lines, that meant maybe not ever.

The reason put forward by the management was that in a seven day period the hotel had been fined some $3000 by local police for not having adequate security, and accompanied by building upgrades to meet council standards was enough to send the good ship Hopetoun asunder.

Punters were, in a word, devvo’d. Sure it’s no small chunk of change, but what are the management doing that a $3000 fine could sink such an iconic pub? And what are the government up to with licensing laws requiring bouncers to guard venues the size of broom closets?

Within nanoseconds the call rang out: “Save The Hoey”. Crikey, didn’t we just go through this trying to save FBi Radio? Do we really have to get bloody Richard Branson to bail us out of every cultural corner we paint ourselves into?

Jesus Sydney, man up you weak bastard!

The headline “Small pub goes bust in economic downturn” is hardly worth holding the front page for, but the desire to turn such an event into, “Pub closure sounds death-knell for Sydney live music scene” while entirely inflammatory, is worth a gentle prod.

You could argue that grungy 30-somethings that kept the Hoey afloat in its heyday are all starting to grow up, plop out puppies, move to the burbs and just don’t have time to support local bands anymore. You’d hardly hold that against them.

You could also argue that the next generation perhaps aren’t that fussed with pub rock anymore, and would much rather get dolled up and head to unmistakably more “now” locales. That too is hardly a crime.

But Mark Gerber, owner of one such trendy venue, The Oxford Arts Factory, offered a somewhat more realistic reason its failure on Triple J’s Hack, about moving with the times and being more realistic about the scale of the industry.

“Live music doesn’t really pay, we all know that. You need to diversify and look for other ways to make an income during the early part of the week when there’s not that much live music happening. You can’t survive on seven nights a week of live music in Australia, we don’t have the population”.

Maybe Seymour Skinner was right. The times they are a’becoming quite different, and old habits don’t just die hard, they die off.

The question of course is, what’s it going to take to save this sucker? Bankrolling? Pokies? Trivia? Mid-week bar mitzvahs? Opening an uglier, flashier version next door called iHopetoun2.0, galvanising opinion and sending outraged punters flooding loyally back to old faithful?

Whatever crafty measures, something needs to be done, as there’s plenty about this rub-a-dub worth fighting for.

The Hopetoun is much more than just a pub. It’s a small but important cog in a wheel that’s in all our best interests to keep turning, if we don’t want our musical choices dictated to us by Australian Idol dimwits.

For years The Hopetoun has been crucial for emerging artists looking to gain their first steps in the biz. It’s is an attractive yet attainable goal. If you could make a dent at the Hoey, it didn’t necessarily mean you’d made it, but it did mean you were probably onto something and should keep slogging away.

But also, The Hopetoun is one of those pubs that people feel a proper bond with. For those who’ve wandered through its doors, grabbed an earful of music and a skinful of booze, the feeling of loss is somewhat akin to losing a cherished grandpa - the cool one that swore and drank, gave you your first ciggie and told you to harden the f—- up.

And while getting all sentimental over a stupid old battlecruiser might seem somewhat immature, to echo the words of Daryl John Kerrigan in The Castle, fighting to explain the true value of his endangered property, “It’s not a house, it’s a home. You can’t buy what I’ve got”.

The Hoey is that crappy little castle at 3 Highview Cres Coolaroo, and anyone who’s bought a beer there is a card carrying Kerrigan. It’s not overly beautiful and it doesn’t smell all that great. It’s hardly a native title claim, but it’s got something that I want to give myself an uppercut for saying but I’m going to say anyway – heart and bloody soul – which is thin on the ground these days and doesn’t deserve to be banished to the posterity of the pool room for all eternity.

And it would be fortuitous to enlist the talents of someone slightly above the buffoonery of Dennis Denuto to make sure this Sydney landmark doesn’t become just another place to piss away your weekly wage into yet another banal bank of mindless fruit machines.

Save the Hoey. Spread it.

Save The Hopetoun Facebook group.
Save The Hoey on Twitter

Audio (MP3): Triple J Hack Hopetoun broadcast

12 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • benvolio says:

      03:51pm | 02/10/09

      Like thee Mr Deal… I played on the Hoey stage. Unlike thee… it was only once. I still see it as the pinnacle of my live (and v.short) career.

      The Hoey was my Everest. That’s how much it meant to me.

      Only 3-4 months ago I stood spellbound and only 3 feet from one of my heroes - David Bazan - as he took the stage at the Hoey.

      It was first place I saw people booed for playing one of the 3 lonely poker machines in the back.

      It is worth saving dammit! If only to maintain the vibe of it. Call Denus Denuto… resurrect Bud Tingwell… save the Hoey!

    • jonathan says:

      03:58pm | 02/10/09

      Well said, Chris, well said indeed.

      Maybe the Hoey should listen to ol’ Matey up there what said that about not being able to survive on live music 7 nights a week.  The Maybe just Thurs-Sun, then have it as a regular pub the rest of the time.  The number of times I haven’t gone in there for a beer because there’s been a cover charge to see a band playing to 5 punters I can’t count.  So I ended up around the corner at the Cricketer’s Arms instead.  The Cricketer’s does incredibly well,  is full most nights, has about 4 (always vacant) poker machines, no big screens playing the footy and one major difference from the Hoey: no live music (or accompanying cover charge).

      If it re-opens, maybe it’s time to look at the business model.  There’s no shortage of thirsty people looking for a refreshing ale, but there is a shortage of people paying to see local live music.  Time to cash in on the former without alienating the latter… somehow.

    • Dave says:

      04:15pm | 02/10/09

      I live nearby, I’ve never been though have never had anything against the place.  I hope they give it a nice refurb and make it into a wine and Tapas bar.  I don’t know if you’d noticed but the grunge is slowly moving out of Surry hills - the exception being the homeless shelters and hostel.  The heyday would have been back before the eastern distributer was put in, when getting to the airport involved driving through taylor square and down bourke st.  The fact is that surry hills used to be a crappy area well suited to grungt pubs and that just isn’t the case any more.  The real tragedy is not that the Hoey is shutting down in its present location, its that there is no new opportunity to start a grungy bar in a crappy area.

    • jonathan says:

      04:31pm | 02/10/09

      Dave: what’s your point?  The last thing Surry Hills needs is another wine and tay-pas bar.  Talk about generic.  As soon as all these places with actual character are closed down and move out you’ll start lamenting how it used to be cool here man and where did all the yuppies come from.

      Benvolio: reminiscences of Bazan has brought a tear to my eye and a tingle down my spine.  That second show is the best thing I’ve ever seen at the Hopetoun, hands down. 

      I’ll miss it if it goes.

    • Mark says:

      04:35pm | 02/10/09

      It’s easy to sit here in Melbourne and feel smug about the fact that our live music scene seems far more healthy than yours in Sydney - evidence: the plethora of inner city venues in Melbourne where you can see world class bands any night of the week (backed up by the two best community radio stations in the country).
      Yeah, it’d be easy to feel smug, but it always makes me sad when a venue like the Hopetoun closes, because these places are part of our cultural fabric. A city’s spirit isn’t something conjured by some marketing expert. It’s organic, and it emerges from places like the Hopetoun, where creative, energetic and passionate people congregate.
      It’s not just in Sydney that we see music venues closing down: iconic punk venue CBGBs shut its doors in New York a couple of years ago. The Hacienda in Manchester.  And we’ve seen venues come and go in Melbourne over the years too - I can remember how devastated I was when the Punters’ Club closed in Fitzroy.
      Kathy McCabe is right: no amount of Facebook friends or heartfelt blogs will save live music venues. People need to get off their arses and go to gigs. Hey, I’m as guilty as everyone. My 20s are now a fond memory and family responsibilities constrain my ability to get out midweek.
      But I’m also a romantic. So remember this also: rock music survives. It survives. It always survives whatever the authorities - whether it’s the fun police, the censors, or archaic inner city liquor licensing laws - throw at it. And it’ll survive the closure of the Hopetoun too.
      Somewhere right now, some kid has just been inspired to pick up a guitar or sit behind a drum kit . . .  and other venues will open somewhere, giving a stage to another generation of bleary-eyed hopefuls in tight jeans who have nothing more to offer than three chords and an undimmed, passionate belief in the redeeming qualities of loud, fast and dirty rock & roll.

    • LTL says:

      05:32pm | 02/10/09

      Re: Mark’s comments. Actually, the live scene in Sydney is pretty healthy if you compare to just six or so years ago. Venues such as Spectrum, Oxford Art Factory Theatre, World Bar, etc are a few of the ones that have sprung up in that time. The Hopetoun issue is way more complex than just Syd vs Melbourne or people not turning up at shows. The last few that I went to there were packed.

      I really was riled by the Kathy McCabe piece because I’m pretty sure a lot of these people (and the people who actually started the Facebook page) are the ones who you do see at the Hoey and other venues around the traps. (And it’s so easy, cheap and lazy to put people down for actually caring or rallying behind something.)

      There’s been so much cheap blame thrown around and not as many constructive ideas about how to avoid this happening again and how to build on the energy that this incident has galvanised. Where to start?

    • Matt says:

      05:48pm | 02/10/09

      F*** it, I’m off to The Annandale.

    • Jay says:

      05:59pm | 02/10/09

      Sad - but to borrow from your article, Chris “Harden up.”

      The Hopey is gone because of the Muppets running it. I don’t see why I, or anyone else, should save their idiot arses. And you have to ask yourself - what is the site worth, and it’s not just a fine and a reno that locked the doors…

      Live music costs money - a CD of the latest hits and an APRA licence tend to be more attractive to the bottom line. A sad, sad fact - but one that plays out all over Australia, and better venues are being throttled because of it.

      That, and I personally blame Australian Idol for dumbing down the music industry as a whole.

      But then, I am but one man, whose capacity to deal with singing hairdos has diminished considerably over the years.

    • Now where am I going to drink says:

      06:51pm | 02/10/09

      Pay the staff

    • Jon Seymour says:

      10:08pm | 02/10/09

      Well said, Chris

    • Kurisu Sonsaku says:

      10:20pm | 02/10/09

      I’m with Mark on this one, the live music scene in Melbourne caters to every taste with an abundance of venues, i’ve lived in both Sydney & Melbourne and Melbourne has a more diverse and entertaining live music scene 24/7.

    • Daniel says:

      10:50pm | 02/10/09

      Pub stories are quite interesting. I could tell some really colourful stories about the Beresford Hotel in Surry Hills. Now its all gobe high class. I remember going there when it was a day club.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

TAbbott to fight PHI rebate cuts on behalf of 2.5 million to pay extra, but won't say what he'd do as PM. http://t.co/lXWpMXXF

Anthony Sharwood

Numerous workplace safety rules (no harness, fall arrest etc) broken in this pic of Roosters coach Brian Smith http://t.co/jx4PgtBs

Anthony Sharwood

Yo, mummy bloggers! Your expert input is required in this doozy of a child-rearing dilemma http://t.co/0JfOnCq1

Anthony Sharwood

The factory where they make Boeing aeroplanes is the world's largest building #Todaysrandomfact.

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Would you kill for a job?

Would you kill for a job?

Who would work in an abattoir? Most of us have done jobs we didn’t want to do because we needed…

Friday Dilemma: child cruelty or harmless fun?

Friday Dilemma: child cruelty or harmless fun?

Parenting. It’s the new oneupmanship. Ah, how quaint the days now seem when parents could raise…

Hipsters with hip replacements

Hipsters with hip replacements

Someone once told me that when people reach a certain age they begin dressing in the manner they did…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Punch on: Open thread 09/02/2012

marley says:

I'm one of the older ones, so I've certainly seen a few changes in my time. When I started school I learned to write with a nib pen, dipped in an inkwell (no, I'm not kidding). My mother became a dab hand at getting inkstains out of my clothes. Flicking ink at one another in the classroom was an essential… [read more]

From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics

Erick says:

Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

151 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter