I have not read the book Eat Pray Love, nor have I seen the movie Eat Pray Love.

Dear diary - me, me, me, me, me, me, me…

In fact I rarely eat, rarely love and haven’t prayed since the third quarter of the AFL Grand Final.

I am therefore in a uniquely untainted and unbiased position to be able to say that this deformed abomination of fertiliser-grade horsesh-t should be blasted back into the hellish furnace of retardation from whence it came.

It is about time that the people of planet Earth stood up and said that no more will they tolerate moronically banal observations by ten cent philosophers who think that if they say the sky is blue and then pause long enough with an expression that means they are either deep in thought or taking a dump that everyone will gasp at this sudden clarity of insight.

Fortunately I have not had direct exposure to every ode to spasticity uttered in this self-indulgent atrocity, but even having had them repeated to me by now-former friends makes me feel dirty and invaded, as though a parasitic worm is sucking out my intelligence.

Take for example this seemingly popular line:

“Having a baby is like getting a tattoo on your face. You really need to be certain it’s what you want before you commit.”

Well thank Christ someone told me that. I thought you could just bang one out on a whim and leave it at the casino. But now that Elizabeth Gilbert has shared her epiphany with me I realise that it’s preferable to have a baby if you really want one. Boy it’ll take me a few days to get my head around that concept.

It is also worth considering that, by my calculations, Gilbert was 36 years old when she wrote that. It took her no less than 36 years to figure out that it was important to be sure you wanted a baby before you had one and even then she was dumb enough to think that it hadn’t occurred to anyone else.

This is toxic stupidity – although of course we are talking about a woman who also thought she needed to remind other people to eat.

Even leaving aside Gilbert’s formidable intellectual rigour, the morality of her quest for self-adulation at all costs is also worthy of note.

Despite covering my ears and screaming every time someone mentions this steaming pile, my understanding is that she left her husband after he said that he wanted to go back to study and she didn’t want to support him financially.

Normally the following old chestnut is a cheap trick, but in this case it is irresistible: Just imagine if the roles were reversed.

Just imagine if a woman told her husband she wanted to return to study and he refused to support her, divorced her, and went jetsetting around the world until he shacked up with a hot Brazilian babe. Then imagine he wrote a book about it and thought that people would feel sympathy for him.

This is beyond rampant narcissicism. This is verging on psychopathy.

Of course I realise some people will say “But Joe, how can you know you don’t like Eat Pray Love if you haven’t read it or seen it?” And I would say this: I haven’t had my legs sawn off by chainsaws but I know that I would not like it—although it would still be preferable to reading one page of that rancid trash.

Indeed the only mind-numbingly obvious thought that hasn’t infected Eat Pray Love is that there are seven billion people on the planet with bigger problems than her and none of those problems will be solved by her self-obsessed banalities.

Gilbert is to empathy what Al Qaeda is to western decadence: Not only does she not practise it but she wants to wipe it out across the world.

Indeed, the truly terrifying thing is she is urging other people to be like her. How many millions of hours, days and lives will be wasted on bourgeois self-reflection while the world burns? How many adult brats are being created by glib one-liners that disguise rampant self-indulgence as some tin-pot philosophy?

Eat Pray Love is an assault on serious thought. It is a virus that feeds off selfishness, laziness and vanity and one which must be wiped out at all costs.

Don’t miss: Get The Punch in your inbox every day

Get The Punch on Facebook

128 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • A Bob says:

      05:15am | 13/10/10

      How do I know I hate it when I haven’t seen it? It’s got Julia Roberts in it. QED.

    • F Hindle says:

      09:15am | 13/10/10

      Thank you!!! I haven’t read or seen it and hope never to do so. I feel stupider for having seen the TV advertisements & sad that these kinds of films are what is inspiring women these days.

    • Ferrall Flynn says:

      05:31am | 13/10/10

      The scary thing here is, this is now mainstream consciousness,it,s everywhere,it has pervaded young humanity to the point of no return,it is the end of the human race, and where do we lay the blame, Hollywood.

    • Bec says:

      06:13am | 13/10/10

      Of course EPL is total crap. It’s poorly written, it fetishizes other cultures, and it’s full of platitudes by which those who lack fortitude can lead their lives.

      Just as movies like “I Hope They Serve Beer In Hell” and “Hot Tub Time Machine” are the equivalent for male versions of the aforementioned. Remember that the lazy and irresponsible are the rule, and not the exception, for both sexes equally.

    • James N says:

      08:05am | 13/10/10

      Hot Tub Time Machine glorifies irresponsibility? I thought it was just dumb (albeit entertaining) comedy. I don’t think anyone looked to it as a life philosophy.

    • bec says:

      05:28pm | 13/10/10

      Wait, “Hot Tub Time Machine” was a comedy? Damn. I didn’t laugh once. When watching it, I felt like funny was dying.

    • Your Mother says:

      06:17am | 13/10/10

      Having not read your article past the opening line I to am in a unique position to say…bollocks to you.

    • Lady Fong says:

      08:46am | 13/10/10

      Mother, I agree with you but I get his drift.  I had the misfortune of reading the book but didn’t dare say I hated it as all the book clubs etc. just LUUUUUVED it. I may go to see the film just to perv on Javier Bardem.
        Son, you have a great point too: I loathe, hate, abhor, detest this positive thinking lark that goes on and on and on. Face it world, you have 1 in 3 billion [gender, remember?]  chances of being Miss Universe…so get use to not being beautiful, slim, tall…wait for this, blonde.

    • Sleepless says:

      09:09am | 13/10/10

      Ladies, I would strongly recommend that you both read Joe’s article with an open mind. I’ve been reading everything that he writes for a number of years now and this column just like all the others he has written is intelligent, informative and above all is worth reading.

      Oprah is responsible for putting this book on the ‘must read’ list with her book club. She has a lot to answer for. She did same with ‘Secrets”. Remember how that turned out????

      Life is too short to read trash like that, it’s as bad as the Secrets. Why do we need to be told by someone what to do? Aren’t we intelligent enough to work it our for ourselves?

      I’ve seen the trailers and this movie is not screaming SEE ME! Why do you want to give people who are worth millions more money for staring in this trash?
      Julia is going to Italy to learn how to eat again? Oh pleaseeee!!!

    • Reg says:

      09:19am | 13/10/10

      Lady Fong, I’d love to hear some of the reasons your book club liked it. The world is littered with rubbish such as this and even my determination to stay away from fiction is being frustrated by recommendations from people whose judgment I used to trust.

      With respect, I am a little disappointed to hear you chose to remain silent rather than be disagreeable. wink

    • C1 says:

      06:30am | 13/10/10

      Jo,

      Love your work!!! My wife is seeing this film with a friend later in the week - best I do not show this review to her. Chances are she will like the film (she liked Sex and the City) or more likely she likes the opportunity to have a couple of champagnes after the film with no kids around.

      My experience of travel in those parts of the world is ‘Eat the local product - Love the tastes -Pray you do not get sick!!!

    • bwren says:

      02:25am | 16/10/10

      Really?...you “love” his ” work”...well I can tell you as a writer that your humble journo has decided to sit down and write a “lets rip the shit out something article” on a film without watching it or reading the book it comes from, in the process making some bitchy pronouncements and denunciations that indicate that he is preaching from a bloody high perch. But isn’t that what journalism is all about?

    • trigger says:

      06:30am | 13/10/10

      “God never slams a door in your face without opening a box of Girl Scout cookies…”— Elizabeth Gilbert (Eat, Pray, Love)

      Does God pay people for the cookies before he crackes them open? Does he share the cookies? Either way it doesn’t excuse the door slamming. Who accepts cookies from a girl scout, opens them immediately, presumably because they cannot wait to scoff them down, then slams the door in her face?

    • Reg says:

      09:26am | 13/10/10

      Trigger, I’m afraid I can never get past the image of cookies made from Girl Scouts. Please ... promise you’ll never mention them again?

      Why is God aiding and abetting the consumption of Girl Scouts?

    • Onemack says:

      07:04am | 13/10/10

      Eating the words Joe, loving them, praying for more,

    • Aims says:

      07:12am | 13/10/10

      I think you’re missing the point. a woman who believed she ‘had it all’ suffered a nervous breakdown, and realised that if she continued living the way she was, then she would die. quite likely kill herself. she didn’t leave her husband because he wanted to study..

      for a book that journeyed through depression and mental illness to find the things, situations and experiences that effectively gave her hope and made her enjoy life again, I say it did quite well.

      I enjoyed certain aspects of the book. there were parts about the Hindu philosophy that I found relevant to my life. particularly about how people find their balance, and everything in life makes demands of us but can be graded on a tangent.

      don’t belittle something just because you don’t like it or couldn’t be bothered to read it. had Julia Roberts not decided to be in a film about it, I doubt you would have made the effort to write your vitriolic little article.

      I enjoyed the book, but I wont be watching the film. this doesn’t mean that I would judge anyone who will. learn some tolerance.

    • T.Chong says:

      07:33am | 13/10/10

      Aims , I wouldnt get too wistfully teary eyed about Hinduism . Its a set of fables like any other.
      Hinduism and the caste system that forms it basis has to be one of the most contemptable social systems the world has had to endure.
      Poor, sick, disadvantaged- well thats your fault. Pray to a god , then he or she might make it better for you next time, otherwise tuff.
      Maybe white people are attracted to hinduism because they do not understand it.  A problem with all religions.

    • A Bob says:

      08:02am | 13/10/10

      She broke down because of her narcissistic ‘had it all’ lifestyle, so she went out on an equally narcissistic journey of self discovery so she could come back and declare ‘I got it all’ again, only this time with deep’n'meaningfuls. But she did keeps some of her old ways, as the book can be had for just $49.95!

      The sequel will deal with her next breakdown when she discovers the mystical thuths she ‘discovered’ were really a load of crap. Oprah will be spruiking it, no doubt.

    • BK says:

      08:18am | 13/10/10

      Having a mental breakdown, or any other illness isn’t a general purpose excuse for selfishness. It is nice that the rest of us can sympathise with these people, but some people will misuse that sympathy.

    • T.Chong says:

      08:59am | 13/10/10

      Aims, please bear in mind that Hinduism is based on castes.
      The “balance’ involves believing that all things are preordained, and that if things are tuff , then its your fault for not living a more pure previos life.
      Like any belief system it is heirachical, and used to keep the population in its place. The same as any other religion.

    • Your name: Nora Charles says:

      09:08am | 13/10/10

      Your comment: The truth is, the author is just a self-absorbed little me-monkey who sadly, has suckered in large numbers of middle class, idiot women.

      Any counsellor will tell you, the best way to get over depression is to do something for someone else. Perhaps if this little ball of ego donated her time helping the poor, the elderly, the disabled, it wouldn’t have taken her six months for her to get her act together.

    • ABC says:

      09:22am | 13/10/10

      Aims,

      If you want to read something that is a true commentary on the humanity of man in the face of irrideemable evil and torment and the capacity to rise above it, read “If this is a Man” by Primo Levi.  Truly inspirational, none this completely ridiculous, find yourself, be true to your self, self absorbed unreconstructed crap that is “Eat, Pray, Love”.

    • Likes Joining Dots says:

      10:33am | 13/10/10

      ABC - thanks for the tip. I was reading this blog with “Life is Beautiful” playing on my mind when I read your post.  I’ll definitely have to track down “If this is a Man”.

      And, sad to say, I must now read EPL. *sigh* the sacrifices we make for a balanced view.

    • Yon Toad says:

      10:41am | 13/10/10

      Aims n Nora, I found everything I needed to know about life and relationships in ‘The Park in the Dark’ and ‘The Owl and the Pussycat’. As for depression and the poor - pharmaceuticals and a c’est la vie attitude get me over them little humps.

    • J.G. says:

      02:39pm | 13/10/10

      I agree, wow, I have not read the book, and have not seen the movie yet.
      Although I have a great appreciation for people with an open mind, they leave a lot of room to learn, and build on character. Sometimes on the odd occasion you see or hear people that may feel, in a moment, so inadequate within themselves that they may feel the need to tear others down, depending on one’s values of course.
      Its that search for a little satisfaction and significance if only being for moments.
      Yet the thing is that taking these small shots and i mean taking them at another persons expense, for happiness and significance, that real satisfaction is never sought.
      I believe that if a person or people have the courage to go for their dreams, they should go for it.
      There needs to be far more encouragement and acceptance in society, toward ourselves and each other if we are to evolve happily.

    • Paul M says:

      11:07am | 17/10/11

      I’m getting the feeling that I’d like to see this movie to be able to heckle “Get a Job!”.

      What the hell is “grading on a tangent”?

    • narel of adel says:

      07:15am | 13/10/10

      If you knew how many women had children because they really believed they wanted one and then regretted it, you’d understand the line “Having a baby is like getting a tattoo on your face. You really need to be certain it’s what you want before you commit”.  As a childless female, my friends who have children know they can be honest with me and it’s alarming that so many of them seem to regret the decision.  I don’t think we can use the above line enough in making people think long and hard about having a baby.  I wonder if these children will be okay or will pick up their Mothers’ regret at their existence.

    • Warren says:

      09:05am | 13/10/10

      What were your friends expecting when they had children? A fantasy world they read about in New idea or saw in a chick flick? I doubt a trite one-liner about a tattoo will raise the wisdom of people that stupid.

    • Jade says:

      11:45am | 13/10/10

      I think the problem would be that your friends thought “oh yeah, a cute squishy baby, what a fun life” and in reality got late nights, no social life, shitty nappies, vomit and no time for themselves any more.  It all comes back to selfishness when you think about it.  They don’t realise the gift that they have.

    • HB says:

      12:30pm | 13/10/10

      That is because many women base their decision for a child in selfishness.  They believe that the child will love them unconditionally , will validate them, will fill the void.  This is tragically incorrect and these children suffer becasue of it.  It is the parents job to love unconditionally, to validate, to give all to the child - and the child is to take, and grow and eventually give back.

    • bow says:

      12:53pm | 13/10/10

      I feel sorry for your friends children ... are they BB (Baby Bonus) kids?
      (Give me $5000 and I spit out a kid -  but after the money goes I don’t want to know them anymore) They sure sound like ...
      I’ve heard that Oprah recommended the book- that’s enough for me to avoid it like the plague

    • nate says:

      12:28pm | 18/10/10

      HB speaks the truth, but I should also add that some women want to have kids for other stupid reasons like ‘as a way of fixing a disfunctional relationship with their boyfriends’. They seem to think that if a relationship doesn’t work, by having a kid they can force their partner to stay and therefore the relationship will work itself out. Sure sometimes it does work out that way, but for every single one that did work out you’ve got tens of thousands that didn’t.

      Some of them also seems to think that babies are like pets and that when you’re bored with it, you can give it away to someone else. And for the truly horrible people, dump it somewhere else or kill it.

    • T.Chong says:

      07:25am | 13/10/10

      Yes, the world is just beastly to white middle class women.
      What do the poor in the Sudan, or Lagos or Haiti have to complain about?
      Self discovery seems to have occurred, and now the heroine needs to give herself a rest.
      Agree with Joe H. Any bloke writing a book about how he split from the wife to find himself, and someone else would be met with the derision and contempt it would deserve.

    • hdr says:

      08:24am | 13/10/10

      hi T.Chong, what got into your head to respond to this non-story

    • Lady Fong says:

      09:06am | 13/10/10

      “Agree with Joe H. Any bloke writing a book about how he split from the wife to find himself, and someone else would be met with the derision and contempt it would deserve. ”  Whaddya talking about! Men do it all the time. It’s called the mid-life crisis: they buy bikie leather jackets, a red sports car and date young twinkies while doing a comb over to hide their balding head. They write about it all the time too. It’s called literature…yes, and sell millions of dollars…make films about them [seven year itch?]. We just lap them up and consider that ‘normal’ but when a woman does it, all hell breaks loose. I know, I know. The world is not fair and yes, I am used to it.
          But we can all laugh about it? A man in his 50s told his wife he was leaving Cairns, going around Australia without her ‘to find himself’. So off he went but in a fortnight, he phoned his wife from Innisfail and said he wanted to come home. Her reply: ‘No coming home for you. You can’t have found yourself in two weeks.” This is a true story.

    • T.Chong says:

      10:17am | 13/10/10

      See Lady F., you prove the point. The male manager who buys the Harley and heads off with the typing- pool temp. is considered a shallow narcisstic joke of an idiot.
      So why does it become virtuos because this woman did eactly the same?

    • Peter says:

      07:26am | 13/10/10

      What Joe said.

    • A says:

      07:32am | 13/10/10

      This was so brilliant that I think I am in love with you.

      I am so sick of vapid western women complaining about their lives because they’ve been so consumed with their narcissistic self-indulgence and pursuit to have it all because they think they’re worth it and deserve it.

      Go to Darfur and see how people live there and then be thankful for what you have. Heck, you don’t even need to go you just need to be aware that it exists to be thankful for what you have.

      This self-indulgent twaddle is now the yardstick for so many soccer-mums who think their life is hard and they deserve a break. Honey, you don’t know hard so STFU.

    • mary wide bay says:

      08:58am | 13/10/10

      Same.

    • Realist says:

      12:26pm | 13/10/10

      Reminds me of the Curtis Stone Coles indian ad..

      Why would 100 indians dancing around give two figs if a white australian child was able to finish a bowl of a meal made for the equivalent of US$10??  All 100 of them could probably have been fed for three bucks in india..

    • Heather says:

      12:46pm | 13/10/10

      Oh I so agree; I am so sick of whinging, self-centred, narcissistic, privileged, pampered middle class, mostly women but sadly now men too, reading some trite one liners written by happiness consultants or the like…life is not meant to be permanently happy and fulfilling; get over it.

    • marley says:

      02:36pm | 13/10/10

      @Heather - well, I don’t totally agree that life can’t be happy and fulfilling - I think it can - but it generally involves looking outwards, to other people and their needs, and not indulging in this sort of lightweight chain of consciousness thought bubbles that passes for introspection these days.

    • Mandy Mc says:

      07:32am | 13/10/10

      I agree wholeheartedley with the last two comments so all I will add it that if we can’t be true and kind to ourselves - we can’t be “good” to others, so Liz’s journey, I see, as one fulfilling herself but relevant and necessary to others in her life as well. The book was great (and I have just started the follow on - Committed”) and I saw the film last night and enjoyed it (by Hollywood standards)

    • Mandy Mc says:

      08:07am | 13/10/10

      Obviously I agree with the comments of Aims and Narel - I submitted my thoughts when I read theirs but delay to check comments have meant I sit below more men taking this book way out of context !

    • Nora Charles says:

      09:12am | 13/10/10

      Utter garbage Mandy.

      Try being good to others first and then you’ll find your sense of purpose and worth.

      You’ve bought into a self-destructive lie.

    • ABC says:

      09:25am | 13/10/10

      I’m a woman, a friend forced it on me, blithering about how life changing it was.  I got through two full chapters before practically pegging it at the wall in disgust.  I hated it - two chapters of unempathatic narcissm.  Tried to force myself to complete it but couldn’t cope with the frustration.

    • Elphaba says:

      09:52am | 13/10/10

      I’m with Nora.  I’m frequently unkind to myself, but have no problems being kind to others.

    • A says:

      12:22pm | 13/10/10

      Now I’m hurt.

      I was hoping there was another woman out there that had no sympathy for vacuous women who whine about having to stack the dishwasher and do a bit of shopping and cooking.

      Not to mention the complete distaste any rational person has for faux-spirituality.

    • Macca says:

      07:44am | 13/10/10

      Joe, This is the funniest article I have ever seen posted on The Punch, Hazaar!

    • AFR says:

      07:44am | 13/10/10

      I have seen it (my caveat is that I was escorting a young lady in order to impress her), and can tell you, it is deadset awful, cliched, predictable drivel. Sorry, but Shirley Valentine was done decades ago. Of course after the movie I marvelled to my date about how it was a wonderful example finding inner peace and knowing when to love again yada yada yada,

    • A Bob says:

      09:05am | 13/10/10

      I take it you got laid, then?

      That’s what these films are really for. Thay are generally made by men.

      Guys can go see them, rub some salt from the popcorn in their eyes to cry a bit, and, hey mama, come to papa! Free market economics at its best.

    • AFR says:

      09:48am | 13/10/10

      Unfortunately I didn’t get laid. AND the tickets were Gold Class smile

    • A Bob says:

      10:06am | 13/10/10

      Whoa! That’s a lousy ROI! I hope she has some other redeeming feature; drives a Porsche, got a hot sister etc…

    • Adele Ephron says:

      07:46am | 13/10/10

      My sentiments exactly Joe. I’ve had the best laugh reading this- literally made my day. If you really want to be bored to tears you should read her book Committed. Vapid boring drivel.

    • Peter Campbell says:

      08:08am | 13/10/10

      Thanks Joe, I admire your deep horror of banality.
      Nice passionate writing. Considered writing about politics?

    • Shane says:

      08:11am | 13/10/10

      Jeez Louise. It’s a M-O-V-I-E so calm the f**k down and stop sounding so hysterical. It is not compolsory to see it so relax.
      Joe - are you angling for a talk back radio host spot? If so, wonderful audition piece. Make sure you mention the “outrage” of it all to really ram it home.

    • Viola says:

      08:14am | 13/10/10

      It was actually, a great story of the journey through coming out the other side of life falling off its axis, knowing to take responsibility and which anyone who has had their heart broken, male or female, relates to it. There is a naivety to it yes, because at the time, she didn’t know any better. PS - she was in her late 20’s early 30’s.

    • Sleepless says:

      09:22am | 13/10/10

      Well since I’ve had my heart broken a number of times, got over it, came out on he other side and allowed someone else into my life does it mean that I have the right to write drivel about it???

    • kylie says:

      09:41am | 13/10/10

      Viola,
      I’m in my mid 20’s and I know how to take responsibility for my actions.

    • Reg says:

      10:00am | 13/10/10

      An interesting observation Sleepless. I’ve noticed to that every new mother also has the impression that it’s never been done before and leaps in to write a book about it.

    • Sleepless says:

      11:01am | 13/10/10

      Reg, sadly too many people think that they can make money by re writing history. We can all dream up a holiday adventure. I’d rather watch ‘Bridget Jones Diary” again, at least it was funny at times

      On the subject of drivel, last I heard a 16 yo kid was writing his memoirs.

    • A says:

      12:28pm | 13/10/10

      Life falling off its axis?

      You mean she lived in one of the poorest countries on earth, with no political leadership, no social infrastructure, no economic infrastructure, warring factions, barely enough food to sustain herself, at the mercy of just about any man that wants to take advantage of her?

      Then one day a group of armed militia storm into her viallage and rape her and every other women there and sell the children into slavery….

      Oh wait, she’s Americanese. A bunch of ignorant, self-obsessed overweight chese-in-a-can eating war-mongers.

      She has nothing to complain about.

    • heather says:

      12:49pm | 13/10/10

      You said it; A. And by the way, Viola, late 20s? Surely a woman should be an adult by her late 20s…oh yes, sorry, as A says, she is American ...and of course, not some poor Black American, living in poverty

    • Lorena Paglia says:

      02:55pm | 13/10/10

      It’s just one person’s story - that’s all.

      The highlight to her age is due to the author of the blog thinking she was closer to 40, having said that, I knew how to take responsibilities for my own actions as a teenager. Like I said, just a story. Don’t read it or watch it if you don’t want to.

    • Sam de Brito says:

      08:23am | 13/10/10

      You’ve peaked, Hildebrand. It’s all downhill for you now. You can never top this magnificence. I kneel before you.

    • A says:

      12:31pm | 13/10/10

      That’s kind of like saying Hillary peaked when he climbed Mount Everest and it was all downhill from there.

      What? Too many puns?

    • fairsfair says:

      08:23am | 13/10/10

      “Toxic Stupidity… Steaming Pile… Rampant Narcissism…Rancid Trash”

      Having read the book - I give your review five stars.

    • bella starkey says:

      08:24am | 13/10/10

      May I reccommend Andrew Gottlieb’s brilliant counter-balance “Drink Play Fuck”.

    • ABC says:

      09:27am | 13/10/10

      One of the books I love is Richard Wilson’s “Can’t Be Arsed”.  It’s a reaction to those 1001 things you must do/read/see etc before you die.  Hilarious!!

    • Tash says:

      08:26am | 13/10/10

      Joe, honey… you’re not the target audience. How do you explain someone who likes Gilbert’s writing as well as your own though?

    • Sleepless says:

      05:50pm | 13/10/10

      Tash, are you implying that the target audience of this garbage of a book are ONLY females?

      Have we gone backwards? Is trash like EPL only written for women? Are you telling us that the author of this trash thinks so little of women being a woman herself?

    • Lauren says:

      08:29am | 13/10/10

      You haven’t read the book? You can have my copy. Actually I’ll pay you to take my copy. Biggest waste of $35.00 and a week of my life. This book was soooooo boring! and the woman is so full of herself it’s disgusting. She decides one day to leave her husband, after many years of wedded bliss and promising him children, yet she proceeds to bad mouth him for making the divorce hard! Hey bitch, you are the one who left him! You destroyed his life and his dreams! If anything he should write a book about what a bitch you are

    • fairsfair says:

      08:56am | 13/10/10

      ha ha ha! I am working on some potential titles smile

    • Likes Joining Dots says:

      11:00am | 13/10/10

      Lauren, if you really must get rid of the book, please send it my way - it’s now on my must read list (plain packaging is fine, something discreet, you know no title showing or anything like that), thanks again LJD

    • marley says:

      02:40pm | 13/10/10

      I believe the ex is indeed writing a book.  I do hope we get an equally ascerbic review when it comes out. 

      Why do these incredibly boring and unaccomplished people think anyone cares about their struggles with good and evil, and their ultimate surrender to utter banality?

    • Caroline Overington says:

      08:53am | 13/10/10

      Yes, but how do you know you don’t like it if you haven’t seen it, Joe?

    • HarlequinBeetle says:

      08:57am | 13/10/10

      Now, please define ‘Philosopher’ - suspect many think they are and arn’t ...other are sure they arn’t and are…bit like brave and eccentric…..never self label

    • Claire says:

      09:05am | 13/10/10

      I do not intend on seeing the movie. It looks like a load of junk.

      Having said that, I have read the book and did enjoy parts of it. I do see where people are coming from with the whinging woman complaint but I also know a lot of people out there who are stuck in a life with children that they didn’t really want (men and women both).

      People should be free to do what they want with their lives and while EG’s choice is a bit of an extreme one, I know quite a few people who were inspired to take up the pottery or language course they always wanted to and this has improved their life’s happiness quite a bit. If that’s all the book does, that’s enough.

      By the way I am not sure where you are getting the not-wanting-to-support-her-husband-while-he-studied thing from. He wanted to have a baby and she didn’t and that’s why she split up with him.

    • Mandy says:

      09:08am | 13/10/10

      Read the book, not a fan. Won’t bother with the movie.

      That being said, surely no one is so full of their own self importance that they can slap together such a vitriolic piece about a book they’ve never read, and a movie they’ve never seen. The one flaw, and a glaring one at that, in your chainsaw meets movie anaology is that you know having your legs hacked off will be painful and will potentially kill you, that’s simple logic. However, you’ve based your opinion that you won’t like the movie on the opinions of others, and clearly they haven’t bothered to watch the movie or read the book properly since you’ve illustrated your points with an example from the book/movie that wasn’t in there.

    • Shama says:

      09:22am | 13/10/10

      I haven’t read the book, I don’t intend to see the movie.

      But from what I hear its a fairly accurate capturing of certain aspects of life for Western women. And the job of any book is to be honest about lives even if they are self-absorbed. By the same token that other trashed film, SATC2, is mindless nihilism for our times (again I ahven’t seen it). I don’t see anything wrong with that.  The lives of Western men by the way are equally incomprehensible to a billion other people on this planet - be it the agonising over metrosexuality or the addiction to comics and related material or the obsessing over obscure bands or the defence of serial monogamy. Men write about these things but aren’t trashed and no one calls them a virus that feeds off selfishness, laziness and vanity (even though they are).

      I am totally bored with the EPL bashing simply because it seems like faux outrage and an easy way to not write about serious stuff (because that requires effort) and yet sound all intellectual. Leave it alone and maybe use your pen to write about stuff that deserves an analysis?

    • Kate says:

      09:23am | 13/10/10

      Love it Joe. I did see the film for a fund raiser and the central character was so self indulgent and I agree that it would have been howled down had the main character been a man. Also, as the book character was in her mid-30s then either cast an actress in her 30s in the role or make the film character in her 40s? Yes Julia is beautiful but she doesn’t look in her 30s.

      As for the book’s sad success, well, think of that ridiculously cliched, simplistic Men are from Mars and Women are from Venus from the high voiced, John Gray [According to Wikkipedia he gots his PhD by correspondence from an unaccredited unviersity so “Dr” seems OTT ] . Apparently that is being turned into a movie too. Lord save us.

    • Elphaba says:

      09:30am | 13/10/10

      Fantastic Joe, well said.  I bet the same people who drool over ‘Eat Pray Love’ are the same people who think Edward Cullen is the greatest romantic figure to have ever lived.

      ‘Scuse me a moment *puke*.

    • not Sue says:

      09:39am | 13/10/10

      So it’s vapid and banal. So it’s self -indulgent and narcissitic - just like the author if this article venting his jaundiced spleen on the world. Yawn. Ever heard the idea that all things are relative? The suffering of the poor and the oppressed is obviously not the subject it’s addressing, it’s concerned with western affluenza, not the problems of the third world..and it’ s ENTERTAINMENT. Full stop. I doubt it will be made compulsory reading/viewing on any university syllabus soon. Take a chill pill and go watch another ep of “Two And A Half Men”. Vapidity is not the exclusive province of women, mate.

    • Horthy says:

      12:52pm | 13/10/10

      The Gender Card: Is there nothing it can’t do?

    • Tempest says:

      09:42am | 13/10/10

      <Standing ovation> Bravo! Bravo!

    • MrsK says:

      09:44am | 13/10/10

      I liked the book and I look forward to seeing the movie. It was an intersting perspective on the illusion of having it all - an illusion that I know I am guilty of trying to fulfill. Somehow, it legitimised some of the doubts and fears I felt but didn’t feel I could talk about. How can you complain about a successful career, being well-paid, a husband keen for children and everything else falling into place?

      To some, this might sound like middle-class self pity. But to me, and I’m sure many other women, it was permission to have doubts about everything that you were supposed to want but weren’t sure about. And know you weren’t the only one.

    • Ms Spaghetti says:

      09:54am | 13/10/10

      Im reading the book now & up to the end of the eating phase…I must say its a boring read so far not something you cant put down…More like nod off on the train with…Ill only see the movie for the man eye candy..I wont be selling up & going on a world trip

    • Danny Janevski says:

      10:10am | 13/10/10

      This article is PURE GOLD. This book has nothing to do with Eating or Loving or Praying.

      Certainly we all know Love is never self-indulgent but rather self-sacrificial… especially from a religious point of view.

      But for some reason people seem to adore this book.

      I guess I put it down to the fact that most people have a desire for a deeper sense of purpose, but are only ever so happy to platonic-ally engage this desire through reading the current best seller written by a woman for women.

      Loving and Praying are certainly not whimsical concepts, but rather thoughtful processes which require a lot of time, effort and ultimately dedication.

      The popularity of it displays the depravity of our culture today.

      Book should be called - “Fast Food - Fast Love - Fasting”

      Well written Joe !

    • Danny Janevski says:

      10:10am | 13/10/10

      This article is PURE GOLD. This book has nothing to do with Eating or Loving or Praying.

      Certainly we all know Love is never self-indulgent but rather self-sacrificial… especially from a religious point of view.

      But for some reason people seem to adore this book.

      I guess I put it down to the fact that most people have a desire for a deeper sense of purpose, but are only ever so happy to platonic-ally engage this desire through reading the current best seller written by a woman for women.

      Loving and Praying are certainly not whimsical concepts, but rather thoughtful processes which require a lot of time, effort and ultimately dedication.

      The popularity of it displays the depravity of our culture today.

      Book should be called - “Fast Food - Fast Love - Fasting”

      Well written Joe !

    • Lachlan Gilbert (no relation) says:

      10:23am | 13/10/10

      You don’t know what you’re talking about Joe, it’s the best thing since the Celestine Prophecy.

    • Traxster says:

      10:34am | 13/10/10

      Jeez Joe,the movie’s stars Julia Roberts !!!!!!!!
      What ,more do you want ???

    • stephen says:

      10:59am | 13/10/10

      Lyndon Barber gave the film two and a half stars, which means a bit below average.. but wait Julia’s in it, so I just gotta see it. I like her a lot.
      A lot of actors are too script-based. Julia’s too appealing - in and out of character - for words to matter so much.

    • Greg says:

      11:01am | 13/10/10

      Which AFL grand final?

    • HanK says:

      11:04am | 13/10/10

      Love the article Joe! At last I can find a place where like-minded people gather to rubbish this piece of self-indulgent narcissistic drivel.

      As a female in the target demographic for this tripe, the only worse thing I can think of would be reading the Twilight Saga. Retch.

      It’s unfortunate that this ‘me’-moir could have been salvaged had the writer displayed any sense of self deprecation. But no, she just took herself way way too seriously.  After all, the poor dear had it all and didn’t know how to handle it… so she went on some kind of journey of self discovery to do what? Find inner peace? Or to maybe to just replace all the old boundaries and strictures of her old life with new different ones - that all have the same psychological function but in new brightly coloured ‘spiritual’ packaging.

      If she had managed a modicum of proper introspect then she would have been able to sort out her ‘problems’ without just running away from them and replacing them with newer versions. It sounds to me like the traditional mid-life crisis but in female form. Snore.

    • Rebecca says:

      10:14pm | 15/10/10

      did you mean to say ‘At last I can find a place where like-minded people gather to write their own self-indulgent narcissistic drivel.’ I enjoyed the review, but these coments are just the same old hate fest with bigger words.

    • benny of perth says:

      11:08am | 13/10/10

      about 8 weeks after reading that book my ex gf pulled the pin and took off to europe now i am starting to put 2 and 2 together . anyone know the authors postal address i really should send her a box of chocys

    • Sleepless says:

      11:20am | 13/10/10

      A number of books that are a must read for the people who think they want guidance and for others who don’t grin
      1. Alchemist
      2. Pilgrimage
      3.  Valkyries
      4. The four agreements

    • Tim says:

      11:43am | 13/10/10

      5 Internets to you sir,
      brilliant.

    • Joolz says:

      12:05pm | 13/10/10

      I tried to read the book. I thought the writer was self-indulgent. I ended up chucking the book at the wall and wondered why I’d wasted 20minutes of my life and $20 of my hard earned on the literary equivalent of bovine excrement.

    • Loving It says:

      12:31pm | 13/10/10

      Saw the movie & loved it. I don’t care about the life philosophies - it’s a movie people (i.e. short term escapism) Sit back and eat in the wonderful ambience; pray with thanks that your life is not as shallow as this; love what you have! BTW I’m a married male and have no hangups on my relationship…

    • Amused bystander says:

      12:49pm | 13/10/10

      I think it’s interesting that at 8:02am the book was $49.95 (@A Bob), then at 8:29am someone said they had bought it for $35 (@Lauren), before dropping to $20 (@Joolz) by 12:05pm..

    • Peter Campbell says:

      01:38pm | 13/10/10

      Market sentiment affects share price…note one person offering to pay someone to take it away.  Might go and see the movie now, this thread has been good, fun, reading.  I reckon I’ll feel pretty superior after seeing it.

      Han K got it spot on.

    • Ollie says:

      01:35pm | 13/10/10

      @HB, this is perfect:  “It is the parents job to love unconditionally, to validate, to give all to the child - and the child is to take, and grow and eventually give back”.

      As a parent, I have never heard parenting encapsulated so accurately.  You should write a book; something like “Eat, Love, Pay…”.

    • Zeta says:

      01:57pm | 13/10/10

      I’ll keep an open mind about bad writing, because even people who can’t write have great stories to tell.

      But I’m a skeptical about a story of a woman who has a break down and goes on a journey of self-discovery which was paid for by a book deal signed off on before she left…

      So, she has her big ‘crying on the bathroom floor’ moment (yeah, I read it. I read Breaking Dawn too, wanna fight about it?) then she picks her self up, calls her publisher and says ‘I think I might need to take a journey of self-discovery and I want you to pay for it and I’m pretty sure my journey will emphasis eating, praying and loving which is the title of the book, k?’ And the publisher is all like ‘Hmm, this woman is legit.’

      Yet at no point in the book do I recall her mentioning this salient fact.

    • fairsfair says:

      02:19pm | 13/10/10

      Keep peeling back the layers Zeta… Each day you expose a new side to yourself.

      You are either every woman’s dream… or worst nightmare….

    • Shama says:

      03:17pm | 13/10/10

      Gilbert has been writing for a long time on diverse topics including a bio of a woodsman called The Last American Man which is not bad at all.  Her TED lecture on creativity is generally held to be good even by her detractors.  She is not a novice who set off one day on a voyage of self discovery. Plus she has always been upfront about her book deal and the money.  And any professional writer will do so.  Are you assuming that Theroux for e.g. sets out on his own money?

      Diffreence is Gilbert’s book became a mega success, maybe she didn’t expect it either. So cue the haters.  The book taps into a huge market of middle class perhaps middle aged women, the same ones who made Mamma Mia and SATC2 a success.  They and their desires are an easy target to criticise.  But I do see elements of misogyny in the criticism because it’s not as if other segments of the population are consuming anything more edifying.  Some self reflection is in order by people who tap out platidudes on shallowness here and then go home to their wii, TV shows, gyms etc.

    • Shama says:

      03:27pm | 13/10/10

      And might I add that EPL appears to be a travel book and there have been plenty of similar books written by men of discovering themselves in duly exotic locations.  Heck the genre was probably invented by men.

      Maybe Joe woud do good to read the book instead of jumping onto the outrage that really has resulted from a *movie made in Hollywood*.  Time was when people turned in essays based on the film of a book, these days it appears even that is not necessary for a critique.

    • JohnHatchard says:

      01:58pm | 13/10/10

      <<T.Chong says: 07:33am | 13/10/10
      Aims , I wouldnt get too wistfully teary eyed about Hinduism . Its a set of fables like any other. Hinduism and the caste system that forms it basis has to be one of the most contemptable social systems the world has had to endure.>>
      Agreed that the caste system in India is horrific, but no more so that the class system was/is in the UK or the monetocracy elsewhere today.
      Anyway, the caste system is a much later addition to Hinduism, an accretion like barnacles on the hull of a ship, not part of the original. It is not supported by any significant thinker or spiritual teacher that I have either heard of, read or met.
      My experience of this faith has taught me more about spirituality than any Christian teacher I had.

    • Ian says:

      05:19pm | 13/10/10

      Well, it doesn’t appeal to me either, but seriously, who pissed in YOUR cornflakes?  Jeez, say you don’t like it, and move on to something more worthy.

      Save us all the angst!

      Go the Pies! 
      And the Holdens.

    • Sleepless says:

      06:07pm | 13/10/10

      Trying not to laugh to hard. Dymocks descries EPL as a heartfelt memoir.

    • Chris says:

      06:28pm | 13/10/10

      Well Joe you seam to have a stick stuck up your backside.
      It’s actually a nice movie. Sure it’s not necessarily an oscar winner but neither are 99% of the so called winners esp crap like Titanic etc.
      I watched it expecting it to be a boring over the top chick flick and was surprised.
      It was a nice feel good movie without the usually violence and America/American tosser saves the world BS or heaven forbid some Australian crap we get assaulted with.

      To be honest I most of the time I couldn’t care less about the 7 billion other people and their problems on this planet and I’d say most of the 7 Billion people feel the same. Why should some who is writing a book for money?
      Honestly I haven’t read the book myself and probably won’t.

      I think it’s a bit rich for a person with their own blog to call someone elses work “self-indulgent and narcissicism.”

    • selfhelpbooksaregoodforlevelingcofffeetables says:

      02:17pm | 14/10/10

      if you dont care most of the time about 7 billion people on the planet why did you bother to write such a reply,  and if u really believed that the 7 billion or so didnt care or feel the same,  this writing stuff really is a waste of time. So Chris i dont care was made to care, and sillyness is pointed out.  Joe pointed out sillyness self absored   people such as your self should take note,feel good movies are a narcissist reward for not caring,  this medium of movie and book is up your ally dont care, you dont care and no 1 should care about self help books, that only help a few people,  the person selling the crap and the timber industry.  now who cared i got that off my chest, thats right dont care if u reply or not

    • Chris says:

      08:29pm | 14/10/10

      “So Chris i dont care was made to care, and sillyness is pointed out.”
      Well for a start I never said I don’t care at all as you seem to be saying here. I said “most of the time”.
      I just spend most of my time working and trying to get by like most of the 7 billion people on the planet. If that makes me self absorbed so be it.
      I look after research animals so my main concern is their health and well being. The last thing I will be thinking about during my day is the 7 billion other people on the planet unless it’s called for.
      If you can’t deal with it that’s your issue not mine.
      Anyone who doesn’t like feel good movies must be missing some of the emotional parts of their brain. What if someone has been having a crappy time and feels they can’t get by in life? They go and see a feel good movie and get a bit of a laugh or it picks their spirits up. What’s so narcissistic about that.
      Lets see about the little amount of time I do care.
      Funny how you are trying to pigeon hole me as some self absorbed narcissist.
      I took photos at the company ball for free because the PhD student don’t have loads of cash to pay $10-15 per photo we usually ask.
      Out of the hundred odd cars on plenty rd yesterday i was the only one who stopped to help push a broken down car uphill off the road as I have done on a few occasions.
      So Phooey to your holier then thou rant.
      The movie was great and hopefully fun sponges such as yourself don’t ruin the world for the rest of us.
      Joe and yourself need to actually see the movie and lighten up or would that not fit in with your stuckup, I care all the time, I’m so special view of yourself.

    • Bookgirl says:

      07:32pm | 13/10/10

      Joe is sounding like an angry little man. It’s a movie…and even if it is a bit of fluffy entertainment (that no doubt many women will appreciate) many people have invested time and energy into creating it. You don’t have to go and see it or read the book, just let others enjoy it in peace. If it really is about a woman who learns to value herself and it encourages other women to do so too then isn’t that ok? Women in this generation may appear to have it all but the reality is many women are working, raising children, maintaining a household and some are also caring for elderly parents or grandchildren. Why don’t you give women a break and allow them to discover self-worth.

    • Sleepless says:

      12:57am | 15/10/10

      Bookgirl, how many women will appreciate a female who walked out on her marriage & responsibilities , and went on an selfish journey of ‘self discovery’?

      Re read the blog with an open mind, there is no anger there, only humor and honest description of the main character.

    • Kate says:

      09:15pm | 13/10/10

      Fantastic article. Every time a friend likes this book or movie I die a bit inside.

    • Mandy says:

      07:46am | 14/10/10

      Funny, funny, funny. Yes, yes, yes to your point of rampant selfishness. Love it, love it, love it.

    • sproket says:

      08:59am | 14/10/10

      Liz Gilbert, I have the perfect name for the book Joe H should write in response to your woeful story. It will be called “Eat, Shit, Die”. I may have missed a word there

    • bigmuzz says:

      10:24am | 14/10/10

      Blame Oprah….

    • Bex says:

      11:04am | 14/10/10

      I totally agree with Chris’s statement   ‘I think it’s a bit rich for a person with their own blog to call someone elses work “self-indulgent and narcissicism.’


      Reply

    • K says:

      11:19am | 14/10/10

      i’d never even heard of this garbage until i read your article

      thanks for making my day

    • Sleepless says:

      03:57pm | 14/10/10

      It’s not Eat Pray Love, it’s Egotism Prey Lust hehe

    • Tomatzso says:

      07:38pm | 14/10/10

      Saw the film last night with my wife - we walked out.  Your uninformed review - only by not having seen film or read book - is spot on and dead funny.

    • Paul says:

      08:38pm | 14/10/10

      On the head Joe. Brilliant.

    • Zach J says:

      09:55pm | 19/10/10

      The movie might be crap (I’m not sure as I haven’t seen it), but gee, what a terrible article. If you haven’t seen the movie or read the book why oh why should anyone consider your opinion relevant? I’m not sure how many hours will be ‘wasted’ on ‘bourgeois self-reflection’, but surely if anything could be considered a true waste of time it’s an article written by a soulless journalist ABOUT a movie that they haven’t even seen! At least the person reflecting on life is trying to better themselves.

      As for the ending of your article, that was just scary. You sound like a nazi.

    • Brendy says:

      11:54am | 17/10/11

      As Charlie Sheen says, this artclie is ?WINNING!?

    • isotonic says:

      03:17pm | 17/10/11

      It’s also worth mentioning that the author had the book deal and $200K advance in place before setting off on her spiritual journey of recovery and self-discovery.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

Cheeky beers with morning papers in unexpected sunshine http://t.co/MD7VPRne

Anthony Sharwood

http://t.co/Zq0nGxkf nice pic of Thredbo this morning

Paul Colgan

@seamus yeah it's now called Smooth or Soft or Douchey Dad FM or something

Paul Colgan

It's a Sydney thing, but 95.3FM... Why? It used to be all Bohemian Rhapsody and Walk this Way; now it's Father to Son and Country Road. Wah.

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter