In racing, the term “pie eater” is an old-fashioned, gently derogatory term for hard-bitten punters. Pies are all they can afford after their weekly pay cheque has yet again put Sunday roast on the bookies’ dinner tables.

Who's the jockey? Who cares! Pic: News.com.au

Well, the pie eaters of Australia have suddenly developed a taste for Black Caviar. That’s Black Caviar, the mighty mare who this week made it 18 wins from 18 starts in her most devastating racetrack outing yet.

Black Caviar attracted 20,000 infatuated racegoers to Caulfield on Saturday, the majority decked out in her salmon-and-black racing colours. Twenty thousand, to a race meeting which would usually attract a quarter that many. With the gates sensibly thrown open for free, they flocked to see the champion, who paraded around as if she knew she was just that.

In his poem “Do They Know?”, Banjo Paterson once poignantly asked whether good horses know they’re good. He answered the question with a definitive “you bet they do” in the last six lines.

They know just as well their success
As the man on their back.
As they walk through a dense human lane
That sways to and fro,
And cheers them again and again,
Do you think they don’t know?

The lines were penned over 100 years ago, but they could just have easily been written on Saturday. The crowd swaying after the race. The horse lapping up the attention, jockey Luke Nolen revelling in it but admitting that his job was pretty much as simple as “not falling off”.

Thunderous isn’t the word for the applause. Rapturous, more like it. The Pope held a mass at Sydney’s Randwick Racecourse four years ago for World Youth Day, but that was nothing on the reception for Black Caviar at Caulfield on Saturday.

More and more, racing is a cold, mercenary numbers game these days. The TAB is little more than a poker machine, with races from New Zealand in the morning and the northern hemisphere long into the night. Each race is as unromantic as a spin of the pokie reels. The horses themselves are mere names and numbers, as anonymous and unheroic as the binary zeroes and ones which underpin the computer betting programs.

And then occasionally, a champion comes along and reminds us all that racing is a magnificent endeavour. That it is, in the purest terms, a sport. In the first decade of this century we had two jolting reminders.

One was the sprinter Takeover Target, the broken down old hack bought for $1200 by Queanbeyan cabbie Joe Janiak, who lived in a caravan on Queanbeyan racecourse which was covered in pine needles. Takeover Target won in every mainland state of Australia, blitzed them at Royal Ascot and banked $6 million, which it’s safe to say is more than the cab takings in Queanbeyan on a Saturday night..

And then there was Makybe Diva, the stayer who won an unprecedented three straight Melbourne Cups from 2003 to 2005. After the third, trainer Lee Freedman urged us to “go and find the smallest child on the racecourse”, his inference being that they would never see the mare’s equal no matter how long they lived.

He was right. We’ll never see that again. But in Black Caviar, we have something even more special. In a word, it’s dominance. It the way she wins. The way her victories never, ever look in any shadow of a doubt.

Makybe Diva used to bury herself away in the pack before unleashing that devastating acceleration. Even her staunchest supporters had their hearts in their mouth during the race.

The best place to watch a Black Caviar race is from the bookies’ payout queue. That way, you don’t have to wait long when she inevitably wins. But the point is, she never for a moment looks anything but the winner at any stage of her races. She really is just a class above.

In the ‘90s, my favourite horse was Octagonal. He won a Cox Plate and nine other Group Ones and was a joy to follow. But he was a scrapper. A real street brawler. He always seemed to be involved in warfare with one horse or another until he miraculously stuck his nose in front on the winning post.

Black Caviar always looks in control. That acceleration. There’s something machine-like about it. To the jockey, it must feel like revving a Porsche against a field of Kombi vans, The owners must feel as coldly assured of a win as the bean counters upstairs in the casino.

Some have tried to quantify her greatness with numbers. Others with the clock. Apparently, she strings together sectional times over three consecutive furlongs (200m sections) that other horses can sustain for just a single furlong.

But really, the only number you need to know is that 20,000 who jammed into Caulfield. They came because when Black Caviar lets down at the top of the straight, she is as unstoppable as a tsunami. It really is a thing to see.

Of course, the horse has her knockers. It wouldn’t be an Australian story without them. Poor old Simon O’Donnell nearly fell off his Channel Nine stool in frustration trying to howl them down. I’m with him. There is a time and place for tall poppy syndrome. Then there is a time and place to open your mouth and gawp in awe.

Inevitably, as Phar Lap and Takeover Target and many in between have done, Black Caviar is now overseas bound. She’ll have one or two more runs here, before targeting Royal Ascot in the British summer, possibly via a race date in Dubai.

Whether she wins or not hardly matters. Oh, we’d love her to show those uppity toffs a thing or two, but Black Caviar has already done much for racing here.

Typically, punters only love horses that make them a dollar or two. But no one but the connections have profited from Black Caviar. She is such a pronounced favourite every time she races, you can’t win anything. Her odds were $1.10 on the weekend – again. That means you’d have won just $1 for a $10 bet. This horse is not sustaining us through GFC II the way Phar Lap got a nation through the depression.

Ah, but occasionally, horse racing enriches the sport-loving masses in other ways. Banjo Paterson knew that. And he firmly believed that great horses know it too.

 

33 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • stephen says:

      07:02am | 13/02/12

      She’ll never be like Phar Lap and will never have the same aduration because she’s only a sprinter, and as such, her race is over in a minute.
      On Saturday she was paying a $1.04, which means that if her odds are going to be like this forever the stewards are going to have to include a few mules in the race just so’s trifectas can get interesting.
      I think Hong Kong beckons then English Races.
      Good luck to her, and when she comes home if Tony and Julia are still haggling about nothing I propose a new suit and tie for for B.C. and she may want to take her own punt at the top job.

    • SM says:

      08:54am | 13/02/12

      The fact that she may not receive as much adulation as Phar Lap has nothing whatsoever to do with her being a sprinter - it’s because Phar Lap raced during the depression when the country needed a hero and because racing in those days was much more a part of everyday life for large parts of the community than it is now

    • VVS says:

      09:07am | 13/02/12

      Agree. Sprinters will never be looked at in the same class as the great distance runners.

      As for betting, it is better taking a punt on another horse at fixed odds and hoping BC is a late scratching…

      Her races are actually do nothing for bookies as no one takes a punt on them anymore.

      They need to find her a competitive horse who can beat her a few times to create a rivalry. Consistently match them up in big races - not shy away and take the easy wins each. That would be worthy of history.

    • SM says:

      09:38am | 13/02/12

      @VVS

      “As for betting, it is better taking a punt on another horse at fixed odds and hoping BC is a late scratching…”

      lol - what a punting strategy that is… you’d be slaughtered with the deductions if a miracle did happen and she was scratched (assuming you could even subsequently find the winner), and on the 99.99% of times she wasn’t scratched you’d be throwing your money away

    • hawker says:

      09:43am | 13/02/12

      “Agree. Sprinters will never be looked at in the same class as the great distance runners”

      Which, if it is the case is ridiculous as the horse racing landscape has changed since Par Lap. Our iconic races may be over longer distances but our depth in those ranks is woeful, and yet we produce the best sprinters in the world. BC is dominating in the area where racing in this country is the strongest.

    • Tim says:

      10:04am | 13/02/12

      SM,
      he’s talking about pre-post betting. There would be no deductions.
      Although I still don’t think it’s a good strategy.

    • RED says:

      10:04am | 13/02/12

      @VVS
      Great strategy as long as you’re prepared for the 80% deduction

    • VVS says:

      11:00am | 13/02/12

      It wasn’t meant to be taken seriously as a betting strategy guys… hence the word “hoping”...

      If you took that seriously, I have a giant rock in the middle of Australia you may be interested in. No claims on the property to my knowledge.. hehe

    • T-rev says:

      11:28am | 13/02/12

      I’m pretty sure VVS isn’t offering a strategy for all you wannabe punters.

      Just that you are more likely to have a miracle happen, like a late scratching perhaps, to get a decent return on a Black Caviar race.

      However, if you actually look at the figures, the prayer may not be a bad idea. Taking the weekends race:

      Black Caviar - $1.04 odds
      Next backed runner - Southern Speed - $16

      Now, on a $100 win bet on Caviar, you would receive $104 back for a win, or $4 profit.

      If you fixed bet on Southern Speed $100 @ $16, you would receive $1,600 back before reduction - after an 80% reduction that is still $320 or $220 profit.

      So, it is $4 (almost guaranteed) profit vs a longshot $220 profit. 4% return vs 220% return.

      220/4 = 55. So, from a statistical POV if Black Caviar scratches only once in 55 starts theoretically you should be in profi, provided you picked the winner in her absence.

      Can anyone tell me if my calculations are correct?

      Not that I’m advocating such a strategy, I’d never do it. And I don’t think VVS is. But theoretically it isn’t that bad, and I’ve seen worse “systems”.

    • Mark says:

      07:03am | 13/02/12

      A great article. As you say, all you can do is look at her in aww….and yes it would be nice to show those uppity poms a thing or two.

    • The Proud Aussie-Brit says:

      07:42am | 13/02/12

      Well, put your money where your mouth is and put her in the Grand National instead, lets see how she handles jumps instead of the flat.

      Toffs does not equal poms, you misread the post; in fact (and especially in the current climate), you would be looking hard to find the average UK man or woman who could afford the expense to get to Royal Ascot, let alone the ridiculous garb you have to wear for it, even in the more ‘relaxed’ areas. 

      It is not like “The Cup” where the average punter can go, take a look at the dress code for the areas.  Even as a man, if you don’t have a top hat, you will not get into Royal Ascot and removing it is oh-so-bad form (!).

      I somehow don’t think ‘thongs and a singlet’ would qualify as ‘national dress’, who really out of the rank and file NCOs would (want to) turn up in full Service Dress, esp. on a warm, 25c day ?...and ladies, don’t have fake tan or a hat that might be the same as someone else, esp. the Queen…oh, the shame.

      http://www.ascot.co.uk/?page=Dress_Code

      Stupid antiquity for it’s own sake.  I think that England has modernised a lot since the Victorian era, but some don’t seem to think so.

    • Kebabpete says:

      09:56am | 13/02/12

      What a load of rubbish. I’ve been to Royal Ascot 4 times in the last 6 years and the General Admission only require a suit, shirt, and tie, and the and Silver Ring Enclosure doesn’t even require that. The Royal Enclosure requires a top hat but you also need to be a member, royal, or sponsored by a 4 year member to get in; so most normal punters would never get in anyway.

      Like racing in Australia, the tv coverage might make it look very regal and full of toffs and celebs but the reality is that any punter can and does attend.

    • The Proud Aussie Brit says:

      12:13pm | 13/02/12

      What, and ‘normal punters’ rock up in a suit, shirt, and tie ?  Doubt it, most ‘normal punters’ I know don’t or wouldn’t.  The ones I know stick in the TAB and are still every bit as serious about their betting.

      It’s called Royal Ascot for a reason, just like it’s called Ladies Day for a reason.

      Easy to write off a whole post with the unimaginative comment “what a load of rubbish”, how about the bit about putting Black Caviar up against the best at Aintree if you seem to know so much ?

    • SM says:

      02:04pm | 13/02/12

      @TheProudAussie Brit

      “Well, put your money where your mouth is and put her in the Grand National instead, lets see how she handles jumps instead of the flat”

      lol…the Grand national is run over four and a half miles - Black Caviar is a SPRINTER who races over less than one mile. That’s like suggesting Usain Bolt should prove himself by running in the marathon

    • The Proud Aussie-Brit says:

      09:31pm | 13/02/12

      SM, why not ?  If she’s that good, she can adapt, at least give it a bloody good try like her two legged counterparts.  Alberto Juantorena did in the ‘76 olympics; Seb Coe did a 4x400m relay leg at 45.5 seconds, so that quoshes your Usain Bolt theory.

      Yes, breeding plays a role, but you cannot tell me that it is the be all and end all because horses compete in so many different types of sport (incl. showjumping), it is also a matter of training a horse.

      If breeding was “it”, then we would never see success stories like Takeover Target and Red Rum. 

      Boxers fight up, down, outside and sideways of their weight divisions, racecar drivers race different codes and as I showed, distance runners can be sprinters, why should horses be that special ?

    • Knemon says:

      07:45am | 13/02/12

      She is simply awesome, if she travels overseas without any problems then nothing will beat her.

      Nothing wrong with $1.10 Ant, where else can you earn 10% for less than a 5 minute outlay? You can’t.

    • Port Punter says:

      07:49am | 13/02/12

      1.04 are slim odds, but try getting a 4% return from a bank in under 90 seconds wink  Black Caviar is about as safe an investment.

    • Tim says:

      08:05am | 13/02/12

      Uppity toffs?
      hahaha, yeah the owners of Black Caviar are real battlers.

      They went so slow for the first half of Saturday’s race, they pretty much handed her the race on a silver platter.
      10.6 secs from the 400 to the 200, unbelievable and unbeatable.

    • CR says:

      09:13am | 13/02/12

      An obtuse reference perhaps?  ‘Pie Eating’ with respect to race horses?

      In National Velvet, the horses name is ‘Pie’

    • Fred says:

      09:36am | 13/02/12

      Why would you go and see a horse that you can’t make much money off unless you want to lay down massive sums and the prize money goes to the rich owners?

    • SM says:

      10:17am | 13/02/12

      Because, Fred, people who love racing get goosebumps when a true champion comes along.  It’s not always about punting

    • Who Stole My Sock says:

      02:04pm | 13/02/12

      Agreed Fred. I think I fell asleep during Saturday’s race it was so boring. I mean really? No track records in 18 starts? Is this really Australia’s fastest? And it’s easy to win against 8yos and staying mares. I’ve seen goats on my farm go faster than those horses. Talk about giving her the race on a platter. The reason she ran such a good sectional was because they plodded along so slowly she didn’t use even a drop of energy, and was able to sprint away. Looks to me like a DECENT horse beating rubbish to me. If she can win as easily over 1600m as she did over 1400m, there’s no reason why she can’t race against a horse such as Frankel. Actually they better not, that might mean she loses. Gasp! And don’t whine about ‘haters’, it’s not a legal requirement (yet) to universally adore Black Caviar.

    • Dan says:

      03:59pm | 13/02/12

      Who Stole My Sock and the rest of you who think she’s never beaten anything - have a look at HayList’s record until he beat her…and the one time he raced in a Group 1 without her last year. Hay List is about 4-10 length better than every other Group 1 sprinter in Australia. She brains him every time…once it looked like it wasn’t completely easy.

      Its not always clever to disagree with the media.

    • Lauren says:

      10:45am | 13/02/12

      Haters are gonna hate.

      My favourite part of the race was realising that Black Caviar required no additional ‘encouragement’ (read: whipping) to get her going. You see all the other jockeys going nuts at their horses trying to hurry them along, but watching Black Caviar you can see she is saying “Hey, I got this,” while Nolan is there to enjoy the scenery.

    • Farken says:

      11:51am | 13/02/12

      because the other jockeys were riding nags .

    • GB says:

      02:08pm | 13/02/12

      One of those “nags” won the Caulfield Cup last year Farken. These are Group 1 winners and while she might make them look like nags they’re anything but. Take a look at Hay List last year. Thrashed everything else in Australia, and is a great horse in it’s own right, but couldn’t get within 3 or 4 lengths of her. She’s that good.

    • Steve Putnam says:

      08:06pm | 13/02/12

      Probably the greatest sprinter I’ve ever seen, but to be considered a true champion you have to have won middle distance and staying events at group1 level. Lets face it, apart from Hay List she hasn’t beaten much. Her time on Saturday for the 1400m was a full four seconds outside Jeune’s race record.

    • Randal says:

      11:45am | 13/02/12

      Horse racing runs through my blood having grown up with it as small child. I remember the recent greats like, Kingston Town, Manikato, Let’s Elope, Super Impose, Saintly, Sunline, Might & Power and the amazing Makybe Diva, rarely did I make a dollar on any of them with the joy in just seeing them run being pleasure enough.

      When we talk of the champions of the track, it is not stories of the punt we regale in, it’s the story of the horse. Like the day the great Bill Collins said Kingston Town could not win the Cox Plate, yet she found a way, or Sunline crushing a Cox Plate field, and who could forget the mighty mare Makybe Diva breaking all records in winning a third Melbourne Cup.

      So many stories, and with each win we cheered, not because we won a dollar, but because there is nothing more noble than an equine champion.

      Now we have been blessed with Black Caviar, and on Saturday we saw her win again, for the 18th straight time, and to see her in the flesh rounding the turn, in cruise control, whilst those behind her are faltering in her wake is a sight to behold… Never in over 30 years of watching horse racing have I seen the like of it, and unlikely am I to ever see the like of it again.

      Her story is not yet finished, and in the next two weeks she will race into folklore as a world record falls, and I will cheer every stride, and when win 20 comes I will allow the awe of the moment to overwhelm me, smile at the thought of what she will do to the world’s best sprinters, and wipe the tears of joy in her performance from the corner of my eye.

      Once the tears clear, and I come down from the cloud, I will reach for my form guide and seek to add some ‘coin’ to my pocket on the next, wherever that will be, and I will do so knowing one thing. That no matter how much I win or lose on the day, in the years to come the tale I will tell will not be of how well I did (or did not do) on the punt, it will be instead be describing the beauty, majesty and sheer joy in watching a champion run, and how fortunate I was just to see her round that turn.

    • Go the Man says:

      12:28pm | 13/02/12

      Manikato would have made Black Caviar work a damn lot harder than the rest of the nags she is currently racing against.

    • SM says:

      12:37pm | 13/02/12

      very nicely said

    • sunny says:

      05:43pm | 13/02/12

      She sure has got a very natural relaxed running style. The other horses had their head and shoulders at all angles when under pressure trying to eke out any extra effort. She was totally in alignment, like a rocking horse with a V8. The jockey never even considered the whip - not sure if he even had one. @Lauren If I was Peter Moody I would say to the jockey ‘If you whip this horse I will take an orbital sander to your Ferrari !”.

    • Chris says:

      07:07pm | 13/02/12

      As with Lonhro, BC is too short to back and too good to bet against. Once again, many punters just watch the race and look elsewhere for value (of which there is usually plenty).
      I read today that connections are eyeing the Cox Plate. Win that, and I’ll jump on the bandwagon in calling her a champion, but not until then. BC has been racing against virtually nothing, save Hay List last year. A true champion horse has to win one of the great staying races (i.e. over 2000m), against the top-notch locals and imports, or be tagged with the second-rate epithet of “champion sprinter”. The Cups look beyond her distance, so the 2040 of the Plate might suit her perfectly.
      Or they can keep chasing the sprints, racing against nothing but making tons of money.

    • stephen says:

      11:12pm | 13/02/12

      I wouldn’t bother putting money on this horse.
      She’s a beaut, no doubt about it, but next race before she goes OS I might try a quad, put her at the top, (she, then is like the powerball) and take you pick on the rest.
      $2 bets all round. No more and take out maybe 15 quads.
      Wet track, then take odds no more than 12 dollars, and no rider more than 57kg.

      I’ll take 25%, with more info.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

@AndrewCatsaras Agreed. Kills more people than AIDS. Yet tolerated. Meanwhile: Good Insiders piece again Andrew.

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @JamieTravers: I'm in Europe and don't care for Eurovision, why is my twitter feed filled with Aussies recounting the bloody thing!?

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter