Tony Abbott’s foray into progressive social policy has backfired, with his conservative base rejecting has plan to tax big business to pay for improved parental leave.

In the first serious signs that the Mad Monk’s honeymoon as leader is over, this week’s Essential Report finds the Liberal leader has cashed in his credentials as an economic conservative for no real gain, with little support for this family plan.

After watching the polls narrow to within striking distance over the summer, the Coalition heartland must now be wondering whether Mark Latham has returned to politics in a different set of Speedos.

It had all been going so well for Abbott. After punching smart on climate change and almost scalping Peter Garrett on home insulation, the Opposition had narrowed the polls to within striking distance. 

But with Labor dominating on health and WorkChoices looming as a negative, Abbott chose International Woman’s Day to regain the political momentum by announcing the sort of policy usually the preserve of Scandanavian progressives.

The Abbott policy was remarkable – a conservative party taxing large companies to fund the most generous leave entitlements in the developed world.

It was clearly a brave move – Abbott drew the immediate ire of the business community that traditionally underwrites the Liberal Party – as well as universal derision from the commentariat inside the Canberra bubble.

Support for the parties' proposed parental leave plans

I think what has caused the political pain for Abbott is not so much the ambition of the scheme, but the sense it cuts across everything the Liberal Party stands for.

For months Abbott has been punching hard at the Emissions Trading Scheme as a big new tax on everything. He has convinced Australia that the world is not worth saving for fistfuls of dollar.

Now he is seen to be throwing the tax around in pursuit of a right that most of the Coalition’s aging base have already missed out on.

It is the sort of reckless policy grab that proved Mark Latham’s undoing – going in too hard on private schools, to feverishly on Medicare Gold, signing one too many giant interest rate guarantees.

As Labor discovered, it is one thing for a leader to take risks. It is another thing for those risks to fall flat. That’s when it becomes a question of judgement and character.

As the political temperature begins to rise this is the sort of game-changing play that can have implications all the way to an election.

35 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • David says:

      09:46pm | 25/04/11

      You can find many funny photoshopped images and sometimes images not photoshopped with image original quality. How to find out whether the image is original or photoshopped picture ? Here is an online tool that let you to find if the image has gone under some digital manipulation: Photoshopped Image Killer.

    • Steve Turner says:

      06:44pm | 16/03/10

      First serious signs Mad Monk’s honeymoon is over.
      In your dreams Peter.
      Newspoll has Libs primary out by 2. Even Newspoll use last election data for TPP. Likely it’s currently much closer than 4 points.
      Many people seem to believe Essential is sympathetic to ALP/Unions/Left Wing NGO’s and is hostile to the Libs. This article does nothing to dispel that notion.

    • Steve Turner says:

      11:55pm | 16/03/10

      Andrew,
      Bit scary that you believe it’s ok that a polling company that the likes of Sky News relies on, is as you say, a front for the left.
      It may not have occurred, but much of your premise as to TPP relies on, as you say sus polling.
      4 months ago I would have agreed as to Greens never preferancing Libs, but they have backed Libs parental scheme, have jointly set up an extensive population enquiry and have jointly blocked ALP legislation in Senate.  MSM can’t hold back the floodgates with this lousy Government forever, just look at the example in SA. There is a lot yet to surface.  It just may well get to the stage that any association with this very smelly animal is going to be too much even for the Greens.

    • Andrew Goff says:

      10:40pm | 16/03/10

      Steve, Essential is just another Left-wing front - who cares.

      But your read on the newspoll is fundamentally wrong. Tony Abbott has crystalised the right wing base… so the preference flow is far more likely to favour Labor more than the Coalition when compared against the last election… as evidenced in the fine print where Family First and One Nation’s support has dropped dramatically while the Greens have stayed similar… if you think Green voters are going to preference Abbott over Rudd you are more deluded than they are!

    • Andrew Goff says:

      04:12pm | 16/03/10

      Intresting that the Liberals on here claim 52-48 as a win in the polling. If that were repeated at an election they’d pick up a seat in the lower house and Labor would get a clear majority in the Senate.

      Interesting that the Labor people on here think Abbott has peaked and will now drop off, based on essentially no evidence.

      Fascinating that you can’t even make a motherhood statement these days.

      Bring on another option. I’m sick of the idealogical warriors on both sides taking borish pot-shots at each other.

    • The Shoe says:

      03:15pm | 16/03/10

      I just wonder about Abbott. He has done some silly things since being elected as the leader. Last fortnight he was “gone bush” and eating grubs for all the world to see - no offence intended here, fellow indigenous Australians - and then came the” tax big business” so the rich mums can enjoy the best of both worlds - being careful of course that other less fortunate mums would also benefit somewhat from his scheme.  So I don’t know about this bloke. He’s no Howard - more a novelty.
      The Libs need new talent at the top and please don’t suggest Dutton or Hockey. Pyne seems to be a bit of a blue blood who’s improving.

    • Christian real says:

      01:53pm | 16/03/10

      It appears that Abbott’s paid maternity leave is a farce like him,because in a “Daily Telegraph story “I’m no silvertail, insist Tony Abbott - my Mercedes is second hand”, written by Malcolm Farr on march 13,2010 at 12.00am.
      “Tony Abbott,embedded in the North Shore up to the knot of his Riverview Old Boys tie, insists he has much in common with Westies -even though he drives a Merc.”
      “He has revealed that his generous proposal for paid parental leave was designed with young families in western Sydney in mind.”
      “And he believes he would be an excellent political emissary for the Liberal Party to the people of Sydney’s greater metropolitan area.”
      “I don’t have any plans at at this point in time,if you like,an ambassador to western Sydney, because frankly I’d like to be the ambassador to western Sydney, the Opposition Leader told The Daily Telegraph.”
      So by Tony Abbott’s last three Sentences he has said that he is only looking after western sydney and Sydney’s greater metropolitan area ,and not any other State or part of the country with his parental leave.

    • Tom (the other one) says:

      01:34pm | 16/03/10

      No more proof is needed that ‘essential research’ is nothing more than a push polling mob for the Labor Party, than a quick glance at the loaded questions asked ....

      The ALP scheme ‘paid for by the govt’ the Coalition Scheme ‘paid for by a levy’

      Where do you think the Govt gets its money from? US the taxpayers ... what a big crock of goona of a yarn

    • JTH says:

      01:36pm | 16/03/10

      Just remember, the Labor party picked mark Latham ahead of Kevin Rudd. Kinda says it all really. For every Liberal voter, Kevin Rudd has been their worst night mare come true. Labor just can’t manage money!

    • Haydos says:

      11:22am | 16/03/10

      Your just another Labour voting wanker in denial of the disgraceful mismanagement and lies of the Rudd Government.
      From ETS, Home insulation rort, School building fraud to Illegal boat people and every other policy, this Rudd government is a sad and costly joke.

    • Mike says:

      11:07am | 16/03/10

      If we are talking simple 101 Politics here, Abbott has opened up Kevin Rudd like a can of worms. He is putting ideas out to the Australian public that are Hot Issues. i.e. I don’t think any Australian Families would object to Companies like the Big 4 Banks paying for their Paternity Leave? Keep it up Tony you’ve got not only Kevin Rudd but the Labor biased Main Stream Media Rattled to the Core!

    • BTS says:

      08:04pm | 16/03/10

      I am not party political, but Mike I think it’s common knowledge that the Australian Media are firmly rooted in Labour policy.  They wanted the Tampa refugees and all the others who can’t seem to enter legally (give them a fair go!), see nothing wrong with the long standing love affair with indigenous Australia (when all they want to do is bus them in to collect their Labour Party vote), donate to Haiti, Save the Planet/Climate Change (even though no one’s sure we have seen any evidence), hug the trees, kiss the koalas…the entertainment industry is the same.  It’s where they come from and Hollywood movie stars are the Holy Grail of taking care of our fellow man (whilst pocketing millions for a two and a bit hours of some flick).  It’s easy to appear humanitarian when you are being paid millions to churn out rubbish that changes nobody’s life.  They bang the drum, but do they make any ‘real’ changes???

    • Matt says:

      03:11pm | 16/03/10

      “Labor biased Main Stream Media” - funniest thing I’ve heard in years!

    • Seano says:

      09:44am | 16/03/10

      Abbott has already given Labor far too much ammo for him to win the next election. His parental leave policy is a classic example of a “non-core” policy which would never be implemented by a Liberal government. Abbott will continue to shoot himself in the foot, perhaps he needs Howard to keep him in line.

    • BigBen says:

      09:42am | 16/03/10

      Tony Abbott is desperate to win, he will come up with any pie in the sky policy to acheive that. He has no respect for women, he will say whatever is needed to secure your vote. He openly says he has a fear of Gays, hes even got the disabled on his hit list. Cigaretts and alchohol will rise, you will work till your 70 years old. In the meantime if this Big new business tax comes in you will pay more for everything else as well. Workchoices will be back so you will be earning less money to pay for it all. The best we can hope for is he doesn’t take to wearing budgie smugglers in Parliment House

    • sonya says:

      01:10pm | 16/03/10

      who’s workplace relations policy will leave us worse off?

      get your hand off it!!

    • Steve of Cornubia says:

      09:21am | 16/03/10

      I read as far as the first line of the second paragraph, where the tired old ‘Mad Monk’ name-calling stopped me in my tracks. There was no point reading any further.

    • Rob says:

      01:29pm | 16/03/10

      That’s the Liberal Mantra… everyone one else has done nothing… and NEITHER did the previous Liberal government… Cut spending top education, then import skilled migrants, dumb down the community and then tell them oh the migrants can do that… or maybe health… do nothing on health care until polling day then after being voted back in… delay for 3 more years… or perhaps insite panic, fear and lathing in the community about refugees… whilst allowing visa over stayers break the law, whilst refugees fleeing war are treated criminally… good on ya!
      Abbott is a clown, hollow as the log he’s riding on down the river… he’ll have a sore butt by the end!

    • Reality says:

      11:46am | 16/03/10

      Agree with Steve! I wasn’t either going to bother commenting as this column had a credible unbiased viewpoint. Read the opinion polls. Rudd has done NOTHING! Capital N!!!!!!

    • Sherlock says:

      08:39am | 16/03/10

      Yet another leftie complaining about a socialist policy that forces businesses to use their profits to pay a generous benefit to the worker.

      Is this just yet another example of the rampant hypocrisy of the left or has the world simply gone mad?

    • John A Neve says:

      12:26pm | 16/03/10

      CSallen,

      I don’t know about Sherlocks world, but there is no left in the real world, or right for that matter. Those terms in relation to politics went out with button-up boots.

      If any one can give me a clear difference between Labor, Liberal and National, I would be much appreciative.

      The major parties keep these terms going so as to maintain the great divide, without which they would be out of a job.

      As the two majors grow ever closer together, does it matter to the person in the street which party is in power?

      Once people realise we are being screwed by both sides, we might get a long overdue change, I’ve still got my fingers crossed.

    • CSallen says:

      11:48am | 16/03/10

      I’m confused about who the left is in your world Sherlock

    • murray says:

      09:37am | 16/03/10

      What an odd comment.  I would have thought that more people opposing socialist policies was a good thing.

    • James1 says:

      09:36am | 16/03/10

      I guess even lefties know bad policy when they see it.

    • Tom says:

      08:37am | 16/03/10

      Your reference to Abbott as the “mad monk” says it all. A boring Labor journalist.

    • Christian Real says:

      01:25pm | 16/03/10

      Tom, to spice it up a little for you so that it is not boring as you appear to think , Abbott could be referred to as the ‘mad pommie monk” being born in London, England on the 4th November, 1957 and arriving with his parents in Austyralia in 1960.

    • Matt says:

      08:25am | 16/03/10

      You guys (pundits and pollsters) just don’t get it, do you? The biggest long-term policy issue we face is the intergenerational one and Tony Abbott has loudly staked a claim in this debate with this policy.  Fearless prediction - whether he makes PM or not, future business leaders, as they run out of workers, will laud, with hindsight, this policy and regret that today’s myopic crew didn’t give this idea its due when they had the chance.

    • Conservative says:

      08:20am | 16/03/10

      This article is spot on! Abbott comes out and re-energises the Liberal base, starts to win people over by returning the Liberal Party to the Conservative roots it should occupy.

      Then Tony does a Latham, has a brain spasm, and proves everyone right who thought that he was too big a risk to be Leader.

      When you hear Liberals coming out with lines of “Mr Rudd why are you backing big business” you realise that Abbott has taken the Liberal Party off the rails.

      The real problem is that all the people who knifed Turnbull in the back when he did the same thing are standing on the shores like Mr Cunningham and clapping Tony (aka The Fonz) on!

    • Ron Roberts says:

      07:40am | 16/03/10

      When it comes to polling, why don’t we all look to the unbiased Newspoll -rather than the completely Labor Left orientated Essential - for a more accurate reflection on where we are at on this issue? It certainly shows the Coalition within striking distance, but behind Labor. There was no real impact on the polling numbers from paid parental leave except Kevin barely has a positive satisfaction rating…

    • Christian Real says:

      01:31pm | 16/03/10

      Ron, As for the poling, I don’t take it too seriously, as there was only 1,143 voters polled, and I think that there ar far more people that vote in our Country than that.
      Besides the poll is undertaken by the Australian, a paper that tony Abbott used to work for when he was a journalist.

    • CSallen says:

      11:46am | 16/03/10

      We all know how much unions love the Liberal party

    • Zeta says:

      08:52am | 16/03/10

      That’s right Ron Roberts. EMC’s biggest clients are all Unions. There is a difference.

    • Peter Lewis says:

      08:30am | 16/03/10

      Happy to debate the findings of this week’s and the comparative accuracy of our polls, but for the record, we are not a Labor polling company. We do not and have not been commissioned to do polling for the ALP. While work for a range of not for profits who could be broadly characterised as ‘progressive’, the whole point of research is that you will give the best advice if you are NOT biased.

    • Peter says:

      07:28am | 16/03/10

      Uh-ha. 

      With the TPP at 52-48, best Liberal primary vote since Beazley and with Rudd at his lowest ever, Newspoll says you’re wrong on this one, Peter.

    • John A Neve says:

      07:14am | 16/03/10

      If there is an omipotent presence (God), it has failed us.

      If there is no such presence, we have failed ourselves.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

@AndrewCatsaras Agreed. Kills more people than AIDS. Yet tolerated. Meanwhile: Good Insiders piece again Andrew.

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @JamieTravers: I'm in Europe and don't care for Eurovision, why is my twitter feed filled with Aussies recounting the bloody thing!?

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter