Rosedale is a small country town in central Gippsland. Now a stop for tourists on their journey from Melbourne to the Ninety Mile Beach, the Gippsland Lakes, or southern New South Wales, Rosedale was, from the earliest days, a resting point for weary travellers.

People remember the horse, but not the races

Following the discovery of gold at Walhalla, the town became a staging point for the Cobb & Co coaches transporting miners, supplies, and gold between Port Albert – and later Melbourne - and the rich goldfields.

Although there are no major ranges between Melbourne and Gippsland, a combination of swamps, and a heavily treed chain of hills between the Great Dividing and South Gippsland ranges deterred exploration from the fledgling Victorian capital. As a result, south eastern Victoria was opened up by explorers from southern New South Wales.

A cairn in the Rosedale town square commemorates Angus McMillan, the Scottish overseer of a station at Monaro, who explored the region in the late 1830’s naming it after Governor Gipps. A few miles down the road stands a memorial to the other explorer of the area, Paul Strzelecki, a Polish Count, who finally made the journey to Westernport Bay in 1840, walking some of it through tree tops because of the density of the forest.

The squatters soon followed, bringing their cattle to the rich plains interspersed by the rivers running from the Great Divide to the Gippsland Lakes. The great homesteads still stand – Kilmany Park, The (Snake) Ridge, the Holey Plain, and Nambrok. Named after Rosalie Dutton, the wife of the original land owner, Rosedale was originally the home of the station workers.

For two decades, Gippsland was sparsely populated, relying on the supply of stock to Tasmania for its prosperity. With the discovery of gold at Stringer’s Creek in 1863, the relative obscurity of the region was soon to change. Within a decade, the Long Tunnel Mine at Walhalla had become one of the richest in the world, as prospectors and miners converged on the mountain. By 1885, more than 4,000 people lived on the steep hillsides. Transport hubs, like Rosedale, Sale and Port Albert expanded, as farmers had a ready market for their produce.

The development in the 1870s remains evident today. The two hotels built in Rosedale at the time housed travelers. The townsfolk commenced a commons school in 1870. By 1873, they had paid off the debt, and handed the fine brick building over to the colonial authorities - the 770th school to be registered in Victoria.

A year later, the Mechanic’s Institute Hall was built. The Bank of Australasia was constructed at the time, along with the Anglican, Presbyterian and Catholic Churches. For a century and a half, these buildings formed the civic fabric of the community.

Demand for overland transport saw a railway built from Melbourne in the 1870s. Its construction marked a changed fortune for Rosedale. No longer the staging post between the mines and the port, the township prospered nonetheless as a hub for the rural community.

It was just outside this small country town that I grew-up in the 1960s. Returning for a few days over Christmas, I was struck by how little the basic structure of the township had changed since it was first laid out in 1855. Now the home for 1,500 people, it never had a population of more than a thousand for most of its existence.

As I surveyed the manner in which the town had adapted in the past, I was struck by the way that outside forces continue to affect rural towns.

Let me illustrate. Standing in the main street, just opposite the Mechanic’s Institute is a statue of Patrobus, the brilliant three year old, who, in the space of three weeks, won the Caulfield Guineas, the Victoria Derby and the Melbourne Cup in 1915.  Mrs Widdis, the owner of Nambrok station, became the first woman to have a Melbourne Cup winner. Patrobus is the only Gippsland horse to win the event.

A few years ago, the local traders organised the erection of the statue of the horse in full flight. The passersby learn of the exploits of the local champion, but nothing of the local race club.

For more than a century, the townsfolk and nearby famers ran a successful racing club. Four times a year, locals flocked to the races. Women purchased new dresses and hats, children played on the lawns, and the men discussed the finer points of the competing animals. The profits generated were returned in prize money and to local charities.

Then in the late sixties, the racing authorities decided that there were too many clubs. In the new era of the tote, turnover was everything. A century of local commitment came to naught.

Some years later, the Kennett government decided there were too many municipalities in Victoria. The Rosedale Council was absorbed into the regional Wellington Shire and the headquarters moved to Sale.

Subsequently the banks moved out, leaving locals little choice but travel half an hour to the next town until a local community bank was opened.

The buildings remained, but the professionals were gone. The decisions robbed small communities of human capital. There was no longer a shire secretary, an engineer, and other professionals who contributed to the community.  The townsfolk and farmers who voluntarily gave of their time to serve on the Council were unwanted, their skills, experience and contributions discarded. The folk who voluntarily devoted hours and hours to the race club were left without even a thank you from all omnipotent bureaucrats in Spring Street.

Each of these decisions was made for a logical and understandable reason. Yet each of them had a profound impact upon the town and its community. Little of this impact was known or appreciated by those who made the decisions.

Each year, hundreds of rural and regional towns throughout Australia experience the impact of decisions taken in capital cities. There is no community impact assessment, no informed consideration for how the decision will impact on the community concerned.

Most towns survive and move on. Some don’t. Every now and again, rural people revolt, voting against governments they believe have lost touch of their aspirations and concerns.

Rural communities are often subject to changing economic circumstances. When the gold ran out, Walhalla slowly withered. For 20 years, a pineboard factory provided employment for many people in Rosedale, but, like the Cobb & Co service a century before, it subsequently closed. A few years later, a tannery commenced operations in the same premises. A century earlier, there had been a local tannery until it had become unprofitable. Changing technology led to changing circumstances.

Droughts and rains, fires and floods have a regular impact across the nation. These are part of the cycle of life that country people know and experience.

What they object to is over-arching governments, hell bent of some grand plan, who are ignorant of local sensitivities, take them for granted, assume their acceptance of whatever change is proposed, won’t listen, and are not prepared to compromise.

We need a renewed sense of subsidiarity in the Australian polity. Not all decisions taken at the central level are the optimal. More often than not, local communities know what is best for them. Sometimes they are wrong, but they also know that they suffer the consequences of their choice.

There are issues that require central approaches – but the case should always be made out. Otherwise, let local communities flourish. The experience of local people running hospitals, schools and nursing homes enriches these institutions and the communities they serve. We need more of it.

31 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Bill says:

      05:44am | 13/01/10

      So what did the Liberal Party do about it when they were in power?

    • Alfred Deakin says:

      07:01am | 13/01/10

      “For two decades Gippsland was sparsely populated” - presumably you mean the white population was low. You do not seem to be aware of Angus McMillan’s role in “dispersing” (I think that was the term he used) the aboriginal people who were already living in the area.

        1. ^ Bartrop, Paul R. (2004). “Punitive Expeditions and Massacres: Gippsland, Colorado and the Question of Genocide”. in A. Dirk Moses. Genocide and Settler Society: Frontier Violence and Stolen Indigenous Children in Australian History. Berghahn. pp. 200–203. ISBN 9781571814104.

    • persephone says:

      07:04am | 13/01/10

      Bill, that’s the whole point of Kevin’s article. Liberal governments were the ones who closed the Rosedale race club and amalgamated the shires.

      You will note the tacit admission that Rosedale has grown under Labor - it’s population is now 1500, whereas it’s always been about 1000.

      In fact, in the past five years, Rosedale has experienced a 36 % growth in population.

      http://www.wellington.vic.gov.au/page/page.asp?page_id=1383

      Kevin is just pointing out that Liberal governments aren’t good for the country.

    • John A Neve says:

      07:12am | 13/01/10

      I was also in this region in the ‘60’s, ‘70’s, ‘80’s and ‘90’s and very ltlle if any thing ever changed.

      The reality is many small communities can no longer support themselves. This is not new, it has gone on for centuries, this is not a political issue, it’s a cultural one.

      Prior to social security, people went where the work was, now people want the work to come to them. Sorry, but things do change.

    • acker says:

      07:44am | 13/01/10

      After seeing the demise of St Arnuad in North West Victoria I agree what you say about councils merging Kevin and taking out a layer of proffesionals, it is something that suits city’s but it has been destructive to smaller regional communities. Now St Arnaud has a council based 75km away in Stawell, thats not quite the same as one or two suburbs away. And the town has been in decline since it happened.

      I’m not usualy a fan of yours, but you are spot on with this story, just because something works well in a city, does not mean it is going to work well in a rural/regional area and vice versa. There are still 4-5 million Australians living outside the major urban areas, surely we are a smart enough nation to work these issues better.

    • acker says:

      07:53am | 13/01/10

      @John A Neve 7.12 ...Take away the need for people to work in the CBD which with high speed internet connections will probably happen; and the urban communities that rely heavilly on manufacturing and produce no primary resources and import 100% of what the consume from the rural areas or overseas, probably look like they have don’t sustainable future where they can sustain themselves. Ever wonder why the governments are not rushing headlong into putting new public transport projects into the outer suburbs. At least I live close to where the food is grown wink

    • John A Neve says:

      08:14am | 13/01/10

      Acker @ 0753hrs,

      I understand what you are saying, that is why I said this was a cultural not political issue.  People are entrenched in the now, short of a third world war or a return of the Black Death, I cannot see people moving into the back and beyond.

      As to a National Broadband, please don’t hold your breath, I am no good a CPR.

    • Dave C says:

      08:25am | 13/01/10

      I agree with you Kevin totally and yes shame on Kennett for merging the councils as the professionals go and then the banks and we have what Economists term “a reverse multiplier effect”.

      I am originally from rural NSW but now live in an urbanized strong growth area in coastal NSW (due to the fact I married a coastal chick who cant get work if we went out west) Every year I go to my parents and see the old home town (and the other towns you go through to get to it) slowly dieing

      The question is what are rural based Liberals in previously held Nationals seats doing about it. For years the Nationals stood up for country people and they have been in constant decline since the 80s due to two factors..

      1) The rural decline meaning more people in the cities and on the coast meaning less rural seats. However if thats due to Govt decisions then which cam first the chicken or the Egg?
      2) Every time a Nationals MP retires the Liberals take the seat. These rural MP’s wont stand up to the Libs in the cities and there you have your problem. 

      Maybe if the Libs and Nats merged to form the LNP as they have in Qld then and only then would rural and regional Australia have a voice because the LNP members would have more total numbers in an LNP party room than a minority of rural MPs in the Libs an ever declining National Party that is looked upon by the trendy commo inner city based left wing media as irrelevant.

      Kevin and fellow bloggers… your thoughts????

    • Bill says:

      08:31am | 13/01/10

      Persephone,

      That’s the whole point of my question.  Thanks for pointing that out.

    • Alfred Deakin says:

      08:41am | 13/01/10

      The rural population as a percentage of Australia’s population has been falling since 1910 - for 100 years. This is not a new phenomenon. Where 100 years ago it required many laborers to harvest a wheat crop, nowadays it often takes only one or two people. Technological advances have led to a decreased need for workers in rural areas, and as they have left they have taken their families and “consumption” with them - this has been happening for 100 years, and artificial attempts to reverse this trend are often disastrous, like the experience of many of the post-WW1 “soldier settlers” on marginally arable land in Victoria’s Mallee region.

    • Darren says:

      08:58am | 13/01/10

      The NSW ALP has done a power of good for many rural communities - all it has to do is keep building more gaols - the town of Wellington had the greatest % increase in land values following the decision a number of years ago to build a gaol there. under the Libs/Nats is was dying, mainly because the Nats got a new highway to Dubbo built. All the landed gentry drove to Dubbo once a week and did all their shopping/banking etc there - allowing their own town to die in the arse

    • acker says:

      09:07am | 13/01/10

      I like the LNP format in Queensland. But I think the Nats have to change their thinking a bit as well, they became too complacent just being a party for the farmers, they must also act as a party for the rural and regional towns as well. No point just seeking aid for the farmer in a drought while the town based businesses holding the debts go to the wall. It is a two way street, but I think it could be productive for both of them. Lets get some commercial development back out to rural/regional Australia. Perhaps assisting rural towns develop solar or wind power stations that feed their community rather than relying totally on a power transmission line in remote areas is a project an LNP type party could promote. Something that makes sense as a rural/regional solution, although it may not be viable for a large densely populated urban centre

    • acker says:

      09:24am | 13/01/10

      @Alfred Deakin ..so resettling WW1 digger settlement blocks in NW Victoria failed, resettling WW2 digger settlement lots in Central Queensland worked.

      So obviously the lesson from the previously failure was learnt. I suppose with a name like Alfred Deakin your destined to be stuck in the past wink

    • John A Neve says:

      09:28am | 13/01/10

      Acker @ 0907hrs,

      I agree to some extent, but rather than wind or solar, why not utilize what’s there eg. generate electricity from the methane produced at the sewerage plant. Any excess could be fed into the national grid and create a revenue stream for the local council.

    • acker says:

      10:00am | 13/01/10

      @John A Neve ..yes..all of these renewable power sourcesincluding poop, and the towns do not have to solely rely on them. They can work in harmony with exsisting power grids, they would actualy help stop long blackouts occuring when transmission lines and tranformer stations supplying these towns fail.
      People tend to run airconditioning when it is hot, solar works well when it is hot. But back to the original article by Kevin Andrews these community need commercial stimulus and probably better marketing, I am sure living within a 5 minute walk to work in a nice house that does not cost a fortune in a location where your kids can walk to school and it there are no hassels taking them to and from various sports and training; should have some appeal to some people eeking out an existence to pay the mortgage on a modest dwelling who spend an hour getting to work and an hour getting home from work each day and who are afraid to step out after dark to walk the dog due to the risk of getting mugged, and who watch their childrens minds slowy dissapear into a Sony Play station..such an attractive lifestyle urban decay offers wink

    • Alfred Deakin says:

      01:21pm | 13/01/10

      acker - as a former resident of SE Queenland, I am very interested in what you said about WW2 soldier settlers in Central Qld - sounds like some lessons were learnt after the WW1 problems (in several states).

      And yes, it has been hard catching up on 90 years of events, though some things never change. Alfred Deakin stood in Parliament as “conservative” Prime Minister and stated “all my greatest enemies are now sitting behind me”

    • Lord Grognard says:

      01:56pm | 13/01/10

      The urbanisation process has been steadily progressing ever since European Monarchs started to centralise their kingdoms during the 16thC.  Increased agricultural and logistical technologies means it takes fewer and fewer people to produce a food surplus and frees up the population for industrial and artistic endeavours.

    • BenZ says:

      02:27pm | 13/01/10

      You are absolutely right….faceless bureaucrats in Sydney make snap decisions that impact the people of country NSW greatly, without even caring about or realising what they have done. I have seen this happen time and time again….rail line closures are the prime example. But it’s also the little things that tick country people off big time. An example is the Tourism NSW sign on the Hume Hwy that proudly declares “Welcome to Capital Country”, when you in fact have just entered the Southern Highlands. Or the sign as you cross the Hunter River at Hexham that says “Welcome to Mid North Coast”. These bureaucrats need to research, consult and get their bloody facts right!

    • acker says:

      03:12pm | 13/01/10

      @Lord Grognard ..smell the roses China and India are well on the way to freeing up the Australian population from industrial endevours. And financial execs will be working from their beachside home via the net in the future. I cant see your artists keeping our city’s from decay. And when the consumer runs out of money the city will quickly turn into a slum

    • acker says:

      03:30pm | 13/01/10

      I can see a day coming very soon where a fully wired and plumbed, painted, fitted prefabricated kit home arrives from China or India in a shipping container and other than pouring a concrete slab, an assembler puts it together and a plumber hooks up the external water & sewerage and an electrician hooks up the external power….and thats it done and dusted

    • formersnag says:

      03:56pm | 13/01/10

      acker @ 03:12pm, I’m with you on that, often see myself sitting on top of a sand dune overlooking lake Eyre. i grew up in Brisbane, which in the 60’s & 70’s, really was just a big country town. it has been getting uglier ever since expo’88.

      But, Kevin’s article illustrates perfectly, why the states should be abolished, I’m sure local government could stuff up schools & hospitals just as comprehensively as state/territory governments have been, so why do we need them?

    • formersnag says:

      04:42pm | 13/01/10

      acker @ 03:30pm, you left out one important detail. The tradesmen doing the assembly hook up, etc, could just as easily be “guest workers”, here on a 6 month work visa because of a “skills shortage”. The power could involve a wind turbine &/or solar panels also imported from china &/or India.

      And these loony, left, wing-nuts reckon we need an ETS to get the “new green” jobs going. “Tell them they’re dreaming”.

    • Daniel says:

      05:13pm | 13/01/10

      The Liberal Party and its free market policies have killed country towns.

    • Mick In The Hills says:

      06:15pm | 13/01/10

      My experience of living between two small country towns, and sourcing most of my needs there, after 50 years of capital cities living, is that these towns have a distinct efficiency and economy about them - they provide all of the essentials of modern living, but not necessarily the indulgences.  We have to go to Melbourne for those.  But on balance, these places are self-sufficient, and the residents seem less expectant, or dependent, on Government largesse, as is often the case in urban centres.  Maybe the town folks would rather be left to see to their own welfare, with appropriate relief from tax impositions, than have BIG GOVERNMENT always arranging the deck chairs for them.

    • Diamantina Dick says:

      06:19pm | 13/01/10

      This is the most worthwhile piece written for Punch in the last couple of weeks, it is an issue that NEEDS to be addressed. The Nation needs to have a serious discussion and hopefully take some decisions to promote regionalisation. The urban drift has resulted from many factors, most commented on here, but that drift has come at a cost and now it is biting. Housing affordability, infrastructure undercapacity and so forth.

      Politically you can not blame parties pandering to thier inner city constituents at the expense of rural electors, there are more votes in it. Witness the Wild Rivers deal, closing regional rail lines and promising metro’s etc. But sooner or later we need to get back to a more sustainable population distribution like that whch existed at the time of WWI.

    • acker says:

      07:22pm | 13/01/10

      formersnag @ 04:42 ...... looking at another thread I reckon after I download load the Jamie Oliver cookbook into her memory, I could download unit 1 plumbing and electrical and get my Roxxxxy the robot doll to do it before she cracks me an ice cold Crowny out of the fridge….then we both sit down and watch Footscray win the 2010 AFL Premiership..life doesn’t get any better than that wink

    • Hermit says:

      09:10am | 14/01/10

      For those who cast this as yet another party political slanging match, the Labor government in Queensland, despite strong opposition all of the experience gained in other states has recently amalgamated its councils.

      Mr Andrews is quite right in what he says. Centralised decision making and other fads such as economic rationalism always have side effects that their proponents do not understand and do not consider important.

    • persephone says:

      10:44am | 14/01/10

      I point out again that Rosedale is a bad example to use of a ‘dying’ country town.

      It has thrived under the State Labor government.

      A population increase of nearly 40% shows that something’s happening there.

    • acker says:

      12:14pm | 14/01/10

      I think amalgamating Local Councils makes a lot of sense in urban areas, but should be looked at on a case by case basis in regional and rural Local Councils which occupy far bigger areas. One size does not fit all as the posts in this thread are revealing.

    • Anne says:

      02:54pm | 14/01/10

      I’m a city girl and always will be, but I think what’s happening to country towns is atrocious. Surely with the technology at our disposal there is no longer any need for businesses and governments to restrict themselves to the capital cities? Or at least if they must have their HQ in the city, allow people to work from home or from smaller offices scattered through the states. You’d get more personalised service for one thing, instead of talking to someone in Mumbai, or a robot.  It would also help solve the housing problem so many of the coastal cities are experiencing - if people know they can move out to the country - or stay there - and still get a job, then that would ease demand. I know so many people who would love to get out of the city, but that’s where the jobs are.  Maybe the govt should start offering incentives to businesses to decentralise their operations and get jobs out to regional Australia. It’s a thought, anyway.

    • Anne Smith says:

      07:26pm | 14/01/10

      The problem is communication. City people need to listen to country people and find out what they really want. Country people need to listen to advice from the city even if they don’t want to take it. Everyone has something to offer. Everything should be seen and heard and then assessed for its value.
      Everyone needs to be heard without prejudice and decisions should be made after surveys on the situation and sent out and researched. And while you’re at it, give us a mobile phone tower that works everywhere. Then we will be able to communicate. And now you can tell me to shut up.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Yo, mummy bloggers! Your expert input is required in this doozy of a child-rearing dilemma http://t.co/0JfOnCq1

Daniel Piotrowski

How we're getting ripped off at the ATM http://t.co/Vpu8DuHy

Anthony Sharwood

The factory where they make Boeing aeroplanes is the world's largest building #Todaysrandomfact.

Lucy Kippist

Can you wear skinny jeans when you're old enough to get a hip replacement? You bet: http://t.co/14b6UGnY

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Friday Dilemma: child cruelty or harmless fun?

Friday Dilemma: child cruelty or harmless fun?

Parenting. It’s the new oneupmanship. Ah, how quaint the days now seem when parents could raise…

Hipsters with hip replacements

Hipsters with hip replacements

Someone once told me that when people reach a certain age they begin dressing in the manner they did…

La dole cheque vita is not so sweet on $16 a day

La dole cheque vita is not so sweet on $16 a day

Your task is simple. Here is $115.50. It must last one week. You have no savings, no assets, but thankfully…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Punch on: Open thread 09/02/2012

marley says:

I'm one of the older ones, so I've certainly seen a few changes in my time. When I started school I learned to write with a nib pen, dipped in an inkwell (no, I'm not kidding). My mother became a dab hand at getting inkstains out of my clothes. Flicking ink at one another in the classroom was an essential… [read more]

From: I’d rather have a piece of toast than listen to crap lyrics

Erick says:

Led Zeppelin are responsible for my all-time favourite mixed metaphor: "There you sit, sit and stare, like a book on a shelf rusting." (Misty Mountain Hop) I laugh every time I hear it. Hmmm, I believe I've decided what to play on the way to work today. [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

151 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter