As a boy I wrote a detailed seven-page letter to President Clinton outlining why he should send a child into space. Coincidentally I suggested the child should be me.

Describe this image

Today, it is a dream that not even in my most fanciful of moments can I still consider a reality.

Last month, Barack Obama unveiled his new budget which abruptly cut NASA’s ambitious Constellation program.

It was an endeavor that would have seen us return to the moon before the decade was out and then set our sights on Mars.

Now, with that single stroke of the pen, he has destroyed whatever speck of moon dust there was of my grandest dream ever becoming a reality. Alabama Senator Richard Shelby rightly observed it was the “death march for the future of US human spaceflight.”

Announced by the Bush Administration in the wake of the 2003 Columbia disaster, the Constellation program was a healthy injection of Obama’s favorite home remedy at a time it was most needed: hope.

But now the magic and romance of grand idealism in the politics of space travel is well and truly dead.

It is hard to imagine President Obama channeling the Camelot era of Kennedy and committing the nation to an unquantifiable and almost unimaginable goal by the end of the decade on any issue. Or perhaps even more importantly, rallying the nation across the aisle towards it.

In these days of stark and bitter partisanship coupled with a vicious media cycle of shock jocks and pundits it would be one of the most dangerous political moves in history. Health care is the closest he has come to such idealism, but it has been so diluted by the political process you would hardly call it visionary stuff. Or to use an appropriate pun: the right stuff.

By most estimates, the cost of launching a manned mission to Mars would total around US $40 billion. Not much really when you think of the size of the bank bailouts and stimulus packages steamrolled across the developed world in the last eighteen months.

Imagine if simply a small part of the Obama stimulus package was used to invest in the vision of a manned mission to Mars, or building a base on the moon. An investment of that size in a sector so diverse that every Congressional district is linked to launching the shuttle in some way would have been phenomenal.

The perplexing reality is that on two of the most traditionally liberal stalwarts of policy: spaceflight and foreign aid, President Bush has actually beaten President Obama thus far.

There is little doubt the Apollo space program cost more than could be afforded at the time. At its peak, NASA’s direct funding alone totaled 5% of the federal budget. This was against the backdrop of a country gripped in the bipolar struggle of a Cold War with the USSR and struggling economically to sustain a rising insurgency war in Vietnam.

But Apollo was more than just a goal.

The prospect of landing on the moon raised people’s spirits. Bank bailouts or some dodgy home insulation in the Australian example have hardly done that.

The benefits were much wider too.

Advances in medicine, technology and energy efficiency have saved lives and increased our overall quality of life. If it wasn’t for Apollo, we may well not have yet developed lasers sufficiently to conduct heart and eye surgery, and solar systems might too be a thing of the future.

With India, Japan and China each successfully conducting manned space missions in the last decade, now is the time for the US to be bolstering rather than booting the sector to the ground. At times it seems like the best thing for the US space industry might just be China’s power becoming a rival to the US. Either that or the effects of climate change accelerating rapidly or the discovery of intelligent life somewhere in the universe.

Sometimes I still catch myself looking up there at the moon and wondering when we will be going back, and who that will be. My astronaut-idol Jim Lovell once proclaimed: “Imagine if Christopher Columbus had returned from the New World and nobody returned in his footsteps?”

Under President Obama it seems like one giant leap away.

Thom Woodroofe, 20, is the 2009 Young Victorian of the Year and founder of Left Right Think-Tank. He is currently living and studying in the USA overcoming his lifelong desire to become an astronaut.

12 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Liz says:

      09:37am | 05/03/10

      Yes imagine! The Indigenous Americans would be thriving in their old cultures not having been massacred, their lands stolen and so on.
      Have we enough resources for the extravagence of space exploration?There are not enough hospitals, a decent dental service and many reforms needing to be made that could take all available money if the good will and reform incentive was there.
      Time to grow up and get real!

    • E says:

      10:24am | 05/03/10

      Get a grip Liz, why do some people hate the idea of exploration and discovery so much?

      And
      “if the good will and reform incentive was there”
      yeah Liz, maybe its you who needs to grow up? The space program isnt stopping politicians from funding health care!

    • Alex says:

      11:24am | 05/03/10

      @Liz
      There were another group of people who though like you and decided to assure their own day to day security instead of taking bold risks. They were called cavemen. Thankfully a handful of them decided to brave the wilds to expand, grow and form civilsations.

    • stephen says:

      02:02pm | 05/03/10

      Don’t be in so much of a hurry Thom.
      America’s new frontier is geo-political i.e. China and Iran.
      Both places have their eyes on ascendency to ‘lead’ the world : China in economics and Iran, in conspiracy with other Mid. East nations, to usurp America’s political influence.
      This is important to counter : space and exploration is most influential when others are ‘looking up’ to you.
      May take a while, then we can get back to real Science.

    • Chris says:

      02:06pm | 05/03/10

      Let’s fix the problems with have here first before wasting anymore money on space exploration.

    • Ross says:

      02:07pm | 05/03/10

      Yeah, lucky you can keep your 12 year old boy dream of being an astronaut going every night (have you done the advanced Air Force pilot training and gruelling fitness regime part by the way?, you know, your end of the bargain, just in case?) rather than to go to sleep feeling responsible for 30 million citizens who have no health insurance. If you looked out the window in the last 18 months you might have noticed there have been a few problems that took some dealing with and cost incomprehensible sums so to do.
      Or he could have let the US and then world economies collapse into pre-industrial poverty for a decade or two in which there would be no rockets, or cars, or hospitals. And in which boyhood dreams were mainly of a hot meal.
      Congratulations on a fine piece of analysis, for a 12 year old boy. Your mum must be proud.

    • Eric says:

      03:55pm | 05/03/10

      The vast majority of government money goes to health, welfare and education. Those who whinge about the tiny pittance given to projects vital for the future, such as space exploration, are narrow-minded and ignorant.

      If the human species is to survive, it needs to get off this tiny, vulnerable planed.

    • Dave in Perth says:

      04:57pm | 05/03/10

      Guys,
      I think you’re being a bit hard on Thom here !? He’s obviously smart, he’s studying in the US!

      He knows that Obama can’t afford a 40B PR stunt, which is how most scientists view manned spaceflight. Certainly not after discovering the steaming turd ‘W’ left on the White House doormat, called the economy.

      I think, if you read between the lines, Thom is actually volunteering to chip is his AUD1.1m for the noble cause. He just wondering how many punch readers will join him to make up the missing 39,999 people required to chip in to make up the 40 Bill. ( That’s a B for any Nationals MP’s reading)

      So, c’mon guys, who’s in for a noble cause ?

    • Michelle says:

      06:44pm | 05/03/10

      Hey Thom, there’s still hope for your lunar ambitions: convert to Islam. I’m not kidding:

      “NASA Administrator Charlie Bolden said Tuesday that President Barack Obama has asked him to “find ways to reach out to dominantly Muslim countries” as the White House pushes the space agency to become a tool of international diplomacy. “
      http://www.jihadwatch.org/2010/02/dhimmitude-in-space-obama-asks-nasa-to-reach-out-to-muslim-countries.html

      Sounds like one giant leap for jihadists by giving them technological aid.

    • ab says:

      08:08pm | 05/03/10

      Liz is right, there are many problems in the United States that need to come first. 13% of the population lives below the US definition of the poverty line. Native American health, like Aboriginal Australians, is of a very low standard and a large majority of them live below the poverty line. I recognise the value of space exploration, but unfortunately there are some things that have to come first.

    • Thom Woodroofe says:

      10:04am | 14/03/10

      Liz, Chris & Ab – Thanks for the comments. I agree that there certainly are more pressing issues if you took a linear view of things, but this piece focuses exclusively on the merit and opportunity for space travel. These issues include things like poverty, education, health care and combating climate change just to name a few touched on by others. The reality is though that by landing on the moon nobody became poorer, dumber, or suffered by any other measure. If anything they benefited, i.e. the examples I provided of the development and now use of laser technology in surgeries, and the advent of solar technology is obviously good within the context of the environment too. If society took a single-issue approach to funding, but arguably more important to aspirations, then innovation wouldn’t be a word in our vocabulary. We can’t fathom the benefits of continued space exploration, it has always exceeded our expectations.

      Ross – I checked, and my mum is proud.

    • football says:

      07:26pm | 08/02/11

      Hello Everyone! I like watching <a >bbc football</a>. I usually watch <a >football online</a> as I do not have PVR. How about you?

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

@AndrewCatsaras Agreed. Kills more people than AIDS. Yet tolerated. Meanwhile: Good Insiders piece again Andrew.

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @JamieTravers: I'm in Europe and don't care for Eurovision, why is my twitter feed filled with Aussies recounting the bloody thing!?

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter