Welcome to this week’s I Call Bullshit, a regular column where we pick apart mischievous misrepresentations, balderdash, and outright bunkum. This week, with bulging bellies, blurry brains and labouring livers, we’re taking a look at detox diets.

This is a monument to enemas. We have nothing else to add. Pic: AP

It’s easy to see the appeal of a detox. You’ve been shovelling twenty kinds of crap into your poor system, you can sense it’s struggling to cope, and you want to turn back the clock.

Like a very Earthly Confession, you want to wipe away your sins with a few Hail Marys, some lemons and dash of cayenne.

Well – guess what? – I Call Bullshit. An entire industry has formed around our yearning for some form of New Year redemption, a lucrative industry that promises to restore you to some pristine, angelic (but entirely imaginary) former self.

Nutrition experts this week ranked the Lemon Detox diet one of the worst fad diets around, followed by the blood-type diet. There are plenty of other dodgy detoxes – from colon cleansing to colour coordinating to chanting mantras while gobbling laxatives.

Some of the worst examples of delusional detoxes went to air on Today Tonight last night.

OK, OK, so we all know current affairs shows can be full of shite (don’t we?). But sometimes it’s hard to work out how the reporter can keep a straight face.

Last night’s episode contained the following gems:

ACUPUNCTURE: There is some evidence that acupuncture is effective in some situations. But does it “flush out toxins and eliminate any blockages of the flow within the body”? No. It doesn’t. I Call Bullshit.

IONIC FOOT SPAS: Woman puts feet in water with small electrical current. Water turns wee-coloured.  Foot spa-ologist says it can indicate “liver things or pancreatic things, blood sugar”. I say this indicates “bullshit things”. The claim doesn’t even abide by the laws of physics.

CUPPING: Heat up a glass bulb, creating a vaccuum. Apply to skin. Vaccuum sucks flesh into bulb. Very effective at creating a lovely bruising effect - that’s about it.

SKIN BRUSHING: “It’s just a dry skin brushing and then once you’ve brought the toxins up to the surface of the skin you then have a shower and it helps to just remove the toxins off the surface of the skin”.  Really? A cheap brush will just attract these mysterious ‘toxins’ to the surface of the skin? And you just wash it down the drain? Utter, utter, bullshit with not even a passing familiarity with how the body works.

There is no magic way to ‘detox’. The body is an amazing thing with its own processes of elimination. You can help it by not putting crap in there. 

You don’t help it by starving it, by overdosing on water, or by putting coffee up your bum.

The best thing you can do is eliminate the marketing from your reading and watching diet.

58 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Al says:

      11:13am | 12/01/12

      There is only 1 way to ‘detox’. Stop putting the toxins in.
      There are a few things out there that can assist removing certain toxins (say chlorphill can help remove some heavy metals from the body but won’t help long term unless you stop the intake in the first place), but no simple cure all to remove all the different toxins.
      De-tox diets are at best fraudulant and at worst dangerous.

    • Elphaba says:

      11:16am | 12/01/12

      Bad.  Your body has a perfectly good detoxer, called your liver.  Eat healthily, and drink plenty of water, and it will work fine.

      *sigh* - but people need miracles.  They have to believe their fat arses and poor skin can be fixed by lemon and cayenne pepper.  Let them at it, I say.  Maybe it’s just natural selection.

    • mm says:

      08:14pm | 12/01/12

      Don’t forget the kidney - it does a pretty good job too!

    • Redeker Plan says:

      11:31am | 12/01/12

      Totally agree.  I felt a little bit yuck after Christmas/New Year, even though I had made an effort not to overdo it with festive food and alcohol. So last week I made a committed effort to drink heaps of water and eat mostly vegetables.  No alcohol, no sugary desserts, but had watermelon and grapes as a sweet treat.  I feel heaps better.

      For Jeebus’ sake, your body will tell you what it needs. Listen to it before you invest in caffeine enemas and Latin Seed bullshit.

    • Mahhrat says:

      11:31am | 12/01/12

      All “diets” are fraudulent. I should know; I’ve tried all of them, including Jenny Craig, Weigh Watchers, Herbalife and Terry Ferguson.

      The thing is, don’t put the crap into your body, you won’t get the crap out.  There is no easy way to lose weight, short of lopping off a limb, and you can only really do that three time (four if you’ve got a machine or a friend).

      I just wish chicken parma didn’t taste so damn good :(

    • The Truth says:

      12:18pm | 12/01/12

      ‘All “diets” are fraudulent.’

      Nonsense. A HEALTHY diet (fresh vegetables, fruit, whole grains, lean meat, fish, etc), combined with a reasonable exercise routine WILL MAKE YOU LOSE WEIGHT. And guess what? It IS pretty easy if you’ve got 2 little things - Discipline and self control.

      From the evidence you yourself have supplied on multiple occasions, you are your own worst enemy and quite frankly you’ll always be fat.

      Your all talk and I’m pretty sure everyone here is over your ‘Woe is me, its horrible being fat and there’s nothing I can do about it so I’ll have another bucket of fried chicken’ grab for attention. Either make an effort or STFU.

    • Kika says:

      12:37pm | 12/01/12

      Precisely. A healthy balanced diet is the best way. Coupled with lots of water. Often the body recognises thirst as hunger. If you eat something rubbish one day, balance it by eating a salad. I like the french way. A bit of wine here, a bit of cheese there, and a big salad and some exercise there.

    • Mahhrat says:

      12:40pm | 12/01/12

      LMFAO

      I don’t consider eating healthy to be a “diet”, that’s eating healthy.  Hence “diets” not working - they’re not designed to.  I was inferring the 2nd defintion of diet in this instance.  Sorry for any confusion.

      As for your second point, were discipline and self-control (at least as related to food) were “little things”, we wouldn’t have obesity epidemics.

      As for your personal attack, maybe I will always be fat.  That doesn’t concern me.  Having health problems concerns me.  I’m not comfortable with my body literally because I’m not comfortable with my body.  My knees hurt, and I can’t run much at all.

      I certainly have never wanted anyone’s pity, though it’s nice to get encouragement and positive reinforcement (thanks Elph!)

      Since you asked so nicely though, you’re right - like many, I emotionally eat, and this week it’s been fucking crap because my in laws are in town and my dog got hit by a car.  This week has just been a bad western.

      Food for thought: most overweight people I know are “making an effort” simply by discussing it.  Emotionally vulnerable, they take significant risk of abuse in opening up about their weight issues.

      I can live with your torment, but go a little easier on others in future, k?  We all have our skeletons.

    • I, Claudia says:

      08:48pm | 12/01/12

      The Truth - what you’re describing isn’t a “diet.” It’s a healthy lifestyle, and for those who choose to live by it, it’s a privilege, not an obligation.

    • stephen says:

      09:22pm | 12/01/12

      Chicken parma is delicious, but it’s best followed by a brisk stroll, then maybe in a month, a slow jog.
      Or buy a bicycle for exercize.

      137 kilos is only good for a panda.

    • Glenn says:

      09:12am | 13/01/12

      Your DIET is the food etc you put in your mouth, whether its good food, bad food, wieght loss food etc…...its still your DIET.
      Havent you heard the expression, “We need to take a look at your DIET” of ” a healthy balanced DIET”.

    • Alicia says:

      09:41am | 13/01/12

      @The Truth - Mahrat has already explained himself but I agree that what you have described is heathly eating - not a diet. As an overweight person in my mid 20’s I wish discipline and self-control were as easy as they sound, but for some people, they aren’t.

      Ease up.

    • maybe says:

      12:36pm | 13/01/12

      Mahhrat, you didn’t “infer” anything, you implied it.  It was The Truth that made the incorrect “inferral” </English lesson>

      btw, i knew what you meant.

    • Markus says:

      11:32am | 12/01/12

      You will notice with all these programs that you take their product in conjunction with removal of all toxins from your diet (caffeine etc) as well as an increase in the amount of water consumed.
      Once you stop overconsuming toxins, and start consuming the amount of water you should be (the majority of people do not drink enough daily), the liver does the rest.
      The detox product itself is just an expensive placebo, stealing all the credit for the liver’s hard work.

      And regarding using detox as a weight loss program, it is indeed very dangerous. Sure doing a detox program for a week will make you lose weight, but that is because you subsist on a liquid intake for 7 straight days (in the case of the Lemon detox in particular).
      Ever wondered why you are so fatigued and unfocussed during those first 7 days? It is not because of the toxins leaving your body, it is because you are starving.

      All detox programs are rubbish. As Al said, the only way to detox is stop doing the ‘tox’ part.

    • perplexed says:

      08:22am | 13/01/12

      lol @ Stephen “137 kilos is only good for a panda”...

    • Wayne Kerr says:

      09:21am | 13/01/12

      As well.  These detox programs pretty much give you the runs for a week so all you’re losing is water.

    • Gav says:

      11:36am | 12/01/12

      Cupping works to release knots in your back and is effective in conjunction with massage to help your back, but does sweet FA for toxin release.

      Drink water for 4 days and you will get a better result than any ‘diet’

    • Lucas says:

      03:31pm | 12/01/12

      IT also helps bring blood flow to the area and can heal muscle injuries slightly faster, turning 2 weeks out of the game into 1 week. Same with acupuncture. I think ICB can apply to the “detox effect” but certainly the techniques are useful for the right conditions. As so many people rightly state, your liver detoxifies your body but it is best not to ingest so much of them.

    • Macca says:

      11:43am | 12/01/12

      “The claim doesn’t even abide by the laws of physics.”

      Reading the response to that article was just gold.

      If you want to detox, go for a run and eat some fruit and veg. And do your best to stay away from the beer. I’m struggling to stay away from the beer

    • Randy says:

      12:03pm | 12/01/12

      I like to detox with more beer and chips.  That’s the way I roll.

    • Jade says:

      12:07pm | 12/01/12

      Lol I tried the lemon detox diet a few years ago… never ever again will I ever do another detox! Disgusting :S

    • KTA says:

      12:34pm | 12/01/12

      My previous boss is actually one of the people on the ad for the “Lemon Detox Diet”, saying how great she felt, and how she lost weight.

      From what I saw, she lost weight because she was only eating salad along with the concoction they sell you. And her feeling great included crankiness, irritability & downright anger - again, I assume, cause she was only eating salad.

    • A says:

      08:19am | 13/01/12

      She ATE?

      Well she was doing it all wrong then!!! You’re not supposed to eat if you want to do it properly!

    • Anne71 says:

      12:35pm | 12/01/12

      Ah, yes, the “Detox” diets. Eloquent proof, if any was needed, that fools and their money are easily parted.  The people who fall for it are usually the ones you see at the supermarket with trolleys full of frozen foods, biscuits, chips and chocolates,  who consider that they’re doing their bit to reduce weight by stocking up on whichever “diet” cola is currently on special, and that the walk from the car to the supermarket counts as exercise. 
      The best detox I know is to cut back on the junk food and alcohol,  increase fruit and vegetable intake, drink plenty of water and get more exercise.  And yes, I say “cut back” rather than “cut out”  the junk food, because I don’t think the occasional glass of wine or bar of chocolate does you any harm, as long as the rest of your diet is healthy.

    • Coby says:

      12:52pm | 12/01/12

      Speaking of bullshit, if you forage around in actual bull crap, you might be lucky enough to find tapeworm which, if you’re serious about losing weight, you should ingest immediately.

      I’m serious. According to Diets in Review, on the tapeworm diet “weight loss is pretty much guaranteed”. Oh yeah, and you can die.

      By the way, tapeworm can grow up to 12 metres.

    • Markus says:

      04:23pm | 12/01/12

      Death is a small sacrifice to look that good.

    • maybe says:

      01:00pm | 13/01/12

      Dying from a cestode infestation (?) is pretty rare though.  If I were a fatty, I’d try it over a gastric band.  I’d name him ‘Michael’.

      I’d rather the larvae didn’t migrate to my brain or anything nasty like that.

    • KH says:

      01:03pm | 12/01/12

      The only thing getting cleaned out here is your wallet…............

    • Sam Chowder says:

      01:16pm | 12/01/12

      Which way round does the enema thingy in the picture go?

    • Al says:

      02:10pm | 12/01/12

      Sideways? (Ouch!)

    • neo says:

      02:06pm | 12/01/12

      All I’m gonna say is if you don’t eat for a week and drink laxatives, of course you’re gonna lose weight. Then once you start eating, you will gain it back, naturally. Detox diets are bs.

      Detoxing is for cleansing your body, not for losing weight, and never will be. If you want to detox without going too crazy, just eat healthy for a week or so, no fats, no sweets. Drink plenty of cranberry juice and warm water with freshly squeezed lemon. No need to spend big bucks on some pseudo-detox they are selling on the radio.

    • Defender says:

      02:20pm | 12/01/12

      What staggers me is how many gullible people out there with no bloody common sense…...some really do belive their is magic out there thats man made huh!

    • Al says:

      02:35pm | 12/01/12

      Many WANT to belive in magic and miracles.
      Thing is, any claims that a product is ‘Magic’ or a ‘Miracle’ is full of crap.
      (There are amazing products available yes, that does not mean they are Magic or Miracles! Anything marketed as such is immediately suspect).

    • Brett says:

      03:36pm | 12/01/12

      Of course the fun thing about ionic foot baths - beyond the ‘violating laws of physics’  thing - is that they change colour *whether your feet are in them or not*.

    • stephen says:

      09:17pm | 12/01/12

      Mate if I saw those girls in white at my bedside table I’d shit me pants too.

    • stephen says:

      09:29pm | 12/01/12

      I went to a japanese masseuse a while back and when I turned over, she tapped me on the nose with her forefinger lightly and asked ... ‘would sir like lucky strike now ?’

      ‘Nah mate, I don’t smoke’ ... and the next thing you know I was out the door tripping over me jocks and I didn’t get to pay a thing !

      Motto : give up smoking and you can get a touch-up for nothin’.

    • Sophie Rose says:

      05:39am | 13/01/12

      if any of this stuff worked there wouldn’t be so many overweight/obese people, and if you read the fine print on most of the ‘detox’ stuff it says that it works best in conjunction with a calorie-controlled diet and exercise program, and that not everyone will have the same results
      It’s the same as when all those ab-blaster machines started showing up on infomercials, you’d have someone saying that they lost eleventy million pounds and lost 46 inches 3 nano-seconds after getting on the machine - while in very small letter at the bottom of the screen it would say ‘results not typical’

      Diets don’t work and they aren’t designed to, the diet industry is worth billions every year. You do the specific diet, lose the weight you want, go off the diet and straight back to the eating habits that got you to the point of needing to diet in the first place.
      I was a yo-yo dieter for years, and each time I gained back more than I had originally weighed before I started.
      So last year I made a resolution and didn’t tell anyone. I changed what I ate, when I ate, and made sure that I moved as much as I could everyday - I’ve never been one for structured exercise stuff.
      On the first of Jan this year I was pretty impressed to have lost 32 kilo’s, I still want to lose another 15 but I now know there is no miricle to losing weight, just common sense.
      As several people have said - look after your liver and kidneys and they will do the detoxing they are designed to do. The detox you buy over the counter? Just send the money straight to the company that makes it, because the product won’t do anything other than lighten your wallet!

    • Daniel says:

      07:58am | 13/01/12

      Its called the capitalist economic system. People are allowed to peddle rubbish and dumb people will buy it.

    • A says:

      08:10am | 13/01/12

      Acupuncture and cupping exist in their own rights for specific problems, but for detox? Haha. Hilarious!

      The only way to “detox” is to stop eating and drinking junk and eating clean while drinking lots of water while committing to a good exercise regime.

      It’s hardly rocket science!

    • perplexed says:

      08:30am | 13/01/12

      oh how brainwashed we have become, diets, magic positons, pharmaceuticals, when we have a perfect body that is designed to keep us healthy and alive, if we treat it accordingly.  All tht food you see everywhere, that isn’t close to it’s natural source is only there to make someone money, it’s not for your convenience or your health etc etc.  Fruit, veggies, grains, legumes etc are there for your health, unfortunately these can’t be made cheaply and sold for a huge profit.

    • Fiona says:

      10:21am | 13/01/12

      I’d love to shop at a health shop or buy pure products, but I haven’t won the lotto yet….

    • Kelly says:

      09:05am | 13/01/12

      Husband and I have decided to wean ourselves off our sugar addiction. We’ve stopped buying anything with added sugar, and even those things which have hidden sugars that hide under other names. Once you actually start reading labels, it’s quite shocking how much is in our food, and in things you don’t expect would need them. Society’s obsession with ‘low fat’ has meant adding sweeteners to make up for the lost taste! We aren’t worried about buying low fat products anymore and in fact have gone back to full cream milk, normal Greek yoghurt etc. It’s not like we drink glasses of it. It’s been tough but we are starting to lose some blubber and are feeling much better. My skin has improved beyond belief. We’ve always exercised but as the years go by the kilos are harder to budge.

      I seriously can’t believe colonic irrigation! Disgusting, paying someone to shove a tube up your arse and flush out the contents. If we’d have been meant to have a reverse flush, we’d have had an inlet valve!

      I once lost 10 kilos using one of those chemist diet things (not Ferguson’s). But I needed to lose some weight before I had surgery as I knew I’d be immobile for a while. It worked, but 3 years later I’ve regained it plus more.

      Don’t detox, just don’t tox in the first place!

    • Tony says:

      09:10am | 13/01/12

      Why is it that in an age where ‘science’ has become the idol of worshippers, we also seem to fall for scams more than ever before? It never ceases to amaze me just how many people are sucked in by absolute rubbish. Diet fads, get rich quick schemes, pyramid schemes, party plan marketing….......The list goes on and on. Trying to ‘detox’ the world’s atmosphere is exactly the same mentality but try explaining that and listen to the gullible scream.

    • Anthropomorphic says:

      09:28am | 13/01/12

      What I want to know is, why has Peter Foster been jailed so many times for his BS slimming/detoxing miracle products such as Bai Lin Tea and yet this entire industry of charlatans (from what I hear, you can add the up-your-nose and up goes your wang cures to that list) has been allowed to flourish? Is it easier for the so-called regulators to target one notorious conman so they can be seen to be doing their job than actually protect the community and regulate this hocus pocus? I call BS and also call the regulators piss weak.

    • Miles says:

      10:05am | 13/01/12

      Isn’t it funny how these ‘toxins’ are always so non-specific?  I’ve yet to see them clearly identified, how they affect your body, and how the de-tox scam being sold specifically removes them from your body.  Really though, it’s just feeding on the ‘I want it now with minimal effort’ mentality that pervades society today.

    • Pauline says:

      10:09am | 13/01/12

      There’s absolutely no point in “eating healthy” and doing your “with moderation” stuff if what you’re breathing and slurping onto your skin is putting toxins into you.  (No point in detoxing either, but that’s been covered).

      If the chemicals preserving your furniture (like formaldehyde and those lovely fire retardants) or the stuff you clean your house with are getting into your system… if the air “fresheners” and deodourants you’re using are actually toxic (they’re the same stuff losers use for chroming!) and you’re spraying these into your house all day or coating yourself with them… if the skin care products (including soaps and moisturisers etc) actually contain skin irritants and in some cases, petrochemicals, formaldehyde and carcinogenic products…  then what’s the point in either “detoxing” or “eating healthy” without looking around and seeing what else you’re doing to make yourself unhealthy.

      Google “building biology” and see what’s in your home or workplace that you’re also voluntarily putting in your body.  Oh, and it’s a science, based on science…

    • perplexed says:

      10:22am | 13/01/12

      very well said, there’s a whole world of ignorance out there, which I find quite baffling as we have at our fingertips such easily accessible information on everything that we so desire.  I like when people spend more money on quality toilet paper and then say they can’t afford to eat good food, priorities!

    • Brynnin says:

      10:15am | 13/01/12

      I did actually try the lemon detox diet and at the end of my second day in I was pale as a ghost, could barely stand for feeling weak, and had a fever. Ever since then I haven’t considered going near a diet. Do it the old fashioned way - exercise and healthy eating. There is no quick fix.

    • Galooloo says:

      10:17am | 13/01/12

      An ‘all or nothing’ approach to detox is not helpful. There is plenty of fraud surrounding the topic but when done well it works. Do your homework and choose wisely and ignore people who like to create fear for the sake of it.

    • Snake says:

      11:38am | 13/01/12

      @Galooloo, lol at you.

      The theories surrounding detox are just that. Theories. The human body itself has its own detox mechanisms throughout the lymphatic system, the liver and the kidneys. The only plausible explanation for the requirement of detox in a human is after excessive drug intake.

      Even then, detox takes place by normal function of the human body. Occasionally you hear of hospitals pumping stomachs or giving relevant antivenoms in poison cases or excessive drinking… but these are just so that the ingested toxins dont KILL the person.

      Detox occurs naturally, you dont need a shifty marketing campain to help you detox. Just stop eating shit.

      Then again, it is promising to know that morons will buy anything with a good marketing spin on it.

    • Anthropomorphic says:

      12:22pm | 13/01/12

      LOL @ Galooloo. What Snake said. And fear, what fear? The only frightening thing is that people are gullible enough to part with their money these snake oil remedies. Complementary medicine is bollocks. Pure and simple. The human body will continue to cleanse itself until such time as it is no longer capable because of abuse. Stop drinking excessively and you probably won’t get cirrhosis of the liver, stop smoking early enough and you might just avoid emphysema.

    • the digger says:

      03:35pm | 13/01/12

      An old friend of mine ended up in hospital after doing one of those chemist detox boxes and her health has not been the same since.  Be warned.  Don’t claim you are “detoxing” when all you are doing is starving yourself.  No detox is a good detox.

    • Lorraine says:

      03:44pm | 13/01/12

      I remember when the word ‘diet” meant, the food you ate… it did not mean the restrictions you place upon yourself in your efforts to lose the weight you gained from eating too much of everything.
      Get real, eat quality food in moderate amounts and turn off the current affairs programs who give us at least one new restrictive diet per week usually talked up by a few women who have lost 3 kilos in the first week and then we never hear from them again.

    • NESLIHAN KUROSAWA says:

      09:31pm | 13/01/12

      Hi Tory,

      The best book I ever purchased was the Liver Cleansing diet by Dr Sandra Cabot way back! Which was so much more than I expected to ever know & could handle at the time.  It kind of stayed with me believe it or not!  If we all have balanced diets based on natural products rather than processed food, which happens to be something to begin with. Good health might just follow naturally.

      However, all the other fancy work outs & cleansing diets seem to be a bit of a joke & a money trap as well. There is always genetic factors at play as well as our life styles!  Meaning getting enough sleep, physical activity such as cleaning your house & being happy have always worked for me!  I could not ask any more than that for having healthy minds & as well bodies.  The rest is history & a bit of a fiasco sometimes, most unfortunately!

      Being all stressed about staying young & healthy in an almost obsessive way, is just another major stress trigger & factor!  Do not worry & be happy!  Kind regards to your editors..

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter