Before I get into this I must say a quick thanks to the many people - including complete strangers - who have sent messages of sympathy and support after Ireland got knocked out of the World Cup by what is surely the worst cheating incident in the history of sport.

One of the milder Photoshop treatments of Thierry Henry doing the rounds

If there’s one thing we Irish are really good at, it’s being outraged at injustice. Thanks to our over-friendly English neighbours we’ve had more than 800 years of practice.

And now we get to do it on Facebook.

The fastest-growing group on the social network right now is a petition to have the fixture replayed and has over 160,000 members. The group We Irish hate Thierry Henry (the cheat) has over 75,000 fans and claims it has been described on Sky News as a “sensational” page.

At least when Diego Maradona handled the ball past Peter Shilton into the English net for Argentina in the 1986 World Cup he had the good grace to say it was “a little of the hand of God, a little of the head of Maradona”.

No such aplomb from Thierry Henry, who openly admitted to cheating to Irish players immediately after the incident in which he used his hand – twice – to control the ball before squaring in to William Gallas to score and secure France’s place in next year’s World Cup.

(Watch it here and listen to what Henry has to say for himself. First vision of the handball is about 20 seconds in.)

Today I spoke with someone back home and as you might expect the country is gripped in a wave of seething anger and indignation. A 15-minute news bulletin on the national broadcaster was dedicated entirely to the story. Brian Cowan, the Irish prime minister, has discussed it with French president Nicolas Sarkozy. There’s talk of boycotting French food and wine.

In this atmosphere it’s probably a good thing that the Irish military’s hardware is basically limited to some propeller-powered airplanes and some trucks.

With most sporting controversies like the original Hand of God incident or the Jarryd Hayne touchline dance there’s some grey area, a point or two that could be up for debate. Even English football fans whose scars haven’t healed 23 years on will readily concede that Maradona’s appalling cheating was somewhat mitigated by the fact that he scored one of the greatest goals ever in the same game, taking the ball from inside his own half and beating seven opponents before toeing it into the net.

This is different. There’s global agreement that Henry is a cheat and that the Irish were robbed.

Even Thierry Henry agrees he’s a cheat, for crying out loud. “It was a handball,” he said after the game, “but I’m not the referee.”

There were two losers in this game: Ireland and sport. The most saddening aspect of it is that Henry is at the centre of it all. Until this week, if you liked football, you liked him. He was considered a gentleman of the game and has been indisputably one of the most delightful strikers of the modern game to watch.

Now punch “Thierry Henry cheat” into Google and you get around a quarter of a million results. Dig deep enough into it and some of the anger is disturbing. I can’t link to some of the content because it’s obscene.

The Guardian wrote overnight that Henry has become “perhaps the most vilified footballer on the planet”. Henry hate groups are everywhere on the web. He has been called every name under the sun and then some. And this isn’t just a case of sour grapes from the Irish. He’s being condemned in his own country – the French teacher’s union called it “unquestionable cheating” and the British press are savaging Henry and the French coach Raymond Domenech. Take this from Rob Kelly, a football writer for the UK Telegraph:

Just a few points, Raymond. Firstly, Thierry Henry has admitted it was a handball, and as such, it is cheating - that is one reason why you should apologise. Secondly, you should apologise for the lack of grace French football officials have shown since their disgraceful progression through to the World Cup finals. And thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, you Raymond should apologise for turning what had been a magnificent French team into the dishevelled shambles we saw on Wednesday night.

So what happens from here? The Irish government and the Football Administration of Ireland are seeking a replay, but the early signs from football administrators are that it won’t happen. Despite the online petitions and the fact that the entire world is basically united in outrage, the likelihood of a replay is practically zero.

Irish people and sports fans everywhere will get to hold on to their indignation, and young kids around the world have been given a clear message that cheaters win.

Another image doing the rounds

60 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Darren says:

      12:23pm | 20/11/09

      I do not know why you are outraged - it is all i expect from the French in general and Henry in particular

    • DG says:

      12:32pm | 20/11/09

      The only chance Ireland have is if the French Football Association agree that they are only in the World Cup due to cheating by their Captain, and stand down from their place in the world cup.

      Simply, it’s not going to happen.

      Just like Grotto taking that dive (even if the tackle was a bit sloppy), and the hundreds of athletes in various sports, business people in the course of their business, drivers who break the law, school kids taking exams etc etc - very few are going to drop themselves in trouble for the things they have done wrong.

      The reality it that people who do the wrong thing get away with it more often than not - not only do they get away with it they gain benefit from it, that’s why they do it. Especially when the benefit of cheating so heavily outweighs the effect of honesty.

      Welcome to the real world.

    • jg_rat says:

      12:33pm | 20/11/09

      I’d say “Gee, it’s only a game, Colgo” but I fear you’d never speak to me again.

    • DG says:

      12:36pm | 20/11/09

      P.S - Love that image!

      Look at the brand advertised on the banner.

      Cheating may destroy young lives and break hearts, fortunately alcohol has never done that.

    • Alain Citroen says:

      12:37pm | 20/11/09

      Thierry Henry a travaillé pour les services secrets irlandais. Il est conseillé d’être où je vous parle ..

    • Bloke says:

      12:39pm | 20/11/09

      My 12-year-old, who’s played a little soccer at school, heard this on AM this morning. “What the hell?” was his outraged response. It stinks.

    • Clem says:

      12:42pm | 20/11/09

      What’s Henry supposed to do - give himself a red card? Surely it’s the Ref who is a cheat, not Henry. Let’s face it, professional sport is full of people who get away with breaking the rules, so long as the ref didn’t see it. Adam Gilchrist walking that one time is the exception.

    • Joel B1 says:

      12:42pm | 20/11/09

      Most of the world knows the French cheat. But let’s face, it compared to the All Blacks they’re like that kid buying a stolen Freddo, pretty minor.

    • Pete says:

      12:44pm | 20/11/09

      Poor old Irish 801 years of persecution now

    • Yves of Youlouse says:

      12:45pm | 20/11/09

      Go away or we shall taunt you a second time ...

    • Sadhbh says:

      12:47pm | 20/11/09

      “In this atmosphere it’s probably a good thing that the Irish military’s hardware is basically limited to some propeller-powered airplanes and some trucks.”

      I laughed so hard my boss came over to find out why coding expenses was so amusing. I think they were hoping for a repeat of the time someone tried to charge a visit to Hooters on a Sunday as a client lunch.

      That said, you give the army a few beers and they’ll be at the Dun Laoghaire docks with those trucks by midday, ready to start the trip to the Eurostar and Paris.

    • Woodsman says:

      12:47pm | 20/11/09

      So a Frenchman cheated? Get over it. The Wallabies have had to face the eye-gouging ferret-fondlers on the rugby pitch for decades. My advice, go down to Bunnings, buy a bag of cement and harden up. Otherwise you Irish will get a reputation as being the worst moaners since Craig McLoughlin covered the song.

    • PeteJ says:

      12:50pm | 20/11/09

      Should have been picked up by the officials but unfortunately was not.  You cannot turn a result however with Henry admitting his actions surely he can be suspended for bring the game into disrepute or some such charge.

    • SM says:

      12:55pm | 20/11/09

      What does anyone expect from soccer players? There’s the blatant diving, the writhing on the ground in feigned agony, spitting on opponents, and the acosting and pushing of match officials.  But my favourite is when 2 players are challenging for the ball close to the sideline, and in the contest for possession, the ball bounces out over the line.  Even when it’s plainly clear which player touched it last, they both still automatically put their hand up to claim the throw in.

    • Rowdy says:

      12:59pm | 20/11/09

      Ahhh the French…....only good for two things…...kissing and surrendering….

    • Budz says:

      01:03pm | 20/11/09

      What’s the big deal? How is this such a big blow up when you see players taking dives to get penalty kicks? Isn’t that worse?

    • iansand says:

      01:07pm | 20/11/09

      I’m glad it is only football.  Aren’t there a fewProvisional IRA members with nothing to do?

    • Chris says:

      01:08pm | 20/11/09

      I admire Henry for admitting he handballed. At least he didn’t offer up some “hand of God” offal. Instead of vilifying him, we should be applauding him (with both hands) for his honesty and for bringing this side of the game into clearer focus. This time it was a handball, but what about the diving, the faking etc.
      Maybe he’s done the sport a favour and now those lardbutts at FIFA may look at the dreadful standard of officials in the game the world over. (Anyone recall Aus v Italy 2006? or Spain v Korea 2002? France v W Germany 1982?)
      The ref was in a poor position to see anything and where was the linesman?
      It’s tough on the Irish, to be sure, but that’s the great thing about soccer, it’s still one of the few sports where the horrors of video technology haven’t intruded thus allowing human frailties and emotions to play a major part in the game.
      Long may it remain so

    • BPobjie says:

      01:15pm | 20/11/09

      Oh, you “can’t link to some of the content because it is obscene”, yet you happily post that FILTHY video!!!!

    • Jugger says:

      01:18pm | 20/11/09

      Just proves the old addage ‘play to the whilstle.’  The whole Irish back line just stood still and put their hands up, allowing galas a free header, someone should have challenged him.  It’s harsh, but these players are professionals, they should know better.  I got told in under 12’s that you play to the whistle, Galas played to the whistle, and his team reaped the benefits.

    • Steve Smith says:

      01:21pm | 20/11/09

      So by FIFA “Fair Play Rules” in the event that a player is injured on the field, the team with the ball must kick it out until the magical water is sprayed onto said body part.. and the player is ok. BUT, if you assist a goal with a handball and the ref doesn’t see.. sweet as!

    • Budz says:

      01:22pm | 20/11/09

      Ahhh blaming the officials. This never gets tired with sports fans! If you think it’s that easy Chris, you should give it a go and see how many games you can ref until you make a massive mistake in judgement.

    • Mark says:

      01:29pm | 20/11/09

      Might be dangerous to say this (with a last name McCormack, and a heritage stretching back to Castleconnell, Limerick), but the Irish do have had a habit of blaming others (i.e. everyone else) for misfortune. It’s never their fault. Don’t believe me: google “Irish Blame”. See who they haven’t laid the boot into recently, for everything from the country’s financial woes to missing the World Cup. It’s a national pasttime.

      So I shouldn’t fein surprise that Paul Colgan then calls this latest episode “what is surely the worst cheating incident in the history of sport”. I like to think of it instead as the worst cheating incident in the history of sport since Irish swimmer Michelle Smith won three swimming gold medals for Ireland at the Atlanta Olympics before testing positive in to a drugs test ...

      Thierry Henry cheated. He admitted it. Who cares. Next!

    • Chris says:

      01:33pm | 20/11/09

      Hey Budz,
      As it happens, I have refereed, and no doubt made the odd blunder.

    • Steve of Cornubia says:

      02:13pm | 20/11/09

      As one who thinks sport should NOT be funded by government, save perhaps for providing community venues for amateur events, I found this very timely. The bullcrap that has been spouted the past few days about the wonderful effects that sport has, on participant and spectator alike, lies in stark contrast to your piece, where you say Ireland is a “....the country gripped in a wave of seething anger and indignation”, online comments can’t be linked because some of the comments are “obscene” and “young kids around the world have been given a clear message that cheaters win”.

      Well, so much for the spirit of cameraderie (allegedly) engendered by sport, eh?

      I have long believed that team sports, at least nowadays, in fact drive negative feelings of tribalism, especially rugby, soccer and more recently, cricket.

    • northern monkey says:

      02:16pm | 20/11/09

      Yes Henry’s a cheat, but the Irish had plenty of opportunities to finish the game off. (Sounds a bit like another game involving Aussies, Italians and a decisive cheat…)

      @ SM

      When I clicked on this post I wondered how long it would take a football hater to moan “What do you expect from soccer players blah blah blah?”

      You don’t get the game, don’t know the rules, don’t like the players - your presence here has certainly added to the conversation, hasn’t it?

      Good on you. You can go home this weekend knowing you did something totally pointless and feel smug about it. You’re a legend! A king! Top dog, the head honcho, the big cheese…

    • Matt says:

      02:20pm | 20/11/09

      A minor point: could journos please stop using the lazy fallback of “type suchandsuch into google and you return 80 bazillion results”. It doesn’t prove anything except for the fact that the writer doesn’t have any real evidence to hand.

    • SM says:

      02:36pm | 20/11/09

      @ Northern Monkey

      A typically mindless soccer fan comeback.  Just missing the “world game” or “the beautiful game” as part of it.  You address none of the my comments, just bang on about how I don’t know the rules.  Based on my post,  which rule don’t I know?

      A huge proportion of soccer players are, inherently, cheats.  The incident is no surprise

    • Eno says:

      02:46pm | 20/11/09

      I had an idea that there was a large expatriate Itish population around Arsenal in London there?

      I wonder if Thierry is goign to ask for a mid season transfer??

      Oh - one thing Colgo - declare this worse that the “Hand of God” incident again and I’ll find you and nibble your knees - you won’t like it!

    • AFR says:

      03:02pm | 20/11/09

      I didn’t realise Henry was referring the game. Silly me.

    • Gingermick says:

      03:12pm | 20/11/09

      Filthy musket droppers!!

    • Rowdy says:

      03:15pm | 20/11/09

      Indeed SM….almost as bad as defacating in a hotel corridor, bashing your girlfriend, punching sponsers, assaulting women, urinating on the field, constant drunk & disordely conduct in public, as as for the players close to the sideline, not quite as bad as the carry on about a knock-on….or the way the bulldogs players carried on when they were beaten by the dragons on a penalty…..you are obviously a closet football lover…if you hate the game as much as you appear to, why on earth are you 1) reading this article; 2) Bothering to post on here and 3) replying to people commenting on you post? Obviously you have nothing to do in your thugby off-season.

    • Greensborough Growler says:

      03:20pm | 20/11/09

      Charming of you to put Henri’s head as target for some nutcase to copy with a real gun. It’s only a bloody game. No babies died.

    • northern monkey says:

      03:28pm | 20/11/09

      SM, I never said anything about mindlessness; I just questioned the point of your comment and, by extension, your very existence.

      Soccer players are inherently cheats, just as NRL and AFL players inherently sexist morons, and rugby union players inherently cabbage-eared private school boys who wear stripey Ralph Lauren shirts with extra large logos.

      Most of your points are correct; it’s that flawed ambiguity that makes the beautiful game so beautiful, the world game so worldly. There’s no room for such discussion in other codes because they lack the subtleties of the football.

      But let’s forget all this nonsense and come together in a loving embrace, safe in the knowledge that whatever our sporting differences, at least we’re not French.

    • northern monkey says:

      03:33pm | 20/11/09

      @ Rowdy

      No need to get tart.

    • Trent Fisher says:

      03:35pm | 20/11/09

      We all watched as Italy was awarded a very ‘dubious’ (and i use that term lightly) penalty against Australia in 2006. 

      If you watch cricket, you will see numerous incidents a game where the umpire is wrong (some that even cost us the Ashes.)

      The fact is umpires often make the wrong decision, and in a game like football, where the winning margin is often the result of one passage of play, it can have devastating consequences.

      But, let’s face it. It happens to every team here and there.  It’s a tragedy for Ireland, but to replay the game would open up a whole new can of worms where teams can claim that due to bad refereeing they should get a ‘do-over.’

      They should look to the future and to video technology, but in hindsight you can’t change the outcome - the ref is always right.

      (btw Thierry Henry is a champ, atleast he admitted to it unlike most other players out there.  I defy anyone in that position to actually stop the game, pick up the ball, give it to Shay Given [the Irish keeper] and say “oh, sorry, i touched the ball.  Your free kick”) As he rightly said, he’s not the ref.

    • shabangabang says:

      03:40pm | 20/11/09

      The French have been putting their hands up when foreigners enter their country since 1940. Dopey surrender monkeys.

      More Hands than a german phonebook in that incident. Not happy Henry, not happy at all

    • SM says:

      03:50pm | 20/11/09

      @Rowdy

      That’s certainly all appalling behaviour, but of course none of it’s cheating

      Soccer players cheat religiously, and are able to cheat without even thinking.  Cheating is ingrained in them.  Cheating is part of their psyche.  They cheat often, and they cheat unashamedly.

      Cheating is an integral part of soccer

    • Bob H says:

      03:56pm | 20/11/09

      Thiery has done the Irish afavour and given a new reason for them to be bitter and twisted, potatoes was running a bit thin.

    • SM says:

      03:58pm | 20/11/09

      @Rowdy

      Indeed, all those incidents are examples of appalling behaviour.  Of course though, none of them are cheating.

      Soccer players cheat religiously, and are able to cheat without even thinking.  Cheating is ingrained in them. Cheating is part of the soccer players psyche.  They cheat often, and they cheat unashamedly

      Cheating is an integral part of soccer

    • SM says:

      04:01pm | 20/11/09

      @ Northern Monkey

      Agree wholeheartedly

      *embraces*

    • JdR of Salisbury says:

      04:16pm | 20/11/09

      The problem is cheats getting away with it.  Henry has.

      Sports that use referees have fallen into the trap of putting all responsibility for fair play upon their shoulders.

      Henry said - he wasn’t the referee.  It wasn’t his responsibility not to cheat.  He, and anyone else who plays a sport with a referee, will cheat and keep cheating unless they get caught (and then they’ll cheat again).

      Change sport.  Make players responsible.  Yes, you can’t do this on the field.  But sport beyond the grassroots has a massive off-field machine that’s integral to the game at that level.  Use it.

    • davido says:

      07:23pm | 20/11/09

      Diddums.

    • Rob says:

      07:42pm | 20/11/09

      I’ve played as a striker and when a ball comes at you at that speed through a crowd of players, it’s all instinct. He handled it, yes, but played the whistle and poked into the middle. If it had been Robbie Keane at the other end, he’d have done the same thing. Ireland had their chances in both legs against a lacklustre French side, but didn’t take them and the inevitable happened.

    • Ryan says:

      10:04pm | 20/11/09

      Pleeeaaasseeee. Sport can be very emotional, and there is no doubt Henry handballed and “cheated” to get the ball in. It’s not a great outcome for anyone at the end of the day - but this sort of thing happens almostly weekly (sometimes more often) in a busy football season.

      To write up an article and make this out to be the worst thing that’s ever happened to the game is making a mountain out of a mole hill. I’m sure if you got enough footage it wouldn’t take you long to find the odd questionable goal that Ireland have scored over the years.

      What this has openly shown is that football players are human, they are capable of cheating and Henry just happens to have admitted it.

      We all know players theatrically fall and hold onto their calves or ankles after tackles that at times have never even touched them! You see footballers admitting to that, even though we all know the truth?

      The decisions been made, suck it up and move on.

    • Robert says:

      11:53pm | 20/11/09

      fair is fair and he cheated, but guiltily and like everyone who isn’t irish or english speaking would say - I’d rather see Karim Benzema, Yoann Gourcuff, Franck Ribery, Lass Diarra and yes, one Thierry Henry at the world cup than Robbie Keane, Damien Duff and Dunne.

    • Rory Donnelly says:

      01:08am | 21/11/09

      Facebook have removed the page…so much for the 90,000 fans.  Maybe FIFA bough Facebook…

    • Martin says:

      03:54am | 21/11/09

      Paul shows he doesn’t know much about sport when he says, “what is surely the worst cheating incident in the history of sport”. What about:
      The organised doping in professional cycling
      A formula one driver deliberately crashing his car to help a teammate
      A rugby union coach cutting a players face with a scalpel to fake a blood bin replacement
      The Italian match fixing scandal involving Juventus.
      South Africa’s cricket captain taking bribes from bookies
      The rest of the article shows he doesn’t know much about what is happening in Irish politics. The outrage by the Prime Minister is an attempt to gain some popularity before he hands down one of the most severe budget in Irish history.
      Irish fans have a right to be upset, but should perhaps look closer to home for someone to blame
      http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/internationals/8370327.stm.
      The outraged jurnos and politicians don’t

    • Sam says:

      05:26am | 21/11/09

      I’m in favour of anything that reminds me of Maradona. Still the greatest, even at cheating.

    • Daddio D says:

      07:12am | 21/11/09

      The thing for us all to do to show our total disgust is to boycott French kissing.

    • S.L says:

      07:37am | 21/11/09

      If a professional sportsman can get away with cheating he or she will. Whether it’s footy, athletics, dominoes, anything really. I’d like to see Thiery Henri step foot in Ireland anytime in the next 30 years or so. Somehow I don’t think he’d be too keen. Funny if Ireland and France already had a friendly lined up before the World Cup next year? I can guarentee one player that will be injured! The ref will have surely stuffed his chances of officianating in South Africa for sure.

    • Norman says:

      01:39pm | 21/11/09

      against georgia the irish got a VERY dodgy penalty; which never was.

      when did the irish demand a replay then?

      these things even themselves out over the course of the season. the irish got one and copped one.

    • james says:

      02:41pm | 21/11/09

      Let’s not stop here.Let’s replay every cricket test in which a batsman didn’t walk;let’s replay every league game in which a missed knock-on led to a try;let’s replay every ‘soccer’ game where a penalty was awarded for a blatant dive.Better still,why not just abide by the umpire’s decision and play to the whistle?

    • harry says:

      12:09pm | 22/11/09

      It’s only sport and I couldn’t care less. Over rated, overpaid and completely irrelevant.

    • S.L says:

      04:49pm | 22/11/09

      @ James….. You have a very valid point.  You could also add in every State of Origin League match refereed by “the Grasshopper” and the Manly/Parramatta league games refereed by Greg Hartley in the late 70s to early 80s and any Swans AFL match umpired by Hayden Kennedy….... What goes around comes around!

    • Shane says:

      08:51am | 23/11/09

      Thierry Henry is Irelands most hated man – but I think this is FIFAs fault, because a replay should have been granted. The referee was blind to 2 hand balls and 2 players being offside.

      The World Cup is now a damaged competition as a result as is Henrys reputation.

    • Macca68 says:

      01:09pm | 01/12/09

      FIFA will never agree to a replay as it sets a precedent that every game subject to dubious decisions should be replayed as well.

      Instead FIFA should fine Henry for unsportsmanlike behaviour/bringing the game into disrepute. He had the chance to tell the referee he handled the ball but didn’t and his team benefited. When will FIFA get the balls to do something to rid the game of divers, cheaters and thugs.

    • Adam says:

      01:40pm | 01/12/09

      This incident highlights the main problem with professional soccer. In a sport where so much money (in this case, national pride) is involved and one play can win or lose a match, I’m surprised there isn’t a video review system in place. While it wouldn’t have necessarily have prevented this, it would provide some recourse to fine or suspend players for unsportsmanlike conduct such as this. However, the MAIN reason why this needs to be done is to remove the disgusting scourge of divers. Fine or suspend unsportsmanlike conduct and you’ll bring me back to the sport.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter