So Archbishop Desmond Tutu has congratulated the Marrickville Council for their temporary boycott of Israeli products. But living a Zionist-free life is actually much harder than most people probably think. This fact finally dawned on the Council earlier this year, when they were forced to concede that their attempt to boycott Israel as part of the global Boycott, Divestments and Sanctions campaign was “impractical and untenable.”

Photo: AFP

Yet last week in the Federal Parliament, the Labor Party watered down a motion moved in the House of Representatives by Julie Bishop on the issue, voting to remove the condemnation of Marrickville Council contained in the original motion.

The reasoning behind Labor’s refusal to condemn Marrickville Council remains opaque. Perhaps some Labor MPs are sympathetic to the goal of removing Zionism in all its forms from their lives, or perhaps they are just afraid to incur the wrath of their Greens allies, some of whom - including Marrickville Mayor Fiona Byrne - still advocate for “in-principle” support of the boycott.

Indeed, last night on ABC’s Q&A program, Greens Senator-elect Lee Rhiannon referred to Israel as an “apartheid system” and smugly announced that Archbishop Desmond Tutu had written a letter to Marrickville Council congratulating them on their support for the boycott.

So, given the BDS campaign still seems to have support in some quarters, I thought it would be worthwhile putting together a handy guide to eliminating Zionist products and services from daily life, in case anyone is still interested in doing so.

Although I haven’t seen the exact list of products and services that Marrickville Council initially wanted to ban, a quick perusal of the BDS website allows us to start piecing together a list of the offending companies.

Perhaps you like to begin your day with a run. Make sure you throw away your Adidas shoes, given that Adidas is sponsoring the Jerusalem marathon this year.

When you get home and want to shower, make sure your bathroom is clear of anything branded Lynx, Dove, Lux, Ponds, Rexona, Sunsilk, Garnier, or Vaseline.

Ladies, before applying your make-up, go through your cosmetics drawer and get rid of anything produced by Revlon, Estee Lauder, L’Oreal, Maybelline, Lancome or The Body Shop.

Do you enjoy a hot cup of Milo or a Nescafe Blend 43 over breakfast? Too bad. Clear your kitchen of any Nestle products, and any Lipton or Bushell’s tea while you’re at it. Don’t go spreading Flora on your toast or cooking some Bertolli bacon, and don’t even think about popping in to Starbucks or Max Brenner on the way to work instead.

Live in Melbourne and take the train to work? Well, don’t. Many Melbourne trains were re-fitted by Alstom, and they’re on the BDS hit-list. And if you drive to work, make sure you don’t do so in a Volvo or a Holden.

Once you get to work, unplug your computer if it is an HP or if it uses any Intel software (approximately 80 per cent of PCs and laptops worldwide). Be aware that many computer companies, including Microsoft, have research and development facilities in Israel. And in 2006, Google bought a search algorithm from an Israeli student, so you may want to consider finding an alternative search engine, if you want to risk using a computer at all.

Need to make any phone calls? Throw away that Motorola mobile and destroy your Optus sim card. And don’t try to get in touch with your friends through instant messaging software instead, because Israelis invented that too.

Feeling like a sneaky mid-week cheeseburger for lunch from McDonalds? Don’t even think about it. Maggi two-minute noodles? No way. Uncle Toby’s muesli bar? You wish.

Need a mid-afternoon pick-me-up? Coca-cola and any of their brands like Sprite or Fanta are off the list. And if you’re considering a healthy alternative and want to pick up some bottled water instead, make sure it’s not Evian. Thinking about a delicious treat from Sara Lee? Some Allen’s lollies, maybe? Think again, mate.

What about dinner? Make sure you cross off any Continental products, or Raguletto pasta sauces. And Streets ice-creams are off the menu for good.

Perhaps your new Zionist-free diet won’t sit right with you, and you start to feel ill. If you need to go to the doctor, ensure that they don’t try to make you swallow the revolutionary Pill Cam that allows doctors to actually see what is going on inside your digestive tract. This was one of the many medical breakthroughs of Israeli medical scientists.

The fact is, much of the technology that we take for granted, and the brands we use every day, have some links to Israel. Israeli technological innovation is almost unrivalled across the world, and the inventions of Israeli scientists have delivered transformational change to the way we live.

You might wonder why so many of your favourite products are on the BDS hit-list. Apart from the impressive technologies Israelis have developed and sold around the world, many companies have major parts of their operations in Israel or do business with Israelis. And in the eyes of the myopic anti-Israel BDS crowd, that’s enough to earn them a spot on the black list. It’s a list that includes some of the largest consumer product manufacturers in the world, like Unilever.

Israel is a legitimate and democratic state. The Greens on Marrickville Council (and Senator-elect Lee Rhiannon, I might add) do not seem to understand that you can support rights for Palestinians, that you can support a two-state solution and peace in the Middle-East, without engaging in anti-Israel rhetoric and actions.

Thankfully, that position on Israel is way outside the political mainstream, and the various products I described above are not likely to go missing from Australian shelves any time soon. So feel free to go home and tuck in to a Milo and a Sara Lee apple pie, guilt free.

85 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • John says:

      03:34pm | 07/06/11

      Thanks for the list! I know what not to buy now!

    • Matt says:

      03:53pm | 07/06/11

      Say hi to Bob for me!

    • Nick says:

      03:42pm | 07/06/11

      Watch out Mitch, my man, making any comment that does not glorify the Jews in the media is cause for dismissal…

      Considering the entire media is run by Jews (i can provide a list of all the Hollywood execs if anybody is interested… only 6 are non-Jews), and the alarming frequency of Holocaust-related material, this article is spot on. We are Australia. Our country has little to nothing to do with the Holocaust. Why is it, then, that i cannot go a single day without hearing about how the Holocaust was such a tragedy? There are far worse genocides in the history of man-kind, some of which the Jews themselves refuse to acknowledge. Our education system has compulsory Holocaust-related courses all the way through from years 9 to 12. I am ashamed to say that i know more about the Holocaust than Australian history, because of the education system.

      Another thing. Supposedly, 11 million people died in the Holocaust. Why do we never hear about the other 5 million? where are the gypsy survivors speaking and recieving $40 billion reperations from Germany alone? Back in the 1980s, the plaque outside Auschwitz read ‘4 million Jews died here.’ Today, it reads ‘1.1 million Jews died here’. Yet, despite the disproval of nearly three million of these deaths, the official number has not been reduced from 6 million to 3 million. Why? So the Jews can continue promoting the Holocaust as primarily against Jews (which they could not do if there were not the majority killed…. 6 million = slight majority of 11 million) and would not recieve anywhere near the reperations, benefits, or attention they do.

      There is a lot of incredibly suspect ‘facts’ about the Holocaust. The most suspicious thing is that it is ILLEGAL for anybody to run an investigation questioning any of these. Doesn’t that seem in violation of freedom of speech? People can debate back and forth about WWI, the Romans, the Armenian genocide, until they are black and blue in the face, but we cannot utter a word against the holocaust without being labelled as ‘anti-semites’ spouting hate-speech.

      Be warned. This alone should set the bells ringing in your head.

      Someday the world will know the truth.

    • Zaf says:

      04:15pm | 07/06/11

      Nick, you are too appalling to be real.  There is such a thing as overdoing it.

      Stop trolling and trying to present criticism of Israel as idiotic anti-semitism.

    • Ally says:

      04:43pm | 07/06/11

      Mao killed 45 million chinese in the space of 4 years.

      55 million people died during WWII ..... 6 (?) million Jews, 5 million of ethnic minority, 20 million Russians and the other 24 mill split between the allies and axis of evil.  Yes, we’ve had an axis of evil before.

    • Jim says:

      04:55pm | 07/06/11

      I think you missed the satire in the senators piece. He was pointing out that it is totally impractical and undesireable to boycott Israel…

    • Spart says:

      08:38pm | 07/06/11

      Nick
      It must be awesome to be 18 and Mummy let’s you loose on your keyboard on Punch.

      Ignoramus

    • Patrick Musson says:

      08:58pm | 07/06/11

      Excuse me but the Nazis didn’t start out to annihalate the Jews, they wanted at first to keep them ‘apart’ from the rest of the population and decided to relieve them of their businesses at the same time. Do you see a pattern here? The Palestinians are being forced ‘apart’ from the land their houses were on for the Isreali settlements to occupy. The rest of the world aren’t the only populations that need to learn lessons from history, the government in Isreal only needs to look at the way they were treated by the Nazi’s then take a close look at the way they are treating the Palestinians. To quote an elderly Jewish man on the mini-series ‘V’ when he said to his son who didn’t want to give shelter to a scientist being hunted by the Visitors “We haven’t learned a thing”

    • annie says:

      10:59am | 08/06/11

      Nick, you are hilarious.

    • Mitchell says:

      11:17am | 08/06/11

      Nick you should move to the middle east and leave all Australians alone in peace.

      “Israel is a legitimate and democratic state.”
        - Not the point really, so was Nazi Germany and we all know how that turned out.

      “...you can support a two-state solution and peace in the Middle-East, without engaging in anti-Israel rhetoric and actions”   
        -Most sensible thing I’ve heard from a politician in years, why all the negativity and hatred? why not spend that those millions of $$$ providing humanitarian aid to Palestine instead of trying to make the council Isreali-free?
      As a long time resident of Marrickvile LGA I was shocked, It was nothing but a shameless grab for votes by local councillors, I hate to think what it would feel like to be an Australian-Israeli living in the area, all of whom I’m sure prefer living in a stable and religiously tolerant country like Australia
      Next we’ll have people shooting rockets into Bondi from Marrickville and a 9 metre high wall stretching the length of botany road.
      As a country we should be laughing together at how idiotic the whole situation is, there is much to achieve in the world, hating and killing your neighbours is not one of them.
      People who want to bring the problem here should be put on the 1st plane to Gaza.

    • Steve Supple says:

      10:07am | 10/06/11

      Great article. Good to see some balanced reporting on Israel.
      I’m not Jewish, but I do watch what’s happening in that part of the world.
      Dispute Israels political & security problems, it is very innovative. It has to content with a Pslintinian cause, a hostile/revolutionary middle east, a liberal west, a bias UN, an idealistic US & a critical BBC etc.
      I fear the pressure on Israel can only increase once the world isn’t so busy with two wars, Islamist extremism, national near-defaults in Europe etc.
      Once these global problems are reduced to manageable levels, I feel Israel will only have more to deal with in the future.
      I don’t think ‘Globalism’ isn’t going to good for them in the future.

    • Nick says:

      03:42pm | 07/06/11

      Watch out Mitch, my man, making any comment that does not glorify the Jews in the media is cause for dismissal…

      Considering the entire media is run by Jews (i can provide a list of all the Hollywood execs if anybody is interested… only 6 are non-Jews), and the alarming frequency of Holocaust-related material, this article is spot on. We are Australia. Our country has little to nothing to do with the Holocaust. Why is it, then, that i cannot go a single day without hearing about how the Holocaust was such a tragedy? There are far worse genocides in the history of man-kind, some of which the Jews themselves refuse to acknowledge. Our education system has compulsory Holocaust-related courses all the way through from years 9 to 12. I am ashamed to say that i know more about the Holocaust than Australian history, because of the education system.

      Another thing. Supposedly, 11 million people died in the Holocaust. Why do we never hear about the other 5 million? where are the gypsy survivors speaking and recieving $40 billion reperations from Germany alone? Back in the 1980s, the plaque outside Auschwitz read ‘4 million Jews died here.’ Today, it reads ‘1.1 million Jews died here’. Yet, despite the disproval of nearly three million of these deaths, the official number has not been reduced from 6 million to 3 million. Why? So the Jews can continue promoting the Holocaust as primarily against Jews (which they could not do if there were not the majority killed…. 6 million = slight majority of 11 million) and would not recieve anywhere near the reperations, benefits, or attention they do.

      There is a lot of incredibly suspect ‘facts’ about the Holocaust. The most suspicious thing is that it is ILLEGAL for anybody to run an investigation questioning any of these. Doesn’t that seem in violation of freedom of speech? People can debate back and forth about WWI, the Romans, the Armenian genocide, until they are black and blue in the face, but we cannot utter a word against the holocaust without being labelled as ‘anti-semites’ spouting hate-speech.

      Be warned. This alone should set the bells ringing in your head.

      Someday the world will know the truth.

    • Jay says:

      10:27am | 08/06/11

      Nick,
      I feel sorry for you that you can hate Jews to such an extent that you now want to question whether there was a Holocaust. One of the reasons we are reminded daily (as you put it) is to remind future generations about what can happen when you let hate and evil prosper. The Japanese have taught their people a completely different interpretation of WW2, so much so that many know nothing about what occured including the massacre of Nanjing. I never heard you complaining about Saddam Hussein when he and his psychopath family was killng thousands of Iraqi’s.I hear nothing about the lunatic in Iran or Zimbabwe, Sudan, Somalia and Afghanistan. No it is easy to kick the Jew and just pepertrate the usual hate filled barbs. Kill the Jews then who is next? Christians? Buddhists, Hindu’s? I have spoken to people who lived and survived the death camps and heard their harrowing stories. But you know better.Your comments shame you and your family.

    • Nick says:

      10:52am | 08/06/11

      Jay,
      I cannot believe the alarming regularity with which lefties turn to ‘you are racist’ to discredit an argument. I do not hate Jews. Questioning the accuracies of a historical event based upon proven evidence is not hate speech.

      Well, at least, it’s not hate speech if you question the Chinese genocide, the Armenian genocide (which the Jews themselves deny) or the gemocide that is going on right now in Palestine. It is only a hate crime if it is against the Jews.

      Does this not seem suspicious to you?

      If you read my comment, i clearly, CLEARLY acknowledge that the Holocaust happened, and that millions of people died. It was a tragedy. But the whole war was a tragedy. 55 million people died. Why disregard the other 49 million?

      Can you answer that without calling me a racist? Or at least provide evidence to support your argument that I am racist? I’m not, i assure you.

    • BMJ says:

      03:43pm | 07/06/11

      This article is as silly as the boycott ban itself.

      You get trapped into the same type of thinking as these idiots.

      Oh well, I guess you’ll get points from the pro-Israel lobby now. Well played.

    • Rebecca says:

      03:48pm | 07/06/11

      Once the Palestinians have sworn to recognise and accept the right of Israel to exist, then come and talk to me about what Israel does which may be good, bad or otherwise.

    • A Dose of Reality says:

      06:43pm | 07/06/11

      I notice that you do not require the Israelis to swear recognition of and accept the right for Palestine to exist.  Unfortunately, no one ever does, which is why the palestinian is slaughtered so readily.

    • Grolsch Sipper says:

      10:50pm | 07/06/11

      Rebecca, don’t be blinded by religious propaganda, that is Al Qaida’s job. One of the greatest lies that is perpetuated in the western media is that the Arabs deny the right for Israel to exist. The Arabs I have known since living in Qatar,  simply don’t care, what they do care about is Israel’s belligerence to come to an end and for Palestine to have the right to exist, clearly Benjamin Netanyahu does not believe Palestine has the right to exist and cant understand why Israel is shunned by the neighbours.  The Israelis are quite capable of demonstrating racism and this is how a fascist state is capable of living inside of a democratic framework. Dont forget the Lebanese are Democratic too.

    • Brutus Balan says:

      09:00am | 08/06/11

      Well said Rebecca. That was a dose of reality !!!

      And for the the other “Dose of Reality”, you have dozed of reality. The Israelis have said over the years now, even recently that they have accepted the reality of a Palestinian state. You better change your pseudonym to “Dozed of Reality” smile

    • MegaLawlz says:

      10:13am | 08/06/11

      @Brutus Balan - if Israel recognises, why the continued building of Jewish settlements in Palestinian-populated areas? What happened to the road map for peace?

      Yes, the Holocaust was terrible. But that doesn’t mean that anything and everything that Jewish people do is right. Given that Israel has the support of America and the West, and is far better equiped than the Palestinians, it’s makes sense to expect more from them than from the stone-throwing youths of palestine.

    • Erick says:

      03:48pm | 07/06/11

      I actually supported the NSW Greens, way back in the late 1980s to early 1990s. I was a volunteer in their election campaigns, and helped with producing and distributing Greens publications, formulating policies, and scrutinising votes.

      I believed in the environmental cause, in global warming and most of the other ecological causes that were popular at the time. That’s why I put in the effort.

      But even then, I noticed that quite a bit of the Greens’ agenda had little or no relation to environmental issues. There were various social and economic initiatives that had nothing to do with conservation. I remember that one policy which appeared out of nowhere was “a ban on boxing”. WTF??

      It took me a few years, but eventually I realised that the Greens were just another far-left activist group, hiding under the banner of environmentalism. That’s why they’re posturing about bans on Israel, and not concentrating on real green issues.

      Do not trust the Greens.

    • Jon says:

      04:53pm | 07/06/11

      Erick@ Sad but true! Why they are they putting bans on the only secular democracy in the Middle East when there is so much environmental work to be done. They are just the Looney left masquerading as Green and the more power they get the less Green they are become.

    • papachango says:

      05:10pm | 07/06/11

      True, but they’re starting to show their true colours now - Lee Rhiannon doesn’t even bother pretending to care about the enviornment for its own sake.

      She’ll only mention it as a justification for more scoialism.

    • Bruce says:

      05:39pm | 07/06/11

      The greens are evil in disguise. No wonder peter garrett left them, he found out the hard way.

    • chris t says:

      06:05am | 08/06/11

      The Greens don’t purport to be a single-issue party.  Brown himself has said upfront that they aspire to government.  So, yes, they are about more than just conservation issues.  Where’s the pretense?

    • Jon says:

      09:51am | 08/06/11

      chris t says@ Many people and especially the young don’t go that deeply into political brands. The Green brand is false advertisement like advertisement on the telly. The young are easily deceived as they have genuine concerns for environment and rightly so. But the Greens have other political agendas that if properly explained many would not agree with.

    • Dieter Moeckel says:

      10:12am | 08/06/11

      Can I please get this right - The Greens are an environmental party therefore they can’t mention anything else! Ergo Labor must restrict itself to labour and work ... what about the Liberals then? are they the only party allowed a multi issue agenda?
      Don’t quite get the idea that the Greens must be a single issue party.

    • Michael N says:

      11:17am | 08/06/11

      @ Jon - Please explain how the Jewish State of Israel is a “secular” democracy?

      The boycott is ridiculous and so outside the purview of local government. But, since we’re addressing the legitimacy of Israel as a consequence, perhaps it isn’t all bad.

      As others have noted here, Israel excuses their gross humanitarian breaches by uttering “holocaust”. Without doubt the Jewish people were the victim of a terrible attrocity during the Nazi reign of Germany (and then Europe) but having suffered these wrongs in the past does not legitimate their oppression of the Palestinian people in the present and future.

      Two wrongs don’t make a right.

    • Liam says:

      11:27am | 08/06/11

      And the left like to say that the conservative right is the racist, sexist, anti-semetic group. An environmental party telling the world to ban israeli products?!? comrade brown and his ilk should be ashamed. Next it will be Jews are the leading contributors to CO2 emmissions and the greens will want a 5% reduction in Jews

    • Zaf says:

      03:49pm | 07/06/11

      Milo and Sara Lee?  Woaaaaah, man, ZOG is for real! 

      As for Israeli Apartheid, what a joke.  From that Peal of Truth:

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_and_the_apartheid_analogy#By_Israelis

      Ehud Olmert, then Deputy Prime Minister of Israel, commented in April 2004 that; “More and more Palestinians…want to change the essence of the conflict from an Algerian paradigm to a South African one…to a struggle for one man, one vote. That is, of course, a much cleaner struggle, a much more popular struggle – and ultimately a much more powerful one. For us, it would mean the end of the Jewish state.”…

      Michael Ben-Yair, attorney-general of Israel from 1993 to 1996 referred to Israel establishing “an apartheid regime in the occupied territories” in an essay published in Haaretz….

      A major 2002 study of Israeli settlement practices by the Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem concluded: “Israel has created in the Occupied Territories a regime of separation based on discrimination, applying two separate systems of law in the same area and basing the rights of individuals on their nationality. This regime is the only one of its kind in the world, and is reminiscent of…the apartheid regime in South Africa.”…

      …founding director of Bat Shalom writes…” I’m not sure the discussion about how we are like or unlike South Africa helps move us forward to a solution. But the comparison reminds us that hundreds of laws do not make discrimination just …And it doesn’t matter how we explain it and how many articles are written by Israeli scholars and lawyers—there are two groups living in this small piece of land, and one enjoys rights and liberty while the other does not.”

    • Eli says:

      04:04pm | 07/06/11

      Should we boycott China too? They’re doing terrible things in Tibet. How about Russia? Heard of Chechnya. Iran? Yemen? Saudi Arabia? Libya? Why the focus on Israel? It doesn’t make sense…

    • Zaf says:

      04:16pm | 07/06/11

      Eli, nobody else hears our plaintive cries but Israel.  It’s almost a compliment, if you think about it.

    • BMJ says:

      04:18pm | 07/06/11

      I agree Eli. However there’s a certain freedom in people critising those other countries. If you criticise Israel you are automatically “anti-Israel” or worse.

      The boycott is stupid but so is the free ride that Israel receives from politicians who see them above criticism for various reasons.

    • fairsfair says:

      04:23pm | 07/06/11

      Austen Tayshus tried this line on Q&A last night. Are you and he admitting that Isreal is “doing terrible things” ? He clearly had a vested interest (he is Jewish), your name suggests you are too but I do not wish to generalise.

      Even if one was not jewish this comment does nothing to hold Isreal up in a good light. The old “but they are doing it too” defence didn’t stack up with my mum either.

      I personally think the movement is rediculous and I thought this article put things into perspective. How in the hell one council from one Australian city thinks it has the political power to engage in complex foreign affairs is beyond me and I can not believe the Federal Government and out mate Kevin Rudd has not put them in their place.

    • Bilby says:

      04:30pm | 07/06/11

      It only doesn’t make sense because you’re looking at it from the wrong angle. Being anti-Israel is the ultimate hipster statement. Hating those other countries is just too obvious.

    • Eli says:

      05:35pm | 07/06/11

      I agree that Israel is doing things that I disagree with, like many other countries.

      My point is not that Israel is or should be above reproach. It is that other countries who are doing much worse things are not held to the same standard.

    • John the Zombie says:

      09:56pm | 07/06/11

      fairsfai I hope then you will be supporting LeT claim to Kasmir then even though in the signed document it was allocated to
      India.

      Interesting Eli if you look at it the situation that India has i the same as Isreal. They both have terrorists who want thier countries destroyed. The only reason why they choose to attack Isreal rather then India is that if they did they would be branded racist and also alot of them are in love with the hindu yoga and peace stuff. 

      Actaully I know of two face greens are as I wrote a letter to Bob Brown asking him to talk to Julia Gillard before her trip to India to ask her to take up the issue of the fact that member of the congress party have still not been bought to justice in thier role in the mass murder of over 5000 sikhs in 1984.

    • Brutus Balan says:

      09:09am | 08/06/11

      What rubbish, ” If you criticise Israel you are automatically “anti-Israel” or worse.” ?  No one is critical about that but when have the loony left vent their venom against the countries mentioned above as much as Israel? Israel side of the story is never the focus of the left.

    • Dieter Moeckel says:

      10:20am | 08/06/11

      The Marrickville boycott is symbolic. Like propaganda it brings an issue to the surface and exposes an issue.
      Goebbel’s I believe once said, “The English think we have no eggs. We have eggs. We are just to proud to show them.” The double entendre is while talking about food shortages - in German eggs is a synonym for “balls.”
      Thus Marrickville Council is say “If Israel thinks we’ll trade with it. No we won’t even if we have nothing to trade.” Symbolism.

    • bikinis on top says:

      04:10pm | 07/06/11

      Are zions lions? Do they devour all kids not their own?
      Move all zionists to a new homeland from israel to wither Florida USA or Kimberleys Australia.
      Is the Jewish Conspiracy Theory the truth or the fastasy fiction?

    • Tyler says:

      04:15pm | 07/06/11

      I’m confused, do you support illegal settlements in the West Bank and the virtual imprisonment of 1 million people in Gaza?

      If you do, then perhaps you also supported Apartheid? There are striking similarities.

      If not, how do you suggest we pressure Israel to stick to the borders that were mandated by the UN?

      Perhaps we could sign a petition? Or maybe put our faith in the US that they will ignore the geopolitical situation and the lobby groups, and suspend their billions of dollars worth of aid until Israel can stand up to the Ultra-Orthodox groups invading whats left of Palestinian land?

      Opposing South Africa’s apartheid was also “way outside the political mainstream”, in fact the ANC was only recently delisted as a terrorist organisation.

    • Paul says:

      05:13pm | 07/06/11

      The West Bank and Gaza are controlled by the Palestinian Authority. Israeli Arabs have equal access to health, education and voting rights in Israel. Any perceived bias towards the Jewish population within Israel can and has been challenged in Israeli courts with no bias in the outcome. This is clearly not apartheid. Gazans are not “imprisoned” they are embargoed by Israel due to their governments stated aim of destroying Israel, the border between Gaza and Egypt is open. Settlements are another issue altogether. Many Palestinians enjoy a greater standard of living than their counterparts in the region and polling suggests that many also respect the Israeli democracy and pluralism. I can visit a synagogue, mosque, church or Bahai temple in Israel, compare that to Saudi Arabia. The suggestion that Israel is an apartheid state is patently false and only mentioned by those who have no idea what apartheid really meant. The borders stated by the UN were accepted by Israel and rejected by the Arabs, subsequent wars allowed Israel to gain territory from which their neighbours had fired rockets, artillery shells and launched attacks on its civilian populace. Many Israelis would return the land in exchange for peace, but the actions of its neighbours discourages this. Israel does not consider women and children as legitimate targets but its enemies do. Just for a moment consider the bias that is regularly spouted towards Israel in many areas of the media, I suggest that you visit Honest Reporting.com for a different view. A good example is the recent attempts to cross the Israeli border in the Golan Heights, the media immediately assumed the reports of deaths from Syrian media were true, even though that very same Syrian media says nothing about what occurs in that country. A Syrian opposition group claims that all protestors were paid $1000 and the families of those killed received $10,000, the reason being to cause a distraction from what is occurring in Syria, and this is just one example. Please, be objective, reasoned and considered, you have a brain, please use it.

    • papachango says:

      05:27pm | 07/06/11

      I don’t support the illegal settlements, but a bit of perspective please. On one side we have some orthodox settlers building houses where they shouldn’t, but otherwise being non-violent.

      On the other side we have a group sworn to the destruction of every last Jew, who regularly fire rockets into Israel. As loopy as the orthodox Jews are, I’ve never heard of one boarding a bus and blowing himself up to kill as many men women and children as possible.

      Why should Israel open it’s borders to a region that has explicitly sworn to kill them all? Why should they do any business or in any way help with Gaza and Hamas? Though they actually do - they’ll let aid supplies through.

      The crimes perpetuated by the governments of Iran, Saudi, Syria, Yemen, Zimbabwe, Sudan, even China and Russia are far far worse than anything Israel is alleged to have done, but the left just singles out Israel.

      It’s a the region’s only democratic country and they grant Arab Israelis full citizenship and equal rights, it’s the only country in the region where gays don’t get shot or put in jail, yet it’s called an ‘apartheid state’. Appalling.

      The BDS movement is not just anti-Israel but clearly racist and anti-Semitic, because they target anyone who has links to Israel regardless of their own views on the situation.

      By the same logic they should boycott anything remotely connected to China, but good luck with that…

    • Zaf says:

      05:56pm | 07/06/11

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_citizens_of_Israel#Economic_Status

      Inequality in the allocation of public funding for Jewish and Arab needs, and widespread employment discrimination, present significant economic hurdles for Arab citizens of Israel.[201] On the other hand, the Minorities at Risk (MAR) group also states that despite discrimination, Arabs in Israel “are relatively much better off economically than neighboring Arabs.”..

      In February 2007, The New York Times reported that 53 percent of the impoverished families in Israel were Arabs.[206] Since the majority of Arabs in Israel do not serve in the army, they are ineligible for many financial benefits such as scholarships and housing loans…

      Of the 40 towns in Israel with the highest unemployment rates, 36 are Arab towns.[70] According to the Central Bank of Israel statistics for 2003, salary averages for Arab workers are 29% lower than for Jewish workers.[70] Difficulties in procuring employment have been attributed to a comparatively low level of education vis-a-vis their Jewish counterparts, insufficient employment opportunities in the vicinity of their towns, discrimination by Jewish employers, and competition with foreign workers

    • loulou says:

      04:17pm | 07/06/11

      That’s not a good photo of him.

    • fairsfair says:

      04:35pm | 07/06/11

      Every time I see him all I think of is that really old AFL ad from the 90s “I’d like to see that”. Actually, was it even AFL? Was it even him? Who knows. I am as confused on that as I am this entire Palistine vs Isreal debate.

    • Spoon says:

      04:27pm | 07/06/11

      Well you couldn’t exactly boycott Palestinian products now could you? I mean its not as if those lazy leeches actually contribute anything to humanity.

    • A Dose of Reality says:

      06:52pm | 07/06/11

      No, they produce very little.  Might have something to do with being separated from their fields (being an agricultural society) by checkpoints and walls.  The funny thing is - there is a ‘law’ that says if agricultural land is not ‘worked’ for a year - it can be ‘seized’.

    • John the Zombie says:

      11:56pm | 07/06/11

      A dose of reality you do know even the Palestines abondened and left the land that was given to the Jews in the original borders. They worked hard to bring the land to life. With in days of the settling on the land with no guns or tanks, this idea the Palestines were chased away is a lie, over 6 Arab nations including Palastine declared war and threatened to wipe all jews off the map, Just look at the threats that were sent via loud speakers telliing of the on comming slaughter,

      The Jews reacted to save thier lives and with in 6 days destroyed these armies of the Arabs and conquered the lands.

      Do you know the essence of the Islamic terrorists is that they want to go back to the days they were the rulers of the world as since the rise of the british empire and the fall of persian and mughal empires the Arabs have always been on the back foot. Losing to the British (conquest of India and Afghan), Losing to India (1967 and 1971 wars), Losing to the USA (financially), Losing to Isreal /96 day war). They aim to see the glory days of the great Islamic empire that ruled vast lands.

    • papachango says:

      11:00am | 08/06/11

      The best example of this is the state of the art greenhouses in Gaza built by the Israelis and left perfectly intact when they handed it back to the Palestinians, as a kickstart to their economy and self-reliance.

      Within days they were trashed and looted, possibly because they were built by Zionists, or possibly just for the building materials.

      While I have some sympathy for the ordinary people of Palestine and think that they deserve their own state, but they really do not help themselves much, by doing this and electing terrorist governments. Thier situation is largely their own doing.

    • Carolyn Cash says:

      04:30pm | 07/06/11

      How about Marrickville Council focusing on fixing the damned roads instead of foreign policy, which is definitely not their turf?

    • bev says:

      07:37pm | 07/06/11

      Thats the real problem.  While we complain about the run down of local inferstructure the councils ignore it and put up rates to fund more and more “social services” which turn out to have a very solid left wing bleeding heart/feminist slant.

    • southernX says:

      05:08pm | 07/06/11

      What I love about this subject is that, whether or not the Israeli system is defendable (which I do not think it is), if any of the Greens had to live in any of the strongly anti-Israel states, including Palestine, they would quite quickly be screaming to be allowed to live in Israel.  Gay rights? Womens rights? Eco-movements curtailing peoples wealth?  Freedom of worship including new age twaddle? Freedom of speech?  try that in Damascus, Cairo, Bahgdad, Tehran, and see how long you live….

    • Chris T says:

      05:56am | 08/06/11

      lol the Greens would require their the new age crystals.  That is certainly a problem for them.

    • stephen says:

      06:01pm | 07/06/11

      But you forgot Johnson and Johnson, which last week was fined 70 million bucks in a US Supreme Court for fraud. And I could rattle on about other crooked Israeli/Jewish firms, suffice to say these lists, (yours and mine) are next to worthless. (I don’t actually know who should throw the next stone ).

      Jews have as much right to a homeland, including the West Bank, the new settlement areas, with Jerusalem as her Capital, as Palestine has with Gaza and parts of the West Bank.
      The Palestinian ‘right or return’ should be denied.
      That Jews need a homeland is not dependant on what they have produced, or their ‘benefits’ to us or others ; the parcel of land they want is tiny, ) a third of the size of Tasmania).
      Let the Arab/Israelis not living there now go to Jordan for a home.

    • Zip says:

      06:03pm | 07/06/11

      Exactly.  And I’d go one further.  As the threat of Islamic terrorism increases in the future, Israel will be see more and more as the only country in the world that refused to tolerate it. The rest of us are too addled with Western guilt to stand up for our democratic values. Most of the people who try to sympathise with the plight of fundamentalist Islam wouldn’t last 5 minutes in an Islamic state.

    • biff says:

      08:00pm | 07/06/11

      I thought our governments both state and federal were keen to close mental institutions. Why leave Marrickville Council open?

    • Gunther says:

      10:06pm | 07/06/11

      I certainly can not agree that Jewish ‘Settlers’ are all non-violent.  I believe that many have an incredibly arrogant attitude to their Arabic neighbours. Unless these roguish settlers can be made to behave more humanely to the Arabs they are dispossesing, I can’t see any peace coming soon

    • mike j says:

      11:56pm | 07/06/11

      I love it. We should thank Israel for Adidas, a German sportswear company founded by a guy called Adolf in 1948 (the same year Israel declared independence). Why? Because Adidas sponsors the Jerusalem marathon.

      Mitch, even disregarding your basic failure to comprehend commercialism, marketing and the concept of ownership, no-one recognises Jerusalem as a part of Israel. Not even the United States. Jerusalem is corpus separatum administered by the UN. Ergo (according to you), Adidas is owned by the U.N.

      So is it okay if I keep my football boots, dipshit?

      Your examples are comical. Google subsumes an algorithm written by a schoolgirl in Israel, therefore Israel owns Google? Let me give you a better example of logical deduction: you wrote this optimistic piece of Zionist supremacy propaganda, therefore you are an idiot.

    • Jim says:

      09:26am | 08/06/11

      Mike, it’s the BDS campaign which advocates boycotting Addidas, you fool!

    • Dieter Moeckel says:

      10:33am | 08/06/11

      Fair go Mike, No need for “dipshit” or “idiot” that’s offensive.
      The article was satirical - of course there is no way we can boycott to any such extent. But to simply accept Zionism is flawed too and some of the atrocities are lamentable, even for a nation in self defence mode.

    • mike j says:

      08:00pm | 08/06/11

      Seeing the forest for the trees fail x 2.

      “Perhaps some Labor MPs are sympathetic to the goal of removing Zionism in all its forms from their lives”

      Obligatory appeal to Jewish victimhood and non-existent anti-Semitism.

      “Greens Senator-elect Lee Rhiannon ... smugly announced”

      Unnecessary pejorative betrays writer’s subjectivity.

      “I thought it would be worthwhile putting together a handy guide to eliminating Zionist products and services from daily life, in case anyone is still interested in doing so.”

      Honestly… how stupid are anti-Semites?

      “Although I haven’t seen the exact list”

      Well researched.

      “don’t try to get in touch with your friends through instant messaging software instead, because Israelis invented that too.”

      Well, no they didn’t, and what? All of it?

      “This was one of the many medical breakthroughs of Israeli medical scientists ... The fact is, much of the technology that we take for granted ... have some links to Israel. Israeli technological innovation is almost unrivalled across the world, and the inventions of Israeli scientists have delivered transformational change to the way we live ... Apart from the impressive technologies Israelis have developed and sold around the world.”

      Optimistic exaggerations bordering on the delusional.

      “Israel is a legitimate and democratic state.”

      Who are they trying to convince? Us, or themselves? Because they haven’t don’t a very good job convincing the U.N. Also, Israel’s democratic legitimacy is undermined by the fact that it has a state religion.

      I haven’t read the list or seen the site, don’t know the intended consumption of said media, and don’t give a fuck about Marrickville Council’s misguided grandstanding. But the writer is obviously exaggerating and expanding upon this list both to trivialise it, and to try and ingratiate Israel to us; to convince us that Israel is ubiquitous to our lives.

      It’s pathetic, Zionist bullshit, I’m sick of reading it, and you two should wise up.

    • jim morris says:

      12:48am | 08/06/11

      Israel is almost past its use by date. Living there must be like sitting in a leaky dinghy in an ocean of sharks.

    • Chris T says:

      05:47am | 08/06/11

      “you can support rights for Palestinians, that you can support a two-state solution and peace in the Middle-East, without engaging in anti-Israel rhetoric and actions”

      Wrong.  Israel has built a huge Berlin-style wall along the West Bank to shut out the Palestinians.  That is illegal under internation law, and it is apartheid.

      I for one am pleased to hear ideas from outside the “political mainstream”.  Is there something inherently wise or righteous about following the crowd?

    • youdy beaudy says:

      07:00am | 08/06/11

      I have Jewish friends and they are very nice kind people but I suppose that the regime in the Homeland are different people, not nice at all. I always felt that while continuing the complaint about the Nazis trying to destroy their race and their current position with the traditional owners that they are trying to usurp lands from, makes it seem that they may have become Nazis themselves. It’s amazing how a Government can become of the same ilk as what they condemn.

      As far as all the products that are produced by Jewish companies well I don’t know, but I feel that if checked out properly we would find that all of us who have loans would be in debt to Jewish businesses, banks etc. Anyway people if you want to boycott Jewish products then eat Asian foods, much healthier for you and me. Half the crap these companies sell are not needed in a good diet and as far as cosmetics goes there are plenty of other brands to choose from.

      Apart from all the innovative things that were stated by the writer that have furthered the internet, computers etc then I say again that buy a brand that is not produced by the Jewish state. But the concerning thing that wasn’t mentioned in the article was that it was the Jews that developed Nuclear fission and not only that but it has been revealed that the Jewish Zionist state has the second largest store of Nuclear Weapons next to Great Britain and this was revealed to the world a few years ago. They were able to keep that a secret from the world since the 2nd World War. During that period they were able to accuse others of despicable crimes against humanity.

      Although Nuclear Weapons brought the end to the war against Japan it is very scarey to think that all the firepower that can destroy the middle east completely is in the hands of Zionist Nazis. Pretty scary. And the question that should be asked is, ” Would they use them”.

      The lands they occupy illegally are the traditional lands of the Palestinians who want it back then if they are not going to give the lands back then at least treat the traditional owners with the respect they deserve and integrate more fairly.

      The quite large wall they have built to separate the two sides really says it all. They pulled down the Berlin Wall and then shifted it to Israel. Well who is surprised, not me.

    • Rev says:

      08:29am | 08/06/11

      Bet you’ve never mentioned any of this to your Jewish ‘friends’, coward.

      2nd largest store of nuclear weapons behind GB?  What happened to all the other nuclear powers?  And how does this have anything to do with crimes against humanity?  It’s not as though they’ve used the things, though I definitely believe they would if their backs were against the wall (or sea, so to speak).

      The lands they occupy are the traditional lands of the Palestinians?  Since when?  How far back do you want to go?  I suppose you don’t live in Australia on the traditional land of the Aboriginies?

      The stupid thing is, if the Palestinians grew a brain and put down the weapons, the Israelis wouldn’t have excuses for the wall, the settlements, the raids.  The support from the USA would be untenable.  But instead we’ll keep having ‘peace talks’ every few years which will fall over at the drop of a hat.

    • MegaLawlz says:

      01:36pm | 08/06/11

      @Rev Of course this argument could go the other way - if the Israelis gave the Palestinians their home back, the conflict would be over. If their homes hadn’t been taken away in the first place, the Palestinians wouldn’t have a reason to rebel.

      And I think youdy beaudy is differentiating between the average Jew and the people running Israeli politics. I can have Chinese friends without approving of the Maoists. So maybe calling him a coward isn’t so productive.

    • Ellis Wyatt says:

      08:27am | 08/06/11

      An excellent article by Senator Fifield exposing the mungbean munching madness of the Greens Party and their Israel boycott obsession.
      If Israel has Arab citizens, why does the Palestinian Authority have such difficulty in accepting the presence of a few Jewish residents in the West Bank?

    • LiberalsSUCK says:

      09:27am | 08/06/11

      Hey Frontbench Liberal MP who wrote this….why? go and do your job and oppose everything that ever comes your way like the rest of your mates and leave Tutu alone…god the more air sucked up by the vile Liberals the less left for the rest of us…

    • James1 says:

      09:49am | 08/06/11

      ” Coca-cola and any of their brands like Sprite or Fanta are off the list.”

      That is fascinating.  Many Jews boycott Fanta because the Coca-cola company invented it so that they could continue selling products in Nazi Germany without having the name coke associated with it.

    • Dieter Moeckel says:

      11:02am | 08/06/11

      It seems like in politics commentators are either for or against ...
      Until 1948 the Jewish nation consisted of a widely dispersed diaspora ... that is a nation without a homeland.
      Adding to the woes of the Jews in WW2 was that the Allies all had anti-Jewish immigration laws and the Jews actually had no where to go. Hence the WW2 belligerents share some responsibility for the Jewish tragedy.
      The Brits and French “created” Israel giving the Jews a homeland in the modern world to ameliorate their guilt. Remember the Allies controlled the middle east after WW2 and “shared it out” among peoples.
      Now consider this:  What if all the “British” peoples were to be returned to Britain ... hence a return of Jews to a place the size of Israel is completely unthinkable. Thus the need to expand against Arab resistance.
      Israel and Jews are clever people not adverse to making the best of western guilt as propaganda and so they should. It’s up the the recipient of propaganda to analyse and pick the grain from the mouse shit.
      Had Israel been allocated a sensible amount of land with potential to accommodate a multicultural people with a multicultural government perhaps things might have been different.
      The Jewish - Arab problem is of Western making and will eventually need to be solve by the West… but shit it’s a problem. Arabs don’t hate the Jews; they hate the imposition of a nation on them by the West. Like Iraq is a horse constructed by a Western committee with Kuwaite expropriated, Like Brunei a British Vassaldom like a pimple on a Malaysian enclave in Indonesia Borneo and Timor Leste will be a suppurating ulcer in the Indonesian archipelago so Israel is an unnatural imposition into the middle east.
      I don’t know the answer - but the Marrickville boycott is a symbolic gesture, laughable but a gesture all the same and may be an expression of dissatisfaction with Israel.

    • annie says:

      11:04am | 08/06/11

      Very well said, Mr Fifield.  I was wavering at the “Zionist-free life” line (its impact may have been exacerbated by the headline they gave you) but am glad I stuck with you.  Excellent article.  It’s only unfortunate to see that a lot of the commenters seem to have missed your point.

    • NGS says:

      11:24am | 08/06/11

      And every single scrap of food you eat or drink in this country has an Israeli input, from the irrigation drippers, filters, fertilisers,pumps, injectors, piping,controllers and myriad other devices, So Marrickville Council should starve themselves now, as they really are village idiots

    • SapperK9 says:

      12:12pm | 08/06/11

      I enjoyed this, needed.  Something the author forgot to mention; that should one of these councillors or their families need treatment for cancer, do not use any nuclear scanning device, CAT, MRI etc., for these were invented by Israeli Jews…

    • youdy beaudy says:

      12:29pm | 08/06/11

      Well Rev, my reply to you in calling me a coward is to meet with you somewhere and work it out. Name your weapon. You are obviously a dickhead.

      Also Kuwait was given over as well to them and that’s why Iraq wanted it back and subsequently the invasion took place.

      Also, everyone talks about anti-semitic. Well i always thought and have read that semitics is to do with language and there were many of them in the past, aramaic being one predominant from the past times.

      Jews and Arabs all come from the semetic language types and even tho they don’t like it they have a common Father of their races Abraham. So to me they are all related, so killing and stealing from each other is the same as committing crimes against you own families.

      I don’t believe that the zionists want peace. Too hard from a Religious group that preaches that same peace in it’s doctrine and can’t even live up to the words of their prophets. I think the so called ten commandments has been crapped apon by people who claim to be the chosen ones and the rest of us are nothing. No wonder they can’t get it together with all this peace in our time business and Religion has always been a good business.

      These races of people have obvious mental problems. Maybe it’s bad genetics or uncle dad syndrome. And as far as your smartarse comment about, ” Why don’t I say it to my Jewish friends, well, i have and they have no problem with my point of view and many agree with me and are disgusted with what is happening over there, so you can shove your opinion where the sun don’t shine but you’ll probably have to get your gay friend to remove himself from that particular orifice first. There’s something about some of you Kiwis that needs urgent medical attention. May I suggest a good shrink for you.

    • papachango says:

      01:07pm | 08/06/11

      This individual is a disgusting racist who is posting explicity anti-semitic comments (anti-Jewish if you want to quibble about the original definition of semitic people including Arabs), and threatening violence.

      I’m all for free speech but would have thought that for their ownsake, News Ltd would be moderating the explicitly racist comments like this one.

      Go away sir and seek professional help for your hatred, racism and dreams of violence.

    • Outraged says:

      05:19pm | 08/06/11

      Amen papachango!...er, I mean Shalom!

      People can’t just say anything they want! If only we could lock these people away…put them into work camps…maybe assign them with a number so we can isolate them until we figure out a “Final Solution” as to what to do with these anti-Semites!

    • grumpy old man says:

      01:36pm | 08/06/11

      we should all butt out and let Israel and Palestine sort out their own problems. Much of the posturing by both sides is created to get media attention and/or money from foreign govts. Its not as if the foreign Govts have a good track record at helping other countries!

    • youdy beaudy says:

      02:51pm | 08/06/11

      and Papachango, in reply to you. Well if you were capable of reading between the lines you might have seen that my reply was light hearted and not threatening at all. Most normal people would not have worried about it and seen it in a more light hearted way.

      Seeing that you obviously know all about it and taking into consideration your obviously very precious nature you might consider that the Zionists in writing and doing evil things to the Arabs might also see their actions as anti-semetic also. It seems very one eyed to me.

      As far as I go i have no hatred for Jews, but i have surely a dislike of the Nazi type of rule wherever it occurs. I have no hatred for Arabs either. I don’t care what they do or what they invent but I certainly am like many who are sick of the constant whinging that goes on with some races that unfortunately were victimized in warfare, not trying to be insensitive at all. Who for instance cries for the Vietnamese, the Cambodians, and other races who underwent the same or in many cases more horrible crimes against them. Where are their voices heard. One race of people have not only got a lot of attention, and so be it, but many others are still suffering from similar carnage.

      No papochango, you’re not for free speech but I note that you always have your opinions displayed on here. I personally am sick of all this Middle Eastern rubbish. I mean peace is really quite easy to have, it’s just a change in the point of view and then carrying that point of view out. Not a hard thing reallly. The Jewish race are not the only race of people in this world but have received a lot of sympathy and that’s perfectly understandable but the world has moved on, unfortunately, some of us haven’t.

      I had a Jewish friend once, a nice old bloke, very eccentric and he was a businessman. Everyday I would receive emails putting down Arabs and some pretty horrible insulting things were sent to me. I wrote to him and complained about it but it turned out that the emails were sent to me by his staff members and not himself. So he was upset that he had lost a friend.

      I wrote back to him and said that as far as I was concerned it did not affect our friendship but I think he was upset and I haven’t heard from him since on email. So there you go old chap, while you go on about me it’s all happening on the emails.

      Now i am sure that many people who are on email receive many negative images about Arabs, putting them down just because some of their countrymen act in bad ways. There is fault on both sides. The Arabian people have given the world a lot, things such as our Mathematics and language. Great Art treasures such as the ones stolen by the american troops and the mosiacs etc etc.

      Anyway, I have to be off now and get on with the racism and hatred that I am falsely accused of. And thanks to News Ltd for printing my diabolical diatribe. They obviously don’t think the way you do papochango, or whatever you call yourself in real life. I will be watching for your next opinion to pop up and give my opinion on what you write. That’s freedom of speech for you, hey!!.

    • papachango says:

      04:27pm | 08/06/11

      ...you called Jews ‘Zionist nazis’, and later said ‘These races of people have obvious mental problems. Maybe it’s bad genetics or uncle dad syndrome.’ Sorry, but how is that not racist?

      It is an unacceptable viliifaction of an entire group of people. Imagine the (understandable) furore if someone had claimed the entire Arab or African race had mental problems.

      In some areas that statement is actually illegal - e.g. here in Vic, if you said that in a public forum you could be prosecuted under racial / religious vilification laws. I personally don’t agree with those laws, and provided you’re not actually inciting violence against Jewish or Israeli people I think you should be entitled to your opinion.

      But I’m also entitled to my opinion that you’re a racist Jew hater. Saying ‘some of my best friends are Jewish’ doesn’t change that.

    • youdy beaudy says:

      05:24pm | 08/06/11

      Papachango, there is a vast difference between Jews and Zionists. Even the Jews would not be happy with the Zionists that run Israel and their negative policies. I know this is true. There are many Jews living in Israel who are pro a better deal for Palestinians.

      I have a feeling that you are Jewish yourself and that’s why you feel insulted. You don’t need to presume that all Jews have your opinion or agree with it. I am Anglo Irish and you remember that it was our armies that freed the Jews and destroyed the Nazi regime.

      If a jewish person insulted me I can assure you that I would not have the benefit to run and hide behind the words anti Anglo Irish. It’s different strokes for different folks. The Jewish are supposed to be intelligent people but it’s obviously not intelligent to continue on taking away the legitimate rights from Palestinian people. One would think that the concept and application of pay back would have been resigned to the dustbin of history by now. But it hasn’t.

      As far as being prosecuted under the racial religious so called laws, well i’m sure that if the Punch Moderator would have thought that then they wouldn’t have printed my comment as they would have deemed it offensive and they obviously didn’t and I know that as I have written other comments which haven’t been printed for that reason. So all i have to say is, have a nice day.

    • stephen says:

      08:36pm | 08/06/11

      The Allied Armies defeated Nazism, and the Jews owe us nothing : we were not entirely ignorant of their plight, but the magnitude surprized us.
      It’s attitudes like yours, : that “The Jews are supposed to be intelligent”...
      which leaves the rebuttal of true believes solely in the court of ‘special pleading’, (an overused description, yet here it’s special).
      If Jews are indeed more successful than others, then that is most likely their only and best defensive mechanism, i.e. the ‘nurtures’ way of creating a lofty and inpregnable tower of respect.
      This has been forced upon them by fifteen centuries of curses, death and neglect.
      So back off.

    • papachango says:

      04:42pm | 17/06/11

      Not that it matters, but I’m not Jewish and have no Jewish ancestry whatsoever (that I’m aware of). I just can’t stand racist people who state that a certain race ‘has mental problems’.

      Have a nice day.

    • Servaas says:

      02:04am | 09/06/11

      I came across this Bob Dylan song the other day, the older folk and Dylan fans would probably be familiar with it:

      Neighborhood Bully
      by Bob Dylan
      From the album Infidels

      Well, the neighborhood bully, he’s just one man
      His enemies say he’s on their land
      They got him outnumbered about a million to one
      He got no place to escape to, no place to run
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      The neighborhood bully just lives to survive
      He’s criticized and condemned for being alive
      He’s not supposed to fight back, he’s supposed to have thick skin
      He’s supposed to lay down and die when his door is kicked in
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      The neighborhood bully been driven out of every land
      He’s wandered the earth an exiled man
      Seen his family scattered, his people hounded and torn
      He’s always on trial for just being born
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      Well, he knocked out a lynch mob, he was criticized
      Old women condemned him, said he should apologize.
      Then he destroyed a bomb factory, nobody was glad
      The bombs were meant for him. He was supposed to feel bad
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      Well, the chances are against it and the odds are slim
      That he’ll live by the rules that the world makes for him
      ’Cause there’s a noose at his neck and a gun at his back
      And a license to kill him is given out to every maniac
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      He got no allies to really speak of
      What he gets he must pay for, he don’t get it out of love
      He buys obsolete weapons and he won’t be denied
      But no one sends flesh and blood to fight by his side
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      Well, he’s surrounded by pacifists who all want peace
      They pray for it nightly that the bloodshed must cease
      Now, they wouldn’t hurt a fly. To hurt one they would weep
      They lay and they wait for this bully to fall asleep
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      Every empire that’s enslaved him is gone
      Egypt and Rome, even the great Babylon
      He’s made a garden of paradise in the desert sand
      In bed with nobody, under no one’s command
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      Now his holiest books have been trampled upon
      No contract he signed was worth what it was written on
      He took the crumbs of the world and he turned it into wealth
      Took sickness and disease and he turned it into health
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      What’s anybody indebted to him for?
      Nothin’, they say. He just likes to cause war
      Pride and prejudice and superstition indeed
      They wait for this bully like a dog waits to feed
      He’s the neighborhood bully

      What has he done to wear so many scars?
      Does he change the course of rivers? Does he pollute the moon and stars?
      Neighborhood bully, standing on the hill
      Running out the clock, time standing still
      Neighborhood bully

    • SapperK9 says:

      12:45pm | 09/06/11

      Yup, and the neighbourhood bully tried it on in 1948, and lost!  Been sulking ever since…

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter