Australian Story is customarily sympathetic to its subjects. This is natural; they’re its stars. Not with the latest episode on Malcolm Turnbull.

The only problem for Turnbull out of this show is that it doesn’t change anything but underlines, with the mother of all magic markers, the existing public perception that his ruthless drive and ambition will lead him to tread over others in pursuit of his goals.

Bad timing for Malcolm, because tomorrow the Auditor-General will publish a report on whether Kevin Rudd’s office made representations on behalf of Brisbane car dealer John Grant - a friend of Rudd’s - to Treasury and, if so, whether the contact was appropriate. It’s unlikely to contain anything damaging for the Government, and ministers have signalled they intend to try lighting a fire around Turnbull, arguing he has no credibility after calling for the Prime Minister to resign over the matter.

You can watch the program on the ABC website here. In short, it focuses on his family story to explain his drive. Talking about how he was affected by his mother leaving his father for another man. “If I look back, you know, perhaps I was thinking to myself, you know, if ... even if unconsciously, if I work harder and do better, will she come back?”

It turns to Turnbull the politician. Proving once again that journalists who are out and about are more likely to end up putting themselves in the right place at the right time, Australian Story was handed a corker when the utegate / OzCar / fake email scandal unfolded in around them as they filmed in the Opposition Leader’s office. It made good TV.

The analysis of Turnbull from commentators - mainly from the ABC’s Chris Uhlmann but also from News Ltd’s Malcolm Farr - was tough. You can see it on the show but as an example here’s Uhlmann discussing the treatment of Godwin Grech, the Treasury official who testified before a Senate committee that he recalled an email from the PM’s office about John Grant.

... Godwin Grech was someone who has been giving good information to the Liberal Party for a long time, but he was someone that Malcolm Turnbull was willing to sacrifice to ensure that the Prime Minister was badly damaged or destroyed. And that struck me as very, very cold-blooded.

This could be the start of a difficult week for Turnbull. We’ll be watching.

7.45pm: The Rudd Government is turning up the heat on Malcolm Turnbull over his handling of the OzCar affair - one minister today said his position was “untenable”. (Story extract below.)

Tonight, ABC TV’s Australian Story will focus on Turnbull and look at what went on in his office on that spectacular day in Parliament last month, when an email upon which the Opposition based its attack on the Government was revealed to be a fraud.

Join us here to discuss the show as it unfolds and give your verdict.

This from AAP tonight:

The Rudd government is increasing pressure on Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull over the faked OzCar email with a key report into the affair due for release on Tuesday.

The auditor-general’s report, ordered by Kevin Rudd in June, will reveal whether the offices of the prime minister and the treasurer were used to make representations on behalf of a car dealer friend of Mr Rudd’s, John Grant.

The prime minister said on Monday he had not seen a draft of the report but said Mr Turnbull had many questions to answer over the affair.

Mr Turnbull used evidence to a Senate inquiry by the Treasury official in charge of OzCar, Godwin Grech, which suggested Mr Rudd sought special treatment for a friend, to call for the resignations of Mr Rudd and Treasurer Wayne Swan.

But the evidence, an email alleged to be from the prime minister’s office to Mr Grech, was found several days later by federal police to be a fake.

Human Services and Financial Services Minister Chris Bowen says Mr Turnbull has had several weeks to come up with evidence on the role both he and senior Liberal, Senator Eric Abetz, played in the affair.

“Now, unless he’s backed those claims up with evidence to the auditor-general and unless the auditor-general makes a similar finding, then Mr Turnbull’s position is now untenable,” Mr Bowen told reporters in Canberra.

Chris Uhlmann, a rising star of the ABC News team who broke key developments in the utegate affair last month and is now joining the 7.30 Report

12 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • cat says:

      11:08pm | 03/08/09

      Regardless of the email, there were faxes etc sent to the treasurer’s home.  Somehow this never gets mentioned. I’m sure there are plenty of small businesses that would love the treasurer to show an interest in them.

    • Blah says:

      11:19pm | 03/08/09

      In relation to the ABC’s latest edition of ‘Australian Story’ featuring none other than the unsavoury, untrustworthy, self serving wannabe PM, Malcolm Turnbull. Honestly, they (the Turnbulls and the Liberal party members appearing on the program) really shouldn’t attempt acting as well as politics because they are all incredibly bad at it. This program was a load of the most obvious propaganda I have witnessed and am outraged that the public broadcaster let this contrived bias go to air. How far will Malcolm go to progress his own share portfolio? After all that is why he is in politics isn’t it! - Lest we forget the Gunns Pulp Mill decision - This program is a desperate and deliberate attempt to pervert the course of justice. I was under the impression that Australian Story was an impartial, honest, lament about members of the community who have a story of significance to contribute. Maybe the show should be renamed “Australian Advertorial”?

    • Shane From Melbourne says:

      11:28pm | 03/08/09

      Look the Liberal Party is as almost useless as the Australian Labor Party but surely the ALP have more pressing matters to attend to, than to beat up on Malcolm Turnbull?

    • Geoff McQueen says:

      12:17am | 04/08/09

      I wonder if the report from the AG tomorrow will identify who created and sent the bait/honeypot, oh, sorry, I meant, email from within Treasury?

      It struck me as incredible just how poor Turnbull’s office’s IT advice is. Forging an email isn’t a case of changing the text before hitting forward. Forging email headers on a system from within Treasury is pretty serious work, and with such a controlled environment, the electronic trail would lead right to the source.

      I wonder if the source will be Labour or Liberal? Because for one thing, we know the email didn’t send itself.

      Will the media cover this angle at all?

    • Charlie says:

      12:51am | 04/08/09

      What sort of morons do the Liberal party employ? For god’s sake what sort of educated person has to look up what the word “concocted” means?

      The thing I always love about these inside looks at politcal parties is all the party hangers on in the background. It’s like every dweeby kid that ever got bullied in High School ends up involved in politics. There is definitely some serious psychological issue there.

    • stephen says:

      01:06am | 04/08/09

      Everyone keeps saying how smart a guy Turnbull was during his stellar business career.  How long then will it take hi, or the Liberal Party to work out that the smarmy, insincere, and fundamentally unlikeable person he comes across as will simply never, ever, wash with the voters?

    • Old Clive says:

      07:52am | 04/08/09

      Lets face the facts, all political parties are good at coverups, don’t you worry about that, the Australian Lying Party is as good as if not better at it than the Libs, they have eons of Union policy behind them. If they all spent as much time on doing something good for the country they might be worth the money they get out of our pockets. As far as I can see none of them can lay down straight in bed or should that be lie straight in bed.

    • iansand says:

      09:49am | 04/08/09

      Did anyone else pick up that he inherited that house in the Hunter from his father?  Just how long did the oft repeated claim of a childhood on struggle street last?

    • stephen curle says:

      11:16am | 04/08/09

      This egocentric wanna be Prime Minister will stop at nothing to gain personal power…the way Godwin Grech was thrown to the sharks after they used him in the office of Turnbull’s wife is disgraceful,this man Turnbull is ruthless..untrustworthy..and quite frankly not the sharpest knife in a politician’s draw, just one faux-pas after an other in this persons political journey.

    • Bluey72 says:

      12:03pm | 04/08/09

      The thing is that Malcolm and Lucy Turnbull owned ozemail and then webcentral. They have the biggest IT businesses in the country in their past business portfolio and they end up wondering how to concoct an email.  There was no security breach here- it is called delete and type or cut and paste.

      I think Malcolm wanted to showcase he and his family and he did that allright

    • DJG says:

      12:48pm | 04/08/09

      Yes he did showcase his family. The Adams or Munster families would get my first preference vote before Malcom.

    • ciweelpibrice says:

      09:17pm | 01/12/10

      <a >best colon cleanser
      </a>
      who wants a colone cleanse <a >does colon cleansing work
      </a>
      the best colon cleanse<a >colon cleansing reviews
      </a>
      you are a colon cleanse<a >colon cleanse
      </a>
      <a >parasite colon cleanse
      </a>

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

Ugh. RT @Colvinius: Lord Monckton urging mining owners to buy up papers & TV stations for political influence http://t.co/xRUgErn5

ToryShepherd

@JohnHillMP it's a spectacular part of the world

ToryShepherd

RT @JohnHillMP: “@ToryShepherd: Star of Greece #happinesshttp://t.co/rPrvB4sL” Welcome to my electorate. #enjoy!

ToryShepherd

Star of Greece #happinesshttp://t.co/faYa2ZWq

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Gillard’s mapping a route but will probably still be routed

Gillard’s mapping a route but will probably still be routed

Julia Gillard and her advisers believe they can see a narrow path to victory for Labor at the next federal…

Kevin 2.0 could be better. Or it could be even KRuddier.

Kevin 2.0 could be better. Or it could be even KRuddier.

As key moments go, it ranked with Gough Whitlam’s dramatic dismissal speech branding Malcolm Fraser…

Working women need to escape the grog bog

Working women need to escape the grog bog

Can you hear a faint sort of teeth-grindy sound? No it’s not the rats in the roof gnawing the wires…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Other stuff to be angry about today (with video)

DOB says:

For the last 2 summers my local beach - which is a kid's beach really (but it has a nice cafe - thats my excuse) - has been overrun by jetskis. So when I go off for an idyllic morning of sun and sand I might as well just go down to an industrial plant and soak up the noise and fumes. My area is a bit… [read more]

From: Match of the century!

Pete says:

Since when has Australia been a land full of whinging, whiney and just plain annoying people. Seriously, we have to take a long hard look at ourselves and notice that we have it pretty damn good and that instead of whinging about every single article ever written we could perhaps be happy and enjoy things.… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

No wuckin forries. These nuckin futs are tuckin fops

Well, puck me with a fitchfork. The F-word is apparently an acceptable part of Australian speech. That’s… Read more

147 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter