UPDATE 10.30am: The author is in a panic following the release of a study this morning that showed watching television can result in early death. As a confessed hypochondriac who persistently frets about dying he is now considering his future and will discuss his position tomorrow on The Punch.

I love television. Absolutely, bloody love it. And I have a real distrust of people who say, “I don’t really watch television”. I’m convinced that I detect a smug sneer as they say it.

My Pavlovian reaction to anyone who says this is to immediately picture the person – and I swear this is true – in a wood-panelled drawing room, sat with their partner in high-backed leather arm chairs, either side of a big old-fashioned radiogram, smiling serenely at each other. Sometimes the female of the pair is engaged in some sort of embroidery.

I have no idea where this mental picture comes from, but I guess it may be some weird visualisation of my inverted snobbery trying to puncture their television condescension at the first whiff I get. (Not sure what this all means psychologically, but I’m sure Dr Phil would know).

I tense and wait for them to follow “I don’t really watch television” with something like “because I’m far more cultured than you obviously are and have better things to do with my time, but if you’re content to waste hours watching brainless drivel on the box then that’s your funeral”.

Admittedly, I’ve never had someone say this to me, but I can just see the thought forming behind his or her righteous (non-square) eyes. The slight variant is “we don’t really watch television”, rather than “I don’t”. This is even worse, as it implies that my whole family are as lowbrow as I am; sat with me on the sofa like we’re The Simpsons, while they’re out at the ballet or saving kids in the Sudan, or whatever it is that’s keeping them away from the TV.

Finally, the hardest of all to take is “I/we don’t really like television”. At which point I think, “Well, I don’t really like you”.

I understand that some television can be mind numbing. Obviously if you’re watching endless re-runs of Hogan Knows Best, The Nanny and Murder She Wrote, then you’re probably in a bad place emotionally. Or you very soon will be. But superb quality still remains on the small screen; comedy, drama and factual documentaries are as good today as they’ve ever been. For every crappy reality show or Friends-wannabe sitcom that pops up, there are The Sopranos, or The Office, or The West Wing.

Dramas such as The Wire, Mad Men and Wire in the Blood are easily as good as anything you can see at the cinema. Better, in fact. Comedy such as Extras, Peep Show and Curb Your Enthusiasm continue to push boundaries hilariously.

I usually assume that “I don’t watch television” actually translates as: “I’ve never really watched television”. Adults who don’t drink normally either tried it briefly and didn’t like it, or drank copious amounts until they decided it was time to knock it on the head. I figure with TV it’s the former rather than the latter analogy.

That being the case have these non-watchers never experienced groundbreaking drama series like Twin Peaks or Brideshead Revisited? Never laughed at Seinfeld or Fawlty Towers? Never seen a David Attenborough wildlife doco or the 7-up series of programs?

That’s not to mention news and sport. Do non-watchers only read newspapers? Have they never witnessed the fall of the Berlin Wall in moving images? What about the Tianamen Square protests or 911? Aloisi’s penalty? Cathy’s Olympic gold or Warnie’s Gatting ball? Have they only heard mention of these events or read about them?

With Foxtel and the advent of IQ (possibly the greatest invention of the last decade) I’m no longer beholden to schedules and my viewing time goes a lot further. Okay, so the video recorder initially helped with that, but who fiddles around taping or even DVDing stuff these days?

(Although bizarrely I WILL watch a movie ‘live’ on TV even when I own the DVD for some reason, but that’s beside the point). The thing is, these days you can edit your TV viewing with ease. Yes, there’s a lot of crap on cable, but you don’t have to sit through it. You can even fast forward through adverts. An hour of TV these days might have taken you over two hours in the past.

Frankly I’ve always watched a lot of television anyway. When I read in the papers ‘horrific’ stats that kids are watching 2.5 hours of TV a day, I think what are they doing with the other 21.5? Maybe it’s the fact I was an only child brought up in the cold of England, but I could average five hours a day no problem.

On a very wet February Saturday in the late seventies I may have done 15 hours in a stretch depending on whether I was allowed to stay up for Match of the Day. I don’t think it affected me adversely, other than the fact I draw comfort from having the TV on “in the background” while I’m doing things. As an adult the first things I do in the morning are put the kettle on, put the computer on and put the TV on in a swift trilogy. I always flick on the box within five minutes of getting home. But when people come round to visit I obviously turn it… er, down.

Even now, I probably average a couple of hours of TV a day. Last night I watched the last half hour of The Secret Millionaire (the one where his son went along too, very weepy), an episode of Seinfeld (when George tries to postpone his wedding to Susan), and the last hour of Pulp Fiction (I’d turned out the lights to go to bed and was only going to watch five minutes, but got hooked).

I guess one implication of opting out, is that TV watchers are missing out on culture, or getting a watered-down imitation. But certainly in England TV shapes culture more than any other form of art or entertainment. Not too many of us are getting down The Old Vic to watch the latest Richard the 3rd, or catching the Bolshoi when it’s in town, we’re more likely discussing Shameless or Life on Mars. Yes, Eastenders and X-Factor dominate the ratings, but quality shows with true artistic and socio-political relevance can still find a voice, and they document the nation in a way that only literature can perhaps match. I think in Australia TV does this less so, but you could argue that Masterchef reflected the face of modern Australia better than almost anything made in the entertainment sphere in the last decade.

The other thing perhaps implied is that I’m missing out on doing other things. I’m not sure what non-watchers are squeezing into their schedules, but in the last month I’ve been to the cinema five times (admittedly, mostly kids films). I’ve read seven books: Blood’s A Rover by James Ellroy, Have A Little Faith by Mitch Albom, Nine Dragons by Michael Connolly, The Lost Symbol by Dan Brown, King of the Cross by Mark Dapin, Winter’s Bone by Daniel Woodrell and Nobody Move by Denis Johnson (and yes, I am also trying to prove my cultural credentials again with this list). I have a busy job; three young children; I’ve been to the beach and the pool a lot; tidied up the garden, been to the zoo and even baked a pie to get rid of the turkey. Oh, and I phone my mum every Sunday.

In summary: a) I have a very full and culturally diverse life, b) Yes, I can be lowbrow in some areas of my entertainment world, but not exclusively, and not to the detriment of cinema and literature, and c) I watch at least two hours of TV a day. So next time you sneer at me with your “I don’t really watch television”, please don’t think you’re a better person than me.

Or perhaps I’m just reading too much into the phrase…

Don’t miss: Get The Punch in your inbox every day

78 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Claire says:

      05:28am | 12/01/10

      No need to be so defensive, dear! I fall into the “hardly watch the damn thing” category myself but that’s because I can rarely find anything worth giving my attention to, other than the news.

      As for IQ - I had a free 3-month trial of our rural equivalent, MyStar, and used it precisely twice. The first attempted recording session failed. We did watch the second, a Disney film my daughter particularly wanted to see. The MyStar box has now been banished. I certainly wouldn’t pay for it.

      My family time - debriefing from the day that’s just gone, discussing the next, just generally shooting the breeze - is too precious to spend in effective isolation staring at the telly, unless there is something specific that’s been identified in advance as worth watching (and then the box goes off straight afterwards). That’s not meant to sound smug/self-righteous/snobby, that’s just the way my family is. Oh, and it was the same when we lived in the UK too ... each to their own, I suppose. Nice piece, though.

    • Claire says:

      05:30am | 12/01/10

      PS I am bloody useless at embroidery.

    • Margaret Gray says:

      05:51am | 12/01/10

      “...And I have a real distrust of people who say, “I don’t really watch television”...”

      I don’t really ‘watch’ television.

      And I don’t embroider either.

      I gave up on television a long time ago.  The contemtuous disdain television executives have for their audiences drove me away and I gladly ran.

      Continually programming bad shows, shifting timeslots, endless ads and promos were the culprit.

      That and the fact that Pretty Woman or Happy Gilmore were repeated every two weeks.

      Now when I want to ‘watch’ something I watch whatever I want, when I want.

      Endless quality television chosen by me.  For me.

      I have just finished the 3rd season of Mad Men and the 6th of Entourage.

      So what’s next?  So much chioce.

      I know for sure it won’t be Motorway Hospital Border Animal Zoo hosted by Sonya Koch-Minogue and Grant Newton-Columbaris.

      Television stations are dead if they continue to treat their viewers the way they do.

      But looking at their audience cume…it seems they already are.

      Has the newspaper experience taught them nothing?

      Quality television is everywhere Rob…and equally as rivetting as a good book (Think OZ or The Wire).

      Sadly most of it is not actually ON television and that is the real problem is it not?

    • Rosie says:

      06:51am | 12/01/10

      I for one, loved this post and agree with it wholeheartedly. Like film, television is an art form, with exciting opportunities for storytelling. I’ve read that 2005 onward has been a new Golden Age for TV- I would have to agree, the writing on shows like Dexter, Supernatural, 30 Rock and Glee is stellar.  Unfortunately, i agree with Margaret in that most of the really great television isn’t actually being aired on Australian TV. Channel Ten, for instance, screws around with its quality genre shows all the time- taking them on and off air, letting other shows run overtime and shuffling the time slot. But let’s not talk about that, thinking about it makes me mad.

      Re. Claire’s comment about family time- I don’t know if I believe that TV can be isolating. My family and I have certain shows that we’ll sit down to watch together especially. It’s really fun to enjoy them together and discuss the episode during the commercial breaks and afterward. It makes what can often be a private pleasure (like devouring a box set on your own) more of a communal activity. Even the mind numbing programs can be good for laughs.

    • Dave Sag says:

      06:54am | 12/01/10

      Watch TV, and even bought a wonderful low-energy LCD flat screen to do so, but I can’t watch TV littered with commercials.  It’s just horrible.  Luckily for me there is iTunes.  For about AU$2 I can just buy the episodes of Lost, Mad Men, The Wire, Entourage, Underbelly etc etc all in glorious HD (which is so much better to look at on my TV than DVD) and without any of those infuriating commercials.  And I can watch it when I want to, not when the TV station chooses to screen it.  (Or not if the station decides to screen something else, or get the episodes out of order, or whatever crime against quality drama they think up).

      As a real plus I can move the shows over to my iPhone and watch them when travelling.  I have seen all of Dexter, minus the last 4 episodes of Series 3 on planes.

      So yay for TV and yay for iTunes and the internet freeing us from the tyranny of TV Stations.

    • Dave C says:

      06:56am | 12/01/10

      Agree totally I love TV. As I thought of pay tv as an extra expense we have instead got digital with extra channels 7Two Go and SBS2. I love the intellectual stuff such as SBS history docos (always about Nazi Germany or Nazis I swear they are obsessed) but I also like old comedies such as The Nanny Seinfeld Get Smart on Go and my secret TV love are the trashy reality shows that are so incredibly bad they are funny if you dont take them seriously (Cheaters and Tool academy) of and of course the Cricket and my wife loves the tennis.

      I am currently on holiday until January 27th so yeah TV is wonderful and to all those non tv watching snobs let us tv watchers enjoy ourselves.

    • Old Bert says:

      06:57am | 12/01/10

      Obviously Rob, you’ve written your own Bio in the third person here. Oh well,  good luck at The Punch. Not a lot to write about this time of year., so why not give TV programs, an in inciteful subject if any, a go. Prof Dunstan, has written about watching TV in the journal Circulation, and the ‘statistic’ that early death can result from TV gazing overload, for lots of reasons.  Yes, there are some good programs on the box, and you’ve named a couple of them, my preference being only the few quality ones on the ABC and SBS. The rest being largely trash TV on the other networks. I’ve taken to recording some of the funnier commercial advertising, to make a CD, and replaying the whole series of Yes Minister, the politicians’ guide for policy formation if ever there was one. You’ll notice it’s still being used today. Humor I believe is one of the answers to TV lobotomy. A new year’s resolution to not sit and watch a lot of tv, could be to stand up. But, bring in a new broom and if you’re not careful you’ll find you’ve thrown the baby out with the bathwater. If you change horses midstream, next thing you know you’re up the creek without a paddle. Finally, in conclusion, let me say just this.

    • Claire says:

      07:22am | 12/01/10

      @Rosie - I agree that watching TV together can be good/enriching/fun but by definition, if you’re engaging with a TV screen rather than with another person, the tendency is always there to slip away into your own thoughts and reactions.

      I don’t have a partner, “only” children(!), so the fact we’re of different ages and have differing tastes makes the isolationist risk even higher. But as I said, that’s just my family dynamic, not a hard-and-fast principle. I certainly would never state baldly that watching TV turns your brains to mush. (My parents would and do, but they are in their 80s and belong very much to the “This is London” era - hey, my mother even used to do embroidery.)

    • cclambie says:

      07:26am | 12/01/10

      I have to agree with @Margret Gray, I don’t really watch TV either.  In fact it has is always a fun pleasure when I go somewhere where the television is on and I can see the ads, as watching them once is often amusing.

      I appreciate your article, as I am always looking for recommendations of shows to watch, but I would never watch them on the commercial or cable stations.  It is a complete waste of time (and money).

      I much prefer to watch them at my leisure, with no ads.  I of course do watch them on a television, but most people when they say “I don’t really watch television” are not referring to the machine itself, but rather the dribble the free to air stations put on, or the slightly better, but still rubbish on the cable stations.

    • Steve Smith says:

      07:31am | 12/01/10

      Funny how most of the great shows mentioned so far are not readily available on Free to Air TV. This really shows just how out of sync our network channels are. They aired the Curb Your Enthusiasm episodes repackaged as “Seinfeld Reunions”, when the episodes were simply taking the piss out of reunion shows!

      Until there is respect for the viewers, including the fact that a show on at 8:30pm wont start until maybe 8:40-8:50 (depending on what show they are trying to make you accidently watch), I will continue to source my TV from the Internet.

    • Andrew Goff says:

      07:40am | 12/01/10

      “But certainly in England TV shapes culture more than any other form of art or entertainment”... but then: “Yes, Eastenders and X-Factor dominate the ratings, but quality shows with true artistic and socio-political relevance can still find a voice”.

      Sorry mate, you can’t have it both ways. TV is shaping culture, and it is “Home and Away” and “A Current Affair” not “The West Wing” and “Curb Your Enthusiasm” that is doing it.

      I love some TV Shows… but I’ll grab them on DVD when they get released. The degrading and often offensive tripe dished up by the networks has pushed me from the “love TV” category, and once I had stopped watching the idiot box my quality of life improved dramatically.

    • Nola James says:

      08:15am | 12/01/10

      The people who admit that they watch TV (I watch TV) can be broken down into two catergories. People who watch low-brow (deal or no deal, wipe-out) or high brow (The West Wing, Mad Men). My favourite is when people SWEAR they only ever watch the SBS news, but are secret fans of A Current Affair, but would just never admit it for fear of intellectual retrubution (even though they can get away with it on a technicality and say its for work related research purposes).

      Like myself. Oops.

    • Brando says:

      08:18am | 12/01/10

      The internet has allowed me to watch the pick of the world’s TV. I can watch what I want when I want to watch it and without commercials. Downloading may be illegal but it’s the biggets threat ever to commercial TV.

    • Rob Pegley says:

      08:34am | 12/01/10

      I’ve just heard on the radio this morning that a recent study has shown that prolonged watching of television can result in premature death. They didn’t show that people who watched TV exercised less, put on weight and therefore died younger anyway, but rather that sitting for long periods - whether you exercise a lot as well or not - was the problem.
      Obviously anyone who read my hypochondria piece will know that this has left me with a huge dilemma: TV or anxiety over my impending premature death.
      I’ll think about it tonight and get back to you tomorrow…

    • ~Rumpleteazer~ says:

      08:36am | 12/01/10

      Just my self and husband at home these days, so we can be in control of all our stuff.
      We like to take two bowls of home cooked yummy food to the couch and put on whatever movie we feel like.[DVD] Sometimes it may be a TV program, like last night, Elders:  an interview with Bob Hawke. Never liked the man, but the interview was excellent.
      After we have slopped food over ourselves, we then slurp a cup of tea.
      After we are satisfied with food and beverage, we rustle packets of lollies to get the good ones at the bottom.  A couple of hours later,snuggled, one or both will be snoring with their mouth gaping open. This is love, I do believe, as we get older. Those cosy nights “in”.
      We then get up and go to bed where we sit up with our big comfy plumped up pillows and read our books for hours and hours.
      No more party animals in this house. All our own time now and we do what we like. Although we do seem to miss the end of a lot of movies these days.

    • Mr Pastry says:

      08:40am | 12/01/10

      @Margeret Gray - good summary of why I don’t watch free to air TV.  While the screens may have become unimaginably large and impressive, TV executives have ensured the content has not caught up with the technology.  The writer does appear to watch a little too much (the photo indicates a little more aerobic activity may be of benefit).  I pick items off the internet menu that are to my tastes rather than getting used to (then liking) force fed junk.

    • Jrod says:

      08:51am | 12/01/10

      Great article Rob! I couldn’t have said it better myself. I LOVE my television, even moreso now that it’s all in HD! Most of my viewing is non-FTA and pre-recorded on IQ (*swoon*) as I loathe TV commercials. I find it relaxing. It’s my way of unwinding at the end of the day. Call it escapism, call it isolationist… whatever. High-brows gripe about the tripe networks dish up…sure, there’s plenty of crap, so don’t watch it, and don’t take it personally. Erase & replace! Foxtel’s Showcase has outstanding programming (and commercial-free). If that doesn’t impress, perhaps you’ve overrated your own intelligence.

    • Angela says:

      08:54am | 12/01/10

      TV oh you mean that think called foxtel with its endless reruns that I pay for every month but dont watch.

      I will grant you one point on new shows that are fresh and all the lovely documentary but the rest is pure garbage, have a look what is being served up on Foxtel called Dante’s Inferno, are they kidding or what, at least the GO channel that nine runs is better than Foxtel all together.

      Thanks for reminding us about 9/11 still haven’t forgotten how I turned on the TV and instead of ABC kids I got to watch that.
      And as TV for the last 10 years has been full of you what what called Reality TV were all you get to see is the best of Feral Society do you wonder why books win hands down for entertainment.

    • Macca says:

      08:55am | 12/01/10

      LOL, top post.

      Too all those who are taking this article;
      get a life ... and watch some TV

    • Colin Cidence says:

      08:57am | 12/01/10

      Not so fast, TV-lovers. By a wild coincidence, I just read this press release:

      Is sitting in front of the TV shortening your life? Australian researchers have tracked the TV viewing habits of 8,800 adults and found that every hour spent in front of the television each day increased the risk of death from all causes. While the study focused specifically on television watching, the findings suggest that any prolonged sedentary behavior, such as sitting at a desk or in front of a computer, may pose a risk to one’s health. 
      The paper ‘Television Viewing Time and Mortality’ will be published in the journal Circulation: Journal of the American Heart Association.

    • Isabel says:

      08:58am | 12/01/10

      Rob, I heard the same thing and was so relieved that my only television is at the foot of my bed therefore am not in a seated position when viewing.

    • 'chelle says:

      08:58am | 12/01/10

      You’re just reading too much into the phrase!
      I don’t watch TV.  I can honestly say that as I don’t have a TV.  Got rid of it 2 years ago.
      Happy that you love it - I don’t.
      No-one is better than anyone in this difference - it’s called personal choice.  That’s all.

    • H of SA says:

      09:00am | 12/01/10

      No watching television per se won’t rot your brain, certain programming though….

      I just don’t get watching free to air anymore, why put yourself through all the horrible advertising/not getting to watch what you want when you want - even on part time I can afford DVD’s of the good shows so why would I put up with TV’s rubish?

    • Mr Pastry says:

      09:00am | 12/01/10

      @Nola - Thats 3 categories.

    • Jamers Hunter says:

      09:04am | 12/01/10

      to me people who dont watch television are either liers and there fore untrustworthy ; workaholics with a fantastic sex life so combined they get no time but because of there lack of numbers i would concider the sample to be ststisyically meaningless therefore we cant trust them either; out nad out ludites who live in an alternate universe.these people realy are at a realit and emotional disconect with reality and probably send messages by carving stone tablets so we cant trust them .
      this means for me any one with a tv is ok and ayone with a wide screen is an integrated part of society and any one with a 55inch lcd with blue ray (like me) has got to have superior inteligence and a hightened awarness of the problems and needs of society.
      so there !!

    • Sam Chowder says:

      09:05am | 12/01/10

      Whats wrong with embroidary,  sitting in a chair creating something by hand with care is to be sneered at, but sitting in a chair mesmerized by dumb TV is to be applauded?  \*shakes head*\

    • Elizabeth says:

      09:07am | 12/01/10

      Can anyone recommend good international websites to watch shows on/download from? I love being able to watch at my leisure and catch up on things I’ve missed because one of the local networks has again changed the timeslot or played a double episode or simply can’t follow the weekly guide.

    • Sanchia Pegley says:

      09:07am | 12/01/10

      Damn. Sal just told me about that study and we were hoping you wouldn’t come across it.

    • Lisa says:

      09:12am | 12/01/10

      I’m in a problematic situation as I would love to watch more television but have a husband who is definitely in the oh-so-freaking-smug “I don’t watch any television” camp.  And I am very much a reality TV junkie - Can you imagine the conflict that goes on on a typical weeknight in our house.  I have just got the Crazies into bed, cooked up some dinner for The Beloved and myself and thinking I’ll just settle down with maybe a bit of TV to relax for a bit.  And he is like “you go watch YOUR TV and I’ll just sit up here at the table (by myself) and read the paper (and therefore educate myself more while you sit curdling your brain with Wives of New York City or The Bachelorette).  There is absolutely ZILCH pleasure in that.  The unspoken is “surely you could be doing something better with your time and extending yourself rather than destroying your TV addled brain even more”.  Actually that part goes along with the “and what do you have planned to do with your time when all the kids are back at school?”.  I’m sure he thinks I sit watching The View or Days of our Lives.  Even I draw the line at that.  I have a friend who said the other day that she just loves sitting during the day watching TV while the kids are at school.  Maybe I’ve been with My Beloved too long, but a I did feel a bit judgemental thinking “surely that’s the kind of thing old ladies do?”.  Anyhow rules do change a bit in our house when there is a cricket test on (TV on for 4 days in a row) or a golf tournament (TV on for 4 days in a row).  And blissfully I clock up The Husband’s TV viewing hours as sweet credits for more crap TV for me.  Thanks for another great blog Rob!

    • H of SA says:

      09:22am | 12/01/10

      Macca, surely it could just as easily be argued that people should “Turn OFF the TV and get a life”

    • Necron99 says:

      09:23am | 12/01/10

      When I was growing up my parents forbade my sister and I to watch television during the day. Weekends during the day were especially forbidden. They encouraged us to either read, listen to radio or plain and simple get out of the house.

      We were, and still are, continuously bombarded with American lifestyles who turn on the telly as soon as they wake up and watch it til the point they go to sleep. They even keep the telly on as they sleep. It’s a background function to many. I was pretty shocked to see this practice going on in Italy 30 years ago.

      Yes I still did watch a lot of telly, regardless of what my parents believed. I don’t watch much now but I do have a look when I’m bored and want to get away from my computer screen (some of us have been in front of computer screens for over 20 years and even that’s starting to get a little dull). I really only watch the telly to see an occasional doco and what mainstream news is broadcasting.

      Most people do not have cable or IQ, and as some have said here it is “Home and Away” and “A Current Affair” which shapes culture of that certain demographic, what are they called again? Oh yeah, the masses.

      When I was younger, I remember the younger brother of a friend telling me of some irrefutable fact. I asked him where he heard it and he told me he saw it on the telly. I proceeded to tell him not to believe everything he saw on the telly. He looked at me in bewilderment, as did my friend. I appeared to be breaking a core foundational belief which he grew up with. And you wonder why we don’t watch so much telly anymore.

      I will say one last thing, not so silent, it never ceases to amaze me when I follow a discussion either supporting the box or criticising those who oppose this practice, in a area which isn’t ‘on the box’. The fact that we’re discussing this here and not on telly, pretty much supports those you oppose. Then again, maybe this is just a troll rant… anything for ratings, huh? I certainly hope so.

    • Liz says:

      09:31am | 12/01/10

      So you’re prepared to judge others for what they watch but don’t like to feel judged yourself? Time to get a real life where you don’t need to defend your tastes.

    • Deanno says:

      09:56am | 12/01/10

      I agree totally. TV has received a bad rap for many years, yet it’s the one medium that everyone can get some enjoyment out of - even the “high brow” types who claim to watch only SBS or the ABC!

      What impresses me most is your ability to read 7 books in a month AND watch a reasonable amount of TV! I’ve been struggling to get through The Lost Symbol since Christmas, and still have about a third of it remaining. How do you do it?????

    • monkeytypist says:

      10:08am | 12/01/10

      Here’s where this piece falls over: “Or you very soon will be. But superb quality still remains on the small screen; comedy, drama and factual documentaries are as good today as they’ve ever been. For every crappy reality show or Friends-wannabe sitcom that pops up, there are The Sopranos, or The Office, or The West Wing.”

      1.  The vast bulk of the content on television has always been unmemorable garbage.  Heck, nearly half of it is advertising!  Watching TV is like visiting your local suburban video store and realising with a shock just how many appalling movies were released over the past few years.  TV is the quintessential mass “something for everyone - or rather, one thing for everyone” medium.  Lowest common denominator is simply the name of its business model.
      2. The new phenomenon, let’s call it “good” TV, is in fact quite recent.  The Simpsons was the only show to challenge everything we thought we knew about the medium, and it’s been on its own for most of its 20-year run.  The high-quality fare that you mention has only really exploded with the diversification of the TV market, and the creation of the multi-million dollar drama with a budget for writers alone that dwarfs most Australian films.  These projects would never be succesful under the old business model that characterised TV for a good 40 years, because they appeal to niche audiences on specialist subscription networks.
      3. I don’t own a TV set, but I watch heaps of the stuff - but it’s what I chose.  What I can’t stand is the mentality of just flicking the set on for the sake of some white noise in the background.  I watch most of the shows you just listed, but not on “television” at all.
      4.A lot of what is still praised as “high-quality” drama or comedy - eg. House, the Law and Order franchise - is predictable, melodramatic rubbish.  But it’s a lot more popular than the stuff you mentioned as actually being good.  Ditto Friends, which eclipsed Seinfeld not despite, but because of the fact that it was anodyne, inoffensive and predictable.

    • Nola James says:

      10:13am | 12/01/10

      @ Mr Pastry: right you are. must have morning coffee before posing comments on The Punch.

      @Deanno: If you are struggling to get through The Lost Symbol I’d pick another book.

      And Channel 7 is my Secret Shame.

    • BULMKT says:

      10:14am | 12/01/10

      If I was a TV exec, I’d be worried.
      A variety of people either doesn’t watch much of it, or they download it, or they record it via foxtel/austar and watch it later.

      Other than live sport or Bloomberg (which I have on in the background while at work), I record the stuff I want to watch as I’m sick of the constant late starts and of course the advertisements.

      I also get annoyed when a network (which they are all guilty of), just out of the blue drops a show. For example, 10 network dropping Supernatural on Monday nights. WTF!

    • James says:

      10:22am | 12/01/10

      Hi Nola,

      I love both types myself.  I am a huge The Wire, Deadwood, Sopranos, Rome, 30Rock, Breaking Bad etc etc fan, and yet I also enjoy Wipeout, and I absolutely love Today Tonight and A Current Affair because they are way funnier than the sitcoms and soapies shown on other channels at the same time.  One of my greatest guilty pleasures (learned from the Chasers) is watching their beat-ups and obviously biased journos.  Who doesn’t love a story about a shonky builder who rips off pensioners?  Or bogans doing burnouts and having parties and generally causing the downfall of modern civilisation?  Or about how immigrants are taking jobs and not assimilating into Australian culture?  “Oooohh this shonky building bogan Muslim gay married immigrant on welfare living up a pole on a hunger strike must be evil.  Just listen to the music darling.  And the way he slammed the door on the camera.”  My wife and I have endless fun with such things.

    • stealthpooch says:

      10:53am | 12/01/10

      This article is spot on.  I too cringe when people say that they’re ‘not into TV’, because I always get the feeling that they’re judging me.  I think I have a bit of a complex really.

      However, I think I’m better off cooking dinner while watching the ABC News and 7.30 Report than talking to myself or the dog. The dog doesn’t really say much of interest nowadays. 

      I honestly believe that I learn a lot from TV too.  I’m thinking, for instance, about the SBS doco ‘ripped’ which screened last week about Intellectual Property in the music and movie business.  It was a serendipidous flicking of the channel that led me to that gem.

      I’ve never been the type who can sit still for long, and I rarely watch TV without doing something else (yes, I can do embroidery in front of the TV).  There is some absolute crap on TV nowadays, but there’s some stellar stuff as well - many people have mentioned 30 Rock (which is unfortunately on too late for most) and The Wire.  John Safran’s recent series and shows such as Summer Heights High say important things about our culture, and the ABC arts shows often have great profiles on our local artists.  Yes, there’s more drivel than quality, but the quality shows have the ability to teach and enrich people’s lives.  I turn my back on you, smug non-TV watchers.

    • Steve says:

      11:09am | 12/01/10

      Entertainment is a life waster.

    • Steve says:

      11:18am | 12/01/10

      I don’t watch TV.
      I do watch TV shows.
      I watch them on DVD or the net.
      That way I can see all the great shows, without the rubbish of actually watching TV, the stupid programs, the celebrity-gossip-masquarading-as-news, the ads, and so on.
      Win-win.

    • Bec says:

      11:23am | 12/01/10

      Ah Rob. I hear you. TV for me is like air. I need a good dose daily. I don’t even get upset when my youngest wakes me in the dead of night for a bottle, as long as I can catch a glimpse of something to make broken sleep a little more bearable.

    • Jamers Hunter says:

      11:26am | 12/01/10

      STEVE 12.09 pm
      yep you one of the work a holic types with a fantastic sex life so you got no time for anything else. as i said in my comment(which see)  type like you are so rare that your numbers aree statistically meaningless. so you can (and should) be ignored.

    • SD says:

      11:33am | 12/01/10

      In saying “I don’t really watch television” (which incidentally, is something I would say) - there are two implicit statements:

      1) Most free to air television is mindless tripe made for the masses. I don’t watch it. Therefore I’m not one of the masses.

      2) I have other interests (haven’t given knitting a crack yet btw) watching the pap referred to in point 1.

      That’s what I mean when I say “I don’t really watch television”.

      Notice that the statement and explanation contains no universals.

      There is no suggestion that I never watch television.
      There is no suggestion that all television is mindless drivel.
      Just most of the free to air stuff.

      More recently, a third implicit statement has been added to “I don’t really watch television”:

      3) I choose what I watch. I often watch shows which are not aired in Australia. TV gems such as Deadwood, The Wire, Mad Men (yes The Wire was recently on free to air (FTA) but that took yonks to happen) and so on and so forth. (Btw pretty much anything by HBO is worth a look). If I am talking to someone who does watch a lot of FTA, I often assume that they are likely to be an unadventurous viewer who has to watch whatever is on / they are one of the masses and enjoy mindless drivel.

      So yes, there probably IS the capacity for smugness/sneering in the statement “I don’t really watch television” however - it is up to you to decide whether it applies to you or not.

    • D says:

      11:49am | 12/01/10

      I no longer watch TV much but that’s because I have new distractions.  I used to watch it a heap.

      I hate sitting and doing nothing though, so I am someone who embroiders while watching television.

    • Jo - Living Savvy says:

      11:54am | 12/01/10

      I read this piece after tweeting that I was so excited that Big Love was back on SBS tonight. 
      So timely for me who so often asks people if they have seen (insert show).
      A friend of mine would often say when I mentioned something that I had seen “You watch soooo much TV, I just don’t have the time”...the hidden meaning being not so subtly shared that he had more important things to do. Many times I came close to having a time is filled with more important things then you competition and then finally let it go. 
      The thing I love about being all grown up is I get to choose how to spend my time (after the kids, family, work etc) and one of the choices I make is to chill out in front of the TV.
      Often the only time I stop, sit & rest during is in front of the TV.  So tonight when the house is quite and work is done, I will be sitting, with a cup of tea and tim tam in hand watching something that I have pre-recorded and immersing myself in the moment – AHHHHH!

    • Kadir says:

      11:59am | 12/01/10

      TV is crap. It’s sensationalised garbage designed to be simple to take in and controversial. It’s suppose to not make you any smarter (otherwise you may just cause problems) and it is suppose to waste your time (otherwise you might just cause problems).

      It is in the best interest of the media to keep you stupid and marketable. No Government or corporation wants you to be decisive and intelligent (otherwise you might just cause problems).

      Watching TV is like eating chocolate it tastes good but too much will make you sick.

      Watch movies, documentaries, surf the net, get a hobby. But please please please don’t watch TV.

      Comming up next; Truck drivers, are they’re out to get you? followed by Groceries, we all buy them but are they causing us cancer?

    • DaveS says:

      11:59am | 12/01/10

      Gee - reading some of the comments here, it’s hard not to think the smugness issue is more to do with TV watchers than TV abstainers…
      Television has been a fundamental part of my life for most of my life. I grew up with it as an integral part of the household, and then I moved into the career of working in it.
      It is said that ‘familiarity breeds contempt’, and I must say that axiom holds true for me. I can’t think of anything worse than the cerebral sedative that is the crystal bucket. Granted, there are times when television is of vital importance - a newsflash can save lives; pictures of natural disasters and their victims can rally resources and vital donations; public service announcements inform, and monumental events played out live on television invite the viewer to vicariously participate in history. Sadly, these form but a tiny percentage of the total viewing fare, which is sadly dominated by the bread-and-circus mediocrity that constitutes acceptable content these days.
      Granted, there are exceptions, as there is brilliance and genius in evidence on television, but behind the scenes I have beheld the all too familiar scene of some of that very genius getting lobotomised for the sake of ‘accessibility’ (presumably by bogans).
      Never believe anything you read, and never believe anything you see on the telly.
      My own personal viewing habits these days are spartan - the news, a little light factual programming, and that’s it. I refuse to watch movies being hacked to pieces with commercial breaks and vandalised by having their credits fast tracked and squished for the sake of more advertising. For the sake of work I am sometimes required to watch certain programs so I am familiar with their format, content or design, and I can tell you - keep it. The appalling percentage of foreign content (expounding foreign values, social conditions and cultural emphasis) also leaves me cold.

    • Nigel says:

      12:09pm | 12/01/10

      We have a small TV, but 6 computers in the house, so guess how we watch the limited TV shows we see, downloaded and commercial free (or on DVD).

      The TV we do watch directly are three digital ABC channels.  They rock.

      Oh, and the cricket, I have to reset the digital aerial to watch channel 9.

    • casey says:

      12:11pm | 12/01/10

      It’s true a lot of progamming is garbage, but I am acutely aware that there is treasure sprinkled throughout.

      I don’t watch much television. I simply can’t be bothered. Between working and lack of sleep, I like to take my leisurely time and enjoy it. So I fill it with conversations, music and reading.
      I hate to commit my time to an activity I know has grim chances of satisfaction, and I have a tendency to re-watch things I already know to be entertaining to me.

      I certainly don’t feel I’m disconnected from pop culture, and I read a lot of news which will often tell me just what everybody around me will be going on about - only with half an hour’s less programming. And there are always video clips for un-substituable things like speeches, and live performance bungles.

      At any rate, Rob, I only ever mention my life’s lack of television when asked which programmes I watch. And it’s usually followed by an admission to my laziness. Please, don’t paint me with your snoot-brush.

      The cessation of my once four-hour-a-day average habit from high school, has meant I have learnt a new instrument, picked up a couple of belt grades in a martial art, am closer to my family,  have better real-time social skills, more dedicated to work-time > time-procrastination, and still I get to enjoy my old hobbies of reading, cooking and music. Do not tell me my life is devoid of quality and culture.

      Frankly, the use of a Dan Brown novel to exemplify your abundance of good culture makes me vomit a little. The admission of bad taste is worth a lot more than trying to pad out your life with ‘culture’.

      Your personal ‘offense’ offends me.

    • TB says:

      12:26pm | 12/01/10

      “Liking television doesn’t make me a vacuous idiot” - as if a title like that isn’t simply *asking* for ridicule. I won’t deny that there isn’t absolutely nothing to watch on TV these days, but one cannot deny that searching for something worth watching is much like fly fishing in a river of shit - what you have to wade through just plain stinks and it is ultimately an unsatisfying exercise. I have nothing wrong with switching off and being ‘just entertained’ (everybody needs some mental downtime) - but the producers of TV programs these days seem to be having increasing difficulty with performing even this simple task.

      As somebody who once spent considerable time seeking entertainment through either TV or video games now becoming increasingly dissatisfied with what both media have to offer, I find myself in quite the quandary with what to do with my time these days. I guess I’ll have another go at learning to play the guitar. I was actually making some (slow) progress the last time I was sinking time into that particular hobby. If wanting to do more than just sit on my arse in front of the TV for hours for the sake of personal enrichment makes me a pompous, arrogant, holier-than-thou elitist snob, then I guess that’s what I am.

    • Justin says:

      12:28pm | 12/01/10

      Bill Hicks once said watchign TV was like taking bacl spraypaint to your third eye. I believe him

    • kate says:

      12:41pm | 12/01/10

      Lovely post and some of the drivel in these comments only drive your point home.

    • Gemma says:

      12:42pm | 12/01/10

      I don’t really watch TV because I prefer the radio or a book.  That is not a judgment on what other people like to do - frankly, I couldn’t give a rat’s what you do with your spare time.  What’s the big deal?  Surely it’s horses for courses.  Don’t be so precious about people liking something different from you.

    • Tonks says:

      12:56pm | 12/01/10

      I don’t watch TV (on TV) but I watch plenty of television shows via the web, some of which are included in your examples above. I find this is the best way to find and watch good quality television - what’s actually on free-to-air is usually reality TV, sports (which is OK, but not for me) and dodgy sitcoms like “Two and Half Men”.

    • isis says:

      01:02pm | 12/01/10

      I don’t own a tv and can’t remember the last one I had. The internet took over because I wanted to know the truth and not be spoon fed by the media.

    • Shama says:

      01:42pm | 12/01/10

      Re the Telly Kills report, you can take comfort in the fact that back breaking work in the fields or in Dickensian factories and offices - besides being hard work and not leisure - would have caused an earlier death.

    • Seth Brundle says:

      01:49pm | 12/01/10

      I find people who dont watch TV to be rather tedious.

    • Chase Stevens says:

      01:58pm | 12/01/10

      I own a TV, I use it to play Video Games and watch the occasional movie. But that’s it the last thing on Television that really captivated me was Boston Legal.  Ever since that finished I haven’t watched TV, I’d rather spend my time on the Internet or reading a book to be perfectly honest.

      Of course this does mean I have no idea what some people are talking about.

    • Chris L says:

      02:07pm | 12/01/10

      “searching for something worth watching is much like fly fishing in a river of shit”
      Well said TB! You have expressed my own reasons for abandoning the idiot box despite having a long and devoted history with it. Sometimes people will suggest a good series to watch (Life on Mars and it’s spin off, Ashes to Ashes, are brilliant!) but for that I turn to DVD…. or, occassionally, the internet.
      I feel no guilt about this just as television producers feel no guilt over treating their audiences like a herd of brainless turnips.

    • H of SA says:

      02:07pm | 12/01/10

      As many have made the point there is TV worth viewing and there is TV that not only is not worth viewing…its just awful.

      To talk about the bad stuff its really simple how it works.

      -TV makes money by delivering audiences to advertisers
      -Larger audiences allow broadcasters to ask for more money from advertisers
      -In order to get larger audiences TV companies try to make programming with broad appeal
      -The easiest way to do this is to find the “lowest common denominator” - something that appeals to a basic appeal in people
      -Therefore common trigger points like lust and fear are appealed to
      -Therefore rather than watching something which value adds to their life experiences they are watching something appealing to pre-existing triggers
      -Therefoe TV watching is often wasted time, additionally cummulative effect has poor results for people - e.g. constant exposure to humans as sexual objects often leads to viewers devauling other humans, or constant watching of fear induicing programming can make people paranoid
      -Therefore its not in your self interest to watch such programming

      If you know all this and decide you still want to watch the crap cuz hey it brings you pleasure - just be aware that there are other ways of bringing pleasure into your life including experiencing things first hand rather than vicariously- but its up to you.

    • chris says:

      03:06pm | 12/01/10

      I dont need TV anymore….I have a shed. “Sucked in” you drones.

    • Mark says:

      03:58pm | 12/01/10

      IDWTV (I Don’t Watch TV) people are best asked three general knowledge questions, all pertaining to catchphrases in TV Commercials. IDWTV people, generally in their eagerness to be seen as the cleverest people in the room will invariably know at least two. Only once in 15 years have I had an IDWTV not recognise any of the three ads. The only real IDWTV had just managed to stab himself in the eye with aerial on his cell phone. Not surprisingly it wasn’t even his phone ringing. So not from the deep end of the gene pool. I challenge you next time someone tells you that they don’t watch TV to ask them if they have seen a certain ad. I will bet that they have.  Given that ads account for less than 20% of content, recall of an ad must ergo prove that they are not IDWTV’s. “The world is full of people who think that they are something that are not” Albert Einstein At least that’s who he said he was!!

    • guy says:

      04:07pm | 12/01/10

      I certainly don’t watch much TV in summer. First there is nothing much to see unless you like gawking at cricket or tennis. Second, it’s daylight until at least 8pm and I’ve always thought that daylight is far too precious to be wasted watching TV. Third, the Sydney Festival is on and there is quality evening entertainment to be had.
      I don’t understand why anyone but the aged, infirm or feeble minded would waste summer time watching dreary TV. Unless maybe it was raining outside. Even then, there are DVDs, books or the computer

    • TB says:

      04:27pm | 12/01/10

      Mark (4:58) - your test holds no water whatsoever. The subtraction of TV from somebody’s life only subtracts one form of advertising and marketing wank. There are other competing sources of meaningless BS sloganeering. The internet is drowning in ads, has been for years - especially now that the big companies have finally gotten tech-savvy.  Radio advertising is still humming along as usual, and that perennial dinosaur we call print media refuses to die. You more or less have to live in a cave to avoid advertising these days, and that’s precisely how the morally-bankrupt, soulless husks of people who work in advertising want it to be.

    • Simon Pieman says:

      04:39pm | 12/01/10

      @Chris :  I’ve got a TV in my shed

    • Lindy says:

      04:45pm | 12/01/10

      I love my IQ too!!!

    • Shama says:

      04:45pm | 12/01/10

      In my experience morally-bankrupt, soulless husks of people can be in any profession -  and I have worked in NGOs and corporates.  This stereotyping of certain professions is incredibly boring and redundant, you fnd perfectly decent sorts in ad agencies/TV/corporates and some really ethically challenged people in professions that are all about a “meaningful” life.

    • ab says:

      04:47pm | 12/01/10

      I find it interesting you mentioned the news, virtually all Australian news channels poorly report on anything important. The worst offender is 9. I remember they once reported 4 times about a trapped dog before discussing news about murderous violence. Even then, I read the New York Times so I can get real international news, news.com.au for Australian news, which even then has some bias but at least reports much more than the TV news, which does not only distract people from important issues but it too is biased. Australian newspapers are also mostly conservative biased, but oh well.

    • benno says:

      05:28pm | 12/01/10

      Hey. Murder she Wrote is actually pretty good, as i have realised from the reruns on 7TWO. I’ve also realised just what a quality show Magnum, PI is. It has depth, humour, serious emotion and light-hearted action. Selleck is all over these new nobodies from the CSI fluff.

    • Peter Thornton says:

      05:48pm | 12/01/10

      The golden rule if you think you’re watching too much TV: watch one more show.

      Pppfffffttttt! TV? What’s not to like about it?

      It’s not hard!

      Nice one, Rob.

    • S says:

      10:38pm | 12/01/10

      I love TV. I do. I can’t help it. I like the trash, I like the documentaries. Commercials aren’t so great, but I put up with them. I especially like watching TV series on DVD.

      I am a TV addict, and so far, it hasn’t done me any harm.

    • Julie Coker-Godson says:

      11:24pm | 12/01/10

      Rest assured, Rob, watching TV does not make you an innocuous idiot; nor will it send you to an early grave.  I really dislike these sorts of reports:  they should be peer reviewed before being given any publicity at all.  As for TV shows themselves, I watch loads of them and will continue to do so.  As to quality of programs I watch:  one woman’s quality viewing is another woman’s rubbish and the authors of some of the posts on this article sound as if they think they should be the programmers.  I thank God they are not as they sound very superior to me.  I’m off to watch a video now as its too hot to sleep.

    • JA says:

      06:28am | 13/01/10

      I have a very simple policy for tv/art/anything really… “Garbage in, Garbage out”.  It’s not the medium…

    • Chuck says:

      07:52am | 13/01/10

      To all of you saying you only watch the “good shows” by downloading or recording and skipping the ads, remember it’s the ads that pay for that show to be made.

    • Mark says:

      09:10am | 13/01/10

      (TB 5.27) You are so right TB. Advertising is every where. I bet you wear it, drive it and move around in and about it. You have a favourite brand not arrived at by personal digging into the products actuality but from information you have garnered from advertising either subliminal or provided to you from a friend. The best advertising medium of all is still word of mouth. You trawled past numerous ads to get to my statement. You will have been assaulted by 2,500 paid for messages since your message posted yesterday. These messages abound because they do affect people. Like IDWTV people there are also people who say they don’t take any notice of advertising. But closer examination of their lives also reveals that the brands that abound in advertising also abound in their lives. The cool brands, the nice car that is in fashion this year. The shoes that were naff last year. The fashions that weren’t fashion last year. Right down to food in the fridge that is 25% more expensive but is a nice label/taste/dolphin friendly/green/less fat/less salt. Advertising is everywhere because it works. If you can persuade the world to stop consuming then it will all stop? Be prepared for a sackcloth existence. But I will bet you and definitely not I won’t stop rampantly consuming what ever we can get our greedy mitts on! Good luck TB.

    • Justin says:

      10:05am | 13/01/10

      “I don’t really watch television”

      I prefer to play computer games!

    • Sigmund Faraday says:

      08:34pm | 14/01/10

      “I don’t really watch television”

      I prefer to iron

    • Claire says:

      06:13am | 15/01/10

      Rob, just saw your update as I was about to post the following: “Australian researchers have found that each hour a day spent watching TV was linked with an 18% greater risk of dying from cardiovascular disease, an 11% greater risk of all causes of death, and a 9% increased risk of death from cancer.”

      But I’ve posted it anyway. Just to show that maybe we non-TV watchers have something to be smug about after all.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter