By the year 2014, scientists - meaning my brain - predict that four out of every five Australians will have participated in a televised cooking, singing or renovation competition.

Bread and circuses. Pic: Supplied

Unable to find anyone over the age of six who hasn’t ruined a batch of macarons, covered an ‘80s ballad or panicked about tiling patterns on national TV, producers will be forced to resort to the construction of an army of immortal robots tasked with endlessly installing water features and preparing fusion dishes until civilisation crumbles and George Calombaris becomes ruler of the rag-tag group of rebels who patrol the Earth’s shattered highways.

For years, our screens have been dominated by accountants and architects in aprons, couples having domestics on building sites and bubbly teens with floppy fringes sacrificing themselves to Kyle Sandilands - the human-shaped God of Patronising Rage.

The latest show to gain a strong following is The Voice - a singing program distinguished from its peers by the fact one of the judges is an ancient, fleshy vessel containing the entirety of human sexuality (known to mortals as “Seal”).

Yes, we’ve occasionally had shows such as The Amazing Race, which has seen a number of Australians have to purge the words “organised”, “loves a challenge”, “works well under pressure” and “doesn’t scream at wife while abseiling” from their resumes.

But these shows are usually presented as distractions from all the jazz hands and minor kitchen-related burns. They never even come close to toppling the Australian Idols and The Blocks for television.

It’s time to find something new - something exciting and fresh and potentially dangerous.

We need to find a new skill - other than cooking, building or singing - to get excited about and use it to pit “ordinary Australians”/attention-starved narcissists against each other.

And no, I’m not interested in the kaleidoscopic, caffeine-addled collection of cartwheelers, waistcoat-wearing card shufflers and wranglers of small dogs known as “Australia’s Got Talent”. I’d prefer to avoid sipping from that particular bubbling vat of exploited childhood dreams and over-priced props.

What we need is a focused, high-stakes competition that chooses one specific skill and sticks to it - no oddball clowns competing against juggling children and grown men who wear sparkly hats.

We could, for example, hold extreme vintage car races in abandoned aqueducts, find Australia’s greatest Jenga master (spoiler: someone gets crushed by the weight of their own ambition/irresponsibly-tall Jenga tower) or clone carnivorous dinosaurs and challenge contestants to tame them over 12 emotional weeks. None of these, you may notice, involve singing, cooking or renovating (except maybe the dinosaur thing).

All of them, however, still present ample opportunity for passive-aggressive exchanges, over-sharing and the emptying of many tear ducts. We would pluck everyday Aussies from obscurity, put them in front of a camera so they can publicly talk about how much they hate their current lifestyle and occupation, hand them a pair of fire-resistant pants and escort them to their potentially-explosive vehicle.

And we would watch as a deli worker from Dalby named Kimberley (with five lower-case i’s) cries because her drift on the 18th corner wasn’t perfect.

“It’s just always been my dream,” she’ll tearily say.

And the judges would tilt their heads sympathetically in unison, before condescendingly explaining that she “just needs a little more time to find the emotional core of her panic-stricken high-speed cornering”.

Finally, a new and interesting show would score a victory against the tyrannical cooking/singing/building format, ending George Calombaris’ sweaty reign of terror.

At the very least, it would give us something to watch until the next season of Masterchef.

Most commented

26 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Kim says:

      06:26am | 17/05/12

      Brilliant article. Perhaps we could have a Tee Vee show in which all those who have watched too much of all the reality shows up to now, plus all contestants and judges, are brought together in some sort of ( actual) elimination playoff (during ratings season only), in a contest that tests the extent of brain atrophy. Call the program “Un-Natural Selection”

    • M says:

      06:48am | 17/05/12

      Thunder dome.

    • sunny says:

      11:14am | 17/05/12

      Classic ... “Two accountants enter, one accountant leaves.”

      Either The Blaster or The Humongous ain’t showing up to their accountancy job tomorrow.

    • subotic says:

      08:11am | 17/05/12

      Why don’t we get episodes of “Faces of Death” here I’ll never know.

      Re-runs of goddamn Get Smart, Hogan’s Heroes and the bloody Love Boat, sure, here, have an endless supply of diatribe. Crap shows from the 70’s & 80’s ad-nauseum. But no decent hardcore shows like “Faces of Death”.

      TV programming peoples, are you reading this? Where the bloody hell are you?

    • Inky says:

      08:43am | 17/05/12

      Get Smart….  Hogan’s Heroes…  bad shows?

      Does not compute.

    • nihonin says:

      09:13am | 17/05/12

      Would you believe, Get Smart is still pretty funny, or have I….....missed it by that much?

    • subotic says:

      09:31am | 17/05/12

      @Inky, I didn’t say they were bad, I said they were crap. Old. Crap. I can watch bad TV. Housewives of Atlanta I can do. And that show is baaaad.

      @nihonin, but watching one more episode of “Craw Mr. Smart… not Craw. Craaaaaw” is just ridiculous. Hell, I’d do Samford and Son, or shit, Good Times, over silly Mel Brooks comedy from the late 60’s.

      It was all funny the first 47 times.

      Only MASH sucks harder…

    • nihonin says:

      10:03am | 17/05/12

      I still get a laugh out of Mel Brook’s Blazing Saddles smile

    • thatmosis says:

      08:27am | 17/05/12

      Ive just read that the crew and contestants in this years Masterchef have contracted Mussilini’s revenge, how appropriate that now they have got what they give us nightly on TV.
        As for reality TV, why. Do we really care if somebody can cook meals that no family could afford better than someone else, do we really care that someone can sing better than someone else when they all sound basically the same, do we really care that celebrities can dance without falling over, do we really care that a couple can transform a delelict house into a dream home using squillions of dollars and then fail to sell it on TV, do we really care if obese people put themselves through hell to lose weight that they shouldnt have had on in the first place,do we really care if the farmer gets a wife , the answer as far as Im comcerned is NO.
        These shows are a blight on TV and an insult to ones intelligence, happily i have pay tv where you can actually watch shows that are entertaining and thoughtful.

    • Jeremy says:

      09:44am | 17/05/12

      You fall into the trap of believing most people have some great intelligence to insult.
      But that’s okay - The first basic law of human stupidity asserts without ambiguity that; Always and inevitably everyone underestimates the number of stupid individuals in circulation.
      They need TV too, thatmosis. In fact, it’s better for everyone else if they do.

    • thatmosis says:

      09:42pm | 17/05/12

      Yes the whole world is mad except me and thee and I’m not to sure about thee.  Yes I"m afraid you hit the nail on the head and i should have realized that TV has been dumbed down to meet the IQ of the average moron, silly me. These shows are fodder for the masses and we should be congratulating them for keeping the inmates quiet whilst others pursue higher planes of consciousness.

    • alan partridge says:

      08:40am | 17/05/12

      Monkey tennis?

    • adam says:

      09:27am | 17/05/12

      All reality show judges/hosts/compares and past winners who attempt to parley their 15minutes into a career, placed on an island with onlt sticks as weapons. All losing contestants who realise their dignity is in tatters are given hunting rifles and one heavily modified means of terrestrial transport each.

      Re enact the wonderful movie Turkey Shoot. You know it makes sense.

      Or “Lord of the Flies, Australian Parliment version”

    • fairsfair says:

      09:42am | 17/05/12

      Yes! Failed reality stars volunteer as Tribute for a Hunger Games type/Truman Show faceoff. Love it.

      In all seriousness though I can not get past shows like The Celebrity Apprentice where the guy who came second is deemed “celebrity” becuase he won The Amazing Race Australia the other year and Johnny Ruffo being deemed a “star” that needs to be danced with becuase he came 3rd on an average singing show last year.

      I think some of these shows would still be popular if the people that were on them were of higher standard. I can’t wait for Johnny Ruffo’s “This is Your Life”.

    • HappyCynic says:

      10:07am | 17/05/12

      Throw a new politician into your reality show island every week as cannon fodder (selected by having a vote off during Question Time for extra drama), immunity gets offered to the first person who descends in to cannibalism, hell you could even do a spin off called MasterCannibal showcasing the best ways to kill, prepare and serve humans

      Oooh the possibilities are endless, once all the pollies have been turned to lunch you can get self-righteous documentary filmmakers out there to explore whether different races taste different, Nigella Lawson and Jamie Oliver and their ilk could be chucked on the island to show us the best ways to bleed a human out without toughening up the meat, the cast of Neighbours and Home and Away could be guests in a spin off of Come Dine With Me, the week’s least popular breakfast news program could host a new Breakfast Show on The Island, the weeks most pre-fabricated popstars host a weekend music show on the island (Rage of the Cannibals).  smile

      You’d never run out of people, there’s still those home shopping people, weather presenters, gossip show hosts, Hollywood stars in rehab or having babies, washed up has-been rock stars…

    • adam says:

      10:20am | 17/05/12

      I know Fairs the celebrity bar is set depressingly low.

      Mind we’re speaking about an industry responsible for both that aussie WAG show and the horror ( I assume) of Bingle being given more airtime.

      A thought! Maybe the next mystery box challenge could have the box filled with the judges, cook em up long pig style…

    • fairsfair says:

      12:49pm | 17/05/12

      “Being Bingle” good god. I hope it is as shortlived as Stephanie MacIntoshs’ show.

      I nominate Hotdogs from Big Brother as first Tribute.

    • Robert S McCormick says:

      10:17am | 17/05/12

      The outcome of the “Voice” was/is every bit as predictable as “Australia’s got (some) Talent”. That was obvious from the very first episode.
      Masterchef is gone or going?
      Thank heaven for that & may it be swiftly followed by the Voice & AgT. Then just maybe these three Commercial Free-to-Air TV stations will start showing their advertised programmes On Time, at the time they advertise them. Both Ch9 & Ch7 allow those two not-so-genuine “talent” shows to run anything up to 30 minutes over their scheduled times. That is unfair & unjustified because, though a lot do, not all viewers are actually taken in by this rubbish & would prefer to watch other rubbish. These over-runs, particularly by Ch7, have now rolled over into one of the few TV channels showing anything worth watching: 7’s “72”. Last night one of their programmes over-ran their advertised time-slot by over an hour..
      Celebrities? What celebrities? That word must be the most mis-used word in any language today. They are not celebrities. They have done nothing, for anyone other than for themselves. They have brought no benefits to anyone. They have contributed nothing of importance or benefit to the rest of the world.
      If SBS can run all it’s programmes on time, every time then so can Channels 7,9,10 & their off-shoots. Though ABC-TV is, thanks entirely to their totally unnecessary constant advertisements, fast catching up with 7,9 & 10, they manage to only run a couple of minutes late. The exception being ABC-TV’s “Insiders” programme which wastes a huge chunk of the programme on their introductory episode. We are lucky if we get even 15 minutes of actual programme on Sunday mornings

    • G says:

      10:40am | 17/05/12

      I think The Punch needs to employ me. What a pointless and waste of web space this is. Empty opinions going nowhere and offering no solution, just like most of the opinions on “The Punch.” Soft and passionless…you guys do this for a living have some respect with your writing and give the readers something meaty to bite into instead of this watered down cashing in on pop culture nonsense.

    • subotic says:

      11:04am | 17/05/12

      Nobody forces you to come here and wallow in our filth & diatribe.

      If we wanted solutions we’d take up arms and shoot politicians. But we’re Australians, so we just shoot the shit in crappy forums and pretend like we give a toss, when in fact we don’t. That’s how we got a Carbon Tax.

      Did you misplace your link to Facebook, G?

    • G says:

      12:04pm | 17/05/12

      LOL smile Yeah perhaps I did!

      I do think the “you don’t have to come here” argument is a bit weak though.  I like to read opinions and it’s frustrating when writers are given a chance to express theirs that they give us watered down stuff like this.

      Too true about us Australians but I do try and give a toss…when I feel like it smile

    • JessWah says:

      10:28am | 24/05/12

      Its a bit of fun.  Not everything has to be doom and gloom, and not all of us enjoy reading about politics every two seconds smile

    • Blind Freddy says:

      10:54am | 17/05/12

      I’m a fan of Karl Pilkington’s (An Idiot Abroad) idea of a surgical reality show; where contestants are given the chance to operate on willing patients waiting on elective surgery lists.

      The challenges would become more difficult as the show went on – with the final being a heart transplant, or something similar. We have enough karaoke singers, chefs and dancers we need more surgeons.

    • JB says:

      12:19pm | 17/05/12

      Life after Masterchef..if that lotto win comes my way I intend to hire Marion as my inhouse cook

    • AnthonyG says:

      06:00pm | 17/05/12

      Masterchef is all about 3 overweight nobodies stuffing their faces and getting even fatter as you watch

    • Cobbler says:

      08:03pm | 17/05/12

      Great article again Jason!

      It would be nice to see some non-reality television again, like in the 20th century, even better if it didn’t center around policing, hospitals or lawyers.

      If some producers felt really naughty they could produce some sci-fi or fantasy shows for you know…. escapism.  I hear there’s this new thing called ‘Game of Thrones’ that people are watching in places that aren’t Australia (except for people who like to pay for more adds).

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter