Is it time for our libraries to get loud? For background music to joyfully sing out from loudspeakers while members flip through their favourite sections of their local institutions?

The silence is deafening. Photo: Thinkstock

For mums to discuss bedtime books for their children over a well made latte (yep, you guessed it, with the sound of a library cafe’s coffee machine hissing along with their conversation).

For book club discussions to rise and fall with the passion of the group, for students’ laughter and cookie munching to be heard at study tables and whole conversations to be voiced within the libraries’ venerated walls.

Is it time to get rid of the staid, hushed tone, the ‘don’t you dare made a sound louder than a whisper’ culture of our libraries?

I make this suggestion with a loud bias. I hate the silence. It completely freaks me out, rather than help me concentrate the silence deafens me, at a library it is all I can hear.

I recently visited my local library to try and get some work done in an environment where I couldn’t get up and feed myself even more food every time I wished for a distraction, but I lasted just five minutes in my library.

The silence physically oppressed me to the point that all I wanted to do was shout out loud and make as much noise as a child throwing a tantrum in a shopping centre.

As a journalist I have always worked in noisy work environments where the constant ringing of phones, shouting, swearing, running, loud jokes you wish you hadn’t just heard and live TV interviews make up the background noise.

Blocking out that noise has never been a problem for me, but I do understand this wouldn’t be everyone’s ideal enviornment to work in.

But I think libraries take things just as far in the silence direction. It’s why I believe you see so many students studying in cafes, earphones visible, rather than at their libraries.

Cafes play music, allow talking, have people coming and going. They create an atmosphere that is enjoyable to sit it. An atmosphere which breaks the isolation of studying or working alone but is still conducive to getting work done.

They have become the new public space because publicly owned spaces haven’t kept pace with the wishes and wants of the public.

As a person who is proudly a bookworm/dork/geek/book freak or any other name us bookish people have been given, here are my suggestions for making libraries more fun places to visit.

In the afternoon and night hours when young people in particular are more likely to be studying or working from computers a cafe environment should be adopted.

Most young people studying or working are after a venue that serves coffee, has wifi access and power points, where there are other people and plenty of movement so they don’t feel so locked away, where there are comfy chairs and lounges and where the space feels uplifting or creative.

And where possible our libraries should try to have both indoor and outdoor space. I love the winding verandah outside the Eltham Library that overlooks a park. Across Melbourne cafes and restaurants have known for a very long time that we are obsessed with al fresco dining.

So why not al fresco reading across Melbourne or even Australia? On a sunny afternoon who wouldn’t prefer to be working or reading in a courtyard or on an open rooftop rather than inside a greyish building?

My local library has no outdoor space and reminds me a lot of the portable classrooms of my primary school education. Everything is in blueish/grey colours and looks a little dated.

Here I would suggest our libraries get creative. Why not let the best photographers, artists and designers free on our libraries walls? Couldn’t they be a great canvas, an ever-changing public space to show off the talents of local creatives?

Imagine if our next Tim Winton or Peter Carey were to sit brooding for months over their laptop, drinking too much caffeine, debating religion/philosophy/politics with the next Gillian Armstrong or Cate Blanchett at their local library, before delivering their masterpiece to the reading world.

That would, I believe, be worth lifting our libraries’ veil of silence for.

35 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Save Our Libraries says:

      08:24am | 30/07/11

      The mud brick library at Eltham is my Church   - anorganic building with such ambience it is more than a place with shelves ofa books.  Any library is a sacred place and must become a protected species.

    • malohi says:

      05:08pm | 30/07/11

      Endangered species more like it.
      Libraries today are where poor deros and old people use the internet.
      Maccas now has free wi-fi.
      The death knell tolls.

    • atthepub says:

      08:27am | 30/07/11

      You forgot the fountain, the chandeliers and grand piano.

    • Katie says:

      08:34am | 30/07/11

      I have a suggestion for you… if the library freaks you out, get an ipod. Why should they have to cater to you just because you can’t deal with silence?

      Either that, or go to one of the cafe-libraries or cafe-bookstores that are floating about.

      My local library is always packed with students and other casual readers… all of whom are just fine with the silence, or bring a headset. It has small rooms for people who want to study together and chat but otherwise, no-one seems to have an issue.

      Besides, who wants their library books with coffee stains?

    • persephone says:

      08:51am | 30/07/11

      Wear an ipod.

      I let kids do that in class, as long as they’re working.

      Even kids who find it hard to concentrate on their work normally work a lot better.

      It also means you chose your own music, and don’t have to put up with someone else’s choices - which would be the downside to libraries playing music.

    • Tom says:

      01:09pm | 30/07/11

      Perse, “Wear an ipod. I let kids do that in class ...” OMG perse, you are a teacher. A Labor propaganda machine in control of the fragile impressionable minds of our future generations?

      “Even kids who find it hard to concentrate on their work normally work a lot better.” ... Any credible support for your whacko assertion?

    • persephone says:

      03:40pm | 30/07/11

      Yes, Tom, quiet classes where kids are working and complete the set tasks.

      I’m simply talking about my own experiences.

    • Brian B says:

      03:44pm | 30/07/11

      Yep Tom - Perse’s logic is a snapshot of current Labor thinking - imagine trying to grapple with high end maths with heavy metal screaming in your ears.

    • Fi says:

      05:57pm | 30/07/11

      As someone who was recently a high school student, I agree with Persephone that it helps students work if they listen to music on their iPods. It tunes out everything else, and even if you’re listening to heavy metal, you can concentrate on the task at hand, rather than the clicking of the pen of the person in front of you, or the conversation going on behind you.

      Though there are a few studies saying that you shouldn’t listen to music whilst you study (as in exam study, not answer a few maths questions), I, and several of my friends, found that complete silence was enough to stop us from working, because not hearing -anything- is distracting.

      Different things work for different people. Don’t criticize a teaching method that works.

    • Fiona says:

      06:41pm | 30/07/11

      Tom and Brian b, did you have to bring politics into a post about libraries? Is nowhere safe???

    • James says:

      09:57pm | 30/07/11

      FYI I wrote my entire honours thesis while listening to heavy metal. Laugh all you want but I got a H1 and am now doing the same with my doctoral research.

    • Kate says:

      10:34am | 31/07/11

      @James - I do my best uni work while listening to Rammstein and Nine Inch Nails. Something about the pace of it makes me work better.

    • Helen says:

      11:39am | 02/08/11

      “Tom and Brian b, did you have to bring politics into a post about libraries? Is nowhere safe??? “

      Because the Baillieu government is cutting funds to libraries, no, it’s not possible to avoid politics in a discussion about them. And it’s a bit sad that this piece was just a puff piece about the ambience instead of getting into this more important topic.

    • Dave says:

      09:10am | 30/07/11

      Add a bar and I’d never leave… smile

    • jade (the other one) says:

      09:23am | 30/07/11

      That’s fine and dandy for you, but for someone like me who has a complete inability to block out background noise due to a condition, the library is the only place I have that I can study effectively.

      Furthermore, the reason libraries don’t allow food and drink is because they are publicly funded. It can get expensive to replace periodicals, books and reference materials ruined by a careless coffee spill.

      Libraries are not just book repositories for fashionable wannabes who don’t want to pay. They often store irreplaceable periodicals, a host of reference material, and expensive and out-of-print books, which can be difficult to replace.

      If you want hustle, bustle and background noise, go to a cafe or eatery. Libraries are there for those who like silence, solitude and a distraction-free environment.

    • Jane2 says:

      03:41pm | 30/07/11

      Im with you Jade. I also find it easier to concentrate in quiet than with noise around me so would hate it if the quiet rule changed. All libraries have “discussion rooms” for book clubs etc and some even have seperate sections for kids so they can get noisy without affecting other patrons.

      Logistically it is far easier for someone who doesnt like silence to have an ipod than for someone who can only concentrate in silence to wear earplugs that will block out the noise….and safer too as if there is an emergency the ipod wearing can hear the alarm but the person with noise blocking earplugs cant.

    • Likes Joining Dots says:

      09:24am | 30/07/11

      Elise, I can sum it up in 12 succinct words. No. No and for the love of all that’s sacred, dear god nooooo.

      If that’s your thing, take your books to the food court or cafe and enjoy the cackling, giggling and gobbling with the accompanying soul ripping strains of Andre Rieu , but please don’t bring your shopping mall to the library.

      PS I’m typing this in the library and have already been ‘shushed’ three times and had the raised eyebrow twice such is my outrage at the suggestion.

    • Cat says:

      09:27am | 30/07/11

      time to take a look at some modern libraries - you’ll find cafe’s and outdoor areas, unique art and noisy school holiday workshops, language classes, day workshops ect. ect.  Councils all over the place have held design competitions to create clever modern spaces which are an asset to the community. If your local library is falling behind the times get in touch with the local council and push for a rebuild or renovation!

    • Joan says:

      09:56am | 30/07/11

      What a sad joke, turn libraries into nattering coffee shops, as if there aren’t enough noisy, boisterous , chatty, cafes in our cities. It is space for peaceful silence , reflection and contemplation that is missing in our society.  My library has a diverse program, a book club, speakers and Sunday concerts winter time and plenty of time to browse, read, reflect , without inane chatter. That`s the way it should be.

    • Stefano says:

      10:21am | 30/07/11

      I’m sorry, Elise, but I simply cannot agree. Having an alfresco coffee these days is subject to traffic noise and fumes and the racket of uncontrolled ankle-biters and dogs. I generally like the ambience of a busy cafe or restaurant but never choose to work there, preferring the quiet of home or the peace of my local library which is somewhat busy and never “you can hear a pin drop” quiet anyway.

    • Tika says:

      10:29am | 30/07/11

      Agreed, I would love to visit a library more often if it had a little ambience.. Maybe if it had a cafe as well for a coffee while I browsed through books? I’d pay for that!

    • stephen says:

      10:30am | 30/07/11

      I think what you want is a cafe.
      Magazines, computers, coffee and scooters.
      In modern libraries today you wouldn’t get the comraderie you are thinking of because no-one reads books therefore no-one has ideas for talk : they are all at the computer, (info babe, and lots of it, but no ideas.)
      A few years ago an outdoor version of your notion tried to get going : philosophy cafes, and it worked out well for plumbers and sparkies stopping off on their way home to pick up chicks over a cuppa.
      “Phil, off me..yeah thanks mate” is as far as they got.
      But if libraries want more customers, the City Councils should again raise PT ticket prices then all the unemployed will have no-where to go BUT to the books.

    • K says:

      10:31am | 30/07/11

      Speaking as a university student, there is nothing worse than having to listen to music you don’t like while you’re trying to study. If you do like the music you don’t get the study done. It’s a lose/lose.

      If you want the noise, borrow the book and go to a cafe

    • Emma says:

      11:43am | 30/07/11

      I don’t know where your local library is, Elise, but let me assure you…the one I work in definitely doesn’t adhere to that old adage! (Seriously, I wouldn’t be allowed to work there…I’m not quiet!) Between storytime, Wii, kids on the Internet…silence is a foreign concept! We’ve had choirs, bands and other performers appear. But we also have students and others who want and need the quiet…and there’s a place for that too.

      However, Victoria’s public libraries are facing funding cuts that could impact all the services we provide. Libraries truly are hubs of the community, but without adequate funding, what they can offer will be disadvantaged…and so will the communities who rely on and benefit from them.

      If you could sign the petition against these cuts, it would be hugely appreciated. Because this is one thing I CANNOT be silent about. grin

      http://www.gopetition.com/petitions/funding-to-public-libraries-in-victoria-must-not-be-cut.html

    • Redeker Plan says:

      01:20pm | 30/07/11

      Well said Emma.  I’m a librarian as well, and honestly don’t know any public library that still adheres to the “silent shush” rule.  It’s as outdated a stereotype as the spinster librarian with cat-hair infested twinset and hair in a bun. Quite frankly, libraries are hard-pressed keeping our collections up-to-date and reasonably stain-free, our public access PCs virus and porn free, our return shutes free of rubbish and (in one memorable case from early in my career) human poo.

      Where is the money to come from for these coffee machines, and al fresco areas?  Every year we hold our breath until we see that our budgets have been maintained, if not increased.  This year it appears we have run out of luck.  Thanks Ted. I’m asuming from her call for radically increased services and additional building works, that Elise Kinsella is putting her hand up to volunteer for rate rises and tax increases? 

      Practically speaking, will there be an on-site barista, or is this to be yet one more area that librarians will be expected to learn, along with photocopier wrangling and unpaid child-minding?  Does the librarian in charge get to pick the music?  Because if so, better be prepared for an onslaught of Zimmer’s Hole and maybe some Nine Inch Nails for the 5 minutes before closing when people are refusing to leave.

    • Noise Hater says:

      05:02pm | 30/07/11

      who wants a bunch of coffee swilling mothers whining at the top of their voices about their uncaring spouses whilst their kids run rampant screaming in the background, we get enough of that in the local cafes, libraries are where people go to get away from the noise lovers like you because we actually know how to focus and we don’t need to be the centre of attention all the time or show how badly our brats can behave

    • stephen says:

      08:11pm | 30/07/11

      Does your old man teach at Kenyon College ?

    • Alicia says:

      08:47pm | 30/07/11

      I disagree. There is nothing worse than a person talking when you are trying to read a book. Quiet libraries are good libraries.

    • Gregg says:

      06:29am | 31/07/11

      It seems you’ve got the Ipod and No No and dear God No message Elise and I was thinking as I read your article not only what a crock of shit but do Journos not use spell checkers? or at least do a quick proof read and I’ll let you find it amongst the wordy environment.

      And Elise, for all the extra costs involved for alfresco reading etc., I imagine users of such libraries would be willing to pay fees and in that case, this could be such a great idea you might be willing to invest funds in is it?

    • Kate says:

      10:33am | 31/07/11

      There are hundreds of places to go if you don’t want to read in silence. Cafes, parks etc. Libraries have areas for conversation, particularly the children’s book area, but they are a great safe haven for people who like to read or study in silence. If you want music, bring an iPod (but for god’s sake keep the music at a normal level so that everyone around you can’t hear what you’re listening to).

    • mickijo says:

      02:40pm | 31/07/11

      I would love to see the day,it will come, when libraries are online and you just pick the book you want from a list and read it right there in your own home. I cannot think of anything more heavenly. The days of electronic books are upon us, old worlds will go and new worlds begin. Starting with online books,magazines , museums . OH! Yes!

    • Craig of North Brisbane says:

      01:34pm | 01/08/11

      I’m heavily involved with Wikisource, a project to digitise and make available books and the like online free of charge.  With that said, I still don’t think you can get over the wonderful ambience of a quiet (but not silent) library and giant piles of wonderful physical books.  If I ever tire of libraries, someone shoot me!

    • Angela says:

      09:55pm | 31/07/11

      I love my library, it has a cafe with nearby racks of newspapers and magazines to read, storytelling groups for kids & cubs, I attend a knitting group there, I wrote my thesis there enjoying wi-fi access in a quiet glassed off area while sipping on peppermint tea and scoffing chocolate, my children love the kiddies section with lounges, a space ship theme, with a control desk that has computers fit into it for searching the catalogue. We go there every school holiday to enjoy special events like puppet shows, craft days and face painting. It has it all, video game section, a heap of computers for internet access, a council desk for paying bills, and Ticketek until just recently and there are art exhibitions and performances. So much better than the way libraries used to be!

    • John says:

      03:22pm | 01/08/11

      Elise, there are some people like me who spend our lives wishing that people like you would just shut up and let us think. Please don’t take libraries away from us.

    • Helen says:

      11:35am | 02/08/11

      “The silence physically oppressed me to the point that all I wanted to do was shout out loud and make as much noise as a child throwing a tantrum in a shopping centre.”

      You could use some self control and behave like the, you know, adult that you’re supposed to be, taking notice of the etiquette of this particular space. Is that so impossible? Can I say “overweening sense of entitlement”? Maybe I’m getting old, but in my day *waves stick* it was a part of growing up to learn how to behave oneself. That was good practice for visiting other countries, cultures and spaces, too. What a quaint notion. Now we just throw our weight around and go “Waaaaa!” when told we can’t do anything.

      That said, I don’t see why there shouldn’t be spacious, quiet reading rooms where people who still appreciate a quiet place for study can sit, and other parts of the library can be noisier.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

Abbott’s crass logic: trash the Parliament in order save it

An email was sent to almost every politician in Australia this week saying that someone should cut off…

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

Our special forces don’t always need special treatment

We admire them, but we’re not entirely sure why. We allow them to operate in the shadows; we rarely…

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

A good holiday is about unrest, not rest

Like a fat full-stop, it lay in my hand. A small orange – not exactly fresh, but purchased anyway…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter