I have always had a fair deal of respect for nutritionist Rosemary Stanton but realised yesterday that this is only because I haven’t been paying attention.

Healthy option: Iguanas contain less sugar than a traditional chocolate cake.

Not sure if the rest of you caught it, but Mrs Stanton has launched a pretty out-there tirade against Bindy Irwin’s new commercial deal as the public face of a particularly sinister company.

Not Union Carbide or Exxon or British Aerospace but the baking products conglomerate Greens General Foods, one of the shadiest players in the evil cake trade.

We’re not speaking here of the mythical drug also known as “cake”, made famous in the British news parody Brass Eye, but package cake mix, made from flour, sugar, baking powder, and flavourings such as cocoa, vanilla and orange.

Greens has been peddling the stuff for years.

Pushing it onto time-poor mums, getting kids hooked on it from an early age, using its addictive sweetness and energy-giving qualities to lure them into eating it by the slice after school - even hiding it in their lunch boxes so they can take it onto school grounds and get a fix at little lunch.

Well, Mrs Stanton has now blown the whistle on this practice - and taken aim at those irresponsible Irwins as part of the deal.

The first troubling thing about Mrs Stanton’s spray is the small matter of Steve Irwin’s death. That tragedy should make the Irwin family pretty much immune on the grounds of decency from any kind of frivolous sledging. It should also be factored into the thinking of any would-be critic as perhaps being the very reason why Terri Irwin needs to form a business partnership with a reputable family company such as Greens.

Mrs Stanton managed to negotiate her way past the taste question as she had a bigger target in mind.

Cake.

Mrs Stanton took issue with the images of Bindi and little Bob helping their Mum bake a cake in the kitchen, and even licking the spoon.

“The message that comes across to kids is “it’s OK to eat cake because Bindi Irwin does” - I think it’s very sad,” Stanton said.

“Children are very trusting, so they actually think Bindi wouldn’t do it if it wasn’t right.”

“I think it’s a bit of exploitation of her as well because she wouldn’t possibly be old enough to understand the impact that this could have.”

“It’s wrong to target kids in trying to sell stuff to other kids. It makes it very difficult for parents to then resist the pleas of their children.”

It’s a good thing Mrs Stanton doesn’t know our address, or the addresses of our many mates with young kids, as we’ve all adopted a totally reckless attitude to child-rearing where we regard baking the odd cake with the kids as enjoyable family time, a great way to introduce them to cooking, especially with a good packet mix because they can do it all by themselves, with the added bonus that you can eat something tasty afterwards or take it down to the park for a picnic. We’re lucky DOCS haven’t come around.

It’s cloud cuckoo land stuff which wouldn’t matter if not for the fact that Rosemary Stanton, author of 25 books on diet and nutrition, is on the Federal Government speed-dial for advice on health and wellbeing issues, one of those superficially innocuous right-thinking people who only has all our interests at heart.

(Googling her last night I found an interesting link to a lecture of hers on “Ethical Eating” on the ABC’s Fora website, where she suggested food prices could be artificially inflated so that our farmers no longer had to export produce, which would not only make food production more sustainable, but solve the “starving pensioner” problem once and for all.)

The other thing about the cake issue - Terri Irwin has only agreed to the deal because Greens has made a sizeable contribution to Steve’s ongoing wildlife and conservation protection programs, and are using their products to increase childrens’ awareness of endangered species through school bag tags.

Which if you’re Rosemary Stanton probably just proves that, like any other pusher, cake dealers will do anything to get people hooked.

Anyway here’s a link to Greens Traditional Chocolate Cake. Buy some and feed it to your kids.

96 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Lara Jovanovich says:

      08:01am | 13/07/09

      Went to the link you provided and have a look at the yummy ingredients that are provided in Greens “traditional” chocolate cake.

      SUGAR, WHEAT FLOUR, VEGETABLE FATS & OILS [EMULSIFIERS (471, 477)], COCOA POWDER (1.5%), BAKING POWDER, MALTODEXTRIN, COLOURS (CARAMEL, 155), WHEAT STARCH, EMULSIFIERS (472e, 481), WHEY POWDER, SOYA FLOUR, THICKENER (1442), SALT, FLAVOUR.

      This is what you are feeding your kids! Good on Mrs Stanton for trying to make people aware of what they are eating. Chocolate cake should be made with flour, cocoa, eggs and milk - not with chemicals. People should be aware of what they feed their kids!

    • Dave Sag says:

      08:32am | 13/07/09

      Sorry Dave, I’m with Mrs Stanton on this one.  As Lara J above noted, cakes should be made out of simple, honest ingredients, not emulsifiers, soya flour, and ‘flavour’.  Making a real cake isn’t hard, hell even I can do it.  Making cake from a packet is like making pasta sauce from a jar; it’s much better to make proper food at home and know what you are eating.  It’s also, in most cases, simpler to make proper food than it is to go buy a packet of something fake, that’s filled with preservatives and other chemical horrors.

    • hmm says:

      08:46am | 13/07/09

      Mrs Stanton, I’m sure enjoys delicious “Marble Cake”

    • Eric says:

      08:46am | 13/07/09

      Puh-lease, enough with the superstitious panic.

      All foods are made of “chemicals”, even the “natural” ones. And just because something grows in the wild doesn’t mean it can’t be poisonous.

      I’d rather eat a little preservative than die from salmonella.

    • Rob A says:

      08:46am | 13/07/09

      Agree David.  I think Rosemary needs to get a reality check here, there are ‘bigger fish to fry’  I’ll continue to enjoy the time making a cake with my kids.

    • Richard says:

      08:57am | 13/07/09

      Leave Bindy alone!!

    • Peter says:

      09:00am | 13/07/09

      Stanton is a hard-core meat-hating vegan busybody.  She hates corporate food production with a fervour rarely seen outside the loopy Left.  If you don’t grow it in your own backyard, then you’re some sort of criminal.

    • Julie says:

      09:03am | 13/07/09

      Some of my favourite memories as a child are around the kitchen table with mum and nanna baking cakes and licking the spoon. Let kids be kids for gods sake! Despite my indulgence in cake baking once every few weeks or so as a child, im healthly, Who would have thought?

    • A. Stannard says:

      09:03am | 13/07/09

      If it wasn’t for the cake being connected to Bindi Irwin I doubt that this article would have made it to the big time. Enough already, if making a cake with your kids is wrong then we are all living in a very sad world.

    • Jana B says:

      09:06am | 13/07/09

      Yes, making cakes as a family is a nice thing to do. But on the other hand isn’t it a worry that children might think you make a cake with a packet mix?  Hardly likely to encourage their understanding of all the ingredients. I think we should be more concerned about the rise of packet mixes and “Betty Crocker’s One Minute in the Microwave Chocolate Brownie”. And cakes made the proper way taste better. Final point, we need children to be more aware of what they eat and what’s in it because there are plenty of companys (like Greens) which will be using clever marketing to get them to not just buy their products - but accept their products - and if it works for Greens - it will most likely work for MacDonalds and KFC etc..

    • Owen says:

      09:06am | 13/07/09

      What a complete and utter joke. Seriously people there is nothing wrong with a cake every now and then (even a packet mix one!).

      If people like this want to be outspoken about something they should do it for something that really counts in the greater scheme of things. The homeless, starvation, povety etc.

    • Evan says:

      09:08am | 13/07/09

      Show me a 100% chemical free cake and I’ll pay you $1 million dollars

    • RobA says:

      09:10am | 13/07/09

      OMG!  You mean packet cake mix isnt ‘real’ cake.  Even if you make a ‘real’ cake, you’ll buy processed bleached flour, and milk that has been pasturised, homogenised and bug$%^$$d with. And the eggs you’ll buy are probably cage farmed so wheres the ethical message in that for the kiddies? The point is ALL cake can be bad for you, I can make a fully organic ‘homemade’ chocolate cake that will be 10 times nutritionally worse than packet cake mix… the ingredients are not the point…  making a cake can be a fun and bonding time in a family… it’s wrong of Rosemary to say that the message ‘its ok to eat cake’ is a bad message for kids… of course it’s ok to eat cake! and its better to have fun making it with mum and dad than buying it from the supermarket!... just dont make it a regular part of your diet.

    • TR says:

      09:13am | 13/07/09

      Finally a good, intelligent news article… and then the first two comments are completely rubbish. I do recall when it was ok for mothers to cook with lard and food was about taste and nobody cared too much what went in to make it happen. Its quite amusing to see how small minded and “righteous” some people can be.

      I’m sure that you are all quite happy to grab a packet of tim tams… which has very similar ingredients.

    • bek says:

      09:14am | 13/07/09

      stanton = stupid

    • HH says:

      09:15am | 13/07/09

      Why is everyone so quick to be holier than thou about cake? Following the same line of logic that concludes emulsifiers are ‘chemicals’, which are unnatural and therefore the work of Satan doesn’t seem to fly. Here are some evil processed substances coming from factories that don’t occur in nature: Flour, Vanilla extract, Cocoa,  Butter, Sprinkles, Salt, Sugar, Baby Shampoo, Nappies, Carpet, your car, your house, your clothes, your shoes and the rest of civilisation.

    • Lexi says:

      09:15am | 13/07/09

      I’m lost on her correlation between artificially inflating food prices, thereby removing the export market, thereby making food affordable for pensioners?  Or does the rest of society pay more for food so that no food gets to, oh say, NZ, and then we have food stamps or ration books for aged pensioners?  What about low income earners? Seriously weird logic, there.

      Cripes, she’s a bit of an old hippy wet blanket these days, old Rosemary, isn’t she.  No cake for kids?! Why don’t we also ban them from swimming pools (chlorine you know), parks (it’s an artifical environment with exotic plants) and parties (the artificial colours are everywhere - beware!).  Sounds like it’s no fun growing up in the Stanton house.

    • Joan says:

      09:17am | 13/07/09

      For crying out loud. It’s cake, not crak that Bindi is peddling. I would rather my kids have a slice of cake than have chips, or other even more fat laden food.  Mine have always had access to a slice of cake, and are by no means overweight. It’s how much cake they eat, not the fact they are eating cake

    • Marty says:

      09:17am | 13/07/09

      I once knocked my brother out in an effort to be the one who got to lick the spoon and icing mixture bowl.  Don’t cross me Rosemary Stanton!

    • Jay says:

      09:18am | 13/07/09

      God—its just cake

    • Debby says:

      09:26am | 13/07/09

      Looks like Bindi is eating a little too much cake!!!

    • KATHRYN DICKINSON says:

      09:26am | 13/07/09

      FOR GOD SAKE THEY’RE MAKING A CAKE, NOT SELLING DRUGS.
      NOT SURE IF ANYONE IS AWARE BUT IN THESE TIMES BOTH PARENTS HAVE TO WORK OR YOU END UP ON THE PENSION. ANY FAMILY TIME WHETHER IT BE TOGETHER COOKING A CAKE OR JUST SPENDING TIME TOGETHER IS PRECIOUS, CARE FACTOR IS ZERO IF BINDI IS PROMOTING ENJOYING FAMILY TIME WITH THE ONE PARENT SHE HAS LEFT, LEAVE THEM ALONE ROSEMARY!

    • Adam says:

      09:27am | 13/07/09

      There is nothing wrong with cake in moderation. Thats the point all these left wing types keep forgetting. Its alright to let your kids eat junk food so long as its in moderation. Morever, i cannot stand these people who act all “we better stop that” as its if they think parents cant raise their own darn children.

    • Bourke says:

      09:27am | 13/07/09

      Frail, pale and sickly. Rosemary Stanton has always looked as though she could do with a big, thick steak.

    • Anne says:

      09:28am | 13/07/09

      Hmmmm, let’s see…
      Option a) Occasionally make a cake (packet, from scratch, whatever) with “help” from the kids, let them lick the spoon, and watch the smiles when they proudly serve it to friends or family with a sense of accomplishment and hopefully, fun memories when they’re older.  While you’re at it, buy them a chocolate frog to eat after their salad sandwich, let them help choose the veggies that will go into tonight’s stirfry or casserole,  have takeaway every now and then, grow a carrot top on some cotton wool and live like a normal person.
      Option b) Ban cakes, icecream, lollies, chocolate, soft drink, heck, anything that Elmo calls a “sometimes food” and watch your kids turn into uptight, cranky adults who’ll rebel as soon as they’re old enough and gorge themselves on whatever junk food they can lay their hands on.
      I know which I’d prefer!

    • Lisa Williams says:

      09:33am | 13/07/09

      get a life, Bindi Irwin has done more for this world that you have..let kids be kids.

    • A says:

      09:34am | 13/07/09

      I hate it when they assume that a parent is automatically going to cave in to their childrens demands for something simply because a famous person is advertising a product. It is up to the parents whether or not they buy something for their kids to eat or play with. If a parent is that weak that they cave into the slightest demands from their offspring, then they are more likely to be filling said child up with McDonalds or KFC than a cake mix. My mother is against Cake mixes, she used to make the cakes from scratch. And they were just as fattening then. Having a cake mix every now and then is not going to hurt anyone, as long as you balance is out with Fruit during the day and Vegetables with dinner. I think it is a great way to get kids into the kitchen to make the cakes themselves. So simple and less mess. I agree with teaching good nutrition, but back off just a little bit. Encourage kids to eat anything in moderation.

    • Adam says:

      09:35am | 13/07/09

      I invoke the ghost of Marie Antoinette, “Let them eat cake!”

      (And yes I know she probably never said these words but let’s not spoil a good story eh?)

      For a yummy cake recipe you can’t go past:
      http://www.taste.com.au/recipes/5235/chocolate+cake
      grin

    • Kate Jackson says:

      09:41am | 13/07/09

      Geez she wouldn’t be happy with the rather elaborate birthday cake that I whipped up over the weekend for my son’s birthday, using packet mix, would she????  Sure know my kid loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • Sir Fred says:

      09:43am | 13/07/09

      Its not fair on the public when popular figures tie their names to unhealthy products. From the size of Bindi it does not look like her mother is stupid enough to allow her to eat a lot of what she is promoting. So why inflict it on other kids who look up to Bindi ?? The next time you see a fat kid wobbling along with pieces of cake being stuffed in the mouth you can thank Terry Irwin. What next, will little bob be washing down his cake with a ‘healthy’ quaff of Coca Cola… or perhaps the two of them will line up to promote Macca’s Happy Meals. Terry Irwin seems the type that would sell her soul if she could find a buyer.

    • Natty says:

      09:50am | 13/07/09

      Damn you Adam! I read through all the comments, ready to write ‘let them eat cake’, and you beat me to it!

    • Nathan Root says:

      09:50am | 13/07/09

      This article has truely opened my eyes! I’ve been an addict for years now. The stain it’s put on my life and family, the terrifying   visits to Bindi’s ‘kids cake crack house! That time Bindi roughed me up when I couldn’t pay her.  It’sall so clear. It’s time to say NO MORE!  It is time to take down these evil Cartels,  Aunt   Jemima,  Betty Crocker….White Wings and   Greens. The people have spoken, thy time is   now…..

    • MD says:

      09:53am | 13/07/09

      Well I now have a higher level of respect for Rosemary Stanton after reading this article (my respect level for he wasn’t huge before mind you).  Thank goodness someone realises there is more to nutrition than just simple fat, sugar and salt levels.  My goodness David, how difficult is it to make a cake for children out of actual food?  My 6 year old can quite easily go to the pantry and get butter, honey or organic sugar, free range eggs and organic unbleached flour to make a basic cake.  Hell she can even mash actual bananas herself instead of buying some dodgy packet mix filled with health sapping ingredients and giving profit to a huge company instead of our local farmers where the money belongs.

      It really not that hard to just mix the dry ingredients and have control over what goes in your food.  A much more on the money nutritionist in Cyndi O’Meara.  Google her, her weekly newsletters are fascinating reading…

    • Kate says:

      09:54am | 13/07/09

      I’m just glad that Rosemary isn’t my mum!! I’d hate to think what was considered a treat in her house…anyone for brussel sprouts??

    • natalie says:

      09:54am | 13/07/09

      Sir Fred, how about you learn to spell? It’s T E R R I

    • Sar says:

      10:01am | 13/07/09

      And Sir Fred, you appear the type of personality that would have me sobbing into my cucumber salad if I were ever unfortunate enough to sit next to you at a dinner party.

      Everything in moderation is the key, you boring old sod! The great unwashed public are not so stupid as you think.

    • C says:

      10:03am | 13/07/09

      I can’t fathom people who wash their dishes in chemicals, yet only eat organic food claiming it is healthy because there are no chemicals.

      What about all the chemicals that your food is rolling around in?

    • Russ says:

      10:09am | 13/07/09

      Given that Ms Stanton looks like death warmed over, I wouldnt be too concerned. By the way, an egg can be classed as an emulsifier so everybody panic. Moderation in everything.

    • Kathrin says:

      10:12am | 13/07/09

      For Christ’s sake - when will preople realise that kids have been eating this stuff for years and the obesity epidemic is a more recent problem?  used to eat this stuff as kids and weren’t all obese - because it was OCCASSIONAL food, not an every day food.  The same with McDonalds, it was an occassional treat, but now, with Happy Meals, it has to be at least once a week so children get the latest toy.

    • brendan says:

      10:13am | 13/07/09

      Get a LIFE!!!
      Why should the Irwin family be treated any different just because they have lost a loved one.

    • Harry says:

      10:15am | 13/07/09

      Absolutely agree that there’s nothing wrong with a bit of cake every now and then, and don’t see that Bindi is doing much harm by promoting it. Rosemary Stanton does eemto have gone a bit overboard with that one. But I cannot accept your argument that the Irwins are beyond reproach just because of the tragic nature of Steve Irwin’s death. Losing your father in a terrible accident at a young age does not make you immune form criticism if you are doing something that is genuinely damaging or dangerous.

    • Sarah says:

      10:16am | 13/07/09

      I’m sorry, I agree with Rosemary Stanton.  It’s fine to make cakes with your kids, even using Greens or other packet mixes, but it’s really not such a good idea to use children, especially well known children to sell products direct to other kids.  As said earlier, it is an underhanded way to sell something.  When you use any famous person to sell something, people take it to mean that they are wholeheartedly endorsing the product.  This should be done very carefully.

    • SJ says:

      10:17am | 13/07/09

      surely there are more important things to be worried about that Bindi Irwin and a cake add. how pathetic can some people be. cake is a treat and should be allowed in moderation.

    • Von says:

      10:20am | 13/07/09

      My objection with packet cake is that it is way too sweet. Cake does NOT need to be that sweet. The sweetness kills all other taste there is in the cake. Hence I prefer to make my own. I haven’t yet found a cake mix that isn’t crazily sweet.

    • Nads says:

      10:28am | 13/07/09

      Penbo, I’m somewhere between you and Sag on this one. All things in moderation I say. I would much prefer the start from scratch approach to baking, even with the kids. But I have to confess that as a busy working single mum, even I have gone the packet option from time to time with the sproglets. It is a quick, easy option and ultimately harmless.

      Besides you can start ‘em on the packet stuff to spark their interest and then tweak it and get them making the more ‘complex’ start from scratch versions when they can also load the dishwasher and clean up the mess in the kitchen! And it’s still better out of a packet/jar than it is out of a drivethru on the way home, ie it is still a form of cooking over takeaway.

      I’m so not a fan of an Irwin, of any variety, but being puritanical about cake is just not on. shame rosemary shame

    • Geoff says:

      10:28am | 13/07/09

      Ms Stanton is completely right.  It is well known that Cake is a gateway to hard drugs.  I tried Cake once as a youngster and suffered addiction problems all through my teen years, in fact it’s only recently that I feel I have control over my Cake problem and can turn it down if offered (although I still indulge in limited recreational usage).  I was always scrawny as a child and I am sure it was because I used Cake instead of eating real food.  Now that my diet is more balanced I have reached a healthy weight.

    • KQ says:

      10:30am | 13/07/09

      ahhh good times
      As a kid I was allowed to cook packet mix cakes. My confidence in the kitchen was born and I felt like I contributed to the family. Who knew the evil truly lerking XD.

    • RT says:

      10:34am | 13/07/09

      As long as the Irwins don’t wash their cake down with that evil bottled water it’s all good. They seem more like a cake n coke family to me.

    • jess says:

      10:34am | 13/07/09

      i love this story. sarcasm may be the lowest form of wit, but i think it has it’s place in this story. what a joke, i have a 3 year old daughter, and i alternate between cake mixes and making from scratch. if she is helping i use a mix, its simpler, and cleaner, and faster, and she loves being involved. Mind you, she has seen the ads, and is more interested in the bag tags than the apparent cake peddling that is happening…. please, there are more important things to be concerned about.

    • Patti says:

      10:35am | 13/07/09

      I cannot believe your comment Debby.  No wonder children have eating problems with comment like that.  Bindi is a healthy size, what do you want her to be anorexic like the models of this world.  For goodness sake what does it hurt if a child eats a little cake every now and then?  I would rather that then a trip down to McDonalds or KFC.  By the way who has said she eats cake anyway, it is an ad for a cake mix.  She is a TV personality making an ad and doing her job for a cake mix company.  How many other people that do commercials actually eat or us the products that the advertise.  Not many I would think.

    • Cameron says:

      10:35am | 13/07/09

      Will someone please think of the children. They did and she’s a nutter.


      Oh they did, and she is a nutter…

    • Kat says:

      10:36am | 13/07/09

      Rosemary Stanton do you have to be such a fun cop all the time?
      The miserable look that’s always been on your face for years pretty much sums up your whole attitude to life.  As long as cake is in moderation, what’s the harm?

    • Burt says:

      10:52am | 13/07/09

      So, Resemary Stanton is worried that the message we give our children is that it is OK to eat cake? Isn’t that the same message we give our kids every birthday?
      Crikey Rosemary - it’s called fun.

    • Darren says:

      10:55am | 13/07/09

      So many people saying it’s ok to eat cake, let our children eat cake. Don’t worry about the ingredients, lets just all have fun and eat more.

      No wonder why Australia now has the largest obesity rates in the world.

      I am feeling very worried about our future.

    • Bea says:

      10:55am | 13/07/09

      Anne, you are dead right!!! Couldnt have put it better myself…

    • Mrs V says:

      10:55am | 13/07/09

      God, this makes me mad!!!

      The world has gone beyond healthy eating to actively encouraging children to be scared of food. I wouldn’t be surprised if there is a substantial rise in eating disorders in the coming years.

      “Oh, I CAN’T have that, it has sugar”
      “cheese should ALWAYS be reduced fat”
      “You only gave me 5 carrot sticks with my meal, Mr waiter, and I NEED 6, and please bring me potato with NO butter on, my calorie count is already up on yesterday”

      In the end, the kids / young adults with these issues all end up at the same place…the Nutritionist. Nice work Rosemary, keeping yourself in a job either way.

    • Sm says:

      11:10am | 13/07/09

      excuse me but when is it not ok to eat cake!!!

    • Rob Dick says:

      11:14am | 13/07/09

      I saw the ad the other day. Kids and Mum making a cake. Plenty of supervision. Little brother even got to help with the icing. Nice ad. At the very end it clicked that it was the Irwin family. Cool. Why not use a high profile family to sell a product? There was a cake ad a few years ago that had to be changed because of the complaints of the politically correct. To quote from the original ad “My Mum says your Mum should get a life”.

    • NO says:

      11:19am | 13/07/09

      Oh come on Rosemary…as been said before, it’s cake not crack….and it’s not like Bindi is telling kids to eat it every meal. I have no respect for the remaining Irwin’s as I agree that Terri would sell her soul to the right buyer but this is ridiculous!!

    • GA says:

      11:23am | 13/07/09

      When was the last time you saw a healthy looking nutritionist?

    • n says:

      11:31am | 13/07/09

      given how many obese children there are in Australia, I don’t think the Irwins should be promoting cake.

    • Billy says:

      11:32am | 13/07/09

      Reading this was a complete waste of time. The only notable part was when you mentioned how sleding of the Irwins was unacceptable due to Steve’s death - I’m not sure whether or not you were joking, but if a death in the family grants you immunisation from criticism, wow, then there goes the entire population of critics.

      Oh, and by the way, for people who would listen to anything Bindi says about cake:

      http://www.blogcdn.com/www.tmz.com/media/2008/07/0724_bindy_irwin_wi.jpg

    • skinny says:

      11:37am | 13/07/09

      Childhood obesity isn’t on the rise, it’s been the same for the last ten years. How convenient for the anti-cake brigade to make continual reference to a statistic that’s just not true. Cannot find anywhere reliable showing Australia has the highest obesity rates either, only news articles without reference.

    • Peter Taylor says:

      11:42am | 13/07/09

      Lucky for my kids, they’ve got parents that don’t get swayed by the ever-changing ramblings of these so-called ‘experts”. Nope, my kids’ parents take a common sense approach to parenting and don’t bother with all this “trendy one minute, evil the next” garbage that constantly spews forth from someone merely looking to shore up their next funding round or sell their next book! My kids parents teach them to think for themselves and not just blindly follow what someone else tells them to do just because they’re a celebrity or call themselves an expert. And the best bit about this is that my kids’ parents’ parents took the same approach with their kids. And, I hope, when my kids are parents, they’ll take a leaf out of what their parents did!

    • Jamie says:

      11:51am | 13/07/09

      The Cake is a Lie!

    • S says:

      11:53am | 13/07/09

      Just to inform some of you about the “harmful” chemicals in this cake and other products.  Emulsifiers 471, 477, 472e and 481 are all just simple modified fats. The fats that are chosen are those that are found naturally in the body. For instance 471 is glyceryl sterate which your own body generates every time you burn some of your own fat. These food chemicals are almost always designed this way so no harmful effects can occur.  Like the evil thickner 1442 - which is a just a modified starch. generally these products are added so even the lousiest of cooks, like me, can make something edible for the myself and the kiddies…which I certainly do for my kids, without a second thought. Please get informed before you dump on stuff you have no idea about.

    • A says:

      11:54am | 13/07/09

      Lara, I’m with you! It’s not about the kids eating loads of sugar, fat, chocolate or junky sweets like cake and biscuits etc, it’s about the ingredients on the packet being identified by a “number”! Stop feeding them convenient PACKET cakes when you can feed them the REAL thing, chock full of the GOOD ingredients (butter, sugar, eggs, chocolate, etc)!

    • iansand says:

      12:06pm | 13/07/09

      Think of the stingrays.

    • Stella says:

      12:09pm | 13/07/09

      I knew Terri Irwin couldn’t stay away from publicity for very long. So this time she’s flogging cakes instead of “choc crocs”. I don’t know why she’s talking about her “love of cooking” when in an interview she once admitted to not being able to “boil water”. With all this commercialism a person could be forgiven in thinking Terri Irwin was struggling financially instead of being just plain greedy.

    • Guylian says:

      12:16pm | 13/07/09

      I’m having chocolate cake made from a packet mix for breakfast right now, so I’m really getting a kick out of this article. smile

    • Steve says:

      12:18pm | 13/07/09

      Please no more stories about the Irwin kids or their other.  I am so sick of the exploitation that this family is a part of and that clearly they are using for their own good, whether it is an advertisement, a feel good news story, a save the crocodiles, a donate money to such and such a block of land that Steve uses to protect the environment, or any other grab for attention and bucks, that if I see their face, hear their voices, etc I immediately turn off.

    • SF says:

      12:21pm | 13/07/09

      its cake…

    • Chi says:

      12:28pm | 13/07/09

      Call me crazy, but I would have thought it’s better for kids to be up on their feet actually DOING things (like mixing cake mix, moving around the kitchen, pouring batter and decorating) than to be sitting on their arses eating biscuits from a package - besides which, cake is a shared food - you take it to school, you share it with friends and family.

      If you want to find a culprit for kids with bad eating habits, blame all the pre-packaged foods that are designed to be scoffed, rather than shared.

      Now let’s all go and bake a nice cake!

    • Scott says:

      12:29pm | 13/07/09

      the problem is that people would actually take any notice of advertising at all no matter hwo the figure is whom advertises it, if you don’t know that things are bad thats your fault the information on additives has been readily available for years, you cannot legislate against stupidity yet governments and other bodies keep wasting time trying to do it , and all the talk about obesity, and nothign about the massive issue of malnourishment and eating disorders full stop is the problem of the media and advertising

    • Kato says:

      12:41pm | 13/07/09

      I don’t care who eats the crap as long as it isn’t fed to wildlife. People can choose to poison themselves… we are the most intelligent species on the planet right?

    • KH says:

      12:42pm | 13/07/09

      Who ever said that cake was SUPPOSED to be healthy?

      It’s supposed to be a treat - like on your birthday.

      No more birthdays for the party police!

    • Kath says:

      01:03pm | 13/07/09

      My little one doesn’t know who Bindi Irwin is yet (won’t be long)... but he does know what cake is and he likes to watch (or sometimes help) Mummy make a cake.

      He doesn’t need Bindi to want cake.  And Mummy doesn’t need a nutritionist to tell her that cake should only be eaten in moderation.

    • EJ says:

      01:03pm | 13/07/09

      The only thing that pisses me off is being force fed by the Bindi brigade. I’m sick to death of hearing about her, seeing her & being told what to think by her. Then again I guess it’s all the fault of the companies that are using her to make profits from. ENOUGH ALREADY!!!!!

    • carson power says:

      01:08pm | 13/07/09

      S says:
      “Please get informed before you dump on stuff you have no idea about”

      Do not accuse people of not knowing the facts.

      You conveniantly left out E155 Brown HT. This is a colouring pigment suspected to cause extreme hyperactivity in children.  It is also BANNED in the following countries

      Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, United States, Norway, Switzerland, and Sweden

      No one should be eating this compound. It is dangerous.

      Disodium 4,4’-(2,4-dihydroxy-5-hydroxymethyl-1,3-phenylene bisazo) di (naphthalene-l-sulphonate)

      mmmm, yummy.

    • Paul says:

      01:10pm | 13/07/09

      My problem is not with cake although I do try to reduce the amount of additives in our food, I personally don’t eat cake, preference, but my kids like to cook cakes and eat them in moderation. I’ve found it gives them a sense of achievement and they proudly show off their handy work, my problem is the fact that a food company is using Bindi Irwin to flog food, trying to trade on the Irwin name thats what sucks and Rosemary should get of her Lettuce leaf and complain about instead

    • Nai says:

      01:10pm | 13/07/09

      ...how often do people eat cake that this is seriously a problem?
      ...maybe we should save the cake for birthdays huh?

    • Alis says:

      01:27pm | 13/07/09

      Is it cake in general that she is against or is it the chemical cakes she doesn’t like? This article implies it’s just cake, and if so, she sounds pretty hardcore and passionate about having the best diet possible. Which is great! But in reality, there aren’t that many people who are that concerned about it. All you can do is inform people about what is in their food and the effects that certain ingredients can have on their bodies. Whether they eat it or give it to their children is up to them.
      Most people enjoy celebrating with something sweet. Why not? We’re only going to die someday anyway…

    • Nerida says:

      01:32pm | 13/07/09

      Firstly, for anyone who hasn’t seen the ad/s, you can view them on the Green’s Foods website here (there are 2 ads):
      http://www.greensbaking.com.au/crikey.html#watchVideo

      My first thought mirrored that of Sarah @10.16am - children shouldn’t be used to advertise to other children. 

      Then I thought about ads I’d seen as a child which used children: these included Bata Scout school shoes (damn, I wanted a pair of them SO BAD!), Nerf toys and any number of other toy ads - all of which I “desperately” wanted and pestered my parents to buy me; all of which I never got.

      So here’s my final thought:  who’s in charge of the shopping trolley - the parent/s or the child?  When the kids start going into supermarkets and buying packet cake mix with their own money, then I’ll reconsider my position.

      Or we could try another approach…. Parents:  how about you just say NO if you don’t like it?  Or - and here’s a really radical thought - don’t let your kids watch so much television that they’re so indoctrinated by ads… how about you switch off the television and play a game with them, or get involved with them in some outdoor activity?

      ooh, I’m sounding a bit too much like a dirty hippy now, I guess.

    • Lisa says:

      01:41pm | 13/07/09

      There’s nothing wrong with Bindi endorsing a cake. I don’t know about everyone here but I buy greens but it’s not something I give my children everyday. Besides I think the point was it’s a great thing to make with the children. Leave the Irwins alone. I honestly think it’s more about attacking them than the matter of the cake. At the end of the day if you think it’s that bad don’t give it to your children.

    • M de Q says:

      04:45pm | 13/07/09

      Oh for goodness sake Rosemary Stanton - get a life!!!

      After all these years of nutritional advice you haven’t learnt that natural fun foods (gee wizz cake baked at home) is actually good food. Good for the body, mind and soul. Happy kids are healthy kid. Go and reek your revenge on the chemical, junk food and additive companies - that is why we have fat kids.

      We have fat kids because Mums aren’t home to make sure they get a piece of fruit and cold drink in summer, and a piece of cake and hot cocoa in winter and sent off to play in the afternoons after school.

      Haven’t you learnt that eating and particularly bad eating habits are based around the emotional, psychological and behavioral eating habits of the brain and environmental mismanagement of their parents ans social attitudes pushed by the media and advertising agencies.

      Good on you Bindi, good on you to writer of the article ‘David Penberthy’

    • Marco D says:

      06:04pm | 13/07/09

      It does actually promote family time, though. It isn’t just about making the cake, although this would obviously be Green’s angle -  “Spend some family time together - with Green’s Cake Mix”. But would many modern, busy Mums have the time to bake a cake from scratch? It is a dying art for a reason. The packet mixes, while not nutritious ( are any cakes?), are probably a step in the right direction. Preservatives and other additives are par for the course these days, unless you eat only fresh fruit and vegetables that you grow yourself.
      Besides, they have a right to earn a living as a well known family. Endorsement of a cake mix would be better than seen eating at a fast food restaurant, wouldn’t it?

    • Lee says:

      10:25pm | 13/07/09

      Its a shame more kids don’t have the enjoyable experiance of making a cake , My kids are in their thirtys and are by know means any worse off for the experiance they had making packet cakes . Most of them are glued to syber games or TV , or the internet . thats what makes them fat .

    • Timothy says:

      07:14am | 14/07/09

      One of your best David!! And I agree with Bourke….Ma Stanton has always looked near death’s door to me. She could indeed use a big steak. And we all know who was supposed to have said, “let them eat cake”. So eat it while you can folks. There may not be much of it around in times to come.

    • Dr Rosemary Stanton says:

      05:14pm | 14/07/09

      Wow - you lot are a bit much! Thanks for the insults - made my day! For the record, I was phoned by a journalist and asked if I thought having Bindi Irwin advertise a packet cake mix was a good message. I said no and added that I thought it was a bit sad that she was being used in this way. I stick to that. But that doesn’t mean I think no one should ever eat cake. I made cakes with my own children and now with my grandchildren - not every day, but always on birthdays and special occasions and sometimes just because it was a rainy day and the thought of cake was good. And yes, we always licked the bowl. I don’t see cake as a daily or mundane event - I think of it as an occasional treat and I like it rich and tasting terrific. Also, for the record, I am not a vegan - not even a vegetarian.

    • Darryl Price says:

      07:51pm | 14/07/09

      Let them eat cake

    • Helen says:

      09:41am | 15/07/09

      K. Dickinson, your “Caps Lock” key is located at the far left hand side of your keyboard, under the Tab key.  Clicking Caps Lock to “Off” prevents the Chris and Maree-Hello-Hello shouty effect in your comments. This has been a public service announcement.

    • carson p says:

      04:04pm | 17/07/09

      As I mentioned earlier. This cake mix contains a chemical compound used to substitute caramel, called brown ht 155. It is BANNED in a lot of countries including the US. You lot don’t seem to be bothered though.

      Rosemary, why not mention that? I don’t get it.

      mmmm, 

      Disodium 4,4’-(2,4-dihydroxy-5-hydroxymethyl-1,3-phenylene bisazo) di (naphthalene-l-sulphonate) 

      a sometimes food! Yum!

    • John says:

      07:21am | 02/06/10

      If you followed Rosemary Stanton’s advice you would be living a joyless, low fat life in which food is a chore, and you would probably end up fatter for it. She has peddled the low fat lie for years, probably because she did her training when it was fashionable. She claims now to support the mediterranean diet, but still says we should only use a teaspoon of olive oil when we cook. A teaspoon!! Has she ever eaten at a mediterranean table, and seen the joy of cooking with simple ingredients and making them taste good with olive oil, butter and salt? I think it is time for her to hang up her low fat steamer, and prepare herself for retirement village food. Meanwhile, I will live a long life, enjoying every meal in the traditional European manner, and so will my children.

    • Shelley says:

      09:27am | 18/06/10

      We have gotten way off track here - Rosemary stanton is right, how could you disagree with the rising obesity, chemicals in food and some are banned in other countries and can cause reactions like headaches and worsening of asthma and children looking up to Bindi and thinking that its good for you. Nobodies trying to take away your precious memories of eating cake. R.S is just putting the message about it being a treat and that it doesn’t send the right message. And the comment about parenting our own children - spot on -  but sometimes its good to hear a bit of advice and awareness though because we can get clouded by adverts such as the greens ones thinking its not all that bad. Everyone is entitled to thier opinions so theres no need to go knocking peoples appearences or trying to hurt othes because of it, now thats just low.

    • Shoshana Young says:

      04:55pm | 31/08/10

      BTW somebody spelled Bindi’s name wrong!!  raspberry

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter