Amidst all the manufactured excitement attached to the arrival in Sydney of round-the-world sailor Jessica Watson consider this: Kevin Rudd, the Prime Minister who condemned the work of Bill Henson on the basis of its alleged exploitation of teenage girls and taxed alco-pops for the binge drinking they “encouraged” among the same, is now turning up to celebrate the fact that a teenage girl was allowed to risk her life by sailing round the world for no better reason than to “break a record”.

Jessica Watson: we can be heroes. AP Photo: Rob Griffith

It is just one absurdity among many in the Jessica Watson saga, a story that every day feels more and more like an episode of Chris Lilley’s We Can Be Heroes.

Adventure is on hard times. Once, those journeying into an untamed wilderness further than any man (or teenage girl) before them excited the public imagination not merely because what they were doing was dangerous but because they wished, to quote Tennyson’s words carved in memorial to Robert Scott, “to seek, to find and not to yield.”

These days, exploration has been replaced by “records” which serve no purpose whatsoever – every ocean has been sailed, every mountain climbed, every orange rolled with someone’s nose across the terminal of JFK airport (really).

In a time in which there is even a world record for holding the most world records, “records” must occupy ever more novel niches: first woman to sail solo round the world in a wooden boat; first man with one leg to sail solo round the world backwards; first man with one leg to sail solo round the world backwards in a wooden boat while wearing a Snuggie. As Homer Simpson once said when told he would have to run around the room pulling faces for three years before he could claim the world record for running around the room pulling faces, “Fine, I’ll just play the banjo with this cobra.”

For all the hype, Watson’s journey is just another variation on the same tired buccaneering that saw Tony Bullimore pulled from the sea in 1997. At the time, Bullimore was the subject of enormous public opprobrium for what was deemed his irresponsibility and the heavy burden placed on Australian taxpayers. Had Watson also required rescue or, heaven forbid, died, then her story would, presumably, have attracted a great deal more sympathy, she being blonde, young, female and, most importantly, Australian.

Had the worse happened, one can easily imagine the grand narratives of tragic heroism – the stoic declarations that “Jessica died doing what she loved” – that would have been required to expunge our national guilt for having allowed such a stupid enterprise to happen in the first place.

In an age in which there are perfectly safe methods of crossing the world’s oceans, Watson’s journey is nothing more than a dangerous, narcissistic indulgence. After all, what has she achieved; what do we know now that we didn’t before? That some 16 year-old girls are good sailors? That some 16 year-old girls are incredibly lucky to be alive? That Kevin Rudd is one step off turning up at Melbourne gangland memorial services in an effort to win votes? She’s not even sponsoring a charity!

On her website Watson’s feat is described as “the Everest of sailing”; appropriate considering that Mount Everest is the perfect symbol of our obsession with adventure in an age when the notion is increasingly irrelevant. As one of the most over-climbed mountains in the world, Everest is now strewn with garbage and human faeces. Every day dozens of people walk to the summit, all on the manufactured “adventure of a lifetime”, some breaking “records” – oldest, youngest, blind, one-legged. Far from inspirational these journeys seem to me an indictment of a western obsession with the self, our cult of “experience” and an increasing reluctance to look inward for meaning.

I’m glad Watson made it home alive, but you’ll forgive me if her “record” doesn’t exactly float my boat.

212 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Richie says:

      07:48am | 27/09/10

      Tall Poppy syndrom coming from an unhappy and envious person.
      If it’s not your boat, sail on yours.
      If you don’t see what’s obvious, buy yourself new glasses.
      Self-challenging and setting high goals is the key to progress and inspiration.
      Are you an Australian? I thought there was still an adventurer’s mentality rnning down under. I see there are many morons too. Booooooooo

    • listen to Kant... says:

      01:44am | 03/06/10

      I feel that this article is directed at the wrong people. Jessica is just a sailor. She sailed around the world. That is an amazing achievement. I don’t believe she intended to garner the excessive support, the sponsorship, nor the label of ‘hero’. This article should be attacking the media; the PM: those corporate bastards that seize a popular story and try to make money off it. Granted, Jessica is probably making money off of her journey. But hey, should that diminish her motivations? As Immanuel Kant argued, the moral value of her achievement should be judged virtuous only by her motivations, not by the consequences of her achievement. I think that line of though is particularly valid here.

    • Steve says:

      03:37am | 21/05/10

      The parents should be arrested for child endangerment.

      I’m telling my kids if they want to do something like sailing around the world where the chance of something going horribly wrong is real (and obvious!) that its too dangerous, you are too immature to appreciate the danger, you are under my care and if you want to do that, you can save up when you are an adult, buy your own boat and have at it.

      I dont reckon the kid Watson is a narcisisst, but the parents almost certainly are, not to mention reckless.

    • Squidly says:

      03:42pm | 20/05/10

      Sigh, if only my dreams and achievements could attract corporate sponsorhip, constant mantra-like media attention, lucrative endorsment deals for socially beneficial products like breakfast cereal and the frothy mouthed adulation of the PM….

    • DM says:

      07:32am | 20/05/10

      Mummy didn“t love you as a child Brendan?

    • Calm down people says:

      01:35am | 18/05/10

      If Jessica Watson is an indulgent narcissist, then so are ALL adventurers and sportsmen and women.

      I didn’t see Jesse Martin being bagged out when he sailed solo around the world.  He had sponsorship, he made money out of his voyage.  Jessica is no different.

      Why does it upset people so much that someone achieves something they set out to do?

    • BTS says:

      04:30am | 18/05/10

      It hurts to realise that life is passing you by and you have never achieved anything.  The fanfare, the sponsorship, the accolades, the financial reward could have been theirs, if they had only bothered to get off the couch and did something.  They are jealous of someone who achieves.  The only hope to salvage the situation is get on the computer, with your now vast life experience and criticise those who do make the effort.  It subconsciously relieves the guilt.

    • Peter says:

      10:32pm | 17/05/10

      Dear God in Heaven but I never realised just how many truly miserable buggers there are out there. Sad, grey people who attempt nothing and achieve nothing. Is your collective sense of self-worth so low that you have to belittle the achievment of anyone that does anything more impressive than you? “Oh I volunteer at the Salvos op-shop on alternate Wednesdays and help old Mrs Ferguson take her garbage out! That’s as big a deal as someone in their mid-teams circumnavigating the world solo!”. *NO* IT* ISN’T*

      Get over yourselves. Honestly, I’m trying to hate you people but all I can feel is abject pity.

    • rj says:

      08:35pm | 17/05/10

      I’d rather watch Jessica Watson on the news than all the ‘news’ about Tiger Woods’ sex life.

    • Kitten says:

      06:58pm | 17/05/10

      Brendan, she’s just a teenage girl who followed her dream and succeeded. How would you feel if someone slammed your greatest achievement? Or told you that chasing your dreams was a terrible thing? Writing such a defamatory article reflects on you, not on Jessica. It shows that you are self indulgent and narcissistic, not her.

      How can Jessica not be seen as a good role model? She dreamed, she set herself a goal and she took a risk to achieve her goal, fulfilling her dream. So many young people lack ambition and drive, yet she appears to have it in abundance. As a young person myself, I see countless intelligent students failing classes (at university), or barely passing them, because they have no dream, they have no goals and they certainly lack ambition. Should teenagers really be taught that dreams, goals and ambitions are terrible things? Should I abandon my dream because it is too risky or I’m too young or it is too much work? I’d really rather not.

      So, after reading your article, what do we know now that we didn’t before? We know that the ambitions of those who dream to do great things have been shot down by a narcissistic, self indulgent and frankly petty writer.

    • grant says:

      05:07pm | 17/05/10

      I bet every negative comment here was written by someone who has never accomplished anything in their life.  So Its understandable that they dont ‘get’ what it means to succeed.  Cut down that tall poppy - its making YOU look short! 

      Jess - you an inspiration.

    • Paul says:

      07:06pm | 17/05/10

      Grant, for all the sense it makes I could just as easily make a massive generalisation and say, “I bet every positive comment (about Jessica) here was written by someone who has never accomplished anything in their life.”

      That doesn’t make sense, just as your comment doesn’t make sense.

    • shane says:

      06:16pm | 17/05/10

      Married, working. Masters done, Phd in the works. Traveled, lived and worked in multiple countries. Climbed a variety of hills, walls, towers etc. Learned a language, have 2 cats, play 2 instruments, am concerned about the future direction of the world. I’ve made negative comments about the media coverage and the implications of such above.

      I’m not saying I’m the most accomplished person in the world,  but I certainly don’t think I’ve achieved nothing. Your idiotic comment shows that you obviously haven’t learned much from life though.

    • Steve167 says:

      04:10pm | 17/05/10

      210 days only talking to her parents when she wanted to,, but with full internet access?  Sounds like heaven for the average 16-year old girl.

      Look, good on her for having a fun time, and she’s lucky she has supportive parents.

      I think most of the objections raised here are against the media beat-up rather than herself.

      Try this scenario:

      ‘Mum, Dad, I want to drop out of school for a year to achieve my dream.  It will be a world record! You have to support me!’

      ‘Um…go on.’

      ‘I want to collect the world’s biggest ball of string!’

      ‘$%@#@$#@#$!!!!!!’

      ‘But it’s my dream!  Waaaaaah!!!’

    • Major Tom says:

      03:22pm | 17/05/10

      Space is the final frontier. We should be doing all we can to come up with faster-than light technologies so we can explore the only thing left explorin… everything!

    • shane says:

      03:42pm | 17/05/10

      Here Here. On every level, here bloody here

    • Vicki PS says:

      02:29pm | 17/05/10

      Interesting that fans of Jessica Watson’s achievement feel it necessary to heap abuse on those of us who aren’t leaping with enthusiasm.  It seems you are all unable to separate the girl from the goal and must resort to ad hominem attacks to make your point.

      In contrast, and leaving aside the sniping about sponsorship, equipment etc, (which is quite irrelevant in my view), the belief that Jessica’s trip was unnecessary and a personal indulgence says nothing negative about her worth as a person.  I think she is a young woman of extraordinary capabilities: but I also think she could achieve many more worthwhile goals than a dangerous, pointless and costly trip which will be eagerly exploited by her commercial sponsors (and no, I am not saying she did it for the money)!

      You goggling enthusiasts who need to feed second-hand on other people’s adrenaline do Jessica Watson no honour at all by seeing her only in terms of this one extravagant dare.  As someone else has commented, what would have been the reaction if she had been lost at sea?  The hackneyed “She died doing something she loved”? 

      So do we all, buckos—it’s called breathing.

    • Saskia says:

      05:04pm | 17/05/10

      Bah humbug Vicki PS.  Lighten up pussycat and smell the roses.  Life is good.  I didn’t read all of your spray but there was such a heavy vibe early on that I decided that I don’t need that kind of hate and negativity in my life.

      I hope things get better for you.

    • DocBud says:

      04:58pm | 17/05/10

      And calling a 16 year old girl narcissistic and indulgent is not an ad hominem attack? The response is to the belittling, controlling, judgemental miserabilism of those seeking to decry her achievement and nasty, envious comments such as bored’s: “Who cares about snooty little rich kids paddling around”.

    • Amanda Lawler says:

      01:43pm | 17/05/10

      Don’t get me wrong, it’s an achievement for a 16 year old girl, but to Shane’s point it simply wasn’t as important as it’s become…

    • Amanda Lawler says:

      01:42pm | 17/05/10

      Don’t get me wrong, it’s an achievement for a 16 year old girl, but to Shane’s point it simply wasn’t as important as it’s become…

    • Amanda Lawler says:

      01:27pm | 17/05/10

      Couldn’t agree more…lets have some real heroes to admire….if she’d rescued a mob of boat people along the way then I’d have wasted half an hour applauding her….

    • Willy K says:

      01:35pm | 17/05/10

      Amanda.  Unlike our moronic PM and his typically glib statement, Jessica Watson has NEVER claimed to be a hero just an average person that really wanted to so something and did it.

      Before you trip over yourself in your rush to judge and criticise others how about you reflect upon your own contribution to humankind.  I daresay Jessica will inspire more people to positive ends than all the nasty judgmental snipes that you and your ilk will make against others in a thousand years.

    • shane says:

      01:05pm | 17/05/10

      Why is it so hard for some people to see that it’s possible to appreciate the difficulty and challenge in what she has done, but to also question the validity of it? Only a moron would make the argument that it was “easy” etc. But only a blind idiot could miss the point that the trust of the article comes down to our societies pointless excessive spending and worship of the “records” culture discussed. If you want to sail round the world, fine, go for it. Congratulations, it’s hard. But she didn’t save the world.  To all those who are crapping on about “what have you done that’s better, or more impressive, or more worthy”. There are 2 answers. 1. Nothing, because ultimately it doesn’t matter. I’ll die, she’ll die, you’ll die, the human race will one day die, and then nothing means anything. 2. I treat people with respect. I help and love my friends and family. I work all day. I vote. I work and contribute to society. That’s just as important (and more so arguably) then sailing round the world solo (and don’t give me those BS arguments about sport ā€œinspiringā€ people to greatness).  How inspired will half those ā€œfansā€ be when they can’t get a hospital bed? Will they take comfort in their sporting heroes whilst their dying in a hospital hallway because its vitally important we fund our Olympians to ongoing greatness?
      All those bitching about Brendan’s bitterness and jealously do nothing but show the limits of their feeble understanding and inability to recognise the nuance of argument.

    • shane says:

      08:49am | 18/05/10

      My hole is a whole lot better then your one dimensional grey. Its got different coloured lights & wondering music. Books, movies and poetry from across the ages. There are rational discussion about science and the problems that face the world. Another great thing about my hole; anyone’s welcome as long as they don’t hurt anyone else.
      So me and my friends will stay in our hole. You can have your teetering tower of blindness, and your brightly coloured balls of string.

    • Sam P says:

      06:41pm | 17/05/10

      Shane you are better off saying nothing.  You are digging yourself a hole.

      Jessica did great job.  Accept that and move on.

    • Paul says:

      06:27pm | 17/05/10

      Good point Shane and expressed well.

    • JJJ says:

      06:19pm | 17/05/10

      Shane, just so you feel a bit of love - I totally agree with you. It’s great she has done what she has done, but it’s just as great that I do what I do everyday and likewise for you. To all you other haters - perhaps you should read what Shane has said. He (nor Brendan) are being negative… it’s just sensible perspective.

    • shane says:

      04:31pm | 17/05/10

      Again, I have no problems with anyone finding inspiration in her efforts. And I’m sure it was tough, and I’m sure I couldn’t do it. I do though take issue with the implication that I’m being negative about her. I’m being negative about the way the media, and society place excessive value on these events. I don’t care who people find inspiration in. The more people are inspired by whatever it is they’re inspired by, the better. I’m inspired by a number of people; scientists, artists, authors, and increasingly rarely, journalists. IT’S NOT ABOUT JESSICA.  Yes, her name is in the article, there’s a picture of her and her boat. But what is the article ABOUT?? Is it about criticising her multiple media deals? Is it about saying that what she did wasn’t tough? Dangerous? Pick your adjective.
      No, it’s about a society which places such immense weight on the ā€œinspirationā€ people derive from arbitrary records such as ā€œthe youngest person to sail round the worldā€.
      I don’t care WHERE people derive their inspiration. I DO care that society trumpets the increasingly dangerous and bizarre as that which is inspiring. I find that concerning.

    • Randal says:

      03:47pm | 17/05/10

      The pont is Shane why do you and the others who are commenting so negatively as well as the author of this piece feel a need to lecture the rest of us who we choose to be inspired by the achievements of another.

      I have no issue with you or others having little interest or not finding inspiration in her story, but why do you think that gives you and the others some right to provide those that are some moral lesson on what we should be inspired by,

      We are all inspired and driven in different ways by what others achieve and teh actions of those around us and I am happy to respect your right to be inspired by whatever you choose without judgment, and would not denegrate from where you seek inspiration and I believe that you should so equal respect to others,

    • shane says:

      02:50pm | 17/05/10

      I am chilled out. I couldn’t care less if she sailed around the world. Congratulations. Regardless of age it’s a big achievement. I’m happy that another human achieve an arbitrary goal they set, and I can see that some may gain inspiration from it. I’m simply making the point that people commenting that Brendan is somehow bitter and jealous of her achievement is nothing but a failure to see to the crux on the article. Whether it was Jessica, the guys who paddled across to New Zealand, someone swimming across the Atlantic, whatever, there is a legitimate question to ask about the amount of time and effort our society spends fixating on these events. I’m not saying that the media should stop all reporting on this stuff, but as someone above said, did we need it simulcast on 4 channels and blanket coverage on the national news? Again for those with no ability to see through a sentence. Jessica, the worlds fattest person, a chimp with one leg and 4 testicles, whatever, the argument is about our societies priorities. Jessica is simply a segue, may she go on to be the happiest, most successful, most publicly lauded person in the history of the world for all I care. But THAT is not the point.

    • Jaye Nash says:

      01:50pm | 17/05/10

      What she has done is a hell of a lot more than you have by sitting here whining about it. Jess has NOTHING to do with the amount of hospital beds. She does inspire people. Its not about what she actually does but the fact that she has gone out there and given it a go!!

    • Saskia says:

      01:23pm | 17/05/10

      Who cares Shane.

      Jessica did a bloody good job.  Chill out and try and be happy for another human being for at least 10 seconds.

    • TM says:

      01:04pm | 17/05/10

      She and / or her PR team (up until her website was edited) were attempting to claim victory over Jesse Martin. Jesse Martin completed the circuit according to the criteria laid down by the WSSRC:

      •  Properly and in line with nautical distance requirements
      •  For the most part whilst 16, turning 17 on the boat
      •  Without 24/7 on-line communication

      A member of her PR team responded to concerns raised by Sailworld in relation to their query about shortfalls in the distance she travelled as follows:

      We are not really interested in the technical concerns of a minority, so the tide can rise. The rising tide of her supporters is a millions multiple of the minority.

      To be honest mate, we have much bigger fish to fry right now!

      This is an absolute insult to Jesse, others like him and the sporting body.

    • Jaye says:

      12:32pm | 17/05/10

      Wow bitter much?
      I have nothing but praise for Jess. Not only did she sail solo around the world (wow, I’m sure having the internet and GPS tracking really makes up for seeing another human in 210 days) but now she comes back and has to put of with people putting her down and critising her all because she got out there and chased her dream. Grow up, get a life and let this amazing teenage girl enjoy all the success that comes her way. That green eyed monster has struck again.

    • Bored says:

      12:24pm | 17/05/10

      Good to see some thought applied to this ridiculous story. The only thing remarkable about Jessica Watson was that she had parents willing to buy her a yacht. If my folks taught me to fly and bought me a plane at age 12, I might have been the youngest person ever to circumnavigate the world by air. Who cares about snooty little rich kids paddling around with a swarm of helicopters and flotilla of watchful support crew making sure the danger was as close to nothing. It’s a nothing achievement and a nothing story.

    • DocBud says:

      11:07pm | 17/05/10

      Pink Lady is owned by Don McIntyre who loaned it to Jessica. But hey, bored, don’t let facts get in the way of your puerile prejudices borne of your bitter and twisted nothing life.

    • Randal says:

      11:52am | 17/05/10

      I feel very sorry for Brendan and the others who have posted such negative comments in regards to this remarkable young lady.

      Have you all now reached a point in your lives that you cannot be inspired by the achievements of others, do you really believe that it is so wrong for people look upon someone like a Jessica Watson who has followed a dream and achieves a goal and find that this in some way helps them strive towards their own goals in life?

      Have you become so negative in your own lives that you would begrudge those youngsters who have felt a connection with Jessica and are now setting goals in their life to achieve their dreams?

      For me I see a young girl, who inspired by another wonderful teenager -  Jesse Martin, drew a picture of herself conquering the oceans and then set about achieving that dream, and has done so amazingly as a 16 year old.

      A young lady who still has so much life to live and will no doubt now focus on the next phase of her life, filled with the knowledge that she can achieve anything that she sets her mind to - a life without limitations.

      What a wonderful way to live one’s life, and if in doing so inspiring the same belief in others, and how that can be seen as anything else is beyond me, and says more about this author and those that have followed his cynical view that it does about Jessica or those who have chosen to be inspired by her achievements.

    • bigmuzz says:

      11:42am | 17/05/10

      i was wondering if it is still considered “solo” when she didn’t sail the return length of the harbour alone, she had others sail for her as she mucked about talking on tv, eating fruit, etc… surely she should have pulled up to the dock alone?!? still a great achievement, it was just strange to see this on saturday…

    • bella starkey says:

      11:46am | 17/05/10

      The start and finish line were the heads.

    • PB says:

      10:52am | 17/05/10

      Saildog is the only contributor to this that has had anything meaningful to say. All the rest of you who keep harping on about mod cons, laptops etc. What rubbish - modern electronics do nothing more than verify what is done the old fashioned way, with charts, compasses, sextants, dead reckoning and sailing and navigation skill. The same ridiculous argument has been trotted out about using calculators in exams. Keyboard cowards the lot of you, without the guts to venture beyond your local Westfield.

    • DocBud says:

      03:19pm | 17/05/10

      “Saildog is the only contributor to this that has had anything meaningful to say.”

      I’m hurt, PB.

    • Q says:

      10:22am | 17/05/10

      She has a manager, a polished website complete with store selling Jessica Watson products, a book deal, a cult following (like all true cults, they’re happy to gloss over fact that make things sound even a little off), a doco in the works, and many public appearancs scheduled. All before she had even finished the trip! She did it with all the mod cons, including computer access which gave her the ability to maintain constant contact with family, friends and facebook followers.

      Enough said.

    • kelly says:

      10:10am | 17/05/10

      wow this article misses the point…
      If some people believe this this whole thing to be self indulgent, or uninspiring to them, that’s fair enough. I definitely agree the media has over hyped the whole thing beyond belief, which is nothing new. There are those bored by the whole thing, and those of us with a sense of adventure who enjoyed the whole story of it.
      HOWEVER, this tiresome attempt to knock people, merely because they are being adored, is both boring, as it is pathetic. Trying to point out petty cracks, make cynical judgements etc. Are these the same people who said she’d die originally, and hate being proven wrong?? Do they hate seeing a young person achieve something?? Hate seeing young girl achieve it?? What is it exactly??
      She knows what she achieved, she knows who she proved wrong, and she is the only one who knows what it was like for her out there. Seeing the loook on her face, her family’s, and the people who greeted her, I truly doubt she will care about petty interpretations of ‘records’, or bitter words from someone sitting at a computer.

    • TM says:

      09:54am | 17/05/10

      I feel:

      Sad for her predecessors who have achieved the same or better without the assistance of state-of-the-art communication technology and who have been grossly overshadowed by the media hype

      Annoyed that she may well receive the Young Australian of the Year Award in place of somebody who has benefited humanity through science or charity or arts

      Annoyed by the censorship of opinion in the establishment press

      Glad she’s returned safely with sense of achievement

    • TM says:

      01:48pm | 17/05/10

      Jan,

      Damn right we’d know who she is! But there are plenty of young Australians doing innovative things for great causes who simply aren’t in the media spotlight because they haven’t got a PR Team feeding the frenzy.

    • Jan Moon says:

      12:59pm | 17/05/10

      If she gets Young Australian of the Year, at least we’ll know who she is,  half the time people who get these type of awards are totally unknown to the general populace

    • Andrew Thompson says:

      09:51am | 17/05/10

      If humanity had subscribed to Brendan Shanahan’s view, we’d still be living in caves. You should thank the risk-takers, Mr Shanahan, for you are the undoubted beneficiary of their daring.

    • SailDog says:

      11:45am | 17/05/10

      I agree. If the only reason to climb the mountain is simply because it is there, that is good enough reason.

    • Benster says:

      09:47am | 17/05/10

      Have to agree. This whole exercise was an act of supreme indulgence and self-aggrandisement. Why didn’t Jessica and her supporters use their obvious skills and organisational abilities to make a real difference to the state of the world? Perhaps raise money for our starving neighbours in East Timor? Provide fresh water to communities ravaged by preventable, water borne disease? Increase educational opportunities for children in developing countries? Just to name a few.
      What a waste of money, time, effort and breath - except, of course, for those who will make the big bucks.
      Please spare me all the ‘inspirational’ crap. It’s all about the money and how to get more of it for yourself. Well, I guess that IS inspiring to some people ...

    • Steve_of_Cornubia says:

      07:49pm | 17/05/10

      Actually, I think she held a wish to circumnavigate by sail for a few years. The whole money thing may be a seperate issue, perhaps somebody else’s idea. Having said that, some people are suggesting she’ll be worth several million bucks within the next few months and THAT is a big pay day, no matter what you’ve done.

      I’m cringing in advance while wondering what daft ideas the media will dream up using Jessica (i.e. judging Masterchef, weathergirl, commentating at fashion week, our roving reporter in Bangladesh, etc) and hoping that she has the sense to tell them where to stick ‘em.

    • Jaye says:

      02:08pm | 17/05/10

      Hahaha you idiot. A completely pathetic argument. How is this about money? Pretty sure there are a hell of a lot easier ways to make money thatn sailing solo and unassisted around the world at the age of 16. Good on her. She had a dream and put in all the effort she could to make it come true.  There is nothing wrong with this. She has a passion for sailing and deserves whatever comes her way.

    • Saskia says:

      10:31am | 17/05/10

      Because people are free to as they they will.  What a pathetic argument.  No one is obligated to help other people.  How about you do it and stop moralising and judging others.

    • grant says:

      09:46am | 17/05/10

      Its called free choice, and Brendan Shanahan what have you done that is even 1/100000 close to what Jessica has done in terms of the achievement itself and the mental and physical endurance required.

      She’s made of much harder stuff then you would ever be.

    • David C says:

      09:41am | 17/05/10

      Are you sure this isnt Catherine Deveny writing this article?

    • SailDog says:

      09:37am | 17/05/10

      Not many people on this thread, maybe none, have actually been out there. I have, I sailed from the UK to Australia. That was nothing compared to what Jessica has done because we were in the tropics on a 44’ boat, which is at least double the size of Jessica’s. We had warm weather with just the right amount of wind mostly on our stern quarter, just where you want it.

      By contrast, the high latitudes and the great Southern Capes are wild and dangerous places. And cold. Freezing cold. As Jessica herself acknowledged: putting to sea in a small boat, especially in the waters she sailed, involves a calculated risk. And courage. It was a tremendous achievement; and that is what we celebrate.

      So the author of this article is just demonstrating this smallness of mind and inability to salute raw courage in a young girl, if nothing else. As for the idiot above who thinks a laptop makes all the difference he or she clearly hasn’t been out there (or anywhere else that needs courage, forethought and not a little luck). In other words shut up: you are uniquely unqualified to have a view, let alone express one. And to all the people who think the money makes a difference, you should be ashamed of yourselves. Try being out in a major storm, on deck in the pitch dark (OK - with the deck lights on), with the boat pitching and rolling, double harnessed, setting a trisail in a rising gale; and tell me how much you will think about money; or anything else apart from seeing the night and storm through.

    • Steve_of_Cornubia says:

      07:42pm | 17/05/10

      OK Saildog, so why did you only give LOA before stating it was ‘double the size’? Next time, try ‘double the displacement’, or whatever it is you actually meant to say, eh?

    • SailDog says:

      12:32pm | 17/05/10

      Steve of Cornubiua - Sorry mate but is you that is clueless. The size of a boat refers to her volume or displacement, not LOA. If I had meant double her LOA, that is what I would have said.

    • Steve_of_Cornubia says:

      11:47am | 17/05/10

      Eh? You think she used a 22’ boat? Are you sure you know something about sailing?

      It was a 33’ boat. Still small, but apparently one of the best boats for round-the-world trips because they’re regarded s pretty much unsinkable. In fact, you could probably slam it into a friggen great container ship and get away with it…....... wink

    • Mark says:

      10:41am | 17/05/10

      SailDog, I’m with you on this - having sailed the pond between us and our sheep-loving neighbours as well as the stream holding back the pointy heads, sailing is damn hard work.

      People rant about the technology assisting her - how, exactly?  She has a GPS - big deal, but I bet she also has a sextant and the wherewithall to actually take sights and calculate her position.  She had a self furling headsail - big deal, I bet she could get on the deck herself and rig a stormsail herself.  She had a satellite data link - big deal, no different from using voice over HF radio or weatherfax service (which she probably had as well).  She had solar panels, wind generators and a diesel engine to charger her batteries - big deal, she needs power for her comms gear.  She had a laptop - big deal, no different from writing your notes in a ships log.  She had a support crew at home assisting her in any way they can - big deal, they wanted to keep her alive so would do all it took.

      I’d challenge any blog reader, contributor or manscaped narcissistic author to achieve 1% of what she has done.  A 34’ yacht is tiny; sailing is hard work at the best of times, single-handedly doing it is an unbelievable triumph of (wo)man over the elements.

      C’mon - hire a yacht and sail the two-hundred-odd miles to do 1% of her journey.  Blog about it. Tell us your story.  See how you go.

      Until then, you are just your words.  A whole lot of nothing, a waste of time and space.

    • david says:

      08:56am | 17/05/10

      Who is this Brindling Shingaling ? Whoever he is , he is a waste of ink and oxygen .
      Is he the president of the Scrofulous Society of Troglodytes ?

    • Darren says:

      08:54am | 17/05/10

      i gather the fact that she was staying in Manly over the weekend was why we had such a massive police presence there - I hope that this was paid for by Jessica and/or her backers and not the taxpayers of NSW

    • PB says:

      08:47am | 17/05/10

      Well, teen can’t friggin win, can they? We spend all our time telling them how badly behaved, lazy and selfish they are. One of them sails around the world, and all you idiots can do is bag her. For WHATEVER reason she did it, only a moron would undermine a solo circumnavigation, record or not. Certainly anyone who’s sailed anywhere wouldn’t. You all disgust me, and particularly the dickhead who wrote this tripe article.

    • claudia says:

      08:46am | 17/05/10

      Hilarious. A good point about Bullimore, and yes, would it have been as positive if she required a taxpayer-funded resuce? But maybe on the whole a tad cynical about personal challenges. Still love it though.

    • Jolanda says:

      07:13am | 17/05/10

      It always was and is a money making exercise.  Then we wonder why young people get involved in ‘extreme’ sports and ‘extreme’ activities.  What this girl did was extreme, dangerous and against what is appropriate for a 16 year old to do as she is a child yet she was not only allowed, she has been treated like some sort of ‘star’.  Why are so many people promoting this and carrying on like it is something that just couldn’t be done?  It has been done before.  Isn’t there any thing else to focus on?  Do we really want to encourage young people to push the boundaries and put their life at risk of harm?

      Education – Keeping them Honest
      http://jolandachallita.typepad.com/

    • James says:

      03:31am | 17/05/10

      Bollocks.

      It is quite dumb and hypocritical for this author to call Jessica Watsons journey narcissistic.

    • Tim says:

      03:18am | 17/05/10

      Have to love journos trying to act intelligent when they adopt non-mainstream opinions. Try to come across as being ‘cutting edge’ and all that. So sad. The day that mankind doesn’t push the boundaries of our existence is the day we stop moving forward.

    • AndrewR says:

      01:32am | 17/05/10

      Aren’t you a bit young to be such a crabby old fart?

      In a world, where your new heroes sob into their failed souffles on Masterchef , its good to see someone step up and out in our increasingly homogenous society. This was a tremendous act of skill and courage, made more remarkable for her age. Forget the trivial whining about the record or the over-the-top hype of your colleagues. I can assure you that at midnight battered by 6m seas, product endorsements were the last thing she would be thinking of.

      As for the communication systems, you would whine if she didn’t have it for her own safety. It’s also a sign of the Twitter times. As demonstrated by your very own blogging. Suck it up. Get over it.

      You may like a passive life in a nanny state but please, don’t flaunt it.

    • AndrewR says:

      10:38am | 17/05/10

      Thanks for the pointers Paul, I’ll use it in my next blog on heavy handed irony.

    • Paul says:

      09:26am | 17/05/10

      Increasingly homogenous society? I would’ve thought increasingly homogenous blog posts. Just looking at yours, you didn’t use ‘get a grip’. It would’ve went well with ‘suck it up’, ‘get over it’ and ‘nanny state’.

    • miketron says:

      12:33am | 17/05/10

      Hopefully all the emo teenagers will take boats out to sea now after being ‘inspired’ by Jessica Watson. At least 10% of them might even make it back home… I hear the pirate / slavery trade is running perilously short of healthy white kids.

    • Sick of the media says:

      12:28am | 17/05/10

      Good on her. Some people go to university and become astrophysicists or neurosurgeons to make their coin.

      Then there are the smart ones who earn their keep doing something they truly love.

      If she makes a mint out of it, she’s earnt it. If her feats weren’t amazing, it wouldn’t be the one of the biggest news stories of the last seven or so months.

      It’s easy to be negative.

    • mrniceguy351 says:

      12:00am | 17/05/10

      You need to get out from behind your desk a bit more beardy boy.

    • Shane says:

      11:37pm | 16/05/10

      I can’t wait until she starts describing “witnessing the horrors of global warming first hand” and becomes a corporate shill. Sailing around the world, by yourself at any age, is an incredible achievement, but in these days, especially seeing as her journey was completely self serving (as stated, she didn’t even engage a charity to raise awareness for), it doesn’t need to be celebrated and I’m sure Jessica is quite embarrased by all the attention as well. The parents though, that’s another matter….

    • JS says:

      10:49pm | 16/05/10

      Ah, so it’s lonely being a bitter, beta male, isn’t it Brendan? Why not tell us something we don’t know about you?

      (BTW she wasn’t going for a record because there are no officially recognised records for under 18 year olds sailing around the world. I hope she makes millions.)

    • Shren S. says:

      10:31pm | 16/05/10

      I just simply don’t believe it!  anyone else? Time will tell. 

      - another old man with sour grapes.

    • Mark says:

      10:19pm | 16/05/10

      Inotrite Rob.

      Tall poppy syndrome alive and well.

      Don’t like the hyperbole complain to the editors and producers Shanahan.

      Seriously did Jessica do the programming and write the stories?

      Leave the kid alone. Think what you like in private but seriously shut up with gutless attacks in public.

      Nice bio - Rose Porteous rubbed vaso on your back. And you have a shot at this kid for wanting attention?

      Puhhleeaaase. All I get from you and your bio is that your a bitter little man.

    • David says:

      01:16pm | 17/05/10

      Well said.

      Especially the bit about Rose.

    • stephen says:

      10:11pm | 16/05/10

      I know a few guys (can’t call ‘em blokes), with no biceps a see-through beard and horn-rims(that’s glasses), who just hate action, lest it ameliorates ther blithering man-hood.
      They think (and i think their actually right), that the world is divided between those that do and those that want to.

      Nice one jess !

    • Nitzpicker says:

      10:08pm | 16/05/10

      Geez Brendan, shes not blonde, shes more of a sandy brown.
      BTW, i agree with you.

    • Steve_of_Cornubia says:

      09:22pm | 16/05/10

      This voyage was foolhardy and I was very concrned for her safety, but it was her choice (and her parents) and I’m glad she made it back OK.

      However, what could have been a wholesome exercise has been cheapened by the overblown PR, sponsorship, media coverage and hype, all geared toward making lots of money.

      I hope Jess wasn’t a willing participant in all the money-grabbing, and if so, that she manages to rise above it.

    • Hugh Mungus says:

      09:16pm | 16/05/10

      16 year old girl sails half way around the world in new boat with all the gizmos and she is a hero. Tamil Tigers and Afghani’s sail 3/4 of the way around the world to Australia in rickety un-seaworthy boats and they are illegal immigrants. She has done nothing that hasn’t been done before. Heck, I sailed from Australia to Canada in a boat with GPS, Internet, Casino, pool and all the mod cons, why ain’t I a hero.

    • Keely says:

      03:35pm | 20/05/10

      You’re not a hero because you won’t post your real name, you can’t congratulate a 16 year old girl for a great accomplishment.

    • Bruce says:

      08:45pm | 16/05/10

      Jess: Make sure that those critics of your efforts are not able to ride on your “coat tail” of success. Those that supported you get all the benefits. OneHD well done.

    • DVandenberg says:

      08:32pm | 16/05/10

      Thank you! I was beginning to think I was the only one!

      I’d love the media to celebrate people who actually do something for others and not just themselves.

      Don’t worry about ‘liberally beating’ her up she can console herself with the million dollars and a new documentary.

    • Carnegie says:

      08:25pm | 16/05/10

      It is easy to be a critic….......most were critics….....I was a critic..
      I was wrong!! and never been happier to be so!
      Congratulations Jess!

    • David says:

      08:19pm | 16/05/10

      “Nothing more than a dangerous, narcissistic indulgence.”

      A bit like you’re article then, eh Brendan?

      You miserable young cod!

      I note your article is full of “Had ... [this]” and “Had ... [that]” happened.  How about focusing on what did happen?

      Yes, it was dangerous.

      No, the purpose wasn’t a record.  The media have focused on the record, not Jess.

      Surely, there are more important things you can moan about?

    • barry says:

      01:03pm | 18/05/10

      that’s right David, was she a hero for crashing into a container ship?  It is the same silly girl, just with a few more miles on the clock!

    • SD says:

      08:21am | 17/05/10

      Wrong buddy, wrong.

      “JOHN TAYLOR, REPORTER: In a few months time Sunshine Coast teenager Jessica Watkins wants to sail into history. The 16 year old plans to go around the world by herself nonstop without help, becoming the youngest around.”

      ...

      “JOHN TAYLOR: Circling the world is one of sailing’s great challenges. Very few people have done it, let alone a girl still going to school.
      Can you do it; can you be the youngest around the world?

      JESSICA WATSON: I find that a bit of an annoying question because I wouldn’t be here if I wasn’t, if I didn’t have every confidence that I can do this I mean, you’ve got to take it as it comes, but I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t know that I had every chance of getting around.”

      7:30 report
      18/6/2009

    • Tsu says:

      08:08pm | 16/05/10

      perhaps.. she did it like she said so, that it wasn’t for the record, just that she wanted to do it.  i rkn youd get the record for the shittiest author in the world. congratulations.

    • Brett L says:

      08:02pm | 16/05/10

      My I just add this: After seeing the channel 10 special and 60 minutes, I was enlightened into the pretentious behaviour of media and government. I guess it was so obvious because Jessica appeared so natural and honest. They body language of Rudd and Keannelly standing on the podium. Rudd playing with his hair and Keanelly looking Sandra Sully up and down. So crass and narcissistic. Rudd talking more about his phone calls to Jessica at sea. Then Charles Woolly asking such stupid questions and comments. Jessica’s intellect left them all for dead. And finally what bravery to publicly announce to disagree with Rudd on his hero BS. The media and government the bottom of the pit for honesty ethics and morality.

    • Max Power says:

      07:55pm | 16/05/10

      Pity she didn’t sail around the world. As for being a Hero, don’t think so, the term hero is applied to loosely today.  Sailing a boat, not quite all the way around the world does not make someone a hero.

    • iansand says:

      10:33am | 17/05/10

      She sailed south of the four capes, and crossed every meridian of longitude.  So she didn’t satisfy some arbitrary rule set down by some Pom.  You do realise that anyone who departs from England satisfies that arbitrary requirement, which shows just how arbitrary the rule is.  It was set up to make sure that northern Europeans were not at a disadvantage in any record attempt.  It serves no other purpose.

    • Max power says:

      08:53am | 17/05/10

      She sailed a long way, but didn’t meet the requirements to claim she sailed around the world. See a post above as to why she doesn’t qualify, she didn’t travel far enough. The distance must be 21600nm measured via the shortest track,  her route didn’t meet that requirement.
      Good on her for her achievement, but she did not sail around the world according to definition and she is not a hero.

    • iansand says:

      08:25am | 17/05/10

      Where did she go if she didn’t sail around the world?

    • Peter Fitzsimmons says:

      07:05pm | 16/05/10

      You are a sad, fat loser - nobody loves you. you are jealous of jessica’s achievements.

    • shane says:

      06:29pm | 16/05/10

      Completely agree. Thank you for actually expressing an opinion contrary to the flood of crap that passes for journalism these days. Still, its nothing more then we see every day. Footballers getting payed stupid amounts of money to run up and down a field. Gold players smashing plastic balls into plastic cups for more money then 80% of the worlds population will ever even know exists. Meanwhile scientists struggle for funding, the world starves and we fill the oceans with plastic. blah blah blah. rant rant rant….

    • Marilyn Shepherd says:

      06:26pm | 16/05/10

      It’s amazing that this pampered silly little girl is a “hero” but if a 15 year old Afghan refugee flees for his life he is considered a criminal and jailed on Christmas Island and we pretend that the boat ride from Indonesia is more dangerous than the frigging Taliban who would have trafficked him as a sex slave to filthy old pedophiles or sent them to fight us by force.

      It’s amazing how the only frigging boats on the planet are those who miraculously make it to Australia with a few refugees on board.

      Humbug to the lot of it.

      Sure it took guts to do what the girl did but she is not a hero to anyone, the 15 year old Afghan kid who had to travel in cars, buses, trucks on boats and planes away from his village to save his life is a hero.

    • Darryl Price says:

      06:24pm | 16/05/10

      I always read the bio of first time contributors to The Punch. Two of Brendan Shanahan’s five lines are devoted to the following “He once lived with Rose Hancock Porteous in Prix d’Amour in Perth where he slept in the ā€œCeausescu Suiteā€ and allowed the Australian-Filipino icon to rub his back with KY Jelly.”  When Jessica grows up she might hope to live as rich and full a life.

    • Amos Keeto says:

      05:50pm | 16/05/10

      Classy ‘ian @ 1:54pm’

    • Rob r Charteris says:

      05:36pm | 16/05/10

      Gee you guy’s must be tough, liberally beating up in the 16 yr old girl.

    • Jeremy Mild says:

      05:34pm | 16/05/10

      One of wee Jess’s major sponsors, OneHD, advertises beer all day and all night long. I guess beer sales will rise after this. That should help the recovery. Good One Jess.

    • DocBud says:

      10:57pm | 16/05/10

      No, Jeremy, beer sales will not rise because of Jessica’s remarkable achievement. People who want to drink beer will drink the amount of beer they choose to drink and people who do not wish to drink beer will not do so. What is wrong with you people that you seek to denigrate the achievement of a 16 year old in any ay you can? Your pointless contribution and that of so many above may stifle the free spirit and sense of adventure of other young people. Good one, Jeremy.

    • S.L says:

      04:59pm | 16/05/10

      My gripe is directed at her stage parents. She could have been on terra firma 5 days before but all the arrangements were made for Saturday so she had to stuff around out there for maximum media exposure.
      Now I’m no boaty but I still don’t understand how she came into the heads from Sydneys northern beaches when she came up from around Tassie?
      How could parents allow their daughter at any age to try that stunt for (ultimately) financial gain?
      Could it really be that she was holed up in a TV studio for 7 months and never really sailed around the world? A conspiricy just like Apollo 11 that according to sceptics never landed on the moon?
      The truth is out there!!!!!! key in the twilight zone theme….....

    • notsurprised says:

      04:19pm | 16/05/10

      Whats the matter Brendan, my previous comment too much for you? Don’t dish it up if you can’t take it.

    • iansand says:

      04:04pm | 16/05/10

      Dennis - can you refer me to your rant against Ian Thorpe for exploiting his celebrity?  Or Shane Warne?  Or any other sportsthing? I am sure you wrote them, given your apparent strong objection to the practice.

    • iansand says:

      08:21am | 17/05/10

      I meant Brendan

    • iansand says:

      03:50pm | 16/05/10

      It was an awesome achievement by a remarkable young lady.

    • Axolotl says:

      03:23pm | 16/05/10

      Sailing a boat, singlehanded, non stop around the world, with or without hi-tech navigation aids is a feat. It is petty to say otherwise. For one so young to have done it is extraordinary.
      Would I have have let my daughter do it at 16 years of age?  No way.

    • Henry says:

      03:00pm | 16/05/10

      Why did I know that Seano and the rest of the ALP apologists would be jaded cynics loudly telling us all that they don’t care/belittle this girls achievements?  Like we care.

      I pity you lot who will go your entire lifetimes without truly achieving anything of note or pushing yourselves behind the mediocre to low benchmarks that you or your peers set.

      Good on you Jessica.  Don’t let the losers bring you down!

    • Seano says:

      07:03pm | 16/05/10

      Hmmm let me check….nope can’t find anywhere that I’ve belittled this girls’ achievements. If fact I haven’t commented on her acheivement one way or another. I can see “commonsense conservative” being quite nasty about what she’s done.

      “Why did I know that Seano and the rest of the ALP apologists would be jaded cynics loudly telling us all that they don’t care/belittle this girls achievements? “

      So should I expect you to get stuck in to the conservative apologists belittling Jessica’s acheivements? Shall I expect an apology any time soon? I wont hold my breath.

    • BTS says:

      02:59pm | 16/05/10

      Jessica Watson got off her bum and did something with her life, so of course we as Australians should do all that we can to pour scorn on her and her achievement.

      Bill Henson is taking naked photographs (and advantage) of an underage child.  The PM has not taken advantage of her, he’s merely acknowledging a magnificent achievement (and I am not a Rudd supporter).

      Jessica Watson was also not relying on ‘records’ since it won’t be officially recognised anywhere.

      What a country we live in, where we champion criticism of anyone who does something in their lives.  Anybody who wants to achieve something is automatically attacked and ridiculed.  Mediocrity, the Champion of the people, don’t dare seek to be different from the pack or you will be singled out and attacked for putting effort into your life.

      One should reflect on why as a person you take the event of somebody doing well at something, as a grand opportunity to promote yourself through the attack of their endeavours.

      Take a look at yourself.

      You are truly sad.

    • DocBud says:

      02:51pm | 16/05/10

      Our neighbours are yachties who have sailed from the UK to Australia, around the pacific and around New Zealand and they are mightily impressed with Jessica’s achievement. Even with all the modern gadgetry, the open sea is a dangerous place and sailing it solo is a courageous act.

      There are some mean-spirited people in the world who seek to belittle the efforts of a 16 year old girl, others who are always convinced they know best how others should live their lives and yet others who seem to think that everything we do must be done out of altruism. These people are crushing the human spirit and aiming to create a world where every activity is regulated and performed for the greater good. It is a world I’d rather not live in.

    • DocBud says:

      05:50pm | 18/05/10

      “and the two here have been derelict in their duty”

      And what qualifies you to make such a judgement on her parents?

    • barry says:

      01:15pm | 18/05/10

      funnily enough 16 year old girls are required by law to be surrounded by people ‘convinced they know best how and how they should live their lives.’  They are usually called parents, and the two here have been derelict in their duty

    • Burto says:

      02:45pm | 16/05/10

      Agreed, glad she got back home safe etc etc but the media circus was embarrassing and painful to watch.

      P.s. Was Brendan distracted when his photo was taken?

    • Jack McCain says:

      08:05pm | 16/05/10

      No , That’s his condescending twit look.

    • LambertLee says:

      02:16pm | 16/05/10

      I don’t want to take off the accomplishment of Jessica but to my mind it was almost criminal that her parents allowed to do this. Anything could have happened to her. Its good shes got home in one piece, but to my mind it does not detract from the danger her parents knowingly let her walk into. I would not buy anything that was sponsored by her, because I would feel I aided and abetted this.

    • notsurprised says:

      02:07pm | 16/05/10

      What’s the matter Brendan, don’t like being outdone by a sixteen year old girl? In reading your article I’ve come to the conclusion that Jessica is definitley still at sail but in a sea full of other peoples bulls#%t. Almost everything today has been sold out to media opportunities, broadcast rights, sponsorship deals and any other cash grab possible, and we have made the world this way for ourselves. What is worse, the so called narcisim of someone who attempts to take themselves right out of their comfort zone and achieve what few would dare or the cynicism of a society that in the dark parts of its mind wants to see her fail and it can say I told you so?

    • Christian Real says:

      01:57pm | 16/05/10

      It is a sad day for Australia to see all these gutless “hero” jumping behind their keyboards, having cheap shots at Jessica Watson and the Prime Minister.
      The Prime Minister was right in in speech calling Jessica Watson “Australia’s Latest Hero”, because she most certainly is, and what she endured and achieved should be recognised not condoned by these pathetic people on this blog, that has the audacity to call themselves Australians, when Australians they are not, by their actions, words and comments, it is obvious that they, themselves have achieved very little or nothing in their lives.
      It was obvious also by her comments that she is a modest person, who didn’t like to be seen as a hero, and instead said that if you believe in your dreams,  then you can achieve anything.
      But in real Australian people’s hearts, Jessica Watson is, “Australia’s Latest Hero”

    • Sam P says:

      11:24pm | 16/05/10

      Rudd’s speech was a sickening ego trip littered with ‘you know whats’, “dropping his name”, pathetic jokes, and glib BS like calling Jessica a hero etc.

      Jessica was right to pull the creep up and clarify that she isn’t a hero just a hard worker that wanted something badly.

      Rudd won NO friends in the crowd I can tell you.  We were cringing.

    • Nicole says:

      08:47pm | 16/05/10

      Oh okay Christian, so if you disagree with the statement that Jessica is a hero then you are therefore a) unAustralian, and b) have achieved nothing with your life. Thanks for that balanced perspective.

    • ian says:

      01:54pm | 16/05/10

      I am SO SICK of Jessica ......... she was HOT when she was with Nick.
      She was even OK in ‘The Dukes Of Hazzard’  .... but then she put on weight…..
      ............. huh!? ....Jessica WATSON? .......That kid in the boat!
      Naw! She’s not hot!

    • Tom says:

      01:41pm | 16/05/10

      What has this journey achieved? She was given excellent equipment due to her 39 sponsors. Everything she did has been done before, just because she is a little younger doesn’t really make it special. I bet she had experts monitoring the weather conditions and guiding her every move.

      I recall a few years ago when a sailor needed rescuing by the navy there was an outcry that public funds were used to fund his rescue. And yet people are silent that a large sum of money was spent on Jessica’s homecoming, for what is a private endeavour, and one that will net her a lot of money. If she were injured or killed any salvage effort would have cost whichever country’s search and rescue services a lot of money. Essentially she assumes the upside of the risk of her journey, whilst I very much doubt she would have been forced to reimburse any potential rescuers, nor the public celebration costs.

    • Shane From Melbourne says:

      01:18pm | 16/05/10

      It would have been a different matter if taxpayer dollars was used to rescue her like Australia does with a few yachtsman making “feat attempts”, under prepared bushwalkers etc. It’s a good money making adventure until it goes belly up but even then you might be able to sell your story….

    • Bubba Ray says:

      01:05pm | 16/05/10

      She went sailing, which is basically a hobby it’s the kind of thing people do on the weekend for fun.

    • Saskia says:

      12:51pm | 16/05/10

      This article was narcissistic.  An attempt at attention by belittling an achievement that people of your ilk can only dream about (assuming that people of you ilk have any dreams at all).

      Watson didn’t ask or want all of the fanfare.  Most was driven by the NSW Govt and that sickening creep we have to call our PM.  His speech was raw narcissism and when Watson put him in his place the cheers in the crowd were matched by all of us at home.

      She has done a great job and it has been a record despite the knockers, doom-merchants, whingers, cynics, and jaded misery guts that love to bring down anyone that is successful.

      I hardly followed Jessica, but am nothing but impressed by this young lady after studying the incredible effort in recent days.  Her speeches, answers to questions and handling of pressure and attention was first class and would shame most ‘professionals’.

      What is it with people announcing how they ‘hate’ something be it success, sports etc as though we care?  Attention seeking through negativity. 

      Shanahan you are sad git.

    • Dann2291 says:

      12:28pm | 16/05/10

      There was one main item that marred the arrival was kevin rudd on the podium saying (possibly 4 times)when   he opened his mouth “when I was talking to Jessica bla blah” “I asked Jessica blah blah” as if it was about him. At least Jessica said she did not agree with him about being a hero-goodonya Jess! As she is not a hero just a teenager -like kevin rudd is not a leader just a spin doctor.It was afoolhardy what she did but she did it so congratulations jess and for also disagreeing to kevin rudd’s face in front of the spectators who cheered you for that.Their was no need for him to be there except for his ego. He also made Hero such an easy common word when as she is not a Hero she is a achiever ,so kev, get a life and give up your day job ,maybe a job with Kerry O’Brien on 7.30 report haha grin

    • Robert of Rural SA says:

      11:45pm | 16/05/10

      Kevvy needs all the reflected glory he can get! ! !

    • Ben says:

      12:26pm | 16/05/10

      The problem here is all of the people who want to make themselves look good by pissing in her pocket. Had she made it around the world without all of the publicity, I think that most of us would have nothing but respect for her. It is the media circus that is so nausiating. It is just unclear whether she chased the publicity, her family did or the media chased her.

    • stevie says:

      12:02pm | 16/05/10

      ....and while we’re at it then…can we get over this bloody riduculous obsession with trecking the Kokoda trail as well and the really stupid dragging of the solemn Anzac Day into a football match at the MCG.

    • A Bob says:

      11:37am | 16/05/10

      Your diagnosis of narcissism is off. A narcissist will usually ride in the wake of the efforts of others to big-note themselves. The sort of thing an under-achieving journalist might do.

      And if making a buck off it is wrong, then I hope your not getting paid for your work.

    • DocBud says:

      11:18am | 16/05/10

      “but you’ll forgive me if her ā€œrecordā€ doesn’t exactly float my boat.”

      I’m sure people could not care enough to forgive you, Brendan. Your article comes across as far more narcissistic and self-indulgent than Jessica’s remarkable achievement.

      The bottom line is: why should people not partake in dangerous endeavours that they enjoy and give them a sense of achievement? Jessica now knows she can do it and why the hell should every such act be done for charity. Perhaps you should try and get charitable sponsorship for every day you don’t write a sanctimonious, judgemental, miserabilist article.

    • amce says:

      11:10am | 16/05/10

      Thanks for articulating the feelings I’ve had about this “adventure”. It is unfortunate that the cult of celebrity is defining of our era…

    • Lucy loo says:

      01:01pm | 17/05/10

      AS opposed to the Big Brother kind of celebrity? Or Paris Hilton?
      At least she did something to earn her fame….

    • Jan Moon says:

      12:35pm | 17/05/10

      At least she actually did something - and has earned acclaim for that the little show mares and stallions who feature in the ‘eyespy’ and similar columns.

    • Gary Cox says:

      11:08am | 16/05/10

      Err…. it wasn’t a record.

    • Aaron says:

      08:23pm | 16/05/10

      Was not….but because of her age, not the route she took.  The body that keeps yachting records no longer recognises any ‘round the world’ records for any sailors under the age of 18.

      She set out to sail around the world - solo and unassisted - and she did it. Nothing she could have done would have helped secure any sort of record.

    • Teddie says:

      03:21pm | 16/05/10

      To err, is to claim a record - Jessica didn’t go far enough*, and didn’t go near the antipode (of the start) which would be near Portugal where Jesse Martin went (or more accurately, somewhere in the Mediterranean)

      *  the rhumb line distance travelled by Watson was about 19,631.6 nm, which is less than the required distance according to the definition set by the World Sailing Speed Record Council (WSSRC),which states in part “The shortest orthodromic track of the vessel must be at least 21,600 nautical miles in length”

    • Joe Bloe says:

      02:51pm | 16/05/10

      Errr… It wasn’t. Solitude my ass. Should look at her internet and phone bill.

    • Susan Q says:

      01:45pm | 16/05/10

      Err….. it was.

    • Scardie Cat says:

      11:06am | 16/05/10

      So do you have any hobbies or aspirations Brendan? Or do you never leave the comfort of your lounge room for fear of a tree branch falling on your head while you’re walking down the street, or getting hit by a car while you’re crossing the road?

      If everyone had your “don’t do it because something might go wrong"attitude nothing would get done. Sure it might have been a bit dangerous but that’s what life’s about; taking a risk here and there.

      There’s probably a lot of other 16 year old girls out there that are equally putting their lives at risk by taking drugs, abusing alcohol, or.. crossing the road.

    • Against the Man says:

      10:59am | 16/05/10

      I think Jessica achieved something great and inspired many people. On the other hand pm rudd should stop appearing on TV eg rove/sunrise and trying to associate with real achievers like Jessica and get back to actually doing some real pm type work. It has been almost 4 years and this pm has progressed slower than scientists attempting to land a man on the sun.

    • Jerry Kovoor says:

      10:48am | 16/05/10

      Nice piece Brendan.  I agree with the points you raised.  But we live in a society where we are told that everything is possible.  Congratulations to Jessica for a safe homecoming.

      You’re right about the manufactured excitement on her homecoming.  Cheap political points for the politicians and increased ratings for networks covering the event.

      Well I guess we all have to follow our dreams even if it is a dangerous, narcissistic indulgence.

    • Jan Moon says:

      12:40pm | 17/05/10

      But you can’t blame her for the manufactured excitment, and the political stunts

    • P. Oliver says:

      03:27am | 17/05/10

      If John Howard had turned up in his little track suit to welcome her I’m guessing the Rudd critics would be singing a different song.  Lighten up folks;  if humans didn’t produce a few adventurers thoughout the ages we would all still be in Africa .

    • SeaMac says:

      10:44am | 16/05/10

      Have to agree, Brendan.  It seems she was out for “the record” beforehand, yet now she did not fulfil the criteria, that record doesn’t matter (or is claimed anyway).  There were a couple of separate pronouncements by Jessica’s mother beforehand that were irrational and thus of concern - can’t recall as have put them out of my mind.

      The saga yesterday was over-the-top and a dangerous precedent, as was the sight of Premier Kenneally and her Ports Minister involvement in staging the show on Friday.  Moreover, Rudds involvement yesterday was dangerous, narcissistic indulgence, too.

    • shane says:

      06:52pm | 16/05/10

      Do you really think the anyone cares that you’re previous post wasn’t put up? Do you really think that it was sooooo full of wisdom and truth that you “shamed” the moderator into not putting your comment up? Do you really think anything you said could have changed the mind of anyone who read it? It would have been read by a few people, who probably would have dismissed it as the rantings of a self important hick with delusions of grandeur. I think it more likely that your “beacon of rectitude” was nothing more then an insulting blurb of such inane stupidity that the moderator momentarily passed out and forgot that it even existed.

    • Beagle says:

      10:40am | 16/05/10

      Great to see someone else isn’t fooled by this ridiculous escapade.

      Looks like wealthy parents trying to live vicariously through their daughter.

      I’m just waiting for the Catherine Deveny tweet about what Jessica really needs to be doing now.

    • Damian says:

      10:38am | 16/05/10

      Yeah you are right, probably best if people don’t try and do anything hard or dangerous because it has already been done. Just stay at home, work Mon-Fri till you are 65 and die having done nothing of note your entire life!

    • John A Neve says:

      01:14pm | 16/05/10

      Damian,

      How wrong can you be? “Stay at home, work Mon-Fri till you are 65” raise a family, pay your bills, enjoy your partners company. You have contributed far more than a cosseted boat trip.

      Bet you watch a lot of TV?

    • Clint Walsh says:

      10:22am | 16/05/10

      Agreed.

    • Andy says:

      10:21am | 16/05/10

      You sound like a sad petty little man Shanahan.

    • Jan Moon says:

      12:30pm | 17/05/10

      Agreed Andy, and isn’t there a lot of it around

    • Tom says:

      09:58am | 16/05/10

      I tried floating this line, sans narcissism, and I got flamed like a fresh batch crĆØme brĆ»lĆ©e. She really does seem like a humble young person, albeit caught up in a juicy media/political spectacle. That said I totally agree with the article; the further we move away from from a society of mere subsistence the more these “adventures” will become staple to our identities.

    • Shelly Stone says:

      09:48am | 16/05/10

      Jess has done something amazing. Tell me Brendan, what have you done?

    • Anne71 says:

      12:54pm | 17/05/10

      @Shelly Stone - perhaps those of us who don’t feel compelled to join in the mass Jessica-worship are secure enough in our own lives and achievements, however humble they may be, that we don’t need to live vicariously through someone else’s?

    • Ric of Perth says:

      12:15pm | 17/05/10

      Easy there Shelly… Brendan has stepped out and done something…. He’s gone against the grain of the Australian mentality…. that if your not on the hill yelling aussie, aussie , aussie, there’s something wrong with you… So like lemmings, Shelly are you saying that everyone should concur with another major event in Australia’s history??? I’m sure ALL the sponsors would want us to, wouldn’t they….  It’s also amazing the yacht was able to stay afloat, what will all the heavy advertising on board…  So lets ask a question here for all and sundry…. Would Jessica have done it… without the abundant commercial sponsorship???...

    • Paul says:

      11:25pm | 16/05/10

      Jessica’s journey: Brave - yes. Courageous - without doubt. Amazing journey - yes. Good on her for achieving it. But ‘Heroic’ - no way.

      @Shelly Your criticism of Brendan – People don’t need to accomplish massive (and extremely expensive) feats of world sailing to ‘make a difference’ in the world. What about the sacrifices that unsung, humble, ordinary people make every day to help others less fortunate than themselves to live better lives? People that don’t have to hang around outside Sydney Heads to time their media exposure for maximum personal financial gain? Who does Jessica’s journey serve the most anyway? (Hint: starts with ‘J’)

      I know quite a few people that have volunteered in Africa, involved in setting up hospitals, building schools and working as nurses for no financial gain. But I don’t see them being recognised or acknowledged publicly as ‘heroes’. Who’s achievements are more admirable and amazing?

    • JJJ says:

      05:37pm | 16/05/10

      Is it amazing, or is it just another ‘thing’? She has made her choices in life - has followed her dreams and while that’s admirable, others are doing that every day (& aren’t getting $1m sponsorship). I, for one, would never dream of sailing around the world - I could almost think of nothing I would dislike more, but I have volunteered in Africa and love my family - I reckon I am just as much of a hero as she is (and Brendan, presumably is also following his dreams and living the life he chooses also). I don’t see that you can value sailing around the world as more admirable that anything else we might choose to do…

    • Jack McCain says:

      09:45am | 16/05/10

      Brendan. It’s very easy to be critical and dismissive of Jess’s efforts , but it would really mean something if you ever had the guts to undertake a similar challenge yourself.

    • Anthony says:

      05:34pm | 17/05/10

      Hah!  Risking your life on an unnecessary, expensive and immature journey, that could actually quite easily result in a fatal accident or death!  Yeah, that does take guts.  It’s also pointless.

    • Jaye says:

      02:29pm | 17/05/10

      Stunt?
      She is a young girl who has a love a sailing and a dream.
      I hope she does milk it for allllll its worth. GO JESS!

    • Skippy says:

      09:09pm | 16/05/10

      No Jack I’m sure Brendan has more brains than that, she’s not a hero, she’s a self promoting kid, that has one interest - herself and what fame she can milk from this ridiculous stunt! Brace your self Australia for the next little while, if your not sick of Jessica yet, I promise you will be very shortly!
      I support your viewpoint Brendan, well said!

    • Matt Dee says:

      09:31am | 16/05/10

      My feelings exactly Brendan and the word hero makes me sick. Courageous maybe this girl is but a hero she isn’t. And no this self indulgent feat has done absolutely nothing for me personally, nor has it alleviated national debt, helped our health system or the homeless. This whole Hoo Ha has been about Jessica Watson from the beginning to what’s going to be a long, painful, drawn out media circus end. They’ll be the radio and television interviews, articles in every magazine possible, books, songs, mini series’ and yes Jessica Watson the movie. So what is it about the majority of Australians who revere sports people who simply do what they do for self gratification and congratulation. And when these people say they did it for their country, that’s garbage they’re doing it for number one. And yet someone like Steve Erwin and family who also do what they do for financial gain and fame, have actually been doing so much good to raise the awareness of the natural world, yet have been scorned more often than not. beggars belief doesn’t it.

    • Jan Moon says:

      12:22pm | 17/05/10

      And you Matt, you’ve alleviated world debt, helped the health system and the homeless, I’m sure. (Probably all before breakfast, too!)
      What is with you people? Why can’t you be happy for the girl, who has returned safely from a mindblowing sail around the world, and not be so damn negative. So you wouldn’t do, and there are so many critics out that couldn’t even if they tried. You don’t have to read the aricles, buy the book, watxh the TV coverage or whatever else.
      I feel sorry for you that you have such a negative view of the world.

    • SeaMac says:

      11:49am | 16/05/10

      There is a dichotomy to these situations - the good aspect v the bad aspect, as with Steve Irwin; Steve’s family, and sports-people.  Each have their own dimension - Steve’s croc-handling really was suberb in its skill and safety, yet he then flaunted his new-borne son famously, and diverted attention from the good.  And he was taught some dangerous impulses, resulting in behaviour that caused his death.

    • Jojhn L says:

      09:24am | 16/05/10

      Excellent article Brendan. A touch mean spirted towards Jessica but the overall view about the meaningless of these “attempts: is spot on.

    • Brett L says:

      08:51am | 16/05/10

      I think you are right Brendan. There is also a never ending line of corporate sponsors trying to get their brand in front of a TV camera. The Nutella thing was a crass hijacking of the press conference. While I agree it is a narcissist indulgence, we do still do need people to inspire us in the modern era.  If we all just gave up and sat at home because it’s all been done before then what a boring life it would be reading this website, and the newspapers. It is human nature to challenge yourself to be better then others, you yourself are hoping for more comments in this blog then the previous, is that not narcissistic? Narcissism is just one of the emotions that fuel our drive, and it can also be proxy intentions as well, the parents for example they may have their own narcissist ideals.

    • Squidly says:

      09:45pm | 20/05/10

      Teenage Sri Lankans and Afghanis risk everything to sail here in leaky overcrowded boats to chase their dreams of a better life (with no support crew or management team). That’s inspiring.  Our ‘welcoming’ for them however isnt quite the same as Watsons.

    • Lenny says:

      08:47am | 16/05/10

      You sound a bit on the jealous side to me.

    • Rosalie says:

      08:45am | 16/05/10

      Yes - well said!

    • Paul says:

      08:45am | 16/05/10

      when she barely made it off the jetty first time round everyone bellowed their scorn and disapproval - “how could any parent let their daughter do this?!” - ; then when she made it over the horizon everyone forgot about her - “Jessica Whoson?” - ; then when she got back not dead they acclaimed her a hero - “what an Aussie hero!” - : forgive me if this all smacks of the kind of cynical opportunism on which most media beat-ups are founded.  Sure, she made it: well done.  But in the end it was a bit of family-promoted self-actualisation hocked to the media as a story of human achievement with which we are now expected to collude with our approval.  I too am glad she didn’t die or end up bobbing in the endless blue for hours waiting for a Patagonian fishing boat to pluck her out, she ‘s clearly a good sailer, but the power of one malarkey being pumped out over this - “you just gotta believe”  and every mantra of middle class self-wonderment - is enough to make you reach for the motion sickness capsules.

    • Edouardo C says:

      06:53pm | 18/05/10

      Hear hear!  Now the media is marvelling at the fact that she turned down a $250 000 media circus - sorry, 17th birthday party.  By the rule book, she broke no record.  In this age of instant world-wide communications, she was scarcely alone mentally.  It was all so totally unnecessary, but a young blonde girl in a pink boat is irresistible to beat-up journalists.

    • Kelly says:

      08:36am | 16/05/10

      It was good to see Jessica put Rudds patronising “hero” label back in it’s box where it belongs. By the way it wasn’t about “breaking records” it was about sailing around the world and chasing dreams.

    • Sherekahn says:

      12:29pm | 17/05/10

      Well said Kelly.
      I’ll bet Jessica had watched TV news or such of the masses trudging to work with gloomy faces and thought, “no way!”
      Whilst visiting friends in a London basement flat in the 60’s having just returned from a voyage as a Merchant Seafarer, I watched the workers trudging past the window from 6.00 am onwards.  The colour of their faces changed gradually from battleship grey to better tones of blotchy pinkish grey from 6.00 am to 9.00 am.
      If you think Jessica is a gambler, so be it.  She has won and won’t be one of the grey faced clones of the GDP.
      That I have fallen in love with her is in my genes, can’t help it!  It’s the hormones!

    • KH says:

      08:28am | 17/05/10

      Even if it was a pointless dream, as it has been done before - over and over again - frankly, big deal.  And I agree with an above post - its hardly ‘solo sailing’ when you have a live blog to do and are being tracked by GPS. Kinds of takes the ‘adventure’ out of it really.  And again, most 16 year olds don’t have rich parents who indulge whatever stupid idea they come up with.  Now, brace yourself for the cynical money making exercise that you are about to be inundated with.  Can’t wait for the ‘life story’ of someone who hasn’t actually had one yet.

    • Pete says:

      08:33am | 16/05/10

      Considering 300,000 plus kids are serving as child soldiers, right now, and would be seasoned soldiers by Jessica’s age it sounds like you need to see a little bit more of the world son.

      The Punch is the cream collection of narcissists anyway.

    • Bob says:

      01:21pm | 16/05/10

      and yet here you are reading it…

    • Diamantina Dick says:

      08:32am | 16/05/10

      I suppose someone had to be the grinch and write this article but I just found it to be a narcissistic indulgence.

    • Old Bert says:

      08:25am | 16/05/10

      You need to get out a bit more old son

    • Daniel says:

      08:11am | 16/05/10

      Im not sure I agree with this this time. Its normally me that agrees but what this kid has gone through is an amazing thing and just needs to be congratulated. The only political aspect to this is the corporate sponsorship and the money involved in this.

    • Super D says:

      07:31am | 16/05/10

      Firstly it is some sort of an achievement and better for a 16 year old girl to sail the world than experiment with drugs and get knocked up by some loser.

      That being said it’s just been over the top.  I mean for the duration of the trip she was blogging and video conferencing and her position was followed by GPS.  She can barely claim to having endured 200 days of solitude. 

      It’s not surprising the way the media has jumped on the bandwagon, nothing a modern news organisation likes more than feel good filler.  And as for the pollies, how sickening was that!

      I hear now that she’s up for a book and movie deal.  Her thoughts may make for interesting reading but a movie deal?  I can’t see her story assisting the flagging Australian film industry.  It needs more pirates for a start.

    • Keely says:

      01:54pm | 20/05/10

      I’d like to see one of you cynical old farts do it. Easy to be an armchair critic. Seems like youd be happier if she was out at 2am in the morning skulling alcopops and wearing a skirt up to her earlobes?

      It gave me joy to see her accomplish her goal. And what a great role model for some of the brain-dead teenagers of today (note - SOME of!).
      It really pisses me off that there are such negative comments posted. Really pathetic. Must be from the parents of the teenage brats we see so much of.

      Try parenting your own kids first. Now THERE’S a goal for you to try and achieve.

    • Super D says:

      08:30pm | 16/05/10

      They can’t all get the sponsors.

    • Kei says:

      06:44pm | 16/05/10

      Because not all 16 year olds don’t have rich mummies and daddies who can buy them an expensive boat with all the expensive equipment. Personally if I was a parent and had the money, I wouldn’t.

    • Arto says:

      05:40pm | 16/05/10

      If it is that easy why isn’t every sixteen year old doing it?

    • John A Neve says:

      05:49am | 16/05/10

      Brendan,

      You have missed the whole point. Ancient Rome has it’s gladiators, we have Jessica, it sell newpapers and keeps the masses amused

    • Ginger says:

      04:05pm | 16/05/10

      Ummm actually @ John- I think that’s his point exactly.

    • Wayne Fehlhaber says:

      06:43pm | 16/05/10

      Julie Coker-Godson :  Well said Julie , it’s the sour grape comments made by posters that stifle the efforts of young people with a dynamic get and go attitude to life . Jessica Watson deserves her day in the spotlight for a wonderful effort in personal achievement and if there proves to be financial spin-offs to her benefit then she deserves that as well. Personally , i am delighted that this young lady has kept to her goal in the face of knockers who are prepared only to sit on their lazy backsides in a lounge chair mocking her for her courage .
      We need a lot more Jessica Watsons in this country , youg people with vision and a sense of getting up and out to achieve their dreams.
      Congratulations Jessica Watson -you are a great Australian.

    • Julie Coker-Godson says:

      04:07pm | 16/05/10

      Of which he is not going to be in receipt of.  A jealous old man and a lot of sour grapes on this article.

    • WKH says:

      05:09am | 16/05/10

      And I thought it was just me who was a stick in the mud…but I have to agree with you. Interesting story, pleased she made it but enough is enough already. Whoopy do! Try doing it without any electronics and without a lap top to be in touch with people 24/7. It’s not that hard and that is exactly what she has proven to the world. You can stack into a container ship one day and sail the world the next. Kevy did make a goose of himself again but thats just KRUDD coming to the surface….

    • Matt says:

      02:09pm | 17/05/10

      You have to be kidding right?

      Clearly if it was that easy everyone would be doing it.

    • SF says:

      12:00pm | 17/05/10

      “Not that hard.” Are you for real? Sounds like you’ve had plenty of “blue water” sailing experience…or perhaps not.

      Reckless or not, she survived 7-8 knockdowns in the open ocean with no nearby land to shelter behind. Try telling any sailor that what she did didn’t take skill, determination, guts, a good boat, and yes - some luck.

      Personally, I thought 16 was a little young to make the attempt, but that in no way lessens the admiration I feel for her. Just because Magellan did it first nearly 500 years ago doesn’t lessen her achievement in any way.

    • Joe says:

      03:53am | 16/05/10

      I couldn’t agree more. I managed to avoid most of the media coverage so far so haven’t had to see Rudd pretending he cares - to get votes. We shouldn’t be encouraging reckless behaviour in teenage girls mr Rudd. What will they do next to get your fake praise?

    • Paul Horn says:

      12:25pm | 17/05/10

      Yeah Joe let’s stop encouraging all that nasty reckless behaviour. When you see kids climbing tall trees or jumping off swings into sand pits or playing rough and tuimble with each other lets stop it pronto!

      And God forbid these days let them walk to school. Instead let’s encourage them to be video gaming dullards ensconced in front of an electronic screen getting fat. My God allowing a child to dream of a great adventure and accomplish it must be stopped at all costs in the name of our ever encroaching OHS risk averse society.

    • Seano says:

      12:04pm | 16/05/10

      if you’d seen the media coverage you’d probably realise that Abbott too was “pretending he cares - to get votes”.

      Can I expect that you are equally outraged? Perhaps not.

    • The Commonsense Conservative says:

      03:15am | 16/05/10

      Ah cynicism, so refreshing after all the fanfaring and what not of the afternoon and evening about a silly little girl.

    • Kitten says:

      07:22pm | 17/05/10

      Angular Gurl: As an 18 year old girl I can tell you yes, some teenagers have goals. And some of those teenagers, myself included, will work hard to achieve them. Its fulfilling. And, in terms of sport, its is a lot of fun (if it wasn’t they wouldn’t do it).

      My own goal involves taking on a 3 year degree condensed into 2 years (from which I will graduate at the end of this year while still 18), followed by a four year degree commencing in February next year. And you know what? I study hard to achieve my goal, and I do it under my own steam. Studying, like doing laps for five hours, isn’t a chore when you are doing it to achieve your dream. My parents don’t pressure me, they support me and let me chase after my dream and I thank them for that.

      PS. To those of you who say her parents shouldn’t have let her go: Jessica’s parents obviously have confidence in her skills as a sailor, or they wouldn’t let her do it. Children/teens appreciate a vote of confidence every now and then. We need a chance to get it wrong and learn from our mistakes (like running into another vessel - she didn’t do it again, did she?). If you wrap us up in bubble wrap we will never achieve anything.

    • Sam says:

      02:38pm | 17/05/10

      I’m gessing Angular Gurl that they would like to gain more from their lives than just ending up as a cynical houswife, hence such silly dreams and goals.

    • Bobby says:

      11:34am | 17/05/10

      Wholeheartedly agree!! As a parent I cannot imagine anything so ridiculous as supporting and encouraging a child to put herself in real danger as Jessica’s parents did.  Thank goodness she is OK but if she had been lost at sea then I wonder how much guilt that would have felt.  I agree that this is self indulgent behaviour and even though she made it she is NOT a hero to me.

    • Angular Gurl says:

      10:06am | 17/05/10

      As a mother of a 12 year old boy, I question how it is that a 16 yr old has such a “goal”?

      Do these children really, honestly, have such ambition?  Or are they like my children, shooting wishes into the air one afternoon and have parents to latch on and force them into endless sail or swim lessons.

      My 6 yr old daughter told me on the weekend that she wished to be a princess… Should I latch onto this dream and do all within my power to make this ‘dream’ a reality?  Facilitate the transition of “dream” to “goal”?

      I struggle to fathom why a 16 yr old would want to sail the world, or be an olympic swimmer and think that doing 5 hrs of lap training up and down a pool was worth while!

      As a parent, I also struggle to reckon why any other parent would encourage such a loss of innocence and childhood in pursuit of a “dream” or “goal”!!

      Furthermore, I struggle to fathom why any parent would allow their 16 yr old to sail the world on her own.  It is our role as nurturers to say “no, you don’t fully appreciate the consequences” and for our teens to begrudge us for it.

      I guess there was some good money to be made…

    • DWEST says:

      10:00am | 17/05/10

      Yep and then there is a tussle between two party robots like Rudd and Abbott, and Labor and Labor-lite (the Liberals)

      BORING!

    • Jeff from Meroo says:

      08:12am | 17/05/10

      You’re absolutely right!  And while we’re at it, how about the Olympics hey…  BOR—RING…  been there done that.  I mean how many times do we need to see someone swim the length of a pool?  And the cricket… okay “the Ashes” we get it, get over it!  And now I hear they’re playing the State of Origin…  AGAIN!  Seriously didn’t they already do that?  Here’s a tip, someone already played in the State of Origin and the Ashes, and the Olympics… so stop wasting all of our time!  I’m so sick of people risking themselves to do something that has already been done that I’m off to open a carpet shop in Turkey..  oh wait, someone’s done that.

    • Sick of the media says:

      12:20am | 17/05/10

      Evan Findlay, you’re spot on.

      Brendan Shanahan (BS) would probably prefer the modern citizen to strap themselves to a Wii and forget about adventure. Then write about how irresponsible people are for sustaining RSIs from those self indulgent games consoles.

    • Chris Deal says:

      09:16pm | 16/05/10

      There’s a glass still?

    • Evan Findlay says:

      02:46pm | 16/05/10

      Isn’t it funny what a negative and shallow society we have begun. No longer do we see the glass as half full but predominately as half empty.

      For the record I personally have no interests in Jessica’s feats and I certainly won’t be submerging myself in her glory, replicating her goals or purchasing her life story, whenever that may be published. But I acknowledge that she has set herself a goal, and a impressive and difficult goal at that, and against all the armchair critics and serial losers, she has managed to achieve it.

      I note with interest that a fellow blogger, WKH (see comment below), has managed to trivialise her achievements and stated that “its not that hard”, like he would know! WKH, you are the serial loser I refer to in my previous paragraph.

      As I said I have no interest in her achievements but I wanted to point out how the media, information network and journalists always seem to focus on the negativity. Journalists have become incapable of praising someone for their good deeds or intentions without muckracking or digging for a underlying nasty streak or skeletons in the closet.

      It seems as a society we prefer sensationalism and gutter based journalism to truth and forward thinking. I have long stopped purchasing media tabloids because of the lack of journalistic integrity and the negative geared stories to which they subscribe. It would be interesting to see what society would be like if the role of the media was reversed and they searched and reported on the positives rather than pedaling the negative.

      Maybe we wouldn’t have to read the constant dribble that WKH pedals. Now that can only be a positive.

      I’m all for freedom of speech but surely there still are some positives in this world

    • Former snag The Child Protector says:

      12:56pm | 16/05/10

      i must agree, am glad she made it back safe & alive, but really, it all was potentially very dangerous. Just like when boys of a similar age were encouraged to lie about there age, sign up, head off to war.

      And for what? jingoistic glory of a more modern spin doctored type?

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter