Some people really know how to land on both feet. Such as the three blokes who host the absurdly popular TV show Top Gear, who are paid a whole shed-load of money to remain in a state of arrested mental development and live out an extended midlife crisis on television, while taking the piss out of people of other races whom they find stupid.

Lazy, feckless, flatulent…the Top Gear team.

It’s assumed that men everywhere adore this program, hence the preponderance of Top Gear DVDs taking pride of place next to the socks and hankies every Fathers Day. It’s also said that women like the show too, that there’s something of a raffish, knockabout quality to host Jeremy Clarkson and his crew which the ladies find endearing or even irresistible. I know a few blokes who enjoy (or enjoyed) the show, but I’ve never met a woman who claims to like it, and suspect the latter assertion is made by men who simply want their wives or girlfriends to endure their seven-hour-a-week Top Gear habit.

Clarkson, James May and Richard Hammond will be heading our way soon on one of their “Down Under” tours. It’s a pity that they didn’t choose instead to take their show on the road to another southern nation, namely Mexico, which was recently the subject of one of their zany gags, and whose excellent citizens would probably love the chance to see these blokes in the flesh.

The BBC was forced to offer an apology, albeit a mealy-mouthed and caveat-laden apology, when Top Gear presenter Richard Hammond said of a Mexican-made sports car that all vehicles reflect the characteristics of their nation.

“Mexican cars are just going to be lazy, feckless, flatulent, overweight, leaning against a fence asleep looking at a cactus with a blanket with a hole in the middle on as a coat,” Hammond said last month.

He then described Mexican food as “sick with cheese on it” – not bad coming from the nation which brought us tripe in white sauce, pickled eggs and the hot chip sandwich. Clarkson chimed in adding that it was unlikely they would get any complaints from the Mexican Ambassador because, being Mexican, he’d been snoring in front of the television holding the remote in his hand.

As it happened the Mexican Ambassador was watching and, along with hundreds of his countrymen, lodged a formal complaint with the BBC. Instead of offering an unreserved apology, the national broadcaster added that the program was “making comic use of a stereotype; a practice with which regular viewers of Top Gear will be familiar”.

This is one of the key problems with the show, and it’s become more of a problem as the car part of the program has been overshadowed by uninspired or tired gags about the Krauts and the Frogs. Rather than being innovative or ground-breaking, the program increasingly seems to belong to the same comic pantheon as a show such as Love Thy Neighbour, in which Alf Garnett fretted endlessly about the fact that a family of darkies had moved in next door. Even Manuel from Fawlty Towers was less of a caricature than the one Top Gear painted about the Mexicans. 

There is another problem with the show, and it’s a bigger one. It’s about cars, and cars really aren’t all that interesting.

For every man who loves Top Gear, gets giddy with excitement about the advent of the Motor Show, has owned 10 different cars and knows the difference between a cam shaft and a carburettor, there’s one Top Gear-hating man – and possibly several men – who has owned two cars, wouldn’t cross the road to see the Motor Show, and couldn’t name a car part beyond the steering wheel and exhaust pipe.

The recent kerfuffle about the identity of The Stig – who for those of you who don’t know is the mystery person in the white helmet who test drives cars on the show – was about as juvenile a moment in pop culture as the unmasking of the rock band Kiss in the mid 1980s.

It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B. We all go through the stage in our childhood when we collect Matchbox cars, we all get excited about getting our licence and buying our first car, but after that, most blokes don’t maintain that same passionate interest in vehicles. As grown-ups we should no more get excited about cars than we should toasters or lawn-mowers. I’m flat out describing mine, other than to say that it’s silver, a station wagon, a Holden, and that the back seat can barely be seen for McHappy Meal boxes.

There’s plenty of better things to spend our money on, to aspire to, to talk about.

My suspicion is that most men feel this way but are afraid to put their hands up and admit that they don’t really know anything about cars, don’t covet cars, don’t even know anything about the car they actually drive, but we all sort of pretend that we’re into them because it seems less than manly not to. From here on in let’s come out of the motoring closet and declare that Top Gear is no more a program for adults than Play School is.

407 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Erick says:

      05:11am | 22/02/11

      You pick on a programme made by men, on a subject you’re not interested in, so you can blame men for both liking it and watching it. That would make as much sense as me picking on Oprah because it’s made and watched by women, and concerns matters in which I have little interest. But that would be kinda pointless, so I don’t.

      Simple solution: If you don’t like it, don’t watch it.

    • acotrel says:

      06:12am | 22/02/11

      ’ there’s something of a raffish, knockabout quality to host Jeremy Clarkson and his crew which the ladies find endearing or even irresistible’

      I don’t mind the programme, it’s pretty harmless, and sometimes mildly interesting.  However my wife tells me the compere is a moron, and she usually finds something else to watch on another channel.  I suggest Speed Week is a lot better for us petrol heads. Did you see the coverage of the motorcycles last Sunday at our Winton Club circuit? One of the joys of living in a small country town, with a proactive car and motorcycle club.!

    • Macca says:

      07:02am | 22/02/11

      @Acotrel, “I don’t mind the programme, it’s pretty harmless, and sometimes mildly interesting”.

      That’s it pretty much smack on the head. It’s harmless entertainment and no-one, not nobody, takes Jeremy Clarkson seriously, particularly, but not limited to, Jeremy Clarkson.

      @Penbo, “but I’ve never met a woman who claims to like it”. I’ve got some female colleagues at work who are into Top Gear. I really don’t have anything else to add to this other than the annecdotal one-upmanship I’ve just displayed. Oh, and once on a blog Sam De Brito wrote about people who are Hot and attractive, some chic commented that James May was hot.

      Top Gear is as much about 3 grown men acting like idiots than a car review show. Kind of like 2 and a half men, just less shit and instead of Pretty Things for from Hollywood, you get pretty things from Italy and Germany.

    • Tubesteak says:

      07:42am | 22/02/11

      Correct, Erick.

      I love the show. I find it hilarious and I love the bits about high performance European sports cars (I own one and will own many more). I loved the bit last week about the new Zonda (I download all the programs). I even went to one of their Down Under shows a few years ago but wasn’t that impressed by it so haven’t gone again.

      I also go to the Motor Show when it’s on in Sydney.

      I love the fact that it is one of the few shows on TV, along with Two and a Half Men, that seem to celebrate the true nature of men. We’re not some bumbling fools who are shackled to a gormless life of paying bills and keeping women happy that most sit-coms are. We make mistakes and we laugh at ourselves and have a great time living our lives.

      I’m sure Penbo aimed this article at the limp-wristed effete sorts who want to deride something not to their liking.

      Erick, you had it right with “If you don’t like it, don’t watch it.”

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      07:47am | 22/02/11

      I watch very little television, but I have read a couple of his books (based on his newspaper column) and they are quite light and amusing.

    • Geoffrey Chaucer says:

      10:01am | 22/02/11

      Yes, you are in control of the remote. Don’t like ‘Top Gear’, just click and watch ‘Question Time in Parliament’ instead. I tend to do the opposite.

      The Mexican gag was merely a humorous cliche - granted, in bad taste for the Mexicans - never meant to be taken seriously.

      Humour is one, if not the main, reason for the show’s popularity. There has been several attempts over the years to create television programmes on the subject of the motor car, some of them right here in Australia. One was hosted by Peter Wherrett, if I am not mistaken.

      None of these attempts attracted a sufficiently large audience on a regular basis. Some episodes of those shows were interesting, but lacked the entertainment factor, and overall the shows became a little boring.

      The ‘Top Gear’ formula does not require a consuming interest in cars from the audience, it relies largely on the appeal of the three comperes’ antics.

    • Ceejay says:

      10:06am | 22/02/11

      Im guessing Penbo is a White Toyota Camry Sedan kinda guy.. Or a Prius!!  Enough said!!

    • Alex says:

      11:14am | 22/02/11

      Erick i believe you have just shown a very jealous amateur journalist the door, well done

    • Shifter says:

      12:32pm | 22/02/11

      Alternatively, Penbo has accomplished his goal.

      Let me put it to you that the point of view taken was one against a very popular subject, and people are more inclined to speak out when they feel someone it putting down something they love.

      As a journalist Penbo wants lots of hits and discussion on this site. Thus, by taking something a popular as Top Gear and trashing it, it has raised the ire of many. Men and women. Children perhaps.

      And the writer has accomplished his goal.

    • bemuseB says:

      12:44pm | 22/02/11

      Bingo. There are plenty of utterly trash shows on TV that I despise so instead of getting on my soapbox and making an ineffectual rant about them, I just… don’t watch them. I have plenty of books that need reading.

    • becca says:

      12:57pm | 22/02/11

      I Love the show and I’m a female. I think its really entertaining and just a bit of fun. Going to the Top Gear live show in melbourne!

    • becca says:

      12:57pm | 22/02/11

      I Love the show and I’m a female. I think its really entertaining and just a bit of fun. Going to the Top Gear live show in melbourne!

    • Far Canal says:

      02:00pm | 22/02/11

      The reason Top Gear works and Top Gear Australia doesn’t is the interaction of the hosts. Yes its a car show, but it’s also a light hearted male view of todays world. Women have Oprah men have Top Gear.

    • Tubesteak says:

      02:24pm | 22/02/11

      If Penbo is trolling then challenge accepted.

      Prepare to be trolled…............

    • Liz says:

      02:54pm | 22/02/11

      True!

      What about program made for women? About fashion and stuff? No comment bout that?

      Give these men a break and let them have what they like!

    • Andrew says:

      08:24am | 23/02/11

      The writer should perhaps stick with his Cafe Lattes and art shows and leave writing about stuff that interest the rest of us to someone else.  Certainly came across as pretentious and up himself.  I suppose that was his goal as it creates some interest.

    • acotrel says:

      06:46am | 26/02/11

      Penbo - Thanks for putting this topic onto the forum.  It gives me hope for the future of motorsport in Australia.

    • Nigel Catchlove says:

      05:20am | 22/02/11

      So just because you are not interested in cars no-one should be?  What a fabulously interesting world it would be if we all had the same likes/dislikes.

      I enjoy watching the show, particularly, because the hosts take the piss out of the PC crowd they take themselves far too seriously, and yes I do accept that occasionally the hosts do go too far. It’s not a serious review of cars we can all afford, it is simply entertainment.

      Despite the liberal use of the word ‘most’ in your article I suggest you take a look at the website of the company that provides timing at racetracks around Australia to see just how much motorsport is conducted in this country every week ( http://www.natsoft.com.au/results ), you may be surprised. Every race meeting relies on volunteer organisers, safety crew, spectators and drivers.

      I’ve owned 11 cars and I drive in the CAMS historic category in a modified production sports car (1979 Alfa GTV). Despite a commonly held belief that all motorsports fans are bogans, many of the participants are university educated professionals, business owners or doctors.

      While I can’t speak for all Top Gear viewers (although apparently you can) I don’t use a light entertainment show as my authoritative guide to etiquette. 

      Lighten up and enjoy the show or change channel.

    • acotrel says:

      06:26am | 22/02/11

      ’ Despite a commonly held belief that all motorsports fans are bogans, many of the participants are university educated professionals, business owners or doctors.’

      I’m one of those ‘bogans’.  I’m tertary educated as a scientist, and I’m the Secretary of the Winton Motorcycle Club .  It’s interesting who drives on our local circuit.  There’s a group of about 6 doctors who bring the Ferraris and Porsches, and blast around at up to 200KPH.  My heart surgeon, and his offsider sometimes turn up.  They all bring their wives, and they have a lovely time!
      The funniest so far has been footballer Sam Newman.  He arrived with a bright yellow Lamborghini.  When he got out of the car he was wearing matching bright yellow cullottes on his feet!

    • Helen says:

      01:02pm | 22/02/11

      Acotrel - I’m not sure what you were trying do describe on Newman’s feet, but culottes are a type of short trouser. Although Newman is such a nuff-nuff I wouldn’t be all that shocked to see him wearing his trousers on his feet.

    • acotrel says:

      03:17pm | 22/02/11

      Helen, they wrere those cut away slip on shoes made out of shiny yellow plastic - very stylish and really suited to the occasion.  Most of the real car enthusiasts were expensive driving shoes and padded fireproof racing suits - all conformists.  Like most of us they feel the need to wear the uniform to say we’re different. Sam was a bit unusual, and I appreciated it - a good laugh!

    • Tracey Spicer says:

      05:45am | 22/02/11

      Penbo - I normally agree with everything you write - but Top Gear is probably the best show on tele! Well-written, beautifully shot and piss funny. And yes, women love it too!

    • acotrel says:

      06:17am | 22/02/11

      Tracey, the best show on telly is The Antiques Road Show.  I love Midsomer Murders, I like to look at what’s in the backgrounds of the scenes, and poor old ‘barge arse’ doesn’t play a bad part!

    • Luce says:

      09:10am | 22/02/11

      Agreed Tracey.

      Penbo, lighten up!

    • Julie says:

      09:56am | 22/02/11

      I agree! I’m female and I really enjoy the show. Plus it’s a little educational as well watching all the rebuilds and fixes - sorry to say that you’re wrong in saying we don’t watch/enjoy it!

    • Vaunted says:

      10:22am | 22/02/11

      I reckon Top Gear’s show’s practical instruction on the appropriate way of dealing with PC makes ideal viewing for young people.

    • Elle says:

      10:36am | 22/02/11

      Not even slightly interested in cars, own a little 4 cylinder hatchback, and don’t like driving at the best of times. Nonetheless, I have in the past really enjoyed Top Gear - until I overdosed on it courtesy of Channel 9 this year. I aprticularly like the challenges, where they convert old rustbuckets into stretch limousines/houseboats/rockets etc.

      And yep, I’m a girl too. And one of my female friends got me into it. Female Top Gear fans exist!

    • Blackadder says:

      10:50am | 22/02/11

      Agree. My wife and daughter love it…it’s the only show that we all sit down to watch every week.

      As for the article, I think the writer needs to lighten up. It’s a fun show, with presenters who take the mickey out of each other, as well as others. It doesn’t take itself too seriously.

      Unfortunately, the author is from today’s breed of politically correct Nazis who’s contribution to society is to simply ruin it, in the mistaken belief that you can’t say anything about anyone at anytime, for fear of offending someone, somewhere.

    • Kendra says:

      11:35am | 22/02/11

      Agreed Tracey, I’m a bit of a rev head and a female who loves the show.  Yes their stunts are sometimes a bit over the top, but it’s all in the name of entertainment.  Who can possibly forget the soccer match??  Absolutely hilarious!  Long live the Top Gear guys!

    • Anne71 says:

      12:27pm | 22/02/11

      Amen, Tracey Spicer! I myself love UK Top Gear. I’ve got quite a few of the DVDs, and will be going to the live show as well. The only downside of that is I’ve just learned that one of the buffoons from that pathetic excuse of a show they call Australian Top Gear is going to be part of it.
      I love UK TG because it’s light-hearted and funny, and not afraid to take a pot-shot at political correctness. And, I have to admit, I do have a bit of a crush on James May! smile
      Having said that, I was a bit disappointed with their comments about Mexico. Were they supposed to be funny? If so, they missed by a mile. It’s a shame because they can do so much better than that.

    • redvixen says:

      12:49pm | 22/02/11

      I’m female and know nothing about cars other than whether I enjoy driving it, where to put the petrol in and the number of my roadside assistance.  I make no apology for this.  However, I love Top Gear - especially the challenge episodes.  Granted I started to watch it because my husband watches it but if I didn’t like it I’d go and do something else when it’s on.  And at least half of the women I know watch it as well.  Oh, and Penbo, if your back seat is full of Happy Meal boxes perhaps you should concentrate more on nutrition for your children than being the last word in what people should watch on TV!

    • jf says:

      12:56pm | 22/02/11

      It seems that your circles are somewhat exclusive and removed from the everyday Penbo.

      My wife, a tertiary educated senior public servant, enjoys the show more that I do. We are not regular watchers and I grant you that the humour can be banal and cliched as well as based on tired old generalisations. However, it is harmless and made without malice.

      I also grant you that many, me included, are not necessarily rev heads. I drive a Toyota. It suits my needs and desires for now. It’s not to say that I don’t enjoy renting a nicer car if I overseas or interestate. Just that my interest isn’t great enough to buy a flash or car, or, more accurately, spend the time loving and maintaining one if I did own one.

      However, I’m not one to judge another person’s interests lest they judge me more mine.

      I’d be particularly cautious of juding other people if my interests y were so narrowly defined and exclusive that I had not met a single person that enjoyed something that is clearly widely enjoyed.

    • Debs says:

      01:02pm | 22/02/11

      There are definitely tonnes of us female Top Gear fans - count me in!  I love the show - I do find some of the “challenges” a bit lame (and cringeworthy!) so if Jeremy is going on with too much bullsh!t I just watch something else for a while.  But I love the format of the show, the banter between the hosts and adore seeing what’s new and shiny in the automotive world.  Jeremy Clarkson’s books are great too - I have read them all, and find them an amusing read.  Team Top Gear!!

    • amanda says:

      01:57pm | 22/02/11

      I love it,- I am 34 and a woman! It’s highly amusing and watching it(downloaded) is the highlight of my week!

    • macca-d says:

      04:15pm | 23/02/11

      Hahahah…..Clarkson is a wanker….pure and simple.

    • Reg says:

      06:09am | 22/02/11

      Richard Hammond’s “Engineering Connections” far surpasses Top Gear.

    • TChong says:

      06:52am | 22/02/11

      Agree Reg, the little bloke is far more interesting in the Engineering show.

    • Marbo says:

      02:24pm | 22/02/11

      but not Hammond’s kids’ shows which are cringe-worthy. I’m a fan of all the top gear blokes, love James’ other shows too.  And I’m a TG Female Fan!

    • Fog Badger says:

      06:13am | 22/02/11

      Agreed, if you don’t like it, don’t watch it.

    • persephone says:

      06:16am | 22/02/11

      ‘Top Gear’ is a great show.

      I love the trip through Africa, have it on DVD and rewatch it regularly.

      But, Penbo, aren’t you scrapping the barrel a bit here?

      What next, an article on how frustrating it is to get up in the morning and not be able to find a pair of socks?

    • Luce says:

      09:12am | 22/02/11

      Have you seen the Arctic one? so good!

    • Elphaba says:

      10:21am | 22/02/11

      The Vietnam one wins it hands down for me.  Saigon to Hanoi on motorbikes in the wet season - as if nothing will go wrong… wink

    • Lee says:

      10:39am | 22/02/11

      @ Elphaba no WAY- the Bolivan one with the four wheel drives!! The end shot of that 4x4 tumbling is just way too hysterical to miss.

    • Shifter says:

      12:16pm | 22/02/11

      +1 for Africa followed only just by Vietnam…

      Oliverrrrrrr!!!

    • Elphaba says:

      12:21pm | 22/02/11

      @Shifter, Clarkson in the rain screaming abuse up the hill to Dalat on his teeny-tiny scooter - awesome.

      It could be I find Vietnam funniest because I’ve been to everywhere they feature in the program.  Or it could be the hand-made suits.  Or the Bruce Springsteen bike.  Or the Spanish galleon.  Who knows?

      I think Penbo’s article sounds like someone who watched the show for five minutes and then listened to what their mates said about not liking it and just adopted their opinion.

    • Anne71 says:

      12:30pm | 22/02/11

      Botswana special for me, followed by Bolivia, then Vietnam. I think it’s so cute that Hammond still has Oliver!

    • Shifter says:

      12:49pm | 22/02/11

      @Anne71 - agreed. I loved when Jezza and May were saving weight and Hammond was mumbling about how he needs it all.

      @Elphaba - I think Penbo’s having a bit of a lend of us for discussion’s sake. Which is all well and good because the discussion so far has reminded me I have more Top Gear to watch.

      Disregarding the specials, I think one of the best episodes I’ve seen is where the boys head through Europe to find the best driving road. That was one of the best shot bits of TV I’ve ever seen.

    • Anne71 says:

      01:36pm | 22/02/11

      @Shifter - the honey badger and “the world’s best combover” did it for me wink

    • Elphaba says:

      01:59pm | 22/02/11

      @Shifter, damnit, I’ve been suckered.

      I like the supercars for under 10K, and the drive across America to the Bonneville salt flats for the speed racing.

      And even though it’s butt-ugly (the car, not the Hamster), Hammond racing the Porsche Cayenne against the Red Devil.

      And the Bowler Wildcat against the skateboarder… ok, I’ll stop now.

    • Shifter says:

      02:16pm | 22/02/11

      @Anne71 - proof that Top Gear can be educational! I went and found out all about honey badgers after the mention on Top Gear.

      @Elphaba - The “car vs another mode of transport” races are always good. It’s always a great way to point out that a car may not be the most fun or fastest method from A to B. Such as Hammond beating everyone across London on a bike.

    • S.L says:

      06:31am | 22/02/11

      Your research into the show is very shallow Penbo. Top Gear gives itself a hard time as well as other cultures or races. You forgot to mention every time Jeremy Clarkson is dealing with a German he always gets in a dig about 1966 (the year England beat West Germany in the World Cup Final) or WW2. The show has little relevence to Aussie blokes as most of the cars being tested will never be sold here but the one simple fact why it is popular is it is entertaining.
      Also Penbo if you are going to knock classic British Comedy try and get your facts right. The bigot on Love Thy Neighbour was Eddie Booth and Alf Garnet was in Till Death Us Do Part

    • acotrel says:

      06:44am | 22/02/11

      S.L. when I was in England a couple of years ago, I stayed in the Dun Horse Inn in Mannings Heath near Horsham.  The publican told me his son was going to Sydney,  Australia on a scholarship to learn to play cricket.  I said to him ‘of course we don’t know much about cricket’.  I still crack up thinking about the effect that remark had on him.  He scratched around trying to find things to come back with.  Even remarked on myself sitting in the passenger seat reading a map while my wife drove!

    • DInsdale says:

      01:27pm | 22/02/11

      And Manuel was Spanish (”...he’s from Barcelona.”), not Mexican

    • Rowdy says:

      01:43pm | 22/02/11

      Que?

    • Paul says:

      06:47am | 22/02/11

      Yeah, this was a misfire of a post - weirdly off key, carping and, really, a bit whiny by your standards.  I get the impression your LatinAmerica-philia demanded satisfaction for their grave insult to the good citizens of Mexico and you couldn’t sleep straight until you managed to shoehorn a defence of them into a rather generic swing at a show that is clearly not aimed at those of us only interested in the utility of vehicular transport and seems not to give a regurgitated burrito whether we approve of it or not.  Whatsmore, despite my car illiteracy, I quite enjoy watching it, not because I know anything about cars or even aspire to, but because when it is good it is entertaining and that’s about all I ever expect from it.  And my wife knows and cares less about cars than I do but watches it on occasion as well - and she’s a school teacher so knows infantile behaviour when she sees it, and yet still neither of us seem consumed with derision, outrage or contempt.  I suspect a lot of its appeal is the fact it is perhaps the only place on television where people can vicariously live out their desires to speak and act without the self-surveillance which is for the most part required in the adult world of propriety.  And yes, they bang on a bit much about WW2 and the decline of the British Empire and deride those other than them…what’s your point?

    • Godfrey Zohn says:

      11:36am | 22/02/11

      Agreed - OP is about 180 degrees off - but it’s worth remembering these blogs are made for just one purpose - to get people’s backs up and generate many replies - looks like I’ve been sucked in as well.  Educated bogan with a healthy interest in cars and a Top Gear habit which persists despite it’s occasional cringeworthiness. Oh - Alf Garnett? A quick Google would have fixed that one.  Fail.

    • acotrel says:

      03:26pm | 22/02/11

      Paul, the article by penbo sounded a bit jealous, but as opposed to the topics on other days, it generated a light hearted atmosphere, and a feeling of good humour.  So perhaps we need more Top Gear stuff? It might help to ward off depression?

    • Missing socks says:

      06:53am | 22/02/11

      Would this show about socks tell us how to find them? I am a tertiary educated, practicing (I hope to get it right one day) scientist and I would love to take part in an off-road rally event, just for the sheer thrill of doing something that is not totally dictated by the formalities of our lives these days. So, like many others, don’t watch the damn show if you do not understand it, like it, and so on…..

    • acotrel says:

      07:34am | 22/02/11

      @ MIssing, better to join a car club, and take part in the timed sprints.  Rallies won’t be around much longer, it’s too difficult to control the risks.

    • persephone says:

      07:52am | 22/02/11

      Missing socks

      There has been extensive scientific research into the sock phenomenon. The theory currently under serious consideration in the peer reviewed journals holds that socks are the larval form of wire coathangers.

    • Steve of Cornubia says:

      09:26am | 22/02/11

      I used to participate in rallies and circuit racing, back when I was fearless and unbreakable. Now, memories of high-speed, dead of night drives thru wet welsh countryside keep me awake at night. Jeez I was stupid.

      Love the WRC, there’s no way I could emulate Loeb and co, especially in the forests. Barking.

      Oh, and I rarely miss Top Gear. I think my favourite episode was the one where they put a mini down a ski jump. Because it wasn’t fast enough, they strapped a rocket to it, obviously. Genius.

    • kath Grant says:

      10:33am | 22/02/11

      Join a sporting car club, they have lots of events and you don’t have own a sports car.

    • Geoffrey Chaucer says:

      01:32pm | 22/02/11

      Missing Socks,

      If you live in the Newcastle area, you could get in touch with the 2011 Newcastle Variety Bash or one of the participating teams. You could have great fun while contributing to a great cause. Variety is a children charity.

      http://www.varietynsw.org.au

      You can also get some idea of the event on one of the many participants’ websites, for example:

      http://www.car1800.com

    • Danny B says:

      03:52pm | 22/02/11

      @ Persephone

      I thought the latest theory was that the closing of the sock drawer created a minature space-time wormhole that spirited one or two socks at a time off to the far side of the Universe?  I suppose this is what I get for not keeping up with the latest science publications :D

    • persephone says:

      04:27pm | 22/02/11

      Danny B

      Talk about gullible!!

      Look, that’s just one of the alternative theories put forward by the denialists, who don’t want to believe that coathangers are mating in their wardrobes, laying eggs (commonly dismissed as lint) which later hatch into socks.

      Rather than accept the clear evidence of their own eyes, their puritanical impulse to deny the sexual urges of coathangers have led them to absurd theories involving wormholes in space.

      We know that these wormholes are flat out dealing with all the stuff which has been put in a safe place. There’s no way they could cope with socks as well.

      Really, the idiocies I have to deal with on this site….

    • The Stig says:

      07:01am | 22/02/11

      OK, Top Gear is really crap. It does not pretend to be otherwise.(Richard Hammond making bottom jokes is just not funny.) But if you do not like it, turn it off and watch something else! It was Eddie Booth who had the “darkies” move in next door too, not Alf Garnett. Do some research please, or are you trying to emulate the light entertainment style of Top Gear where a quick stereotype about the frogs or the krauts makes up for serious analysis.
      The episode in which Richard Hammond drove through the southern USA in a ute scrawled with “Man love rules” in pink paint was one of the funniest things I have ever seen. Stupid, childish and intellectually barren, lets face it the yanks are an easy target, but funny all the same.
      The Top Gear crew do not take themselves too seriously and I suggest no viewer should either.

    • Liz says:

      07:03am | 22/02/11

      A ‘raffish, knock-about’ racist in the true British manner as only the British know how! women watch and love the show too apparently, I gave up long ago and no longer read his column either, being a knocker all the time gets boring.

    • adie says:

      07:04am | 22/02/11

      I love Top Gear.  Clarkson, May, and the Hamster are amusing, a lot of the challenges that they do are pretty impressive (even if they’re possibly staged at times).

      Ive liked Top Gear ever since my boyfriend first showed it to me.  And it was never about liking it for his sake (as you claim, because otherwise i would like 5th Gear as well), as we broke up several years back, and i still watch the show.

      As someone who spent most of her childhood standing around at car meets with a group of people who could tell if your car had the wrong hose clamp for its age, ive always found it funny when Clarkson takes the piss out of those kind of meets.

      A lot of the cars they feature i’ll never be able to own.  But its nice to watch the boys drive it, and dream for a bit.

    • Tim says:

      07:10am | 22/02/11

      You drive a Holden station wagon, no wonder you hate cars and Top Gear!

    • Megsy says:

      07:14am | 22/02/11

      I have enjoyed watching Top Gear for quite a few years with my 10 yo son.  Less so now, when it seems to saturate the night time TV.  The early days were wittier and fun.  But I would have to agree it is made for kids (the big male ones and the little ones) and disagree about it not appealing to women.  I live the fact that my son can spout off about Vayrons (sp?) and Lambos, of which I know nothing.

    • acotrel says:

      07:43am | 22/02/11

      Megsy, a passion for racing cars, and motorcycles is not all bad.  I spend a lot of my life doing tricky engineering on a racing motorcycle.  I’ve never trained as a fitter and turner, and I’m not a mechanical engineer.  I’ve shown my bike to some of the engineers I worked with, and I know from their comments, the engineering involved is beyond them, despite their tertiary qualifications.  You son could end up with some unexpected competencies, which can only help him enjoy life! For me, the biggest thrill I can have, is to build my own machine, and win a race with it.  I’ve done that twice in recent years.

    • Christine says:

      07:15am | 22/02/11

      What have you got to say about Bear Grylls then?  I have to sit through that one too LOL!  Lying in bed with the pillow wrapped around my hears so I don’t have to listen to Bear’s absolutely disgusting eating habits while the other half chortles and slaps his leg at Bear’s antics.  Clarkson and Co are easier to take but still very “Boys Own” and really rather silly old men.

    • The Original Oz says:

      10:47am | 22/02/11

      Bear Grylls is an utter waste of space and the TV executive who thought that he should have a show of his own deserves to be out sweeping streets for a living. I enjoy Top Gear but Bear Grylls NO WAY he is a goose.

    • Lee says:

      12:57pm | 22/02/11

      His mother never hugged him. That’s my theory

    • Seano says:

      07:15am | 22/02/11

      I like Top Gear. I’m someone who came to driving late in life (designated drinker) and was never particularly interested in cars. Now I quite enjoy the show and the fact that they like to take the piss, all the better.

      I always think that you can get away with all sorts of things with comedy if you’re funny, and these guys are mostly funny.

      PS. My 18 month old daughter loves the show too, particularly the the studio parts, she sits on my lap and claps along with the audience.

    • Bob says:

      07:26am | 22/02/11

      On ya Penbo - I couldn’t agree more! I’ve seen the show a couple of times, before changing channels to something more intelligent like Mr Magoo!! I can’t see why these guys have to carry on like bogans, impressed with speed, loud noise and trashing expensive cars. As you say in the article - “Top Gear is no more a show for adults than Play School”. Another incisive article - thanks mate!

    • acotrel says:

      03:32pm | 22/02/11

      I like Thomas the Tank Engine better!

    • Richard B says:

      09:27pm | 22/02/11

      I agree, and unfortunately, it’s making all its viewers think the same way! Very dangerous stuff.

    • Glen says:

      07:27am | 22/02/11

      I normally like your articles, but you’re missing the point on this one Penbo.

      For one, as much as the show is about cars, it’s not really.  People with a passing interest in cars can still get some good laughs and get to see some spectacular and well shot footage.

      And secondly, the blokes take the piss out of themselves (and their countrymen) far more than anyone else.  The line that the program was “making comic use of a stereotype; a practice with which regular viewers of Top Gear will be familiar” is 100% accurate.

      And thirdly,  if you don’t like it - don’t watch.  Based on the ratings plenty of people do like it.  I’d much rather see you go both barrels on some crap like 2 1/2 Men, now that is some braindead television….

    • Car Loving Woman says:

      07:31am | 22/02/11

      “I’ve never met a woman who claims to like it”

      Well, I do. I love it, in fact.

      Your skills as a journalist would vastly improve if you didn’t determine what people liked based solely on their gender.

    • KH says:

      09:16am | 22/02/11

      So do I.  My fantasy car is one of those lovely Bugatti Veyrons….......I just purchased a Top Gear supercar book so I can drool over the cars.
      Penbo - not all TV has to be ‘educational’ or even ‘serious’............sometimes it is just plain old light entertainment, and there isn’t anything wrong with that!

    • Chi says:

      11:54am | 22/02/11

      Me three! I love the jovial nature of the show, and the way they take the piss out of everyone - every country including England gets mocked from time to time, they mock each other constantly, it’s great fun!

      I have little interest in the mechanics of cars (though I still find it interesting to learn about), but seeing what they can do with the cars themselves, on the road and on the track is incredible.

    • sailorgirl says:

      02:01pm | 22/02/11

      I love it too, and have loved it for a long time.
      I have every season on DVD, and introduced it to a lot of my friends, some of whom were male, some of whom were female. Common thread - most of them like it!

    • Janice says:

      07:34am | 22/02/11

      Well firstly Penbo, I am a middle aged female, I love Top Gear and all three hosts, and I love cars and I find them interesting.  I will never have any of the cars they test drive, but I still love to see them.  I would give anything to have the job of driving so many different cars. And you know what, the guys are hilarious. I love the way they take the piss out of everyone.  Tuesday night is the best night of the week for TV.

    • Yossarian says:

      07:36am | 22/02/11

      I have absolutely no interest in cars, but I love Top Gear. It’s piss funny for precisely the reasons Penbo derides. I also know many women, none of whom have an interest in cars and all of whom hold high ranking corporate and public sector positions, who think the show is high-larious and watch it religiously. Penbo, I think you are in desperate need of a friend clean out - try to get some new ones with a sense of humour and you’ll start enjoying life more. Sadly, you’re starting to turn into a stereotypical journalist - jaded, cynical and unable to see the amusing side of anything.

    • Top Show says:

      11:57am | 22/02/11

      Agree fully, what many do not understand is Top Gear is actually not all about cars!  The entertainment value is the fact it is so UN pc.  Driving gas guzzling cars, taking the piss out of others (or other countries) is designed to upset the tree huggers, which to many (who have had a gut full of being pc) is great entertainment.!

    • EJDR says:

      07:37am | 22/02/11

      I agree with you David about women generally disliking Top Gear. I find the show completely infantile and at times “cringeworthy”. The best I can do is a couple of minutes of it. I do need to say however that all of the males in my family really enjoy it and watch it religiously. I think because you and your friends are probably not interested in cars David (and I’m with you on that one), it seems inconceivable that large numbers of the western male population do have some levels of interest and therefore watch this programme.

    • Bonestar says:

      07:40am | 22/02/11

      David Penberthy hates Top Gear as much as i hate the articles he’s been writing of recent times.

    • Fi says:

      07:43am | 22/02/11

      @Seano - your 18 month daughter likes the flashing colours and noise. She probably laughs when she soils herself. Why is her liking of the show relevant to whether it’s good or not?

    • Seano says:

      08:34am | 22/02/11

      Title of the article: “Is Top Gear the best children’s show on television?”

      Do try to keep up.

    • M. Gdafey says:

      07:45am | 22/02/11

      TOP GEAR- its the show my family gets together to watch.

    • iansand says:

      07:45am | 22/02/11

      Hey Hey It’s Saturday with cars and no ostrich.  And better jokes.

    • Macca says:

      08:55am | 22/02/11

      @iansand, it has an Ostrich, it’s name is Jeremy.

    • iansand says:

      09:41am | 22/02/11

      Ostriches and geese are different species.  Clarkson is the latter.

      Although he is quite charming in real life.  I took his photo for him at Garie Beach once.  We had a good chat.  He was driving a Lotus, if anyone cares.

    • ibast says:

      07:48am | 22/02/11

      I’m only mildly entertained by the show and I normally abhor racist sentiment, but I didn’t see the Mexican comments as racist.  In fact quite the opposite.  They were commenting on the cliche characterture of Mexico presented by Hollywood.

    • Bron says:

      07:51am | 22/02/11

      Gee David, I didn’t realise commercial television was only allowed to show programs that appealed to you-don’t worry about anyone elses interests. Top Gear is awesome light entertainment -it never claims to be anything else. It mocks everyone & everything equally, including themselves. I would suggest the affinity you have with Mexico as per your bio has made you a touch overly sensitive. I would also suggest there is nothing infantile about having a knowledge of automobiles, unless you fail to see a value in science & engineering?
      PS: I am a woman & I have other female friends who also enjoy Top Gear.

    • Leigh says:

      07:52am | 22/02/11

      you’re a wanker Penbo, seriously…...

    • Bennymac says:

      08:00am | 22/02/11

      “It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B”

      “There’s plenty of better things to spend our money on, to aspire to, to talk about”

      Planes, trains and automobiles will be remembered as the #1 human acheivement of the 20th century.

      The internal combustion engine, developed first in cars, was used to, and made possible, the first successfull, powered, manned flight by the wright brothers. From there the aero industry turned into the aerospace industry, man landed on the moon in 1969, and i can visit the other side of the world for a holiday without a six month return sea journey.

      Other things to think about are the bigger cars ie: tractors, trucks, earth moving equipment, used to till fields and haul food across the globe, allowing you and i the free time to intreract on this website, instead of milking the cows, weeding the vege patch and taking the pigs to market via horse and carriage.

      If people like Alphonse Beau de Rochas, Nikolaus Otto, Dugald Clerk, Rudolf Diesel, didn’t spend their money on, aspire to, or talk about their interests, the world would be a very different place.

    • Elphaba - vrrooom! says:

      08:05am | 22/02/11

      “but I’ve never met a woman who claims to like it,”

      You’re talking to the wrong women, David.  And I think you’re taking the show waaaay too seriously.  I love Top Gear.  Sure, it’s probably starting to stagnate, and be a bit forced at times, but I still love it.  I’m not even that interested in cars, but the boys are witty, smart, and the films of the road/track tests are just superb.

      The Vietnam specal is by far the best program they ever made.  I thought I was going to have an asthma attack, I was laughing so hard.

      The kerfuffle about the Stig was warranted.  He ruined some of the magic of the show by being a big whinger.  I mean seriously, he got to drive cars that most people will never get within 10 feet of, let alone drive, without the pressures of fame.  What a douche.  I hear now he wants to start a rival program.  Good luck.

      Hammond is cute and smart, May is brain sexy (*sigh*), and Clarkson reminds me a little of my Dad.  They’re cashing in on the same thing that made the Mythbusters famous - smart guys doing stupid stuff is funny.  If they make an obscene amount of money doing it, good bloody luck to them.  I hope they never change.  If you don’t like it, well, I guess there’s always an exception that proves the rule.

    • Shifter says:

      12:23pm | 22/02/11

      I’m all for women who love Top Gear, but that said, I’ve always wanted a bright orange smoking jacket. And a replica galleon.

      On a side note I think Mr Collins may need to head back to the BTCC for some work, I doubt the BBC or Sky will go against Top Gear and Fifth Gear in the same genre.

    • Elphaba says:

      12:31pm | 22/02/11

      @Shiifter, yes, I don’t know how well he’s going to do with a show.  He wanted a bigger bite of the fame apple and got it - too bad that might mean him getting spat on it public.

      I nearly died with laughter when I saw those suits.  Priceless!  But it is just like that!  Go in, pick the material, pick the outfit, come back the next day - clothes.  Sensational.  My only problem was, I was so overwhelmed I couldn’t make enough decisions about what I wanted.

      I’ll be ready next time…

    • Shifter says:

      01:00pm | 22/02/11

      I think I’d like to go to Vietnam for that very reason, to buy a suit. Or three.

      And to see Hue. Apparently it is still very bullet scarred from the war.

    • Elphaba says:

      01:32pm | 22/02/11

      @Shifter, Hue was amazing.  By far the hottest point in Vietnam though, faark!  42 degrees and humidity that feels like a solid wall when we were there.

      But tough it out.  We went bike riding for a day!  The Forbidden City is very interesting, it takes a few hours to get around it, but like they show on the TG special, the collision of these ancient buildings with modern bullet scars is wild.  Quite a bit less shopping in Hue, since a lot of that is in places like Hoi An and Hanoi, but you can also visit Khe Sanh and the DMZ - also very interesting.

    • Andrew says:

      08:09am | 22/02/11

      Since when was Alf Garnett on Love Thy Neighbour? I think you mean Till Death Us Do Part. Do your research Penbo.

    • Vroom vroom says:

      08:14am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is a lifestyle show, not a car show.

      It’s about looking at cars/places/events most people can never afford or will never go to.

      I watched one season, but then it repeats itself, so I too wonder what the attraction is. I feel the hosting is cringe worthy, as we see them trying really hard to think up a new line.
      “It’s like…a bucket of monkeys in a blender!”, and dud bits like “Can I outrun a Leopard tank in my Lexus!”, or “Who can stand the heat in a car on a sunny day the longest! Yeah!”

      I would have loved it when I was 10.

      Consequently, I don’t watch it, except for the few grabs I incidentally see.

      So far just about every commenter seems to have missed the point of the article, which could equally apply to followers of sports.

    • Eleanor says:

      08:22am | 22/02/11

      One of the best things about being dumped after Christmas is that now I won’t have to endure any more Top Gear boy’s nights and hiding in the bedroom trying to read while the boys all stayed up until god know’s when playing Gran Turismo with the volume on full.

      I don’t get the appeal anymore. All they ever really feature on Top Gear are cars most people couldn’t ever afford, and then they do stupid challenges - like playing soccer. It was funny as hell at first, but now it’s just a tired old trope. Yes, we get it, Jeremy’s a crotchety old bugger, Hammond’s cheeky and May is the slowpoke. Move on already.

    • Bazza says:

      12:02pm | 22/02/11

      “cars most people couldn’t ever afford” - Yep, the show is pretty much tapping into that aspirational thing that is so popular these days, which was pioneered in Dallas. Look how rich these people are. Look at what they drive. Look at what rich people do.

      It’s no coincidence that shows that feature characters that are all successful and respected are popular. Top Gear is just another version of it.

    • Shifter says:

      01:38pm | 22/02/11

      It’s a form of escapism. I know I’m probably never going to be able to afford an item of desire such as a Ferrari F430 Scuderia, but that doesn’t stop me enjoying seeing one in action.

      Maybe some people pine for an engagement ring link Princess Di’s, but it’s likely the can’t afford one. This doesn’t stop those people indulging in the stories of the ring in New Idea and Woman’s Day et al.

      The appeal is in the field of interest, obviously @Eleanor you’re not that enamoured by fast and loud cars. Yes, the antics will have a use by date, but if anything the presenters have been adaptable over there years.

    • Eleanor says:

      03:27pm | 22/02/11

      Shifter - I get it. I used to really enjoy Top Gear. Then, it just got over the top in my opinion, and my ex watched it so much I couldn’t hear the theme song without wanting to bang my head into a wall.

    • Shifter says:

      11:08am | 23/02/11

      I’ve never really considered the Allman Brothers being able to drive someone to self harm.

    • Paul C says:

      08:25am | 22/02/11

      At least it’s a refreshing change from all the american crap we usually see.  Typical journo, would probably rather curl up in bed with a book all weekend.

    • Joel B1 says:

      08:28am | 22/02/11

      The writer has missed the point on several issues here. The notion that a car is just for A to B shows a lack of understanding.

      By way of example, as a youngster I was taken from a lovely city environment into the country to live. The boring, nothing to do except watch the sheep frolic country. For me and everyone else a car was a lifeline to escape rural life and do something. It also gave us access to the city where the employment is, even if it meant getting up at 5:20am to get to work on time. And quoting from that Ministry track “Jesus Built my Hotrod”; “Where you are aint no good unless you can get away from it”

      Having said that I find Top Gear really loathsome, sort of fascinating yet at the same time unbearable.

    • top gear lover says:

      08:29am | 22/02/11

      Just read through the “About Us” section on Penbo…
      “When not writing about stuff or reading stuff other people have written, he can be found at home in the kitchen cooking traditional dishes from Mexico, where he lived for a year in 1986, and which after a few tequilas he will wrongly cite as his place of birth.”
      ah, that explains this article’s bitterness

    • Bonestar says:

      09:24am | 22/02/11

      He’s just letting off some flatulence oops i mean steam.

    • Tubesteak says:

      10:27am | 22/02/11

      Mexico:

      One of the few places on earth that hires a 21yo to be a police commissioner because no-one else applied for the job because they’re too scared of the druglords.

      Mexico: sounds like one hell of a backwater of a hell-hole

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      12:20pm | 22/02/11

      Why does Mexico have such a shitty olympic team?

      Because all the ones that can run, swim & jump are in America.

      Whoops. Penbo. Can I laugh at that without racially stereotyping?

    • Huey says:

      08:30am | 22/02/11

      The cars tested are mostly automotive porn but the show is funny. If they don’t take themselves seriously; and they don’t. Why should Penbo? It’s a bit
      blokey (pommy style) non-P.C. and meant to be humorous.  Seven hours a week would be way too much though.

    • Steven says:

      08:33am | 22/02/11

      I’m jumping on a plane on Sunday for Geneva to go and see the Geneva Motor Show and there won’t be a Holden wagon or a sock drawer in site.

      Would you like me to provide a review for The Punch, Penbo?

      As noted by a number of people before me, the participation rate in motor sports and car club related activities is much higher than many realise.  There are a lot of closet petrol heads out there.  I live in Tassie and I’m always astounded by the number and quality of vehicles that get dragged out of the sheds when there’s a classic car show on somewhere.

      They’re much more than A to B, Penbo.

    • Wayne Kerr says:

      08:38am | 22/02/11

      My wife and step-daughter love the show.  So there’s at least 2 females that watch it.  Me, on the other hand, am quite bored with it and don’t watch it anymore.  It just seems to be the same gags and same dialogue every week and the hosts seem to try and be more ludicrous in each episode.

      But to each their own.

    • Gee Jay says:

      01:46pm | 22/02/11

      I used to watch it too,untill it whent to ch.9—now a 60 minute show takes 90 mins.—shocking!! Clarkson is a big headed twat…

    • Female Fan says:

      08:47am | 22/02/11

      I am a woman and I love watching Top Gear.

      That is all.

    • Mck Doohan says:

      08:52am | 22/02/11

      I think you have to be from pommie land to like this show.
      Don’t find it interesting or funny and I love cars and MC’s

      Play school for adults is a good analogy.

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      11:51am | 22/02/11

      That could be right, except for the fact that its the most watched TV show worldwide…

    • acotrel says:

      06:43am | 26/02/11

      Mick, If it gets people interested in motor sport, it can’t be all bad?  I’ve raced a fair bit over the years, and I agree the show is a bit of a yawn.  But if the kiddies love it, let’s have more.  We might eventually get decent TV coverage of more events? I suggest Top Gear is cause for optimisim amongst mosport enthusiasts!

    • Steve says:

      08:52am | 22/02/11

      Dear Penbo - almost all commerical televison is puerile rubbish designed for children and childish adults.  Why are you even objecting?

      Extrapolating from one tv show’s popularity to sweeping claims about men and their knowledge of autos is a big reach.

      If you’re going to object to the rubbish shows, I hope you have a very large DVD collection.

    • Ana says:

      08:54am | 22/02/11

      I’m a 35 year old woman, not a bogan and love this show. You just have to take it for what it is.. light entertainment. It doesnt pretend to be anything else and the hosts are quite happy to take shots at themselves as much as they do anyone else.

      And besides - who wouldnt love to get paid to have the fun they obviously have?

    • Rob says:

      08:56am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is so gloriously un-politically correct, it’s no surprise why its an easy target for Right-On Penberthy. Frankly, I’m pleased it exists.

    • Cybacat says:

      08:57am | 22/02/11

      This article is clearly written to get a reaction by picking on the world’s most popular TV show - and you’re getting one.  There is more than a hint if envy in the article at these mates who get to travel the world driving hit cars and just having a laugh with each other.  It’s pure male escapism.  One reason it’s popular is it do refreshing to see a show that’s not politically correct and isn’t afraid to have a joke.  If you so crave PC non-speak, perhaps tune in to media watch or the ABC book club.

    • biff says:

      08:59am | 22/02/11

      I am proud to say that I have never watched Top Gear after having to suffer through the banality of the show’s promo clips. I want to know why Jeremy Clarkson spends plenty of time with his hands in his pockets. What are his hands playing with?

    • cleaver says:

      09:00am | 22/02/11

      Penberthy, you’ve ended a sentence with “is”. Not just any sentence, but the final sentence of the article. Rather infantile grammar wouldn’t you say?

      Enough of the scorn for enthusiasts, please, otherwise we’d all wear black suits with white shirts, drive silver/white/black cars, and purchase items such as a house based on their potential resale rather than their value, worth or meaning to us.

      The entire sporting world would be made up of fairweather fans who support only the winner side.

      Cut them a break Penbo; without enthusiasts it would be a sad, passionless life.

    • acotrel says:

      03:39pm | 22/02/11

      Cleaver, the big attraction about motorsport is the opportunity to participate.  I’m usually a spectator, but now and then I manage to prepare my bike, and coincidentally can afford to race.  There’s a lot to be said for having an active manhood.  Incidentally, the fastest driver at the Benalla Auto Club sprints is often Robyn Wagner, she’s much faster then her husband he is no slouch himself.

    • Cassandra says:

      09:03am | 22/02/11

      You’ve struck a nerve with a couple of readers Penbo.

      Oh dear there are differences of opinion and a few feathers ruffled. Special mention, as always, to Erick. True to form, he managed to bring his own special perspective and theme into this - he reminds me of John Pilger in some ways. Nevermind.

      Well I watch it occassionally and I know some women who really enjoy the show. But I think it is all getting a bit past it now. It can be funny but things are getting tired. It is very formulaic and a lot of that is becoming cliched.

      Jeremy Clarkson really has had a fair run but his blatherings are predictable. Good luck to him for the mileage he gets out of so little Compare anything he has written a few years ago to now - not that different is it?  He is just a little too predictable - his rants are all his recycled exaggerations based on stereotypes of the type of people he doesn’t like

      One thing about the show which deserves credit is that it the format works so well (as judged by its popularity) because of the chemistry between the three. May and Hammond do not have the same presence on their own shows (IMO) and the Australian version just never struck a chord with the audience.

      Yes, yes I know -  if I don’t like it, I shouldn’t watch it. But I wonder how long before it gradually slips below the waves into ratings slumberland.

      Oh and the Mexican episode. This is one perspective
      http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/2011/feb/05/top-gear-offensive-steve-coogan 

      Each to their own

    • kath Grant says:

      10:57am | 22/02/11

      You’ve raised a really interesting point Cassandra.  Why are tv shows/films about people who are obviously fond of one another, and who hit sparks off each other so endearing?

    • Nevyn says:

      12:47pm | 22/02/11

      If the Top Gear crew REALLY made stereotype remarks about the Mexicans it would have surely included something about running drugs and killing people in their thousands over those drugs.

    • CaptainCrunch says:

      09:05am | 22/02/11

      Gee Penbo…

      You would boo Santa because you don’t like reindeer.

    • Luce says:

      09:07am | 22/02/11

      You know, Penbo, I normally agree with your articles, but can’t get on board with this unnecessarily patronizing one.

      Top Gear is one of the most watched shows world wide, and for a couple of reasons. Firstly, as much as it may bewilder you, a lot of people actually do like cars. Some of them are amazing pieces of machinery, which go fast and are fun to drive, and look amazing. Your lack of interest in them doesn’t change that for everyone else. Secondly, it’s light hearted British humor which is silly and enjoyable to watch. What’s not to like??

      Add to that Richard Hammond is gorgeous.

      And for the record I love Top Gear, and know a lot of other women who do as well.

    • ibast says:

      09:07am | 22/02/11

      Well we all now know Penberthy drives a Camry.

    • Matt says:

      09:59am | 22/02/11

      He’s not Indian is he?
      (how’s that for racial profiling!)

    • Nicole says:

      11:10am | 22/02/11

      He said a Holden…. And who makes Camry…. DER!

    • Ydo says:

      09:11am | 22/02/11

      So David,

      You watch it but you don’t like it, you don’t get the jokes, you don’t like racial stereotyping (although you managed to throw a barb in there about English food), and your own car is a pig sty. 

      Hmmm, where could you have better spent your time?  Maybe cleaning and reading books on nutrition?

    • Brad says:

      09:12am | 22/02/11

      Penbo… Hmm sounds Mexican. Shit article by the way.

    • Elisabeth says:

      09:14am | 22/02/11

      Woman. Love the show. Nothing more to be said really.

    • Dupa says:

      09:18am | 22/02/11

      I am a 36 male who lives in a small country community bought up on a love for all things with wheels and engines. I have made my self sit thru’ nearly a whole episode of top gear only to be bitterly disapointed. It is a whole load of pommy bullsh#t.

    • James says:

      10:14am | 22/02/11

      You’re being post-modern and ironic, surely?

    • Luce says:

      11:21am | 22/02/11

      Ironically, the silly humour is just too far above some people..

    • Emma Short says:

      09:30am | 22/02/11

      I’m female, 40 and I adore Top Gear, I never miss an episode. My daughters who are 13 & 11 love it too. I find Jeremy and James VERY attractive, I have a Cool Wall inside my wardrobe and get a little thrill when I look at the picture of a Jag coupe every morning. I care about the car I drive, the joy of steering a beautiful machine around the corners makes the school run enjoyable. Penbo, maybe you should test drive a real car instead of driving a crummy Holden and stop feeding your children McCrappy meals or they’ll grow up to be as gormless as you!

    • funfun says:

      09:36am | 22/02/11

      this article is one man’s opinion….. every time an episode of Top Gear goes to air, several hundred million people across the globe, disagree with this man’s opinion. nuff said.

    • Denise Webber says:

      09:37am | 22/02/11

      I don’t even like cars, but I LOVE watching Top Gear, my housemate who is from England put me on to it when it first started showing on SBS.  Jeremy Clarkson takes the piss out of everyone, especially himself, anyone who thinks he is being deadly serious about anything he says really needs to improve their comprehension skills.

      And for the record, I’m female.

    • Chris says:

      09:38am | 22/02/11

      David, why oh why did i waste 2 minutes of my life reading this blog?  Have you lost your TV remote?  As said previously, if you don’t like it, then don’t watch it. 

      Your blog sounds strangely similar to the ramblings of a pensioner, angry at a suggestive commercial aired during his dinnertime at 3pm.  Things like this are only written when there is too much time on one’s hands. 

      Either that, or you are just trying to get a rise out of readers (and the associated number web page hits) - in which case, well done sir!

    • Kirsty says:

      09:39am | 22/02/11

      You comment on the Top Gear hosts bad mouthing other nations/cultures and yet you come out with this - “not bad coming from the nation which brought us tripe in white sauce, pickled eggs and the hot chip sandwich.” 
      Pot. Kettle. Black.

      Also, a hot chip sandwich is delicious!

    • Jason says:

      10:17am | 22/02/11

      Especially with gravy ...

    • JohnScwarz says:

      09:41am | 22/02/11

      The author is a tosser.

    • Top Gear Fan says:

      09:42am | 22/02/11

      Penberthy is just jealous that he cant get 300 million people to read his blog as Top Gear has an audience of over 300 million, it is the worlds most watched TV program for a reason.

    • Steve says:

      09:46am | 22/02/11

      Lol, you wouldn;t know real driving pleasure in your silver station wagon with the kids in the back.

      You just jelly you dont get to talk crap, get paid millions and cruise around it wicked cars.

    • ij says:

      09:46am | 22/02/11

      I’ll guess that the author has never actually seen Top Gear.
      It’s a bit of fun, and anyone who takes offence should just grow up.

    • Ralphie42 says:

      09:46am | 22/02/11

      Hell Yes! Men Like cars, that’s why we watch it! If you don’t like to watch thye show, turn the channel. As for me ....Vroooommmm!!! Vrooommmm!!!!

    • veraison says:

      09:47am | 22/02/11

      Clearly Penbo has had a sense of humour bypass.  I’m a woman, I’m not particularly interested in cars, can’t stand hoons and rev-heads but think this is one of the funniest shows on television.  I love that Jeremy says what people would love to say but daren’t - it is so non-PC in a world where political correctness has gone into overdrive (excuse the pun).  Lighten up.

    • Nick says:

      09:50am | 22/02/11

      Fair enough if you don’t like Top Gear, but who the hell are you to tell the world we aren’t allowed to be interested in cars?

      It’s a bit rich to say the Top Gear presenters are living in a state of arrested development, then proclaim that nobody can like what you don’t like.

    • Benjamin Bonatesta says:

      10:03am | 22/02/11

      “infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B.” Your piece of crap that you discribed is obviously a machine that gets you from A to B. B ut one day you might be travelling along a desrted section of road. Your vehicle stops, you have no phone signal and your family has run out off maccas. Your whole family is now at risk. In some parts of Australia at serious risk of death. And you have the nerve to say that knowing so much about a car is “Infantile” Its people like you that are creating a generation of men that have no idea about anything. Totally self relient on the infantile moron that went and got the knowledge to be a mechanic, plumber, handy man, etc. This is the reason our youth work at maccas instead of getting a real job. Cause they think that its all right to be oblivous to the things around us that make our modern life work.

    • Cassie says:

      12:34pm | 22/02/11

      Thanks Benjamin. I’ve been trying to put into words my disgust at the slur against people who have a knowledge and understanding of cars. You’ve summed it up pretty well.

      Penbo. Next time you get your car serviced or repaired I suggest you mention to the mechanic what an infantile profession he or she has entered. Let’s see you get that silver commodore from A to B without their help.

      So you don’t like Top Gear. That’s fine, I do (and I’m a woman). But there’s no need to label an interest in cars as infantile.

    • Tris says:

      09:51am | 22/02/11

      David, You’re going through a mid-life crisis and you don’t know it. Did nothing in your youth and re-living it now!

    • Derek says:

      09:52am | 22/02/11

      I take it Penberthy is one of those car owners that call road side assistance when he gets a flat tyre or the windscreen washer runs out of fluid.

    • Anne71 says:

      12:56pm | 22/02/11

      He could probably do with watching James May’s “Man Lab” then wink

    • Simon says:

      09:57am | 22/02/11

      You’re a joke David….an utter joke. It took every ounce of my self control to not comment on your last piece about “Boys club win again in AFL” but you’ve really done it with this one.
      Top Gear constantly takes the piss out of itself and its presenters. Do you really think anyone except you cares that they make a gag about the stereotypical mexican? They make gags about every stereotype in the world. As much as may not like it, stereotypes are funny and this is purely because everyone knows they’re not true! Do you really think those three blokes don’t eat mexican food because they think its “sick with cheese on top”? Seriously mate, grow up. You’re a professional, start acting like one and write a story that people might actually take seriously for once.
      “Cars are boring”? Wow thats interesting coming from a bloke who makes a living on grinding people for expressing an apparently shallow and narrow minded opinion on….well…everything. The show has 500 million viewers mate. My girlfriend loves top gear, as do I, and I don’t pay much attention to cars. You’re a joke mate. Read every single one of your articles and then look at yourself in the mirror….if you don’t cry you’ve got bigger problems than Top Gear.

    • Daniel says:

      11:24am | 22/02/11

      I find it interesting that he decided to take offence to the Mexican gags, when the Top Gear boys will make fun of Aussies whenever they get the chance.

    • John says:

      09:57am | 22/02/11

      Pembo, if you don’t like it that’s fine, why do you feel the need to tell everyone about it? We don’t care. Just like we don’t care if you are gay, but we don’t want that rammed down our throats either. Just get on with your life and leave those of us who do find Top Gear an entertaining, non-PC, bit of fun show, to watch in peace.

      In other words, shut up and write about something that really is important.

    • Dale says:

      09:57am | 22/02/11

      so because you dont like cars, thats makes top gear a bad show?

      i find the guys funny as hell, and so do 600 million people around the world , thats the viewers everyweek,

      people that dont like cars, just shouldnt drive, its like being a doctor , yh you dont like your job , but you do it anywayz to pay bills, Member clarkson said that,

      and trust me , Id rather a doctor that likes what he does lol

    • DocBud says:

      09:57am | 22/02/11

      “who are paid a whole shed-load of money to remain in a state of arrested mental development and live out an extended midlife crisis on television,”

      Not discovered the secret yet, Penbo? As a 52 year old, I reckon growing up is for the birds and accounts clerks. Life is too short not to live it to whatever you consider to be fullness, your budget will allow and the Mrs will tolerate.

      If cars float your boat, go for it, if you prefer sitting in sanctimonious judgement on others, go for that, each to their own.

    • average aussie bloke says:

      09:57am | 22/02/11

      Penbo, you are not representative of the average bloke, please don’t ever put your hand up to represent us ever again. You may know nothing about the car that you drive, but most of us have a mechanical aptitude and hunger for a knowledge of how and why things work. We also have a sense of humour.

    • Matthew says:

      09:58am | 22/02/11

      My 58 year old mother likes Top Gear.  She doesn’t go out of her way to watch it but enjoys it when it comes on and has a good laugh.

      Cars are not just for getting from Point A to Point B.  They are wonderful pieces of engineering that have taken over one hundred years to develop into what they are.  You should take a closer look at that car that you drive as one day it might just save your behind.

    • Tony H says:

      10:00am | 22/02/11

      Its not a show targeted towards inner-city latte sippers, if you don’t like it then don’t watch it.

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      11:24am | 22/02/11

      Pffffft - why do we always have to bring ‘inner city latte sippers’ into everything? I know lots of blokes that live in the inner city that love Top Gear. Your generalisations are almost as bad as Penbos.

    • Anne71 says:

      01:01pm | 22/02/11

      Tony, I’m an inner-city (soy) latte sipper. I can’t even drive, yet UK Top Gear is one of my favourite shows. It’s the chemistry between the three presenters that I enjoy, and the total lack of political correctness. You don’t necessarily have to be a petrolhead to enjoy it.

    • Julian says:

      10:01am | 22/02/11

      “to another southern nation, namely Mexico” ... last time I looked Mexico was actually held entirely withing the *northern* hemisphere… maybe they should turn their “blowtorch of satire” onto observational/banal posts from sometime journos?

    • Matt says:

      10:02am | 22/02/11

      No one complains when Top Gear pokes fun at a country regarded as “white”. They routinely make fun of Germany, USA, and their own UK, often using racial and regional stereotypes in their gags.  No one blogs about that.  However the instant those white Top Gear boys make a joke about a “brown” race, whether it be making jokes about Mexicans or dressing up as Muslim women, it becomes an instant “outrage”.

      You’re more conditioned for this kind of nonsense than a Pavlovian dog.

      I will agree that people watch and enjoy the show because the antics of the hosts are entertaining, even if they act like 7 year olds.

      For the record, my wife loves the Top Gear boys.

    • Cassie says:

      10:03am | 22/02/11

      Im an girl.. im not an motorhead.. but i love top gear. Its light, funny, and interesting.

      When they ‘pick on cultures’ all they are highligting is stereotypes. Because it makes us remember how outrageous stereotypes are…

      And i know many many girls who love top gear, once again, none of them are tomboys or motorheads, we love our ‘chick flicks’, and high tea.

    • mike says:

      10:04am | 22/02/11

      David Penberthy, you just lost a reader. An unbiased opinion of something you obviously care less about I can accept, but your bias on this subject is so blatant it’s offensive.  Would I be right in saying you like to hang out at sidewalk coffee shops drinking latte’s and never watch Bathhurst ? If so you have little to no idea of the driving forces behind being a typical man are.  Cars are as primal to men as religion.  If you’re a man and don’t like this show, you have no soul.

    • TheRealDave says:

      10:05am | 22/02/11

      I like cars, they beat walking or riding a horse any day, but I know 3/5ths of bugger all about them…and more to the point I don’t want to learn anything about them. I can change a tyre, check the oil and water and put fuel in it….thats about it.

      I hate motor racing. I’d rather watch wet paint dry or masturbate with a cheese grater. If they played non-stop NASCAR on a loop at Gitmo I would be the first out there burning an American flag to protest ‘Crimes Against Humanity’.

      You get the picture? OK.

      Saying that, Top Gear is a fantastically brilliant show. I love it. Even when they pulled the piss and cheated against the Aussie Top Gear show recently. The cars stats and raw numbers are a mere brief mention in passing and its the pulling the piss and having fun where the show really shines. Can’t wait till the next ep I download wink

    • Richard Hammond says:

      10:05am | 22/02/11

      I think I would rather watch top gear than read this guys opinion blog again. No fact, obviously not his subject. If you dont like it, dont watch it.
      These guys act and say what 95% of men are thinking anyway. You just fall into the 5% that like skipping through a field of daisies with bow in your hair.

    • Britney says:

      10:06am | 22/02/11

      “Top Gear is no more a program for adults than Play School is”.
      This makes you sound like a whiney kid who watches Play school.
      What’s up with that?

    • James says:

      10:08am | 22/02/11

      David Penberthy, you could have easily saved yourself the trouble of writing this article, as all you need to write was “I don’t like cars, so neither should anyone else”.

      I don’t like cooking. I do it because its a necessity, and when I can get someone else to do it for me, I do. To me, it’s just a chore that has to be done to put food on the table. So obviously I have no reason to watch cooking shows, masterchef, etc.

      I don’t go off having a winge about everyone else liking them though. Fact is, Top Gear is the most watched television show in the world. So obviously, your in the minority here.

    • Anthony says:

      10:09am | 22/02/11

      So your saying you dont like it.. thats fine.

      take your negativity else where and ill bag you about your love of gardening and how boring a show on that would be.


      Dont like it, dont preach to the audience that enjoy it.

    • meatmachine says:

      10:10am | 22/02/11

      top gear has almost 500m viewers per episode.  if you’re not one of those, you obviously don’t “get it”.  it’s all about the chemistry between the presenters and the tongue-in-cheek / gags that make it so good.  add to that the top gear specials are truly epic!

    • Rob says:

      10:10am | 22/02/11

      The funniest thing about this article was that Penbo decided to focus on the use of humour when used to vilify stereotypes. Had he re-read this before posting, I fear he would have come to the same conclusion about his own article.

      I’ve only recently started watching Top Gear, and I love it. It’s very funny, and sometimes even informative. I know very little about cars, but it doesn’t matter one bit. My wife watches the show with me sometimes, and she laughs along too, and she knows nothing about cars, including how to reverse one!

      If the intention of this article was to see how many blokes you could irritate, you might well have succeeded. Otherwise, this is rubbish

    • Anne71 says:

      06:51pm | 22/02/11

      He’s irritated a fair few women too, Rob. Including this one.

    • Declan says:

      10:11am | 22/02/11

      “It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B. “.... Why?

      I, like many others, like to know why things we use on a daily basis work, so when they don’t work we don’t end up standing at the mechanics counter getting bent over because we are blindly ignorant of any basic knowledge about cars! grin

      Somewhat ironic that a journalist would deride a quest for knowledge of any kind, let alone one that is linked to a tool that 95% of the population use on a daily basis!!

      The sad thing is you are probably happy to stir the pot to get a(ny) response…

    • Katy says:

      10:14am | 22/02/11

      “It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B” - that is perhaps one of the most unattractive statements I’ve ever heard and certainly would not aspire to being in a situation which required you to know what to do if a car had a problem (even a minor one).

      For some of us it is a show that allows us to see the beauty in something that we will never own and there is nothing wrong with that. They are three hosts who have hosted it prior to their ‘midlife crisis’ stage and have done a remarkable job adding humour to what essentially is a very mechanical subject - no matter the form, as some of us aren’t as ridiculous to get worked up over amusing stereotypical jokes which were created due to lets face it, a basis of truth. To be honest, they living to what is most, a child’s dream and let’s admit it, who wouldn’t if thats were your passion is.

      I watch the show, not with the intention of indulging my partner’s adoration of cars, but because it’s a great show - unique, clever, humourous, and at times a reality (as their special episodes depict). Seeming as I’ll never own a supercar - knowing what the experience is and seeing it filmed fantastically by the BBC is a window of opportunity I’ll happily take. Personally I believe your distaste towards a show that you clearly don’t like, nor watch, is extremely biased and that you chose to write on it, well now that was a little silly.

    • Relax says:

      10:15am | 22/02/11

      Ok, so I’ve read this piece a couple of times and I’m still trying to work out what your point is. From what i can see this is essentially just a piece about how because the writer doesn’t like cars and car shows that no one should.

      The assertion that because the writer doesnt like cars or top gear, there are probably tonnes of men that don’t seems to be the crux of a rather poorly written peice in my opinion.

      Yes, Top Gear has had some infintile moments, poo jokes included, but they have also driven a car to the north pole setting a world record, promoted the british army and increased recruiting and done telethons and numerous charity events. In addition they’ve raised the profile of a number of causes whilst having a bit of fun.

      You don’t have to be a car guy to like top gear, in fact you can be a car guy and hate top gear. Conversely you can know nothing about cars and love the show. As another comment stated, its a lifestyle / entertainment show and should be taken with a grain of salt. If you want a serious car review show, go watch drive time if you can find a channel showing it.

    • Seppi says:

      10:16am | 22/02/11

      I wonder if there’s a little envy in this article, as I think hosting Top Gear would be a pretty good gig.

      I’m another woman who loves the show. I used to watch it more regularly on SBS but less often now it’s moved to a night I’m not home and I hate the extra advertisements on commercial TV. I’m really not interested in cars but it’s the chemistry,  banter and humour between the three hosts that I enjoy. And the stupid things they get up to.

    • Adrian says:

      10:18am | 22/02/11

      It is clear by the dribble you write you are one of these “metro sexuals” that lives in downtown Sydney,  you know, one of these men who wears a bit of “lippy” and makeup, sees nothing wrong with this, and dont have a clue how to repair a leaking tap. I suggest you go and do an article on some moisturiser that is good for the complexion, than write articles you admit you know nothing about, the millions of viewers world wide that enjoy this show clearly know more about cars and the passion you can have for them than you will ever know about this subject.

    • Get Over Yourself says:

      10:18am | 22/02/11

      Penbo, you have proven that you really are a simple minded moron, simply because you are not interested in this program or cars, does not mean that everybody lives in the same square that you do. Perhaps you should learn more about the big metal boxes that are carrying your kids around every day, and what safety precautions have been put in place to protect your family, not sure about you but my families safety is a priority, where obviously yours is to write pointless articles criticising an internationally renowned television program.

    • Wendy says:

      10:19am | 22/02/11

      There is a reason this show is the most popular television program in the whole world. At first I thought it was just a stupid car show (cars have zero interest for me - in fact I don’t even have a driver’s licence) but then I watched it and became totally hooked. Their races, challenges and road trips are what makes the show.

      And some background - Top Gear was on in the UK since the late 1970’s but got axed in the last 90’s because it was all about cars! Nobody was watching it. It was then re-vamped and became the powerhouse it is today.

      The author should perhaps do some research - it was James May who made the comment about Mexican food, not Richard Hammond and only James and Jeremy are coming to the live shows here next month.

      And oh yes, I am a girl!!

    • ana says:

      12:44pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a woman and I’m hooked too. I’m going to the Melbourne show next month with my sons and their girlfriends. Can’t wait.

    • Paul says:

      10:19am | 22/02/11

      I’ve always thought there was a fair amount of parody in what they do, ie they are characters as much as they are presenters and as such the viewer is asked to laugh at them as much as with them.

    • Scott says:

      10:23am | 22/02/11

      If you wanted to make yourself sound like a purile, politically correct, self opinionated wanker penbo…....... you won!

    • Champy_champs says:

      10:23am | 22/02/11

      I don’t like cars so much, but I don’t mind Top Gear. My wife loves it, and so does my 8 year old daughter. (They both prefer James to Jezza though).

      And Penbo, it was Eddie Booth in Love Thy Neighbour, not Alf Garnett.

    • Gravelly says:

      10:25am | 22/02/11

      I’m supposed to be a grumpy old 61 year old, and I love the show. Nothing comes near it, certainly not the pathetic Australian version, in all it’s reincarnations!

      When I want serious viewing Mr Penberthy, I put on the ABC! For 4 or 5 minutes! That’s about as much as I can stand of that biased, self-important, up-itself network!

      Top Gear rules, sonny, and don’t you forget it!!

    • Have a sook says:

      10:25am | 22/02/11

      300 million viewers must all be wrong then, mate… What a pointless, shallow, and very biased article. I’m not in to cars, I love the humour, and enjoy the show. Love to know what you watch to have a laugh…. Are they still airing 7th Heaven….?

    • Sydney says:

      10:26am | 22/02/11

      Its a wanky show hosted by Wankers

    • Scott says:

      01:43pm | 22/02/11

      Looks like your in the minority on that one mate, but at least you had a go even if you cant say your own name. Havent seen a reply from the author of the article either come to think of it, he must be having a latte with you at Paddo…......

    • HappyCynic says:

      10:28am | 22/02/11

      “It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B”

      And therein lies your problem.  You view cars as a tool and nothing more.  The sight of an Alfa Romeo 8C Competizione (one of the world’s most stunning cars in my opinion) would elicit little more reaction than a ‘meh’ whereas I would start drooling like a neanderthal and probably run over to the car so that I could feel those gorgeous lines and generally make a complete idiot of myself smile  Aston Martins (especially the old ones) evoke something similar, it’s almost primal.

      I’m not going to knock you for viewing cars so practically some people simply don’t get it and they’re the same people who think Top Gear is puerile and it’s fine to think this way.

      I have to ask though, does nothing in your life evoke the same visceral passion and childlike enthusiasm that the guys from Top Gear have for cars?  If not I feel really sorry for you.  Because without passion you’ve lived a life half dead.

    • Glenn says:

      10:29am | 22/02/11

      People who watch Top Gear - Millions and Millions.
      People who read Penbo - very few.
      Penbo is just a pretentious twat who doesn’t (despite his belief’s) have a clue about what people like, and that includes women (they do watch it).

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      11:16am | 22/02/11

      Indeed women do watch it, and they like it too. I watch it even if my bf isn’t home, my mother watches it for, and she knows nothing about cars, she drives a minivan for gods sake.

    • Simon says:

      10:29am | 22/02/11

      Oh yes isn’t it terrible to take the piss out of people!  The modern world frowns on anything other than perfectly politically correct rubbish.  A light hearted show like TG is great entertainment and gives us a good break from wowsers and do gooders such as this author.  Mind you I didn’t waste my time reading trhe whole article.  The first section was enough.

    • Top Gear Fan # 2 says:

      10:30am | 22/02/11

      For me,  Top Gear is the best show on TV (and Big Bang Theory as well)
      It’s super funny, very innovative, well planned and executed. You’ll never get bored of it. =D

    • Steve of Cornubia says:

      10:31am | 22/02/11

      I think we should all chip in and buy Penbo a remote control for his TV. Mind you, it is widely accepted that women aren’t allowed to operate TV remote controls, so we’d be wasting our money.

    • SM says:

      10:33am | 22/02/11

      Two and a Half Men

      *%#@ My Dad Says

      The Big Bang Theory

      that Ben Elton dribble

      Top Gear

      all part of Channel Nine’s attempt to create the dumbest lineup of shows for the dumbest audience in television history

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      11:13am | 22/02/11

      Shit My Dad Says was a really really funny blog. William Shatner killed it for me.

    • Luce says:

      11:24am | 22/02/11

      Oh lighten up!

    • Peter says:

      10:33am | 22/02/11

      David - being in the print media - you yourself are paid a whole shed-load of to money write and publish this sort of populist rubbish as well as throwing in the odd profanity, major exaggerations and downright lies…

      pot? kettle? black?

    • Ben says:

      10:37am | 22/02/11

      Im not a car guy at all but i like top gear. the xmas special was great.
      My gf likes it as well. And she isnt a car person either.
      I like the stunts/pranks and the banter between the co-hosts. The interviews with celebrities are usually pretty good as well.
      The joking about the mexicans was painful to watch, it seemed scripted to offend. And they all joined in.

    • Ashley says:

      10:38am | 22/02/11

      You’re so wrong Penbo and millions of people around the world obviously agree with me and not you. Top Gear is the best show on TV - simple!  You’re also wrong with another comment - Alf Garnet was not a character in Love Thy Neighbour, so you should do a better job with your homework and leave Top Gear alone.

    • Rodger says:

      10:38am | 22/02/11

      We get it. You don’t like the show. It’s really sad that you wasted hours of your time writing such an mediocre article.

      I’m assuming that you have kids. Seeing as you’re not a slim man, I’d assume the McHappy meal boxes are from your kids.

      This tells me many things about you.
      1. You don’t care about your health
      2. You don’t care about your kid’s health
      3. You’re a slob
      4. You don’t care much about road safety. (New Super Cars don’t just bring the world immense speed and grip, they bring cutting edge technology into road cars that eventually filters down into ordinary cars to help save lives)
      5. You’d rather spend hours, and hours obsessing over something you HATE rather than spend time with your kids. That leads to point 6….
      6. You’re clearly an arsehole of a father.

      I can understand why you don’t get the show as a man. You’re a pathetic excuse for one. In fact, I’m ashamed the the theory of Darwinism actually allows you to continue to be a member of the human race.

    • Daniel says:

      10:40am | 22/02/11

      It’s simple. If you don’t like it, don’t watch it. Switch channels, Turn off the TV, go outside, spend time with the kids, or go walk your dog, just don’t whinge about the show

    • Andrew says:

      10:41am | 22/02/11

      I love Top Gear. How is it that no-one is complaining about the amount of ads that Channel Nine show during each of the new episodes? SBS is where is belongs. Channel Nine have ruined it for me.

    • Wendy says:

      01:48pm | 22/02/11

      It would be better without the ads. But then if it hadn’t been moved to Channel 9, I’d never have discovered it!! I didn’t know what it was all about - just thought it was a car review show. How wrong I was!

    • Grumpy says:

      10:43am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear was good before they thought it would be a good idea to do an Aussie one with hosts that seemed like they were straight from their shift at Autobarn. Its old news.

    • Bevan says:

      10:45am | 22/02/11

      We like it because it is delightfully disrespectful of the safety brigade, who, as mostly women, think risk taking is childish irresponsible behaviour

    • Richard B says:

      09:23pm | 22/02/11

      Oh, you like the idea of killing people? Good for you.

    • Gale says:

      09:37am | 23/02/11

      We live in a nanny state,  in an over-regulated, politically correct society with too many laws to the point it takes away a person’s sense of adventure and humour.  I think Top Gear appeals to that part of us which would just like to ditch the chains for awhile.

    • Graham says:

      10:47am | 22/02/11

      See Hypocrites post ....http://www.thepunch.com.au/articles/Texts-tweets-emails-and-other-inanities-at-36000-ft/

      But it seems to ok for your to run down other nations to appease your audience !!
      ... ‘Yeah but it’s all good taste banter” I hear you cry
      Just evaporate you fool.

    • Jimmy says:

      10:49am | 22/02/11

      Get over yourself and write something worthwhile. If you don’t like it don’t watch it, certainly don’t bother wasting your time in a vain attempt as to show everyone why it’s bad. I hope you didn’t get paid for this…

    • Dee Dee says:

      10:49am | 22/02/11

      I smell a tad bit of jealousy from Penberthy.  Three average guys making heaps of money driving fast cars .Big boys and their toys. Alot of men and even women would love to do what they are doing. Top Gear is hugely popular all around the world. By placing “Top Gear” in the article title at least guarantees the author will get his article read by many more people.
      I find the show entertaining, and its refreshing because it isn’t afraid to be politically incorrect.  Good marketing also as the publicity makes more people want to watch it. It is a show that the whole family can sit down and watch.  Do hate all the commercials during the show dragging it out an extra 30 minutes, so it is much easier to watch it directly from the BBC.

    • BJ says:

      10:52am | 22/02/11

      Penbo you have some great pieces sometimes, and I know it’s an opinion column and all, but lighten up. There is a reason this is one of the most popular shows in the world.

      Yes Top Gear (particularly Clarkson) is very un PC and sometimes carry things too far but duh. Don’t you think its nice to have a show thats not about cooking/dancing/singing? And on the subject of hosts, what about the demeaning and negative way some of the talent show judges deride their participants?

      I am not really into cars, but like the show because they arent so incredibly wound up they lack the ability to have fun. And my wife doesnt mind it too much either. The fun-suckers of Australia have already censored this country to excess don’t take away the last vestiges of our larrikin nature.

    • Angus says:

      10:52am | 22/02/11

      “There is another problem with the show, and it’s a bigger one. It’s about cars, and cars really aren’t all that interesting. “

      I would suggest that if you don’t find cars interesting then the show probably isn’t for you, in which case you should by all means watch something else.  Perhaps they should take cricket off TV because Tony Greig churns out the politically-incorrect gaffes faster than Jeremy Clarkson and Prince Phillip combined.  And, of course, plenty of people don’t like cricket.

      Or perhaps I could just go and watch something else and leave those who do enjoy watching cricket to enjoy it.  Meanwhile I’ll continue watching Top Gear WITH my wife who also enjoys it as a bit of light comedy, even though she’s not particularly interested in cars. Which is actually one of the keys to the show’s success - you don’t need to have a deep and intimate knowledge of the internal combustion engine to enjoy it.  They’ve cottoned on to the pretty simple fact that the real joy of cars isn’t in the nuts and bolts under the bonnet, it’s in the enjoyment that comes from actually driving them.

      Perhaps David Penberthy would have been better spending his time exploring the multitude of options that are only a press of a TV remote away instead of writing this drivel.

    • thumbs10 says:

      10:55am | 22/02/11

      The only intelligent comments on this show come from the STIG!

    • 33yo Male Top Gear Enthusiast says:

      10:57am | 22/02/11

      Ha, sounds like you just want to push “Your opinion”.  Good for you, but your actions are more childish than….Play School!! Jealious much Mr Penberthy?

    • jimbo says:

      10:57am | 22/02/11

      Erik ripped you with the very first comment, end of debate!!

    • JB says:

      10:57am | 22/02/11

      Yes, enough of these childish jokes based on race stereotypes. Clarkson has even accused Australia of not contributing anythng to the world except snakes and spiders.

      What I would really like to see on television is some classy Chaser skits about terminally ill chidren….

    • Steve of Cornubia says:

      11:57am | 22/02/11

      Ah but the Chaser was OK because it was on the ABC.

    • gabby says:

      10:57am | 22/02/11

      Its not so much the show but the presenters - tell them to get the plum out of their mouths

      If you read Clarkson’s books you will see what he really thinks about Australians…not good

    • JC fan says:

      11:26am | 22/02/11

      I was lucky enough to meet Jeremy Clarkson on a recent trip to the UK. Pulled up in the service station next to me. I asked for a photo, to which he said yes, then proceeded to buy me a cup of coffee and have a chat about Australia. He was genuinely interested and very funny. He actually has a deep appreciation for our country and said he wished he could travel here more frequently.
      That doesn’t sound like someone who hates us! Taking time out from his day to have a chat with a (female - thanks Penbo) fan is exactly what makes the boys so endearing to so many!
      Long live Top Gear!!

    • DP says:

      11:03am | 22/02/11

      I will admit, before watching Top Gear I had less motoring knowledge than an average male would or should. I think I would have struggled just changing a flat.

      Over the years I’ve been watching it, Top Gear has given me a genuine interest in cars, even through their boyish antics and hilarious moments - of which there are many. In fact the whole reason I started watching the show was because it was funny. It was entertaining. It made me laugh.

      A side effect it seems after all these years is that I now have a boosted understanding and knowledge of cars and how they work, which will most definitely come in handy in the future, and at the same time, I get to piss myself with laughter. What’s wrong with that? 

      As for offending people, who doesn’t these days? I can’t even look at someone funny or else they might sue me. Anyone who gets offended by a car show is a goose and needs to get a straw and suck it up. End of story.

    • Samson says:

      11:04am | 22/02/11

      I’m sensing a bit of cognitive dissonance here Penbo.  Last week you wrote an article praising a pair of prominent Muslim spokesmen for forgoing the usual charade of preciousness and victim hood regarding Eddie Maguire’s dumb joke, but this week you think the Mexican ambassador to the UK was justified in being precious and defensive in retaliation to Clarkson/Hammond/May’s dumb jokes.

      These two opinions are obviously in conflict, so why the sudden change of heart?

      Please don’t tell me that you don’t really care but wrote this article for some higher site traffic on a slow day.  I think you’re a generally great editor and that would break my heart :(

    • Tash says:

      11:04am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is at the top of my list of TV shows.  Jeremy and James are excellent speakers, the sayings they come out with are giggle-worthy if not hysterical.
      The way those three guys work together is amazing and certain people make such a big hoo-ha over the stuff they say because guess what “everyone’s watching it”.
      How anyone can have a go at someone’s interests (namely cars) is beyond imagination, what are your interests? I’m sure 99% of the population can put them down as well. 
      In fact, a man who doesn’t respect his car and belongings by throwing mcdonalds all over the backseat is quite a turn-off. I have children but they know that our possessions require respect.
      Leave the ‘boys’ alone.
      Signing off as female car fancier and Top Gear lover!

    • Katharine says:

      11:05am | 22/02/11

      I’m female. I adore it. So do half the girls at work. My mother likes it - we probably watch it with more devotion than my father, who’s always been a car man.

      I like it for it’s fun, laid back approach; it’s just comfortable viewing. People shouldn’t take things so seriously, they insult themselves and the UK just as much as they insult anything else. Anyone who can watch the pranks they pull on each other on one of their roadtrips and not grin, needs to take a holiday themselves and relax a little.

    • Steve Putnam says:

      08:34pm | 22/02/11

      I loved the episode where they each had to buy a 70s muscle car for 10 grand or under for one of their race scenarios. Clapped out Lamborghini Miuras and Maserati Boras with coolant leaking onto exhaust manifolds and wiring shorting out everywhere likely to cause a fire at any stage and Clarkson sagely nodding his head and saying ‘yes, that’s normal’. Priceless unscripted stuff!

    • Nicko says:

      11:05am | 22/02/11

      Penbo, I have to say that I am surprised by your article. I don’t think I have seen anything written with such a generalised view. As it appears, you have heaped all men into the same category as yourself, which I think most of us guys will agree, is not the case.

      I think Top Gear is a fantastic show, I wasn’t interested in cars a kid but now I most certainly am. Not to the extent that I will attend a car show on the weekend, but if I see a beautiful car on the side of the road I look at it with a different appreciation to what I had before getting on the Top Gear bandwagon.

      I don’t understand your reasoning by heaping all Top Gear watchers into a single ‘bogan’ category either. I am a solicitor and I think Top Gear is great. I think we can all admit that sometimes the jokes can be a bit cringe worthy, but I am a redhead and they love to take shots at ‘gingers’ and I still laugh. Besides, that is television of today, give the people what they want.

      So Penbo, research your topic next time, don’t make absurd generalisations and go look at an Aston Martin DB9 and just appreciate the fact that it’s a glorious car.

    • Cameron says:

      11:12am | 22/02/11

      The show is “absurdly popular” because it is entertaining. Much of the content is not to be taken anywhere near as seriously as some people here want to do!
      If you are not into cars, go and watch something else!

    • Leopold says:

      11:12am | 22/02/11

      I agree that Top Gear isnt worth the tv guide it’s printed on. Tried watching it and only mere fractions of the show were actually worth watching… and I come from a family of tradesmen. However I agree that a simple change of the channel is a good fix. Preferred Hammond in Brainiac.

      Furthermore… those of you making personal attacks towards the author should also be aware that reading this article was your choice and you could simply close it if you didn’t enjoy it rather than making pointless offensive jokes about sexual orientation and mechanical prowess. Criticising the article itself seems much more appropriate than pathetic personal attacks.

    • Amused says:

      11:14am | 22/02/11

      I LOVE Top Gear. I was actually watching re runs of season 2 last night before bed because all terrible crime mystery and reality shows were clogging the airways.

      Power to you, David Penberthy for writing what you think needed to be said, but anyone who is seriously insulted by what three middle aged and entirely silly men say on a show that has never taken its self seriously in any capacity, needs to re-evaluate what they think is really important in life.

    • Peter says:

      11:14am | 22/02/11

      Perhaps they should rename the show to “3 Half-Wits” after that US show made famous (or infamous) by Charlie Sheen.

      They both share the same level of intellect.

    • Marc says:

      11:14am | 22/02/11

      David Penberthy seems to have taken the jovial dig at Mexicans a little too seriously and taken it personally (having been there on exchange some time in the 80s).

      David, your article here is like most of your writing.  Boring, meaningless tripe full of your own self-importance and lack of any real substance.  Do you really think that about most men?  That most men don’t like cars?  Whether you like Top Gear or not, to declare this is ridiculous, just look at the amount of men who go to motor shows. Unlike yourself they are not frauds and don’t hide behind a love of motor cars to “look more manly”.

      Grow up David and go back to Adelaide Uni… learn to be a real journalist.

    • Patrick Bateman says:

      11:15am | 22/02/11

      To the writer of this article. You are a talentless hack. Thank you.

    • Bob says:

      11:15am | 22/02/11

      My suspicion is your boyfriend likes it.

    • trolledcy@ says:

      11:21am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is the most watched tv show across the world.

      Therefore your argument is invalid.

    • Ben says:

      11:23am | 22/02/11

      350 million viewers would suggest they’re doing something right. Anyone who thinks Top Gear is a car show hasn’t watched it. Sure, that’s the underlying topic, but it’s really a comedy program, hence all the gags. That’s why people watch it, and that’s why it’s more successful than any other car show.

    • Stewie says:

      11:25am | 22/02/11

      What’s wrong with some crass, not politically correct humour now and then? It’s funny regardless. Lighten up.

    • Jerome says:

      11:26am | 22/02/11

      The author of this article does seem to be making quite quite a few assumptions!

      I don’t know a whole lot about cars but love the show, and love cars, the sound of them, the look of them. I don’t pretend to like them to be more manly. I drive a hybrid for crying out loud. That’s about as unmanly among my petrol head mates as you can be. But I still love cars and would prefer to be driving something with a little more power if I had a choice!

      And for the record my girlfriend loves the show, and doesn’t just watch it because I’m there watching it too. We don’t live together and she watches it and every so often updates me on her new “favorite car”. At the moment it’s the bugatti after seeing a re-run!

    • Dave says:

      11:27am | 22/02/11

      poor people do not like this show because they cannot afford the cars.  In this case the journalist seems not only poor but jealous of the success of these journo’s.

    • GB says:

      11:30am | 22/02/11

      Get a grip Penbo. They take the piss out of everybody, including themselves. And us Aussies haven’t been spared their acerbic wit either. Seems to me the PC police are just falling all over themselves trying to find a story to concoct some faux outrage over.

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      11:30am | 22/02/11

      Well Penbo, the people have spoken it would seem, you are wrong on this one. With the amount of people who watch Top Gear, I doubt you would have seen this going any other way.

      But I do want to know -  Why are you praising prominent members of the Muslim community for having a laugh about Eddie McGuire’s felafel comment out one side of your mouth, but deriding Top Gear’s comments about Mexicans out the other side of your mouth?

      Comments on the punch going down?

    • Carols says:

      11:31am | 22/02/11

      Ay man…Carlos from mechicho ere man…don’t be pickin on the top gear show man…we lerv the show over in tijauna…my wife Lupe….and my 11 keeds…Jose, JoseB, Guadalupe, Fatima..and I forget de udder names man…we tink the show is tops…juz look kat all the weeman in the audience man…so go back to the roadshow show man…peace…time for my siesta…

    • Dave Gear says:

      11:32am | 22/02/11

      I think you are simply trying to jump on thier populatrity by writing about them to get my readers.

      Top Gear is a funny (I love it) and interesting show. And one of the things I like about it is that it does use sterotypes, you don’t want it and believe that Jeremy Clarkson is actually a hater of Mexicans. He has gone on interviews before and mentioned how he loves Australia and so on. Yet in an Australia vs England Top Gear he simply makes fun of them none-stop, yet we know it is in good humor.

      I personally say Shame on your for writing this when you have no passion on the show. While you claim to be talking about whether it is an Adult Show or Children’s show (your title). It is simply you attempt at bashing a show that has done something very few have done before it. Becoming amazingly entertaining and keep growing on that after 16 Season.

      Keep that in mind next time you are having a go at the show. It has lasted 16 Season. How long has your little blog lasted?

    • Happy in Alice says:

      11:36am | 22/02/11

      The author of this article is apparently one of those idiots who thinks that no one is entitled to say or do anything that he doesn’t like. I am a woman and I personally love the show. It’s a bit of light hearted fun. It’s not great prose or hugely important social commentary…and it’s not supposed to be. Yes, they piss a few people off along the way but so what. These three guys are very intelligent and far more educated than this author has cared to find out. These three guys also have a show persona that has nothing to do with how they are in real life. If the author of this article cared to find out more and perhaps watch some of their documentaries, he’d know that. I don’t think it’s the greatest show in television but it sure beats a lot of the other tripe they show.

    • Tom says:

      11:42am | 22/02/11

      The whole concept of the show is not necessarily to be dedicated to those die-hard petrol heads. It’s the humour, adventure and downright abdurdity in some cases that appeals to so many of its viewers.

      I am by no means a petrol head, a car enthusiast, and would struggle to tell the difference between a single or twin cam. But, I enjoy watching the show. It’s on prime-time TV because people enjoy watching it, and provides considerable topics for conversation - regardless of whether it be discussing the latest Jaguar, or arguing about the hosts wearing bulletproof vests in an otherwise safe Iraq.

      Everyone has a hobby, things that interest them - I for one take greater offense to the thought that there are people out there who actually enjoy watching a show about gardening - no offense Mr. Burke.

      But it seems once again, an opinionated person given the right to free speach in a developed Western country has gone and sparked an argument, perhaps even offended someone, by giving THEIR opinion. Opinions are like posteriors, everyone has one, but no one cares about yours!

    • Emma says:

      11:45am | 22/02/11

      You clearly have no idea what you are talking about.

      Top Gear is a fascinating show, even for those people who don’t know much about cars, the idea is that they learn. Even if viewers tend to zone out in relation to the technical words, they can still appreciate a beautiful vehicle.

      And for your information, women do like this show, not only for the hosts but also for the cars themselves. So next time you think to criticise Top Gear for using racial comments, think about your own sexist comments.

    • SallyStig says:

      11:46am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is the greatest show on TV today.. I love it.. And I would happily spend all day watching it..
      I’m a 21 year old female - and i don’t know anything about cars other then what top gear tells me..
      It’s an entertaining show.. The poeple who watch it find it humorous.. the people who don’t get offended about everything on the show..
      I’ve been to all the top gear live shows in previous years.. And I love all the hosts.. I would marry them and have their babies! especially a little stig baby!

    • Mike says:

      11:47am | 22/02/11

      Typical journo. No research. TV shows all mixed up Alf Garnet, Love Thy Neighbour, Till Death Us Do Part. No wonder they are ranked so low on the scale
      Go get a real job. Do they really learn how to be a Journo? Amazing.

    • Peter says:

      12:09pm | 22/02/11

      I completely agree!!!
      If he knew anything he would know that the presenters make fun of every nation including their own.
      I think David Penberthy is effeminate and most likely useless at everything, including journalism!!!

    • jp says:

      11:56am | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is the only show I watch on tv these days.  After a hard days work, nothing like a light entertainment mixed in with exotic cars I can only dream of. 

      Sometimes we take ourselves a little too seriously.

    • Keith Hammersmith says:

      11:58am | 22/02/11

      Just discovered the author of this article is a Journalist!  Never would have been able to tell from reading the article…
      what a joke, 
      so you don’t like a tv show….  /yawn


      as a journalist do some research and discover that many people have different interests to you, and guess what many people like cars and humour.

      “There is another problem with the show, and it’s a bigger one. It’s about cars, and cars really aren’t all that interesting. “

      So you are a metro male that would rather pick out curtains than look at cars,  HEY i have the solution!  -  watch something else

      there is a reason Top gear is the most watched show in the world, and your articles are not exactly the most read articles in the world - they are on to something - you are not.

    • Sammy says:

      11:58am | 22/02/11

      You say you have never meet a woman who likes the show well… I love it, never miss an episode, own many MANY DVDs, read all the presenters articles and also go to their live shows. In fact I was the one who converted my partner as he is now a fan.
      I’m not for people racially abusing others, but if you have watched the show more then once or twice you will see that EVERYONE, including the Poms get a mention their light hearted fun.
      You obviously dont like cars and are not an enthusiast so I don’t expect you to like the show and therefore I and I should think many others feel there is no weight to your article.

    • Shaun says:

      12:11pm | 22/02/11

      You sir are an idiot and so is your publisher for allowing this crap to be posted

    • Michelle says:

      12:14pm | 22/02/11

      I am female and i LOVE the show. For the record, lovely Richard is not coming to Australia only the other two, and he is the only one to have offered an official apology and explanation over the matter. You can find it on his Facebook page or his twitter account @thehamsterscage

      Before you bag these guys for being guys, do a little bit of research

    • brabus says:

      12:16pm | 22/02/11

      Whats not to like about 3 charismatic men, giving plenty of amusing feature stories about amazing vehicles.
      Its extremely entertaining and is a show for true car enthusiasts & many others.

      The writer of this article is obviously a middle aged and middle class nobody, driving a horrible holden commodore wagon that he wont even clean up old mcdonalds boxes !
      Simply has no clue

    • Cassandra says:

      12:18pm | 22/02/11

      What a reaction! Oh dear - someone has a difference of opinion about a TV show

      So David doesn’t like your favourite show? So you disagree by personal attacks?

      Lighten up.

      jeeeeez .........

    • BundyGil says:

      12:22pm | 22/02/11

      Of course it’s a show about blokes with arrested development living out an extended midlife crisis on television . That’s the whole point. If you can’t get that, well don’t watch it. Simple. Go back and have another latte

    • Really journos are so hard to find these days says:

      12:22pm | 22/02/11

      Seriously David stick to what you know because it’s not woman, cars or television. A lot of women I know love the show the fact that the show is one of the biggest in the world is proof of that (as the majority of it’s audience are families not single men, if this wasn’t the case the show just would not be as successful as it is)

    • Top Gear Chick says:

      12:24pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a mid 30’s female who doesn’t really like cars much. But I do love Top Gear and own four seasons of it on DVD. It’s probably the most entertaining shows on TV. You don’t need to be all that interested in the cars - it’s also about travel, creativity, friendship and just having fun.

    • richard says:

      12:25pm | 22/02/11

      What a joke of an article… ‘essentially designed to get us from A to B’ people who say this are about as intelligent as a rock.

      A house is just somewhere to sleep, but people spend hours and hours making their house a place that make them happy. There are hundreds of programs based on things about houses, from gardens, to auctions, from kitchens to architecture.

      If the writer actually did his research, he would also know that Clarkson doesn’t actually know much about the workings of cars, and is even less able to work or repair a car. He enjoys cars because they make him smile. Just like a handbag or a pair of shoes might make a woman smile. Just like watching sport make some smile, and just like collecting stamps make others smile.

    • soupbones says:

      12:30pm | 22/02/11

      So you don’t like Top Gear and take Clarksons jokes seriously. To me this means you have a poor sense of humor or prefer tardy American Humor. Better switch back over to Two and a Half Men. Charlie Sheen with his bow legs is about to say something you may find funny…

    • Adam says:

      12:37pm | 22/02/11

      I just happened to do some quick research (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/research) on yourself David by reading your bio. You “fell into journalism while not studying law at the University of Adelaide.” Hmmmm…..couldn’t tell. Is it possible that since Mexican is your favourite food that you are just having a tantrum about the gents from Top Gear having a mild dig at Mexico. Slightly hypocritical when you have written an article under a week ago citing the need for multicutlural humour.

    • AKoiLus says:

      12:37pm | 22/02/11

      I used to enjoy the show, but over time Clarkson has shown himself to be the PRAT that he is, and has simply become too annoying for me. Also when he’s in a re-badged vauxhall that he likes. He can never bring himself to exclaim it’s made in Australia. If he left I’d watch it again.

    • Steve of Cornubia says:

      07:58pm | 22/02/11

      What? I suggest you actually watch the episodes where Holdens are tested. Not only does Clarkson like them, he DOES mention that they’re made in Oz.

      OK, he also says that means they’re crude and unsophisticated.

      Thankfully though, he’s never met you or Penbo, so his stereotype of an Aussie doesn’t include ‘has no sense of humour’.

    • Kris says:

      12:41pm | 22/02/11

      Who is interested what you think, your’e a nobody and always will be! You have NO class. What a boring Git you must be to live with.

    • Helen R says:

      12:42pm | 22/02/11

      Well David, I am a woman and I happen to love watching Top Gear. I am not much into cars at all but despite this I do like watching the show because of it’s light heartedness and fun along the way. Just because YOU are not interested in cars does not mean that you might not like this show if only you opened your mind a little and took it for what it truly is - entertainment. If you still don’t like it then feel completely free to change the channel as nobody is forcing you to watch something that you clearly have no understanding of.

    • Neuraxis says:

      12:44pm | 22/02/11

      This report seems very one sided you clearly don’t care about the show so why are you reporting on it. Your no worse then the presenters saying stupid comments on a subject they know little about, except they are funny where as you just sound bitter.  Bad Reporting!!!

    • Ferdinand says:

      12:53pm | 22/02/11

      David, you are obviously a limp-wristed, car-hating prick! Top Gear is simply the best show on TV (apart from Two and a half men of course). You should spend more time in greek-bath houses having your balls scrubbed by two hairy blokes whilst you drink your self stupid on XXXX. Smoke a pipe, put on your slippers and pour yourself a large scotch and enjoy the program like the rest of the male population of the world (or just, do your wife’s laundry and cook her dinner like you do every other night!).

      This comment will obviously get moderated so I’ll finish off by saying - fuck off and die you miserable old bastard!

    • Malleeringneck says:

      12:55pm | 22/02/11

      I watched 5 minutes of the programme once.
      I haven’t been back to watch any more.

    • Todd says:

      01:01pm | 22/02/11

      3 things:

      1. Mexico is in the northern hemisphere, and hence should be ‘one of those northern countries’. IF your localizing it to the USA, that’s essentially like saying the Earth is the centre of the universe. I think we moved on from that mentality a few hundred years ago.

      2. For one of the most popular TV shows in the world, it’s a pretty darn good children’s show!

      3. There’s no reason to get snooty just because someone else thought of the idea before you smile

    • Matt says:

      01:02pm | 22/02/11

      I hope David Penberthy is reading these comments and realising that he had got it wrong, write a piece on that David….

    • Tracker says:

      01:04pm | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is an informative program and you need to understand British humour mixed in with some serious advice. I was looking for a new car and wasn’t sure what to buy when Jeremy said the Audi A4 3.2 Quattro was boring and conservative… that sounded good to me coming from a Pom so Audi can thank Top Gear for a sale.

    • Batta says:

      01:06pm | 22/02/11

      A “journalist” writing an article about “the best children’s show on television”, you must be waiting for the pulitzer nomination.

    • amused says:

      01:06pm | 22/02/11

      I was fine until you mentioned hot chip sandwich….mmmmmm. Lovely. People have been making fun of the English for years. I know I have. If you don’t know by now that this show aims to shock then you have been living under a rock. How many people actually laughed at what they were saying. I would like to think that I am smart enough to know they were just pulling my leg. I don’t think anything of the sort when I think of Mexican’s…I think of mass bodies being discovered with their heads missing, girls being stolen from the streets and drug cartels killing lots of people. That’s what I think of when I think of Mexico. so there.

    • Tracker says:

      01:42pm | 22/02/11

      I bet David doesn’t even butter his bread.

    • Tracey says:

      01:15pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a 47 year old woman, not really into cars and I love the show too.  Oh, and James May IS hot smile

    • Wendy says:

      03:48pm | 22/02/11

      You said it!! What is it about him that makes my knees weak! hahah

    • Paul says:

      01:16pm | 22/02/11

      You do know Mexico is in the Northern Hemisphere?

    • S M says:

      01:18pm | 22/02/11

      I turned on the TV about five years ago to see this middle-aged man doing a review of a car and pointing out more faults than good features.  I couldn’t stop laughing! 
      I then learned it was Top Gear, and couldn’t miss it.  Especially not the challenges.

      Oh, and I’m female.

    • carmy says:

      01:21pm | 22/02/11

      well ive loved top gear for ages and i dont know anything about cars i just love how entertaining and funny it is and theyre 3 smart guys not afraid to make a fool of themselves. sure some of the comments might be a bit much but theyre not meant to be taken seriously..

      this guy really needs to do his research instead of making assumptions

    • Bonetopick says:

      01:22pm | 22/02/11

      As editor-in-chief of news.com.au and The Punch, David has a very good understanding of what will draw a good response -case and point with this winner article.

      I detect a hint of jealousy in your view there David. I assume you have the same opionion for anyone in a profession that involves an increased heart as a by product of their work? Bear Gryills, Getaway, Hollywood actors just to name a few… (and no, your lunchtime sit on the can doesn’t count sorry)

      How about an article on something that produces genuine responses, not something that generates a high response count, when 99% of the posts are saying you are an idiot.

    • BGW says:

      01:26pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a middle aged woman with a bladder to match, and this show is so funny, I nearly always end up wetting myself - literally.

    • Michael says:

      01:30pm | 22/02/11

      Ridiculous article, the show is entertaining and funny it is sad that you dont watch it for what it is - light entertainment that is not PC most of the time. You need and interest in cars and a sense of humour to enjoy it, I suspect you lack the latter. Also check your facts before you publish, Alf Garnett was in the sit com ‘Til Death Us Do Part’ NOT ‘Love thy Neighbor’

    • cronessa says:

      01:30pm | 22/02/11

      Must have been a slow news day to have to resort to drawing attention to an article about nothing much in particular by putting ‘Top Gear’ in the title.

      I want the last 2 minutes of my life back!

    • David says:

      01:32pm | 22/02/11

      Love the show and the way it sticks it idiots like the Greens and does not take crap from looney regilious groups

    • d33j says:

      01:34pm | 22/02/11

      David is proof that men of today are more interested in waxing themselves than waxing cars.

    • d33j says:

      01:36pm | 22/02/11

      David is proof that men of today are more interested in waxing themselves than waxing cars.

    • Richard says:

      01:36pm | 22/02/11

      if you like cars, then you watch a car show. you like cooking, then you watch a cooking show. if you like both, watch both. you dont like both, then dont watch it at all.

      1+0=1
      0+1=1
      1+1=2
      0+0=0

      logic. simple.

    • junks says:

      01:36pm | 22/02/11

      trollface.jpg

    • stephen says:

      01:37pm | 22/02/11

      The last Pom I met was leaning against a railing at a guest house picking his teeth, which is kinda reflected in that English tradition of a car, The Jaguar, as a bucket that has decent gaps between its panels, and has a knockabout quality to the engine.
      Stick to Holdens.
      And where’s Peter Wherrett ?

    • Steve Putnam says:

      09:04pm | 22/02/11

      What the hell is all that supposed to mean? Tell me your name isn’t really stephen!

    • Ben says:

      01:46pm | 22/02/11

      “It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B.” is just as offensive to the thousands of men and women in the motor vehicle industry as it is to call Mexicans lazy. The different between you and Top Gear is that when they’re offensive, it’s actually funny.

    • jimbo says:

      01:48pm | 22/02/11

      Good way to get lots of hits, rip on something you know everyone likes and wait for the hate. Next you should write about Steve Irwin, the keyboard warriors will still for it..

    • Jessica says:

      01:51pm | 22/02/11

      Im a woman and I love the show and have been watching it for years!

    • kelvin says:

      01:53pm | 22/02/11

      Apart from Great show and a poor reports from David; not much I can say.  Wish top gear will keep on going until we don’t drive a car anymore maybe.

    • Steve says:

      01:55pm | 22/02/11

      It’s not a program that all men like. I certainly don’t. A tad too bogan for me. I’ll leave it for the rev heads who appreciate teenage level humour.

    • Bridget says:

      01:57pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a female fan of Top Gear, have been so for nearly 4 years now (since I was 16) and I’m also one of the biggest fans of cars and motorbikes you will ever meet. I can meet new friends through my love of these things, and it is a wonderful way to meet interesting men! It is also a finacnial bonus- I don’t need to pay for some garage to do minor maintenance/repair of my car, i can do it myself. So I can see a lot of benefits to me being “infantile”, actually.

      I don’t see how people can discard other peoples’ likes as not interesting and as such obviously not popular/important. If cars are not that big an interest of people nowadays, why do things such as F1, V8 Supercars and the annual Motor Show continue to run and apparently thrive? (albeit less so currently due to the financial crisis)

      Finally, declaring being a fan of Top Gear and/or cars as “infantile” is no better than Top Gear itself’s stereotypes of various countries/cultures. It’s a lazy way of getting publicity through being incorrect.

    • Brett says:

      02:04pm | 22/02/11

      Maybe you should spend less time fattening your kids up with Happy Meals and more time learning how to write an educated article instead…  All you have really said is you don’t like a show you don’t watch. Maybe take your family for a walk instead?

    • Zeus says:

      02:05pm | 22/02/11

      Wow, for a reporter to be so out of touch with the public you’re meant to report is worrying.

      I agree the Mexican comments were ignorant to say the least, but then half of what all three of those people say is ignorant it’s there style. you only need to watch their challenges to learn this.

      Also I showed your comment on women not actually watching and the one’s in my office that love want to kick you square in the nuts. and I gotta say this are very “girly” girls that hate everything else about cars except the indicator they are to mans wealth.

    • Ian says:

      02:05pm | 22/02/11

      My girlfriend loves it and she knows less then nothing about cars. The writer of this article is a fool and a hypocrite. Having a go at Top Gear for using gross stereotypes then proceeding to crank out a few himself. How does this fool keep his job?

    • Simon says:

      02:08pm | 22/02/11

      David…...........having read your painful summary of Top Gear it is quite clear that you are burdened by numerous issues and am so glad this program gets right up your nose !!
      You strike me as the most boring person on earth and your political correctness makes one want to vomit !!

    • Daryl Saal says:

      02:09pm | 22/02/11

      You seem to have missed the entire point of the show which is not really about cars, Just uses them as props to take the mickey out of just about everything from PC rules, to feminists, to bogan blokes, the expectation that we should take ourselves more seriously as we age, pomposity, excessive OH&S, religion, and all the sacred cows.
      I suspect that after 10 minutes in the same room as Clarkson I’d clobber him, but I do enjoy watching his show.

    • Matt says:

      02:17pm | 22/02/11

      Wow.. So this is what passes for journalism these days?  You should be highly embarrassed to write this piece of crap and publish it..

    • Franq Spencer says:

      02:19pm | 22/02/11

      See what’s happened here is this here David fellow had an editorial deadline which he cannot meet with his planned article on teenage angst amongst Peruvian goldfish ... so in a few minutes, instead, knocks up a infantile article about an English TV show.

      Two points (because I have neither the time nor inclination to read the rest of this peculiar article) Mexico isn’t southern and they don’t ‘pick on’ people they think are stupid, they make jokes about everyone. Top Gear can make jokes about WWII whilst at the same time saying a VW car is great (or BMW drivers are ‘cocks’) What do you drive Dave? BMW?

      They make jokes about the Swiss, Australians, Austrians, Italians, Welsh (quite a lot actually), Germans (more than the Welsh), French (more than the Welsh also), politicians, ducks, Belgians, Finns, F1 racing, stock car racing, Americans being stupid and fat ... but do they complain? No. Why?

      Because they occasionally get the joke - it seems that Dave and his Mexican brethren, do not. Shame really.

    • Paul says:

      02:22pm | 22/02/11

      Pick one of the most popular shows on TV, bag it and bag those who watch it.  Nice baiting.  Poor article.

    • Les says:

      02:32pm | 22/02/11

      The show - Love it! Love it! Love it!.
      So does my whole family and I’m the only male in my house.
      Also, if you know nothing about cars, then you’re at the mercy of the salesmen (of both sexes) and the manufacturer’s marketing depts…and that is sad situation to be in when it comes to the second biggest purchase one makes in a lifetime.

    • Shane says:

      02:34pm | 22/02/11

      I have a confession to make: I am a car tragic, and I have not embarrassed about it. Yes, my obsession has grown from my collection of matchbox cars, but so what? That is my hobby. I am a little tired of the constant bagging of men in the media, particularly about traditional male hobbies. David I respect that you aren’t into cars, but don’t criticise those that are. If your favourite hobby is getting the best price on fondue set for your partner so be it. Just don’t criticise the rest of us for not being in touch with our feminine side.

      The only criticism I have of Top Gear is the show is showing just pranks, and the cars seem to being left out of it…

    • Grant says:

      02:49pm | 22/02/11

      I find them actually really funny. It is nice not to have everything dumbed down not to offend anyone. I mean if they said those things in Australia, they could end up in jail. They would be crucified by everyone from Julia Gillard to the local postie.
      Australia sucks because it has become a land where everything is so PC that you really can’t say anything, that could in any way be construed as an insult. If you do you could end up in jail or ostracised and end up losing your TV career. Fortunately Clarkson lives in a more enlightened land. No you don’t have to love this 7 foot motor mouthed chain smoker with pubes for hair but at least he is free to say what he thinks and finds funny even if other people disagree.

    • Tom says:

      02:50pm | 22/02/11

      Weak article, all you have done is said that the show is bad but haven’t given any reason. I think you have done this because you know the general population like this show and will comment on your article.

      Sad that Jeremy Clarkson is a tv host but still a better writer then you Penbo.

    • Jon says:

      02:58pm | 22/02/11

      I love Top Gear but I don’t like Channel 9. They’ve successfully butchered a show I love with 45 minutes of ads.

    • Tristan says:

      02:58pm | 22/02/11

      “we all sort of pretend that we’re into them because it seems less than manly not to.”

      Gold! Ha ha. God i hate this show for trying to mainstream our admiration of something that kills more people, wildlife, environment, culture and atmosphere than you can poke a stick at. I havent seen it but it sounds a bit like ‘The Footy Show’ for the sports-uninclined.

    • LauraBoBaura says:

      03:59pm | 22/02/11

      If you haven’t seen it - then how are you able to form the opinion that you hate it?

    • Peter says:

      03:03pm | 22/02/11

      Penbo, I think you’re struggling with your own masculinity… Fairly sour old article you’ve written here.

    • Steve says:

      03:07pm | 22/02/11

      Lets keep this one short and sweet.  I like cars.  You don’t.  I did go through a mid life crisis.  You probably didn’t (yet).  I drive a very nice late model German sports “coupe”.  You drive a Holden wagon of unknown vintage.  Very patriotic of you but I assume its nothing flash. I have many non-car enthusiast friends and colleagues. Funnily enough they turn into enthusiasts when I take them for a drive. Pluck the courage and visit your nearest Porsche dealership. Ask them to test drive a 911. No, its not good enough to just look at it.  Drive it.  Savour it.  Tell me what you think

    • lexi says:

      03:08pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a girl and I watch it every week eiterh by myself or when my husband is home its funny

    • Antonio Muchachos Morientez says:

      03:08pm | 22/02/11

      Haha Penbo you tool. You wouldn’t happen to be Mexican would you?

      Seems as though someone has gotten a little upset about a stab at the Mexicans and whinged about something he doesn’t know or care about.

      The percentage of car shows to serious current affairs / talking point shows is on par with the amount of people who know more about a car than the steering wheel and exhaust pipe to the people who don’t.

      There hundreds of other shows you can watch amigo.

    • Dave says:

      03:11pm | 22/02/11

      what a absolute nonsence article, top gear is a great comedy show, funny comments and down to earth good fun. David you have no sence of humor and should be embarressed with yourself, who cares if you dont like cars? top gear is one of the greatest shows ever, the numbers are proof.

      Hope this is your last article ever

    • Melanie says:

      03:14pm | 22/02/11

      Like so many other people have mentioned… if you don’t like this show and find it insulting… simple: don’t watch it. And as for you not knowing any women who actually like this show? How about you get out a little more. I, for one, being a young woman, find this show hilarious, informative and interesting. You say that cars “aren’t even that interesting”... ??? Given, they’re not everybody’s cup of tea, but you don’t need to make such wild general assumptions!

    • Sarah Seczkowski says:

      03:16pm | 22/02/11

      Why would you bother critiquing a show about cars if you aren’t interested in cars?  It is a great show for car enthusiasts and others as well. My husband is very into cars and he loves the show for the visuals of the different cars (even though the presenters apparently aren’t great drivers) I like the show as they have made a car show accessible to non car people so I can enjoy a show with my husband about one of his interests.

    • Chris says:

      03:26pm | 22/02/11

      Who the hell is this David Penberthy character. I’ve never heard of him til i seen this rubbish bagging top gear. Obviously an effeminate, politically correct Twat who grew up in an all female environment. Hey Pembo go and give your old man a good swift kick in the crotch for not raising you as a man. What good would you be to anyone in distress if you aren’t even capable of changing a Tyre. I’d rather be a useful bogan than an inept pc ponce

    • Todd says:

      03:26pm | 22/02/11

      Mexico is not in the southern hemisphere David. You have invalidated your whole argument with your initial display of stupidity.

    • mary monica roche says:

      03:30pm | 22/02/11

      SBS 1 Friday Nights 10 pm is the best Adults TV show.
      7 PM Project is the best kids TV show after 6PM George Negus..

    • robh says:

      03:34pm | 22/02/11

      I am always heartened when my comments in blogs like this don’t get published . They can’t possibly be any more banal that the repetitious drivel that does make it on to the screen so I can only assume they are just a bit close to the bone for notoriously thin skinned journos like yourself to want to see published .

    • CA says:

      03:39pm | 22/02/11

      When you pembo come up with something that’s anywhere near as popular as TG is, then you can pass your comments on it…till then, I can tell you that in our household, my wife and two daughters are keener to watch the show than I am at times. Those guys could do a show about washing machines and that would be more entertaining than your article…
      Is this your answer to your failing ratings: shock tactics?
      I almost feel sorry for you mate - you must be on your way out or something!

    • most popular show in history says:

      03:42pm | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is the most watched television show in the history of….television.
      I find it hard to believe that there are that many petrol heads in the world.
      I am a woman, love the show, STILL know nothing about cars, but enjoy the silly way they approach the ‘challenges’.
      I don’t find any of the hosts to have any rogue charm, but just good fun.

      Penbo - if you think this show is about cars….you’d be about 3/4 wrong.

    • TominSyd says:

      09:12am | 23/02/11

      that’s the thing isn’t it, - it is not really about cars anymore. Although it is promoted as being about cars. It used to be… but now it is a mix of game show, comedy, and spoof… on perpetual rotation.

    • AC says:

      04:27pm | 22/02/11

      Anybody linking to this video shouldn’t be talking about being ‘unfunny’. That has to be the worst comedian I’ve ever heard.

    • Blink says:

      03:53pm | 22/02/11

      David, if nobody likes the program then why is it so consistently high in the ratings?  It is, literally, the most popular show BBC has.  Perhaps a bit of reflection on the fact that, yes, different people can like different things would be good for you.  Well, that and possibly taking a bit more time to select what you write about….

    • cassandra says:

      04:01pm | 22/02/11

      Gotta love this.

      Lots of punchies like top gear. They read an article written by someone who doesn’t. Cue hundreds of angry readers launching personal and very bitter attacks on the author.

      And what’s the issue? A difference of opinion over a light entertainment motoring show.

      Glad we are dealing with the big issues.

      Umm… I’ll say it first .....time for a deep breath and to lighten up people.

      oh and btw @Chris @ 3:26 pm. “This David Penberthy character” has been editor in chief of the Punch site for a while and was editor at the Tele before that. And he used to get the occasional mention on media watch. Just for your information.

    • Richard B says:

      09:19pm | 22/02/11

      Yes, perhaps if they don’t like the article, they should wander over to another one. And they can’t tell David about people being precious! Stephen Fry called Dr. Who a children’s programme, and it’s one of my favourites, but that’s what makes him different from me. I’m sure they’re not going to cancel Top Gear because of this article. The man has a different opinion, and differences are good. But sadly rare.

    • Andrew says:

      04:02pm | 22/02/11

      Great show, if you don’t like it, you are either a wowser or a prius driver. Yes they make fun of other ‘races’ (you do realise Mexico is a country not a race right? not very PC of you) but they make fun of everyone equally, including, in fact primarily British people. I have to say one of the funniest bits was the Monaro test where they made fun of Aussies.

    • cassandra says:

      04:06pm | 22/02/11

      Umm David - according to wikipedia you lived in Mexico for a while. Is that right? Was that the Mexico or bizarro Mexico?

    • Dingo says:

      04:09pm | 22/02/11

      Considering it is one of the most popular shows on the planet, I guess they’re doing something right. Your article sounds like sour grapes to me.

    • Stewart Henstock says:

      04:14pm | 22/02/11

      One of the most boring stupid shows ever made….i want my 5 minutes back…time thief.

    • RIght said Fred says:

      04:22pm | 22/02/11

      woo hooo hooo. So your middie not going so well or something? I cacked myself at the quote of Hammond on Mexicans. It’s comedy! Not meant to be taken too literally! Relax, it’s people like you beiging up the planet!

    • Arjayempee says:

      04:35pm | 22/02/11

      Blah blah blah , , , , anyway, they are hugely popular and you are not! 

      (Oh, and by the way, I think if you look at an atlas you will discover that Mexico is in the northern hemisphere!!)

    • Matt says:

      04:36pm | 22/02/11

      David… You are a brave man hanging crap on one of the highest rating (and most downloaded) TV shows in the world that is watched by lots of internet savvy geeks. Expect a shit storm!

    • Levi says:

      04:50pm | 22/02/11

      Do you find it interesting, David, that while the presenters make fun of Germans, Frenchies, Welsh and others on a regular basis, these people do not get all precious and complain?

      Mention Mexicans though, who are on average somewhat more brown than your average Welshman or German, and they are all instantly racist and childish. Learn to take a joke, and if you dont like it then change the channel

      Go and peddle your pro-multicultural crap elsewhere, namely one of the fifty thousand other pro-multiculturalism, politically correct articles on this website.

    • pookemon says:

      05:32pm | 22/02/11

      “I know a few blokes who enjoy (or enjoyed) the show, but I’ve never met a woman who claims to like it”

      Do you know any women?  Perhaps they don’t frequent the kind of establishments you prefer?  Is your dislike for the hosts based on their fashion sense (or lack there-of).

      My mother likes the show, my wife likes the show, the partners of the guys at work all like the show.  Why?  Because they recognise that it’s purely entertainment.  It’s not about the cars, it’s about the antic’s.  Everything they do on the show is meant to entertain.  Plain and simple.  If you “don’t get it” then watch something else.

      Personally I think your article is a load of tripe concocted to draw attention from the legions of fans of the show, somehow inflating your worth.

    • Anaerobic says:

      05:39pm | 22/02/11

      Some people will never experience and appreciate the sheer joy of heel-toeing from third to second uphill through a tight left-hander on an open country road in an MX-5.

      I feel sorry for those who see cars as a conveyance from Point A to Point B. When they go on holidays, the holiday doesn’t start until they get there.

      With the right car, the right training and the right attitude, a holiday starts the minute that you back out of the garage.

      Top Gear is not a celebration of the machine but a celebration of the freedom that allows anyone to go anywhere at any time they choose simply because they own a car - Zonda or reasonably priced shitbox.

      If you can’t understand that then continue to catch your bus and train to work and deliberate on the profound thought that where and when you go in your life is decided by a dull colourless and boring public servant. If you’re lucky, you’ll die in a train wreck

    • David says:

      05:45pm | 22/02/11

      Clearly the opinion of someone who drives a boring Toyota and has never known the feeling of driving fast on an exciting mountain road or a race track. For many people cars are to get from A to B but for many others the open road is an exciting place to be. These people are Top Gear fans.

    • AUtlaw says:

      05:48pm | 22/02/11

      David says “to another southern nation, namely Mexico”

      Mexico is in the Northern Hemisphere so is not a “southern nation” unless you are in the US or Canada, and so geographically north of that country. Sorry David, it looks like you are as prone to stereotypes as the next guy. You really aren’t as clever as you think you are, David.

    • Kikalo says:

      05:49pm | 22/02/11

      I’m a big Top Gear fan and the last time I checked, I didn’t have a penis. No, it wasn’t removed, I’m a woman. I also really like cars…  Yes, I’m a fully grown adult woman. Speaking of stereotypes.. I don’t have a mullet and I’m very much a feminine woman - who does really like cars and Top Gear. 

      Mister Blogman, how far away did you look for a woman that likes Top Gear? There are quite a large number of us.

      I see very little harm in Top Gear, but I do see they push some boundaries and can chalk it up to banter. Other shows couldn’t get away with it because they don’t have the same pull that TG has. They’ve also got the BBC on their side. I don’t think we’d see the AU Top Gear get away with the same kind of “banter” the UK guys do. Those kinds of jokes from anyone with an Australian accent is often cringeworthy.

      But maybe that says something about us, that we’ve become more sensitive (overly?) to what can be simple humor? or perhaps we just got really really burned by how silly we can seem in tv/movies when our stereotypes are blown up on the screen.

      The UK TG have slugged Australia with some jokes about our stereotypes before, and we had that mudslinging match between “Australia” and Robin Williams. I just don’t see the point in making a fuss about every single joke-like-comment. What ever happened to context?? Did we lose that when we stopped reading and writing and began drooling at the TV?  I don’t think we did. I think there are too many monsters in the media who would otherwise have no job if they didn’t make news of something that wasn’t really news… and maybe a few people who get their nickers in a knot too easily. Is that assumption, too, stereotypical?

      I think it’s really up to the broadcaster/regulator/public to see the difference between BS jokes and serious racial undertones. I think TG doesn’t have it in them to go that far to be actually considered offensive… If everything was put through the same PC filter, there’d be next to nothing on TV.. oh maybe that seventh heaven show - but they didn’t exactly have a varied human palette.

      hmmm I also think you’re a little wrong about not knowing or caring about cars. I see a more of a point to knowing about a car - its mechanics, engineering and more importantly its real value before you buy one - than knowing about what Britney Spears is up to in her spare time, barefoot at the mall grabbing some Starbucks.

      To know and understand engineering, design and marketing could inspire you to be the next Steve Jobs. On the other hand you could just watch TG and laugh a little. What’s the worst that could happen? You laugh hard and release a little peepee into your pants….

    • Richard says:

      05:56pm | 22/02/11

      Has anyone heard of Mexico’s Mastretta car company before TG review their car. They could not have bought that publicity in a thousand years.

      TG is an entertainment program. They producing a program that you can sit down relax, not that it too serious and every now and then they put the lives on the line just to entertain their viewers. They poke more fun at each other than there every do at different nationalities. Would the Mexican Ambassador called in and complained if they were calling Americans fat or would have been laughing like the rest of us.

      As the show is the most watched program in the world, most people know what the humour is like so if you don’t like it then switch it off.

    • Jose says:

      06:26pm | 22/02/11

      Alf Garnett was not in Love Thy Neighbour.  Alf was a character in Til Death Us Do Part.

    • Daniel says:

      06:32pm | 22/02/11

      If you think that no one takes Jeremy seriously, read through the Australian ” Top Gear magazine.

      Jeremy is a funny composite caricature based around a the British class system, with his love for fox hunting, scorn for anyone remotely Green, climate denial and other funny notions of what a ‘real man’ should drive, do and believe. James and Richard act as foils in some ways, but mostly reinforce Jeremy’s caricature, than undermine it in any way.

      The show is mostly harmless, and the nutty ideas they have (or pretend to have) on climate change, speed limits, car safety and so on will probably never influence policy. That being said, I would appreciate an intelligent critique of the show, but to imagine a tabloid scribbler like David could provide it is crazy.

    • Hudson says:

      06:38pm | 22/02/11

      FYI, Manuel from Faulty Towers wasn’t Mexican. He was Spanish.

    • car-hobbyist says:

      06:46pm | 22/02/11

      Penbo, a car was essentially designed to simply get from A-B, true.  but the critical word there is WAS. what about the people who work on cars as a hobby and a passion to escape the dull world of 9-5 repetitive work? to free there mind from dramas? and to keep out of trouble? top gear gives the not so fortunate who loves cars a chance to see what engineering masterpieces are out there! would you prefer we just took the drugs you were on when you wrote this? grow up!

    • Hawko says:

      06:58pm | 22/02/11

      Hi Penbo. Great piece and I couldnt agree more. One disturbing bit tho. Please to know that you feed your kids Mc Happy Meals.

    • Aussie Top Gear Fan says:

      07:12pm | 22/02/11

      This article couldn’t be further from the truth.  Men and women love the show. 

      Political correctness is getting out of control.  Having a go fun joke about the mexican stereotype is no different to Sydneysiders having a go at Melbournites, or the rest of the country having a go at Qlders.  Just because the joke is made about someone of a different race it shouldn’t be taken any differently to how it is intended… as a joke.  They call everyone from Liverpool car thieves and you don’t hear about anyone from Liverpool complaining.

    • Craig says:

      07:32pm | 22/02/11

      who wrote this piece?  It seems like someone who was born a male but never became a man. What are men to be passionate about?  Manicures and pedicures? Shopping for clothes?  Thats not what being a man is.  Manhood is having an interest and pursuing it. 

      As for the show which is what you should have concentrated your venting about, yes, it has become a crap show just like most things on TV these days. 

      I’d rather be passionate about one of my cars or boats or other hobbies…

    • Andrew says:

      07:33pm | 22/02/11

      Quite a shallow analysis David and incorrect on many levels. You will clearly be amazed to find many women (including my wife) who disdain cars and revheads actually love this show . I think they (and I) find the approach of the hosts to be cheerfully non-PC, open and cheeky. The hosts are generally witty and erudite and take the piss out of everything, INCLUDING each other, the Brits and the work they themselves do. And of course when you’re firing like a machine gun sometimes it is tasteless and doesn’t work so like all standups they move on.

      They mark a refreshing difference in the TV world because they haven’t allowed themselves to be PC’d to a living death by the professionally and continually outraged. Everything is tongue in cheek whereas you want to dull them down and give them a hair shirt to cover your sensibilities. Toughen up Princess.

    • Ket says:

      07:55pm | 22/02/11

      ” but I’ve never met a woman who claims to like it”.

      Really? I adore Top Gear and I’m a woman.

    • Rob G says:

      07:56pm | 22/02/11

      Actually they take the piss out of everyone and everything!  Its just your turn hasnt come yet David! Or maybe your not worth having the piss taken out of you.

    • Alan says:

      08:19pm | 22/02/11

      I see the method of the Lazy Journalist again: “Oh dear, I have to write a hundred words again. What subject will I pick?”

      Deride a show that’s popular, for failing to reach your standards for entetainment. Then sit back and let the public do the work, rebuffing your claim. Bravo! 350 responses, and counting!

      Maybe someone will even prompt you with something you can recycle as your next article. The saddest part being - you get PAID for this, we don’t

    • David says:

      08:21pm | 22/02/11

      Ummm…Manuel was Spanish, not Mexican…“he’s from Barcelona…”.

    • Connor Mc says:

      08:41pm | 22/02/11

      I used to sit down every week with my 3 friends who are girls and enjoy it.  Worried about injustice in discrimination in the world Mr Penberthy, try and look for a slightly more engaging and tangible topic other than a tv show about cars.

    • Jason says:

      08:43pm | 22/02/11

      You really do have to appreciate and understand the engineering which can bring character to a vehicle. Most people live in their own little world and drive dull cars for the purpose of getting from A to B. People who ride motorcycles probably enjoy the show more because they can relate to performance. Most of us could never afford the cars they review and even if we could we’d still prefer to spend the money elsewhere. It’s a fun show with a few bad jokes.. get over it.

    • John M says:

      08:48pm | 22/02/11

      Stone the crows, isn’t this taking the piss out of the best TV program that the stations can up with. I love it, I enjoy itand so does the bloody wife who is rather particular about what she watches, just goes to show if you get something good to watch on TV and the bloody “critics’ want to degrade it, all I can say is get a bloody life and understand these blkes are into what they do.and the wife?

    • Richard B says:

      08:58pm | 22/02/11

      I used to like the show, and I do watch a number of car shows from time to time, as well as always being at the motor show. But Top Gear is very irresponsible in its approach to safety, I think. They make it look very easy and safe to do huge speeds and difficult manoevres, and don’t differentiate much between their racetrack and the public road. Forget insulting the Mexicans, I think it’s their continuous glorification of dangerous and antisocial behaviour that’s their problem.

    • Lee says:

      09:09pm | 22/02/11

      I have only seen bits of Top Gear when I am waiting for the next show to come on but what I have seen I can honestly say I can’t stand it. From what I can see it is a bunch of juvenile guys prattling on about cars. But to each their own. I have been surprised on who has enjoyed the show and tried to explain why they like it so much. Many of them would not be considered car nuts

    • john doe says:

      09:34pm | 22/02/11

      “There’s plenty of better things to spend our money on, to aspire to, to talk about. “

      yes, like a pair of pliers to pull the stick out of your bum. just because you can’t pass as a metrosexual but arent masculine enough to join the rest of us dont look down your nose at people who enjoy their brand of entertainment. i’m sure you can find a rerun of antiques roadshow you’ll like while topgear is on.

    • napes says:

      09:48pm | 22/02/11

      Top Gear is where it is for one really good reason - it does what it does really well, which is to be a bit silly & have very tongue in cheek poke at pretty much anything… and all of this OVER car reviews. @ Richard B - you stopped watching it because of SAFETY! Do you also eat dinner with a cork on your fork? Don’t watch NCIS… people get murdered!

    • Kimberly says:

      10:01pm | 22/02/11

      I’m female and I like Top Gear.  I work with people (some of them women) who like Top Gear. None of the people I know (myself included) are particularly into cars (I’ve only owned one it was a Ford Taurus).  So I’ll take exception to this article, not that I disagree about Top Gear being immature and vaguely racist, but the writer has not done his homework, merely jumped on a bandwagon against something he likely feels excluded from.

    • Edward III says:

      10:51pm | 22/02/11

      In a sea of turgid boring lame PC sludge this program stands out like a beacon of refreshing normal blokes talk where anything can be funny, no one is offended and its tits out, big asses, and silly cunts all the way in crazy fast cars.

      Don’t like it?  Well go f*ck yourself.

    • Darius Jedburg says:

      11:18pm | 22/02/11

      Take the program as it is… light entertainment.  Clarkson, May and the Hamster are an enjoyable distraction.  Pembo, if you’re not interested in the program, it does not mean that you should bag out the program…. just accept that you drive a Ford Festiva and move on.

    • Emma says:

      12:02am | 23/02/11

      I’m a girl and I like the show. I dont even like cars! I just get a giggle out of watching it!

    • KR says:

      12:39am | 23/02/11

      I don’t like the show either, but it’s more entertaining than this drivel you’ve just written about it!

    • Sean Williams says:

      03:45am | 23/02/11

      Just out of interest, is this the same David Penberthy who once “joked” that the British-born Muslim 12th man of the England cricket team was a “member of al-Qaeda”, a “joke” which led to damages being awarded to said cricketer?

    • Grumpy Middle Aged Man says:

      05:12am | 23/02/11

      Penbo, you’re obviously not in the shows target audience, that being men who aren’t politically correct all of the time and can poke fun at themselves as well as others for nothing more than entertainment.  There are way too many people in this world calling for the sacking or gagging of the Top Gear presenters, you’ve shown your colours fairly early in the piece.  There are millions of others who enjoy the good old fashioned blokey fun and TV stations like the nine network are loving it.  Their ratings are going through the roof for the original series at least, and if their show, based on the personalities of the current presenters is so wrong, why has it been sold as a production model to so many countries around the world?  I ask if it is so wrong, why, unlike the PC dribble we’re normally fed, is it shown all over the world to audiences who stop what they’re doing to watch, sometimes even having to watch a translated version?  The answer is simple, it’s because people don’t actually like having to worry about what their neighbours think of their choices, sometimes they like to escape into a dream world where they’re putting a million dollar car around a track sideways.  Most of us will never see the cars featured in real life, yet we all form opinions on them, and as for the Mexicans or the Germans or the French being offended, well that’s what the British do best, and before you get back on your high horse, have you ever used the term Pom?  Believe it or not, it isn’t a term of endearment, it is offensive, racist and used all too frequently in the Aussie mainstream media, but guess what, no one cares about that either!
      It’s about time the sterilised, nanny state approved media that we’re force fed by organisations that are simply too scared of the risk of litigation sat down, shut up and looked at what we actually want on our TV’s, it’s not reality TV, no it’s entertaining shows that occasionally offend people, they have an extremely high production standard and we like them, they’re not PC, if they were, they’d suck and we wouldn’t watch them!

    • Eduardo says:

      06:42am | 23/02/11

      In my experience those people with absolutely no interest in their car (other than its colour and that it goes from A to B) are often poor drivers with little affinity for the road, their vehicle and the craft of driving. For them driving is not a craft, it does not demand respect, nor the car any understanding nor affinity. The unfortunate result is more dangerous roads. So before you lambast people for being interested in driving and cars (albeit through a light-hearted medium), the society with no populace with a respect for driving and all that goes with it is very much the poorer.

    • adz says:

      06:50am | 23/02/11

      Wow, talk about a wet blanket.

      “It seems kind of infantile to know so much about something which is essentially designed to get us from A to B”

      Do you look at Technology shows/mags and rubbish them because they are about something which is essentially designed to write emails? Or maybe cooking shows because they are about something which is essentially designed to provide nutritional support for the body?

      You need to lighten up a bit mate!

    • al says:

      07:05am | 23/02/11

      Penbo just needed something for a response cause he didnt know what to write today… “i know, i’ll tag it with Top Gear, easy!”  How about tomorrow you try something like how iPhones are crud.

    • Ben says:

      07:25am | 23/02/11

      Thanks for that useless information David Penberthy, hope you feel you have contributed to society…

    • Linus L says:

      07:50am | 23/02/11

      It really is a bad show.
      All they like are English cars.
      Never mind that the English dont own any of their car industry.
      To make up for this they have to bag other races and their cars.
      Why dont they just change the name to the Aston Martin show.

    • Sanchy says:

      07:53am | 23/02/11

      And your slamming of Top Gear is better than their poorly chosen racial comments because…...

      ....because nohting!

      They are at least amusing.

      You Sir, are an anti male bore.

      Shame on you, for crossing the pink line. Next you’ll be telling us that men shouldn’t be interested in home improvement, exercise, sport or anything other than cooking shows.

      Great to know you’ve joined the sisterhood of the travelling pants, Penbo!

    • Phil says:

      08:01am | 23/02/11

      What a pathetic load of drivel. Many many men like fast cars, we are not faking it mate, honest! Despite driving a wagon myself, I do know what a camshaft is, I can even explain exactly how it functions if you’d like?

    • Matt lawrie says:

      08:10am | 23/02/11

      LOL
      I wonder if he reads the comments on his article and realises what a douche bag he has been

    • Sat from Springhill says:

      08:17am | 23/02/11

      If you have to comment at least get your facts right about the stars of TV shows. Alf Garnett was never in the show Love thy Neighbour. He was in Till death us do part. I love the show and as someone else says above do not like do not watch it.

    • Jodie D says:

      08:23am | 23/02/11

      You could at least have had a stab at researching your subject.

      The Mexican car maker in question, Mastretta, admits that the controversy has brought in a sudden surge of Internet traffic on the company’s website. There was even an increase in visits to the factory and orders for the Mastretta MXT sports car are beginning to pour in.

      “We were not prepared for this,” said Mastretta spokesperson Carlos Sandoval. “The Top Gear program has given us publicity in Mexico and abroad that we could not have paid for.”

      And it was James May, not Richard Hammond, who said Mexican food is “sick with cheese on it”. Not his finest hour, it must be said, but May is no dolt: he has a degree in music and a pilot’s licence and has written extensively on science and engineering. He’s also terribly funny—sick-with-cheese jokes notwithstanding.

    • Ken Bruns says:

      08:37am | 23/02/11

      Oh Dear the green eyed monster really has had a good day with you hasn’t it? Well David just because the Top gear crew have found a way to make journalism REALLY pay and you haven’t is no reason to write such a poor critique. Pick on somehting else, improve your writing and perhaps you too can have some success!

    • Geoff says:

      08:46am | 23/02/11

      Yeah most men “grow out” of being passionate about things they find interesting.  And most men “don’t enjoy” a bit of immature humour…  hahahahahaha


      ..  sounds like someone’s bitter that they’ve lost their sense of fun in life.  Make sure you don’t get your slippers wet when you go to get the mail! 

      Top gear is entertaining.  If you don’t like it, don’t watch it.  And get off your soapbox your jibber jabber makes you sound foolish.

    • Nutts says:

      09:09am | 23/02/11

      It’s the only car show on TV that’s NOT about cars, but about the stupid things these presenters do with cars. Some of the things are so stupid I have to turn it off. I actually feel sorry for those in the Country or City they Invade doing those stupid tests. And then there’s the Austrailian Version trying to imitate their Heros in the UK, OMG.

    • Christopher L W says:

      09:29am | 23/02/11

      So what if they mock Mexicans, it was funny as hell.

      They have mocked Aussies too and I am Aussie and I thought it was funny as hell also.

      If your that sensitive to obvious and “being neon flashing sign, written with taking the piss for fun, all over it”, stop watching tv, and never leave your house or use the internet, and make yourself a nice big bubble!

      Or you could go to your local Bunnings and purchase some concrete, promptly make it up and put into a mug, drink it and harden the **** up!

    • Punisher says:

      09:35am | 23/02/11

      David, you have just increased the shows popularity even more!

    • Geography Nerd says:

      10:44am | 23/02/11

      ... “Down Under” tours. It’s a pity that they didn’t choose instead to take their show on the road to another southern nation, namely Mexico”

      It’s a pity that someone who claims to have lived in Mexico seems unaware that Mexico is north of the equator, by a long way.  I suppose it’s south of England at least, and kinda southern for the northern hemisphere.

    • Andrew says:

      03:54pm | 23/02/11

      I’m not exactly sure why you spent so much time on this alleged ‘article.’  You don’t like the show and don’t understand why people watch the show?  If that’s the case don’t watch it.  I don’t like daytime soaps so consequently I don’t watch them.
      And honestly, have we really become so PC that we are actually taking Jeremy Clarkson seriously???  This is the same man who created a fake add for the diesel Polo with people running away screaming and a catch line of “Berlin to Warsaw on one tank.”
      In an age when 3 people can complain about an ad and have it successfully pulled off air, good on the Beeb for defending one of their highest rating shows and continuing it on air.  It’s just a bit of shame the Ch. 9 hasn’t aired the episode yet, we seemed to have skipped over it

    • John Morland says:

      09:58pm | 23/02/11

      Top gear is not a TV show, it is a TV phenomenon. 

      Yes, it is Jeremy’s show but he has shown that he can laugh at himself.  And the car manufacturer’s queue up for the exposure.

      As well, both Richard and James have their own successfull TV shows.

      The team has worked out their chemistry, are entertaining and professional.

      Top Gear is clearly aimed at the reasonable well-heeled who are considering buying or trading up to a respectable car.

      What’s the problem ? I just see this article as criticism for criticism sake.

      John M

    • Matt says:

      09:55am | 24/02/11

      I love the show and I’m not a car nut at all. I’ve never been to the Clipsal despite living in Adelaide and don’t watch Bathurst or Formula 1. I do like to drive a nice car though.
      Top Gear mixes the perfect blend of humour, challenges and interesting information about some beautiful creations. Every guy that I know really enjoys the show, but is able to take it for what it’s worth, unlike the author of this piece sadly. And I thought the Mexican reference, whilst a bit crass, was actually quite funny. If they said something like that about Australians, I’d simply laugh at the gag and move on. Why do we need to be so precious about these things. If you want to see offensive racial humour, go to any live comedy show that’s running!

    • Pat Mc says:

      10:38am | 24/02/11

      Bloody hell, it seems the lazeabout who wrote this article was as lazy as the forementioned Mexicans. Did he bother researching, possibly checking up on the fact that it IS actually one of the most popular shows around?

      Why would a person watch a show in the comfort and secret of their own home, in order to persist the notion that they were indeed “Manly”,

      I know jack all about cars, I dont really care about them, but Top Gear is one of the most enjoyable shows around at the moment. To say it is a show about the nuts and bolts of a car, and the occasional racist joke, is complete nonsense.

      I challenge you to watch the Vietnam episode and not enjoy it.

    • Deano says:

      12:25pm | 25/02/11

      The car aspect of the show is really not about cars per-se. Its about a highly styled, highly engineered, fashion driven consumer object. My wife, and my son, both love it.

    • Kyle says:

      11:45am | 27/02/11

      I find it about as interesting as smelling someone’s farts and trying to work out what they’ve eaten…. And I dont do that very often either. Switch channels, its very boring ande the gags stopped being funny ten years ago.

    • Daniel says:

      12:52pm | 28/02/11

      For the record the show is only 1 hour a week. Unless you want to count repeats and catching up on missing previous programs into your little whine.  But I wouldn’t imagine a person who literally know nothing other than the brand and colour of their car (which is depreciating at thousands per year) to be much good at counting either.  Congratulations reality says you are less of a man.

    • Fitzy says:

      01:44pm | 06/03/11

      Are you still on the Hormones Dave or are you post-op now? It’s hard to tell in your ‘writing’.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter