As cynical as it might sound you can’t help but think that Communications Minister Stephen Conroy would have been relieved last week’s media scrutiny was mainly soaked up by Peter Garrett’s problems with roof insulation.

Senator Stephen Conroy is copping it on a few fronts.

But following the Sunday Herald-Sun revelation that he went skiing with Channel Seven chief Kerry Stokes shortly before handing out $250 million to the TV stations it means he’ll at least be continuing in his role as best supporting stuff-up.
Political cliché that it is, Conroy’s decision to hang out with Stokes on the slopes goes to the Minister’s judgment and it’s that judgment Kevin Rudd must really be beginning to question.

If you’re not across Conroy’s problems here’s a beginner’s guide:

Handouts to free-to-air TV

Basically Conroy’s recent decision to significantly reduce the licensing fees free to air channels pay has the left the three big networks with a $250 million windfall. Now while the Government has said the decision was made to encourage more local content on free-to-air TV, there’s actually nothing in the deal that says the networks have to spend it on local content.

Pay TV operators like Foxtel (part owned by The Punch publisher News Ltd) are obviously annoyed with this decision. The fact that it has emerged he spent time racing Kerry Stokes down the hills not long before he made the decision doesn’t look very good.

ISP filter

If you only relied on the internet for your information you’d be under the impression this is the most important policy debate to ever take place in this country and Stephen Conroy is the devil. It’s not and he isn’t.

That being said Conroy’s been pretty at bad trying to sell the filter, which, regardless of whether you’re an internet freedom activist or not, a lot of Australians would probably have an inherent suspicion of. It’s also unclear when this thing is actually going to be introduced as new glitches seem to appear almost weekly.

Conroy previously laughed off the threat of attacks by hacker groups protesting the introduction of the filter, and last week they managed to bring down several Government websites including Parliament and the Department of Immigration, that could have real implications for things like visa applications

National Broadband Network problems

Last week former Labor MP and power-broker Mike Kaiser was announced as head of public relations for the Government’s new NBN, a job that was not advertised and pays $450,000 a year.

This was only a week after a report by the Audit Office found $30 million was spent on the failed tender process for the NBN, $17 million of which was spent by Conroy’s department. Conroy was unapologetic claiming it was “absolutely not” a waste of money.

Whether the above list is an indictment of Conroy or more a reflection of the pitfalls of the communications portfolio as whole, a job Kim Beazley once described as “time in hell”, is no doubt a discussion that Senator Conroy’s colleagues are having.

But there’s also no doubt that Conroy’s case would be helped if he wasn’t tied up in so much factional Labor malarkey that the Rudd Government has thus far been able to avoid - at least in public.

Conroy’s factional fiddling earned him the “factional Dalek” moniker from former Labor power broker and one-time mentor to Conroy Robert Ray (I’m not sure what that makes Robert Ray, Davros perhaps) and a labeled a “rooster” by Mark Latham for unsettling Simon Crean’s leadership.

Recently he has been involved in a series of Victorian Labor disputes that are too tedious to go into here, but it’s fair to ask how much a Minister in charge of supposedly the largest infrastructure project since the Snowy Hydro should be dealing in this rubbish.

Conroy has shrugged off this latest controversy but Kevin Rudd and his colleagues may not continue to be as dismissive.

Most commented

39 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Andy says:

      06:12am | 15/02/10

      Conroy goes skiing with Stokes and don’t forget Rudd had holidays at Kerry Stokes’s mansion in Broome as well. Appointment of a former Labor MP with no other applications sort. Makes you wonder how far off the mark Turnbull was with UTEGATE? Jobs and handouts for the boys?

    • Nathan H says:

      10:36am | 15/02/10

      Lets not overlook Rudd’s friendly treatment and soapbox platform that he gets on Channel 7 via Sunrise, then on An Audience With the Prime Minister, and now Sunrise again.

    • Jack Thomas says:

      10:45am | 15/02/10

      The media’s handling of these has been a classic wet lettuce leaf slap, which says so much about the bias and agenda of the likes of the ABC and The Age, and the plain pathetic nature of the rest. No real scrutiny or ethical standards what so ever and these blokes will sail on through. Code of conduct is another lie from the Hollowman.

      Conroy’s statements about not knowing anything or meeting with Mr. Kaiser before parachuting this Labor mate into a $450,000 a year job are complete fiction, but no journo will even bring to account his actual dealings on this. His meek admitting to arranging it is hardly mentioned anywhere.

      What did he know about this? Why are Kaiser’s real credentials so good that the job is not even advertised, apart from being a Labor mate who previously has form for (electoral) fraud? 

      The Queensland government’s own code of conduct states that Queensland public servants are not to hold business meetings with former ministerial staff on matters they have dealt with in their past 18 months of public sector employment.

      Rudd’s holier than thou claims about his Labor Ministers living up to a higher standard of ethics, etc. was met with the usual smugness from those Howard haters. Yet another election lie.

      Has any journo bothered to check Rudd’s Ministerial Code of Conduct?

      Then we had Belinda Neal and her “counselling”. Then we had Defence Minister Fitzgibbon and his free trips and unusual payments to his Dad from mysterious Chinese ‘business’ people.

      Now we have a Labor Minister skiiing in Whistler with a media baron the week before the media baron is part of a $250m freebie. This is far worse than Vic Labor’s Thwaites’ expensive family ski junkets from a few years ago because it rips off the taxpayer in a huge way.

      Clearly all those ‘Fat Cats’ Rudd talked about targetting don’t include Labor mates.

      What about Free TV, the lobby group which arranged this $250 loss to the taxpayer and media baron windfall?

      Ah yes, run by Kevin’s old mate and boss, ex Labor Premier Wayne Goss. Not too many journo’s seem to have mentioned that little connection either.

      Yet another Labor broken promise and yet another example of Labor Ministers getting their snouts in the trough as soon as they can.

    • Caz says:

      07:24am | 15/02/10

      “Conroy has shrugged off this latest controversy but Kevin Rudd and his colleagues may not continue to be as dismissive. “

      I think he underestimates the bad image he has made for himself. Methinks the electorate won’t be as dismissive either.

    • Sceptic says:

      10:59am | 15/02/10

      Not a chance Caz.

      Cue Rudd’s latest advertising campaign, prompted by his poor management, incompetant and corrupt Ministers, and a very real fear of Tony Abbott.

      A few phone calls to the unions, the odd kickback to help them fund their own ad campaigns, and viola the electorate is back in love with this trumped up public servant called Kevin.

      Never underestimate the stupidity of people, or the sheer disdain of them from many within the Labor machine.

      Watch this space. Move over Bob the Builder.

    • WKH says:

      07:31am | 15/02/10

      If it looks like a turd, and it smells like a turd, then there is a dam good chance it is a turd. The words “corruption, collusion and carnal knowledge spring to my mind. At the very least the Senator has proven he is incapable of managing his portfolio/duties and it has cost the tax payer millions in wasted dollars again. A company director would go to jail! Does this guy have a business plan? What does it say about Krudd that he will “stand by his man”? The arrogance of this government is on display for all to see. I can’t think of anything this Senator has done since coming into office that could warrant any kind of support by anyone. It is another example of KRUDD=FAIL….

    • shabangabang says:

      08:08am | 15/02/10

      The Communism minister, Stephen Conroy, directly compared Australia to China and Thailand in regards to internet filtering. Thankfully Google told him to go jump when asked to voluntarily filter their searches. Hopefully Google will threaten to pull out of Australia if our internet is filtered.
      “Conroy has shrugged off this latest controversy but Kevin Rudd and his colleagues may not continue to be as dismissive.”
      What CONroy needs to realise is that in an election year hell hath no fury like an electorate ignored.

    • Charles says:

      08:36am | 15/02/10

      Leo, you also missed the fact that this bozo (Conroy) also killed off the contract for the Optel project that the coalition had signed up just before the last federal election.

      In this project, there was a commitment by Optel (Optus and Elders) to supply mostly wireless internet to the majority of Australian located outside the large capital cities.  Given that wireless is rapidly overtaking fixed line technology as a broadband delivery mechanism, this decision is now looking more like partisan politics than anything in the interests of the Australian tax-payer.

      The ALP is living in a time warp with its talk of Fibre to the Home (FTTH) proposal,  especiall;y given people like myself living in remote rural locations.  I know with certainty that in my lifetime I will never see the bulldozer rolling up to my place with a fibre cable, and I hope I never should, it would never be an economical exercise.

      When Conroy killed off that project, he put back the possibility of a halfway decent broadband for regipnal areas by at least 10 years, as well as costing both companies significant $ millions for no benefit.

      He should be sacked for gross incompetence, if not for all the other reasons you have listed above.

    • Dave says:

      11:55am | 15/02/10

      Totally agree - Conroy is a menace

    • Nigel says:

      08:49am | 15/02/10

      $43 billion on a NBN without a business plan and not $250 million gift to free-to-air television without any measurable KPI’s for Australian content on air.  Where does this guy get off spending taxpayers money without accountability.  If that spending wasn’t bad enough, the Government attempts (sucessfully) to hide its culpability by releasing a bland media release on a Friday.  This government is starting to make Whitlam look like a statesman.

    • Kim says:

      08:55am | 15/02/10

      Conroy must go, or the young vote will leave the labor party!

    • Macca says:

      09:19am | 15/02/10

      Disagree Kim, whilst the young vote will abhor Conroy’s actions / policies, I doubt they’ll jump the fence to the Conservatives. I think they’ll need a bigger push than that, or at least more time.

      The young vote will stick with Labor for this election, despite Conroy’s best efforts

    • Mark says:

      08:56am | 15/02/10

      This man is not for the people. He is for big business!!! GET HIM OUT!

    • Evan Findlay says:

      10:57am | 15/02/10

      Damn right Mark! He should be on the benches of the coaltion.

    • Macca says:

      09:26am | 15/02/10

      I’m going to sound like a little snot preaching to the converted here, but the Free-to-Air lot get a $250m windfall so they can keep producing Gems like “Home & Away” and “Talking ‘bout my Generation”, and Foxtel get an anti-siphoning list for investing in the Cricket (Domestic OneDay cricket), Football* (A-League &  Asian Champions League), League (U/20 competition) and Union (Super 14 & the failed Domestic comp)

      Am I the only person who has a problem with this? or can we throw a collective Trident at the heart of Conroy’s political career?

      *read “Soccer”

    • DocBud says:

      09:27am | 15/02/10

      People here seem to think a lack of Australian content is a bad thing.

    • Matt Stewart says:

      04:49pm | 16/02/10

      LOL.  Far point, I would have been happy if they said “Here’s $250M, but you have to cancel Home and Away”.  But if we can get that rubbish for free, why do we need to pay $250M for it?  Outrageous decision.

    • Glenn T. says:

      09:46am | 15/02/10

      The chickens come home to roost…......
      I always thought Conroy was a dill; this latest revelation confirms it!
      I also remain highly suspicious of his so-called Christian ethos~ leave it at the church door on your way out please senator; I don’t need you to deceide what I may or may not see on the internet!
      And while your’e at it stop banging on about ‘family values’, whatever they are…....

    • Harquebus says:

      09:48am | 15/02/10

      Religious nuts are not capable of making sane or rational decisions.

    • Luke says:

      09:54am | 15/02/10

      There were no restrictions put on them to spend it on local content, that is just the excuse the Rudd Government are using. They can spend it however they like. Ask Kevin Rudds mate Stokes, he’ll tell you I’m sure.

    • slugger says:

      09:59am | 15/02/10

      i would imagine that conroy is simply leveling up the playing field,and it seems to have worked judging by the howles of protest coming from news ltd.rupert is not happy,let the battle begin.

    • Hunter says:

      10:01am | 15/02/10

      What about the effect on the budget of the $250 million gift by Conroy & KRudd? One off decisions like this need to be funded. I thought the Labor mob said they were good economic managers? Where is the justification for the rebate? What does Labor get in return? I think I read somewhere that it is to help the broadcasters with the effect of teh global economic slowdown, if Labor is going to reimburse businesses for economic loss then could someone please let me know how to apply for my share. This dangerous lot need to be stopped.

    • Haggis says:

      10:36am | 15/02/10

      The myth of free-to-air?
      Meh!
      What is the total advertising revenue of the commercial stations?
      Where does it come from?
      From the producers/sellers of the products advertised.
      How do the advertisers pay for it?
      In the price of everything they sell.
      Who pays for it?
      The same schmucks who won’t rage against the $250 million of their tax money going to the commercials as cream.
      (Oh, and us schmucks also fund the ABC)
      Meh!

    • Nathan H says:

      10:25am | 15/02/10

      “If you only relied on the internet for your information you’d be under the impression this is the most important policy debate to ever take place in this country and Stephen Conroy is the devil. It’s not and he isn’t. “

      I do, it is, and yes, he really is the devil.

      Stephen Conroy believes the internet should/can be controlled as easily as ‘old media’. Us internet users realise how much better the internet is than old media. It allows an infinate number of views and information to be made avaliable, by anyone at any time. You only need to look at the flight from news papers to see why people hate old media. The web was the ONLY source for the exposition of the lies and crimes that we now call Climategate. Only the internet makes wikileaks possible. Only the internet lets chinese people (if theyre smart enough) find out about the Tianenmen Square massacre, or their own failed war against Vietnam.

      Stephen Conroy wants to create a filter that everyone is subject to, that no-one knows the contents of, and it’s aministration will be 100% opaqe. In short, someone in ACMA will be in charge of what we’re allowed to know, and we’re not even allowed to know what we’re not allowed to know. He’s is the most insidious enemy of free thought that this nation has encountered in a long time. Johnny’s Book banning was bad, but this is so much worse. He must be stopped, and he will be stopped. Kevin will not escape the consequences of his part in this either. Vote below the line people; that’s how you chuck out a senator.

    • Eggs 'n Bacon says:

      10:40am | 15/02/10

      Alwats good to hear another side of things; even from a Conroy staffer….......

    • papachango says:

      11:03am | 15/02/10

      I agree. This issue trumps all of Labor’s other mismanagement and incompetence. It is truly evil.

    • watty says:

      10:43am | 15/02/10

      A bit patricidal? The Father of Daleks killing off a favourite Dalek son??

    • Hermann from Clare says:

      10:49am | 15/02/10

      and don’t forget that by sheer coincidence Channel 7 retracted over the Chantelois affair just in time before the next SA elections. What a gift to the Labor Premier. ?????

    • CynicalGoatWA says:

      11:42am | 15/02/10

      Me thinks that there is a lot more water to flow under the bridge on this entire debacle. And now that the sycophants in the Canberra press gallery seem to at last be taking off the “Kev07” complimentary rose coloured glasses (and not before f*****g time), maybe this incompetent clown could at last be held to account for something of substance.

    • leonora says:

      01:46pm | 15/02/10

      Calm down, everybody.  Kruddman and his grub sidekick Conboy are going to save the children, so who could argue against that?

      Apart from the inconvenient fact that the filter won’t stop child porn, won’t stop grooming on social Net sites and won’t remove the need for parents to watch what their kids are doing online.

      What it will do is set up the means for a future govt to utilise scope creep to expand secret Net censorship to include opposing political views, and we’ll never know because it’s all a secret, with heavy fines for any disclosure.

      The filter bureaucracy will also cost a motza, slow the Net, and result in many websites being mistakenly blocked for spurious reasons.  Nice one, Kruddman and Conboy.

    • Phil says:

      02:05pm | 15/02/10

      Wonder who paid for his skiing trip?

      If it smells like s*&t, looks like s*&t and tastes like shit it usually stinks.

      He is on borrowed time. But why does this surprise me, labor is always saying one thing and doing the other.

      They appear to be for the worker, but as soon as in power they are corrupted by business and cant help but put their noses in the spoils of office.

      They then do deals with the same businesses they helped in power as soon as they leave. TNT Building in Canberra bought by R Hawke showing a 40+% net return when same did not go for auction.

    • Anthony says:

      02:21pm | 15/02/10

      Conroy and Rudd took one on those tough decisions for tough economic times. Should we go down the blue or black run? Should we give em 250 or 500million. Just goes to show that Stokes and big business are running the country. Rudd and Conroy are displaying principles worse than howard, at least howard vocalised his corrupt traits and was easier to read.

    • Not Pete from Sydney says:

      03:30pm | 15/02/10

      Given the Govt is looking to means test Medicare rebate etc to try to save money why are we handing back $250 million in revenue to a group made up of billionaires and foreign private equity groups

    • Nathan H says:

      03:37pm | 15/02/10

      Who’s a Conroy Staffer?

      Mate, if I was a Conroy Staffer, I’d eventually be known as Leaky MacLeakerson of Leakersville. I’d give the Libs EVERYTHING. I’d wear out the photocopiers and burn out all the USB ports. Alas, if only I were allowed into mount doom (his office), I would cast this filter back into the fires from whence(?) it came. Although, you would think one of his many younger staffers would have had the decency to do some leaking by now.

      P.S. Since the Lord of the Rings features a Human doing it with an Elf, that would technically be bestiality as they are from different species. Therefore, just like naughty simpsons pictures, it would be refused classification by one of the Orcs at ACMA, and the all seeing eye (filter) would have the ring wraiths (federal police) conducting a warrant-less search by the end of the day.

    • Grumbles says:

      04:34pm | 15/02/10

      Last week former Labor MP and power-broker Mike Kaiser was announced as head of public relations for the Government’s new NBN, a job that was not advertised and pays $450,000 a year.

      The BIGGEST question that needs to be asked is, why do we need a head of public relations for a wholly owned government subsidery?

    • Matt says:

      01:16pm | 16/02/10

      You’re right Grumbles, and the second biggest question is why does this Company and job exist when there is no business case for the whole NBN? Rudd and Conroy can’t even state if the whole thing is viable (which any first year accounting student can tell you it is not).

    • COF says:

      01:46pm | 16/02/10

      What I don’t get is why the ACMA filter has to be compulsory? Just put it online as an optional download and democracy is restored.

      Why is it so difficult for Conroy to be mature about this issue? He almost consistently refers to naysayers in a negative light, comparing them to the people who manage the sites he is seeking to ban. It seems that people cannot have principle without having a nasty agenda, according to Senator Conroy anyway. The arrogance!

      How can the content of the ACMA blacklist be independently reviewed if no one but the government can access the sites? Where is the fail safe?

      The entirely policy is poorly thought out, and immaturely put to the public. This issue is everything at the moment Leo, because it shows exactly how this government wants to govern, and it is not pretty.

    • Shane says:

      07:21am | 17/02/10

      Yup throw Conroy out he is as big as the rat that we call Rudd.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @adamroy37: Just received a phone call from a young girl apologizing for her actions. Lets support her please #racismitstopswithme#Indi

tory_maguire

RT @adamroy37: Just received a phone call from a young girl apologizing for her actions. Lets support her please #racismitstopswithme#Indi

Daniel Piotrowski

Australia. Where you die for your country and get a rest area named after you http://t.co/hO6LpfwDvI

ToryShepherd

@benpobjie @jessadamson7 @jhwakelin kinda creepy from a high school cheerleader #misheardlyrics

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter