In Adelaide we worry a lot. A mall, trams, grandstands, hospitals even roundabouts cause hours of debate. However, nothing winds us up more than someone criticising our city. We’re so defensive.

Artist's impression of Adelaide having a bit of life zapped into the joint.

Sometimes I think we get so outraged because secretly we worry that Adelaide may actually be a backwater.

Often the “solution” that is put forward is to build an iconic building such as a tower or a fantastic or unusual museum. These are all great ideas – we should build more unusual and more controversial buildings. Interesting buildings give a city character. I like buildings that have gardens down the side and on the roof. It would be great to see some of them.

But we shouldn’t build them and expect people to come to see them thus solving all our problems. It won’t work. Let me give you an example. Would you go to Taipei? It’s the home of Taipei 101 the world’s tallest building. It’s a great building in a great city but Taipei’s not an international tourist mecca.

Iconic buildings of themselves are not enough. What lures visitors is other visitors saying, “You have to go there. I loved it. I want to go back.” That means we need to make Adelaide an experience people want rather than a place where there are interesting buildings.

For this to happen, we need to do three things. Firstly, all of us need to make a conscious decision that we want Adelaide to be a place that people want to visit and enjoy being here so much that they want to come back.

Secondly, we need an attitude change. We are too negative and the idea of change really freaks us out. Our attitude needs to be, “What do we have to do to make this work?” It’s time we all changed the way we think and talk.

Lastly, we need to build on our strengths. For instance, we have great food and wine in South Australia we could start there. Eating is so important to humans both for our health as well as socially. So it stands to reason that if we do food really well, it will stand out in the minds of our visitors. But I mean world’s best. Not better or just good.

A couple of years ago, Tina and I were lucky enough to go to France for a 9 years late honeymoon. I have so many great memories of that trip but one of my favourites is a meal we had in a village close to the Villers-Bretonneux War Memorial. It was a small restaurant in a small town. The restaurant had been awarded one Michelin star.

The Michelin star system is a rating system for restaurants that originated in France. The top rating is three stars but it’s hard to get just one. Tina and I still talk about that meal and we want to go back.

We could either adopt the Michelin system here or devise our own but it has to be hard and we need to consider making it compulsory in some way. I think that we should go for Australia’s first Michelin star. We could start with the city centre and work our way out.

Our wine is great too. It’s a different style to the French wines but we are really good at making the wines that we make, especially the Shiraz, so our wine regions need to be part of our plan. We need to raise the quality of our wine to such an extent that South Australian regions become the world wide bench mark for at least a couple of varieties.

Coffee’s another thing. We could become a state of baristas, not just coffee makers. People should be able to get around SA without ever having a bad coffee. For that matter we could take Tea more seriously as well.

To some extent we are already doing these things but this is my idea for the next step and it will help develop an Adelaide experience.

Small regional economies and cities tend to try to do a little bit of everything and end up doing not much really well. We should concentrate on a few things and do them exceptionally.

Adelaide is a great place. Let’s just accept that. Let’s just be Adelaide and try to make it even better. And let’s have the courage to really think it through and carry it out.

Most commented

17 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Chad says:

      09:18am | 25/08/09

      Great call, it all starts with the eradication of the Adelaide City Coucil, if anyone would like to start a petition i’d be more than happy to sign…

      Lets get it started, petition time, get rid of the ACC

    • Barbara Flowers says:

      09:35am | 25/08/09

      I’m a frequent visitor to Adelaide lately, from Brisbane.  It would be hard to find a more contrasting pair of cities.  Adelaide is like a dear old aunt still living on in her colonial homestead in her 90s and keeping the anti-macassars spotless.  And Brisbane is your yobbo cousin from Ipswich, overweight from a diet of beer and pizza, and aggressive with it.  Being unfit and badly fed does that to you.  When I said how much I liked Adelaide to my daughter her (Gen Y) response was: “That’s because you’re old.” Perhaps I’m not officially ‘old’ yet, but old people like the calm of Adelaide and lack of monster traffic jams and road-rage thugs (I’m reminiscing about my home city here), the wonderful food and beautiful old colonial buildings.  I like being near the Southern ocean, and the sense of being close to things that are ancient and mysterious.  But I do miss the frontier politics of Queensland when I’m away.  The scandals are almost as good as those from NSW.  SA - buck up.  Your nightly news is TAME, that’s what you have to work on.

    • Noah Young says:

      10:35am | 25/08/09

      Well said, Tom. We need to be bold in pushing Adelaide’s strengths to the world. Great to see a politician with some vision and positive ideas.

    • ShaneO says:

      10:36am | 25/08/09

      Delete ‘Adelaide’ and insert ‘Perth’ and the meaning of this piece would not change one iota!

    • Matt Ryan says:

      11:09am | 25/08/09

      Couldn’t agree more Tom. The furore over one bad review of Cheong Liew and the Grange looked set to ignite a civil war between Adelaide and the entire eastern seaboard. It is ridiculous that it generated more reader/listener feedback than most other issues.
      You can walk down Rundle Mall and you will know whether the Crows have won or lost just by the feel of the place.
      Adelaide needs to move on from the whole Balfours/ Iced Coffee/Fruchocs thing and embrace the laid back feel of the place and before you know it, that will be what makes people want to go to Adelaide.

    • Justin Turner says:

      11:33am | 25/08/09

      What Adelaide & greater South Australia (& SA companies) needs are more slogans, because clearly there aren’t enough.

      Proudly South Australian, Adelaide’s own, SA’s own, the wine state, the festival state, the defence state, the city of churches, the gateway to the outback, the rose state, the creative state, a brilliant blend, a thousand secrets, SA great, proudly Australian - more so McLaren Vale, Sensational Adelaide, SA - great place to live and work.

      Clearly not enough.

    • Ash Simmonds says:

      11:42am | 25/08/09

      I don’t think “change” and “progress” for the sake of it is worthwhile - why can’t a place be considered “finished”?  If you want constant new stuff - why not go somewhere that has that? 

      I spend plenty of time in the other capitals, it’s kinda fun having not been somewhere for a month or two and seeing new stuff that wasn’t there before, but that feeling disappears within a minute or so.

      What’s the big push to get a constant stream of visitors and increase the population - again, there’s already plenty of places to go live if you want to be part of that.

      What I agree with from your article is that instead of increasing, we should be improving.  I’m not talking about new monoliths or things to make Adelaide feel more modern, I mean increase the standard of what we have, like you say - the food, the wine… facilities, parks, infrastructure.

      I don’t think we need to be doing this to get people from yonder coming to check stuff out, we need it done to get people already here more inspired to leave the house.

    • Adrian says:

      11:57am | 25/08/09

      “We could either adopt the Michelin system here or devise our own but it has to be hard and we need to consider making it compulsory in some way.”

      You can’t adopt the Michelin system because it’s a private company and they wouldn’t bother producing a guide for Adelaide because the market for it would be so small.
      Any style of restaurant ratings would have to be completely independent of any government office, so would have to be a private group. In Melbourne and Sydney Fairfax produces the Good Food Guides. Perhaps in Adelaide some entrepreneur could try something similar.

      The single best thing a lot of people in Adelaide could do to get over their insecurities is leave and live somewhere bigger for a while. And then you’d realise it just doesn’t matter because there’s no way Adelaide can ever compete with a city like Sydney, Tokyo, London or even (dare I say it?) Melbourne.

    • Tony says:

      12:20pm | 25/08/09

      I spent most of my life in Adelaide, but now live in Brisbane. My wife is from Brisbane and she hated the quiet of Adelaide when we lived there. We both loved the food and wine, however, and miss it in Queensland because no one here knows what good food is. We used to drive long distances, to places like the Lyndoch Bakery and The Corio Pub at Goolwa, just for the food. Yum!

    • Dan from Adelaide says:

      12:40pm | 25/08/09

      I returned to Adelaide after living in Sydney and Hong Kong for 14 years. I am biased but I love the place. I equally love Sydney and get back there regularly whether for work or catching up with mates. For me Adelaide has a great lifestyle - Mediterranean climate, great restaurants, top wineries, clean beaches and in “Mad March” (which unofficially runs Jan - Apr) the place goes off with the Tour Down Under, Festival, Fringe, WOMAD, Clipsal 500, Adelaide Cup and Oakbank Easter Racing Carnival in the hills. I live 5 mins walk from the beach and cafe strip at Glenelg and couldn’t possibly afford to have the same in Sydney on my salary. In summer I’m home by 6 and playing petanque on the beach with a ball in one hand a glass of Clare Valley Riesling in the other. With the cost of living so good here, we can afford to fly back to SYD regularly and the airport’s only 10mins from my house and 10 mins from the city. So from our point of view, we’ve got the best of both worlds. Come to Adelaide, don’t come to Adelaide - it doesn’t matter but every one of our interstate and o/s friends who’ve stayed with us for a weekend here have totally changed their perceptions on the place. I can only describe my experience but you’ll have to see for yourself. If you do, come in March. And I don’t work for the SA Tourism Commission.

    • stephen says:

      12:55pm | 25/08/09

      Not so much Adalaide, but South Australia itself. It has the prettiest countryside of all Aussie, and really should be the focus of adv. campaign.

    • Liza ex-Adelaide says:

      02:21pm | 25/08/09

      I love the whole Balfours/Iced Coffee/Fruchocs thing. I also the love the Beerenberg/Golden Chicken/kitchener bun thing. I live in Sydney these days but great weather and a pretty impressive harbour aside, what’s so specifically Sydney like these Adelaide favourites? Maybe Adelaide is that city with a face only a mother could love but if people aren’t in on its many secrets, it’s their loss.

    • Dave says:

      04:44pm | 25/08/09

      A chip on the shoulder is a good thing. It stopped the SANFL getting pushed around by the VFLand gave us the hilltop hoods and cold chisel. South Australians have an edge to them which helps them in the big wide world.

    • Davo from St Kilda says:

      10:21pm | 25/08/09

      Don’t worry, Adelaide, about the attitudes of other state capitals. Here in Melbourne we hear a never ending stream of abuse and insults from people who live in Sydney and we just laugh at their insecurity and their need to put others down in order to feel better about themselves! Adelaide is a GREAT city with the most beautiful cricket ground in the world! Anyone who puts you down is actually jealous, so wear the criticism as a badge of pride.

    • AMJ says:

      07:23am | 26/08/09

      I grew up in Adelaide and I’ve got to say that the chip-on-the-shoulder thing is pretty accurate. I’ve lived in lots of cities around the world but everytime I go home it seems Adelaide is trying harder still to be Melbourne. It’s not going to happen!
      It’s a shame because we have the best wine and probably close to the best food, but still we’re pre-occupied with comparing ourselves to others.
      Every time I watch the Adelaide news I cringe with perochial nausea!
      Lets compare Adleaide with say…Hobart. (You see, as an Adelaidian at heart I can’t help but compare it to other cities!!) Both cities have great food and wine and are located close to but removed from the eastern seaboard, but in Hobart I sense that they’re perfectly comfortable with being a small, quirky place because who cares what others think? Yes it’s cold, but what a veiw!
      So PLEASE adelaide, just be yourself and dont listen when the eastern states bullies run you down. Eat, drink and be merry!

    • PJD says:

      09:41am | 26/08/09

      My Father, a proud fourth generation South Australian, used to say that the Eastern states, still could not cope with fact that their cities were settled with convicts and Adelaide was settled with free settlers!  I think it is they who have the ‘chip on the shoulder’ and are continually putting South Australia down.  I have visited all the capital cities in Australia and lived in Brisbane and overseas, and agree Adelaide has the best lifestyle and climate.
      But we do have a very big problem competing with the Eastern states regarding overseas visitors, especially where our own carrier (Qantas) is concerned.

    • Diana says:

      07:52pm | 30/09/09

      Truthfully as lovely as Adelaide is it isn’t lacking change or a Michelian star, Adelaide is lacking in history. Adelaide is lacking in small dingey little coffee shops, twisting alleys, ruins, urban legends and old buildings. Everything in Adelaide is either just over one hundred years old or new, the really interesting parts of the city are overlooked because everything is always being renewed and rebuilt. Believe me, there is nothing more facinating than reading head stones in a pioneer graveyard, spending hours browsing books in a tiny lightless shop, drinking coffee in a quiet square or exploring the remains of a once grand building. Although the food in South Australia is very enjoyable. There is one very nice little place in the hills called Maximilians, just lovely.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

.@maxbaumann I'm sure they can on some issues, but you'd have to be a hypocrite to legalise something you think is a sin...

ToryShepherd

@ThatDamonGuy Not to mention the Catholic Church and associated institutions....

ToryShepherd

@Bogans_Heroes @samsonjbutler not black and white separation. Tricky as mastering a Metallica chord. (Not actually sure how tricky that is)

ToryShepherd

.@JacobLeigh @samsonjbutler Agree re evidence and reason. So question is: can we believe people who say they'll put religion aside?

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter