When we were kids, the geeks played their pathetic little fantasy games in the corner of the playground, while the sporty dudes ran around, dated hot girls and sneered at the geeks. And lo, all was good and right in the universe.

Apparently this is really interesting

Today, the geeks earn three times what anyone else earns, while the cool people have become the spotty recluses who play so-called “fantasy” football games. Many people think these games are cool and interesting. They’re wrong.

For the uninitiated, fantasy sports games are a season-long undertaking where you pick your own “team” comprised of players sourced from numerous clubs. You then swap your players around weekly, aiming to reap more points from the ridiculously complicated scoring system than everyone else. Pass the Nodoz, I say.

Let me offer some perspective here. There is a trend in online opinion pieces to blow deliberately against the wind. Australia loves MasterChef, attention-seeking hack says they hate it. Angry Birds goes viral, smartarse writer says it’s a pale shadow of Plants vs Zombies (which by the way, it is).

This is not that kind of piece. This is no argument for argument’s sake. This is an article that cuts to the heart of everything that’s wrong with modern life and modern sport and pretty much modern everything. Let’s break it down:

1. Fantasy sports games are dull
Building your fantasy team is like doing the weekly footy tipping, only infinitely more complicated. It is like buying an expensive yoghurt machine so you can sit around all day and watch the culture grow, when you could go to the supermarket and achieve the same result in a quarter of the time for a fraction of the cost. What’s wrong with good old footy tipping, anyway?

2. Fantasy games suck the life out of the way we enjoy sport
Nobody likes corporate jargon. But fantasy games have introduced a whole dictionary of meaningless gobbledygook into sports speak. Look at this clip, which is one of 100 I could have linked. Apparently some NRL dude is a good buy because he’s averaging 70. Seventy what? I don’t care. When I assess the worth of a football player, I want to know if they tackle hard and run into gaps. We might as well replace the whole English language with ones and zeroes.

3. Um, life, people
See, I have this thing called a job. And I have this person in my life called my wife. And these other vaguely humanoid creatures called kids. And friends. And they demand, nay, deserve my time. As does the lawn, and the washing up. I also engage in leisure activities occasionally. Unsurprisingly, all of the above leaves no time to contemplate whether Nick or Jack Riewoldt is likely to accrue more “hard ball gets”. (OK, so it’s probably Jack)

Anyway, that’s it. Clearly, if you enjoy playing fantasy sports games you care nothing for those around you. You are a tailgating driver on the road of life. You are the Chokito that’s left dangling in the vending machine after the machine has gulped your last two dollars.

How to end this piece? Well, the traditional method would be to flip the argument on its head at the end. “Oh, but you know what? I kind of just happened to catch MasterChef on telly last night and I actually sympathised with the surfer dude who couldn’t cook a sabayon to save his life…”

There will be no such back flip in this piece. That means I need an ending. So let me opt for the following angle:

The angle is to plead for my job on hands and knees. See, fantasy sports games drive all kinds of crazy traffic to the very mastheads that employ me and many other online journalists in Australia. The suits look very, very kindly upon people who play and promote these games. People who knock them, not so much.

Indeed, the suits themselves play fantasy games with enormous relish, presumably because reducing everything to numbers and jargon is precisely what they’re really good at.

Now, excuse me while I pop off to get some serious carpet burn…

Most commented

61 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Gary Cox says:

      06:46am | 24/06/11

      Agreed, couldn’t think of a better way to waste you’re life away than spend a Saturday afternoon on a video game. I actually think the same about people who go to the movies, surf the net and hang out at shopping malls during daylight hours.

    • Tom says:

      08:41am | 24/06/11

      Great article. These dipsticks have lost sight of the essentials in life. Footy is for kids in the backyard and then on Saturday afternoons for fathers and sons to cheer their locals.

    • acotrel says:

      08:57am | 24/06/11

      It appears that many people are becoming less interested in participation these days .  Some of us have in the past, built our own racing motorcycles, and competed on the bitumen.  The sport of motorcycle road racing seems to be in it’s death throes.  It seems that youngsters are much more intent on playing computer games than getting involved with reality?

    • CH says:

      08:58am | 24/06/11

      @Tom.. “Footy is for kids in the backyard and then on Saturday afternoons for fathers and sons to cheer their locals.”..

      can I add “.. and then when the kids have gone to bed I can check my fantasy score” and still be a good person?

    • Arnold Layne says:

      09:23am | 24/06/11

      @CH - Agreed.  It’s the main reason the fantasy league I play is on the English Premier League, cos I look after my team after the kids have gone to bed.

      There’s no reason you can’t get out and watch your kids play (I do), play All Age or Over 35s as well (I do) and still enter a fantasy comp.  It also has no impact on supporting your team through thick and thin.  Why does everything have to be broken down into black and white by so many posters on this site, no matter what the topic is?

    • chungo mung says:

      09:58am | 24/06/11

      love your piece Sharwood, you are nailing it on the head. Ch and Arnold, it is balanced folks like you that he is definitely not referring to, it is the wallies that live in obsession land and distraction land and avoidance land that he burns, aa well as the love of numbers to define reality (bloody statistics and polls and b.s).

    • Tom says:

      12:22pm | 24/06/11

      CH, Arnold. Yes guys, you have my permission to check your score. As Chungo Bungo would admonish, don’t let it become your main game.

      PS: Talking about forgetting the main games, why is our media so obsessed about off-field stuff?

    • Gregg says:

      07:12am | 24/06/11

      Ant,
      Get your Yo yo out and show them the trick of walking the dog across the carpet.

    • Dave-o says:

      08:03am | 24/06/11

      Sorry, I didn’t have time to read this as between the weekly bye and soft suspensions I’m rotating on average 6 players a round. So I’m just going to go ahead and assume that your in support of Dream teams and all they represent.

    • CH says:

      08:10am | 24/06/11

      This article was an entertaining read, if only for the passion in your hate for fantasy football! But as a fan of fantasy football myself (specifically the AFL’s official fantasy game), allow me to offer a couple of quick rebuttals..

      a) The scoring isn’t complicated. 3 point for a kick, 2 for a handball etc.. pretty basic stuff.
      b) There is no great joy like beating your mates score and earning bragging rights for the week.
      c) Fantasy football actually gets me more involved in the sport I love.
      d) My family, friends, job, and the 2 “real” sports I play seem thus far largely unaffected.
      I suggest Anthony you need to work on your time management skills

    • Macca says:

      08:57am | 24/06/11

      @CH, agreed. In fact the debates and conversations that can be had over fantasy football are probably the only reason I am interesed in them.

      Sharwood, I’m not angry at you for this post, just disappointed.

    • acotrel says:

      09:09am | 24/06/11

      @CH What’s the score for returning a positive result for a drug test?

    • CH says:

      09:34am | 24/06/11

      @acotrel.. is the answer “high”?

    • acotrel says:

      09:56am | 24/06/11

      @CH ‘High’ is irrelevant, we’re all about ‘zero tolerance’
      these days!

    • Shifter says:

      12:00pm | 24/06/11

      Nothing like a DT icebreaker at a party. If you overhear some complaining about Mundy then Bartel you know you’re in.

    • TChong says:

      08:12am | 24/06/11

      These type of “fantasy games"sux.
      Any one with a love of the AFL or ARL, even ARU ( soccer doesnt rate anywhere , anytime) gets out there and heads to the game(s) , or at least watch on the telly with friends and family.
      Fair Dinkum fans follow the clubs thru defeats and victory, thick and thin , good times and bad.
      Forget god based religions, just believe in the One True Faith ,headed by - Maxwell, Malthouse and ( even ) Maguire.
      They’ll show us how to play the game.

    • Bilby says:

      06:22pm | 24/06/11

      Why not do it all? I’m in tipping comps for Aussie rules and league, and I have an Aussie rules dream team, I’ve recently retired from coaching juniors AND I’ll be at the ground tomorrow night to see the ‘pies fold like a cheap suit. (It’s been 6 long years of very quiet bus trips home but this year ... this year is the one.)

      P.S. Having a small wager riding on my tipping and dream team helps keep it all interesting too.

    • Chris says:

      09:26pm | 24/06/11

      what has ratings got to do with anything ??

    • JK says:

      08:32am | 24/06/11

      Ant i have one this year something to do with our coaching co-ordinator trying to get all our club coaches to have soemthing more in common or soemthign i dunno he talks a lot of crap anyways i have just rotated soem players and was wondering if you think i should trade andrejs everitt this week as he will more then likely end up as the sub anyway and if i do trade him who do you think would be a good alternative? i was thinking maybe matt maguire from Brisbane seems there will be alot of ball in their back half this week. Anyways jsut soemthing to think about oh and also with a fantasy team that i update every friday morning while doing my tips i also have time for 45hours of work a week, trainign two nights a week, coaching two nights a week spending time with friends as well as playing friday nights coachign sundays and assisting our other senior teams on a saturday so yes time management is a great thing.

      Lastly Get on the swannies need to rebound and get over that black and white mob.

    • MD says:

      09:03am | 24/06/11

      I thought we were beyond this ‘games are for people with no life’ tripe, be it fantasy sports or video games.

    • Tim says:

      09:04am | 24/06/11

      Top Rant,
      8/10.
      Would read again.

    • Brendan says:

      09:07am | 24/06/11

      I love this article for what it says about the author.

      He seems to have really enjoyed despising the geeks at school.  Now the geeks are all grown up and out earn him while he is trapped in a dying industry, its no longer fun to reflect on their relative position in the social order. 

      So our friend seemlessly turns his anger on fantasy sports, a game that has done him no more harm that the Dungeons & Dragons players of yester year.

      Now I’m no clinical psycologist, but can I venture that the need to attack things he has no interest in shows the slightly stunted emotional development?

    • Tchom says:

      09:47am | 24/06/11

      @ Brendan

      Seconded. The “get a life” argument is very junior high school. Everyone needs to unwind somehow. Some people go to the gym, some people do suduko, some people watch Masterchef and some people play games. If you lack the imagination to the play games, don’t blame the people who do.

    • Anthony Sharwood

      Anthony Sharwood says:

      10:24am | 24/06/11

      No to the dying industry thing.

      No to the fact i despised geeks at school, for I was indeed said creature

      Yes my emotional development is stunted.

      One outa three ain’t bad Brendan

    • Troy Flynn says:

      04:51pm | 24/06/11

      I think Brendan was referring to the death of “print” media. I would be surprised if circulation figures weren’t on a downward spiral. I only still buy the paper so that I can jot down my own comments to a particular story or article that I feel strongly about, but know won’t get published on the website. I actually find it a cathardic way of expressing my feelings without the worry of offending anybody.
      And I was one of those geeks who played D&D, watched movies etc and wanted NOTHING to do with the footy drop-kicks. But I did play Championship Manager 1992 (English Premier League Sim).

    • lawrose says:

      09:42am | 24/06/11

      My dad played Rugby League (as in, on an actualy field)  for most for 12 years of his life and is now in his 50s and he works 14 hour days (shift work). There is nothing remotely pathetic about him playing fantasy NRL. It is his way of unwinding and allows him to interact with other people passionate with the game. What is so wrong with that?
      It seems you need to get a life my friend.

    • lawrose says:

      09:56am | 24/06/11

      Oops, a few mistakes in that post. Note to self - don’t reply to articles on Punch while still irate.

    • Shane* says:

      11:02am | 24/06/11

      It’s a bit pathetic. After all, it’s rugby league. Worthless game.

    • Sara Something says:

      09:55am | 24/06/11

      Now, those geeks you sneered still play fantasy games (though they wouldn’t be caught dead with fantasy football), but earn three times what you do and date hot girls as well. And lo, all is good and right in the universe once again.

    • sid says:

      10:00am | 24/06/11

      Ummmmm I have a love hate relationship with Fantasy football. Week by week I love it or I hate it . The AFL fantasy football requires endless hours of checking who injured whos the new rookie, who playing what and with 18 players plus subs. It a time killer.

      Fantasy Football EPL and A-League only has the 11 players and it not as hard. About 5 years ago the EPL gave 2 tickets and flights, accomdation and to the FA Cup. Problem is 3 million people world wide play the game.

      But its a great way to keep in touch with whos who and who is doing well or poorly.

    • Katie says:

      10:03am | 24/06/11

      The reason you’re so angry at ‘fantasy’ games is that, clearly, you’re playing the wrong sort of games.

      Yes, for sport, go out and play it yourself.

      Your bagging on us geeks and our ‘fantasy’ games, however, is largely unwarrented… and by the way, I say this as someone who can manage my full-time job, my friends and my husband yet still get some gaming hours in.

      Noob. Go mow your lawn.

    • Brendan says:

      10:24am | 24/06/11

      Awesome post…give this girl a sock and a handful of 20c pieces smile

    • Shenanigans says:

      10:41am | 24/06/11

      Noob is just raging because they fail.

      Power to the gamers!!!

      beware the nyan cat….

    • Amazed says:

      10:06am | 24/06/11

      So don’t play it ya sook.

      Also, I have hair, so nyeah, nyeah!

      See, your not the only one who can act the child.

    • Matt F says:

      10:25am | 24/06/11

      i’m detecting some biterness in this article. you weren’t one of those people who spent 10x longer on his team then everyone else, thought of nothing else all week (including boring your mates to tears asking and giving unwanted advice all week) only to finish last every year without fail were you?

    • Luce says:

      10:58am | 24/06/11

      That sounds like it would take up way too much time.

    • Sheldon says:

      10:26am | 24/06/11

      If it doesn’t invovle a 8 sided dice its not a true fantasy game.

      Rock on D&D

    • Seanr says:

      10:53am | 24/06/11

      LOL Sheldon, I would clarify your post by saying ‘Rock on D&D..upto but excluding version 4.0..”

    • St. Michael says:

      11:32am | 24/06/11

      Thank Christ, I thought I was the only one who disliked fourth edition.

      As a net commentator once said: “In 3.5 you make your character and play D&D.  In 4.0 WOTC makes your character for you and permits you to play D&D.”

    • Seanr says:

      01:09pm | 24/06/11

      I’ll sound like a snob but fourth edition is ‘DnD for dummies’ in my view St M.

    • St. Michael says:

      01:26pm | 24/06/11

      It’s not snobbery if it’s the truth. raspberry

      Still, maybe they were just trying to make DMs feel better by cutting away all those gamebreaking character builds: the Mailman, Chuck E. Cheese, the Cheater of Mystra, or even Pun-Pun… ahhh, good times.

    • Direct says:

      02:11pm | 24/06/11

      If you’re not calculating THAC0 yourself, then you’re playing D&D for Dummies.

    • St. Michael says:

      04:00pm | 24/06/11

      Ahhh, I love Edition Wars… smile

    • Troy Flynn says:

      05:40pm | 24/06/11

      Personally , I miss “Gamma World”, but at least Bethesda’s Fallout series is a perfect substitute.

    • St. Michael says:

      11:41pm | 24/06/11

      These young ‘uns and their fancy Fallout series.  Back in my day it wuz all Pool of Radiance and Wasteland on the Commodore 64…

    • Chris L says:

      10:47am | 25/06/11

      @Direct I disagree. I mastered the rules for AD&D 2nd Ed but still prefer 3rd Edition (3.5). I do agree with the others about 4th Ed. It’s like they tried to turn WOW into a paper & dice game, and I didn’t like WOW in the first place.

      Anthony, an article about hating on a group of people for having different tastes to you? Yep, the act of a true sportsman. Ah the memories of highschool torment….

    • Dan says:

      10:46am | 24/06/11

      I know what your problem is - you don’t have Pendlebury in your mid-field.

      Slightly more concerning is that you have Gary Ablett. In a Geelong guernsey.

    • Timmah says:

      11:17am | 24/06/11

      The picture is obviously from last season - Bock and GAJ not in GCS colours, and Dustin Martin at that price is an absolute steal!

      I do get what the article is saying though, since joining Dream Team, it has sucked the fun out of watching footy, when I watch a game all I am watching/listening for is Pendles to get another possession or score a goal. The only reason why I know some of the rookies is because they are good “downgrade” targets.
      I know it raises interest in the sport, especially if you have a league with mates in, but it also takes the “love” out of the sport, it just becomes all about the stats. It’s a bit of a double edged sword in some respects.

      Oh, and I bet the reasons behind this article was because he was equally pissed off after last weeks shenanigans in DT, as it was a terrible week for a lot of teams. I know personally, I lost the unlosable game, even with GAJ as captain, and received a large amount of stick from mates as a result!

    • Shifter says:

      11:58am | 24/06/11

      Ant, you’re just jealous I’m beating you in the footy tipping.

    • Damo says:

      12:48pm | 24/06/11

      I agree I wasted so much time on Fantasy Football, with all that additional time I am able to get into Fantasy Surfing, also it would be wise to have Mick Fanning in your team for J-Bay, he loves a nice long right hand point break.

    • Daev says:

      01:52pm | 24/06/11

      I see you have Nathan Bock playing for Adelaide, you should get a more up to date team, Skipper isnt playing anymore and Dangerfield in the mids, what are you thinking???

    • James says:

      02:22pm | 24/06/11

      Ummmm…now for a bit of perspective. Fantasy football is a bit of a diversion for a man- an alternative to the shed. I’ll bet I’ve got a larger family (4 kids) and a busier life than the author - yet somehow I find time for a drink or a game of golf - yes even Fantasy Football.

      There is something seriously wrong with people that lose all perspective about these things - like the author of this article who is seriously creepy in his rage about a few guys who take five minutes out of their week to play an online game.  The alternative is people that spend half their week on fantasy football - they have similarly lost all perspective and are equally creepy.

      Neither has the right to feel supercilious because both are just plain weird.  Maybe he’s just still mad at the jocks that gave him a wedgie as a kid.  It sounds like it.

      An alternative explanation for this article is that the author gets paid per word and was looking for a bit of extra money before the weekend.  I hope that was the case - for his sake.

    • Kate says:

      02:45pm | 24/06/11

      My boyfriend plays footy. 90% of the guys on his team also play fantasy football. They aren’t mutually exclusive.
      I love Supercoach, it’s a fun way to get more out of footy games you normally wouldn’t care about (seriously, anything that makes Freo v Port Adelaide watchable is fine by me). I don’t take it far enough that I barrack against my own team for SC reasons though, that is just wrong.

    • Alexander says:

      02:54pm | 24/06/11

      Oh Dear Me.
      You so have the wrong end of the stick here.  Fantasy Futboll is a tool to get the mindelss masses practising thier Mathematics.  Just the same as the stupid athletes at school could not handle mathematics in class, but could accurtately calculate the percentages on the ladder based on the scores.
      You are attempting to destroy one of the greatest educational tools delivered to man in the last century, please stop.

      PS:
      And for the love of all things holy, please dont tell them it’s Educational.

    • Jason says:

      03:47pm | 24/06/11

      My 11 year old son is quite obsessed with Super Coach. During games he is constantly checking the performance of his players (and giving me a running commentary (sigh).

      What I find interesting about the whole thing is the total change in how the game is supported. In the old days you supported your team, against all others. Now you can pick players from any team, the player has become more important, my son and many of his friends no longer really care about the performance of their chosen teams, only the number of points accumulated by the players he has on his list.

      If I were in football administration I would be concerned about this growing trend.

    • Lesley Laurel says:

      09:50pm | 24/06/11

      For those who want to die instantly,Murder, Assasination, Euthanasia,abortion and Assisted Suicide,  are illegal.
      Try going to war in the Middle east with the army, the navy and the air force.
      Or get admitted to the latest detention centre,jail, mental asylum, nursing home, marriage bureau and school.

    • stephen says:

      10:02pm | 24/06/11

      But it is not active.
      Only today I read in the newspaper that ‘virtual exercize’ according to a medical doctor is as good as real exercize. So you can watch a video, dance to the music, and that will make you fit.
      Now apparently this has been going on for ages which is why on trains, buses, cars and on the footpaths there are so many interesting people, healthy, and ready to start or at least respond to conversation.
      And it’s why private school kids are told that if you don’t make it by 25, you are are lost, e.g. there is nothing good for you, because character and an active life plus experience counts for nothing, which is why the every damned ‘artist’ I know will not make it, but be up the duff living in a 3 bedroom brick veneer in Aspley with jeff, who’s got a jet-ski.
      Get real, or get out.
      And if you wanna change the world, pirate movies just won’t do it.

    • Stuart says:

      10:44am | 25/06/11

      Video games are fot the brain dead of society,these drop outs are the most boring people on the planet,they need to get out and get a real life if they are still able to.

    • Alicia says:

      09:11pm | 25/06/11

      Oh, piss off.

    • Chris L says:

      07:52pm | 26/06/11

      Stuart’s right! We should all get out, booze up and get into fights!

    • Ash says:

      01:08pm | 30/06/11

      You are just angry cause your team is rubbish…

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

David Penberthy

@michelangeloruc not at all mate it is a great story and photo

tory_maguire

@nswpolice very polite and helpful officers manning the Pyrmont road closures this morning

David Penberthy

@KevCorduroy @SallyHitchiner it's a great idea I doubt he'd go for it though far too laid back

ToryShepherd

. @mcguiremi is journo of the year! #samediaawards

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter