I’m an orphan. My mum committed suicide when I was seven and my dad had a heart-attack when I was 16.

Getting child protection right will never be easy. But we have to try.

Thankfully, I wasn’t living with either of them at the time. I was removed from my mother’s care at age five and my relationship with my father was estranged since before I could remember.

The very first night I spent in a foster home I was bullied.

I wanted to eat porridge and despite being five years old, my new foster sister told me porridge was for little babies and I was one of them. Fortunately she was only a temporary sister and I haven’t seen her since.

Mine is by no means the worst story on the books. I wasn’t abused or severely neglected like many children in the care of state agencies like the Department of Community Services in NSW.

Over the years I met and lived with a lot of kids who endured unimaginable circumstances. My many foster sisters and brothers often shared with me their heartbreaking stories. Cases where parents had beaten them, taken hard drugs in front of them and sometimes even sexually abused them.

At 15, I remember crying myself to sleep worrying about my future - then realising there were three other kids in the same house as me who were a lot worse off.

I’m now in my twenties, have completed high school, been to university and am living my dream career.

At times it has been really, really hard. But in the end I made it through what is unquestionably an out-of-touch and over-stretched child welfare system.

Almost everyone has an opinion on how we can fix our current system. It is so clearly broken.

We see politicians like Mark Arbib on The Punch rallying for early intervention and more community support.

We see social commentators and activist groups calling for more reporting on the issues that are often vastly under-reported in care.

I don’t have all the answers, and I’m not going to pretend I do. But I’ve lived through the system. I’ve seen it from the inside, and I know what helped me get to a point where I can be here today, writing this.

I was in kinship care with my grandparents for most of my infant years. At 14, I was placed back in out-of-home care. My grandparents and I were fighting all the time and the situation was explosive for all parties involved. This was one of the hardest times for me, and the time I needed help the most.

Most of my years in out-of-home care were spent with the support of a non-government agency called The Burdekin Association.

Burdekin gave me one of the best caseworkers in the world. Someone who spent time every week with me, and was always there to help when I needed a guiding voice.

She made a real difference in my life and I believe she was able to do this in part because the case loads for agency workers are often a lot lighter than their DoCS equivalents. These organisations often target a smaller area of the community and as a result there are fewer children to spread their time across.

These are the organisations that should be given more assistance and recognition from both the Government and the community.

Often kids in care just need the right emotional support and guidance in order to turn their lives around. Smaller community-based agencies can and do provide this level of support better than DoCS.

This was my reality. My DoCS caseworker touched base with me on average once every three months. My Burdekin caseworker was there every week. In a troubled life, this can make all the difference.

There is a current push by the Government to move more support services out to agencies like Barnardos, Anglicare and Burdekin to ease the pressure on DoCS and other Government agencies.

This is great news. But it’s no substitute for the job DoCS has and simply shoving extra work in the direction of others agencies isn’t a long-term solution.

Teenagers requiring out-of-home care is too often a sidelined issue. Teenagers are difficult to place and it’s more difficult to find funding as it is mainly aimed at smaller children.

Society tends to blame them for their dysfunctional behaviour when they reach adolescence. The emphasis switches from protecting them to getting them to take responsibility for themselves.

This is also where Burdekin and lead agencies are unique. They catch the teenagers who probably wouldn’t be picked up by an already over-burdened system. This is why they deserve more support.

At the risk of sounding all “let’s hold hands and be friends” – DoCS, communities and external agencies need to work together more to bring about real change in the system. There needs to be fluid lines of communication between each of the parties involved in shaping our welfare system. This is something that doesn’t happen enough.

Individuals need to personally get more involved with non-government organisations. They are community-based so it’s a lot easier to support fundraisers and lend a hand.

Even simply making a donation could make the world of difference. There needs to be more awareness around this.

Some people say there will never be a perfect child protection system.

Of course there will never be a completely perfect system, but if we don’t aim for it, how can we ever say we’ve done the right thing by children in care?

I survived. I was one of the lucky ones. But I shouldn’t have to be.

29 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Peter Thornton says:

      08:02am | 10/08/09

      Good article. Breaking the cycle really, really helps. I know, too.

    • MY says:

      08:21am | 10/08/09

      I fostered for several years, we had 16 children under 10 years old at various points.  These kids are shunted from pillar to post in a system that thinks it knows best.  Brothers in our care had 3 case workers in 3 months.  Unfortunately at one point in time my four yo daughter was attacked by one of the children we fostered. The agency wouldn’t respond to our calls or requests to please take the child.  The system is clearly broken - but the lack of support for us as carers was nothing short of shameful.  With our eyes wide open we eventually stopped being a foster family.

    • Retired Carer says:

      09:05am | 10/08/09

      I believe that the child welfare system should be an independent body uanble to be effected by changes of government and the often quick change of policy.  Funding of course has to come from the Government - but a minimum annual budget should be agreed.  We had a 15year placed with us by docs through Barnados.  All was going well, visits by Barnados caseworker weekly or as necessary.  Child settled at home and at school happy and thriving.  A sudden change of Government policy and we received a letter stating that fundng was unavailable and that arrangements would be made for the child to be placed in a group home.
      We objected to this totally (after discussing with the child their needs and wishes) and organised that the placement would continue with us with no funding but with Barnados still using the same caseworker until no longer necessary.  Fortunately we were in a financial position that allowed this and the child completed schooling and has gone on to a succesful and happy life - probably far different to the outcome if the group home placement had gone ahead.
      Fostering is not easy - but each and every child deserves the chance to live in a safe environment, be loved and be allowed to develop.  Some of the children have experienced things many people would not believe and are very damaged.  Porridge eating (no matter the age) to be encouraged if it gives the child comfort - in fact anything that fills the tummy will do to start..

    • Ted says:

      09:09am | 10/08/09

      It’s funny how old fasioned ideas like marriage for a lifetime, having both fathers and mothers caring for children and living in a supportive community environment have all proved to be the institutional arrangements that best suit childen. One wonders why so many want to invent new kinds of arrangements?

    • Lanai Vasek says:

      09:14am | 10/08/09

      @MY That’s great you fostered so many children. It’s an extremely tough thing to do and I too agree that more support needs to be given to carers.

      It can be challenging enough bringing up your own children let alone ones that are already broken.

      Lead organisations like Burdekin, Anglicare and Barnados are much better at providing this support to all parties involved in care - children, carers and even the wider community.

      If you’re interested in becoming a foster family again I would highly recommend you do so with one of these organisations.

    • im says:

      09:15am | 10/08/09

      Intelligent kids are inclined to stay in their dysfunctional homes because they can read and know what happens in foster homes. There should be help for these less rebellious kids but that’s not the way it works.

    • alan cotterell says:

      09:20am | 10/08/09

      The article you have written clearly shows a strength of character not seen in a lot of people.  Heaven forbid we try to justify your treatment on that ground!

    • LR says:

      09:20am | 10/08/09

      I have worked for DoCS and private foster care agency’s - and it’s true. DOCS is over stretched. The stress of the job (it is not easy removing children from their families and being hated by almost everyone you deal with) coupled with the stress of being under resourced is the reason why so many kids don’t hear from their caseworkers - they’re aren’t enough hours (or caseworkers) in a day. I then worked (for far less money) for a private organisation in Sydney who cateres solely for teenagers . The work they do is remarkable and I still volunteer there. They have the children come and live in a residential house so they can get to know them and then match them with the most compatible carers to try and prevent placement brreakdowns or the kids being shoved from one home to another

    • Trevor says:

      09:23am | 10/08/09

      Yes, Ted - I wholeheartedly agree. Yes to long term support of relationship structures that work. But in the mean time and with the reality of the mess we humans get ourselves into we have to support much more being poured into the care of these percious ones. Excellent article.

    • alan cotterell says:

      09:24am | 10/08/09

      Ted, are you one of those who would place society in a straight-jacket by supporting ‘fault based divorce’? The reality is that there are many ways kids get neglected, even in the most conventional marriages.

    • Lanai Vasek says:

      09:58am | 10/08/09

      @im I think the real issue is the under-reporting of organisations that do a good job at providing out-of-home care.

      I would say that kids who stay in dysfunctional homes unnecessarily are not making the intelligent choice. There are fantastic agencies that can and do provide both early intervention and out-of-home care for these kids.

      Children don’t and shouldn’t have to live in damaging homes. Sadly, this is often what keeps the cycle of abuse going.

    • alan cotterell says:

      10:29am | 10/08/09

      Lania
      ‘I would say that kids who stay in dysfunctional homes unnecessarily are not making the intelligent choice’.  If your concept was true we’d have thousands of kids leaving ‘disfunctional’ homes where daddy or mommy has said ‘no’ to them a few times too many.  Perhaps many kids are incapable of making ‘intelligent choices’ or even defining the term ‘dysfunctional’?

    • formersnag says:

      10:49am | 10/08/09

      The real problem is not a shortage of DOCS workers. But an excess of middle and senior management, micro managing, their front line troops. There have been many cases where the case file manager was over ruled by supervisory staff and children have been horribly abused as a result.

      An old friend of mine was a DOCS worker in these circumstances and was hounded and victimised until leaving on medical grounds. Maybe the treatment meted out to this DOCS worker was because of pursuing all types of abuse and abusers of both genders equally? or because he was a male?

    • Steve says:

      11:54am | 10/08/09

      What a pity we are sliding backward socially toward violence as we become more technologically advanced. I guess all cultures face the same dilema as us here in the West: Technology liberates people from ‘straight jacket’ social structures that have stood the test of time only to destroy us in the process.

    • Regina says:

      12:37pm | 10/08/09

      Wow, what a touching article. It’s an amazing story. BUT, not sure I really agree with what you in terms of fixing the system.

      Wouldn’t we be better to give more support and money to government agencies like DOCS and DHS? The non-government agencies do help and do great work but at the end of the day DOCS and DHS are running the ship and setting the agenda.

    • Pcaselo says:

      12:48pm | 10/08/09

      Gosh what a hectic life.

    • AH says:

      01:15pm | 10/08/09

      What a brilliant article.  I think it is a rare glimpse at out-of-home-care from the inside out.  And to consider that so many people who have had similar experiences do not have the education or voice to talk about their lives in the way you have shows that our system needs intervention.

    • Paul says:

      01:34pm | 10/08/09

      Really revealing piece but I don’t think the system will ever get better. How long have we all known how bad the system is and yet it is still the same.

      You can speak out as much as you want but nothing will change. Plain and simple.

    • Joe says:

      01:50pm | 10/08/09

      alan cotterell, your attitude clearly reflects reality in our society and represents some very valid points.  However it is one that promotes outcomes that are less than the best, and tends to deride those who want to aim for the best.  If we aim for the best we won’t make it, but we will still do better than if we aim lower.

    • dabba says:

      02:26pm | 10/08/09

      Well said, Formersnag. As the partner of a current DOCs worker, I hear first-hand how the undermining tactics of middle management serve nothing but to lessen caseworkers’ capacity to effectively work with their clients.

      No there aren’t enough caseworkers, but this could be eased if those that are there were allowed to properly stay with clients along their journey and not be restricted by department heads who are more concerned about negative media reports.

      All who work at DOCS are there to help - but the system makes it almost impossible for them to do so. It is clear that many caseworkers are overworked and overstressed at DOCS and stay only because as a government organisation the pay is better than at another NGO.

      The syetm needs a comprehensive overhaul that puts both clients and caseworkers at the front, with the management providing adequate support for both. Only when clients know their caseworker is there long-term, and caseworkers have the capacity to spend time with clients will there be any improvement in service.

    • Lanai Vasek says:

      02:28pm | 10/08/09

      @Joe agree with you wholeheartedly.

      The issue of child welfare is too often sidelined. This needs to change. People often see it as one that is too big to tackle and will never change so they do nothing about it. This gets us nowhere.

      I’d like to see Kevin Rudd hold a 2020-esque summit purely on child welfare and protection.

      One where representatives from ALL Government and non-government agencies around Australia convene and discuss how to fix our broken system.

      A summit that invites and includes the ideas of kids currently living in care, and those that have previously lived in care.

      A summit that invites and includes the ideas of social commentators and experts in the field.

      Of course this won’t create a perfect system, but it will encourage better dialogue of the problems that need to be addressed and @Paul at least that would be better than just simply giving up.

    • Julie says:

      02:35pm | 10/08/09

      As someone who knew Brian Burdekin during his time in Canberra and knew Lanai as a teenager, I always thought Brian would be very proud of the organisation named after his ground breaking work as Human Rights Commissioner on Youth Homelessness and even more so of Lanai who has been and continues to be an outstanding young woman.  It’s great to see her finding a voice and speaking out for other young people in similar circumstances.

    • Chris says:

      03:55pm | 10/08/09

      Just want to say it isn’t all bad! I’m a ‘stay at home dad’ and have looked after my foster daughter since she was just over a year old… she’s now almost ten. Through the years dozens of other ‘short term’ kids have come and gone, but this one is staying with us - hopefully into her adult life as well!! smile

      We have been working with the Dalmar ‘Out of Home Care’ organisation and have nothing but praise for them. Only for one short period did we have any problems and they were almost entirely of our own making caused by my wife and I not following what turned out to be good advice.

      Oddly enough for people in our circumstances, we also have a good relationship with our daughters birth family, something we have worked at since the little one came to stay.

      Yes the system has flaws and as with anything it could be improved, but it’s *not* all doom and gloom. Some of us are there for the hard slog and loving every minute of it.

    • Brian says:

      04:21pm | 10/08/09

      What an enlightening article. I have always believed that any society can be truly measured by the way it cares for the young and the elderly. While my exposure to the systems in Australia is very limited, there seems to be a whole lot more that could be done to ensure that we care for those less fortunate in a more balanced manner. Unfortunately all services are hamstrung by beaurocracy. Too many pen pushers and not enough frontline caring people. My wife is a nurse and she is as frustrated at not being able to provide the services needed because of red tape and ridiculous rules and regulations. Lets bring back some common sense and lets give the real experts at the coal face the opportunity to serve.

    • me says:

      07:19pm | 10/08/09

      great article!

      I have often looked for non-financial ways I can help teenagers in this situation, and just can’t find a way… I don’t earn enough to give money, but I would give time to be there for someone.

      The community needs to band together to support all children.

    • Heléna says:

      09:47pm | 10/08/09

      we are interested in fostering children Lanai some time in the near future would you recommend initially approaching Burdekin, Anglicare or Barnados over DOCs?

    • Lanai Vasek says:

      09:51am | 11/08/09

      @Helena Yes I would definitely recommend approaching an agency such as Burdekin, Anglicare or Barnados first.

      Often they work collaboratively with DoCS anyway - but as I mentioned in the above piece they often are able to give much better support to carers and children in care.

      If you live in Sydney I would definitely encourage you to contact Burdekin on 02.8976 1777.

    • Heléna says:

      09:50pm | 11/08/09

      thank you Lanai for your advice smile - it’s much appreciated

    • fehowarth says:

      01:04pm | 12/08/09

      We need to hear from more people who went through the system.  No story is the same.  We need to hear from those who succeeded as well failed.  Without this history we cannot plot a better future where all are winners.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

Dementor doing a good job for sweden #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Ukraine song pinches chord progression from The Verve's Bittersweet Symphony. Fo real #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

RT @GerardDaffy: @antsharwood all the talk over there is the grannies will win.they entered to get a church built,feelgood story

Anthony Sharwood

These peole insult my grandmothjer, who was born in minsk, belarus #sbseurovision

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

We don’t deserve this huge, exciting scientific project

I’d like to be able to say that sharing the world’s largest radio telescope with South Africa…

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

Mining money talks the loudest in Australian politics

When North Queensland Liberal MP George Christensen got the idea of launching a new political organisation…

Please enter your password

Please enter your password

Help! I’ve succumbed to a crippling modern illness that can strike at any moment. Symptoms include:…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter