Editor’s note: This week on Twitter Rhiannon pledged to donate $10 each day to a different charity. And she’d welcome your suggestions on charities worth donating to. You’ll find her blog and Twitter name at the bottom of her piece.

Here’s my confession: I’ve done a few bad things in my life. 

Describe this image

When I was seven I stole some stickers from my teacher. As Julia Roberts would say, big mistake. Huge.

Even now I still turn nauseous now at the thought of banana-scented scratch-and-sniff.

I’ve been rude to my parents. Mean to my friends. I have deliberately started arguments because I found it entertaining. 

And painfully, I am a bit disillusioned when it comes to charity giving. In fact, apart from the occasional sponsorship of fundraising friends and the odd Big Issue, it’s something I rarely do. 

Not for lack of wanting to. 

I’ve said this before, but I’m not convinced our charity giving habits are that awesome.

Fundraising days are good reminders to donate, but the practice of buying pens, flowers, badges or other things we don’t really need is just a teeny bit dubious. Mostly, I don’t like the idea of manufacturing a whole bunch of junk – destined for the top drawer vortex of useless stuff – in order to motivate people. And what about all those other charities in need of funds, that can’t afford to advertise? 

Yet, we do need motivation. 

A few years ago, an old school friend decided to spend just five dollars on food every day for a month. I am pretty sure he half-starved, but he did it.

The blog he kept was a fascinating excursion into our obsessive relationship with food and his experience of living in relative (self imposed) poverty. I was really impressed by this “life experiment” and how simple it was to execute. The idea stuck with me long after the month was over. 

On a whim, I have decided to give away ten dollars to a different not-for-profit every day for a month. It’s not a lot of money. Not nearly on par with British ethics professor Toby Ord, who pledged to give away 10 per cent of his income for life, or former millionaire Karl Rabeder, who is giving almost all of his fortune away “for the sake of happiness”. 

Ten dollars is roughly how much I spend on lunch, but it still adds up to about 700 per cent per year more than what I would normally give. 

I want to make a commitment to investing in charities that I think – and others think – are doing a great job. No carrot or stick, just a slight readjustment to help out areas that constantly struggle for money. 

There are literally thousands of not-for-profits competing for donations, and I want to know my money is being well spent. That’s why I’m asking people to nominate their preferred charities to me, and I’ll keep track of how the money is used on my blog. 

I also want to encourage public support for a single national charities regulatory body. Federal legislation and an accompanying not-for-profit watchdog are currently being considered by the Council of Australian Government’s Business Regulation and Competition Working Group.

Among the recommendations are best practice standards for not for profits, a complaints investigation channel, a searchable public database and enforced compliance with relevant legislation. 

Finally, this is also a learning exercise. By stripping a few hundred dollars out of my monthly budget, it will teach me to manage my own finances better.

Ten dollars a day won’t drastically impact my lifestyle. It’s a realistic, sustainable amount. Hopefully I will realise I won’t miss this amount too much, if I lose a few of my more impulsive purchases. 

Will it make a difference? I’m yet to find out.

In the meantime if you would like to nominate a charity or even pledge to match my donations, please get in touch.

Follow Rhiannon on Twitter or visit her blog

Don’t miss: Get The Punch in your inbox every day

Get The Punch on Facebook

Most commented

44 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Dontate your time says:

      06:47am | 11/02/10

      Sadly, I am cynical about giving money to charities. You would be making a real difference in donating your time. Work less (earn $10 less a day?) and volunteer at any number of places around Australia that provide food for the homeless. Or do what I did… save your money and go to Africa. I spent 4 weeks teaching in a school in Kenya last year and SAW the difference I made in the future of the children I spent time with. It cost me $10,000, mind you - but was worth it. Good luck in making yourself live a more guilt-free life in this lucky country of ours!

    • T.Chong says:

      06:48am | 11/02/10

      The coolest (karma wise) charity around would probaly be “Starlight” or similar that try to make the sickest of kids happy.
      The Salvos and St Vinnies also have pretty good reputations when it comes to doing the right thing with donations.
      (And yes, we donate to all three)

    • Rachel says:

      08:54am | 11/02/10

      Can I suggest Anglicare?  You can see their balance sheets etc. at http://www.anglicare.org.au/about-us if you are worried about what is spent on what. I’ve seen the Canberra branch in Reid do wonderful things. The staff and volunteers are kind and have a helping hand for everyone .

    • Scott Glennon says:

      09:11am | 11/02/10

      The Sea Shepherd!

    • Jack from Perth says:

      02:55pm | 11/02/10

      Sea Shepperd do fantastic things to end poverty, compared to the likes of Oxfam who recklessly waste donations sinking vessels in the southern ocean. Or have I got it the wrong way around?

    • Christine says:

      09:23am | 11/02/10

      The MS Society is severly underfunded.  18000 people in Australia have MS, but hardly anyone knows what the disease is about. Even better, instead of donating $10, sign up to one of their fundraising efforts (MS Read-a-thon, Brisbane Brissie to the Bay bike ride or whatever is equivalent in your state etc). http://www.msaustralia.org.au/

      Youngcare is a Queensland based charity that provides residental care facilities for young people with high care requirements that would normally end up in aged care facilities. It was started by a guy who’s wife was diagnosed with MS, and needed to go into an aged care home as he couldn’t look after her anymore, and he couldn’t stand the thought of her going into that kind of facility at such a young age. http://www.youngcare.com.au/

    • NCG says:

      09:35am | 11/02/10

      Kiva is my charity of choice, as a micro credit organisation it allows people to fund others business ventures in the third world. No interest is applied, and money is repaid in monthly instalments, which can then be loaned to another party. Frankly it’s more appealing to me as I’d rather give people the opportunity to better themselves, their community and follow an entrepreneurial dream rather than just receiving endless handouts. It’s the only organisation that I know of to try and break the cycle of poverty.
      http://www.kiva.org

    • cats says:

      09:36am | 11/02/10

      Monthly i donate $35 to WSPA, $30 to WWF and $15 to Amnesty. The thing i don’t like about charities though is when they ring me to ask for more money. WWF doesn’t do this though. I tell them that i simply do not earn enough but they keep asking. I would like to be able to disclose my income to them so that they realise that HEY this person really does not have enough money!

    • Sschmavo says:

      09:41am | 11/02/10

      I agree cats…...once they have your details it’s like a bombardment. I finally realised that selecting 3 charities was the way to go…...Vinnies, Royal Childrens’ Hospital and the Cancer Council for me.

    • Erin says:

      10:33am | 11/02/10

      We have a rule in our household - you can ring and ask for more once, but hassle us after we have given a polite “no” and we cancel our support and divert our money elsewhere - So far I have found WWF and the Cancer Council to be good charities; they don’t hassle us and WWF even calls you every once in a while just to say “thanks”.

    • Alicia says:

      10:11am | 12/02/10

      Why don’t you just politely ask the charity to not call you anymore? I’m sure if you tell them you don’t ever want to increase your support (unless you choose to and call them) and can they please not call you anymore then they wouldn’t. Erin, just saying “no once” won’t stop them from calling - your circumstances may change and in the future you may be able to give more hence they would try again later. Unless you tell them of your strict “no calls policy” you are not being fair. It costs money to make those calls and if you know you will always say no, be fair and tell them. Don’t just get stroppy and cancel!

    • Rhiannon says:

      10:02am | 11/02/10

      Thanks for all these recommendations. To the first person who suggests ‘donate your time’, this is something I’ve tried to do many times (and have done), but ironically many organisations seem to be swamped with people willing to volunteer. You’d be surprised at how many times I’ve asked about volunteering never to have gotten a response.

    • SK says:

      10:04am | 11/02/10

      Can I suggest ‘To Write Love On Her Arms’? It’s a charity that aims to reduce the youth suicide rate.

    • Jeff says:

      10:06am | 11/02/10

      We all too often convince ourselves we (first world countries) don’t have enough. It’s only when we see with our own eyes and understand the need that is all around us (here and overseas), that we gain perspective. I want my life to be more than accumulating wealth. I want to be a generous contributor to addressing the genuine need of others. It’s not the government’s responsibility, it is my actions and attitudes.

      Some suggestions - World Vision, Compassion, Free to be kids (orphanage in India)

    • John T says:

      10:10am | 11/02/10

      I don’t give as much as you Rhiannon but do donate regularly to a number of international, national and local organisations.  I sometimes have misgivings about things such as how much of the money collected is used for administrative purposes but don’t let this stop me.  Financial reports (like the Anglicare one which Rachel links to)  give some guide while each state and the ACT (though not the NT) has an agency (usually part of the gambling regulator!)  which is responsible for overseeing charities : eg NSW http://www.olgr.nsw.gov.au/charitable_info_investigating.asp

      As for a suggested donation recipient. Wht about a health related charity such as The Royal Flying Doctor Service, The Brain Foundation or the research fund of a hospital.

    • Go on says:

      10:13am | 11/02/10

      Why do people feel compelled to promote the fact they give, or choose to give to charity? Probably for most part, people are extremely selfish.

      Good on you, but to my mind it is far more satisfying to give and not gloat about it! Try it, if you dare. Then you can be truly selfless.

      While you are at it, why not try and find non-organised charities, such as women’s shelters, after school programs, etc. Ones that don’t offer a receipt making the donation tax deductible.

    • Hero says:

      01:47pm | 11/02/10

      You’re a very miserable person Go on. At least Rhiannon is being more proactive and considered than most in the way she is giving

    • cats says:

      03:58pm | 11/02/10

      Why did you read this article then? Go away.

    • Go on says:

      08:48pm | 11/02/10

      @ Hero.
      no she is not. she is self-promoting and trying to raise her profile. Plus, what makes you think I am miserable? I did not say anything that could be deemed miserable. I am critical, yes.

      Besides, I commended Rhiannon for her efforts and offered her some alternate suggestions for thinking about how she “donates” her hard earned money.

      I still stand by my original statement and I hope you are not implying that she is actually more giving than me, because frankly you have no way to know. Not that I care, as it’s not a competition for me, unlike others.

      @ Cats. Um, I read the article because I like Rhiannon’s previous posts and the title of this one intrigued me. Shame it was a self-promotion piece. I do commend anyone willing to part with cash to help others, but why do we have to hear about it and pat them on the back. Probably because people like to take a stand, firmly on their higher ground and stroke their egos.

      Truly charitable people are the ones who humbly go on about their day-to-day activities caring for and providing for without a peep. You should try it. Much better for your soul.

    • Rhiannon says:

      09:31am | 16/02/10

      Go on, thanks for your thoughts, but if you think I wrote this for shameless self promotion - and tax deductions - you have really missed the point. Making a public commitment has made me more accountable and given me loads of support. Giving $10 per day will not make much impact if only one person does it, but if it gets people talking and thinking about charities and what we can do collectively, it might be more effective.

    • Suzie says:

      10:28am | 11/02/10

      The Activ Foundation provides support and employment for people with disabilities. It helps these people contribute to society in a meaningful way giving them a sense of purpose and is just wonderful.
      http://www.activ.asn.au/

    • Amber says:

      11:11am | 11/02/10

      I recommend the “Homicide Victim Support Group” in your state.

      They are a registered charity who provide support, councelling, trial assistance and many other functions to the family members of homicide victims.

      Unfortuanately this charity is mostly unknown until they are needed. I personally have lost a family member due to homicide and this group has helped my family and i out in many ways.

    • buddingphilanthropist says:

      11:32am | 11/02/10

      A few suggestions for Rhiannon and anyone interested in donating, or donating more -

      1) The reticience about donating towards admin expenses is unjustified. These should be kept to a reasonable percentage of the charity’s operating budget but charities need to be able to cover these expenses to build capacity within the organisation and also engage in vital future planning. This is a popular idea that needs to be challenged!

      2) Rhiannon, please consider donating to some ‘unsexy’ charities. Charities like the Cancer Council and particularly Starlight Express receive a significant percentage of Australia’s philanthropic dollar, mainly because they are an instant feelgood (and safe!) option.

    • Simmo says:

      12:17pm | 11/02/10

      I hear the Prot Adelaide Football Club could do with some charitable donations at the moment…. jokes aside, any charity that provides support to young children who are at risk of slipping through the cracks in society is always a worthy cause

    • Super D says:

      12:29pm | 11/02/10

      It’s hard to go past Legacy as a charity.  Families who’ve lost servicemen and women, fathers, mothers, sisters and brothers deserve our gratitude for their sacrifice and our ongoing support.

      The soldiers don’t choose which wars they fight and die in, they just obey the orders they are given whether they agree with the politics behind them or not.

    • JE says:

      01:17pm | 11/02/10

      The RSPCA is a fantastic organisation to donate to. They advocate for and give a voice to animals who can’t speak for themselves.

    • Kyle says:

      01:40pm | 11/02/10

      I would suggest the RFDS, they have fantastic programs for the immunisation and health care in communities around the country and as we all know they rescue and fly sick and injured people to health services. Hey without them my son probably would not be here today, Alice Springs doesn’t have a Neonatal Unit so it is off to Adelaide you go when Antenatal and Neonatal help is required. You don’t realise how good we have it in the “city” until you are ill in the “outback” and need help! The staff, nurses, doctors, pilots (who can fly in almost any weather) are all amazing caring people who are a credit to their professions.

    • TPM says:

      01:40pm | 11/02/10

      I would suggest Melanoma Patients Australia, a small, NFP, young organisation. Melanoma is one of the highest killers in Australia yet there are no support groups! Melanoma Patients Australia provide melanoma patients, their family and friends with information about melanoma and its treatment options, as well as providing a support network to nurture them through difficult times.
      http://www.melanomapatients.org/

    • Scot says:

      01:46pm | 11/02/10

      TPM, In Zimbabwe the god of charity is Robert Mugabe when it comes to charity. What Nieve fools we are in Australia to get sucked into this. USD2Trillion has been pored into Africa and what have they go to show for it. Mugabe’s nephew “took over” the assest of Tiny Rowlands. Philip Chiyangwa, the millionaire businessman nephew of Robert Mugabe, at his opulent Zimbabwe home full of deluxe cars http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/newsnight/8509149.stm

    • Malone says:

      01:44pm | 11/02/10

      The Warwick Foundation. This is a charity that helps support young people with cancer, 18-35year olds. As a man who had testicular cancer I can attest to the fact that the system is much better equipped to handle childrens needs, or those over 40. Not much fun being 22, stuck in a hospital, after having moved back home to have ya mother waiting on you hand and foot.

      The Warwick Foundation sends out care packs to these young people living with cancer. These help.

      When thinking of cancer charities, please don’t think that children’s charities are the only one’s ‘worth’ giving to. There is a lot of need out there, and all charities are worthy of our attention. Thanks

    • Patrice says:

      02:12pm | 11/02/10

      Hi R,

      I suggest Peta, WSPA, Monikas Doggie rescue and the Cat Protection Society.

    • stephen says:

      03:07pm | 11/02/10

      Medicin sans frontieres is worthwhile.
      I think also there are various ways to be charitable.
      It doesn’t have to be money. Can be time, or affection or a phone-call.

    • stephen says:

      03:12pm | 11/02/10

      Hell, I nearly forgot : these kids selling the Big Issue on city street-corners.
      5 bucks a pop, and a good investment.

    • Jenni says:

      04:01pm | 11/02/10

      agreed with Stephen on both counts smile

      Medicin Sans Frontieres (Doctores Without Borders) go into war zones and disaster areas and offer medical help to everybody and anybody who needs it, regardless of race, gender, politics, nationality, etc - fabulous organisation!

      and i like the Big Issue because a set portion of the cover price goes DIRECTLY to the (usually homeless) person that you buy it off.

    • Marnie says:

      06:00pm | 11/02/10

      Donate to the RSPCA - the work they do is fantastic and very deserving of your $10.

    • Justin says:

      06:37pm | 11/02/10

      I’m with those supporting the RSPCA. I support them in both a volunteer and financial capacity.

      Why them? Cause I’m a miserable prick who hates people. They’re all corrupt and self serving and undeserving, and for the few that aren’t, well they’re too rare to even worry about.

      Animals on the other hand, we screw them over left right and centre like they’re our posessions. Like they and their lives are meaningless and exist only for our pleasure and entertainment. Bullshit to that, Animal Welfare is where my money is going.

    • Mick Skinner says:

      08:33pm | 11/02/10

      I’d suggest the Smith Family. Aussie and boring. They kit out little kids with uniforms, pencils etc so they can fit in at school.

      Also, the people at the top are not nutjobs.

      As opposed to many of the organisations previously mentioned.

    • Deap Froat says:

      08:53pm | 11/02/10

      I prefer to support charities that are all about prevention rather than cure.  I have just started donating to an not-for-profit called Western Chances which was started by ex-Victorian Premier Steve Bracks’ wife Terry.  They give scholarships to talented and motivated young people in Melbourne’s western suburbs who are financially disadvantaged.  The scholarships can be for simple things like music and dance lessons to help the young people follow their passion - http://www.westernchances.org.au/

    • Lucy says:

      12:13am | 12/02/10

      I’m with Patrice - Monika’s Doggy Rescues and RSPCA.  You could also look into supporting some local arts groups, which have significant community engagement, such as Kickstart Arts.

      I donate to two charities regularly - the RSPCA and Oxfam - yet I’m a student living on a slim budget.  I still have charities that knock on my door and are really pushy in trying to get me to sign up for ‘just $10/week’.  They generally answer with a dismissive ‘that’s great’ when I say that I regularly donate to two chosen charities and that’s all I can afford, and then tell me that $10/week is not much and I should give to the Heart Foundation/Red Cross/Cancer Council etc. as well.  It doesn’t help a charities cause when they harass people for money and make them feel guilty. 

      Additionally, a month ago the Red Cross knocked on my door trying to get me to sign up for a regular direct debit, yet when I said I couldn’t afford $10 a week (I had to qualify that for her too - apparently she didn’t believe me) but could instead make a small one-off cash donation, she said that they no longer accepted cash donations. Crazy

    • Samesy says:

      08:47am | 12/02/10

      I suggest donating to “Childcare Kitgum Servants” - This organisation was started by an Australian woman named Irene who sold her house in North Sydney in 1991 and moved to Kitgum, Uganda in the middle of the war to start taking care of Orphans under a Mango tree while living in a caravan…today she clothes, feeds, provides medicine & educates over 10,000 children at her school and relies solely on donations to keep it running.

      My sister has just arrived back from 3 weeks in Africa and was so moved she also wants to move there for a year to make a difference, we are going to hold a fundraiser in Oct for this charity in addition to the children we sponsor.  Irene has a fasinating story if you would like to know more pls visit the website -  http://www.cks.org.au/

      Just shows what a difference one woman can make Rhiannon!  Well done smile

    • James says:

      10:39am | 13/02/10

      Suggest you start by shortlisting things you really care about and then donate to those charities that will address your feelings.  As rightly said, donation doesn’t need to be only money, it can take many others forms as long as the recipient and the donor gets fulfillment out of it. 

      However if you want to donate and not spend any money from your pocket, i would suggest you take a look at http://www.auscause.com.au/ .  These guys offers a very unique fund raising solution.

    • Emma Hobbs says:

      10:24am | 19/02/10

      Rhiannon can I say that you are doing a really great job in doing this. My frinds say that giving to charities is too overwhelming and they just don’t know where to start. But $10.00 is sometimes all it takes to make a difference. $10.00 can buy a mosquito net to save a child or families lives from Malaria. Malaria kills more people per year than HIV/AIDS. Every 30 seconds a child under 5 dies of malaria. Not just in Africa, but Central & South America; India, Asia and South Pacific. Global Concern is an Australian Organisation that has been around for 30 years making a difference without all the pens,badges etc. When you visit Global Concern they give you the option to buy a mosquito net for only $10.00 and also see amazing videos on this cause and what Global Concern is doing. Otherwise check out my video on Youtube Malaria NET TEN that I created for this cause.  It is something I strongly believe in as I am a Registered Nurse who has witnessed the horror of Malaria on all ages - it is one of the major causes of poverty.

    • Bernadette Young says:

      06:21am | 12/12/10

      I suggest looking further at the work that Toby Ord and the rest of the group at Giving What We Can do - analysis of the cost effectiveness of giving: how much bang do you get for your buck?

      $10 will save 2 years of life for those affected by parasitic infections in rural african, by deworming 20 children:
      http://www.givingwhatwecan.org/resources/recommended-charities.php

      Best of luck!

      PS Toby Ord is actually Australian, as is Peter Singer who also champions the cause of giving more. Looks like an Australian trait!

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @ConradLiveris: Thanks @drpiotrowski for highlighting Coalition MPs who support #marriageequality: http://t.co/l502Tw2oIH

Daniel Piotrowski

@w_m_lewis Thanks WM

Paul Colgan

Given they are the world's biggest advertiser, can't pass without observing the AU MD just got poached by Google http://t.co/PAg9ffZ1IF

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @w_m_lewis: Enjoyed @drpiotrowski's story http://t.co/H74SblJd6P. Dear @TeresaGambaroMP - I'm a constituent who supports #marriageequali

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter