They called it Tangentopoli. ‘Tangenti’ is one of the Italian words for ‘bribes’, and Tangentopoli summed up the idea that Italian politics had become a game of Monopoly fuelled by kickbacks.

A protester dressed as the Italian Prime Minister. Pic: AFP

I spent a lot of time in Italy in the 90s, starting with a story for ‘Foreign Correspondent’ in April 1993. Tangentopoli had convulsed the country, with magistrates uncovering vast swathes of corruption involving most of the leading political figures of the previous three decades.

My first encounter with the new reality came in a town in Abruzzo called Chieti. It was a sort of magnified microcosm of Italy, because almost every councillor on the local government had been arrested for corruption.

They’d all been at it: the councillors of the centre-right Christian Democratic Party, the DC, and the members elected for the Socialist Party.

That reflected the situation in the country as a whole, where the former Socialist Prime Minister Bettino Craxi, had fled to North Africa to escape the investigators, and the former Christian Democrat Prime Minister Giulio Andreotti faced trial for involvement with the Sicilian Mafia.

In Chieti, a situation which could have had its comic-opera moments was actually quite serious; its most glaring symbol was a hospital the town badly needed, but which had remained half built and empty for years because so many of the councillors had been on the take, and the bribes had just run out.

I say ‘almost’ every councillor had been arrested. The glaring exception was an elderly Fascist, who had apparently never taken a bribe, probably because he was so marginal to the council’s affairs.
Not any more.

An affable gentleman by the name of Nicola Cucullo, he took us around the now leaderless town, demonstrating the ways in which his colleagues had plundered the place, and clearly demonstrating by his popularity that he was the likely beneficiary of their arrests.

So in 1993, when our film crew visited for the first time, Chieti , like the whole country, was effectively a political vacuum.

For a brief period, the moral and political centre of Italy had moved away from the Parliament and towards the judiciary.

In the south, magistrates like the brilliant and determined Giovanni Falcone and Paolo Borsellino had made such massive inroads into the Mafia’s dominions that, tragically, the Mafia felt compelled to blow them up.

In the north, with less physical threat, magistrates led by Milan’s Antonio di Pietro were forensically pursuing corruption into every corner of the political world, in an operation known as Mani Pulite, or Clean Hands.

It was, I thought, a brief moment of opportunity for a country whose entire post-war life had been dominated by the Cold War, from the 1940s on.

For nearly half a century, the US and its Allies had been haunted by the fear that Italy, with its large Communist Party, might fall into the shadow of the Soviet Bloc.
The events of 1989 had erased that fear, and Italians, in 1992-3, had a chance of a new start.

But it didn’t last long.

If things had gone well, when we went back to Chieti in 1994, there might have been a new, cross-party, anti-corruption local government in place. Instead, the new Mayor of a far-Right-dominated council was – our old acquaintance the Fascist Nicola Cucullo.

That was the local microcosm: nationally, there was a rising tide of support for a new movement called Forza Italia. Named after the football chant “Go Italy”, this was, of course, the brainchild of the communications billionaire Silvio Berlusconi.

You could argue that Forza Italia could only have thrived in times like those. The existing political parties were in ruins. There was no infrastructure and no preparation for new ones.

Berlusconi had the money, the TV stations and the corporate PR network to step in and, effectively buy his way to power.

His party looked on the surface like many other European parties, but even then there were signs that one of its chief purposes would be to maintain and build the corporate interests of Berlusconi himself.

His first encounter with power, which was that very year, 1994, was brief, because his majority was too small.

But Silvio Berlusconi has held the reins in Italy now for most of the last decade. He must have begun to think himself untouchable.

His utter domination of media ownership has meant that for much of that time most Italians have seen, heard and read little about his financial and other excesses.

One of many, many examples: a lawyer named David Mills, married to a British Cabinet Minister, was found guilty of accepting a bribe from Berlusconi of nearly $650,000 to tell lies for him in court.
Berlusconi came away scot-free.

But even billionaires can’t insulate themselves against everything. The lurid headlines in the last few months about “bunga bunga” parties attended by prostitutes were bad enough.

Then it emerged that one of the prostitutes, Ruby Rubacuore, or Ruby the Heartstealer, was under age, and that Berlusconi had intervened to get her out of police custody on the spurious grounds that she was related to (of all people) Egypt’s President Mubarak.

And so it’s back to the judicial system, and Milan’s Judge Cristina di Censo, who’s ordered Berlusconi to stand trial for procuring sex with an under-age girl and trying to cover it up.

The man they call the Cavaliere, The Knight, has excellent lawyers and plenty of them: he may escape yet again. But his reputation is now massively damaged, and he has hurt his nation’s image even more.

Whether or not he faces judicial sanction, Italy may soon be at another turning point, the second opportunity in two decades to shape its future for the better.

We can only hope that things will work out a little better this time. Because in terms of true openness, rationality, democracy and pluralism, these have been wasted years.

Most commented

30 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Paddy says:

      07:27am | 17/02/11

      Many countries, including Australia and its States, have similar problems. Take Victoria for instance. Over the past 10 years developers, businesses and other businessmen(women) make contributions to the ALP and the then State Govt called in projects for Ministerial intervention, rezoning, issuing of permits, companies receiving approvals in bulk to establish in areas effectively preclusing competitiors gaining access, manipulation of the poker machine tax by clubs so as not to pay any tax and on an on it went. The Labor politicians all benefited from these contributions.
      Tangenti is alive and well in our political system. We cannot throw stones at the Italians at all.
      As for manipulation of the political system, we need go no further than local councils. In and around Melbourne, Labor runs a multitude of candidates in a number of seats over and above its preferred candidate. These people are funded and run out of the local Labor parliamentarians electoral office. They each identify a single issue and run on this as independents. The objective being to pick up preferences that can be given to the preferred Labor candidate.
      Australia cannot throw stones at anyone, we are just as corrupt as Italy.

    • v says:

      07:39am | 17/02/11

      At least in Australia, adulatory is not considered a national pass time, where the greatness of a person is measured by the degree of their betrayal of a marriage.

    • marley says:

      09:16am | 17/02/11

      Actually, the Italians judge Berlusconi by the elegant cut of his suits.

    • Paul says:

      09:55am | 17/02/11

      @Paddy, love the fact that you are comparing a centre left ALP to centre Right Berlusconi. My take is that all parties exist in some form of corruption, whether if be builders or big business or trade unions.

      @V, personally, I couldn’t care less what our pollies did once the lights were tunred off as long as it was legal. That the GOP was prepared to bring the US to halt just because Bill Clinton had a fling always seemed strange to me, and self defeating. Attack on policies, but his marriage is his business. What it really showed was they had no policies themsleves, just a a lust for power.

      Finally,beware the power of the media. We see examples everyday where Murdoch shapes opinion by bending the news - or even outright lies in the case of Fox News. The Berlusconi has got away with this for so long is a condemnation of countries not allowing a truly free but accountable press.

    • Adam Diver says:

      10:12am | 17/02/11

      “They each identify a single issue and run on this as independents. The objective being to pick up preferences that can be given to the preferred Labor candidate.”

      That is incredibly smart, albeit incredibly wrong. Any journalist going near this claim that you know of? Or how did you come by this information, particularly that its funded by ALP.

    • HappyCynic says:

      07:32am | 17/02/11

      Ah Italy, where the food is good, the people great, the architecture magnificent and the politics is actually interesting oh and it’s one of the best languages to curse and insult in smile

      Why can’t we have these nice things?  Oh that’s right us Aussies are the bambini di puttana e condannato smile

    • marley says:

      08:32am | 17/02/11

      Ah, speak for yourself. My folks were neither.

    • Oh so classy says:

      08:35am | 17/02/11

      Such a wonderful turn of phrase oh Happy Cynic. You forgot to mention Italy managed to either export its immature adults to Australia or exported Italians who forgot to give their children any class whatsoever. Now that foresight reflects positively on Italy and means poor old Australia is now stuck with such stylish individuals as you. 
      You know HappyCynic, the AngloSaxons taught their children “it is better to be thought to lack class than to either open one’s mouth or to put pen to paper and remove all doubt”. Then again, maybe I am off beam and you are not the child of Italian parents or an Italian who has emigrated to Australia.

    • George says:

      08:39am | 17/02/11

      @HappyCynic

      Takes one ‘bambini di puttana e condannato’ to know another ‘bambini di puttana e condannato’ right!

    • HappyCynic says:

      09:21am | 17/02/11

      @George - It sure does smile

      @Oh so classy - I’m Anglo (kinda), but you have to admit this country is nowhere near as interesting as Italy is nor is our language as much fun

      Don’t take it too seriously or alternatively seek a humour transplant

    • Ciccio says:

      01:46pm | 17/02/11

      My original post wasn’t published so I’ll try again.

      @HappyCynic

      The correct phrase should read; “figli di puttana e condannati”
      If you’re going to swear in another language at least do it properly.

    • Zac de Spudnut says:

      07:33am | 17/02/11

      But how is this different from our BER-Pink Batts Labor government led by “Bing Bang Soup Believer” (3BS) and it’s counter part in NSW?

    • HappyCynic says:

      07:51am | 17/02/11

      There’s no effective Opposition in Italy, fool, and the media controls the government.

      Oh…  I guess it is quite similar here smile

    • TChong says:

      07:59am | 17/02/11

      Do tell Zac, do tell.
      (I’ll bet the devil had something to do with it).
      Interesting, though, not surprising, you have joined up with the LNP camp Zac, spose it will make you less of a target when you start your religios spiels.
      You can now be even more intolerant of everyone who doesnt bat for your god, and do so with greater support, specially from those who share your fear of “Them”
      Smart move.

    • P. Darvio says:

      09:38am | 17/02/11

      ....leave Silvio Berlusconi alone….he is a member of DBP…(Dinosaur Boat People)....those people who believe Humans fed Dinosaurs on a BIG wooden boat in a BIG Flood not that long ago – its all in that BOOK that DBP believe in and brilliantly demonstrated by that Australian businessman Ken Ham who lives in the US.

      http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/1999/11/05/dinosaurs-and-the-bible

      It should be madantory for all DBP to visit this Museum as a part of their DBP faith and also to contribute to the building of a replica DBP Boat

      http://arkencounter.com/

    • Zac de Spudnut says:

      10:26am | 17/02/11

      @HappyCynic,

      So the comrades who rule our country is actually doing a great job and the media is not the non-elected ruler of our country? By the way how is that “Genius Multi-cult-urism” going for ya? Any chance we will get a referendum on this?

      @TChong, ok the religious are ignorant fools but how did the “omnipotent chance” believer who is said to be rational and intellectual produce the worst BER, Pink Batts etc programmes? Just a glance at history would tell you Intolerance is the trademark of Atheists. Tell me this Chong, would a religious person be elected as the PM of an Atheist country? This would tell you who are the intolerant ones.

    • P. Darvio says:

      07:40am | 17/02/11

      1 million women in Italy get out to protest against Berlusconi and an alleged use of an under age female escort but they barely raise any outcry over the Christian Priest Child Rape Scandal (and the complicit cover up by the Christian community) when protesters went to the Vatican to protest some months ago. There is something terribly wrong with humanity when it allows religion to get away with these crimes against Children.

    • Zac de Spudnut says:

      10:06am | 17/02/11

      P.Darvio,

      These priests are convicted and charged under the law and rightly so. So where did religion get away with it. There should be no place for such people in the Church. Christians are more than happy for these priests to be charged, the lifestyle these priests led are totally against the principles of Christ. But that wouldn’t be the case in a darwinian/Atheistic world. Even Richard Dawkins is aware of this:

      “If somebody used my views to justify a completely self-centred lifestyle, which involved trampling all over other people in any way they chose. . . I think I would be fairly hard put to it to argue on purely intellectual grounds.  . . I couldn’t, ultimately, argue intellectually against somebody who did something I found obnoxious.  I think I could finally only say, “Well, in this society you can’t get away with it” and call the police.”
      Ref: Dawkins, ‘Nick Pollard talks to Dr. Richard Dawkins’, Thirdway, April 1995, vol 18, no 3

      Thats right in this Christian society you can’t get away with it - that includes the priests. So thank God for Christ-ianity.

    • Sherekahn says:

      12:06pm | 17/02/11

      It will need more than 1 million protesting women to condemn Berlusconi for his ‘so-called’ misdeed.
      She was only a couple of months away from the legal age.  Anyhow, there are just as many men in Italy who must be smiling at his luck.
      As for the Vatican, they can wail away.  Nature is GOD and nature has made MAN in the mould that he will always be drawn by beauty we can’t help it.

    • biff says:

      08:02am | 17/02/11

      Is there any truth in the rumour that Mr Berlusconi was the successful bidder for Shane’s used mobile phone?

    • stephen says:

      11:07am | 17/02/11

      Yeah and it’s where the phone’s been that leaves bertie all dirtie.

    • Steve says:

      08:55am | 17/02/11

      One of the reasons that Berlusconi has been admired and suppprted by many Italians for so long is that he actually managed to succeed at building something when there are so many regulations, laws and bureaucrats in the way, and corruption at every turn.

      If every Italian knows there is corruption amongst officials and huge bureaucracy, why would they give a toss if someone successfully navigates the crorruption and the system. They themselves need to batle the bureacracy as well to do something as simple as changing address, or having a new utility put on.

    • Luce says:

      11:03am | 17/02/11

      Berlusconi… what a player

    • TEZZA says:

      12:11pm | 17/02/11

      ” . .  his reputation is now massively damaged . .” 
      So, Mark Colvin, what is it that Mr. Berlusconi is being charged with that has got you so excited?
      Corruption? No, he’s been found not guilty of that previously.
      Being italy’s version of Rupert Murdoch? Sorry Mark, although you and your ABC colleagues no doubt wish that this were a crime, it is not in fact illegal to be Rupert Murdoch.
      Having under-age sex with “Ruby the Heart-Stealer”?
      Yeah right. The girl was seventeen (which is above the age of consent in Australia, as it is in many countries), she looked 24, and she WORKED AS A PROSTITUTE!
      I have nothing against prostitutes, but if you adopt that as a profession you can’t really complain about your customers taking you up on the offer to engage in sex.
      Oh, I forgot, she didn’t complain, in fact she said no sex actually took place. So can this be anything more than a witch hunt.
      The alleged offence is not yet proven, but even if it is proven, how can we condemn an “offence” which would be perfectly legal if it took place in this country.
      As a thought experiment, imagine if Berlusconi were a politician in a country, say Malaysia, where homosexuality is illegal, and he had been accused of committing a homosexual act. Would not Mark Colvin, his ABC buddies, and the rest of the Australian media be united in defending him? In fact that is exactly what happened with Anwar Ibrahim

    • Luce says:

      01:20pm | 17/02/11

      TEZZA, the age of consent in Italy is 16 also, but the problem is it’s illegal to pay someone for sex if they are under 18, hence the charges.

      No it’s not proven yet, but if it is, then he did do something illegal.

      And not knowing she was underage is not a valid legal defense.

    • LegalEagle says:

      02:46pm | 17/02/11

      1. Berlusconi is also accused of covering up the girl’s shoplifting charges through his office, which could be considered corruption. The tenuous reason provided was that she was a relation(?) of Hosni Mubarak.
      2. The age of consent in Italy is 14 years, but it is still illegal to work as a prostitute until the age of 18 years. It doesn’t matter she was only a couple of months shy of her 18th birthday, it’s still illegal. This means that she has something to gain from denying this took place, just like Berlusconi.

    • Luce says:

      04:05pm | 17/02/11

      Good point. It goes to 16 if the older person has some sort of influence over the younger one, e.g. teacher..

      Although I have to say that’s a little dysfunctional, teachers and students shouldn’t be doing that at all…. Italians! whaddaya gonna do, eh?

    • mary monica roche says:

      07:15pm | 17/02/11

      Silvio Berlusconi behaves like a rich businessman and covers up corruption like a politician.
      Silvio Burlesconi would be an ideal prime minister for any conservative party or liberal party anywhere on earth.

    • TCB 24 X7 says:

      08:30pm | 17/02/11

      gillard should tee up with him then.
      They would make a good couple, the fiery red head and the hot italian sausage.
      .

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

@Chritana01 No. NSW state

Daniel Piotrowski

@FreeDannyJovica Hi guys, I sent you a Facebook message. What's the latest on Danny Jovica?

tory_maguire

RT @johnluu: Amazing story of how a @triplej journo does her job visually-impaired. Goosebumps. http://t.co/N0ApEppril (via @abcmarkscott)

ToryShepherd

Writing column on orgasmic birth. Needed last line. Inspired by this necklace I bought. http://t.co/PgQ7jtGxaE

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter